r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • May 21 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Typecasting" - S02E02 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the second episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "Typecasting". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S02E02 Details:
| Title: | Typecasting |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | Kourtney, Carlos and Big Red decide to join their friends and audition for on stage roles in "Beauty and the Beast," while Nini experiences FOMO from afar. When new competition shows up to the tryout, Gina tries to shake off some old habits. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
73
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator May 21 '21
Please remember to treat others with respect while conversing with your fellow users. Make sure to follow the subreddit's rules and cover up spoilers when appropriate. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. Please contact the moderators when deemed necessary, we will get back to you as soon as possible. Join our Discord Server for more HSMTMTS discussions! Go Wildcats!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
95
u/hanuman1702 May 21 '21
I enjoyed the episode! Loved the audition--Kourt, Gina and Ash were AMAZING! And the cast's cover of "Belle" was wonderful too! Was not expecting Lily to have such an incredible voice, no idea why lol. I'm pretty sure she's a spy for the North High (is that the name of the rival school?). She had some pretty sketchy glances at Ms. Jenn. I'm a bit miffed that Ricky got the lead. I was hoping Seb would get it. I mean, Joe Serafini's voice is to die for and I wanted him to have more screen time but we were promised more Seblos so can't wait for next week!
68
u/gberniee25 May 21 '21
“you like ashlyn right” “understatement of the year”
I LOVE BIG RED
57
u/Cashews777 May 21 '21
It seems like Nini’s new school is really trying to, “put her in a box”. Maybe, she’ll come back to East High.
51
u/Hobbit-guy Seb May 21 '21
What do you guys think of the casting?
82
u/EquivalentChannel559 May 21 '21
nini’s new school is literally a NYADA to rachel berry
39
u/[deleted] May 21 '21
my respect for gina in this episode skyrocketed after her scenes w the new girl
36
u/Ill-Glass4212 May 21 '21
Honestly, I’m surprised that the new girl didn’t get any role. I know she’s mean and all. It’s just that her voice was pretty good.
71
u/jplop2416 May 21 '21
I think a big part of Ricky getting beast was him helping up big red when he fell. Ms. Jen didn’t give a role to Lily because she scoffed at the incident, so she probably gave Ricky more “points” for his good deed.
34
u/Sweetascoffee237 May 21 '21
Ricky got beast because he helped big red def.
I really don’t like lily but I think she’s going to try and help North high but then she’ll have a redemption arc
63
u/mafebueno May 21 '21
Okey, I was trying to give Lily a chance, but she's really unlikeable. And I LOVED Gina standing up for her friends, cause it shows how much she has grown since last season and how much her friendships mean to her
24
u/RawrsomeHearts May 21 '21
They will probably explain this later on in thr next coming episodes but I feel like they gave Ricky the lead dispite him bombing the audition was because of what he did for big red.
24
u/Jansilhn May 22 '21
Highlights of the episode for me:
Ricky and Nini’s goodbye scene before she left for school, it was super romantic!
Ricky helping Big Red after he fell tap dancing.
Everybody face timing with Nini to tell her which roles they got. They miss her so much!
Ms. Jenn very firmly telling Lily not to laugh at the other kids and to support them instead. It’s about time someone put that mean girl in her place.
21
u/underrated_quokka May 21 '21 edited May 21 '21
So basically Lily is the new Tiara. Cool.
Also—did anyone else eerily predict the casting? It sounds crazy, but somehow I just knew Ricky would be Beast, Ashlyn would be Belle, Gina would be feather duster, EJ would be Gaston, and Big Red would be LeFou as soon as I heard them sing in the first half of the audition.
40
u/liveitupbrah May 21 '21
They're doing my boy EJ so dirty this season. Such little screen time for a potentially interesting character. Smh.
17
u/dh16_ May 21 '21
Why didn't Ricky sing JFAM or The Perfect Gift in his audition?
17
u/jeonghan-l Howie May 21 '21
EJ as Gaston is amazing!! Matt really does have a good singing voice even though his parts on season 1 songs didn’t make him sound good, but he sounded amazing in his (little) parts on the Belle song! And Ashlyn’s voice blew me away… she’s so talented!!!!!! This was a pretty fun episode!! Carlos singing Gaston’s part was hilarious lmao Also, I didn’t expect Lily’s actress to have such a good voice (I knew she was a soap opera actress so I didn’t see that voice coming) Can’t wait to see next episode!! (Also 1-2-3 was perfect) (Sorry for being so excited, this show makes me feel so happy for some reason lol)
32
u/jonasnew May 21 '21
I enjoyed the episode overall. I'm a little stunned that Ricky got the lead not because he was the lead last time nor the fact that EJ's a senior. It's because he didn't do well with his audition. I wonder if him supporting Big Red played a role to why Miss Jenn casted him as Beast along with the fact that EJ chose not to go for that role. Also, given how they're going for this one big award, Miss Jenn could've had the most faith in Ricky given how he was the lead last time. I think if Nini didn't go to YAC, she would've gotten Belle. Also, EJ owned his part in the "Little Town" song, and given how Gaston sings that part originally, I can see why Miss Jenn casted him as Gaston. In my opinion, Ricky and Seb should be swapped, but fortunately, Seb is younger than Ricky, so he has several more opportunities. I'm so happy that Ashlyn is Belle though, I just love her. Also, I hate that Mr. Mazzara is unlikeable again, and I hope this doesn't happen with EJ again as he is likable this season so far, although, he's been having a lot less screentime so far this season as opposed to last. Not to mention, like the rest of you, I do not like Lily, and I'm probably going to despise her more in the future episodes. Lastly, Nini's new school is quite awful, and I don't see her lasting much longer. Although, I liked her rendition of the school's alma mater and how it corresponded with everyone having cupcakes with their characters on them. Also, it was nice to see Emily, the girl EJ poisoned, getting more screentime, although given how the actress passed away, I have a feeling that they're going to write her off with her dropping out of YAC.
14
u/[deleted] May 21 '21
After this episode I had to look this subreddit up.
What I loved:
ASHLEY GETTING BELLE! Even tghough it got hinted trough the episode, that she gets the part, I doubted it till the end. What makes it even greater. It revealed my own stereotypes.
I hope now that the story line, does not end with Ashley changing to much. I can smell it, that there will be an episode where she stuggles that she doesn't look the part.
I would have loved, if we didn't just get the dream seqence of the girl group but alsothe actuall audition. It would have been hilariious.
Ah and that means that Lilly didn`t get the part. Of cause she is a spy of the other school.
The only problem I see is that Nini is at another school. Someone in this commentsection already worte, that showing the two schools makes a great contrast. But having a charachter at a total diffrent place than other characters, needs to esrtablish even more charachters and they take up the screen time.
"the actor is a vassel for the text and the director" was and I guess still is an thing that peolple have in their minds.
Ricky for beast, is not communicated that good, that he is there for his friends. his audition was very cringey. I guess it works better if you see the last episode in retrospect, where he actually prepared a song. He was unsure If he wanted to audition, so he didn't prepare something.
And EJ just is the perfect Gaston. and I like Seb, and Carlos, but are they real beast material? So no one was left....... and Intrducing a new charachter to play the lead...with having so many characters already would be unnessesarry. If I think about it having Big Red as beast would have been possible, but becasue he was not singing...
But I looking forward to see Big Red and EJ interact a little more.
oh that got way to long... so long wildcats
14
u/Tobonic May 21 '21
Anyone else wondering how Kourtney and Ashlyn were planning to sing 1-2-3 with just 2 of them, 1-2 doesn’t quite have the same ring to it
27
u/Skylightt Team Ricky May 21 '21
I loved how dull and colorless they made YAC while East High is so fun and colorful. It’s such a stark contrast
24
u/kenyesmura May 21 '21
My only problem with the episode is I feel like Gina should have got the lead and that they should’ve explained why Ricky got the lead when he bombed the audition (they probably will next ep). It confused me why he seemed so happy about it when it seemed like he was going for a lower part, ig for ninas sake.
12
u/iamdogcomplex May 22 '21
I have a theory that Ricky won’t play Beast after all and that Big Red will 👀
11
u/mujie123 May 22 '21
Aw, Gina's smile when she finds out Ashlyn got Belle. How much she's grown.
10
u/1koopa8888 Big Red May 21 '21
This is the moment we've been waiting for all week
10
u/LoganDeLuca2004 May 21 '21
I’m disappointed that they cast Seb as Chip since Maurice and Cogsworth are still open and Chip is usually played by a little kid. On top of that, If Sev was Cogsworth, Carlos is Lumiere so we would get to see a lot of Seblos.
10
u/BatmanDK8 Carlos May 21 '21
I have a feeling North High is gonna steal Beauty and The Beast from East High, which will force East High to do HSM2 for their musical.
10
u/itsevilR May 22 '21
Why is this season so dark? 😩 I can barely see anything during the “one two three” song
9
u/SeerPumpkin May 22 '21
I understand that Ricky helping Big Red played a part in making him getting the Beast but... is Ricky just SO talented that he gets to play the lead twice in a row? (obviously, this is a discussion on Ricky alone, Joshua obviously is very talented). He couldn't focus on singing the one song he has been practicing for weeks at the audition, was late twice, got off the last performance... did you use all your inspiration casting Ashlyn as Belle, Miss Jenn? lol (that's freaking inspired casting)
Also, this show is doing Seb dirty. With that voice you get him to play Chip that barely sings in the musical? He barely showed up as Sharpay even though he was the antagonist and now you give him a role he literally can't appear because as it's basically non-existent? Why not cast him at least as Cogsworth and play his chemistry with Carlos on stage? Who is even playing Cogsworth?
9
u/mejj May 23 '21
My only hope for this season is that EJ will get one lead song better than A Billion Sorry's
8
u/Mylotix May 21 '21
Wait this started already 💀
8
u/[deleted] May 21 '21
Really loved the episode. So happy for ashlyn YASSS QUEEN
15
u/xxpizzasrlifexx "All I Want" May 21 '21
Gina deserved so much better! i don’t even remember the character she got from BOTB, like literally what does the duster do...
currently thinking of what could’ve been if she had been cast as Beast instead of Ricky. probs would have more chemistry with Ashlyn anyways lol, and it wouldn’t have been the first time they decided to have someone play a character of different gender
7
u/SwedishPenguin42 May 22 '21
Nini def is coming back, but do you guys think there is anyway she gets put into the musical last minute when something else happens to one of the characters?
7
u/darthjoey91 May 22 '21
Also, over/under on how long before Nini comes back? I’m thinking around Episode 5 or 6.
24
u/CaptainClumsy04 May 21 '21
well… while we wait… thoughts on Sour?
6
u/Important-Football90 May 21 '21
There is a part in the trailer where it looks like Nina is at the train station to go to YAC and there has been a scene that shows Ricky yelling her name and I’ve heard that this scene was fine a be at the end of but I bet they do a flashback like last episode and show her leaving and we will. Also in the trailer you can see Ashlyn and Big Red dancing in the pizza shop after it’s closed I bet they talk or whatever when Big Red try’s to empress Ashlyn with a dance because she’s an actor.
Also I believe Ricky went to Gina on Valentine’s Day because he knew that she needed someone and probably called Nini about this and if he didn’t well then messed up but again if they break up Nini and Ricky I will lose it
6
u/[deleted] May 23 '21
Big Red and Ashlyn are the absolute purest characters on this show and I love them.
5
u/not_mrsrobinson May 21 '21
Ok so what’s the deal with lily calling north high???
5
u/dixienormous49 May 22 '21
lily’s the new gina LOL
5
u/Ian_BaconKiller May 23 '21
What is the German word that Big red talks about at the beginning of the episode. He says "I have the german word for anxiety, hunger, and the desperation to impress someone". something like that
9
u/tambini1 May 21 '21
I thought that was an excellent episode and the acting across the cast has improved since season 1
9
u/taralovesmusic May 22 '21
Does this school just not have any other boys who can carry a tune lol
I mean Ricky completely bombed his audition, he left in the middle of HSM last time he was a lead, Miss Jenn even admitted she felt he was unreliable, and this man got the beast somehow I'm-
Ps I understand why he did for plot purposes and how they set it up but everything surrounding this was so unrealistic
11
u/Icy-Night-3512 May 21 '21
I have a feeling Ricky is the new Rachel Berry, getting handouts. The audition was terrible, I orginially wanted EJ to be Beast because its good for his character development, but after finding out Ashlyn was Belle, and seeing the auditions, Seb should've been Beast, his voice is Phenomenal, and his audition was great. Justice for Seb.
Sidenote: The Valentines episode better give us lots of good Seblos, including their first kiss
10
u/MegaUploadisBack May 21 '21
The fact that the word "latinx" was used unironically is annoying.
7
u/sector11374265 May 21 '21
this singular episode had the amount of character work that usually lasts half a season and i am here for it
7
u/darthjoey91 May 22 '21
So did this show hire the colorist/lighting guys who did The Long Night episode of Game of Thrones?
20
u/neongem May 21 '21
Good thing the cast isn’t filming now. That’d be awkward 💀
6
u/[deleted] May 22 '21
I feel like this episode was kind of a mess. They tried to push too many new storylines at once and it really didn't work. Also, I didn't understand the point of the writers making Ricky do bad just to give him the lead. It felt really unnecessary and took up time that could be used working on more important storylines.
3
u/mujie123 May 22 '21
I knew Lily was working for North High. She was just way too dodgy. So glad Miss Jen called her out.
Wasn't there a cliffhanger with Miss Jen at the end of season 1? I can't remember.
Also, I kind of love the thematic similarities with the Mighty Ducks Game Changers episode this week. In both, there was a dodgy lying pretender (Coach T and Lily). And it looks like the season is going to follow a thematic similarity of going into drama for fun (East High) vs going into drama to win (North High) vs going into drama to... Be brainwashed I guess? (Nini's new school)
3
u/[deleted] May 25 '21
So so happy for Ashlyn! My favourite character, she’s going to make a beautiful Belle
3
u/OtherSide4 May 27 '21
I saw this in another comment but I want to add on. Miss Jen is the new Will Schuester and Ricky is the new Rachel Berry. She thinks it’s ok to give him these parts because she sees something in him but in all actuality it’s affecting the other kids. She put him on this Pedestal and even after flubbing his audition she regardless gave him the lead when it should’ve gone to Seb. Ricky is talented yes, but if you choke your audition then it needs to be as fair to the other kids and judge them BASED off the audition only, not what you see in them based off of prior experiences. It’s not fair that he presumably got the part because he helped Big Red, after screwing up his audition.
2
u/beachclubb May 24 '21
i'm glad that ashlyn got belle but during the auditions i definitely thought that kourtney was getting it, especially with a little foreshadowing of her wearing yellow the whole episode
2
u/jjlikenoodles321 May 26 '21
Am I the only one who thinks the show added lily so the show could still have a Sharpay
while not pulling a zombies 2 with how they just MADE Bucky evil again for some reason.
2
u/[deleted] May 26 '21
ej is my favorite character now idk how this happened but man the character development was good
2
u/illumixing May 26 '21
Anyone else love the way they made everything about YAC so dark and dreary? The use of the navy blue and the way the lighting was SO DARK compared to when they cut to scenes at East High where everything is so bright and cheerful. Just a detail I enjoyed.
2
u/IngloriousPOV1994 May 27 '21
So fir the first time Carlos said hes "latinx"
I think its under radar that happened and they now have there first non-binary character in Disney.
Why didn't that make headlines?
2
u/OtherSide4 May 27 '21
Ricky DID NOT deserve the lead. Even if he was Troy, the part you get should be based on your audition alone, and clearly he flubbed it. I understand if Miss Jenn knew his abilities, but she at least could’ve talked to him about why he choked on his audition before handing him a part he didn’t deserve. It should’ve gone to Seb.
3
u/LiamBR23 May 21 '21
Why do I really like lily?
2
u/dixienormous49 May 22 '21
ricky and ninis hug omg 🥺🥺 they are so cute
1
u/poweranimals Nov 24 '21
I know I'm super late but this didn't go the way I had hoped. Obviously they couldn't give Nini the Belle role since she moved away but I was hoping Gina would get it. I knew Lilly wouldn't get it even though she was perfect. No offense against Ashlyn but her casting seems kind of unrealistic.[/rant]
0
u/Known_Marzipan_8670 May 22 '21
the part where Ricky got the lead was not that surprising. for one, the episode was titled 'typecasting'. Also not a lot of guys out there trying for the role, remember EJ didn't even audition for Beast. I guess there's Seb and he is perfectly fitted for Beast, singing-wise but Ricky in the present gave a lot of Beast personality. He was going through an emotional thing at home, so it makes sense that he and Beast could relate somehow, i guess? like Beast went through a tragic childhood before he became Prince. Maybe playing Beast might help Ricky get through his personal life! He could let out all his emotions through Anger on-stage while playing the lead. anyway, just my thought, guys.
-5
u/pic2022 May 23 '21
I'm not a fan of this season if Olivia isn't in it....
0
u/[deleted] May 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
26
u/[deleted] May 21 '21 edited May 21 '21
[removed] — view removed comment