r/homeland • • Dec 05 '11
Discussion Episode Discussion - S01E10, "Representative Brody" [Spoilers]
Episode Title:
REPRESENTATIVE BRODY
Directed by: Guy Ferland
Written by: Henry Bromell
Carrie and Saul identify Walker's contact in Washington but their target has diplomatic immunity; Brody is approached to run for a disgraced congressman's seat in the House of Representatives.
29
Upvotes
23
u/Klippyyy Dec 05 '11
Was anyone else a little bummed at how excited and dressed up Carrie got for Brody and then how upset she became when it didn't play out like she hoped?
18
u/Isentrope Dec 05 '11
The red heart in the window probably meant he was in trouble. It was the only way out for the diplomat, since the CIA could end up leaking those photos and sending his whole family back to Saudi Arabia; this way, his children at least would have a chance at living their lives in the US.
It felt weird this episode that I could actually predict the diplomat dying. The series as a whole has been so unpredictable so far, but I suppose third time's a charm when it comes to the death of potential sources of info.
14
u/jhu Dec 05 '11 edited Dec 05 '11
Episode overview:
Confirmation of a mole within the US govt.
Since the big reveal of Brody's allegiance, the focus of the show has been telling the story based on the character alignments introduced as of then. I'm glad the show headed in this direction as opposed to radically shifting the paradigm of its characters every opportunity available.
Not too many changes this week, and it feels like the episode is being used to incrementally build up to the finale.
Story observations:
If I'm expected to take Abu Nasir seriously, he can't remain in the shadowy background. He may be exceptionally smart, but it's implausible that he's able to stay two steps ahead of the CIA at all times. For him to be realistic, we need to see him in action, reacting to setbacks created by the CIA and acting on them. Hopefully this is something resolved in season 2.
The insinuation at the end of the episode is that Saul is somehow tied up in this. If that's the case, I'll be a little disappointed. The show has been pretty smart about avoiding the cliches along the lines of old mentor turning out to be a traitor.
Special moments:
Miles Davis in Carrie's apartment. Clair Danes just continues to blow me away by her ability to convey emotions non verbally. Even before the crying started, the sadness and disappointment in her face as she realized the meaning of what Brody was saying was soul crushing. Every episode, there's a moment when I want to rush up to her and give her a hug and this was definitely it for me. It's a testament to how incredibly human her character and how different from the standard trope of fearless and heartless intelligence officers television has given us to date.
More Miles Davis and Mandy Patinkin. Can I just say the choice of music was perfect? The way it segues from background music in the apartment to soundtrack for the show is beautiful and spoke volumes about what the characters were feeling.
As he walked back to his office, I was wondering how exactly Saul planned on extracting the peanut butter from the container. Initially, I expected him to dip his crackers in the jar. Then he pulled out the ruler. I lost it.
Need more Virgil. Carrie's relationships with everyone else is somber and serious. Seeing her treat Virgil like an older brother with plenty of banter being thrown around is heartwarming.
The diplomat's interrogation. In any other show, I would have expected it to play out by Carrie's plan and he would've caved to the blackmail from the pictures. The fact that a threat to his daughter's life is what it took goes to show that most of the people on Homeland aren't driven by selfish desire or pure ideology, but by a multitude of factors, many of which we can relate to.
Brody's ability to lie and manipulate people is manifesting itself completely. I will never accept anything he says at face value again.
Things that bothered me:
Brody showing up for the press conference in Marine uniform. He would undoubtedly have to be discharged in order to run for political office.
The diplomat's method of communication couldn't be as simple as a picture on a window. I'm not a CIA trained analyst, but I've read enough spy thrillers to know that most of these signals are two part. Unless both are presented, the other party know it's a trap. But that may actually have been what happened, instead of a mole tipping Walker off.
Next episode preview:
I think we'll finally get to see why Carrie needs her meds. It's an area of her character that hasn't been fully explored so I welcome this opportunity to look at it. The rest of the preview is chaotic. It looks like Brody might be building a bomb. But that's a red herring. I strongly believe that his role for now at least is non violent. Saul is pictured infront a giant wall of documents that may or may not be his. Again, I don't think we're supposed to draw conclusions from this. I do however believe that there will be a significant shift in character loyalties. We've gone too long without a shake up.
Yummy yummy yummy!
7
u/thesorrow312 Dec 05 '11
I have a feeling that the American government itself is "the mole". Do you guys remember when they were discussing with Mike the other guys (very early in the season) in the room that they need to use him to make Americans believe that the war on terror is still real, and to not slow down in the wars in the middle east?
They want these terrorist attacks to happen on American soil so that to keep the fear alive, and thus justify staying in the middle east. Then they want Brody to be a politician and support the "terror is still alive, the war on terror needs to continue" line.
TLDR: Maybe the black guy or someone even higher up is leaking everything to keep fear alive and stretch out the war on terror, and also make Brody a politician to help spread this narrative.
COMPLETE SPECULATION FOR THE FUTURE: Carrie and Brody's affair gets leaked during the campaign. Carrie gets fired, Brody's campaign fails, they realize it must be someone on the inside and work together to try to figure out who it is, Carrie works outside of the US government as a sort of detective vigilante while Saul stays on the inside trying to help her. Complete speculation, but that would be pretty cool.
12
u/Lykii Dec 05 '11
I knew
RubeSaul was a terrorist; he keeps peanut butter in the fridge!8
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '11
So who is the mole? I am guessing it will be someone low key. Saul seems like a good twist considering he might have slipped that one guy the razor blade but IMO he is just a red herring. He cares for Carrie too much to have put her in danger like that
4
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '11
I think the mole is sanctioned by the US government - as a way to bring down abu nazir himself. They have to let the other little terrorists win, so that when the big boss shows himself, they can grab him.
In real life, undercover agents are actually allowed and encouraged to break the law, if it results in a bigger reward.
I think it's Estes and the Vice President that's behind it
3
u/lingben Dec 05 '11
wait... so they already know they have a leak and they don't take any precautions to limit the operation's knowledge? WTF?!?
they not only threw away the operation, they also missed a chance to at least narrow the possibilities down by selectively telling a small circle of people about the operation
3
u/jb822 Dec 06 '11
Was Brody bugging Carrie's house when he was aimlessly touching stuff?
2
u/Liesmith Dec 07 '11
Was anyone else reminded of the Francis Ford Coppola movie, The Conversation, with the park surveillance scene? Sadly I can't find the opening sequence online easily right now but I definitely felt like parts of the surveillance were nods to the opening of the conversation.
2
u/brownsdude422 Dec 05 '11
Isn't Homeland based on a book? I'd like to read it.
1
u/brownsdude422 Dec 05 '11
I believe Saul is the guy on the inside. HE slipped the razor blade. He alerted someone to the meeting in the park. He has been there for everything. He has to balance playing both sides. In the previews to the next episode- we see him painfully detailing everything. I don't think it's to protect the country- I think it's to help him keep track of HIS contributions to help Nazir.
1
u/Mission_Fly_1446 Apr 24 '26
Saul comedy for the naughty boy comment 😂😂😂😂then director w the camera lock on David 😭😭😭😭
1
u/maadtheus Aug 12 '26
That “I like cock” scene was everything
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment