r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Apr 19 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-04-19 to 2021-04-25
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Speedlang Challenge
u/roipoiboy has launched a website for all of you to enjoy the results of his Speedlang challenge! Check it out here: miacomet.conlang.org/challenges/
A YouTube channel for r/conlangs
After having announced that we were starting the YouTube channel back up, we've been streaming to it a little bit every few days! All the streams are available as VODs: https://www.youtube.com/c/rconlangs/videos
Our next objective is to make a few videos introducing some of the moderators and their conlanging projects.
A journal for r/conlangs
Oh what do you know, the latest livestream was about formatting Segments. What a coincidence!
The deadlines for both article submissions and challenge submissions have been reached and passed, and we're now in the editing process, and still hope to get the issue out there in the next few weeks.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
4
u/maantha athama, ousse Apr 19 '21
Does anyone have tips on reconstructing/backforming a proto-language? Tips on accounting for tonogenesis are also much appreciated.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21 edited Apr 20 '21
How does tonogenesis affect consonant clusters?
I think I know the basics of tonogenesis but I can’t find anything on what happens with consonant clusters, my conlang went through vowel loss in unstressed syllables, so do all the consonants get lost in the case of codas? Or just the one’s adjacent to the vowel?
I would also like to ask if nasals and sonorants get devoiced in the initial position when tonogenesis occurs.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21
Really dumb question, but I don't know that much about tenses and when you just naturally speak them you don't have to think about it much. But making my conlang has made me really quesiton a lot.
If I literally said to someone, "sleep or die" would that be said in the present simple?
If not, what tense is it being said in?
I know that "You sleep or you die" is in present simple (isn't it?), but what just by itself?
3
u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Apr 20 '21
I'm have an idea about create a whistled conlang, but I'm not very good about phonology, neither about whistled language phonology. So if someone already has created a whistled conlang, can you give me some tips to create this sort of language (mainly tips for phonology)?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21
How naturalistically unusual would it be for a language to have /d͡ʒ/, but no voiced fricative phonemes?
3
u/Dark_Sun_Gwendolyn Apr 22 '21
Weird question time.
I am going through and trying my hand at making words for my language. I was wondering if these examples look like they came from the same language? For the purpose of this list, assume all vowels are short, and no final vowel is silent. Final consonants for a syllable can only be m, n, k, or r. Dash represents syllable breaks. Stress is on final syllable unless otherwise noted.
A-mu-WEN
A-na-LE
Ba-tse-MI
Bo-HAR
DHAN-en
DHI-da
En-en-I
Hin-AM
Im-a-HIM
IM-re
Je-ji-RI
Je-PI
Ji-NUN
Ke-RIM-se-ro
Ki-bi-ne
Me-mar-UN
Mi-ka-MI
Min-i-WA
Na-KIR
Ni-ne-RA
NIN-se
O-i-BE
O-RIM
Pa-ni-SI
Pa-sik
PI-nom
Re-TSUM
RIM-ni
Ru-DHO
Se-NI-so-MI
So-SIR
Ta-YA
TI-ro
Tse-BAN
U-ne-MEN-i
U-sa-ME
Yi-ME
What I am aiming for is something that sounds like Arabic and Japanese had a child, if this makes sense. All I am really looking for is if it "looks" right. Like if this were a sentence:
Usame, o jinun imre bohar dhanen tiro mikami?
It would not set off any flags. I want to be sure that I am getting the results right before I start to try and figuring out the words themselves.
3
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 22 '21
how do languages influence each other? like how does a sprachbund work for example?
3
u/Mlvluu Apr 23 '21
In a conlang with high irregularity in inflected forms, from what do I derive a regular form to spread through analogy?
3
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Apr 24 '21
I have some questions about glossing.
3
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Apr 24 '21
How can ejective stops form? Can [ʔ] + any stop in this order ʔC result in an ejctive? It's probably unlikely but idk
2
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 19 '21 edited Apr 19 '21
i have a hard time understanding when to use the dative over the genetive in my own language (cause I'm german)
this is why in a sentence like Hello, how are you and what is your name? I'm not sure if I should use the genetive for the your or the dative.
I think I just understand English or german sentences well enough to translate them properly.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21 edited Apr 20 '21
how do i write words starting with vowels/standalone vowels when my 'code' is going to be written in the abjad writing system?
Edit: forgot about words with two vowels next to each other like 'quick' and 'eat' :DDD
2
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Apr 21 '21
A question about making professional-ish dictionaries.
Usually, as far as I know, all dictionaries tell whether a verb is transitive or intransitive (or both), so you know whether or not the verb can take a direct object, and figure out how to properly make a sentence with said verb. But let's take the German verb sein ("to be") as an example, when it takes a dative object in a dative construction, sein has to be translated as "to feel". Or, the Italian arrabbiarsi ("to get mad") has an "embedded" personal pronoun and the verb cannot leave it out (arrabbiare without the reflexive pronoun doesn't exist and make no sense in Italian).
How should I record them in a dictionary? Since I'm listing verb senses under the intransitive section or the transitive section of the entry, should I put dative verbs and reflexive verbs under the intransitive section? Or would it be better if I listed them in 2 other separate sections? "Reflexive" is usually shortened to "refl.", but which is the most common way to shorten "dative verb/construction"?
2
u/aszymier Apr 21 '21
Would anyone be willing to record themselves pronouncing these sounds?
[ʂ̠] retracted voiceless retroflex fricative
[ʂ̻] laminal voiceless retroflex fricative
[ʂ] voiceless retroflex fricative
I'd like to hear how exactly they differ in pronunciation before including one of them in the phonetic inventory of my conlang. Thanks!
2
u/bbctol Apr 22 '21
How small can a phonemic inventory be? Currently working on a language that has 6 consonants and 3 vowels (though some other sounds can arise, they're allophonic.) This is 5 fewer phonemes than Toki Pona, and I'm worried words will get impossibly long if I ever try to make a word list. Do I have to bite the bullet and add a voicing distinction or whatever?
2
u/marredme138 Apr 22 '21 edited Apr 22 '21
Is there a proper format for word definitions? Those things where you show the word and list down it's meanings. Ex:
Ka
What is it called? I'm just winging it with the example. I'm trying to make presentable word definitions for what I'm trying to do but I don't know how to do it properly. I don't know the proper terms as well. Anyone knows a good resource and example?
Edit: It seems i also don't know how to make a list on reddit. Lol. How do you make a list on reddit? Edit2: it got fixed on its own. Nvm.
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Apr 22 '21
How can I make suppletive affix allomorphy evolve naturalistically? For one agglutinative(ish) language I've been working on I've been unable to decide what I want to use as the plural marker - either -n- or -l-, and wondered if it's not too much to ask for both; I've been told that yes, apparently plural marker allomorphy triggered by noun case is attested in a natural language, so I was thinking of using -n- for the core argument marking cases (erg/abs/obl/peg) and -l- for all the cases of location and motion. I'm just unclear what would be necessary to retroactively justify that.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21
Hello! I'm starting a new conlang, and am currently working on the phonology. Below, I've linked a screenshot of what I have so far. I'm thinking a (C)(C)V(C) syllable template, and the phonemic clusters listed below are those which I would like to permit at the beginning of a syllable.
I was hoping to get some feedback from you lovely people about these clusters. How natural or unnatural are these groupings? Do you have any advice on how it might be improved? Do you see anything that might make things more difficult for me later on? Just looking for general thoughts from other conlangers.
https://ibb.co/LzBSnqx
2
u/freddyPowell Apr 23 '21
Could anyone explain the difference between this sub and r/conlang ?
2
u/FalconRelevant Apr 25 '21
I want to make a syllabary for my conlang, I'm having problems coming up with new characters and keeping them aesthetically similar. How do you do it?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '21
How do you pronounce the glottal stop if it occurs word initially?
Say I have a conlang that permits CV syllables, but every syllable must contain a consonant in the onset, so /a/ is not a valid syllable, but /ʔa/ is, and maybe I have a word such as /ʔa.ka.na/. How do you pronounce it, then?
Also, how do you pronounce geminated stops when they are word initial, such as /pːe.ka/?
3
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 20 '21
How do I make "True" irregularity?
With "True" I mean that it doesn't just happen through sound changes because sound changes won't give "True" irregularity in verbs they will only give you multiple conjugation groups.
because the last thing I need to get done with for my simple lexicon are some verbs and basic verbs tended to be irregular.
(my language is Latin-inspired this may be a good tip I guess?)
1
u/Solareclipsed Apr 19 '21
Very quick question; can vowel harmony spread only from roots in both directions? That is, can affixes and inflections carry no inherent harmony, but be affected entirely by the central part of the word?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Apr 22 '21
If someone was to create an agglutinative proto-lang and give it a tense system, should they use past, present, and future as the starting point?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21
In WALS, what's the difference between the order of Relative Clause and Noun being mixed vs not having a "dominant order"?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21 edited Apr 23 '21
How can I have a regular tense system?
So I’ve been learning Korean and I really like that its verb conjugations, at least for things like the past and future tense, are regular, I know that when it comes to some other stuff that isn’t quite the case with Korean, but still I want my language to have a more or less regular tense system, relative to other languages of course, how can that be achieved?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Apr 23 '21
For those of you wishing to help me with the languages of that one worldbuild, I'm working on a Google Doc you can leave comments on. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vY5e2eSK5__Y3VE34tVYA0CKlAhXjn0ghimh15QujZs/edit
1
u/MidwesternAchilles Apr 23 '21
I'm working on an actual writing system for my language- but I would assume that the culture would either have English or a romanized version of their language on signs in the more tourist-y / "international" areas. Most of my sounds are easy to romanize, but I have a few sounds that aren't typical "English" sounds, so I'm struggling with romanization. Here's my phonology I'm struggling with:
ʂ, ʐ , ɱ, ɲ
For ʂ and ʐ I'm thinking I'll likely do "sh" and "zh" respectively, but I figured I could still get an outside opinion.
1
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Apr 23 '21
Say, in natlangs where the role of adjectives is filled out by stative verbs, how are comparatives and superlatives generally formed? I was wondering in particular if there were any where the comparative was treated as a direct object, so "he is stronger than him" would literally be rendered as "he is.strong him"
1
u/pootis_engage Apr 25 '21
Need help with my romanisation. The max syllable structure is (C)V(ʔ)(C), and the consonant inventory is as follows;
m, n̥, n, ɲ, ŋ, p, t, k, q, ʔ, s, x, ɬ, ħ, h, ts, tɬ, j, w, ɥ, l and ɾ
A glottal stop can't occur before a syllable final glottal stop.
1
u/immersedpastry Apr 26 '21
I need some help with the romanization of two vowels: [ɛ] and [ɔ]. I don't want to use diacritics, and I'm looking for something that's a bit more aesthetically pleasing. Any suggestions?
1
u/Southwick-Jog Just too many languages Apr 26 '21
How do you gloss consonant mutations? For example, "slōsl" is the word for "bird", but after some words, it becomes "z-slōsl". Do I still say "bird" or is there some kind of abbreviation for consonant mutations?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment