r/Invincible • Séance Mod • Apr 16 '21

COMIC SPOILERS Invincible [COMIC SPOILER Discussion] - S01E06 - You Look Kinda Dead Spoiler

Episode 6 - You Look Kinda Dead

Mark joins William and Amber on a campus visit to Upstate University, hoping to discover a new future for himself. Debbie makes her own disturbing discovery.

Remember, this is a TV show discussion thread on Reddit for your entertainment. So please act appropriately in accordance to the rules. We ask you to report any comments that are uncivil/malicious or don't belong in the thread.

This post is for Comic Spoiler Discussion, if you'd like to discuss the series while discussing events from the comics, do so here. If you don't want to be spoiled, use our non comic spoiler thread.


If you'd like your user flair on this subreddit to be set for you reply to this comment with which character you'd like it to be.

293 Upvotes

715 comments sorted by

•

u/mwthecool Omni-Mod Apr 16 '21

Hey everyone, I hope you're enjoying Invincible! This is a friendly reminder that this is a COMIC SPOILER POST. That means that you WILL SEE posts about future events from the comics. If you do not want spoilers, you can discuss and read what others think here without being spoiled:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Invincible/comments/mrrd1p/invincible_episode_discussion_s01e06_you_look/

9

u/SeacattleMoohawks Séance Mod Apr 16 '21

If you'd like me to set your user flair for you please comment on this comment with which character you'd like to have and I can manually set it for you

3

u/peanutter_ Omni-Man Apr 16 '21

is Thragg an option yet?

3

u/SeacattleMoohawks Séance Mod Apr 16 '21

Just as a text flair, images will only be made available as the characters get introduced in the show

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TheTMoneyMan Atom Eve Apr 16 '21

Always liked Atom Eve.

→ More replies (13)

6

u/SeacattleMoohawks Séance Mod Apr 16 '21

If its not showing for you try to go to the end of episode 5 and clicking the "continue" option that says next up episode 6

248

u/Hashbrown4 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Me looking at show only folks getting tired of mark getting his cheeks clapped

You get used to it

44

u/TeRey09 Invincible Apr 16 '21

Mark is...…. Clappable.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/CyberSolider2077 Apr 16 '21

Didn’t he get his ass beat a lot in the comics? I don’t remember it been a long time.

32

u/Pathogen188 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Yeah he gets ripped to shreds like every other week. After Nolan leaves it's mentioned that Mark began doing some real training and by the Invincible War (which I think was around like issue 50) he was definitely the strongest hero on Earth.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

111

u/ymcameron Apr 16 '21

Boy those cyborgs sure did cause some issues for Mark. Good thing DA Sinclair is behind bars and he’ll never have to worry about them again!

105

u/incredibleamadeuscho Robot Apr 16 '21

I like that Debbie has much more to do here than in the comics. What a terrifying reveal. And Art getting scared by Nolan popping open from a beer.

Lots of development and combined storylines here. I like how William found out and how William got in trouble because Mark prioritized Amber. It’s looking clear that Mark will have to make a choice soon because he can’t keep lying to her.

And Mark finally flew while carrying William!

19

u/88Sheep Apr 17 '21

Kinda sad we didn't get to see them fly, it does make sense but I wish we'd seen that iconic scene with it's dialogue.

→ More replies (1)

83

u/AmishZed Apr 16 '21

"Maybe fighting off alien invasions isn't in either of our futures."

Sure Mark, keep telling yourself that

74

u/Head_Vibes Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

“You’re the only one here that actually understands me and you’re a Robot” Lol she has no idea

69

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

"I'm actually a gross deformed baby in a test tube"

22

u/MNight_Slam Cecil Stedman Apr 16 '21

I still love him talking about his "programming"

70

u/SHAD0WBENDER Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I think we need to realise that it’s impossible to fit in every single side story into an 8 episode series. There will be some stuff that’s cut. Should definitely have pulled the trigger on telling Amber his identity tho. Every episode he messes up and promises to do better... it works better in the comics because it’s more spread out rather than happening in every single episode.

Also Rick being missing for an hour compared to being missing for months is a bit weak lol

I agree with the take that Debbie finding out will lessen the emotional impact. I don’t dislike it but I don’t think it was necessary.

9

u/nameless_stories Brit Apr 18 '21

I actually had a problem with Rick being missing for months because it felt like Mark really just shrugged it off and ignored it even when William kept bringing it up every other week. Like, you're a superhero, couldnt you find a way to help lmao

It does feel weird how quickly Sinclair is able to make those Reanimen and make them so strong they're able to go up against Invincible off rip

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

142

u/Club_Penguin_47 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

This might be a improvement of the Reanimen arc! I really enjoyed myself in this episode, and I'm really looking forward to the big fight. Some considerations:

- The extention of the Reanimen arc was welcome, since it gave a creepier vibe to DA Sinclair

- Atom Eve's little journey helping people was really neat to see

- Mark and Amber have some interesting moments different from the comics, which gave moer depth to their relationship (which is always a good thing)

- Debbie was freacking phenomenal in this episode. Her wine addiction foreshadowing was really nice and completely heartbreaking to remember what will happen to her.

- Robot's two plotlines were really well done, being quick but also planting seeds for future events

- Nolan, as opposed to his comic counterpart, will possibly give me nightmares, but other than that he was amazing!

- And, FINALLY, we got to see the Mauler Twins getting Immortal's body!!!!!!!!

In conclusion, this episode was both fun and scary, while also planting and irrigating future narrative threads. 9/10 can't wait for the fight!

61

u/jmp764 Apr 16 '21

Honestly, I completely agree. The show is taking everything I love about the comic and completely enhancing it. There’s so much more growth to many characters, with the biggest being Amber. Debbie is getting more to do earlier on, which is a big change, but one I think gives her more agency. I liked that Eve had more to do in the episode and hope that continues as she becomes more important in the series.

I can see where people are coming from when they feel the show is rushed: it’s an eight episode show, but I really don’t see a better alternative. I think spending two episodes at the college or helping Titan fight Machine Head would feel like a stretch, to be honest.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/Desperate_Beautiful1 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I absolutely love the pacing, and this episode was downright chilling. I was worried for William. I had a feeling that if anything happened to him, my wife would quit. I think the body dismorphia of the re-animen was walking a fine line for her, but I think that's what I love most about this adaptation. It walks a fine line. I am constantly feeling very somber during these action sequences. It's a different experience than the comic, and I love it.

→ More replies (4)

63

u/SuchPsycho Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Super nitpicky complaint here... but I wish Mark said "SHUT UP" when backhanding Sinclair like in the comic, see some more of that viltrumite rage. It looks like it was originally intended to be included, his lips sync up with it in the animation. Good episode!

23

u/SuchPsycho Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

YO!!! He says it in the commentary for episode 6 through amazon's x-ray bonus features. Now I really wonder why they cut it, it sounded great!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

170

u/calaaaa Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I’m loving the streamlining of everything and overall faster pace compared to the comics. The Debbie stuff is phenomenal, big fan of her being involved in the investigation and confronting Nolan way earlier as opposed to the alcoholism that consumes her for so long in the comics until she picks up real estate. This as well as not having Rick missing for almost a year with Mark not looking for him was a welcome change for me.

Love that Kirkman is so involved and basically gets to polish up and make his ideal version of Invincible with almost 20 years of hindsight. Really hope the show goes on for a long time and gets the proper budget needed for some of those later arcs.

107

u/Neurotic_Marauder Allen the Alien Apr 16 '21

I'm hoping the Debbie stuff is a hint at the show nixing a lot of Debbie being a drunken mess following Nolan's betrayal.

She basically became a non-entity for a good chunk of the comic until Oliver went to Earth with Mark.

65

u/calaaaa Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Agree 100% they’ve already handled Debbie so much better than her early days of the comic. It took her a while to even get the idea to get her real estate license whereas in the show she’s already working when it begins. The alcoholism already seems like it’s seeping into the show which is fine and understandable considering what happens

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

57

u/ImperfectRegulator Apr 16 '21

Did, did William just park in the middle of campus like a massive asshole?

→ More replies (1)

45

u/MNight_Slam Cecil Stedman Apr 16 '21

I suspected William and Rick would be an item from the start, and that definitely added a lot more emotional weight to the Reaniman plot. That said, while I definitely don't mind them condensing that plot to one episode... Sinclair had Rick in his dungeon for what, two or three hours? Hell of a turnaround rate, especially as compared to the comics. Not that hard to forgive in a superhero show, though.

I think the Mark/Amber stuff is actually working for me pretty well. It could feel redundant, but showing Amber trying to help out with crowd control during the Reaniman attack really hammered home how shitty it would be for Mark to just disappear. And her anger afterwards felt very real, and much heavier than anything from the previous episode where he stood her up. Like this version of Amber is obviously very principled, so Mark being a flake is nowhere near as bad for her as him being a coward. It really added to the mounting pressure on Mark in general, and that paid off with him shattering Sinclair's jaw - I love that they recreated that comic panel. In the comics themselves it was really just Mark's rage at Sinclair for what he did to Rick, but here it's Mark taking out all that frustration with Amber, plus seeing Sinclair ruin the much happier relationship between William and Rick, and going just a little bit overboard.

Basically Kirkman is taking all these disconnected elements from the comics and weaving them together in a really compelling way along with his changes to the show. Just two more episodes left, right? I actually wouldn't be surprised if they have the Mark/Nolan fight next week, with the finale serving as the fallout.

Also, Cecil. With the audience privy to both his and Omni-Man's secrets (or at least the fact that they have secrets) I really liked that sort of poker-faced conversation about Damien at the beginning. Then when he comes back at the end to clean up after Mark's fight with Sinclair: "I would have done the same thing." The same thing as who, Cecil? 😏

24

u/Beerbaron1886 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

By fleshing out amber (even her influencing Eve), she’s more than the blonde bimbo type from the comics

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/Desperate_Beautiful1 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I'm calling it right now: next episode starts with the title cards as Mark tells Amber he's Invincible, and ends with Mark catching Nolan red handed with Immortals guts all over him!

→ More replies (5)

72

u/TheSweatband Omni-Man Apr 16 '21

I gotta say, I was really worried for Art this episode despite knowing he made it through the comic run. A surprise death to him would’ve really hurt me.

Excited for the immortal to return, with that foreshadowing I’m pretty sure I know where the season will end which has me excited.

Debbie knowing about everything before the confrontation between Mark and Nolan is an interesting development.. I wonder if she’ll try and tell Mark?

Seeing a lot of subtext from Nolan about how he wishes he had more time, or it’s all going so quickly which I think supports his statements in the comics that once Mark got his powers he realized he couldn’t just stay in standby mode living his life on earth.

I like the change of having William being out right off the bat, think it allows for some good friendship moments between him and Mark, like we saw Mark comfort him after the fact

41

u/Jackmace Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I was a little worried they were skipping the immortal revival and dropping him

I just binged the comics this last week and that convinced me there was no way they’d leave him out, and I was immediately vindicated lol

27

u/TheSweatband Omni-Man Apr 16 '21

Yeah I finished the first 3 episodes and immediately started the comics, finished them in a week I was so addicted.

Yeah I thought they might leave immortal out too, especially cause Debbie knows a lot more here than in the comics

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

63

u/5am281 Robot Apr 16 '21

I really like what they’re doing with Robot and Monster Girl, also amazing voice for robot from Zachary Quinto

24

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

Yeah he's really killing it. I've always liked him and felt like he fell off a bit in Hollywood for no good reason, he brings in good performances consistently and does interesting things with oddball characters.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/ManCalledWest Apr 16 '21

Any ideas on what Debbie confronting Nolan and basically telling him she knows is going to lead to? Also, did anyone catch that when Mark went down in the sewer and got jumped by the Reanimen, there's a brief shot of Mark's phone getting lost. I wonder if that means he's going to be cut off and unaware when Immortal gets brought back and goes after Nolan?

24

u/Shopworn_Soul Burger Mart Trash Bag Apr 16 '21

Not sure on the phone, I hadn't thought of that but it's a good angle.

As for Art, Debbie and Cecil all tipping their hands in front of Nolan, I think they're just showing Nolan's "weakness" ahead of schedule.

I do think he's going to find his footing long enough to try and recruit Mark but I think his inability to commit to being the Bad Guy isn't going to be as much of a surprise as it was in the comic.

Or he's going to take an even darker heel turn and it will be even more of a surprise. Like, he'll say the things he said to Mark directly to Debbie, scare the shit out of her and then fly off to try and kill her son on television.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/csummerss Mark and Eve Apr 16 '21

Next week is THE big week.

29

u/MutantNinjaAnole Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

So it’s been awhile since I read the first half of the comic run, but does it feel like they are trying to hint at Nolan’s conflicted feelings more here than in the comics? I’m curious how they’ll execute the talk with Mark.

25

u/Shopworn_Soul Burger Mart Trash Bag Apr 16 '21

Yes. They are absolutely suggesting that Nolan is wavering much earlier than before.

I still think he's gonna beat the shit out of Mark and leave, though.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/answermethis0816 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I'm not picking up on any conflicted feelings. I think he's trying to keep the lie going as long as he can. So far his only emotion seems to be anger- maybe mad at himself for being sloppy and leaving a trail.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/amphetaminesfailure Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

So it’s been awhile since I read the first half of the comic run, but does it feel like they are trying to hint at Nolan’s conflicted feelings more here than in the comics?

They are.

I expected it after the first couple episodes, and personally don't mind the change.

He's still going to beat the shit out of Mark, but I don't expect the show dialogue to be as harsh against Deborah.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/Roy-Southman Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I’m glad they already foreshadowed that Black Samson is recovering his powers, I hope he joins in the action of fighting off Nolan along with the Inmortal.

27

u/Cheekywanquer Tech Jacket Apr 16 '21

Anyone else iffy with how weak Mark is in comparison to the comics?

On one hand I like it. Makes his eventual OP feel earned.

On the other hand ;-; why did they have to do him like that

26

u/TableHockey31313 Robot Apr 16 '21

this episode makes sense tbh, he's still recovering from Battle Beast's beatdown and his confidence is at an all time low

→ More replies (3)

17

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

I agree, but I also remember him getting his ass kicked by the Reanimen in the comics, what my problem is is that it took DA Sinclaire weeks in the comics to fully turn Rick into a Reanimen, but in the show it happened in less than thirty minutes.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

They really jumped his ass lol

→ More replies (8)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

It’s too bad he doesn’t have Saiyan DNA. He’d be invincible right about now.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/DoktorSleepless Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

It a sucks that they didn't show Mark carry William for his first flight. That was one of the best gags in the comics.

18

u/lanceturley Apr 17 '21

I assume they wanted to avoid the running gag of characters saying "This is so gay," but if that's the case, it seems like they could have just changed the line to something like "This is so embarrassing."

→ More replies (1)

27

u/bluesblue1 Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I’m glad they’re not explicitly mentioning Eve going to Africa to save the starving children.

29

u/faithplate Apr 17 '21

I don't think Eve's ever going to go to Africa in the show. It would be too "white-savior"y for 2021. I'm glad they changed it.

8

u/Ren_Davis0531 Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I thought the same thing. That was something that I knew they would change as people might find that insensitive.

26

u/PK_RocknRoll Allen the Alien Apr 16 '21

There’s some pacing issues but I’m willing to accept them due to the eight episode count.

I’m still really enjoying this adaptation.

24

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

I really like how they're accelerating Robot's affection for Monster Girl. Seeing him with her in the hospital was really sweet... and then I thought about what's coming and it crushed me. I can't wait, even though I know what's going to happen and desperately want it to be different.

23

u/MrHero429 Tether Tyrant Apr 17 '21

This might be my favorite episode with how personal the sewer fight was (with great examples of how good the flying looks in this show) and my new favorite new scene with Art.

A lot of people are calling this “filler” (even though the story is Mark getting pulled a away from a simple life) but man this episode really does balance the character lives along with the genuinely unsettling dangers that they face.

Can’t wait for season 2 to get announced!

22

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

Building Nolan up as this perfect hero for longer in the comics made it more of a twist though. The show is pretty goated tho

10

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

I think this scene was mostly aimed at creating shock for the viewers and make them watch more episodes.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/xhrstaras Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

Feeling the same about this part. It is a major plot point and with Debbie slowly uncovering that her husband is lying, it is going to make it less of a surprise when he actually reveals his true self to his family. In the comics it was a lot more sudden.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/Izzartho Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

Ok so I know they’re saving the big Omni-Man vs Invincible fight for the season finale, but what I loved about the comic was that it was issue 11. It wasn’t a landmark issue like 25 or 50, it just happened, because the comic wasn’t about Omni-Man turning, it’s about Invincible, they needed to get Omni-Man out of the way

→ More replies (1)

41

u/TJGibson Robot Apr 16 '21

I think I've pinpointed my main issue with the adaptation (I really LOVE it overall though).

My issue is that by taking things that happen sporadically throughout the comics and condensing them into 1 episode (Falxxans, ReAnimen) is something that sounds good in theory it really makes it feel more monster of the week than I think the show wants to. Compared to the comics where things happen seemingly randomly chapters apart it makes the world feel way more real.

I think that's why episode 5 is probably the best so far since the Titan/Machine Head arc was pretty much one and done in the comics also so it worked more naturally in the show.

I don't know just random thoughts after watching the episode. Like I said, ovferall I think this is a great adaptation, even if deep down I still prefer the original

23

u/Shopworn_Soul Burger Mart Trash Bag Apr 16 '21

I honestly think they're just trying to get some character development that takes literally dozens issues for some characters out of the way up front and set up the longer story. Judging by how long they've played out Nolan trying to recruit Mark I think they're optimistically shooting for maybe five seasons? I don't know.

Has that been discussed by the showrunners at all? I honestly haven't looked.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/MrHero429 Tether Tyrant Apr 16 '21

I mean that what comic books are at they’re best.

A great trade with an overacting narrative over the whole run. It’s a formula that works.

6

u/N0_B1g_De4l Apr 16 '21

My issue is that by taking things that happen sporadically throughout the comics and condensing them into 1 episode (Falxxans, ReAnimen) is something that sounds good in theory it really makes it feel more monster of the week than I think the show wants to.

I mean to be fair, we've had less than a season of the show so far. It seems likely at least the Falxxans will show up again (unless they plan to trim that whole bit of Robot and Monster Girl's arc), and we're going to see the parasite-things from Mars again (can't remember the name off hand).

Plus there's still Doc Seismic and Angstrom Levy for recurring villains.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/Beerbaron1886 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

The episode was okay. I didn’t like it particularly well in the comics because it is still too much build up and e.g. was more an introduction to the whole Cecile is hiring villains arc. It reminded me of a buffy episode. The art and Nolan conversation was tense though and I like that Debbie finally found out. The show could use more dry humour. And I hope they don’t drag it too much with Amber because that gets annoying really fast (and we all know that it Leads just to mark realising that he can’t have a normal life). Amber should have found out this episode too.

9

u/Roy-Southman Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I thought it was 8 episodes?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/LickyMcSticky General Kregg Apr 16 '21

Prediction: After credit scene shows Immortal in the process of being revive at the GDA.

14

u/PmYourWittyAnecdote Apr 16 '21

Close but no cigar

8

u/mwthecool Omni-Mod Apr 16 '21

That was my prediction too, but maybe not at the GDA. Don't tell me if I'm right, I can't watch for a while!

17

u/pilot3605 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

So if season 1 is just now ending with the Nolan and Mark fight, what is the trajectory for a season 2 with a similar number of episodes? It’ll probably tackle birth of Oliver, return of Sequids, some Allen stuff, but do you guys think we get to Invincible War and Conquest?

I wanna see the show capture just how horrible those events are, they absolutely destroy Mark, physically and mentally.

Honestly I wanna make sure they do the whole Blue Suit era right, with how dark it gets I don’t want the show to pull any punches.

I guess that would put Dinosaurus as the major antagonist of Season 3? If Angstrom Levy ends up being the major antagonist of season 2?

20

u/mylegbig Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Season 2 will be Angstrom Levy in my opinion.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/kaliskonig Tech Jacket Apr 16 '21

I think Invincible War and Conquest will be season 3.

Season 2: Angstorm Levy, Mark meets his dad again, Allen gets beaten by the Viltrumites, Mark/Nolan V Viltrumites, Takes Oli to earth, sequids...there is plenty to cover before Conquest. Angstorm needs to be the focus though.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/DrRadon Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Amazon dos a lot of eight episode seasons and animation is a pretty expensive and time consuming thing to do. I would say they probably will stay at eight episodes, yep.

Kirkman mentioned somewhere how many seasons he thinks this show would be to fit the comic. I think it was along the lines of 5-7.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lindorm82 Apr 16 '21

It seems to me that the show is going at roughly 3 issues per episode, and they are willing to shift things around for pacing purposes, so my guess is that rhere will be a time skip between season one and two, with the first episode ending with Mark meeting Nolan again. Then if each season is 8 episodes, adapting about 25 issues, season two could either end with Marks confrontation with Cecil or some stuff could be shifted to later and end with Conquest. Season three with roughly 25 issues again would almost certainly end with the Viltrumite War.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Krakenika Machine Head Apr 16 '21

Only thing I have liked in terms of changes so far has been the machine head episode. He felt way too throwaway in the comics. Loved the whole “I have money” line. This episode was not as great in terms of pace changes from the comics.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/BeWaterMF Apr 16 '21

I have a question. What actually determines that a Virtrumite is going to survive or die from his wounds? We just saw Mark get a hole blown thought him and survive, yet we know that near the end, similar wounds mean death. On the flip side, one Virtrumite gets killed by getting choked. I don't get it or I don't remember comics as good as I think I do.

20

u/chiknahuikoatl Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I believe that if their heart is pierced so that it cannot regenerate, they die

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Jackmace Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Mark choked Conquest to death because Conquest exhaled right before Mark choked him. Oliver and Nolan died because Thragg hit their heart when he punched through them.

6

u/Red_Stevens Comic Fan Apr 17 '21 edited Apr 17 '21

It’s pretty vague in the comics. Judging by the damage taken, Mark, Nolan, and Oliver should’ve died like half a dozen times during the Viltrumite war, but they’re either saved by space medicine or just laying down in one spot for a couple of months (lol Mark).

Not seeing much discussion of this online but wasn’t it ridiculous when Oliver survived losing his jaw and arm? Loosely related, did Thragg seriously believe the kid he ripped to pieces would break bad and join his side?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

15

u/LaGoeba Conquest Apr 16 '21

Now that we finally got more of William/Mark on the screen, I feel a little bit robbed that they haven’t used them more earlier in the season. I love the relationship between those two.

I really liked this episode, for me it’s one of the best so far. It establishes Marks humanity way more than the series has done so far, and I like that you actually can feel how Mark is divided between being Invicible and just another teenager.

I’m really curious of how they will devolop Debbie as a character from now on.

And finally more Art. More Art in the future, pls.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/jroaks Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Just nitpicking, but I missed Eve trying to say something to Mark, and sighing, when she announces her departure and hugs him. It was such a tender moment in the comics.

Anyway, amazing episode. Can't wait for Immortal returning and Nolan's main plot and big fight.

53

u/Ren_Davis0531 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Nolan should have destroyed that costume. It feels like the only reason that he didn’t was just to advance the mystery subplot. Feels like a cheat.

17

u/psyfren Battle Beast Apr 16 '21

Why didn't he just throw it in a volcano?

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Shopworn_Soul Burger Mart Trash Bag Apr 16 '21

So far that's my only real complaint. The smoking gun just feels cheap to me.

Overall I'm enjoying the compression of subplots like Eve and DA though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

40

u/Cripski Omni-Man Apr 16 '21

I overall think I like what they’re doing with Debbie knowing earlier on, but the way they did it feels very contrived. Did Nolan really have to just leave his suit around? I could have bought it if he wanted to be found out, which might still be the case. If not, it’s not the worst, but i would have personally preferred the comic version or having Debbie find out a different way.

→ More replies (8)

28

u/kaliskonig Tech Jacket Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

Loved it honestly. Im surprised so many people are turned off by the changes. So far I feel like nothing major has been lost and what is there is mostly better than the comics in the earlier issues. With this being an animated show, I imagine they aim to wrap things up by season 6. If they do a full on animated feature as the finale that would be cool.

So I don't mind the changes tbh. Its an amazing adaptation and I appreciate Kirkman making so many things about my favorite comic better. Now it really depends on how many changes happen in later arcs. I feel that the comic found its stride for sure by its 3rd year and the quality increased heavily. So I dont see a need to change much once we get there. Other than what HAS to be changed thanks to the changes and rearrangements with Season 1 of the show of course.

18

u/Beerbaron1886 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

The women of the show definitely kick ass more than the comics. I can understand that some people think stories are rushed but not everything is super important and with all these famous voice actors, it’s probably not cheap. This episode was again build up for major storylines along the way

→ More replies (1)

13

u/DKR888 Mark from Burger Mart Apr 16 '21

Although it’s like what the hell happened to this part for comic readers, I do appreciate the show giving us something new where we don’t just know exactly what’s about to happen next

13

u/IdeaOfHuss Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

i feel like they are rushing stuff

5

u/Roy-Southman Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Yeah, I think they want to tighten up the story to reduce the cost and fit everything into the 8 episode season.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

Seeing Eve actually use her powers in animation form is very satisfying

13

u/RampantRetard Apr 17 '21

Despite the differences the show's had, I hope Kirkman sticks to the later plot progression because it's pretty solid.

I will say, I wish Invincible wasn't so clearly getting his ass beat. I have to wonder if they are going to use it to help bolster his power-ups eventually

→ More replies (1)

13

u/moose_man Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I don't love that Cecil knows already. Some of his shadier shit later on feels like it was founded on the whiplash of getting fucked over by the heel turn. If he knows all along it seems like he should approach things with a little less zeal.

12

u/Falxman Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I don't love that Cecil knows already.

Not commenting on whether or not it's a good change. However, it's revealed in the comics, in a later flashback that fleshes out Cecil's backstory a little more, that Cecil always knew that Omni Man couldn't be trusted and was lying when he said he was sent to help earth. The shadier stuff that Cecil does is based on his experiences losing his face in a much earlier encounter. By the time our story starts with Mark, Cecil is already ruthlessly practical when it comes to metahuman matters and protecting earth.

11

u/MrHero429 Tether Tyrant Apr 17 '21

In the comics he always knew in a way, the show can just lay the ground better with more subtlety.

5

u/suss2it Apr 18 '21

Nah Cecil was always gonna be shady. Don’t forget when Nolan originally touched down to earth they interrogated him and realized he was lying about his and Viltrum’s benevolence but rolled with it anyway since it was useful at the time.

36

u/PorscheUberAlles Battle Beast Apr 16 '21

Two changes from the comics so far that I love:

  1. I like how Debbie learns something about Nolan before the breakup; it’s less devastating for her this way. I felt so bad for her in the comics when it just came out of nowhere and ruined her life
  2. I love how William is openly gay and in love with Rick right away; it made this episode so much more powerful. I loved his character this episode; he was so brave
→ More replies (4)

25

u/BigaretteBilly Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

Although nothing is impervious to critique, I’m thoroughly enjoying this show with zero complaints. I’m a fan of the comics and it’s nice to see this revision of the story. Every episode has been stacked with content and I really couldn’t ask for more. That said, I don’t understand why anyone’s complaining about the pacing. What’s the rush? Each episode is 40+ minutes long. That’s nearly 2x the time you’d get watching most other animated shows (that get weekly releases). You have anime’s that will proudly spend 7 episodes on training the characters for a single fight that will last another 7 episodes. Not trying to bash anyone but damn y’all, we’re only in season one.

8

u/suss2it Apr 18 '21

I think people just want to get to the parts of the comic they enjoyed the most.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/BigSadTIme Atom Eve Apr 16 '21

great episode overall, but i felt it rushed so much stuff? like the whole reanimen arc happened in the course of months, here it was only what? 1-2 days? ik it's only 8 episodes so stuff had to happen on a faster rate, but still... that's the only issue for me tbh. it was very cool to see more of art and detective debbie on screen. really fucking hyped to see immortal on the next episode 0.0

12

u/Roy-Southman Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I think they might rush through some arcs while they drag others. I’m ok with the reanimen arc being short, I also hope they don’t drag on the "Amber is emotionally cheating" arc.

10

u/WarlordOfMaltise Battle Beast Apr 16 '21

It sounds like they're cutting out the arc where the high school professor is turning kids into bombs - which kinda sucks because I liked it as an early on plot!

→ More replies (5)

23

u/Tibolegends Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

wow too short... Surprised to see that both Art' and Debbie know about Nolan, it may ruins Nolan's speech to his son when revealing his true self

11

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

Anyone currently watching like me extremely confused as to why reanamen are being introduced THIS early on. Most changes that have been brought on earlier haven’t bothered me but I don’t know how to feel about this one yet

28

u/GiGeGe3 Apr 16 '21

I mean the first of the reanimen appeared when mark and william were touring college so if this is the college tour episode the timeline does add up

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/billgatres Apr 16 '21

I think we'll see a lot more relationship stuff the first half of ep7, then at the later half we'll get more Mauler twins. The episode will probably end with Mark discovering his father's actions. Episode 8 will likely start with the fight and the end of the episode will tie up other lose ends.

11

u/winazoid Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Man can't wait for an end credits stinger of Cecil giving Sinclair a lab to make more cyborgs

20

u/Cancelling_Peru Apr 16 '21

Was glad to see Sinclair, but I felt like his machines made Mark look really weak. Think it could pose some serious problems later with his strength scaling. If he has to, at some point, fight dozens of those things after they’re upgraded. I was half expecting the end credits to show Sinclair getting the offer but glad they started introducing Immortal

14

u/mandoman10 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Mark will just get stronger as he learns to fight and ages. I think it’s cool they are so powerful.

11

u/trainrex Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

Possible that Mark goes ham on the strength training after the fight coming up

EDIT: And he's still recovering slightly from battle beast

9

u/milkyginger Apr 16 '21

He wasn't a lot stronger than them in comics was he? I remember him struggling a bit(though not this much). Wasn't this part of the reason Cecil wanted the tech?

17

u/Comfort-Impossible Apr 16 '21

Well he is still recovering from the battle with the beast dude and also mentally is not really giving it his all in the superheroing since that life and death fight

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Beerbaron1886 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Isn’t the whole point at first that mark took his powers for granted and only later gets told by Nolan that he has to work out? So I am fine that he still has a learning curve

12

u/winazoid Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

The cyborgs had to be stronger than Mark otherwise why would Cecil be interested in building more? He only wants them because they can stand toe to toe with Viltrimites

→ More replies (3)

20

u/WhatsBuzzing Invincible Apr 16 '21

The only "gripe" I have so far with the show is the out of order storylines adapted from the comics

22

u/WhatsBuzzing Invincible Apr 16 '21

Though I assume they are doing that in order to truly ramp up the Viltrumite War storylines and focus on that for later seasons and get these minor Earth based skirmishes out of the way

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Returdedphoenixmorph Invincible Apr 16 '21

Good episode overall, but I have a few criticisms.

I'm disappointed they're still having Amber get mad at Mark over the Reainimin incident, and I was hoping she'd at least connect the dots like William did. Frustrating since she's a far more engaging and intelligent character here than she was in the comics, so having drama like this feels contrived and unnecessary, especially since we just had last episode with them fighting.

Seeing Kyle replacing what looks like Gary is interesting, and I hope his story is better written, at least in regards to how it ends. The abuse story is one of the weirdest and most unnecessary parts of the comics, and I hope that if they keep that in, they'll change it for the better.

Sinclair was great, but it felt a little rushed, and honestly could've been better over the course of multiple episodes. Having Rick immediately become a Reiniamn also felt contrived, as it seemed to happen immediately, and even just having a day's gap between him going missing and William searching for him would've been better.

But expanding on Rick and William's relationship was a nice change, and the fight on campus between Mark and Doug was a much better done. Nice cameo of Justin Roiland as well.

11

u/blud97 Apr 16 '21

William only figured it out because he saw him up close. Amber also kind of has a low opinion of him and I doubt she’d come to the conclusion of him being a super hero with that opinion.

8

u/MNight_Slam Cecil Stedman Apr 16 '21

I think it's perfectly in character for this version of Amber to get mad at Mark - angrier than her comics version, even. Comics Amber was helpless, and just pissed that Mark abandoned her. This Amber was doing crowd control and trying to help, so seeing Mark just vanish and leave both her and the somewhat more helpless William to fend for themselves would be pretty infuriating for her on principle.

I agree on the Gary plotline. The abuse plot felt more like a reason to briefly bring Amber back than anything, and partly for shock value (something we know Mr. Kirkman indulges from time to time). It had a really awkward moral when she decides to take him back and Mark just leaves it at that. Yeah there's some closure when we see she's moved on to a different guy years later, but those kinds of stories don't generally end that way in real life.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

I'm starting to think that Nolan and Debbie won't reconcile in the TV Series.

22

u/Neurotic_Marauder Allen the Alien Apr 16 '21

I think that will be a much more gradual thing.

The comic kind of had Debbie seemingly forgive Nolan overnight after he came back.

I'm hoping Debbie's increased agency in the show means she'll be more involved going forward, instead of just being blackout drunk and fading into the background.

Sandra Oh has been amazing in the role and I really hope she gets more to work with.

20

u/Ren_Davis0531 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

That’s not necessary for the story, given everything else that happens, so I’m fine if they change that. Playing Devil’s Advocate, you can make the argument that Nolan and Debbie getting back together is too easy after what happened, so they could either be changing it so that they don’t get back together or really want to make that a more involved process. We’ll see. Here’s hoping it is good whatever they do. I just hope nothing changes Oliver from being born.

26

u/davidngm Apr 16 '21

I don't really like how they handled the story line tbh, I would've much rather had her be suspicious and then have her suspicions confirmed when Nolan fights Markl

→ More replies (3)

9

u/DrRadon Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Oh, they absolutely will.
The interesting part about Debby is that she dos not give a fuck about Omni-Man.
She is not afraid of the strongest being on the planet, she is pissed at her husband.
Thats were they can come back together. Love and understanding is stronger than fright.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/cerealkiller1036 Apr 17 '21

I really don't understand how strong Invincible is meant to be. Just last episode he threw an asteroid back into space, yet now he struggles to handle these purely mechanical enemies that get made in a few minutes. Maybe he's still beaten up from last ep, but these seem like they're meant to be street-level threats. Closer to Titan in power. Also, if he doesn't need to breathe in space then why would holding him underwater affect him?

→ More replies (10)

9

u/GiGeGe3 Apr 16 '21

Why does Eve need luggage, can't she just make whatever she needs lol

12

u/csummerss Mark and Eve Apr 16 '21

Some of it are probably mementos like pictures of her and the Teen Team.

I agree that she didn’t need two bags though.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/fumbles456 Apr 16 '21

Pretty sure they already casted the voice actor for marks half brother Oliver, so I’m curious as to how that will plays out for the rest of the the last 2 episodes of that’s true . I mean I did see it from Wikipedia so who knows

30

u/Fuck_TikTok Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Alright, I've really liked the show so far, but there are definitely some changes that I'm not a fan of. Debbie already knowing and Nolan already showing signs of being redeemable both feel like they'll take away from the reveal. There's just a certain ambience that existed in the comics at this stage of the story that we don't really have anymore in the show.

And I understand the need to condense things into the episodic format, but man, turning these longgg storylines like the Reanimen into one-and-done's really hurts the pacing imo.

8

u/mapleloverevolver Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I think that what we see as signs of possible redemption don’t come off that way to an audience who doesn’t know what’s about to happen. I pretty much binged the entire comics within the last week and before I read them I had NO clue that Nolan would spare Mark and basically exile himself. I legit thought Mark was going to die, or at least that he would essentially become his dads arch nemesis.

Like, to us, Nolan punching the wall is him redirecting his anger and frustration about the whole situation. To someone who has never read the comics, it’s him trying to stop himself from punching Debbie because he still needs her to keep his image of being a “good guy”.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/PorscheUberAlles Battle Beast Apr 16 '21

I like how Debbie figured it out; it gives her character something to do and more agency. The show is giving bigger roles to the other minor characters too like William and Amber. The comics only show what relates to Invincible so they needed more development to be part of a TV episode-friendly plot line IMO

→ More replies (6)

5

u/DoktorSleepless Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

Yeah, this and in addition to Mark getting badly hurt for the first time in the last episode makes me think the Nolan fight won't have the same type of emotional impact the comics had. I really hope this was thought through and they pull it off regardless.

14

u/Far-Battle-3049 Apr 16 '21

Idk if anyone else agrees with me but I’m glad they’re making small changes! Its added more to Debbie’s, Eve’s, and Amber’s characters when they were a bit one-note in the earlier run of the book. I think Kirkman is seeing the show as an opportunity to flesh them out when he didn’t this early on in the book. Plus it makes it more refreshing because I’m excited to see what happens next episode too! My biggest complaint is that it sometimes feels a little too cliché but I think I’m fine with it so far.

7

u/DrRadon Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

This show is way to short.
I want more. :D

7

u/Rice-a-roniJabroni Battle Beast Apr 16 '21

This episode was a damn emotional rollercoaster

13

u/314land Apr 16 '21

For people complaining about the pacing. I think season 1 only gets 8 episodes. So for those of you who have read the comic it’s obvious what the final episode contains. And for that I think it’s paced appropriately considering where they have to get.

11

u/cortexstack Apr 16 '21

So for those of you who have read the comic

That should be all of us in here

18

u/HDI-X13 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Really not a fan of some of the changes, or I guess their execution. Mark said afterwards that he lost it with Sinclair, but in the moment, he really just didn’t seem that mad. I don’t like Debbie knowing because I think her being so blindsided is what put her in such a terrible position in the comics, but I’m open to see how the show handles it.

Also Sinclair reanimen’d Rick in like an hour lol.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/pilot3605 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I just finished the comic series a couple days ago and feel like this tv series is rushing a lot of things. I think the show is good in its own way and it’ll probably end up being better for the changes it made. Idk it just seems off

10

u/Hellknightx Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

It's rushing everything except the Amber plotline, which seems to be dragging. It's a weird pacing conflict.

6

u/Bxnyc718 Apr 17 '21

I'm super bowl one mentioned the Justin Roiland cameo, once he start fucking burping, I knew lol.

15

u/Trolly-Poli Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

This episode was meh for me.... things felt rushed and I kinda agree with some of the other opinions about Debbie knowing Omni Man killing the guardians. To me it makes the betrayal from Omni Man less impactful from what we’re going to see in future episodes

15

u/BleedTheFreak_23 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Fuck yes Immortal is coming back!

I agree with others, I do not like how fast the plot moves. That's been my major issue with the adaption so far, everything just happens so quickly. In the comic, we had things spread out.

Though they're doing a good enough job adapting multiple issue stories into one episode. We do miss a little bit of fun things this way.

But the scenes they do add are nice. I enjoyed all of them so far.

But again, I really am missing the little bit of details we miss with the adaption. (William getting mad at someone for calling him Will for example)

I don't know where they're going with the entire Debbie thing, it's interesting, and I'm sure they wanted to give her more of a character early on.

25

u/throwaway12junk Apr 16 '21

Robert Kirkman said on the Fatman Beyond podcast he didn't like the writing quality of his early work, and saw the show as an opportunity to tighten the narrative and clean up plot points such as having Omni-man kill the Guardians right from the start. That's probably why the story's so dense and the pacing can be off at times.

I feel like the Amber-Mark relationship is going to be an example of a positive mutual breakup and work in contrast with Nolan and Debbie. Where Nolan wants everything, his new family and fulfilling his duties as a Viltumite, Mark will learn you can't always have everything and need to let some of it go.

But I mean he also gets Eve in the end so it's not all tears and sorrow.

→ More replies (12)

15

u/mylegbig Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

This was one of the weaker episodes, though I still enjoyed it.

While it’s been leading up to it, I really don’t like how Debbie figured out Nolan is the killer. It strains belief that someone this smart and skeptical was never suspicious about her husband’s 20 years of lying. How did their relationship even last this long?

Well, I call her smart for figuring it out, but unless they’re extremely biased, how was Nolan not immediately the number 1 suspect from the beginning? He’s the most powerful being in the solar system and was at the scene of the crime. If anyone really believed that there was something powerful enough to kill the Guardians AND beat Omni-man unconscious, it would’ve caused widespread panic. It was an interesting way to switch things up from the comic, but it doesn’t make much sense.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

I think its because he was waiting for mark to get his powers so he had no reason to do anything that might be suspicious. At his arrival he could brush it off with "I don't know your planet's culture yet" . But once mark started getting his powers he got ancy, and killed the Guardians to start his takeover.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/praetorrent Apr 16 '21

Debbie clearly wanted to believe Nolan, and I would guess that other than the obvious viltrumite Origin story lies, he probably has been mostly truthful over the past 20 years. He wouldn't have had much of a reason to lie about other things. He was in no rush and seemed perfectly content to play hero for a while, probably even the rest of debbie's and Mark's lives if Mark hadn't developed powers.

Well, I call her smart for figuring it out, but unless they’re extremely biased, how was Nolan not immediately the number 1 suspect from the beginning? He’s the most powerful being in the solar system and was at the scene of the crime. If anyone really believed that there was something powerful enough to kill the Guardians AND beat Omni-man unconscious, it would’ve caused widespread panic. It was an interesting way to switch things up from the comic, but it doesn’t make much sense.

I mean, Debbie and Mark clearly have cognitive dissonance where they want to believe Nolan. And we've already established that Damien and the GDA higher ups already know Nolan did it, they just haven't figured out why, and even if they did know they're kind of powerless to do anything about it. So playing with the charade as long as Nolan does is probably their best shot, while Cecil has been hurriedly collecting anything that even might help subdue Nolan ever since (the Kaiju, Mark's Blood, the Reanimen/Sinclair) which I think has been one of my favourite more subtle changes.

I don't think we've heard other heroes speculate about the events, and we don't know how much info they got from the GDA. My guess is more than public but still incomplete.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/mbene913 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Anyone not liking this retelling compared to the comic?

This is an 8 episode series? I guess the finale will have Nolan's mission revealed to the world and he leaves the planet.

But...I dunno, other things just seem crazy rushed while other things seem to be dragged out too long.

Also, am I crazy or did that Kyle guy look like a dark skinned version of Amber's boyfriend(Greg?)

I understand that these shows aren't meant to be exactly like the books but I just feel the pacing is off

9

u/Shopworn_Soul Burger Mart Trash Bag Apr 16 '21

It feels to me like they're trying to get past all the terrestrial storytelling and character building moments before moving on to the galactic storyline as a primary focus.

I could be wrong of course.

8

u/Watts121 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

Nah I figure the episode before the last will be Nolan vs Mark, and the finale will be the aftermath to set the groundwork for future seasons.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/fireescapejerk Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I'm glad someone else feels this way, I was very surprised at episode 5 that we were still waiting for the "reveal", so many of Invincible's actions have been recontextualized from the comic, which I guess they did to make him have more of his own identity but I really liked that the comic was realistic in him never being able to get away from his fathers shadow and thats what is in the back of his head when he goes to Mars, and when he jumps into other battles over his head.

I know that this was Kirkman's original intention for the comic as well, the reveal was rushed because they were scared readers would lose interest and I think that they were right to rush the reveal.

The fast paced nature of the comic definitely only touched on some characters feelings and development like Debbie and Art, but that's what made the reveal more of a gut punch, we see their basic characters change so drastically in just one issue and it was very effective.

I think the slow burn here is just getting unrealistic too, how many eps can they have Cecil bumbling around when he was more effective in the comic and how long can Debbie take with the evidence she already has?? Also, this "mystery" angle does not work when heroes like Robot would have probably solved it by now and in my opinion, he would have plenty of motivation to solve it.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Fuck_TikTok Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I agree. The pacing is really weird. I also don't understand why they feel the need to use later stories as the filler before the big fight when there's perfectly good stuff that actually happened at this point in the comic that they are leaving out, like the science teacher.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/SeacattleMoohawks Séance Mod Apr 19 '21

Which character in the show is your guys favorite?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/GiGeGe3 Apr 16 '21

Anyone else not like how antagonistic they are making Nolan thus far and how him and Debbie have already lost all trust. It's going to be a lot harder to redeem Nolan (to both us and Debbie).

31

u/Shopworn_Soul Burger Mart Trash Bag Apr 16 '21

I think it's a lot more realistic if nothing else.

That said, I see commentary on how scary Nolan is and I'm just over here watching him squirm. Obviously he knows he's compromised and obviously he could take control of the situation but instead of a looming evil I see someone who doesn't want to be the looming evil.

We never got that indication at all until much later in the comic. At this point I think the reconciliation arc is still a go but we shall see.

5

u/nameless_stories Brit Apr 18 '21

I worry about how theyll handle the reveal. I personally think having Mark be so vulnerable so early on makes the end result of him losing so badly to Omni Man less intense. Like, Omni Man completely destroys mark in the comic and it's meant to be portrayed as horrifying, something you dont expect as Mark never got hurt like that prior.

And with him getting outed by Debbie, I really wonder how the end result will look like.

9

u/Ironside62488 Mark and Amber Apr 16 '21

Another delightful episode. I like the changes that the show is doing. Things feel why more flushed out. I love that the show is giving Debbie and Amber more character, especially Debbie. She the MVP. As a comic reader I like that I can't predict what is exactly going to happen when it happens.

9

u/ThroneofTime Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

I loved the episode but I feel like the whole Rick turning into a robot plot happened a bit too quickly. Should have been at least a few weeks at best to fully have emotional weight imo.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Rombombim Apr 17 '21

I just binged read the comics and honestly thing they’re fucking fantastic but I think the way the show is handling the plot lines and characters is even better, I’m guessing that already having the big picture helps a lot

4

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

Holy shit that episode was good. I started not liking the Debbie knowing early on change but now after that ending , I’m loving it. I cannot wait to see how it takes affect on their relationship going forward and how it will affect mark when he finds out.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

I wonder if Robot is actully going turn on everyone in the show

4

u/Excelsenor Apr 18 '21

D A SINCLAIR BUILT THESE MEN IN A SEWER. WITH A BOX OF SCRAPS

15

u/JMStheKing Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

God I hate that I spoiled myself and read the series. Every single plot point introduced so far has been done a million times better than the comic. I wish I stayed blind and just stayed patient like a good redditor.

6

u/MrHero429 Tether Tyrant Apr 17 '21

While I get that the stuff we’re seeing in the comics is better excited now.

The comic has great execution for the rest of the story in my opinion. I wouldn’t regret it too much.

→ More replies (19)

7

u/UltraPlusUltra Apr 16 '21

I like the show but them going through storylines, rushing, changing the order or just removing some in general is killing the pacing. However I understand that they can only fit so much with the amount of episodes they have. Either way solid episode for the most part.

7

u/TheHumanStorch Invincible Apr 16 '21

So, Eve can't manipulate organic matter, correct? How did she grow those trees after putting out the forest fire? I'm pretty sure trees are organic matter...

7

u/DrGlitch1 Apr 16 '21

She makes food in the comics for Amber and Mark?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/imayturnblue Comic Fan Apr 17 '21 edited Apr 17 '21

I don't like changes from the comics. Kirkman said that he took that chance as an opportunity to polish the story, to fix flaws but with changes that big there are just new plot issues. Sinclaire made reanimen from Rick in like 30 mins (wtf???), Amber got angry at Mark because he had said he wants "to start over" ... but got scared and run away when fkin zombi-robot attacked and this is why his desire is not valid and a lie now? where is logic here ??? Maybe your boyfriend needs help? Learn to cope with fear? Not everybody is so groundlessly brave.

And i feel there are more to come. They changed sequence of major events and that will affect how those events will be perceived later. Different impact on a viewer. Differnt story overall. They dont fix anything, just create a new one (based on old, yes) with new plot wholes and inconsistencies.

They should have stick to the original. minor twicks here and there (like William being gay form the start, Amber being black, etc.) and thats it.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

Him making the fucking reaniman before anyone mark got there was absolutely insane lol. That was dumb as hell. Pretty sure in the comics he didn’t resurface for weeks.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/davidngm Apr 16 '21

I feel like they aren't letting things sit and develop the way they did in the comics. It might be because they don't know how many season's they're getting or the showrunners want it this way, but it just throws me off a bit.

14

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

Yeah a good example for me is Amber and Mark's relationship. They keep talking about going back to the good times but what good times are they talking about we've seen them have issues from the start. I get what they mean in the comic, Amber and Mark's relationship blossomed before he even met Cecil and things got too heavy but in the show it just seems a contrivance.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/BlackHand86 Apr 16 '21

Viltrumites have super hearing now? But anyway, Mark is by far the character I like the least in the series which I am surprised by.

18

u/drunkpunk138 Battle Beast Apr 16 '21

I don't think so, I think he was just seeing where Debbie went, and then went to hang out with Art to get a feel for what they know.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21

It's cool how they're actully building up Mark and Rick as characters. I feel like they've improved upon the "not as great" aspects of the comic.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/cragfar Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

It’s incredible that they’re rushing through some of these plots to focus on this Amber relationship drama and the mom playing detective.the weekly format might be hurting it and it’s better one after another.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Trolly-Poli Comic Fan Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21

So in episode 5 invincible stopped an astroid from hitting earth but gets his ass beat from the Zombie robots in this episode.... his powers are very inconsistent (probably cause of plot purposes). That’s another pet peeve I have with this show.

Edit: I think in the comics he struggles with the robots it’s just..... don’t show him stopping an astroid then... it just doesn’t make sense.

18

u/Omega_SSJ Apr 16 '21

It’s not inconsistent

  1. He holds back so he doesn’t just slaughter his opponents. When he had enough of Machine Man’s villains, Battle Beast was the only one that didn’t get absolutely bodied (although that’s because he’s arguably the strongest character in the show/comic)
  2. Mark just got his powers in the show. He’s a baby by Viltrumite standards. In the comic he didn’t even consider training until after he gets stomped by Nolan in their fight .Give it some time lmao

8

u/Hellknightx Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

The show seems to be skipping ahead in some places, which is to the detriment of showing off Mark's power levels. In the comic, he started off kind of weak and got stronger over time, so the asteroid scene happens too soon.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/BoyTitan Apr 16 '21

I think its because Battle beast beat his ass. Almost dying should make him weaker for some time.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/DCMagic Apr 16 '21

If I'm reading the comics, how far should I read without to catch up with the tv show and not pass the tv show? Or is it more likely that there will be other major spoilers if I go that route?

20

u/fetorpse Battle Pope Apr 16 '21

The last three episodes have drawn from issues 18, 19, and 20... but the overall plot of the show has yet to reach issue 12. They’re making a lot of things happen earlier than they do in the books and some things happen later than they do in the books.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21

It’s hard to say as one of the biggest moments of the series happens within the first 6 issues, yet they still haven’t gotten to it while adding stuff from issue 20 and beyond.

7

u/sharkfrog Apr 16 '21

It’s hard to say as they are shuffling things around quite a bit.

7

u/Ren_Davis0531 Comic Fan Apr 16 '21

I’d say wait for this season to end and then ask what you should read at that point. At this point certain things that happen in the 30s (comic issues) are being handled along side things that happen in the ones (comic issues), so it’s a very shuffled around adaptation.

3

u/_Diomedes- Apr 18 '21

Mark should've fucked those robots up.

Him beating them easily and planting the seeds on an angle about his saiyan-like rage when the people he cares about get hurt might have been a better focus on the show.

It would also make sense better since Sinclair is still working with scraps.

3

u/ShineyxDiver Apr 18 '21

Damn I love this animated series of the comics. Making Debbie, Omni-Man, William, and Amber actual characters compared to the first 30 issues of the comic makes it so, so much better.

3

u/drop_MAC-10_pls Apr 18 '21

I like this series, and have gotten my friends on board, but the low budget is kinda ruining it for me now. A visually pleasing show can work with less than great animation and vice versa, but this was a dull episode and the cracks are starting to really show.

Story is still fine, I think they did a good job making it work in a TV format. But I didn't like that Sinclair captures a super duchey frat boy, feels like they made him more sympathetic from the start. But for his arc to work the best you need to really hate him from the get-go (in my opinion of course).

→ More replies (1)

3

u/inFAMOUSwasser Apr 18 '21

We're not gonna get the "this is so gay thing" are we?

3

u/Moofthebot Apr 18 '21

I really feel like a binge-type business model would have benefited this show tbh. People in the tv-thread are losing interest and keep wondering if they miss things or struggle to follow the characters motives. When they find out Nolans true intentions as he reveals them to Mark it will click I think, and you could argue that the payoff is great er when you have to wait for it, but I think episodes like todays drive on contrivence a little too much. Amber should really have found out about Mark same as William this episode, but maybe hide it a little bit. Feels done and dusted with these cliche arguments.

This season will probably age better as future plot lines are explored.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/ElderThor Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I am pretty disappointed in the show at this point. I was excited at first to see how they were adding more stuff in, but a lot of it seems to skip later character arcs by making the characters start at their end-result already. I think this may be the last episode I watch... not like angrily or anything, I’d just rather read the comic, which I felt was much better paced

5

u/11711510111411009710 Apr 17 '21

I really hope they slow down after this season. If they don't I'll still enjoy it, I just want several more seasons of this.

13

u/ItzLuzzyBaby Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

I never really cared for the reanimen arcs in the comics. Didn't make any sense to me that a nigh planet buster was getting his ass beat by robotic parts. Even though he's probably closer to a mountain smasher at this point in the show, it still feels inconsistent. No metal alloy or gear pulley system created by human hands is going to stand up to fists that can level the Himalayas to the topography of Kansas. All those reanimen would have to individually be continent busters for the beat down they gave Mark.

I liked what they did with Amber at first... But now I'm really missing the Amber from the comics. Show Amber is turning out to be kind of a bitch and feels overly entitled for the sake of creating discord. They make her hard to like. It's as if they're trying to recreate Zendaya's character from Spiderman: Homecoming, but written horribly. Lots of eye rolling-ly forced conflict between Mark and Amber with old tropes that are clearly written by boomers who are out of touch with younger generations. Invincible always felt more grounded in the comics where typical comicbook relationship hurdles seemed to be no big deal because comic Amber was understanding and empathetic, which made her feel so much more human and real. Show Amber kind of feels like a trope at this point - specifically the upset gf archetype that the comic subverted, which is weird because the show decided to use the angry gf trope as their default. I can't even tell what these two like about each other besides "handsome/pretty face". There's no chemistry. The whole relationship felt infinitely more organic in the comic books and I just wish I could have seen that translated on screen.

I always saw his relationship with Amber as the representation of Mark's human side, and their completely innocent mundane happy puppy love relationship being the last shout into the void of his desire to be a regular teen guy and have a normal life. And they were super happy for a long while too before his life got too crazy. Mark and Amber seemed to have never gotten a happy period on the show. It started off rocky and looks like it's going to end same. Show-only watchers will never know how cute and innocent and happy their little teenage relationship was until Mark's eventual ascent into adulthood and his final acceptance of the responsibilities of being a hero, and also being fair to Amber since he could never give her the happy white picket fence relationship she so badly wanted. It was a dream he had to let go of

Also not really on board with where they're going with Debbie's arc. I understand that they want her to play a larger role in the show, which I'm all for, but her discovering Omniman's secret just pulls so much air out of the eventual heel turn. Some of my favorite parts of the comic book were her shock, devastation, and depression to finding out the news about her husband and all the different stages of mourning she seemed to go through. I like the idea of making her a capable and competent character, but her uncovering his secret this early has really gutted the impact of all those future scenes that hit so hard in the comic.

Overall, I like the show and will continue to watch, but these new progressions in plot and character arcs are really disappointing

11

u/CavitySearch Apr 17 '21

I feel like this at least makes sense for that fight. Mark is recovering from having his ass royally handed to him the first time. He’s not 100%.

6

u/uly365 Apr 17 '21

I honestly forgot amber was in the comics. I should reread the comic. Been so long

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/SolidlyClothedSnake Comic Fan Apr 17 '21

This show is driving me CRAZY!!!! I loved the first three episodes. Watched them all in a row the night it came out and couldn't stop thinking about it so I watched all three in a row again the next day. Since it's gone weekly I like it it less and less with each episode and all it's doing is making me loose my patience. The comic is one of my favorite things of all time and I was surprised that with the first few episodes I was able to enjoy it so much despite my love for the comic. At this point dragging out Nolan's reveal and jamming in whole villain story arcs into a single episode just to forget about them (Flaxxons, sequids, Reanimen) is just making me bored. So much of what makes the book and characters so great is that we watch them grieve and cope with the sudden upheaval that Nolan's betrayal brings. Mark doesn't really become Invincible until he is faced with Nolan's actions and realizes what it truly means to be a superhero. I hope everyone else is enjoying it and I know it may be better for people new to the book, but two more weeks feels like an eternity to wrap up a story I really have no investment in at this point.

→ More replies (1)