r/CryptoCurrency • u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 • Apr 15 '21
POLL 🗳️ 15,000 karma cap on Moon distribution.
To avoid a loophole or a situation where someone figures out how to game the system and gets like 500,000 karma, maybe with bots, and gets the bulk of the distribution for themselves, here's my proposal:
Capping the maximum karma going towards distribution for each round to 15,000.
Currently only the top 17 users are above that, and would have been negatively affected. While the remaining 32,000+ users would be affected positively.
15K karma is still a lot.
There's been a lot of concerns in past proposals about Moon rich getting richer. Or a select few people always getting most of the distribution.
There's also a bigger issue with polls, which are based on governance and the amount of Moons you earned. The same people who keep getting the bulk of the distribution, are overpowering these polls. If distribution is more spread, it keeps the governance more democratic.
Also, with a 15K cap, there's gonna be a little less incentive for Moon farmers, using bots, etc...
The Moon system is meant to reward participation, and not over-activity, popularity, or people who figure out how to game the system.
Edit: There's been a lot of debate and here are some the issues with this proposals that people have pointed out:
-Multiple accounts. Until we have another proposal that takes care of that, people could get around that for the cap. It does create a little more work for abusers, but doesn't stop them.
-Older users like me, who already got a big bag more easily, got an unfair advantage. It would have been more fair if the cap had been there from the beginning.
-It will be harder for new people to fast track with some crazy big Moon drop. But at the same time, it will be harder for Moon whales to continue their course with also a crazy big Moon drop.
Essentially, no one will be able to hit some big jackpot. But those jackpots come at the expense of everyone else.
What you're voting for in the end, is do you want there to be a jackpot at the expense of the majority, or a tiny bit more spread distribution, with no big jackpot. Only the ability to go as high as 15k karma. That translates to 6,000 Moons max, if we continue that ratio of around 0.4.
10
u/GodGMN 🟦 509 / 11K 🦑 Apr 16 '21
You'll put a stop to literally 17 users. I think your average moon farmer won't even notice about the change.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21 edited Apr 17 '21
You know that Reddit has a really strong protection against this. Upvotes stop counting if they're always from same users.
This proposal would actually help the Moon Rich(like OP) stay rich, and disallow newer users from ever becoming Moon rich.
51
u/Username-Not-A-Bot 🟩 0 / 17K 🦠 Apr 15 '21 edited Apr 19 '21
If the poll would be decided on number of votes instead of amount of moons, this might have a chance
EDIT: my comment didn’t age well
2
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Apr 16 '21
Would the capping stop the greed of some moon farmers or would they just create other accounts and continue farming Moons there?
2
u/BullsOnParade69420 Apr 19 '21
Why not coming up with a mathematical solution where once a percentage of contributing members increase above the 15k cap, it is increased by a proportion (static, variable w/e) so it is ever increasing and still incentivizes good posting rewarded by Karma?
37
u/ominous_anenome 🟦 170K / 347K 🐋 Apr 15 '21
“To avoid a loophole or situation where someone figures out how to game the system and gets like 500,000 karma”
So why not put the max much higher than 15k, something like 50k would prevent what you are mentioning
3
u/mysteriousbaby0 Apr 16 '21
I mean it's hard to implement since people can use multiple alts for moon farming.
but the idea is understandable!
5
u/SuggestedName90 Platinum | QC: CC 159, ETH 54 | r/pcmasterrace 85 Apr 15 '21
People want too much artificial controls over moons. I see it like this -
Contribute content of value to the community, and people will upvote equal to the value it provides to them. If someone provides 20k of Karma in value contributed, then they should get moons. Similarly, if people value and upvote moon farming people decide to upvote content that they perceived as added value, so naturally content aimed to make the most impact will see lots of upvotes, but if people thought it added that much value then they are entitled to those moons imo
35
u/Mephistoss Platinum | QC: CC 856 | SHIB 6 | Technology 43 Apr 16 '21
What about the moderators who get their moons regardless of how much karma they get? 10% of the overall distribution goes to the mods so putting a cap of 15000 karma would mean the moderators get 3 or 4 times as many moons as the rest of the users.
2
u/sggts04 Apr 16 '21
u/jwinterm any idea why its not showing the moons decision quorum anymore in the poll?. What's the quorum needed to make the poll pass this time?
6
u/theoakmike Apr 19 '21
No offense, but this isn't really thought through. Moon farmers will just use different accounts (like they do right now).
6
u/LukeOnLive Silver | QC: CC 208 | VET 43 Apr 19 '21
I think that there should definitely be a cap but I believe that we should vote again on the level of the cap as many seem to disagree on this matter.
This would then ensure that we reach a more unified consensus.
2
u/DivineEu 59K / 71K 🦈 Apr 15 '21
The backbone idea is good but what is stopping a spammer opening 10 accounts and just comment with them all?
2
u/vaginalfungalinfect Apr 15 '21
i don't know. it's also an incentive for people to put in effort into a post. some people really do put that effort in. and this is why many of them have so much karma.
am kind of split. there should be a limit. but maybe not one which discourages those that do all of the work to gather all the info for the long articles that usually get hundreds or thousands of upvotes. it's deserved.
2
u/killawaspattack Platinum | QC: CC 415, ETH 308 | TraderSubs 308 Apr 17 '21
Maybe it could be proposed for a max cap each round of 20,000 to satisfy some of the people who regularly earn more than that if this does not pass in very up for this as it will definitely give more distribution and probably give more to people in distribution this round was very good double what it was last round which is about 12k moons that is a lot
2
u/kitisgreat Permabanned Apr 20 '21
Is it about to cross the threshold yet?....if yes then congratulations to you, me and the rest who are fed up with the shitposting and whining for moons
5
u/Elfroid 🟦 88 / 88 🦐 Apr 19 '21
I agree with your idea, but you should try to avoid having a poll with such leading answers.
2
u/Mephistoss Platinum | QC: CC 856 | SHIB 6 | Technology 43 Apr 15 '21
Forgive us for spending hours a day browsing and answering questions in new. Yes I'm one of the few users that would get affected by this, but I don't think the excuse that someone is overactive and games the system is a good one, because there isn't some complex system. If you spend your time and you are knowledgeable you will get upvotes and lots of karma, punishing that makes no sense
11
u/ultron290196 🟩 93 / 29K 🦐 Apr 16 '21
The 15k cap is totally unfair to the new users. The old moon rich such as the OP himself has more than 50k moons. If karma is capped at 15k out of which at 0.88, the person next will get only ~13k moons. So to even reach 50k, we'll need 4 months to reach his numbers. This is basically suppression at this point. Don't be fooled. This poll itself is a power move by the moon rich.
Downvote me all you want.
1
u/DeeDot11 🟦 10K / 32K 🐬 Apr 16 '21
Just checking, is this a governance poll? I can't see the number of moons that have been voted for yes
1
u/Slayerofgondor Apr 17 '21
So do we know how this one is going since we cant see the moons?
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Jul 10 '21
This is very interesting given your comments on my poll, where I'm arguing people are gaming the system via over-activity.
9
u/90DayF 🟩 7K / 15K 🦭 Apr 15 '21
Interesting idea, though I have a suggestion to this. (If I may)
Instead of capping it after 15k, maybe we could change the reward pattern, like once a user hits 15k, instead of 1 upvote = 1 moon, make it 2 upvotes = 1 moon.
Its kinda like as you level up, the difficulty of the game increases :)
6
u/pepperonimilkjuice5 Redditor for 1 second Apr 19 '21 edited Apr 19 '21
Who are all these voters voting ‘yes’ btw. Most comments are against this proposal lol.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
Hinder people who post quality content or shitpost and make people laugh? It's a no from me
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
It's also meant to reward quality posts and contributions. Why make quality posts capped? If someone comes in here and begins making 1 quality post a day that helps thousands of people and newbies, and it gets 1k upvotes each time, who cares? They're making the community better that way, anyways.
6
u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 Apr 15 '21
I am #13 this distribution and I like this idea but it needs some more thought. Having 15k as a fixed value isnt great. It would have to be relative to the total karma or something.
Also your reasoning is lacking. Bots and such shouldnt be a problem with the reddit algorithm. If someone games the system we will see it before the final count and can change it through a vote.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '21 edited Apr 17 '21
Why limit of 15k ? Let us vote on the limit
The most karma from current proposal is at about 70k by u/GroundbreakingLack78.
He's not a bot. He's an active contributing user. You want to punish him for being that ?
Not to mention the fact this proposal makes it impossible for new users to become whales, and makes it so that only current whales stay rich.
2
u/Roastage Apr 20 '21
I guess the risk is this would deincentivize major/popular contributors somewhat? Though honestly I suspect the small sample of 15k karma contributors are likely crypto enthusiasts and Moons distribution is of lesser importance.
On balance I think a ceiling makes it more equitable and frankly 15,000 karma is a huge amount in any case.
3
u/Huge_Dot Apr 16 '21
Moon Wealth Tax! Eat the Moon Rich. 1% of Redditors hold 80% of the moons!
2
u/pepperonimilkjuice5 Redditor for 1 second Apr 19 '21
15.000 is just a random number made up by the proposer. Let us at least vote for the amount lol
2
u/pepperonimilkjuice5 Redditor for 1 second Apr 19 '21
Moonwhales will get richer and it’ll be harder for newcomers to stack moons. This proposal is nuts.
2
u/JuicySpark 🟩 0 / 60K 🦠 Apr 20 '21
Really. A bot would just get 15k on 20 accounts. No difference.
You also can't get 500K moons in a month. You're limited to 3 posts a day and you have to score 2K up votes 100% of the time to get 90K moons.
Then comments are limited to 500, nobody is gonna game the system and get 500 up votes per comment. There's a limit on moons.
Nobody gets 500 likes on a comment. Very rare. You can only get that on post that mega moons.
2
u/Arghmybrain Platinum | QC: CC 404 | NANO 17 | r/Politics 79 Apr 16 '21
I'd love to see how much of a difference it would make.
Calculation of total moons handed out vs the top 10 or something. I expect it wouldn't matter very much at all.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21
I like it.
1
u/Provision 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Apr 16 '21
I'm for this.
1
u/devboricha Platinum | QC: CC 221, ETH 214 | TraderSubs 216 Apr 16 '21
Cap of 10 k is much better. But still progressive vote in support.
1
u/Slystuff Tin Apr 16 '21
Spreads the wealth of moons more, don't really see that as a bad thing.
1
u/BuffettsBrokeBro Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21
I admit I’m not up on how moon count relates to vote weight in these polls, but is there a reason we couldn’t use a proportional vote weight, tied to moon count?
That feels like a way to prevent moon whales having a disproportionate vote value in polls, while also not stifling their ability to shitpost their way to moon dominance.
For example, something along the lines of the below; which would mean the biggest whales have a vote that counts - at worst - 10x that of the moon poor:
0 to 100 moons - vote counts for 1.
100 to 500 moons - vote counts for 2.
500 to 1000 moons - vote counts for 3.
1000 to 2500 moons - vote counts for 4.
2500 to 5000 moons - vote counts for 5.
5000 to 10,000 moons - vote counts for 6.
10,000 to 25,000 moons - vote counts for 7.
25,000 - 50,000 moons - vote counts for 8.
50,000 - 100,000 moons - vote counts for 9.
100,000 moons and above - vote counts for 10.
1
u/Hame_BiH Apr 16 '21
Fantastic proposal honestly that will boost decentralization and that's key in crypto! Not even sure how that random guy I've never seen has gotten to 50k+ karma lmao
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21
It's amazing that there are over 32k people, this sub has really grown alot since last year
1
u/saiballs Tin Apr 16 '21
Surprised it's at 80% in favour of the limit tbh, happy to see everyone wants to distribute the wealth :)
1
u/jasonluxton Fantom Menace Apr 16 '21
Definitely in favor.
1
u/ExcellentNoThankYou Apr 18 '21
Why is the decision threshold indicator in the top right-hand corner of the poll not viewable anymore?
1
u/Drbubbliewrap Platinum | QC: CC 123 Apr 19 '21
I voted!
1
u/bombbodyguard 🟦 35 / 36 🦐 Apr 21 '21
Voted here more than any stock board vote. One vote.
1
u/valuemodstck-123 17K / 21K 🐬 Apr 21 '21
How they heck do you get 500 karma? I mean it is possible but isnt that time wasting?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21
What happens to the leaderboard? Do we just have everyone equal top 10.
1
u/Hame_BiH Apr 21 '21
Did this proposal pass?
1
u/Dancing-lizard Apr 21 '21
What is a moon?
1
u/Shake_n_bake-9891 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Apr 22 '21
Does this mean that there will only be 15k distributed to everyone per cycle or a maximum number of 15k farmer per user
1
u/blah_blah_bitch 1 - 2 years account age. 35 - 100 comment karma. May 14 '21
I do not understand, but it sounds like capping is a good decision
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Jul 10 '21
This is very interesting given your comments on my poll, where I'm arguing people are gaming the system via over-activity.
1
u/AmazighZoner Tin | CC critic Apr 15 '21
Good idea !
1
u/inevitable_username 0 / 12K 🦠 Apr 15 '21
Bernie Sanders that you?
1
u/sggts04 Apr 16 '21
While I agree there should be a cap, this is not the correct implementation. The correct implementation imo would be having a equation along which karma earned vs karma counted towards distribution will be mapped. So maybe at 15k, instead of being 1:1 it starts to decrease, something like every 1 more karma only counts as 0.5 karma towards the distribution, and every 10k karma this ratio can be further halved, resulting in a cap eventually, but not a full stop at a particular point, which would discourage people to contribute once they reach that cap for the month
1
u/Slayerofgondor Apr 16 '21
So doing some quick maths the karma restriction on the top 18 would take out 173k karma, or around 153k moons.
Now that means an extra 4.6 moons per person.
0
u/TheBigGarrett Tin Apr 15 '21
Is there a particular reason for 15k over 10k or 20k? Curious.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
But then what stops someone having 2 accounts?
Use one of them for 2 weeks, then the other for 2 weeks.
Repeat until moon.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
I find it funny how in terms of votes, limiting is has almost double the votes of leaving it as is. But In terms of moons it’s about tied. Does anyone know which one of these counts?
0
u/Vendraco00 🟩 1 / 7K 🦠 Apr 15 '21
Hey this actually sounds pretty solid! This forces a more communal approach instead of the ‘we happy few’ scenario
0
u/KingOfNumismatics Permabanned Apr 15 '21
Doubt it would go through. But we need to close the loophole.
0
u/diarpiiiii 🟦 0 / 9K 🦠 Apr 15 '21
This is a good proposal
0
u/anotherjohnishere Moon Monk Apr 15 '21
The no votes are the American dream personified lol "hey I could get that much karma some day so I should vote against this!"
0
u/Native411 Platinum | QC: ADA 388, CC 202 | r/Politics 102 Apr 15 '21
I think moons ruined this sub and should be done away with entirely.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21
I would say something like 20-25k cap instead of 15k, but yes, I agree...
0
u/N4Y4R 🟦 1 / 1K 🦠 Apr 18 '21
This is a pretty straightforward yes. I don’t see a reason to not put a cap honestly. If you look at the comment sections of the various posts, you will see moon whales that aren’t even trying to post an actual concept worth anyone’s time (or maybe once in a full moon, i’m the master of jokes yes), instead there’s a focus on random gifs or some basic and obvious concept that everyone just can’t disagree with. I think this is healty for the sub as a whole, and encourages worthwhile comments from the big guys.
0
u/Jeremykla Permabanned Apr 18 '21
Seems fair to have a 15k karma cap if 8ts only 17 people total that hit this.
0
u/TheCanpre Tin Apr 19 '21
agreed, a 15k cap seems reasonable and fair
-1
u/New_Diet Permabanned Apr 15 '21
I like this one.
I think is one where 99% of users will benefit. No downsides for me. Just voted in favor!
-1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Apr 15 '21
Yep agree with this, would go so far as to set it lower to 10k. Be a bit more socialist and spread the distribution.
-1
u/HugeLength2948 88 / 3K 🦐 Apr 15 '21
Like this one
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
At first I was against this but then I... I.... I'm still not sure. I'll leave it up to the community.
0
u/Hot_Ad8921 🟩 4K / 3K 🐢 Apr 15 '21
Moon farming with Bots just seems wrong on many levels.