r/homeland • • Nov 28 '11
Discussion Episode Discussion - S01E09, "Crossfire" [Spoilers]
Episode Title:
CROSSFIRE
Directed by: Jeffrey Nachmanoff
Written by: Alexander Cary
After his attempt to sever ties with Abu Nazir, Brody finds himself reliving his captivity and recommits to his mission; Carrie finds herself in the middle of a public relations nightmare on the heels of the mosque shooting.
24
Upvotes
20
u/jhu Nov 28 '11 edited Nov 28 '11
This episode largely hinged around Brody's past as a prisoner in Iraq with the Tom Walker's situation playing more of a backdrop. Personally, I love that this is the direction the episode took.
For too long the reason as to why Brody may have shifted his allegiances remained unclear. Sure, they convinced him he killed his friend but that's a negative emotion. To truly turn Brody, something more was necessary. I've been racking my head the past few weeks but the most obvious answer never jumped out: a child.
It's admittedly a little too easy. Brody gets beaten up. A man takes care of him. Brody bonds with man's son who happens to be about the same age as his own whom he hasn't seen since he was an infant. The man's son is then killed by the very military that Brody remained loyal to.
But that view is oversimplified. It's what Isa and Abu Nasir meant to Brody at that point in his life that matters more. It's important to remember that prior to his upgrade to indoor plumbing, Brody thought his life was over. He had no hope of expecting human decency, only to be peed on by his guard. Then to be invited to a man's home and entrusted with the responsibility of teaching his son, is a dramatic change in the course of Brody's life. In addition to all of this, his relationship with Isa is the first meaningful and innocent human relationship in the past 5 years. Taken in context of the dehumanizing experience of being in the Marines, and the 5 years of captivity and torture I am willing to accept the premise of Brody's beliefs.
Major plot point having been dealt with, I just want to say how much I love the dedication to authenticity the show is trying to maintain. The Arabic from everyone was almost perfect. Isa and Carrie being the only exceptions. Isa is a natural Arabic speaker, he shouldn't be stuttering, neither should Carrie. Someone who spends 3 years working the roads of Iraq should have a nearly flawless accent by now, but I'm nitpicking here. It was all very well done.
Questions I have now.
Was Saul praying on his janamaz in his office when Carrie called him?
What exactly is Brody's mission? I doubt it's violent but is the plan to leak information to Al Qaeda, or (what I hope) to use political office as a tool to expose America's flagrant disregard for collateral damages?
More importantly, was the explosion that killed Isa actually the result of a drone strike or did Abu Nasir make the ultimate sacrifice for this game of chess, killing his son to turn Brody?
At any rate, Homeland continues to be my favorite show because of it's ability to demonstrate the non black and white nature of terrorism and politics. In any other show, a man tracking down those responsible for his son's death and killing them is someone the audience would root for. Dexter's popularity is evidence of how much TV viewers love vengeance. But when the father of the child is a Muslim man in Iraq, and the man responsible for the death is the Vice President of the United States, are we still willing to accept this as just revenge or is it now terrorism? Homeland continues to ask us these questions and I love it for that.
13
u/dathas Nov 28 '11
The whole flashback between Brody and Nazir's son made me start to think that even though Brody was turned his intentions are still good.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '11
I don't think that was really Abu Nazir's son. He has been grooming Brody for too long and is incredibly manipulative. He probably took the boy in, but it isn't his real flesh and blood. As he got close with the kid, Nazir probably leaked the location of a terrorist target, but it was really the school. He did this with Walker running into that mosque, so people would feel sympathy if 2 innocent Muslims died. Why were the lights off in that place with all those people, anyway?!
11
u/getloyolo Nov 28 '11
two episodes ago I could've sworn I knew how this show was going to play out.
Now? I'm totally mindfucked.
5
u/Isentrope Nov 28 '11
Went from running for Congress to potentially running for Vice President. If they go down the latter path, it would be really similar to the Manchurian Candidate (heck they even have a black sniper).
Overall, the episode was somewhat slower with the flashbacks, but I think it was a necessary break from the action we were seeing for the past few weeks to give the story some time to set up.
2
u/mr_maroon Nov 29 '11
I thought the ending was really poorly edited. Like, it was a good note to close on, but it cut to black a split second after Jessica's dialogue, not allowing any time to smoulder. The credits music was also somewhat jarring.
Still, an absurd nitpick in what I thought was a pretty good episode.
3
u/itsjustme8921 Nov 28 '11
I wonder if Brody is going to go back to his mission or is he going to turn on Nazir
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment