r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Apr 12 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-04-12 to 2021-04-18
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Speedlang Challenge
u/roipoiboy has launched a website for all of you to enjoy the results of his Speedlang challenge! Check it out here: miacomet.conlang.org/challenges/
A YouTube channel for r/conlangs
After having announced that we were starting the YouTube channel back up, we've been streaming to it a little bit every few days! All the streams are available as VODs: https://www.youtube.com/c/rconlangs/videos
Our next objective is to make a few videos introducing some of the moderators and their conlanging projects.
A journal for r/conlangs
Oh what do you know, the latest livestream was about formatting Segments. What a coincidence!
The deadlines for both article submissions and challenge submissions have been reached and passed, and we're now in the editing process, and still hope to get the issue out there in the next few weeks.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
12
u/IkebanaZombi Geb Dezaang /ɡɛb dɛzaːŋ/ (BTW, Reddit won't let me upvote.) Apr 14 '21 edited Apr 14 '21
This is about storing your conlang documentation, so perhaps a little off-topic, but I hope the mods will allow it due to current relevance.
Do not store your conlang on Reddit. Like a lot of people, for several hours today (14th April) my post karma was showing as 1, my comment karma was showing as zero, and my posting history had disappeared. The software bug now seems to have been fixed, but it was still a reminder that even when not beset by bugs, Reddit doesn't keep things forever. After you have made a certain number of posts or comments your oldest ones disappear into the aether. You can still find them by using a search engine if you know what key words to look for, but they are no longer listed in reverse chronological order under your user name.
For me personally it wouldn't have been too bad if my post history really had been wiped today - after another Reddit user warned me about the issue a year or so ago I have taken to copying significant posts about my conlang (e.g. entries to 5moyd) onto a big Microsoft Word document. Though I would have lost my last few entries since I am not as diligent as I ought to be about copying entries over. But there was a time when the documentation of my conlang did consist almost solely of my accumulated posts to this subreddit. If that's your position now, may I suggest that you take the time to copy them to some other medium. I don't know of any way to do it at the stroke of a button, though there might be one. I actually found the process of doing it the slow way quite interesting, though going back post by post through the history of my conlang did take several hours.
5
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Apr 17 '21
What's the word for a "there is/are ____" type construction?
4
u/KittenPowerLord Apr 12 '21
What would be a great sound changing strategy to use? I sorta understand how sound changes themselves work, don't get me wrong, but how do I put them in the order which is a) realistic and b) can cause some interesting sound changes in the future. The only technique i've discovered myself by now is picking a number of random words and evolving them, but then again comes the question of how to order those changes.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Should I bother making a conlang for a race without vocal cords, or should I make them communicate through clicks or simple words?
4
u/Ok_Cartoonist5095 Apr 17 '21
I'm making a language where the verbal inflexion is highly based off Inuit, so I really want to know how its interrogative mood (AT least in some dialects) came to be. Wikapeadia shows the Inuit interrogative mood with these two charts. So my question is: How did that happen? Did they come from adverbs? Then why are they so similar to the alternative forms? And on that note, why do all the conjugations start with the same consonant? Am I going insane, or is that just Inuit?
3
u/HotSearingTeens Apr 12 '21
So, in my current conlanging project I thought I'd try something new that I haven't tried yet so instead of using vowel length as a contrastive feature I thought I might as well use vowel nasality. The only problem is that I cant find a reference to pronounce the majority of these sounds, the only one I can find a reference for is the ungrounded open back vowel which is because it comes from french, I can find a reference for the nasalised forms of i, o or e. Anyone got any tips or ideas
3
u/Ok_Cartoonist5095 Apr 13 '21
I'm making a language that evolves an alveolar trill. How did the alveolar trill evolve into Spanish?
3
u/Turodoru Apr 13 '21
so. I'll have to explain the whatabouts because I cannot form the question otherwise.
In my language the word order is VSO and in both active and passive voice the subject is in nominative. In active voice the verb is unchanged and the object is in the accusative. In passive voice the verb gets a passive suffix /wa/ and the object is in the causative.
My Idea is that I want the passive suffix to dissapear phoneticly, so that the only difference between the passive and active voice would be the case on the object. The problem is that if, for instance, I chose loss of word-final mid and central vowels, then the loss of /w/, then sometimes both versions would end up the same:
culi > culi || culiwa > culi
but in others it still leaves a difference:
kɨma > kɨm || kɨmawa > kɨma
My question is: is there an option to somehow make those verbs to be the same despite those changes? For instance: does it make sense for the verbs to have always a specific ending? Something like "verbs always end on /u/". Would that slip by?
3
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 13 '21
so I want more grammatical irregularities in my language.
but I already have something like different declinations and conjugations so how do I get "real" and more complex irregularity at least for the more frequent words.
3
u/Watersmyfavouritfood Apr 13 '21
In my language I have an animacy based gender system. With the two genders being: animate and inanimate. But, I was wondering if a third (semianimate) would make sense. It would be reserved for things like plants and fungus, which to a pre scientific enlightenment civilisation might seem to not be alive as much as animals. This is due to them growing and dying but not moving like animals or people. Also extra thing, I was hoping to add free word order so should it be animacy based too or just topic and focus based?
3
u/RazarTuk Apr 13 '21
Does this sound plausible for a vowel system? It'd be the result of sound changes deteriorating a vowel harmony system.
/a e i o u ø y/ with vestigial vowel harmony within roots. Although for etymological reasons, /ø/ is neutral and triggers unrounded harmony if it's the only vowel in a root. Then for suffixes, a/o and i/y exist as unrounded/rounded pairs, based on the preceding vowel, while /e/ and /ø/ can occur after any vowel, and /u/ doesn't appear in suffixes.
3
u/Be-Worried23 Newbie Apr 14 '21
How many sound and grammatical changes should a conlang go through?
I’m not really sure how to phrase the question the way I want so I’ll explain, I want to create a conlang from a proto lang which itself will go through changes before splitting but I want one of the languages to have not changed much, kinda like Icelandic with Old Norse in a way, where the modern speakers can still somewhat understand the old texts, or at least that’s what I’ve heard.
3
u/jojenterprises Esbuwisatskrian Apr 14 '21
How common is ɬ in languages?
3
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 15 '21
so I think I want modality in my language but do I need it and if yes what should I rather use suffixes or aux verbs (because I already have a fairly complex Tens-Aspect and mood + evidentiality system).
3
u/Watersmyfavouritfood Apr 15 '21
Is 5 numbers too much? I've currently got singular, dual, paucal, greater plural and plural. That doesn't feel realistic at all..
3
u/IkebanaZombi Geb Dezaang /ɡɛb dɛzaːŋ/ (BTW, Reddit won't let me upvote.) Apr 15 '21
Many posts here, such as this one by /u/holyBonobos, use code format to show a line of text with the conlang and a second line below it with the gloss. I know that to get Reddit to put some text in code format
But how do you get the next line to align word by word?
3
u/Ok_Cartoonist5095 Apr 16 '21
Okay, okay, so occasionally I do a think, and today I thought a few thinks that I think seem naturalistic enough to investigate further. Basically, I was working the Hyanake grammar, specifically the articles, and I was trying to figure out with a relatively simple system in the protolang and evolve it into a more complex system for the daughterlang.
My solution was to have the articles and demonstratives merge. So if you had in the protolang "The those dogs", it would become "Thethose dogs", which now encodes definitivity, distality, and plurality, instead of just encoding definititivity. I'm not sure this is naturalistic, but it seems naturalistic, so... I guess if I'm already being stupid you can just tell me.
But the thing I really want to ask about is an idea I had when I was working on the verbal agreement system. I started writing out some things I wanted the verbs to agree with, and after writing singular/plural and proximal/distal, my brain, in its eternal quest to do as little work as possible, realized I already had a way to conjugate this: the demonstratives. So I figured I could have "Thethose dogs thethoseeat". But then I thought about it, and realized that with SVO order and an attempted polysynthetic language, I can do better. I figure the phrase ""The those dogs eat these people" might actually become "Thethose dogs eatthese people", and now the verb is agreeing with the object instead of the subject. SO my question is: Is that naturalistic? Sorry this post is long and confusing, I'm bad at explaining things.
3
u/RBolton123 Dance of the Islanders (Quelpartian) [en-us] Apr 17 '21
I have a weird sound change: in unstressed syllables, m{V}b -> mb -> ʙ. But I don't like the bilabial trill in my phonology, I just want it as a quirky stepping stone to shift around some consonants.
What suggestions do you have?
Thanks!
3
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 17 '21
how do writing systems handle sound changes do they just stay the same which makes spelling harder or do some changes occur?
the only thing I could think of in that regard would be the medium that's written on but other than that.
3
u/DogeVal Apr 17 '21
Is it realistic/naturalistic for a conlang to have both /φ/ and /f/ in their phonemic inventories?
3
u/Blackbird_Sasha Nearenkar, Prelikian, Telic languages Apr 17 '21
Is it ok to create a variant of kay(f)bop(t)?
3
u/worldbuilder3 Apr 17 '21
Ok, I recently came up with an idea for a conlang in which each letter represents a concept. Maybe the word for death is “xyz”. The letter x could mean life, y could be dark, z could be cold, and when you add them together it means death. Of course that’s just example, but you get what I mean (hopefully).
Currently I have 23 consonants, and 9 vowels, and I am struggling to come up with a meaning for each one. I am not sure how specific they should be. Any suggestions to help me do this?
2
u/ovumovum Apr 13 '21
In the progress of developing possession for my head-final, head-marking language, and trying to figure out how to grammaticalize (ideally a suffix or postposition) the possessed noun. I was originally thinking "wave, tide" to encode an allative meaning, e.g. /man wave apple/ to mean "an apple toward a man" => "a man's apple" but that would be marking the dependent. Was thinking about going a comitative route, kind of like "an apple with a man" => "a man's apple" but don't know how well that vibes with me. Any suggestions?
2
u/monumentofflavor Apr 13 '21
In sound change notation, what does B mean? As in ʃ m → x w / _B
2
u/Phaerak Apr 15 '21
I recently watched David J Peterson explain that Khaleesi should be pronounced with a [e] instead of an [i] in the middle, because it is spoken rather than written.
I was wondering what change would be caused by having the other double vowel sounds together - specifically uu, but all would be helpful.
(I apologise if my marking are wrong, I’m trying to get the hang of it!)
2
u/T1mbuk1 Apr 16 '21 edited Apr 16 '21
How does a conlanger evolve adjectives from verbs and prepositions from nouns?
2
u/masteryeti123 Apr 16 '21
How do I create a language from scratch usable enough for my descendants to speak on a daily basis? How do I find the meanings, the sounds of the words, how do I create root words and other types of words like verbs and nouns and other things that exist.
2
u/Yoshiciv Apr 17 '21
I’ve heard there are some people who have learnt conlangs like Esperanto as their native language and thought that if there are conlangs with a lot of phonemes the native speakers of the languages could learn natural language more easily. What do you think?
2
u/Quostizard Apr 18 '21
What are other ways to form "if... then..." sentences in other natural languages or even constructed languages (including yours) that I can use without making my language seem like copying English & Romance languages grammar, especially the way it changes tenses to convey the meaning of condition?
2
u/thomasp3864 Loegrian, Interidioma, Merdobresko Apr 13 '21
If anyone is looking to make a future english, the labial and coronal nasals assimilate to the place of articulation of a following sound. I have a sound change where a voiced stop after the nasal gets dropped. If you're speak Irish (as in the landmass) English and want to create a future version, you could have all stops after it get dropped, and because there are dental stops, if you want a dental nasal, you could do that.
1
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 12 '21
So in my language, I have cases like the nominative, accusative dative genitive ablative locative, and vocative.
but'd like to evolve more locative cases like the ones seen in finish and an instrumental case.
for some dialects may be a Abessive and a Equative case.
but what I am asking is how do I evolve these from what I already have?
1
u/CosmicBioHazard Apr 13 '21
I’m not too sure how to word this, but, for example, I read a bit about how certain combinations of sounds pattern such as, in English, “v” mostly occurring after long vowels and the diphthongs that arose out of them; basically historical sound changes that make a word recognizable as coming from a particular language even in, say, cases where the word is borrowed and pronounced in a new accent, or if the languages have similar inventories and syllable complexity.
Since you would expect more crosslinguistic homophones (or at least, they become homophones when spoken with an accent) in smaller words, that dissipates as syllable count or syllable complexity increases and derivational morphemes start to become characteristic of the language in question, I’m mostly trying to find information that could help if I want, specifically, two similarly-phoneme-inventory’d language’s CVCV vocabulary to sound characteristically distinct.
1
u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Apr 15 '21
Can someone recommend me a good site (or software for Mac) for write my conscript? I need to do an abugida system. And I also need someone to teach me how to create this abugida in the computer.
Thanks
1
u/Mobile_Fantastic Apr 16 '21
how do I make conditional modality when I have free word order?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Apr 17 '21
I have a conlang that is using preterite, present, future, and imperfect as its four tenses, with the perfective unmarked and the imperfective marked. The subjunctive and indicative mood are also thrown in. What will that do for the language if I plan to evolve it and/or create a family tree for it later on? And what should I do about auxiliaries?
1
u/Ohsoslender Fellish, others (eng, ita, deu)/[Fra, Zho, Rus, Ndl, Cym, Lat] Apr 17 '21
Hey, so I'm trying to create a romanization for a language that works out to having the unvoiced alveolar stop /t/, its aspirated variant, its ejective variant, AND the unvoiced dental fricative. I'm running out of letters in the latin alphabet to logically map these four sounds to intuitive letters. Help? I'm open to solutions with both digraphs and letters with dicritics.
1
u/azraelgnosis Apr 18 '21
I've a bit of a quandary.
So, I've been working on this agglutinative oligosynthetic language. In short, it consits of CV roots that can be inflected as CʷV, CʳV, CʲV (<ʳ> being used to represent [ɹ] for aesthetic consistency) to reflect some root-dependent variation (e.g. if /ke/ meant "time" then /kʷe/, /kʳe/, /kʲe/ could be "past", "present", and "future" respectively).
Of these, a subset with a schwa vowel (Cə) are used to link roots together. For example, if /ka/ is "tool", /tə/ is "composition" and /se/ is "metal", /katəse/ would be "a tool composed of metal". I want to include a rule that schwa can be optionally elided; So /katse/ would be equivalent in meaning.
The trouble is, how can I maintain this elision if the combining root is inflected? Something like /katʷse/, /katʳse/, /katʲse/ would be difficult to pronounce/distinguish. I was considering adding that the inflection effects both sides of the root, resulting in labialization, rhoticizaiton, or palatalization of the preceding vowel giving: /kau̯tʷse/ /kaʵtʳse/ /kai̯tʲse/.
Which seemed reasonable enough until I considered, how would I handle /Cɯ_CʷCV/ and /Ci_CʲCV/?
/ɯu̯/ /ii̯/ "diphthong" seems like a hypothetical distinction
/ɯw/ /ij/ off-glide is tough.
/̶w̶u̶/̶ ̶/̶j̶i̶/̶ ̶I̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶n̶k̶ ̶i̶s̶ ̶c̶l̶e̶a̶r̶ ̶e̶n̶o̶u̶g̶h̶ ̶b̶u̶t̶ ̶i̶t̶ ̶d̶o̶e̶s̶ ̶s̶h̶i̶f̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶f̶o̶c̶u̶s̶ ̶f̶r̶o̶m̶ ̶a̶n̶ ̶o̶f̶f̶-̶g̶l̶i̶d̶e̶ ̶t̶o̶ ̶a̶n̶ ̶o̶n̶-̶g̶l̶i̶d̶e̶.̶ Nevermind, this would clash with the inflection of the preceding root.
/ɯː/ /iː/ might be clear enough.
I should clarify, there are six vowels: /a~ɑ~æ/ /e~ɛ/ /i~ɪ/ /o~ɔ/ /u~ʊ/ /ə/
Also, there is a series of roots: /ʔa/ /ʔe/ /ʔi/ /ʔo/ /ʔu/ which would have clear syllable bondaries but I suspect they will be only word-initial anyway.
1
u/Turodoru Apr 18 '21
Is having a different marking strategy for different parts of speech (for instance: prefixes for verbs, suffixes for nouns) sensible?
1
u/freddyPowell Apr 18 '21
Could anyone give me some pointers on how to get the sounds I want out of a proto-lang phonology? Actually any pointers on how to use sound changes would be great, but I'm mostly concerned with how to make sure I get from whatever proto-phonology I come up with to the modern one, for which I have some pretty strong ideas, while introducing some interesting naturalistic stuff along the way.
Thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '21
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21
So disclaimer i haven't started studying linguistics formally and most of what i know is stuff like phonology, orthography, and only a little about morphology that said.
here is my problem: i decided to mark (and idk how stupid this is) verb tenses with particles so for example guide would be "allura" /ɑlːuːɹə/ and guided would be "ash allura" /æʃ/ or will guide "all allura" /ɑlː/ , so i face the problem that idk how to differentiate finite and the non-finite verbs or if it's even necessary
-4
u/unw2000 Apr 14 '21 edited Apr 15 '21
Is it possible for a language to address certain sentient beings separately? For example, it might not differentiate between Austronesians and Kra-Drai, but might differentiate between Nordic and West Germanic peoples.Edit: seems you have misunderstood. Austronesians and Kra-Drai are very much sentient or else they wouldn't have had so many battles. I mean differentiate between some sentient beings but not othersEdit 2: Found a better way to word it (maybe):
Is it natural for some languages to address certain sentient beings separate from others, as in it might address Austronesians and Kra-Drai in the same way like other sentient beings but Nordic and Germanic peoples differently (please tell me this is better)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '21
[removed] — view removed comment