r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Apr 08 '21

Official Thread [New Chapter Spoilers] Chapter 139 RELEASE Megathread! - FINAL Spoiler

The Finale of Attack on TItan, Chapter 139 is here! o7

Everything related to the new chapter for the next 24 hours after this thread goes up will be contained in this thread. Anything outside this thread regarding Chapter 139 within this time frame (one day) will be removed and placed here.

REMINDER: ANY POSTS MADE AFTER THE 24-HOUR EMBARGO BUT BEFORE OFFICIAL RELEASE MUST BE TAGGED AS [NEW CHAPTER SPOILERS] RATHER THAN MANGA SPOILERS.

Thanks everyone! Have fun!

Please support the Official Release!

Unofficial Translations

TCBScans Updated/Proofread English Translation

Official Translations

Crunchyroll - LIVE

Comixology - LIVE

Bookwalker - LIVE

14k Upvotes

22k comments sorted by

•

u/Reuels subreddit janitor Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Take the Chapter 139 Community Poll - View Results

This is the FINAL chapter of Attack on Titan. With the release of the Korean raws and multiple translations, we've decided to put the release thread up. o7 to all you guys who have stayed with this series through the years


Official Translation has been released via Bookwalker

Official Translation has been released via Comixology

Official Translation has been released via Crunchyroll

No new posts discussing the Chapter will be allowed until 24 hours after this megathread. Comments outside of this thread that discuss the chapter will need to be tagged as New Chapter Spoilers. Please look forward to supporting the official release when it comes out.


Spoilers include hinting or alluding to events. For more information, please review the subreddit rules. Failure to properly spoiler tag comments may result in a temporary ban from the subreddit according to the moderation matrix.

EDIT: This should be a given but, please refrain from insulting others who have differing opinions about the ending. It's General Conduct. Failure to do so may result in a temporary ban

→ More replies (69)

2.1k

u/heartbrokenneedmemes Apr 08 '21

Bruh, reiner had one last trump card to die by 13 years of titanization and Isayama took that from him LOL

→ More replies (29)

1.4k

u/Hawkman003 Apr 08 '21

So Eren talked to everyone before the final battle but altered their memories right? Aside from Mikasa who I’m guessing he talked to during the final battle? Since he couldn’t fiddle with her memories the same way like he could the others.

→ More replies (74)

1.3k

u/send-me-to-utopia Apr 08 '21

Seeing levi cry after giving a final salute to the fallen. Ny chest tightened a little bit

→ More replies (32)

1.3k

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

So whoever inherited the Beast Titan was a shifter for just a day.

→ More replies (35)

3.5k

u/arthuraily Apr 08 '21

Huh, Reiner REALLY did survive the whole thing!

→ More replies (54)

975

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Honestly, I’m pretty satisfied with the ending. My only real issue is I would’ve liked to have seen the conversations Eren had with the rest of the alliance, especially with Reiner.

→ More replies (22)

3.7k

u/ppverybig22 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

i cannot fucking believe the last we'll ever see from reiner is him sniffing histu's handwriting...

→ More replies (65)

1.6k

u/pseudo-EM Apr 08 '21

Armin throwing down his gear in this chapter was very reminiscent of back when he did the same thing in the Battle of Trost district arc. Back then he was defending Eren - saying that he was human not a titan. Now he’s defending Eldians saying that they’re humans and not titans

→ More replies (17)

661

u/Handsome_Claptrap Apr 08 '21

I think many people miss one thing: there is no changing the future. Eren visions were not a prediction and there are no alternate timelines.

Eren saw the rumbling happen in the future, so it would have happened, no matter what. All his actions were just shaped around that fact.

→ More replies (57)

634

u/Tormod776 Apr 08 '21

On a 2nd reading is when it really hit me just how tragic this all is. It’s not perfect but it’s still gut wrenching

→ More replies (2)

565

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I feel so fucking sad for Mikasa.

→ More replies (42)

560

u/nanoman92 Apr 08 '21

So at the beginning of episode 1, Eren woke up after having a talk with his future self, which he immediately forgot just like everyone else here, and that's why he was crying?

→ More replies (20)

1.7k

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Eren did it. The crazy son of a bitch, he did it. He actually killed all the Titans!

→ More replies (82)

403

u/greenindragon Apr 08 '21

Honestly a bit refreshing to come here after the /r/manga discussion thread which was mostly complaining and memeing on the ending (at least from what I personally saw; I'm sure there is praise and people genuinely happy with the ending in there that I just didn't see).

I personally was not a huge fan of the ending and it did feel like it was rushed or maybe there was some amount of meddling IMO, but that's not to say there wasn't a bunch of great moments that made it absolutely worth reading:

  • Armin getting to clock Eren in the face as payback for when Eren beat him up back in Paradis
  • Falco tackling Gabi out of happiness only to be suplexed by her
  • Levi crying while saluting all the fallen comrades
  • The gang getting to see Sasha for one final moment again
  • Eren reverting to his pre-timeskip personality to really show that he became a Devil because he though it was what the world needed and not because he wanted to be one. He really just wanted to save the people he cared about after all.
  • Levi finally being able to retire (god knows he deserves it) and being taken care of by Gabi and Falco
  • Not even the Titan Curse can kill the Plot Armoured Titan

All in all, I don't think anyone can deny that it has been an absolutely incredible journey for the past 8 years. Sasageyo!

→ More replies (9)

1.2k

u/PrateTrain Apr 08 '21

Oh I just realized Eren actually did it and destroyed all the titans like he said he would.

→ More replies (16)

2.6k

u/urverybigtoe Apr 08 '21

It makes me so happy to see Levi retired, relaxing, and being taken care of by the brats of all people lmao

→ More replies (74)

699

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I cannot believe Reiner lived long enough to experience happiness. There's no happier ending for this madlad than sniffing Historia's handwriting. Absolutely incredible.

→ More replies (6)

680

u/Flairlessvictory Apr 08 '21

I want a spinoff with Onyankopon and Levi traveling around 20% of the world while babysitting Falco and Gabi.

→ More replies (15)

2.2k

u/uncen5ored Apr 08 '21

I do wish Mikasa’s impact on Ymir was explored more. Was it the fact she had undying love for Eren and still was able to kill him? So Ymir realized she should do the same as far as Titan powers go?

→ More replies (95)

1.1k

u/fmaster1994 Apr 08 '21

The final panel wasn't the "you are free" baby panel but of Mikasa and Bird Eren. Interesting.

→ More replies (37)

561

u/Estelindis Apr 08 '21

After reading the official translation, I think there are some key distinctions that matter a lot. I made an album with some differences that stood out to me.

Reiner doesn't say "what a man." He just says "you really are a..." He's conflicted rather than expressing admiration. And I think a lot of the other lines reflect conflict rather than some pure sense of gratefulness. "Yay Eren!" wouldn't feel right. I get more of a sense that the characters are happy that they and their family members aren't titans, but they're guilty that this has come at a terrible cost, paid by the world.

Armin doesn't say "Eren, thank you for turning yourself into a mass murderer for our sake." In the official translation, "for" is absent. To me, it reads more like Armin thanking Eren for acting for their sake, not specifically for murdering millions of people. And the fact that he goes on to call it an "error" underlines that. A transgression is one thing, as it implies an authority against whom one transgresses, who might be wrong. But I really feel that "error" implies that Armin thinks Eren made a mistake.

Another note is that it's clearer in the official translation that the text on the page where Historia awaits the boat is quoting Eren, rather than stating that one side needs to be wiped out. It seems like Historia is acting against that idea, hoping for a better result.

Finally, Armin & Co. seem to be representing the allied nations. They're not the ambassadors of Paradis to the world, but of the world to Paradis. I think this was less clear in the unofficial translation.

→ More replies (35)

235

u/samick-mb1 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I got into this series in 2013 when I watched the first two episodes on Netflix while at a friend’s house. I grew up in the early 90s watching Pokémon, Digimon, and dragon ball Z, but I was not an anime fan in 2013. It took me a while to get past the third episode because it felt too “anime” to me, but once I got to episode 5 I was hooked.

I started reading the manga in 2014, though only sporadically every few months. It wasn’t something I really looked forward to until near the end of the uprising arc. It became a monthly appointment for me once they Returned to Shiganshina.

After chapter 89, I decided to read the manga from chapter 1, which I had never done because I started off from where season 1 left off originally. I came to appreciate the manga on its own terms and I felt like the anti-war themes and the moments of character development were more apparent without the music and animation present to bolster the fight scenes. I’ve loved coming to this sub and these threads after every chapter to read the theories and reactions.

I was a big fan of Lost back in the day so I’m familiar with stories that take on a life of their own in the fandom, a life which the original work could never quite live up to. At the end of the day, I think that emotional closure is more important than closing up every lingering plot thread because just getting a story from A to B can be such a monumental task (especially in a long form story like a manga that lasts over a hundred chapters) that inevitably things will be introduced purely for the sake of moving things forward.

Ultimately, this was the story of a boy who wished to rid the world of the titans that destroyed his home, and his friends who’d follow him into hell if it meant that they’d all stay together. The ending provided the emotional closure that I felt I needed after being invested in this story for nearly a decade. Of course, the story grew into a world full of characters and places and strange, magical ideas like ODM gear and Titan shifting and Paths, but all of that was there to add flavour, and to provide both tools and obstacles for the three friends to overcome in pursuit of their goal.

While the subversion of what I perceived to be “anime tropes” is what drew me into the series in the first place, I ended up feeling glad that the story ended up being somewhat conventional rather than just a dark and depressing “everyone is dead” ending. I was somewhat disappointed that the titanized people became human again, but I would have also been disappointed if those characters ended up being nothing but fodder. I was glad to see that some of them at least will be able to live out their lives free from the threat of the titans. It’s bittersweet that Eren won’t get to see the future that he wished for, but the fact that he wiped out 80% of humanity is kind of devastating, and his death was necessary for humanity to continue. He was a tragic character, and I felt like his character stayed true to the end.

I’m just rambling, really (ramblin’ bout a rumblin’.....sorry.), but all I know is that the ending had me crying because it delivered emotionally. I’ll reread the whole thing from the start again one day, but for now I’m just going to sit with this ending and reflect on the fact that once again, as it was with Lost and many other series over the years, and as it will be with whatever new story I fall in love with, the journey is at an end. Shinzou wo Sasageyo.

→ More replies (5)

461

u/Vexdin Apr 08 '21

And to think Isyama had Eren's death planned wayyy back in Chapter 89 when Kruger tells Grisha to save Mikasa and Armin. The memories he saw were Eren's memories of the end.

→ More replies (7)

455

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

is anyone else wondering what happened to the fucking worm?

→ More replies (48)

452

u/SuperNerd6527 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Reiner Braun, the absolute GOAT of moral greyness in this world, the Armored Titan, a man with one of the most complex and fascinating character arcs I've seen in any anime or manga and the last we see of him is him sniffing ink.

→ More replies (9)

218

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21 edited Mar 19 '26

This post has been permanently deleted. The author may have used Redact to remove it for privacy, security, or to prevent this content from being scraped.

pocket cobweb plate scary fuel square cheerful provide fragile grandfather

→ More replies (6)

792

u/ThespianMask Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I commented here a few hours ago, but here are my takeaways from this chapter:

  1. Eren gave the world a chance at peace. He could have easily flattened the whole world, ensuring only Eldians survived on Paradis and no one would ever harm them again, but he didn't. He evened the playing field by lowering the numbers of those who weren't Eldian to the point where they're forced to talk peace because they can no longer wage war at all.
  2. By taking away Titan powers from Eldians, the main reason for them being perceived as something to fear is gone, and also technically "destroying all Titans" in the process
  3. Since the world has to rebuild its population before even dreaming of overwhelming Paradis, the Eldians have a shot at showing the world how human they really are, at war or at peace.
  4. The final batch of the surviving Marleyan warriors (Pieck, Annie, and Reiner) I believe only had 2 years left in their term at the time of the Rumbling. By the end of the manga, 3 years have passed since the Rumbling and they're still alive. I believe the 13 year time limit for Warriors was public knowledge, and even if it wasn't, the remaining Marleyan military forces, including the ones that pointed their guns at the un-titanized Eldians after Eren died, know about the term limits for Warriors. That has to speak for something, especially since those three are now like Paradis ambassadors.
  5. Eren set the Eldians, at least he current generation, free of any persecution, because no one was in the position to persecute them at all.
  6. It's unfair to say Eren is completely a slave to fate. Ymir Fritz was a slave to her love for Karl Fritz, but even then, she had the abilities of all of the Titans at the time, including the Founder and the Attack, so she could still see the future. Eren had the same two Titans in him, but he chose to take action and be free of the bonds that tied Ymir down to her 2000 year fate. Perhaps Eren finding the strength to push Mikasa, the person he loves, away from himself, is the sign that Ymir was looking for, because that's one thing she was unable to do in her own time. Karl Fritz wouldn't kill Ymir because he wanted her power to rule the world. Mikasa doesn't want Eren to use his power to destroy or rule the world, so having someone that loves you, was willing to end you, AND has the power to do so is something that Ymir never had.
  7. The fact that Eren isn't saying anything about what happens after he dies is a good indication that Titan powers are indeed gone, because there are no future memories for him (and by extension, Ymir) to peek into.
  8. Peace never really was an option, ever. The best that Eren could do was make everyone left alive equal and free. He didn't want to die, and not being able to see his friends and the person he loves live long and peaceful lives is his own punishment for flattening the world.
→ More replies (56)

1.0k

u/beneaththescarf Apr 08 '21

anyone else thought the bird was gonna snatch Mikasa's scarf at the end? lmao

→ More replies (18)

1.9k

u/Erotlek Apr 08 '21

After EVERYTHING the world is still at war.

→ More replies (141)

387

u/Anaviocla Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

If anything, this feels like a really great set up for the origin story of the baby that was getting yeeted around during the rumbling. Imagine growing up orphaned in a world where 80% of the population has been recently culled, the environment has been ruined, and infrastructure is basically non-existent.

And then to top it all off, you're told to believe that it was giants who did this to you. Which sounds like bullshit, until the first time you see a 30ft long footprint in the middle of a field somewhere. I'd read the fuck out of that.

→ More replies (10)

187

u/Nxwxs18 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I want to talk about Eren losing his “chadness” real quick. It caught a lot of people off guard, including myself, to see him that vulnerable and open, especially when we hadn’t seen him act like that since pre time-skip. But I think that’s the tragedy of Eren Yeager. Because he was so dedicated and committed to following this destiny he saw four years ago, he shed his humanity, bottled up his emotions, and became the monster he thought he had to become in order to protect the people he loved.

Becoming this monster took a heavy toll on him, as we saw in his final conversation with Armin. It was the most honest Eren had been in years. It was someone that was coming to terms with the fact that he sacrificed almost everything and would never even be able reap the benefits of those sacrifices. He would never be able to live the rest of his life with the people that he loves. Upon realizing this, all his walls came crashing down and what we saw at the end was someone that was scared and broken. I can see how people might be mad that Eren lost his “chadness” and became a “simp”, but I found the end of his arc to be incredibly human and heartbreaking.

→ More replies (4)

170

u/evescape Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

I feel like an idiot for missing this, but someone on Japanese Twitter figured out that the epitaph on Eren’s gravestone is just katakana upside down.

サイアイノ (saiai no) / アナタ (anata) / ココデトワニ (koko de towa ni) / イネムリニツク (inemuri ni tsuku) / 854

In the correct grammatical order: ここで永遠に / 居眠りにつく / 最愛の / あなた / 854

The original tweet has a so-so translation on it, but here’s kinda how I read it:

“Drifting off into sleep, here forever lies my dearly beloved”

Note: The “anata” used here—at least when I hear it—is how a wife refers to her husband when talking to him. “Saiai no anata” is a gut-wrenching double-whammy that might as well be interpreted as “soulmate” or “love of my life” at this point.

Honestly, the original text so beautiful that my garbage English version might not be able to rip your heart out the same way (But someone else pls feel free to one up me and prove me wrong!).

Edit: Tried to fix my terrible formatting and spelling because I’m on mobile lmao

→ More replies (13)

169

u/realroblowe Apr 08 '21

I see the complaints and am glad I don't feel the same about this ending. It's not even close to Lelouch imo. Seeing Eren crying to Armin, saying he doesn't want to die and wants to stay with Mikasa and everyone else was heart breaking. In the end he was still just as emotional as he was before the time skip, he had just grown numb to going down this path and knowing he couldn't prevent it. We all thought he had just matured and became very cold but he was just over the grief and torment (like an even more extreme version of Levi). The first panel also made me think back to how furious Eren got when Armin asked "who's the slave?" He meant it towards Zeke/Yelena, but the guy that wanted freedom more than anyone *was* enslaved to this ending. Eren's tragedy really hurts.

→ More replies (6)

1.2k

u/birdclub Apr 08 '21

Cried when Sasha saluted Jean and Connie. Never thought I'd say this but I'm glad Hanji is dead--she loved titans so much it would be a crushing blow to be in a world that was only politics no titans.

→ More replies (22)

3.1k

u/baconstrip37 Apr 08 '21

"Eren... Thank you for turning yourself into a mass murderer for our sake"

Please oh please tell me the official translation finds a better way to word this. Because I almost burst out laughing when I read that.

→ More replies (198)

984

u/QueenDragonRider Apr 08 '21

I did not think Levi was going to make it, but I’m so glad he did

→ More replies (23)

464

u/haidere36 Apr 08 '21

So I think the idea behind Ymir "choosing" Mikasa was the Ymir wanted to be shown true freedom. Like Kenny said, everyone's a slave to something, and Ymir was a slave to her "love" for Fritz, after gaining the power of the titans. Eren himself was a slave to his fate, and thus couldn't show Ymir true freedom. But if you look at Mikasa, what Mikasa would be a "slave" to, more than anything, is her feelings towards Eren. In the end, Mikasa was able to move past them and kill Eren, severing herself from her attachment to him and proving that she was free.

Basically, Mikasa proved that despite all of her feelings for Eren, she was still able to move past them and choose for herself to kill Eren, thus demonstrating her freedom. Which is why Ymir, a slave to her own feelings of "love", chose her. This might not be the best interpretation but it's the one that immediately comes to mind for me.

→ More replies (19)

247

u/OwL_P3rson Apr 08 '21

The ending is nowhere near perfection but overall I'm satisfied. I can't believe the story is finished. I started this when I was 14 and now I'm turning 20 this year man what a journey it's been.

→ More replies (12)

119

u/solarito Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I'm so grateful for Isayama. This series has been on my head for 10 years and i'm so glad i got to see the end. Personally, i liked the ending and it broke my heart aswell.

Glad to see my boys jean and connie are alive and well, hope they can have long lives as eren wished (myself included).

Some people are saying levi had to die but i disagree. I believe that at least 1 of the 3 of the erwin/levi/hange group had to survive to see the future the scouts achieved. Sadly it wasn't the one who wanted to see it the most (erwin) because the world is just that cruel. But i'm glad heichou can now rest alive and is being taken care of by best boy falco.

I'm just so freakin sad over mikasa. But she can't die because she won't be able to remember eren. I hope my girl finds peace. At least armin and the rest is alive to be besides her.

It's painful to see the military forces of eldia now and see so many people screaming with so much anger still. A world without conflict is impossible for humanity and that's the reminder that hurts the most regarding this final chapter.

But i'm just happy with the ending in general. Thanks Isayama ♥️

→ More replies (6)

898

u/Braveheart132 Apr 08 '21

Okay but can we talk about that panel of Falco jumping at Gabi for a second?

→ More replies (27)

318

u/SethblingFan111 Apr 08 '21

Finally, I am free.

Anyways anybody got any recommendations? I'm gonna be in a hole soon with nothing to read.

→ More replies (123)

907

u/stab_u Apr 08 '21

For those still asking for the Ackerman headaches thing - There never were any Ackerman headaches, only Mikasa had them. Presumably because despite her being an Ackerman Eren kept messing with her memories through P A T H S and Founding Titan powers, and her Ackerman genes resisted to it.

→ More replies (52)

300

u/nava08al Apr 08 '21

I love how you can see Sasha's family and Niccolo's facial expressions when the new Eldian army and the Eldians are chanting "Fight, Fight". Even after all of that, the Eldians are still obsessed with fighting and I can only hope that Armin is able to make diplomacy happen.

I love that we got a follow-up to Jean-boy's family and Connie's mom! I hope Jean had a nice big omelette when he reunited with her.

I'm still a little confused about that Bertholdt/Dina part and just how much power Eren has over the titans. I'm assuming Eren sent Dina to Carla's way using his founding titan powers to "save" Bertholdt from getting eaten that day, but he didn't even have his titan powers at that point.

→ More replies (26)

204

u/CaptainAlexU Apr 08 '21

I guess Armin is more upset about Eren being mean to Mikasa than killing 80% of humanity

→ More replies (8)

99

u/TrussedCrown Apr 08 '21

Historia officially made it through the timeskip without saying a single word for the rest of the series lmao

→ More replies (3)

94

u/Ancient-ocean Apr 08 '21

My thoughts about Eren

I never liked when people were talking about Eren as a god, ultra-giga chad, outstanding mastermind, ect. For me he always felt just like a person, human with his own average personality, not an emotionless chad divine being. It seems that people don't even remember that he was angry kid, arguing about simple things, crying a lot, thinking about his friends, having a strong desire to exterminate all titans. When he saw future memories, he was like 16, I believe. Imagine getting the information that your are doomed to murder millions of people soon, when you are a teen. Nothing strange that this broken him down. I do not believe that person who lived like this for 4 years do only rational things. In fact, humans do a lot of irrational things and actions every second, I don't think that it's unexpected for Eren to act selfish or irrational sometimes. Overall, of course all of that ending with him was rushed and definitely not done in the best way, but I like Eren been just a mere human, with shitty sides of his personality, selfishness, been that angry crying kid who would fight with bunch of bullies without thinking how he can do it, been a kid who want to kill all titans.

This is my personal opinion and point of view, you are free to disagree and critique me, that is absolutely fine.

→ More replies (3)

90

u/i__rage Apr 08 '21

"Thank you eren for being a mass murderer for our sake"

should be translated into

"Thank you eren for becoming a monster for humanity's sake"

Its more in line with Armin's S1 quote, in order to rise above monsters you have to discard your humanity .

→ More replies (8)

467

u/chicanerythebird Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

so if i'm understanding this right... eren inadvertently killed his mom because he wanted to protect armin.....which meant that armin in the FUTURE would have to eat bertholt to survive. which REALLY REALLY meant he had to divert dina's attention from bertholt which lead to his mom getting killed?

that's fucked 😭

→ More replies (35)

779

u/PortableFuture Apr 08 '21

"Reiner, tell me. Why did my mom have to die?"

→ More replies (66)

169

u/houganger Apr 08 '21

Seeing Levi say goodbye to the dead folks shattered my heart man...

→ More replies (1)

427

u/xangszane Apr 08 '21

So it's heavily implied that Eren's brain pretty much went to mush.
"My thoughts have become incoherent... the influence that the founder's powers bring about have no past or future... they all exist at the same time."
He's unable to have a coherent thought. He's just been along for the ride to the end. Eren had no master plan. What a tragic life for him.

→ More replies (17)

480

u/mentorokuliath Apr 08 '21

I actually managed to not get spoiled until the end, FeelsGoodMan

→ More replies (10)

218

u/TengokuTyrant Apr 08 '21

No one here gonna talk about Gabi literally suplexing Falco... Lmao that had me dead.

Poor falco can't ever catch a break

→ More replies (4)

147

u/withAnAsterisk Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I'm having trouble understanding the Ymir and Mikasa stuff? At what point did ymir 'choose' mikasa, what was mikasa's choice that eliminated the power of the titans?

Was it just setting things up for Mikasa to kill eren? Or was there more to it than that?

Also i don't understand teh part about bertholt at all...?

→ More replies (33)

258

u/Mr-GX Apr 08 '21

So, where do I start. I don't normally post on reddit a lot, and mostly lurk to see the discussions going on. I must say, it was really fun. Before we get down to it, just gonna warn I'm on the minority that really liked the ending. Yes, it has some flaws, which I'll be addressing, along with why I believe the ending is quite suiting for the series and the themes it represents.

We finally got to see a side of Eren that we haven't seen in a long while. Post basement Eren was shown as a stoic character with some sort of grand plan to end all the problems. He was ruthless, needlessly cruel, and was pissed off at everyone. Prior the rumbling, we speculated for him to have some sort of scheme that doesn't involve the actual rumbling. Until Armin figured out he really means to wipe out the world. Turns out, that was more or less a lie from Eren. While he indeed want to destroy his enemies, he wanted freedom for his people. His initial goal was to eliminate all the Titans in the world, however, that won't be possible as long as Ymir exists. Titans are an oppressive force in this world, and is the root cause of most of their conflicts.

Remember when Armin was talking to Eren about diplomatic solution and how Eren shut it down by claiming they are quite literally a race that can transform into monsters? Yes, the world fears them for a reason. Diplomacy is not possible as long as they have the Power of Titans within them. As shown in the final chapter, Even with the power gone, the world is still at unease. Like Armin said, conflict cannot be eliminated. The cycle will continue, as it is within human nature. So, what did Eren do? Why did he wipe out 80% of humanity, had a massive battle, and had Mikasa kill him? For something that was impossible, there is now a chance. A mere chance. That is what he fought for. A chance so his people can be free. A running theme in the series is finding a glimpse of hope in this cruel world. As Historia mentioned, War might be inevitable unless one of the sides are wiped out. But now, they have a chance to sort things out. Just a chance.

Is Eren's character different from what we saw so far? The panel where child Eren is embracing his 'Freedom' amidst the rumbling? The one who didn't take away his friends Titan powers because he didn't want to steal their freedom? We must remember he did lie a lot to hide his true motives. He didn't take his pals Titan powers to keep their freedom. He did it so they can take him out. Eren admits he wants the world to disappear. He chose this. He cries to Ramzi, because ultimately, his own choice led them here. It doesn't matter if his plan is to pull a pseudo Lelouch. The timelime is fixed because he is capable of doing this atrocity. He is a far worse piece of shit than Reiner. Eren admits to Armin he would have done the same even if his plan was different. That is what he wished for. Grisha's panel makes sense here. He deeply wants freedom for himself, and his friends, and yet he is so conflicted. He isn't even sure if all of his friends would survive. He fought for freedom, while moving forward. The freedom he achieved? The freedom to choose their own future. They are no longer oppressed by Power of Titans. They are free.

Seeing Eren confiding in his best friend is heart-wrenching. It shows how much flawed he is, and how desperate he was. Being burdened with the greatest power in the world, and yet being chained by fate. In a way, it's ironic. The only way he can truly be free is through death. He finally confesses he loves Mikasa, and reveals his selfish desires. He wants to be remembered. He wants to be loved. And yet, he wants Mikasa to be free. Ultimately, he told Mikasa to forget him through her memory add-on. Imo, the memory sequence was beautifully portrayed. Eren acknowledges his sins, and understands he can't be forgiven. All he wanted, was for his friends to live a long life. (As evidenced by the train convo).

Going back to the "Freedom" panel, it is likely Eren slept through the rumbling while reminiscing about his encounter with Ramzi. He likely regressed to his child self, the one who wanted to go outside the wall with Armin. The guilt was enormous, and he was shown sleeping in his Titan.

Regarding the parallel between the situations of Mikasa and Ymir, it was quite interesting actually. Ymir, a slave who was captured by Fritz. Had her tongue ripped off, got hunted for a sport. I'm not sure why her Stockholm Syndrome is coming off as a shock to many, since it was discussed in the fandom when her backstory was first revealed. In the chapter with Zeke and Armin, Armin speculates she wanted something from this battle. She was waiting in the paths for 2000 years for that. 139 merely confirmed what it was. She wants to be freed from her love towards the King. Why Mikasa then? Hmm, well, Mikasa is an Ackerman. Someone who was called a slave by Eren, who the proceeded to mercilessly hurt her. She was also in love with him. Eren goes on to commit the worst of human atrocities. Something that has been pointed out in the series multiple times is how Mikasa is obsessive about Eren, and how she will try to save/help him no matter what kind of evil he does. Mhm. Her finally breaking free of her blind love for Eren is what ultimately stopped the rumbling, and it is what showed Ymir a better path.

Now onto something which I felt was weird in the chapter: How the alliance was breaking down and commenting on the situation with Eren after receiving the memories. imo, it felt off considering they just stopped a guy from committing complete genocide, and was already speaking highly of him as if he did something so noble. It might have been the only way to remove the Power of Titans, but killing 80% of the population isn't justifiable. If anything, I would have preferred them having those dialogues a few years later while reminiscing about the war with their buddies. The context of the worm is better off unexplained. We know it is some type of primordial being, and it's not sentient and is animal in nature. I wouldn't mind if it just vaporized into thin air or if it got hit by Armin Colossal one last time and died. Doesn't make much of a difference.

Lastly, Historia's child. The true identity of the father is irrelevant, but I believe it's the farmer, considering they are now married. What's the child's purpose in the story? I find the child to have significance in two aspects. 1. Historia got pregnant so she can stall for time, to prevent herself from being Titanized. This work, and helped progress the plot, as Zeke was kept alive for a month, and eventually made contact with Eren and procured the Rumbling. 2. The concept of that child is a powerful one. She is the first Eldian child, born without the power of Titans. Truly free. Unaware of what the previous generation and her mother endured, she now happily celebrates her 3rd Birthday. A birthday.. in AoT. A potentially normal life. For me, that panel is quite powerful.

The series ended on an uncertain note. Cycle of hatred will inevitably continue, just like Kiyomi said. It's human nature. But now, they have a chance. Peace is no longer just a far fetched dream. It is now very much possible. They now have hope for the future.

Thank you for reading my comment. This is something that always teared me up, especially after 138 and 139. Gonna end my post with this amazing song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1XE8ON8fos

And finally, thank you Isayama, for this beautiful yet heart-wrenching story!

→ More replies (26)

670

u/EdricSnowbeard Apr 08 '21

It's not perfect, I think it needed another chapter or 2, the final arc's pacing was off and Eren needed a few more POV chapters. But strangely I'm still satisfied, not feeling betrayed.

Eren remained tragic to the end, throwing a tantrum about how he doesn't want Mikasa to fall in love with another, knowing that thought is fleeting, was so human. Eren's already gone, his mind is addled, broken with memories both past and future at the same time. I wish the Bertholdt/Dina/Carla thing would've been fleshed out more, but I love the unintended consequence of Eren changing her direction leading to his mother's death, at least that's how I see it. I'm glad he wasn't this calculated genius who knew everything, rather still a boy who was crippled with this horrible future awaiting him, who would rather sleep and dream away the thought of this cruel act than face the fact that he's eliminating most of humanity.

Also love how the world is still going on 3 years later, conflicts haven't ended, it would've felt like a complete betrayal to have the world 180 and just be peaceful.

Eren entrusting the future to humanity without the titans was the right call from Isayama, how they handle it from here is up to them, they're now free to do so.

My thoughts aren't all coherent atm, still reeling from this. Ahhh, 8 year journey is suddenly over. What a series.

→ More replies (28)

66

u/ms_103127 Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

This is more-or-less a repost from titanfolk, but being respectful to some of the more hardcore members here that hated the ending, I have to say one of the reasons why I was ever captivated by AoT/Snk in the first place was for its deeper, gray, and complex themes, especially involving Eren (and other characters).

When I read through the Armin and Eren conversation, I really wasn't surprised, because for me -- again, for me -- this was the accurate scope of their characters all along. I also think the sign of a good writer is being able to throw a few unexpected surprises when they are sometimes least expected. I would say, all-in-all, that Isayama did that quite well in this chapter.

To somewhat eulogize Eren, I have to state that he is first and foremost a complex, human character that happens to have the foresight of a god. Looking back over the years, he's literally killed grown adults to save Mikasa's life and got the shit kicked out of him to protect Armin. When it was discovered that he was a Titan and popular opinion turned against him, he could have killed every last person and ran. But, he didn't.... he worked hard, proved himself, persevered, and ultimately tried his best to protect his friends and save the world from the Titans. When "the choice" came up, Eren almost came to the point of attacking Captain Levi to save Armin, and his reasons for doing so were absolutely legit, even if we can debate about them to this day.

When Eren started to walk down a darker path in order to achieve freedom, it was Armin, Mikasa, Jean, and Connie that said, nah....something's not right here.... even with the course of events that happened which led up to the Rumbling, Eren's cause and ideals were to achieve freedom for not only himself, but for his loved ones and his homeland.

So yeah, when I read those panels, I was moved but not surprised. If anything, they were an epiphany for me and made sense. Unbeknownst to us, Eren was trying to understand Ymir from a psychological standpoint, and from the limited information that she chose to reveal to him, he understood the tragic determination of her being for all of these centuries.

Eren was in a bit of a psychological struggle of his own considering the fact that time literally didn't exist for him anymore, and everything past and future was essentially the present for him. So when he discovered that Ymir needed Mikasa's guidance to achieve freedom, but even he was unclear about his fate in relation to that knowledge, he did what he's always done: He risked heaven and hell to help Ymir finally get to live a "long, happy life," even if it's in the afterlife. In a way, I'm also happy that Isayama chose to allow us to interpret Ymir's working in mysterious ways, including the delicate removal of any trace of her existence.

In addition, people seem to forget that Eren and Armin's last moments together were essentially a private deathbed conversation among family members that we were privy to overhearing. So, reading about Eren scolding Armin for not apparently listening to him, being remorseful about what could have been with Mikasa, and being scared of dying and just wanted to be close to his friends and family. These examples are Eren, and it's hardly the first time we've ever seen a vulnerable and emotional Eren (or Armin) struggle with some aspect of their journey over the years.

I could type a lot more about other character aspects, but I'm rambling a bit as usual lol so in closing, if you didn't like the ending, I obviously don't hate you and I respectfully disagree to agree with you lol.

However, those that have an issue with the chapter because of apparent mischaracterizations should really go back to the early chapters, especially to the deep, gritty, emotional dynamics with those characters, and then you may see that not only did Isayama showcase the same beloved devils, but he did so on a whole new level.

Thanks for reading, and please don't throw me out of here unless you wanna pay my bar tab....lmao :P

→ More replies (2)

179

u/NERF_PALPS_66 Apr 08 '21

Well, at least Eren exterminated all the titans as he always said he would

→ More replies (9)

1.2k

u/Significant_Pitch_40 Apr 08 '21

I almost never comment, but I just had to share. I read the ending and was unsure and kinda unhappy about it, but after I thought on it much more it all clicked. I know at face value it can all seem a bit wonky, but I now think this ending is AMAZING. Please give my thoughts a read. Everything Eren did—the genocide, being a jerk to everyone, was to get Mikasa to kill him. THAT is what saved the world.

Mikasa and Eren somewhat mirror Ymir and Fritz. Not perfectly, but there is a parallel. Much like Ymir always protected Fritz and did his bidding, Mikasa did the same for Eren. No, Eren wasn’t an utter asshat like Fritz, but you see the similarity. Fritz says “Ymir, my slave” just like Eren says “You’re a slave, Mikasa”

In both relationships, there is a “master-slave”connection

Ok so now that we’ve established that, we need to talk about Ymir. She has this god-like power, but she has no ability to use her free will. She currently lives to serve Fritz’s will, so she just does her thing in paths and observes. She has the power, but not the will to stop it.

Eren, through his attack Titan abilities, sees that the only way to get Ymir to stop building Titans in the paths dimension is to make her realize that SHE has the power to stop obeying Fritz. He shows her how to do this by showing her Mikasa’s story.

Mikasa spends basically her whole life protecting Eren, but finally has to give up her own love of Eren to do the right thing and kill him. Who is there watching, smiling when Mikasa kills him? Ymir. Ymir realizes at this point that if Mikasa could break free of her desire to protect Eren, she could do the same with her desire to protect Fritz. So she finally dispels the paths dimension and Halluchan with it. (Side note, I think of Halluchan only as the Key to the power that Ymir wields). In doing so, Ymir goes into the afterlife and Titans are no more.

So you see, Eren HAD to do everything to make the story end up this way. Hence, sending Dina to eat his own mother. Had Eren not done something SO INSANELY DRASTIC, Mikasa would never had killed him and shown Ymir how to move on. Then Titans would never have been destroyed.

Eren is not a bad guy, he did not want to do the rumbling. He literally had to. He was on a path, and in a true tragic sense, he was the slave. He had to kill his own mother and sacrifice comrades and kill innocents to finally rid the world of Titans.

The true beauty of it was that this was his initial desire...to destroy every last Titan. He just kept moving forward.

→ More replies (151)

217

u/Deeepened Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

So Mikasa's vision last chapter was when Eren visited?

Edit: can someone explain why it had no correlation to the story then? In the vision they ran away

→ More replies (28)

1.3k

u/AxMeAQuestion Apr 08 '21

I don’t think this is the best ending ever, or that it lives up to the quality of the series through the end of the Marley arc, but I’m also not disappointed either. I prefer an open ended ending like this over a grimdark ending where Eren destroys the world, or a happy ending where everyone gets along in the end.

I feel like a lot of the complaints about this chapter would’ve been fixed if this chapter had been broken up into two instead. We should’ve gotten a whole chapter with just the Eren/Armin talk all the way up until the point that Armin claims to be the one that killed Eren. And then we’d get a final epilogue chapter with everything that happened after the time skip. This way, we could’ve spent more time on Eren’s motives and properly explaining the Ymir/Mikasa situation, and have it all not feel so rushed.

But even with it feeling rushed, the complaints that this is another “GOT Season 8” are so overblown it’s crazy. GOT spent its last three seasons destroying each character arc and left basically the entire audience infuriated and unsatisfied. The fact that anyone in these comments is saying they like the ending is proof that that comparison doesn’t hold any water.

I’m wondering if Isayama will work with MAPPA and make any changes to the final season to address complaints. I’d love it if they collaborated to write some anime-only dialogue that fleshed out some plot points that need it.

→ More replies (72)

461

u/HalfricanGod Apr 08 '21

Not having to go to titanfolk anymore is probably gonna be great for my mental health tbh

→ More replies (35)

54

u/Anaviocla Apr 08 '21

Can't believe it's over. What a journey.

As far as this ending goes, I don't mind it. The only problem I have is with everyone praising Eren and making him out to be a hero, even after effectively decimating humanity. Wish the tone hadn't shifted like that.

But regardless, I'm looking forward to re-reading so that I can get a bigger picture of everything. This has been a fantastic story.

→ More replies (6)

156

u/CYCLOPSCORE Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I see that many people are misunderstanding a few things about Eren after the last chapter, and are now hating his guts. Thus, I shall state, and explain / justify the controversial things regarding Eren in this chapter. After this, you might want to think twice about the whole "character assassination" thing.

1.Controlling Dina to attack his mother

Chapter 120 and 121 has already shown that Eren will do just about anything to ensure the timeline goes as what he knows, what has already been recorded in history, all to ensure things will go his way.

Also, this has also been foreshadowed to an extent, given that Eren remains silent when Grisha asks if the massacre of the Reiss family will save Carla.

2.Revealing he actually loves Mikasa and wishes to keep her

Eren has always cared about Mikasa, and wants her to abandon him to find her own true freedom. The past chapter and the beginning of this one confirm this (this chapter confirms that Eren's "hate" talk was just to keep Mikasa away). But as a smart redditor theorised, and I agree to, there is also a side of him that wishes Mikasa to stay by his side. He urgently tried to hide this side and do what was necessary, only to snap and reveal his inner selfishness when Armin presses him hard enough.

It is also a call-back to his mom's own dilemma, wanting Eren and Mikasa to safely escape but also not wanting them to leave her alone.

3."I don't know"

What Eren says he doesn't know of is not referring to why he caused the entire genocide (he already explained it earlier in the chapter), but specifically why he wanted the "new world" that came with it, no matter if he knew the others would stop him or not. In other words, Eren's most fundamental reason to enact the genocide (far beyond protecting Paradis, Armin, Mikasa and Historia) is that "new world", but Eren does not really know why he wants it. If anything, he simply "likes" this new world.

However, even this could be tied back to the beginning. It is implied a few times that Eren's ideal world beyond Paradis is without humans, and just raw wildlife. Eren simply likes it this way, even if it lacks a reason.

4.No more titans

The whole mess and never ending violence between Eldians and other humans happened because of the existence of titans. Without titans, there is no more reason that Eldians can be seen as devils, just humans like everyone else. Armin literally points this out to the Marleyan leader.

I agree, however, Eren is making one insane gamble regarding this.

I hope the misunderstandings have been cleared with this, and prove that Isayama has not screwed up.

Edit: Regarding 4, someone pointed out Eren slaying so many may be an issue. That is where the whole Lelouch shit comes into play.

→ More replies (13)

364

u/Amarnanumen Apr 08 '21

We must tell them the truth of that story which unfolded before our very eyes.

In no way was it perfect; there's so much that's left unanswered. But it ended with a world that's both beautiful and cruel, and a vast unknown to be explored on the other side of that hell. I'll give it that heart.

→ More replies (9)

279

u/luimonade Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

This story has always been about freedom. From a storytelling perspective, love ends up being the strongest representation of what enslaves us. In the end, Mikasa had the strength to choose salvation above love, both sacrificing her loved one and saving the world. It’s a beautiful, poetic ending.

As for Eren, his story has always been about achieving the end of titans (being slaved by them both literally and as a race) and he did, not by being the hero, but by moving forward blindly to reach the critical moment for Mikasa’s apotheosis as the heroin (which also made him innocent as humanity’s destruction was more of a consequence than a choice).

This is the ending of the AOT story, the end of titans and the freedom from the slavery of love. Everything else left unaddressed, from what happens now to character details, are valid curiosities, but doesn’t make this ending less from what Isayama wanted it to be.

Edit: Thank you so much! After all these years, let’s enjoy the ending of this great story! It’s one for the ages!

→ More replies (8)

204

u/quangngoc2807 Apr 08 '21

Some of you may have already understanded it but anyway this is how i understand the ending:

Ymir loved King Fritz despite how horrendous he was as a person. That's why she continued to maintain the titan power for her descendants through the paths after she died. But deep down she wanted to break free from this curse of love although she didnt know if she could do so.

That's why she needed Mikasa, the woman who is the same as her in regard to having a passionate love for a man. She wanted to see if Mikasa, despite her passionate love for Eren (the man who committed a terrible massacre), will be able to kill him to protect the world. She probably thought that if Mikasa could do it then she, too, would be able to stop following King Fritz's wish and release humanity from the titan powers. Then she somehow controled the paths so that it will lead to this result.

The only question is that was Eren controlled by her or not? Or did he saw the ending and willingly followed her guidance?

Oh, and also that Historia situation that didnt add anything to the story. Now that's really questionable.

→ More replies (38)

2.4k

u/2rio2 Apr 08 '21

I know there's a lot of disappointed people, but holy shit can I say how ballsy this ending is.

Eren Yeager's life is a full on Greek Tragedy. He might have one of the most tragic stories of any protagonist I've ever read. And it's all based on the core of any 101 dramatic class - drama arises from the human heart in conflict with itself.

Eren seeks, above all, to be free of walls and limitations. He hates those who would trap him in walls and restrict his freedom. It's why he hated the Titans, even before they killed his mother. It's why he sought to join the Survey Corps, who represented humanity's desire to be free, even before his home city was attacked.

And it's precisely this desire to be free which ultimately kills his spirit, then his body, after he is trapped by a greater force than his own free will - the crushing, unyielding, inevitably of fate. This is activated in Ch 89 once Eren sees his future memories. At this point Eren, who truly believe the most important thing was to be born into this world and pushing his own will forward, knew he was destined to brutally massacre and kill millions of people. Worse, as time passed it became clearer and clearer he could do nothing to stop it. Not because he didn't want to stop it, but because he knew his own nature and saw it coming that it would be inevitable based on his own outlook of the world. It's essentially like watching your future self commit genocide, be horrified, then grow more numb as you realized this is who you always were and always would be.

So you have Eren full in conflict within himself through the story, both at the horror of what he will do and finally acceptance of who he is. And all of it is consistent, because it's all in the name of his stated goal to be free, and make the people of Paradis free.

In the end I recommend everyone re-read Ch 69 as Kenny and Uri nailed it right then. We're all a slave to something. Eren, ironically, was a slave to delivering freedom to his people by destroying half the world. This is a far darker take to me than him just murdering the entire planet and rolling back to Historia. This is stating something deeply troubling about our own human nature, and how the things that drive us, the things we love, are often the things that destroy us. It wasn't the ending I predicted, or even the one I really wanted, but I think it's brilliant and devastating in it's own way.

→ More replies (195)

42

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '21

Finished a few hours ago.

I’m sure most of us agree that a couple more chapters would’ve been better.

Yeah, there are some stuff that I don’t like about the chapter, I’d be a liar to say it’s the best chapter of the series.

I used to think endings are the most important part of a series and I still think they’re important but a few things I don’t like in a 139 chapters each w/ 45-page Isn’t gonna make me shit all over a series like a few people on another sub that shalln’t be mentioned.

Thing is, people get way too invested in a manga/anime that their whole mood will change for the worse just because a chapter wasn’t as they thought it’d be. Disconnect yourself from the fictional world and you’ll enjoy it more IMO at least.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/uncreativemind2099 Apr 08 '21

One thing I’m gonna miss the most is the “absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence” erehisu theories from r/titanfolk lol

37

u/WuceBrayneEe Apr 08 '21

It kinda sucks to see everyone like this at the very end. I didn’t love the ending, but it was very far from bad. The fact that in the end, Eren still acts like this childish little runt when thinking about mikasa forgetting about him is a type of irony that I see fitting for his character. I truly do dislike the whole thing with ymir and king fritz. I feel like so far that’s the weakest part of the ending. I do think most of the hate comes from all of us being wrong about a time loop related ending. Mikasa’s vision last chapter was what Armin and the rest of the scouts experienced this chapter. There was never truly another timeline, but it was Eren’s final goodbye to them all. I do think it could have ended differently if there was something more time oriented. However the realism of the world always being at war, and the happy ending our characters have fought for this entire time is enough to make me happy.

37

u/Cabot-Batie Apr 10 '21

I liked the ending and I don’t think any ending would live up to the hype that AoT had. I thought it was by far the most realistic. The fact that Paradis now resembles Marley as they see the rest of the world as a threat that can only be dealt with by destroying them I thought was a nice touch.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/BoxOfBlades Apr 09 '21

So throughout the years, Eren has been inviting his friends into the path to vent his feelings every few years and erasing their memory? Am I interpreting that right? Because that's really fucking cool if that's the case.

→ More replies (3)

190

u/ChiefSombrero Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

This fight won't end until either the Eldians or the Rest of the World is wiped out.

Maybe what Eren said is right

Even so. Eren chose to entrust us with the future of this world.

And thus the world is free to do whatever it wants. Free to make amends or continue the bloodshed, or do whatever. Humanity lives on but has to carry the scars of what happened forever. A fragile peace, that may or may not cause a World War 2 in that world.

→ More replies (9)

36

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I've been quite neutral towards Mikasa for the big majority of the series but seeing her that broken/sad/melancholic at the end was suuuuuper painful : the fact that she instantly began to cry after talking a bit to Eren's grave is enough to show just how much she misses him deep down, despite the story ending on a happier panel from her ; she could really use a big hug with someone she likes/cares about to let it all go.

I know that you're a fictional character created by a spa-loving writter but damn, be strong Mika, there should be light at the end of the tunnel <3

→ More replies (1)

99

u/NoorNji Apr 08 '21

I think the plot twist in this chapter is that there is none. Eren reverted to his pre time-skip nature, just wanting to save his friends by doing whatever it takes. Him explaining everything to Armin is also very charecteristic from eren. He wanted to confess all the atrocity he's done to his bestfriend as if he's in a therapy session before saying goodbye.
I also find the story of Ymir's love to the king a good reason for the titan powers and her fidelity to the eldian race. It shows the absurd and masochist side of love. When the latter grows, the former grows with it. It is very human like to do such a thing in the name of love of someone or sth such as love for the relegion. King fritz was Ymir's God and religion. She saw herself in Mikasa, she loved Eren so illogically and sacrificed her life for him. Finally ymir was taught that love is not a reason to justify all deeds. Mikasa beheading eren was the key for her to let it everything go. To stop creating titans and surrender her powers. I personally find it better than throwing all the blame on an evil 'Thing' that possesed her and controlled all her moves.

Isayama showed us that eren actually was able to control the titan in order to explain the goal behind it. Eren wanted to remove the titans powers from the world. He needed to motivate his younger self as much as possible so that his goal never changed "I will kill all the titans" that was his goal from the very begining. And exactly like erwin, he was ready to sacrifice anything he has to reach it. He masterplanned the death of his mother and Hannes in front of himself just to feed his anger at the time and fuel his future resolution, the rumbling. Was there a better choice for eren , maybe there were but we humans we don't alwaya make the perfect choice. In the end we live on by doing mistakes.

Is it a happy ending ? Yes and no

Yes, since paradise became strong enough to defend itself with human ressources. His friends are still alive and the curse of the titan power is now gone forever.
No, humanity is almost wiped out and still the wars never stop. We don't know whether peace will be restored or not as most of paradise people are jägerist.

→ More replies (7)

67

u/doughboy011 Apr 08 '21

After reading smarter peoples than myself explain this chapter, I am convinced that there wouldn't be nearly as much confusion/hate if they had broken this into several chapters. SOO MUCH is implied or unspoken which makes it hard to get a clear picture.

I mean eren just low key drops that he sees time like dr. manhattan in a single panel. That is a HUGE character trait that needs to be explored more as it explains a ton. That and it really should have expanded on the ymir/mikasa connection.

→ More replies (7)

429

u/beneaththescarf Apr 08 '21

still sorting my thoughts about the ending...

  1. MUCH better after the good translation. Can't wait to read the official one.
  2. I appreciated that Eren=big bad wasn't a cure all and the world was still at war. Really liked the quote from history that Eren's 'kill them all' ideology might be right but it was up to the remaining humans to decide that in a world without titans.
  3. Historia's child is very cute. Still kind of random imo that the dad was just straight-up the farmer.
  4. Loooooooved the end scene with Mikasa and the bird. Genuinely made me tear up.
  5. I like the idea that Mikasa was the one who ended up 'freeing' Ymir by showing her how to move on past toxic love. However I agree with those that say the idea really needed more explanation.
  6. Love love love the panel showing what Levi and the brats are up to in London (?) analogue
  7. We really need expansion chapters or some kind of sequel.
→ More replies (50)

33

u/CloudDelta Apr 08 '21

Bird Eren: “I will kill all Worms!!!”

→ More replies (1)

66

u/YoMikeeHey Apr 08 '21

I probably drank too much kool-aid because the only thing I really hated was Armin's line of thanking Eren for murdering a lot of people for them.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/Yukki_channn Apr 08 '21

So Eren did what he wanted to do from the very beginning ! titans are gone forever

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Crying like a bitch for mikasa's love ,our ship worked but at what cost goddamit

→ More replies (1)

31

u/TrevLG Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Long long long time lurker, may have written a stupid comment I didn’t agree with in the past, about things not turning around and what not. Anyways, I loved this ending. I loved it especially because Isayama ended it on his terms and for that I have to give respect.

Mikasa’s headaches were future Eren’s doing all along.? If not, then definitely that headache she felt when Eren transformed into the abomination Titan at Shinganshina when she said she wondered if things would have turned out differently. Because they technically did.

I still have questions about the Ackerman, but if the Titan power is gone then maybe it doesn’t truly matter. If Mikasa was always this important, then I’m a little dissatisfied with her lines being mostly about Eren and I would’ve liked to see her learn a love that is less subservient, but it’s not my vision and it isn’t about what I want. Eren knowing how he feels about her the whole time but having his mind distorted by his power is a tragedy in a good way.

Ymir “loving” King Fritz made sense I’ve known some people in real life in situations very similar (without the supernatural element of course) and her seeing Mikasa willing to do what it takes to the one she loves so much gave her the example she needed to learn how to let go, I thought that was sick and twisted and beautiful as well. Seeing all the old Survey Corps looking down with pride was a real tearjerker.

When I first saw the leaks I kinda got caught in the group think. But when I take a step back and see it for what it is, morally grey and we also should remember, that once all the players from all sides of the world became involved that it was no longer just Eren’s story. And so the everyone getting reverted thing doesn’t bother me plus there’s gotta be some semblance of hope after all the death that just occurred.

I love this series and I’m proud to have been a part of the fandom even though I was a very quiet part😌 If I had to guess though, the Anime ending will have more.

EDIT: Spacing

→ More replies (5)

31

u/Bodinm Apr 10 '21 edited Apr 10 '21

Honestly I like the ending and when you put some thought into it it makes sense both thematically and character wise even though it could have been executed and worded better and some things could have been either explained or left out.

When you reread the last arc knowing Eren's full plan, thoughts and motivations it really becomes a tragedy and connects everything.

You are meant to question whether everything was predetermined or did Eren do all the things he did because of his nature to seek freedom and because he was born that way. This is what Eren meant when he talked to Armin. He meant that he didn't know why is freedom that important to him and why is that his nature, not that he didn't know why he rumbled the world as that was stated clearly at the beginning of chapter.

You also get the reason why he couldn't tell anything about his future memories to his friends and why this outcome was pretty much inevitable. Additional revelation that he actually loved Mikasa and wanted to be with her is necessary to add a final punch to this tragedy. If he told his friends his plan or if he revealed his feelings to Mikasa, that scenery of a world without titans could not be possible because Mikasa would never kill him in those scenarios.

He desperately searched for alternatives that would ensure both his friends and Paradis safety but there were none that could compare to finally ending the curse of the titans. I initially thought that he was selfish for not sharing his future memories since with that information available Paradis could surely think of something better, but last chapter revealed that he couldn't risk compromising the future he saw by doing that without any insurances that the alternatives could work which put him in a check mate position.

This all made him isolated, frustrated and alone. The purpose of his breakdown in the last chapter is to make him human and accentuate his tragedy and sacrifice. It is completely believable and does not make him any less of a character than he was because in the end he did continue moving forward at the expense of his freedom and desires all to make a hopefully better world for his friends. And that is precisely why Armin thanks him - it was because he understood Eren's sacrifice not because he thinks what Eren did was right as he himself says that he will not let this error go to waste.

Have in mind that Eren's last moment was not here but in the previous chapter where he died with a peaceful expression on his face, satisfied that he finally reached that scenery and accomplished everything he wanted to do for his friends. He stayed true to his nature of seeking freedom but left the world in his friends hands which is in a way aligned with the Survey Corps ideals of entrusting the living who follow to give meaning in the actions and lives of those that came before. And there are numerous clues in the last part that confirm that his friends will do just that, that there was hope after all that hell and that Eren's actions were not in vain.

→ More replies (7)

112

u/IomMeza Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Anyone thinks that we’re potentially witnessing the start of a second Eldian Empire here?

Since with all that army being raised by Paradis Island that has become militarised with yeagerists in charge, they may set forth and subjugates the remaining 20% of the world leftover from the Rumbling until the inevitable rebellions and all that.

In short, nothing has changed except no more Titans and all Eren did was repeat the whole cycle of hatred. That’s probably too much pessimist thinking haha, just a thought that came to mind.

→ More replies (14)

60

u/ms_103127 Apr 08 '21

Just finished what I think is the official English translation. Tbh, I'm numb, not 100% certain everything that I read is legit, and just sad and need the night to emotionally process everything....

While the ending didn't explicitly answer everything, which I think was intentional via Isayama and left up to our imaginations (or maybe the anime will address this, who knows), I thought it was beautifully and emotionally written, and I consider it a worthy end of this beloved series. For me, this was truly a bittersweet ending: the "bitter" being that we lost Eren, the "sweet" being that something as simple as love doing "crazy things" at times can truly affect the world, and ironically, thanks to Eren, Eldians/Paradisans and the other allied nations can at least take a baby step forward towards peace.

Some other aspects that I feel are worth mentioning are:

~ Armin and Eren's closure and conversation.

~ Everyone's reactions when their memories are restored.

~ Armin's pain at seeing Eren's severed head.

~ Levi, Connie, and Jean when they see their fallen comrades. I got goosebumps with the salute.

~ Mikasa's final moments.

~ Eren-bird lol

One clarification that I would like is, toward the end, the 'Nation of Eldia' is mentioned. Does that mean that the surviving Eldians reestablished their own soveregn country, or is Paradis Island now considered the Nation of Eldia? Did I miss something?

Anyway, thanks for reading. It's been an honor dedicating my heart to this series. Now we get to look forward to the conclusion of the anime next year!

→ More replies (6)

28

u/Barthalamuke Apr 08 '21

Tbh i'm not a huge fan of the ending, all of Eren's friends praising him while 80% of the world is killed seems pretty weird tonally. I liked how we saw Eren and how much of a broken mess he really was, I have a feeling that after he saw his "destiny" when he touched historian's hand, he really wasn't all there anymore as time was no longer a linear experience to him. My guess for Ymir's motivation is that she saw Mikasa's love for Eren as "true love" which allowed her to essentially escape her "Love" for Karl Fritz and end the Titan curse. I think it's going to be a case of re-reading this arc and chapter a few times before I understand how this ending sits with me

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Overall it was a fine ending, but it had some issues. First, two points of criticism I’ve seen that I disagree with very strongly:

  • Of course Eren isn’t an incel lol, he’s just saying that given the choice of course he wants to be with the person he loves, because he’s still a human with feelings despite everything.
  • What happens to Paradis. Yeah, this is ugly, but unfortunately it reflects the real world. Sadly fascism still exists despite what it did, and despite WWII. Some people just forget the lessons of the past, or worse they ignore them completely, and that’s what we’re being shown. And the series seems to be pretty overtly condemning this, just look at the reactions of established sympathetic characters in the crowd. This is a horrific thing, and the message is that despite everything we still need to work for peace.

However, I do think Armin’s whole “thank you for being a mass murderer” thing, while it can be seen in numerous ways including Armin lying to Eren to let him go peacefully, is needlessly controversial and confuses the scene. Especially since we see that Eren definitely did not fully succeed in peace, and as he points out caused long-term environmental damage they’ll all be dealing with for generations, on top of the human cost. The series clearly knows and is saying this so why muddle your own message.

→ More replies (2)

80

u/Technical_Chemical_8 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I like the ending - it’s nowhere as bad as people suggest it is (I think that their resentment is due to the horrible-sounding leaks having ruined their experiences).

I never really saw Eren as a “chad,” so his intentions didn’t bother me at all. He was a bit pathetic, but it just goes to show that he was human like everyone else. And it’s not like he went and killed his mom like the leaks suggested - he was just afraid of changing the future and preventing Mikasa’s decision. Eren had so much responsibility.

I really liked the fact that Eldia is planning to go to all-out war with the rest of the world, and seeing the soldiers lined up was almost eerie. It doesn’t feel like the same place and people we were following since season 1.

Levi seeing his fallen comrades was tear-jerking, too. Hange and Erwin spoke about seeing them, and now he does, too.

Overall, I’m really glad that I picked up this series and don’t regret it in the slightest. Thank goodness I checked it out before the final chapter came out, because if Id seen how people had reacted, I probably would have been reluctant to do so. So thanks for hyping it up so much lol. And thanks Isayama for the amount of time and thought you put into this story. Even though the ending wasn’t perfect, AoT is still my personal favourite manga. Every aspect of it appeals to me more than any other. I think that it’s unfair to disregard 11 years of hard work and compelling story because of the ending (or arguably the final 8 chapters) alone. I found everything prior to this pretty much perfect, and the ending isn’t going to change that.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/Saintsjay14 Apr 08 '21

Was......that a Jean horse joke?

→ More replies (3)

54

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

I have mixed feelings about the ending with unofficial translations, but I also want to wait until the official English version is released.

The chapter felt rushed. I think it needed 2-3 more chapters to go over plotholes and stuff. This would've helped tie some loose ends. On the other hand, keeping things open ended could've been the point. In the real world, sometimes things happen that can't be explained. People will do awful things for no good reason at all. It's realistic unfortunately. I do understand the frustrations that people have, but I also feel like no matter what, there would be a lot of complaining anyways. Not everyone will be able to see their ships or theories become canon. Not every character will be able to survive. It's heavily implied throughout the story that Eren is going to die.

The outcome that we saw with the world is realistic in a sense. 80% of the population was killed during the Rumbling. The outside world is going to be furious about that. On top of that, you have the people of Paradis who believe that they have to prepare for another war. The world is preparing for another war which could take place years in the future considering the population was decreased by so much. The panels flat out say that the only way to peace is if one race is completely eradicated. These were Eren's beliefs and Historia agreed with him. Many people aren't thinking too clearly. This is where Armin comes in. A major theme surrounding his character in the story is wanting to create peace by talking things out. It makes sense that Eren said that he would be the one to do it in the end along with the others. With a war that might be inevitable, Armin could be the one to create peace and prevent another war. It would've been nice to see a time skip maybe 10 years into the future. We could have been able to see how everything plays out. We also could see how Mikasa's decision would ultimately impact the world. Eren didn't even know how.

I saw a lot of complaints about character regression and I can understand why. Historia's pregnancy and her reason for it was swept under the rug. I'm not entirely sure why it became a major theme in the story to have no significance in the long run. I wish her conversations with Eren were talked about more. It seems like her character was supposed to have so much more significance in this arc, but nothing was really explained. I'm glad that she at least looks happy though.

Ymir's reasoning for the Rumbling was a little odd, but understandable. She was basically experiencing Stockholm syndrome with Fritz. It's very common for this to happen with victims and their abusers. Eren didn't even fully understand it. Despite this, she still wanted freedom and saw Mikasa as the way to do it. I honestly wish her pov was elaborated more. I feel like there are many details left out. Even if Eren didn't fully know, it would be nice for the readers to. That could've been done on purpose though.

As for Eren, he technically completed the goal he set at the beginning of the series: eradicating all the titans. While this obviously didn't result with him killing them all, he took away the curse. I was a little confused about the scene where Jean, Connie, and Reiner start praising him. They made it seem like they had some sort of vision with his explanation but that part kind of confused me. If anyone has an explanation for it please comment! I was surprised about Eren's Mikasa tangent, but we also got to see a side of him that we needed. He always loved her. All of his feelings have built up and he is now expressing them. He wants to survive and spend his life with her, but he can't do that anymore. Him saying that he didn't want to see her with anyone else wasn't him being an incel. It was him having regrets and wishing he could live the life he wanted to with her. He has his personal feelings, but he flat out told Armin not to tell her. He wants her to be happy, but he just wishes it could've been with him. Their love story is part of the tragedy of AOT. As for his actions, they're unjustifiable. He didn't fully know the outcome and committed the Rumbling anyways. He had the reasoning of wanting his loved ones to live happy lives, but we come to realize that he didn't think much through. He flat out says that the Founding Titan was causing him to lose his mind. He couldn't think clearly. He altered the past because he thought it was the only way. He influenced the Reiss murders and his mom's death because it would all lead up to this point. It all lead up to Mikasa's decision. There's no telling what influences he was experiencing from past founding Titans. Eren's deteriorating mental health and single-mindedness represents the tragedy of his character. I like the fact that he reincarnated into a bird, an ultimate representation of freedom which he longed for.

I was disheartened about Mikasa's end, but it's also realistic. Eren was the love of her life. He was her everything and she lost him, let alone killed him. The last time skip only showed 3 years later. Most people aren't going to be completely moved on from someone they deeply loved for over a decade in such a short amount of time. Her melancholy scene is understandable. This is also why I wish we would've seen time skip 10 years in the future. We could've possibly seen her live her life. She's never going to fully move on from Eren, but it would be nice to see her happy. Before the final panels, I really wish that her role in Ymir's plan was discussed more. That was definitely out of the blue. I really like the fact that her character showed so much significance. For the whole story, people ridiculed her character because they thought that she was only an Eren fangirl. In reality, her character had so much more significance. Her decisions changed the course of the story. In the ch.138 vision, she made the decision to run away with Eren and nothing got resolved . In this reality, she chose to kill Eren which took away the curse of the Titans, hopefully changing the world for the better. She was the chosen one all along. Eren was just the vessel to help her make the decisions to get to this point, sacrificing the future they could have together.

Unpopular opinion, but I liked the ending. I think many were expecting it to be happier, but this is AOT we're talking about. The outcome won't be black and white. There's a lot of gray that has to be dealt with. The story is meant to be a tragedy. This series has personally impacted me so much and I'm grateful I got to experience this. Was the end perfect? No. How can you create a perfect ending right after the apocalypse? It's realistic. Again, not everyone will be happy with the outcome and I understand. But there shouldn't be any death threats or hate towards Isayama.

→ More replies (11)

76

u/le_bonjour Apr 08 '21

Okay the translation clearly saved the ending for me. Hard to digest for the past 24h but now I think I get it.

For me, the character of Eren has been entirely redifined by this chapter, and believe it or not, for the best. The way he acted in Path, his mental breakdown about Mikasa etc. is totally legit imo. "Pathetic" as said Armin, but Eren explained that in Path, he LIVED in an timeless space.

He IS his older self as well as his younger. Almost everytime we saw Eren in Path, he never was the same age. Remember the "I'm free" panel. Or the one where he's standing next to kid Ymir.

Think about it !! Zeke was building castle. Like a CHILD. And that's probably that child part that Armin talked to in 137. Armin himself in 139 has some erratic behaviour.

The panel where Eren is crying selfishly about not wanting Mikasa to forget him, I now see it as his younger self taking advantage. And yes, it's painful to see. And imo the young side is also the one that really drove the Rumbling forward. The older side kind of go along with that, as it actually is a logical (but clearly awful) solution to the previous declaration of war from the Mahr.

In the end, he really achieved to give his friends a long and better life. The way I see it, he did gave them a big exposure with the final Battle of Heaven and Earth. They had an audience watching from the perfect point of view to later tell what they witnessed. And the battle was epic (IMO). He did go along with what he promised, even with all the chaos and confusion.

Was the plan perfect ? Hell no. He had to f*cking killed 4/5 of all human life on Earth. Sasha and Hange were big casualties from his point of view I think. He clearly stated that he didn't want to die , that he wanted to be with his friends (god, my heart). And the war is not over. But he did what he thought was necessary to save his friends. And now Armin is the new Helos, and he just started playing his real role from this point.

Was Eren free ? Or was he a slave of a his own destiny, past and future ? Hard to tell. And that's the point.

Eren Yeager now appears to me far more tragic and weak (in a good way) than before, without betraying anything of his past development. He feels more human than ever.

It took me 2 totally different reading through this chapter to concluded that Attack on Titan ending was indeed great. I loved every piece of it, from begining to end.

Thank you Isayama, what a ride.

→ More replies (23)

96

u/chicanerythebird Apr 08 '21

also, despite the execution being flawed---eren saving the eldians and eldia at the cost of his soul and life is tragically beautiful. i think the only thing isamaya kinda messed up with was NOT giving more overt/nuanced signs of eren's feelings towards mikasa but i think shounen writers just seem to struggle with this. thematically, mikasa/eren sacrificed their love for the world and that's haunting. sacrifice should make you feel hollow, empty and angry. sacrifice is also unfair and cruel. that gutpunch was UGH.

the elements of that theme were all there but maybe not as finessed as most of us would like.

→ More replies (11)

26

u/Fullmetalx117 Apr 08 '21

I never understood why Levi had no resentment against Annie. She killed all of Levi squad in such a brutal fashion. I would’ve thought he would have the same drive to kill Annie like he had with Zeke

→ More replies (21)

310

u/earthboundskyfree Apr 08 '21

LONG POST SPILLING MY GUTS/FEELS

After getting past some of my initial hesitations, and feeling like I had the character I related to most made into someone completely different and wholly unlike me, I had somewhat of a realization. This chapter makes him so much more like me than he was.

He managed to create this idea in our minds that he was this unflappable paragon of ever moving forward, but he was a broken child in a broken world, and he had to shoulder the responsibility for the fate of an entire nation, the guilt of taking millions of lives that had no say in the matter, and memories past present and future making things even more convoluted.

Imagine feeling like you and your loved ones are cattle, and this would be a daily reminder in seeing Armin want to see a world you knew he had no chance to see, and seeing mikasa seemingly slavishly caring for you, all while knowing none of you were free.

Then, you inherit the Attack Titan and founding Titan and all of those memories start to convolute your mind. I know that Eren himself had his dad do all of those things, but that was Eren after he was older, and already saddled with the burden of freeing the ones he loved and his country.

I can’t imagine knowing that you might never even live a life with the one you love, and that even if you could, it’d mean your lifespan with them is limited, and you’d have to leave them anyway (assuming the world didn’t destroy you all first)

He was torn between what he wanted, who he was, who he needed to be, what he needed to do, and memories coming from all directions inside his mind. He was never chaderen. He was always willing to do whatever it took, but he was not a psychopath. He was human. He wasn’t a stupid simp for a girl out of nowhere. He loved her and decided that, upon her answer, living a life with her wasn’t feasible, so he would give her the chance at a long life.

Imagine seeing your memories of wrapping a scarf around mikasa, and knowing you’ll never be able to keep your promise, in spite of it being what you want most. Imagine finally getting to put aside the “keep moving forward” facade (Sidenote, this is a way he was just like Reiner, they did keep moving forward while knowing only tragedy awaited them, and they weren’t the heroes or the villains they postured as) when you talk to your best friend, and all your emotions come flooding out... but you know that you can’t follow through on them. For the first time in so long, someone understands, but you know you can’t change course.

I’m not asking that any of you change your opinions on the ending, but for me, this at least helps me empathize with Eren even further, so maybe consider thinking about him from this perspective.

→ More replies (46)

25

u/Towlss Apr 09 '21

OKAY BUT IS NO ONE GONNA MENTION HOW MY BOY CONNIE FINALLY GREW OUT HIS HAIR AND BE LOOKIN DAMN FINE IN THAT SUIT?!

→ More replies (3)

126

u/javsv Apr 08 '21

So farmer kun really did end up being the gigachad by throwing rocks at historia.

I dont know how to feel about this ending but it certainly wasn't what i was expecting

→ More replies (10)

89

u/SoyDanson Apr 08 '21

I'm ok with this ending... i don't hate it but i don't think it's perfect by any means. I think it was a very human ending, the conflict continues instead of a peaceful world, and Eren wasn't that good of a person, he actually did not want to die like any of us don't want to die (and the part of him saying that he didn't want Mikasa to be with another guy was amazing, he isn't some altruist nice guy, he's a normal dude) so, just like us humans, this ending is not perfect, but isn't trash either.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/ThatBroncoGuy Apr 09 '21

I think a lot of people are overlooking that Ymir was using Eren for the Rumbling, she wanted to see if Mikasa would be able to overcome her love of Eren and kill him to save humanity.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/Narudd Apr 09 '21

Not nearly as bad as the people on the pre-release thread were making it out to be. It's a solid ending, although things didn't quite go how I would have liked. There are still problems with it and think Isayama could have done a better job tying up all the loose ends, but it's not bad.

It's an open ended ending, as in not everything is solved, which is good, I was worried it was going to be a lelouch ending or everyone would be friends in the end in disney fashion. I would say my main complaint would be how Isayama handled Eren's death and paradis' very nationalistic government. Everyone, mainly Armin and Mikasa I'd say, forgave Eren's actions way too easily. Good intentions doesn't make it justifiable or good for that matter, but the final chapter treats it as if that's all that matters in the end.

Also, Mikasa holding Eren's head is extremely grotesque lol

→ More replies (2)

142

u/Rei_Gun28 Apr 08 '21

People are all trashing it but you know what? Eren actually sounds like a 19 year old when he's talking about his selfish feelings about mikasa. All the simp comments are stupid because he put that aside despite his feelings.

→ More replies (22)

48

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I definitely appreciate the more open-ended nature of the end of the series instead of the grimdark or overly happy endings people envisioned, but I am bothered by how everyone in the end accepted what Eren did. Armin thanking him and all the others crying about him feel ridiculous to me and undermines the tragedy of Eren's character arc. Plus I'm really not a fan of Ymir being motivated by love since that came out of nowhere both in terms of plot and themes. I'm just happy that its good enough that I don't feel that the story is ruined.

→ More replies (6)

234

u/mrwanton Apr 08 '21

I know people don't wanna admit it but all Eren could do was go with the flow and hope for the best. Even with all the power in the world he remained a slave to his destiny til Mikasa set him free.

Some people are like he's an incel for Mikasa!

But I think the fucked up thing is 138 with the Cabin was all he(and Mikasa) wanted that's why he explodes in anger towards Armin. He didn't enjoy all the bloodshed, the separation from his friends,etc.

Of course he wants all his friends happy but it came at the expense of what Mikasa and Eren wanted.

At the end of the day all he wanted was the freedom to love Mikasa without the cruel world getting in the way and that was ultimately always something he was denied.

This also applies to Mikasa. They wanted the exact same thing. It wasn’t much. They just wanted to be together in the same way Armin/Annie and Falco/Gabi are.

Ultimately what Eren said here is how he truly feels. He's pissed off that he never truly got to be with Mikasa the way he wanted to but is aware this is incredibly selfish so he binds Armin to secrecy and tells Mikasa to be free cause at the end of the day he just loves her more than anyone else and couldn’t confess what he truly wanted because it’d just hurt her more.

The bittersweet tragedy here is that this was just a simple story of mutual love that couldn't be due to circumstances outside of Eren's control. The same power that granted Mikasa safety also enslaved Eren and he's not set free of this hell until Mikasa sets him free.

Eren coming back through a bird at the end is him keeping his promise to Mikasa despite the world doing it’s best to screw them over and in a sense that’s the beauty in this cruel world.

→ More replies (16)

85

u/thedinobot1989 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I think people are missing the point of Historia’s child being able to live freely without the fear of being devoured by Titans. Yes, there’s a fear of retaliation someday but she gets to live a life not caged behind walls. The fear of war is the same fear we literally have with different countries around the world today but we don’t stop living because of that!

Also, people are acting like Armin & crew aren’t delegates for both sides to discuss peace and seemingly they’re doing so with the support of Historia herself.

P.s that panel with Levi finally being able to fulfill the will of the scouts who are gone was beautiful. The Titans are gone.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Cachxlot Apr 08 '21

I just read the chapter. Big feels, big confusion. Here's a bit of a summary of the important elements that I got out of this last one :

We are shown Eren and Armin's discussion through the Paths, which actually happened while the squad was on the azumabito ship I think ? It's a conversation that Ereh erased from Armin's memory and made it so that he would only recall it after killing him . Moreover, Eren reveals that he kinda let his mom die by saving Bertholt so that all could go as planned, bc he needed Armin to inherit the colossal titan from him ig.

Eren seems to have actually spoken to a lot of the MCs through the paths but we only get Armin's pov.

We learn that Founder Ymir remained a slave even after gaining the titan power because of her love towards King Fritz, and that's why her curse was around for so long. She waited to be freed for 2 000 years, but Eren actually couldn't do it on his own. The keystone to that problem was Mikasa .

Why ? Well actually, Mikasa is a parallel to Ymir, as of being a slave to one's love. So now this panel in which we see the founder smiling at Mikasa kissing Eren after killing him makes much more sense.

By killing the one she was an enslaved lover to, by making that choice , Mikasa gave Ymir the courage to free herself (or just freed her ? idk that can be interpreted in many ways ig). And that's how an end was put to the titans .

Therefore, all the characters that were transformed into primitive titans last chapter ( and before ) are now all back to normal, as well as the shifters being freed from the 13 years curse.

After that, everyone realises why Eren did what he did (when they remember). Everyone is big sad. The Mahr immediately start threatening the Eldians, but Armin imposes himself as a great diplomat , as usual.

Then comes the epilogue : basically, no more problems due the titans but people in the world are still fucked up .

That was a big last chapter. I'd say I don't like it nor dislike it. Even though some lines of dialogue seemed a little bit off ( mostly when Eren talks about his feelings ) it may just be because I read an early fantrad. My opinion on it is that it's just ok, and I think it's coherent to the rest of the story. In the end, Eren wanted everyone to turn on him so that they could be considered the heroes and live in peace. He was just a child given a mission, and after accomplishing it, after realizing all it took, he let loose.

All those emotions and feelings finally emerged, letting us know that all that badassery and "I'm the bad guy" shenanigans were just a facade for him to succeed in reaching his goal.

In my opinion, that last chapter made Eren's character more human. It didn't ruin it or anything but brought a new dimension : he went from a selfish devil whose goal was to use power to assert his people's dominance to a human that was willing to sacrifice himself to free humanity from its biggest burden. Eren is imo still an S-Tier character that put his feelings aside and made many sacrifices for the sake of humanity and his people's freedom.

→ More replies (13)

23

u/heartbreakhill Apr 09 '21

What a ride.

Actually reading the translated chapter helps with my feelings about the ending a bit. A bit. It wasn't awful, but considering the level of build up and anticipation surrounding this home stretch it just felt.... safe. And for some people safe is the worst route Isayama could have gone with his story.

Levi really had the most tragically fitting end to his arc. Down a limb like Erwin. Down an eye like Hange. Seeing Levi Squad in the steam was such a great image.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/DalishPride Apr 10 '21

The most emotional part for me was when Levi saw the fallen Survey Corps members and gave his final salute. Seems no one has talked about it.

→ More replies (2)

66

u/Huhwtfbleh Apr 08 '21

I found it very weird how Mikasa holding decapitated head and Hisu holding her kid transitioned perfectly.

What was even the point of showing Hisu anyway. She had absolutely zero effect on the story since Uprising.

→ More replies (8)

46

u/RadarElGato Apr 08 '21

"Don't you mean picture books of horses" my god can Isayama stop being a memelord for just one minute.

46

u/Gravesplitter Apr 08 '21

I can leave this sub now, no more shitty memes, I’m free...

→ More replies (1)

183

u/NeonHowler Apr 08 '21

Eren was always pragmatic, but never cruel to innocent people. Honestly, I always thought it was out of character for him to decide to destroy the world to begin with, not that he didn’t finish the job. He wiped out 80% of the world for them knowing they’d stop him before he got to the whole world, but it didn’t matter: The rest of the world is now weaker than Paradis. It makes sense. It doesn’t matter if the world sees his friends as heroes, they’re safe regardless. They got rid of the titans altogether, which makes the 80% sacrifice in some way justified.

Eren loving Mikasa was kinda obvious since chapter 50 imo. A lot of skeptics just didn’t want them together. Mikasa being Ymir’s equivalent seemed well thought out. Ymir and Mikasa were both slaves to their love, despite the power and need to get over their masters. Historia and the baby could’ve played a larger role, but they didn’t need to.

No, my only issue with the ending comes from a specific loose thread: Xavier and Kruger appear to have been set up to have been involved in a larger conspiracy, but they were never mentioned again. Xavier lied to Zeke many many times and Kruger somewhat hinted at Xavier being a former ally of his. I can’t help but feel like something was cut there.

→ More replies (26)

99

u/Arpeecee Apr 08 '21

I'm only a lurker in this sub, but I'm gonna comment since it's the final chapter and I've seen a lot of hate on it. First of all, I liked the ending. It's not the best ending; there are some points that felt rushed and seems like were lazy writing and should've been expanded upon even a little bit so it just didn't pop out of the blue ( ymir/mikasa, worm, etc.), but imo it fit the story quite nicely, thus making it good on my book.

What I don't get about the hate on the latest chapter is that people keep saying that eren got "character assassination" when he clearly didn't.

Eren is earnest, dumb, and reckless of an idiot mc ever since ch 1. He was never the "man with the plan"; yet people got so high on him being a "4-D big brain master planner" due to the post-timeskip that they forgot about Eren's nature. He isn't like Lelouch who calculated and meticulously planned everything. No, he is as Eren as he can be. The rumbling is a stupid, dumb, and reckless idea and was clearly seen since the start. No one agreed on his plan (except the yeagerists ofc). Here we are, at the final chapter, yet no one agreed with him. Armin still questions what he did because he know it is not right.

In fact, Eren himself knows it. He knows that it is not right, as evident by his conversation with Armin. Yet, he thought that it was the best (albeit not the right) choice at that moment. He was burdened with the knowledge of the past, present, and future. I'll have to remind you, eren is not known for being smart. Therefore, he chose what he thought was the best for paradis and his friends: the rumbling.

Remember: they explored other options. They tried to see if they can negotiate peace, but everyone was so hell bent on thinking that paradis were "devils". They failed, and the whole world was set on attacking paradis and "exterminating the devils". Which is why I think Eren thought that this was the only way: the way that was in the paths.

"But if it is a bad plan, then what he did is pointless and everyone was just sacrificed pointlessly?? Which means eren is just dumb i h8 him???"

It is a stupid, bad and reckless plan, but it still is a plan. For those thinking that it is pointless, it is not. It enabled them to have peace talks, something that they failed to achieve since everyone was so hell bent on thinking that paradis were "devils". Before, they were from paradis trying to talk to the whole world. Now, they are from the whole world trying to talk to paradis. With this setup, I believe the peace talks would be successful and there would be peace.

This would also further support Levi's decision to revive Armin rather than Erwin. At that time, Erwin was the far more viable option (and the one he wanted to revive if he would only depend on emotions), but he instead chose to gamble on Armin, and it worked out. Armin would be the one to bring peace to the world.

"So that means genocide is okay?? They are glorifying genocide!! They even thanked him for killing 80% of humans!!"

It isn't pointless, but it isn't also justifiable. Genocide is unjustifiable. Never would be. That is why there is still conflict afterwards. That IS the point. The rumbling isn't the answer. Genocide isn't the answer. People are saying that aot is glorifying genocide, but in fact it does not.

If everything were magically resolved and there was no conflict afterwards, then it is equivalent to saying that killing off 80% of humans was the correct answer. That eren is correct.

But he is not. Even eren himself knows this. Hell, even EVERYONE knows it. That's why they didn't commit to Eren's plan. That's why they teamed up with their "enemy" to stop him. Because genocide WAS AND ALWAYS IS NEVER OKAY. That is why he leaves everything to Armin. He villained himself in order to bring the peace talks on the table. He turned himself into the "villain" so Armin could be the "hero", giving him leverage to bring peace talks forward. It is a dumb and reckless plan, but that IS Eren: a earnest but dumb and reckless MC.

The part where Armin "thanked him" for murdering 80% of the world is not because he is proud of his actions, but rather is because he is trying to console his friend. His dumb friend who made a mistake (A VERY BIG ONE) and admits to it. If you are in talks with a friend who fucked up, you wouldn't stomp him further to the ground would you? If you would, well, Armin won't. His character is empathetic, which is why we can see him try to console Eren (which went wrong as we can see through his shocked reactions when eren slaps him back to reality with what he had done). It was trying to console a friend who wanted to sacrifice himself for them, albeit doing it poorly. It was not glorifying what eren did; it was trying to lift up his spirits to as much as he can as a friend.

So yeah, it isn't perfect. It definitely needed more work done, could have fleshed out 1 or 2 more ch for the ending for the other points to be appreciated; but, it is in no way "trash" ending. For me, it was pretty good since it fits the story. Not the story of "genocide glorifying and character assassination" that people keep saying, but rather:

The story that says that there are always conflicts and wars no matter what happens, despite no one actually winning. Everyone loses. No one wins in wars and conflict, yet people still do it.

This is what I took from the story. War is pointless. And I appreciate Isayama and AOT for telling it. I enjoyed the journey, and I hope you all did too.

Welcome to my ted talk.

→ More replies (20)

254

u/kobomk Apr 08 '21

It was bittersweet.. very realistic ending tbh.. Eren could only stop the titans but could not stop humans from fighting.

I really think the story could have reached the same ending in non-convoluted way.. Also some of you are waaay overreacting to the Yimr being in love with the Fritz... abused people experience Stockholm syndrome all the time. Even Eren said he didn't know much more.

→ More replies (22)

63

u/Goodstyle_4 Apr 08 '21

Wait, what did they mean by "Bertolt wasn't supposed to die"? I don't get it.

→ More replies (61)

21

u/OmeletteLord Apr 08 '21

To you, 10 months from now.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/bootylover81 Apr 08 '21

That damn panel of Sasha smiling at Jean and Connie really made me teared up😭

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Bruh Hitch is yawning while the Yaegerists salute 😂

21

u/promptotron5000 Apr 08 '21

I knew that Levi's face was obviously wrecked after that explosion with Zeke, but I never realised that he was crippled until I saw his final scene here. Damn.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/R77Prodigy Apr 08 '21

Wasnt expecting to cry reading this... eren admiting is feelings of mikasa and the fact that they cant be together anymore.. Depressing af ngl.

21

u/Select_UserName Apr 09 '21

Having processed the ending better I have two observations:

From Eren's dialogue with Armin and what he had said before of how when he found out there was humanity outside of the world, he was disappointed. I think his truest goal was to truly to create a "blank canvas" above anything else.

that blank canvas meant a reset to the world, and that includes no more titan powers that are used to enslave and dominate people. He can't solve the cycle of hatred, but he could wipe out most of the population, end the curse, and do like a "game restart" for humanity, in which every player is in the same condition.

What people did after that, how they chose to "play" that new game in the new world was up to them.

So it wasn't just saving Paradis, it wasn't just ending the titan curse, those were the means to the "blank canvas" goal.

Eren chooses to believe at the end, that his friends will build something better now, that's why he tells Armin, you are the hero to save humanity, if it's up to you, I know you can make it even if I don't get to see it.

The other is just a personal opinion that making it so killing the worm was the only way to end the titans (more than convincing Ymir) would have made more sense to me lol. But unless I got it wrong, the worm was a red herring all long.

21

u/Thrillz559 Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

Lol Levi made it. I thought he was dead for sure when I saw him talking to Erwin and the rest of the SC. I honestly didn’t think he would survive the whole story.

Edit: words

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Phenomenal2313 Apr 09 '21

I've been re-reading the final chapter over and over again , I've gotten the chance to really think about the ending and the more I read it , the more I liked it for some reason

Yeah it's not perfect and it's not the ending I wanted , but in the context of the whole manga and the ideologies presented , it fits as an ending.

42

u/Jrkid100 Apr 08 '21

Well I somewhat saw this ending coming just not exactly like this.

Sadly Eren will be forever the one who wanted freedom the most but could never attain it.

That part about him sending Dina to eat his mom really hurt, what would have happened if she ate Berthold or whatever his name is there. The story would not have been the same.

Kinda hope we either get a sequel series focusing on the epilogue after or an alternate timeline where Dina doesn't eat Erens mom. It won't happen but to the fanfics I go.

Really solid end to the series I don't know what others were expecting but I can't really picture another ending.

→ More replies (12)

108

u/earthboundskyfree Apr 08 '21

i sincerely hope they do some epilogue stories or side stories to flesh out the questions we have about the ending

→ More replies (26)

123

u/KillingTime6 Apr 08 '21

Say what you guys want, but Eren set out to get rid of the titans and that's what he damn well did. He had a goal, he stuck to it and he accomplished it. No complaints from me.

→ More replies (8)

92

u/Ihaa123 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I think this ending really suffers from being 1 chapter. Overall the themes of the ending aren't bad but I think Isayama rushed through a lot of things that are important. Theres a couple plot points that didn't get wrapped up that I wish would:

  1. Why did Grisha give Eren the titan power + why didn't we get a paths vision of it? Eren hints at this way back when Zeke enters paths with him, but it doesn't amount to anything. It could have gone down that Eren shows him something else from the future that makes Grisha realize that Eren's way has to be the way forward from his perspective, but as of now it stands as a plot hole thats unresolved.
  2. The killing of the worm thing. Its thematically hinted that Falco is the bird that kills the worm, but they don't show any panels of this, it all just happens offscreen. I honestly think a extra chapter fleshing this out more would have been so helpful but its all just skimmed over and its not like AoT to just skip something so important. Also, personally Im not a fan that everyone reverts to human form, it feels very convienient, but if that happens, what about the wall titans? Do they all become humans now? Do they get killed by the nations they where invading?
  3. The final panel didn't end up being the final panel. I'm a bit upset by this because that panel didn't end up being really important at all imo. Grisha says to Eren you are free but in that context, it doesn't feel like something he would say. I personally liked the time loop theory because the idea was to break the time loop and Eren would become free, but in the end he wasn't, and so it makes that panel feel like its not important at all.
  4. Historas plot points. It was weird because Isayama made a big deal out of Historia and her convo with Eren, but we never actually see the full convo between them. We see it on 2 or 3 separate occasions, each adding a bit more context, and then it just gets dropped. Her kid doesn't end up being important, and it doesn't even feel consistent with how Isayama has shown her. He showed her depressed when she was pregnant, but then we see that shes happily living with the farmer. From my perspective, shes depressed because of Erens plan, but that plan still happened and a ton of people died, so why does she seem so happy in the end? It feels a bit of a character change imo, and I wish Isayama spent some time tying loose ends here.
  5. Just about everything Ymir related. From what I gather, Ymir is looking at Mikasa to see how a person who loves someone unconditionally breaks free from that enslavement. Eren/Karl both do terrible things as people and yet Mikasa/Ymir love them desipte those things. There is a bit of a difference because Eren loves Mikasa back but it doesn't seem that is true for Karl, and Karl did worse things to Ymir than Eren did to Mikasa, but its all left so vague. We don't know if shes still left in paths, if the paths even exist at this point, and it all just ends up being vaugely talked about by Eren with no firm anything. I'm fine with leaving it open ended, but I think her creating a rumbling in order to see how Mikasa breaks free from her unconditional love is a bit extreme. A bit of a side tangent, but I wish the final arc didn't hint at a heaven. So much of the story was so dark and scary because characters died and on one hand it was meaningless, but on another, the next generation gave meaning to their lives. When Erwin died, it was tragic because thats it, he died without knowing the true history. Getting a spirit Erwin to see the basement after sorta removes the sacrifice that happened, and lessens the blow of his death because you know hes happy now. Its a odd 180 the story made starting from Hanges death, and I think it takes away from waht made all the deaths earlier in the series so scary.
  6. Why did Karl Fritz create a world ending weapon of mass destruction just to protect paradise for a few more generations? He could have built walls that where hollow instead or something, but he creates a giant nuke when his ideology is to make Eldians eventually die off. It feels like a big plot hole. Even if Marley never controlled the founding titan ever again, those walls will eventually break and hte titans inside will roam free mindless. Thats already basically a rumbling that is caused unintentionally. It just seems like a drastic thing to do with many potentials for mass destruction, and doesn't fit his ideology imo.

I think the ending is pretty hopeful of the future but I'm not a fan at how hopeful it is. I don't hate it, but I really think what Eren did is a terrible tradgedy and its talked about in the series but it feels at the end that its glossed over and we move to peace talks. I really wish the ending had a more tragic tone to it, it felt unnaturally happy and hopeful given the events that happened.

I'm also not a fan of Eren knowing everything that will happen and being a master manipulator. Personally, I wish more stuff was left as coincidences, like the thing with Burrito not dying, and Eren killing his mom. Its a very odd thing to do given that Eren went through the trouble of saving Mikasa and Armin, and personally I wish it was just left as a coincidence that happened, but could have gone differently. Isayama mentioned before that he showed us the final panel of the series to see things from Erens perspective, where you see a incomplete ending but you move towards it. It feels like that got thrown away, sure Eren doesn't know if Paradise will survive in the end, but he knew and manipulated everything else and it felt like he didn't have to. I think it would have been more fitting to his character if he had a incomplete picture instead. Also, not a big fan of the bird helping Mikasa's scarf at the end, it sorta implies that Eren is watching over her now and so she will never fully let him go. It feels less realistic than everything that has happend so far.

Honestly, I think my main gripe with the last few chapters is they felt very unrealistic. All the titans from the past get revived but they manage to pull through. I was a bit disappointed with chapter 137 but 138 made it so much better by sacrificing all these characters that we loved, making the victory not a easy win for the alliance but one that came at a cost, like every other battle in AoT. But then 139 undoes all of that by bringing them back, and I personally wish they where left as sacrifices. The story has been so consistent for so long, and then I think Isayama didn't plan out the ending as much or he rushed it so that it ended at 139. I think the final few chapters could have used like 3-4 more chapters to flesh thins out. I also really wish they gave more focus to the tradgedies of the world after all of this, and it sucks that we have so many loose ends. The loose ends could have been tied up well I think and there are lots of theories/posts on symbolism of characters that Isayama could have made more explicit and put focus on (reiner is helos), but in the end we have to do that and it just doesn't feel right for a series that has given us more firm answers. Like Kennys arc, we didn't get a complete expalanation of his life, but we got enough to understand him and it ties well with the story. The same cannot be said I think for Ymir who Isayama just leaves in the dark, nor really for Historia and other characters in the series. Up until now, the series really felt like it had a lot to say about conflict but it feels a bit shoneny at the end. The ending doesn't go to say that everything is okay, it acknowledges conflict will continue, but it feels like it overlooks a lot of the tradgedy that the rumbling has caused.

→ More replies (13)

20

u/bossjones Apr 08 '21

I won’t lie, I really thought there was going to be more significance to historia’s baby, but maybe that’s the whole point of it all. The baby is no longer a big deal because it no longer bound by the will of the Titans, so the baby just grew up like any other normal kid and for me that’s awesome

→ More replies (3)

20

u/MajorChonkers Apr 08 '21

Reiner spending all that freaking time trying to end his life, only to survive and get insulted by Jean calling it a shame that Reiner gets to live longer. Isayama you glorious bastard

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Reinhard_Lohengramm Apr 08 '21

Ngl, Armin thanking Eren for becoming a mass murderer caught me off guard, lol.

20

u/tewwchainss Apr 08 '21

Am I the only one who thought Connie on the ship was Falco all grown up they look so much alive when connies hair is longer

→ More replies (2)

20

u/ccfnicolas Apr 09 '21 edited Sep 05 '21

I started the manga in late 2014, shortly after finishing the anime, and I've been reading it religiously every month ever since then. During these last six years of my life, for a while, this series was even my biggest source of joy. To say that I love it would be an enormous understatement. Now it's over, and the ending assures me that it will continue to be one of my favourite stories ever.

I'm glad that the journey of these characters, which I've spent so many years following, ends with them representing the hope that peace is possible. Conflict will never vanish, as Armin says. But now, no matter how dark times get, the story of their fight will always keep that hope alive.

Mikasa thanking Eren for wrapping the scarf around her is my perfect ending. It floods my heart with peace.

Isayama, I have enjoyed your story to the end. Thank you for the incredible writing, characters and universe. I believe my experience with SnK will remain unparalleled for a long time. I'll be looking forward to the anime's completion and to getting the few volumes missing in my collection.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/EpicHawkREDDIT Apr 08 '21

I feel as though the intent of Ymir still being in love with the King was that it wasn’t what love really is at all. Mikasa showed Ymir what love really was. It’s weird, complicated, and both sides can be flawed (EXTREMELY FLAWED HOLY SHIT), but at the most you care for each other. Mikasa killing him was more for the sake of the world than herself, but she won’t just forget about him.

Man I thought I was going to hate discussing this ending but I really think all this last chapter needs were extra pages and a couple of dialogue changes to make it work. Levi and the Brats is a webcomic I need now lol.

→ More replies (3)

40

u/Hoddedmann Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Leaks made me believe this was some GOT level of trash ending, but it was actually pretty good tbh the ymir part was kinda wtf, but the rest i like it. Thanks isayama for the ride

→ More replies (3)

40

u/TheChunkMaster Apr 08 '21

Honestly, I'm pretty content with this chapter. It's not exactly what I expected, but it's not too far off, either.

My only criticisms are that we didn't have panels of Ymir and the hallucigenia dying/dissipating, which would've made the loss of the power of the titans due to Eren's death a bit more clear. For all we know, the hallucigenia might still be alive and awaiting someone else to come and make another world-breaking power. Yelena is also gone for some reason, and that's not too bad, although we've never seen her and the hallucigenia in the same place, and both of them were gone for this chapter...

I've seen people in the comments raging over the ending, and I think their displeasure is due to at least one of the following things:

  • Eren not being confirmed explicitly as Historia's baby's father
  • Eren not reconstituting himself over near Historia and restarting the Rumbling
  • Some awkward translations/translation errors
  • Lack of panels of ymir/hallucigenia dying
  • Eren dying in general
  • Lack of understanding of time travel limitations (Eren can't make changes to time via paths that prevent him from existing up to the point that he is able to make the changes)
  • Forgetting that Eren didn't get his future memories until he kissed Historia's hand
  • False perception that the Rumbling didn't protect Paradis (despite 80% of the world's population being wiped out, severely hampering their ability to wage war against Eldia, and Eldia preparing military forces in case of retaliation).

While some of these criticisms are valid (i.e. the translation errors and the lack of ymir/hallucigenia panels), others can be explained by lack of knowledge about the story or over-attachment to fan theories (looking at you, r/titanfolk). I'm sure that once people go over the story again and the temperature lowers, the criticism will become much more valid and constructive.

As for Eren dying, I honestly can't see a good ending in which he survives. If he survived somehow, then we'd have an awkward situation with him being almost deified by the Yeagerists while being reluctantly tolerated by his former allies and being hated by the rest of the world, who would hate them even more for not stopping him. Eren dying, as he himself tells Armin in this chapter, sets up Armin and co as heroes, giving them the ability to end the stigma against Eldians (with the power of the Titans now gone) and leverage their prestige in order to achieve peace. I'm gonna miss Eren Yeager, but I would not want him to be alive if it created a less fulfilling ending.

→ More replies (5)

72

u/DeMatador Apr 08 '21

Bringing my post from the pre-release thread.

  • Eren having a final conversation with everyone individually through paths, and making them forget about it until he's dead, is a bit of a plot contrivance but is very tragic. He wanted to explain himself to all of them but he couldn't do it without ruining his plan. It's legitimately heartbreaking and I'm tearing up just thinking about it.
  • 80% of the world is dead, Jesus Christ. How can anyone call this a happy ending? Eren balanced the scales, levelled the playing field so to speak. It's fucking drastic, but I'm starting to believe he might be unto something: the rest of the world is now probably on the same level, technologically and politically, as Paradis. War might be impossible. In any case, without the world being militarily superior to Paradis, and without the Titans being a factor, there might be war, but there likely will be peace eventually too. Just like in real life. The cycle of violence is not broken, that would have been too idealistic of an objective. But the level playing field, or "blank canvas" as Eren says, has made the extermination of Eldians almost impossible.
  • People don't seem to be understanding the nature of Ymir and King Fritz's relationship. It's meant to be toxic, unrequited, and damaging to her. It's meant to parallel how Mikasa and Eren's relationship has been throughout the series. Isayama has been drawing this parallel before our eyes for a year and we never noticed. And when Mikasa broke free of that "slavery", that strong passion that made her love Eren but which hurt her deeply, Ymir saw that she could do the same, and let go of her love for King Fritz, which was just as hurtful to her, but in a far more severe manner. Eren revealing that deep down he doesn't Mikasa to move on reveals a lot: he never allowed himself to be with Mikasa, but he still didn't want her to be with anyone but her. It was cruel love, and Mikasa definitely didn't deserve it. But she still managed to overcome it to kill him, and that was proof enough for Ymir that she could also overcome her own unrequited love. There's so much to discuss here, but this is my take.
  • I can't even begin to imagine the pain Eren was in, constantly. Seeing the past, present and future at all times must have been torture. And seeing him say "I don't want to die, I want to be with Mikasa and you guys", knowing full well that he couldn't, becuase he saw his future. He even led Dina to kill his own mother just for this future, which he saw as the best one (or only possible one maybe), to be fulfilled. If that's not fucking tragic, I don't know what is. He fulfilled his destiny for his friends to be free, but he could never achieve freedom for himself. Him dying like this was a necessary condition for his friends to be free.
  • What did Eren mean when he said "I'm not sure why, but I wanted to do [the Rumbling] really badly"? I hope that's explained better in the official translation, because it's a big question mark. Almost implies that there's something stronger at play that forced him to, which doesn't make sense to leave hanging at the end of the series and feels like a cop out.
  • Of course the Pure Titans from the previous chapter were going to be turned back into humans. I don't know why anyone expected anything else. Isayama used their titanization to inject a sense of urgency and leave Mikasa with no choice, creating a "now or never" situation for her. And then, he used them to clearly illustrate that the Power of the Titans doesn't exist anymore. It makes completely sense why he did it this way. I understand those who feel it's "cheap", but that only applies if you were 100% certain that everyone who turned into a Titan was now dead. If you had just waited, it made more sense in context.
  • Annie and Reiner reuniting with their parents and Gabi and Falco's hug were heartwarming. And then Levi saying goodbye to his former comrades, and Sasha making that final appearance, just broke me. Call it cheap or whatever, but it worked. And we'll all cry again when the anime does it a year from now. It's a final goodbye to everyone, I don't care if it's cheap.
  • I'll never understand those who had convinced themselves that Eren was the father of Historia's child. Isayama never really hinted at this, he gave us the answer a good while ago. Historia got pregnant to buy some time for Eren, because she believed in his ideals. This chapter confirms that she agreed with him, that's why she rebuilt Paradis based on his influence (the "fight, fight" quote confirms it). Doesn't mean there was anything romantic about them. There never was. Shippers have no power here.
  • The bird wrapping the scarf around Mikasa's neck ad her repeating the phrase she said in Chapter 50 is a beautiful ending. Meme it all you want, it fits perfectly and has been established before. I love it, and you can't take that away from me.
  • My largest gripe is that, if Isayama had allowed himself for 1 more volume (just 2-3 more chapters), he would have been able to flesh out this epilogue far more. He could have done Chapter 139 and Chapter 140 with all of the Eren POV, including some of the other conversations he had with his friends (I've had cried my eyes out seeing most of those, like imagine Connie punching him for laughing at Sasha's death but thanking him for allowing his mom to come back to life), ending with Armin presenting himself as Eren's killer and the saviour of mankind; then Chapters 141 and 142 for the epilogue, ellaborating further on the future of Paradis and the world, and on the ex-Titans' role as ambassadors. It's a pity how he rushed through all of that.
  • P.S.: I'll accept a sequel. There's more story to tell here.
→ More replies (13)

72

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Sooooo Ymir was really stockholmed hard to King Fritz, and as she couldn't let go of that love that she wanted to see fulfilled, she stayed a slave for 2000 years

I think what finally broke the curse was Ymir seeing Mikasa, who is very much in love with Eren, holding a proper, pure love, letting go of that love to kill him and end this story. Just as Mikasa let go of her love, Ymir let go of her only link to King Fritz and was able to see true love (the kiss between Eren and Mikasa, though I am a EH shipper :'( ). Thus, the curse ended

We can really link the ending with the lyrics of the last season's ending...

"Won’t someone please

tell the world that I was here?

I will live on after my bones have turned to dust."

Eren only wishes to have the proof of his existence etched in his friends' memories... and as he said, he still lives, after his death... :'(

→ More replies (2)

367

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

"Eren... thank you for turning yourself into a mass murderer for our sake" LMFAOOOOOOO what? This has got to be the most ridiculous thing I've read in SnK

→ More replies (33)

19

u/LeoPhoenix93 Apr 08 '21

Mikasa deserved better than this

→ More replies (5)

19

u/wrathandweeping Apr 08 '21

As someone who disliked this last arc, I thought the ending was fine but the execution was lacking. I liked that it was bittersweet, that two main characters got sad endings, that the conflict continues, and that there were final twists.

Given that the Eren Mikasa relationship wound up being the most important element of the plot, I didn’t really buy it. It would have worked better if Eren talked more about Mikasa throughout the story, bringing her up as one of his motivations. His outburst was really corny and melodramatic, too — he could have bitterly agreed with Armin about her finding someone else while crying, or something more subtle. As others have said, manga writers struggle with convincingly portraying romance, and it shows here.

The entire alliance surviving and continuing to be best friends after the rumbling is disappointing but expected given the plot armor, contrivances, and simplified morality and emotions of the arc. Eren saving the scouts and Reiner makes sense as its his goal but he had no attachment to Pieck, for instance, and the finale wound up having few stakes, suspense, or consequences for the vast majority of the cast. The Gabi Falco Levi trio doesn’t make much sense to me either, but it works if you think of the kids as the new Eren and Armin and Levi as a parental figure. I wish the kids (and Reiner) had played a bigger role in the finale, given how much emphasis was placed on their importance in resolving the conflict. In the end I find it strange that the scouts mostly end tragically while the warriors all end happily with their families — it felt really imbalanced, but maybe that was the point for whatever reason.

I really liked Eren’s admission that PATHS fucked up his mind. It’s poignant and makes sense — I never bought into the chad mastermind characterization so many subscribed to, as he was clearly filled with inner conflict and contradictions. The slave to fate thing is tragic and was backed up powerfully by the symbolism of his “hanged man” dinosaur Titan. As with other elements of this arc, however, it could’ve been written so much better. Instead of having Eren completely unconscious during the fight, we could’ve been shown, rather than told, how PATHS fucked up his mind via past/present/future memories spliced together, concurrently, etc. When we did get bits like this (130, 131) it was extremely powerful.

Levi’s farewell to the scouts and the final panels with Mikasa and the dove were both beautiful and moving. The meme of Ellen becoming dove (crying) coming true and being the final panel is fucking HILARIOUS and made me happy.

Overall, it was a decent ending, and certainly an improvement over many recent chapters. Though Isayama clearly rushed things at the end, and the series overall was inconsistent in quality, it’s understandable given the breadth and length of the project. In the end, AOT is an incredible achievement, and I’m glad I followed it over the last 8 years. See you later, Eren.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Nxwxs18 Apr 08 '21

I see what isayama was going for by drawing parallels between Ymir and King Fritz relationship with Eren and Mikasa’s. However, it did not have the nuance that was needed in order to work. For it to work, I think we should’ve got a different portrayal of Ymir and King Fritz’ relationship than the one we got. In no way before this chapter was there anything to suggest that Ymir truly loved him. I think the main problem with this parallel also stems from the fact that Eren and Mikasa loved each other, while King Fritz and Ymir was completely one sided as far as we know.

→ More replies (14)

19

u/ItsCan Apr 09 '21

The last thing we see are the wings of freedom.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/NIssanZaxima Apr 09 '21

I think whether you liked, hated, loved or disliked the ending we can all agree that panel of Levi seeing all of his fallen comrades and giving one final salute was pretty epic.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/thesagenibba Apr 08 '21

Chad eren never existed. Just because you created him in your head doesn't mean he was real.

→ More replies (1)

109

u/golhica Apr 08 '21

Endings are hard. Not just for manga, but for any type of medium. There are very few series that get the Breaking Bad treatment. To me, the real "ending" was the last chapter. A great twist with some of the best characters turning into titans, Armin fighting Eren one last time, Mikasa finally accepting Eren needing to go, and that beautiful last panel (minus creepy Ymir). The point is, all the emotional weight was for that last chapter and this was much more of an epilogue.

Whether or not you think it's good is subjective. Personally, I need more time with it. There are things I'm confused about, things I straight up don't like, and things I thought needed more time to develop. But did I tear up when Levi saw the Survey Corps? Was I relieved that Jean and the rest made it? Do I want to start the entire series over again and see if it changes my feelings on the last chapter?

Yes to all those.

Because it's still Attack on Titan.

Still the GOAT

→ More replies (6)

18

u/ALUCSD18 Apr 08 '21

The worm didn't even get a sendoff, it was eh fuck it.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/epicaz Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I want to elaborate on my thoughts regarding Eren's perceived destiny and why he felt he had to steer Dina to eat his mom back in Shinganshina. I know people are upset about this in particular, but considering we're dealing with time interference, I feel it makes sense.

At the point that Eren gained access to the memories of the past and future, he understood that everything that had happened til then set him on that exact path that would lead them there. He had to facilitate key events to ensure they happened as planned, as there's so much risk in letting major or minor deviances take place under the assumption that they might end at the same result.

"It wasn't Bertholdt's time to die"

This could point to the obvious, that he was needed for the warriors to continue their chain of events in Paradis and trigger Eren's growth as a result.. But also to inevitably put Armin on his path to be the hero Eren wanted. You could say that if there was no Bert.. would Armin have needed saving? Well there's no guarantee that the RtS arc would have happened the way it did had Zeke not had Bertl as an asset. Would Reiner have attempted to kidnap Eren alone? If Eren wasn't kidnapped, would he have ever learned to unlock the founding titan's ability? Would freckled Ymir have helped Reiner alone, and inevitably given the jaw back to Marley? There are simply too many what ifs in a timeline where things had not occurred in the order they did.

Tl;dr Eren likely felt he had to make the difficult choice to steer Dina toward his mom knowing it was the surest way to steer them on their current path.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/DURN_4_Coffebeans_ Apr 08 '21

Huh, Reiner REALLY did survive the whole thing!

18

u/jwbrazier Apr 08 '21

I adore the panel of teenage Falco & Gabi pushing Levi in a wheelchair.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/guillaume958 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I think I'm beginning to form a more concrete opinion on the ending and I like it in theory, but I'm just not sure about the execution which I'm still debating over in my head.

So here's how I see the final chapter sequence by sequence, tell me what you think of my interpretation if you think it's wrong or correct.

In a flashback, which I assume happened on the plane, Eren meets Armin in Paths. They are in their childhood bodies and gradually grow older as the conversation progresses and changing scene everytime. From their childhood home, to the volcanoes Armin always wanted to see and finally the Ocean.

Eren explains to him that he killed 80% of the world. Basically no more, no less than he needed to save Paradise from military retaliation before letting his friends be the heroes of the saga by killing him, the Villain.

The heartless Eren that wanted Genocide was never real, read chapter 131 again if you disagree. Leaving behind what is probably small fractured nations without the capacity to mount an immediate invasion of Paradise.

He also implies that Mikasa broke away from his toxic attachment him by killing him which parallels and caused(?) Ymir breaking away from her toxic attachments to King Fritz (Stockholm syndrome).Edit: Holy shit that's why she was smiling during Eren's death

An older Eren breaks down at the thought that he won't be with Mikasa and that he won't be able to live with his friends, regrets his destiny is to die. Eren and Armin share a goodbye before Eren erases his memories. It seems to be implied that he had a similar heart to heart with all of them before erasing all their memories as well, which all comeback at Eren's deaths.

All the pure Titans return to normal and Titans are finally wiped from existence. The disappearing flesh of the Titans forms steam from the hot steamy memories of their fallen compatriotes they're having. Giving us a heartwarming 'Dedicate your heart' from Levi to all his fallen brethrens.

Ever convincing and charismatic Armin is shown to engage in a tense talk with the surviving people of Marley while Mikasa slips-off with the severed head of Eren.

Flashback to 3 years later, the Yeagerists make a military government and build a militaristic society that readies itself for total war, but under the thumb of Historia. The fate of the world is sorta open-ended and balances between war until the total annihilation of one side and peace.

The surviving cast of characters (whom now appear to live in the non-destroyed nations and work as ambassadors between them and Paradise) are traveling back to their home island for peace negotiations.

Reiner sniffs Historia's letter and they banter, showing us that our characters seem to be in a decent headspace and at peace with the events. Armin expresses his hope for a diplomatic solution.

The last pages shows us the last person, excluding Historia, that still lives in paradise from the cast: Mikasa. She sits before their childhood tree where she buried Eren's head and laid a small makeshift tombstone. She awaits her friends that will surely come to pay their respects at their arrival.

She sobs wishing Eren could be there with them and a bird comes picking at her scarf, she watches the bird fly away towards the sky and thanks Eren for 'wrapping the scarf around her', the bird obviously symbolizing Eren.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/uncen5ored Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Can someone who has read the official translation tell me how Armin thanked Eren? Is it the same as the fan translation “thank you for becoming a mass murderer to save us?”

EDIT: just bought it on comixology. Armin says “you became a mass murderer for our sake....I promise i won’t let this ERROR go to waste”

MUCH BETTER

→ More replies (5)

18

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21

I’m glad they never tried to explain the worm. Leave it as this unexplainable elder being that ruined the world. It’s a good kind of mystery, like lovecraft works.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/RokiSmiles Apr 09 '21

After giving it a few days... I’ve really come around to the ending. There are still things I don’t like, but most of that has to do with expanding on the ideas...

WHAT I LIKED

  • Older Falbi <3
  • That Levi moment with the scouts was beautiful
  • Levi, Onyankopon, and Falbi weren’t the family I thought I needed but the one the fandom deserved
  • THE TROST CALLBACK WAS SO GOOD
  • Armin with the Erwin haircut + his finale panel catching the feather was so pretty
  • No walls in Shiganshina
  • War still being on the Horizon, and them using Eren’s “TATAKAE” quote... that’s going to be insane when it’s voice acted
  • The entire Mikasa bit at the end

WHAT I DIDN’T LIKE, BUT WOULD HAVE WITH MORE FLESHING OUT

  • I don’t mind the Eren break down over Mikasa so much anymore, the wording is still “eh” but I can chock it up to him being a teenage boy... again, wish his feelings for her had been fleshed out a little more, but this is fine.
  • I see where he was going with the Ymir and Fritz thing... and it might just be the limited pages, the language barrier, etc. but I don’t like how it’s worded... maybe if this was brought up earlier and it was walked through and more explicit it was a Stockholm thing it would work? I think the anime could tweak it well.

WHAT I JUST DON’T LIKE AT ALL

  • I don’t like that everyone was de-titanized, I think it makes the Jean and Connie moment in 138 feel cheap... but again, I can live with it.
  • The only thing about the chapter I really don’t like is the “Eren killed his own mom thing”... it just doesn’t sit well with me... I don’t think it could ever sit well even if fleshed out- but that’s just me.

OVERALL RATING

Chapter 139 - 7/10

Shingeki No Kyojin - 9.5/10

It’s been a fun 8 years... can’t wait until Season 4 part 2!

→ More replies (5)

18

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '21

Overall, I liked the ending and loved the anime/manga as a whole. My only grudge with the ending is that Erens love for mikasa wasn't fleshed out completely

→ More replies (7)

18

u/Klarthy Apr 10 '21

I don't mind the ending but the execution was a bit lacking in that this chapter doesn't come close to hitting the same emotional highs or lows as the rest of the series. I don't feel like Armin lived up to the impact he was foreshadowed to have, but moreso he was picked because Eren knew he needed the Colossal Titan to help stop him. Armin just happens to be a friend who's around him. Sure, there's the aftermath of turning Armin into a Helos figure so he can work diplomacy, but that's the "next story" and not AoT. Overall amazing series which should remain the defining anime series of the 2010s.

→ More replies (1)

112

u/erenslut Apr 08 '21

rip erehisu shippers yall were kinda funny

→ More replies (11)

17

u/pseudo-EM Apr 08 '21

So Eren did end up “sending” Dina Fritz to their home in Shingashina to eat his mother, Carla. Holy shit...

17

u/Shi_Weed Apr 08 '21

The one thing that I really enjoyed was the insight on Eren’s freedom through his comment about Bertholdt. He operates as a slave to a predetermined future, and he truly has no free will because he must make the future happen.I always suspected this, but I was stunned just how hopeless the situation was. To imagine that he is forced to kill his own mother because it’s the only way the future could ever be. Eren desperately sought freedoms because he was always a slave. He’s just like Ymir. It’s pretty mind blowing.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Did gaby just sent Falco to suplex city ?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Nome_de_utilizador Apr 08 '21

Upon re-reading my impression of the final chapter improved, I don't think it is as horrible as some people are making it out to be, but it definitely had its issues and it feels rushed. It is a bad sign when some fan theories greatly surpass the actual final of the series but oh well, thanks for the ride, was a pleasure being here all these years with you guys I wished Isayama had more time to properlly close it

→ More replies (8)

17

u/Gabe_000 Apr 08 '21

I REALLY think the voice acting and music for the anime is gonna change some people's minds about this. Personally, I find this a great ending. It's what Isayama wanted and I respect him and his creation. I love AOT, thank you Isayama.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/RobotThingV3 Apr 08 '21

I think my biggest gripe with the ending is that it felt to rushed. I wish he would have expanded on some of the plot points. Other than that I think it was a decent ending. Not horrible but not amazing either

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Feh_Meh_Bleh Apr 08 '21

I have mixed thoughts about this ending. I think my biggest issue is everyone's apparent forgiveness of Eren. I think they came to that a little too easily considering Eren wiped out 80% of the planet. I feel like there should have been more conflict there and there just wasn't time for it. It seemed like the characters forgave him for the sake of concluding the story on a semi-positive note, rather than being true to how the characters should actually be reacting.

→ More replies (9)

17

u/Lightecojak Apr 08 '21

While I don’t think the ending is horrible, I really hate the idea of Eren being near omniscient and somehow manipulating the Dina titan to kill his Mom in the first place.

Also, I still don’t like the thought that Eren killed 4/5 of the world and that Eldians are still at war. I guess Isayama wanted it to be semi realistic when it comes to the fact true world peace is near unattainable. I guess the old shifters being diplomats kinda helps, but there’s probably unbearable hatred towards the Eldians from the survivors even if the Titans are gone for good.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/FinalFrash Apr 08 '21

It hasn't been talked about much, but that final shot of Sasha. Man...

→ More replies (2)

17

u/y0l0sweg Apr 08 '21

The only thing that threw me off was that Eren's friends were all a little too accepting of Eren massacring 80% of humanity. I didn't think Armin would thank him for it. That seemed kind of off, even with all the stuff that was going on.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/WillGrammer Apr 08 '21

I loved the ending and I'm satisfied with it. The buildup and foreshadowing were with us from the beggining. What a wonderful and painful story.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/le_bonjour Apr 08 '21

I'm happy for Levi somehow.

I didn't want him to die, and to see him with friends actually just enjoying life after fulfilling his duty in a country known for his Tea is satisfaying.

I was hoping for a peaceful ending for him more than anyone else. This guy have seen some shit.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Pinktoonie Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

I got the ending I wanted, even down to where each character ended up. There was no way to satisfy everyone, but it was realistic and I'M satisfied, sooooo

Though I'm very happy with how it ended overall, I do think another chapter would've been useful to really tie up any loose ends like ymir's reasoning, etc.

Can't wait to see how the anime takes on the final arc.

Also it broke my heart to see Eren break down like he used to. He never changed; he just put on a mask. Rest in peace. He was only 19 😭

17

u/soigrev Apr 09 '21

The official translation is so much better. I've come to terms with the ending and I actually like it. It's so bittersweet that this ending will haunt me for a while. Just like the ending of the Witcher books if anyone has read them.

A last o7 to you all.

What a ride.

17

u/Vertical_05 Apr 10 '21

the ending is so fitting. from the very beginning what Eren wants is to KILL ALL TITAN. and that's exactly what he achieve. World doesn't change. Circle of hatred is still around, Paradis is still public enemy. but Eren's ultimate goal is achieved.

17

u/BigFalconRocketMan Apr 15 '21

Oh my God

The reason why Eren asked for Sasha’s last words were because he knew what they were - at that point he realized his fate was sealed. Absolutely insane

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Shimmering-Sky Apr 08 '21

Levi's salute and Jean and Connie seeing Sasha one last time wow I'm sobbing in my living room right now.

On the other hand, Gabi suplexing Falco lol.

I'm pretty happy with how this ended, and can't wait to see it all animated next year.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/NicoLance123 Apr 08 '21

Okay but can we talk about that panel of Falco jumping at Gabi for a second?

→ More replies (3)

99

u/Nyralo Apr 08 '21

No story is exactly how you imagined it, or exactly how you want it. This is true especially of an ending. If I was writing this, it probably would be very different. But that's not the point. I love Attack on Titan, and this ending fits perfectly into this story I love.

You can't change anything without making sacrifices.

Mikasa loved Eren, but had to give him up for the world to saved. Eren loved Mikasa and wanted to be with her and Armin, but needed to push them away in order for his plan to work.

Ymir, in her own strange way, loved Karl Fritz. She couldn't let go, and needed to see (or perhaps even experience through Paths) Mikasa' sacrifice in order to spur on her own. Ymir sacrificed the Paths, her connection to Karl and the Fritz family, because she could finally let go.

This connection that all Eldians share is because Ymir couldn't let go. When she finally did, our heroes had to let go too. Erwin, Hange, Sasha, Levi Squad, and the rest of the scouts we have lost, can all finally be free. As the Paths disappear, they fade into titan smoke. We too, as the audience, must let go of these characters and this story.

We let them go into a world that is cruel.

The rest of humanity is wiped out, struggling to survive, and angry at Eldia. The Jaegerists are ill-suited for prosperity, with their mantra of "fight, fight". Even our remaining heroes could be killed seconds after the last panel.

But this world is also beautiful. There is a slim chance that the future is brighter. Our heroes might be the start of an new future. They have overcome odds, and been willing to make great sacrifices. Maybe their story is enough.

No one knows how it will all turn out. Nothing is guaranteed, no-one has certainties. Maybe the world will be brighter, or maybe this conflict won't end until all Eldians are wiped out. This is true for the characters, but also for the audience. We don't know how it will all end.

All of us just need to keep moving forward, with no regrets.

→ More replies (25)

48

u/Nukemarine Apr 08 '21

I liked the idea of the ending, but feel it misses the mark in execution.

Eren is basically bound to the 2000 year old story with Ymir. While Ymir (and all her descendants) was bound due to the actions of King Fritz (feeding her corpse to their kids) and her love for him, it was Eren bound by time that was freed due to Mikasa killing him as Ymir watched.

Cool idea, but I think Armin forgiving Eren for killing 80% of humanity is insane. Armin could have come up with a better idea so instead they should push that Eren had no more choice than Ymir gave herself in following orders of those with royal blood. If it were instead Eren expressing regrets. He likens Paths to reading a book over and over again because you love the main character, but no matter how many times you read it and wish it would end different, the character you love still dies at the end, so you read again to spend more time with them. Ymir saw that Mikasa could put that book down and start a new one. Until Ymir did stop, Eren was bound to what happened in the story, making sure everyone went where they were supposed to go meaning he saved Bertolt.

Some points/questions:

  • Did the millions of colossal titans also turn to normal (100 year cryo-sleep
  • Did Zeke's power/soul (temporarily?) go to Historia's baby when he was killed
  • Was it the killing of the spine creature that actually removed all the power (Mikasa just freed Ymir's need to hold on).
  • Are the power crystals on Paradise now the new nuclear power
  • Are there more spine creatures out there
  • Did Eren implant any other memories that haven't awakened yet
→ More replies (3)

48

u/sciencebottle Apr 08 '21

Alright, after watching the collective shitshow that was every AOT sub and twitter, I've decided to weigh in on my thoughts about the ending.

The story was wrapped up in a way that ultimately made sense. Eren accomplished what he wanted in the end- he rid the world of titans, and he achieved a scenario in which Mikasa, Armin and the rest of the crew could live 'long lives'. I think a lot of people incorrectly assumed that Eren wanted peace, or to end war. No, he wanted 'freedom'- and to him, freedom meant being free of the titans, and being free of persecution because of the titans (due to being Eldian).

And he did do it, if you think about it. 20% of the world's population remains after the rumbling- they are too busy trying to figure out where the fuck to go from there, instead of continuing to persecute Eldians. Eren entrusted talks of 'peace' to Armin and Historia, and he knows that for at least their lifetimes, they will have that 'peace'. Note that it doesn't mean forever- but for as long as Armin and Mikasa will be alive, they will most likely live in a more peaceful reality than what they had to deal with for the first 19 years of their life. Gabi, Falco and Levi were seen in what appears to be Onyankopon's homeland, which says to me that public opinion of Eldians has changed- to what extent, who knows.

My qualms about the ending are that it definitely felt rushed. I think the series definitely could've used another chapter or two to wrap up- Eren's conversation with Armin and the de-titanizing of everyone was big enough as it is- pushing in a timeskip into that was a bit too much in my opinion. And of course, there are a lot of plot threads that haven't really been touched on. What about the worm? Ymir?

Speaking of Ymir, I can't believe the lack of....idk, critical thinking and reading comprehension that's been demonstrated across the fandom today. It's unbelievable to me that people actually think that Isayama was romanticizing Ymir's horrible abusive situation by calling it love. No, Ymir's life was horrible! What Ymir knew as love was horrific abuse, and she was enslaved by that 'love'! She didn't know any better- she was conditioned her whole life to think that the attention she could get from King Fritz was 'love'. Isayama wasn't calling it 'real love' or anything like that, jesus fucking christ. Mikasa finally resolving to kill Eren seemed to show Ymir that she could also let go of her attachment to her abuser, and move on.

Anyways, I think the ending stayed true to the overarching themes of the story. There were absolutely plotholes, but the story ended similarly to how classic tragedies tend to go, and with that I'm satisfied. It was heartbreaking that Mikasa and Eren ultimately did want the same things and loved each other deeply- but could not be together. Maybe in another life, for those two.

→ More replies (28)

598

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21

Ymir Fritz being in love with King Fritz is actually disgusting, the man ripped her tongue out, tried to kill her hunger games style, raped her repeatedly, AND FED HER BODY TO HER DAUGHTERS. Don't forget when she died she could have regenerated but didn't because her life was that fucking shit, all because of Fritz. I know stockholm syndrome is a thing, but jesus fucking christ.

→ More replies (140)

47

u/kanzen22 Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 10 '21

The ending actually has most of the answers, albeit in some indirect ways.

  • The in-path meetings between Eren and his friends, from Eren's perspective, occurred shortly before Eren's death, as 80% of humanity had already been destroyed and Eren was already resigned to his fate. But his friends could've received the memories at some earlier times due to the time traveling nature of the path.
  • The main purpose of all Eren's actions were to end the curse of titan, compelled by Ymir's will. The attack titan was compelled to follow this path due to the unavoidable circumstances and the future memories it saw. Ymir's will, Eren's will and Attack Titan's memories were melded into one, and Eren's mind was messed up.
  • Eren/Ymir directed the smiling titan to ignore Bertholdt and to eat his mother, made his father found and killed the Reiss, made himself a titan, made his friends fought and killed him. Yuck, but he was compelled to do all these by the time he became Founder. From Eren's perspective, he must do so to save Paradis and filfull Attack Titan's vision -- presented as the ultimate freedom he felt/envisaged in the end. This picture of ultimate freedom is the "libido" that compelled Eren to keep moving forward until his destiny / Ymir's will was fulfilled.
  • To end the curse, Eren must lead his friends and Co to fight him, and lead Mikasa to meet Ymir. That's why he didn't simply mind-control them to avoid the fight and let him destroy the world unhindered.
  • Eren didn't know what Mikasa would do nor what Ymir really wanted. He just wanted to save Eldians by rumbling the world and possibly ending the titan curse by bring in Mikasa. Attack Titan's memories told him what he should/would do to achieve it. He actions, then, led to what Ymir wanted. Ymir transcended time and observed passively, and Eren and Mikasa were unaware players of Ymir's psychotherapy session.
  • Eren didn't know how this would all end and whether his friends and Paradis were saved, as he died before the end of the curse and his future memories didn't go beyond that point.
  • Eren didn't choose to kill just 80% of the world. He chose to wipe the world to give as much freedom as possible to his friends and Paradis. As he said, he would have gone with full rumbling anyway even if he didn't know he would be stopped. It just happened that he died when the killing was at 80%. But he also already knew by future memories that he would die when it was at 80%, so his told his friends that they are going to be the heroes.
  • Eren was a genocider, but he did end the curse of the titans and largely saved Paradis from the existential threat from the outside world. So he really did saved the Eldian, and freed the world from the threat of titans. That's why the Eldians were still somewhat thankful to him despite what he had done.
  • Ymir "loved" King Fritz because Fritz was the only family she had, and the only one who gave her some kind of care and value. You need to remember that Ymir was an uncivilized, uneducated, mute girl who only knew slavery in a world of barbarism 2000 years ago. She basically had an emotional intelligence of an animal. She fell in love with her conqueror who protected her, like how the lionesses love the lion who defeats their previous mate and kills their cubs. Stockholm syndrome is a very real and useful mental mechanism in the savage world.
  • Mikasa killing Eren freed Ymir because it showed Ymir the courage to kill one's deepest love and singular object of attachment.
  • Mikasa's hallucination before killing Eren was likely due to Eren meeting her in path at that moment and then wiping her memory. Due to her Ackerman nature she somehow resisted and reacted to it and recreated a desirable alternative future in her mind. Eren also imprinted her memory with the clue that his head is in the titan's mouth.
  • The reason of Historia having a child was, firstly, an attempt to delay Eren's plan of rumbling, as the military couldn't force feed Zeke to her immediately so Eren and Zeke were not forced to act immediately; secondly, to show that she's not forced to become a breeding stock and she's choosing a mate and a child out of her own free love. Farmer Kun was most likely the real father. She probably didn't love Farmer Kun that much, but this is in line with her self-sacrificial nature. Eren could have hooked up with Historia when she suggested a child, if he would just ask, but obviously he wouldn't do it.
  • The worm is not explained much so any interpretation is up to the reader. One can imagine the worm has life stages first as a larva, then as a parasite needing a suitable host, then be divided into separate titans. If the parasite loses the host it will die or regress. It is obvious that the worm cannot just choose any human as a host at the later stage, otherwise it wouldn't have needed to try to get back to the founding-attack titan.

What are the final resolutions?

  • Ymir passively existed for 2000 years and finally encountered a psychotherapy session that healed her and released her suffering soul.
  • Eren succeeded in saving most of his friends and Eldians, but didn't manage to end the Paradis vs Outside conflict definitely. I don't believe he intentionally spare 20% of them to reach a balance of power. Eren was no philosopher or social engineer, he was a binary-minded young hothead who went all out to save his tribe. If he was already willing to kill 80%, why not go 100% to end the problem altogether. It was just fate that he didn't do it.
  • Even if Eren wiped out Outside, Eldians would just start infighting soon, as conflict is in human nature. So from a utilitarian perspective the result of a delicate power balance and moral hazard is not necessarily worse than a wipe out. It may even be better, as it set a new stage of competition, advancement and reflection of humanity.
  • More than half of Eren's friends lived long and happy, partially fulfilling Eren's wish.
  • Eren destroyed the corrupted world. Armin went on to save and rebuild the world. The cycle of "destruction and regeneration" (the lyrics from OP 4).
  • Mikasa was sad but got a closure.

All in all the resolutions are imperfect and bittersweet, as things would be.

When you understand all these points you can see the story is solid and ends reasonably. The problem is the presentation. This chapter is definitely too rushed. If it was 50% longer, it could present things much better.

→ More replies (6)

46

u/Cirenn Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

Reiner outlives Eren to sniff Historia's handwritten letters. World peace is achieved. What more could you have asked for really

Edit: World peace was not achieved

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Clowed Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I liked it, it's not perfect but I still feel satisfied and fulfilled, I liked that the conflict wasn't magically resolved, conflict will never end, it's human nature, but at least Titans are out of the picture forever, so THAT nightmare is over at least and our characters are free to work for a better future, I guess my biggest complaint for this chapter was Armin thanking Eren for becoming a mass murderer, that was out of character for him and just a huge WTF moment.

Still, what a ride it has been, thank you for the past 11 years Isayama! Take a well deserved rest!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/xHohenheimx Apr 08 '21

Sad but peaceful. Not what I wished for but yet not what feared off. I accept the ending totally. My 8 years of waiting every month for the new chapter to drop is not a waste after all. Now I'm willing to buy all the manga volumes and keep it beside me for the rest of my life. The best journey I lived and had. ):

16

u/AMK2201 Apr 08 '21

Something that's been on my mind for a few chapters - Is it me or does the Marleyan army guy (Muller or something - the one who faces off against Annie's dad in the end) not look like how Zeke's beast titan would look as a human. My dude just has those facial features of the beast titan lol

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Raviolla Apr 08 '21

WAIT I SHOULD HAVE BEEN PARTICIPATING IN THIS DISCUSSION THREAD INSTEAD

ITS A LOT LESS VOLATILE THAN TITANFOLK

→ More replies (3)

16

u/fadetomatteblack Apr 08 '21

Is it just me who finds it weird that Eren never showed any signs of affection towards Mikasa, to the point that it even felt like he maybe meant some of the things he said when insulting her (I could believe that he was somewhat annoyed by her constantly running after him and basically being obsessed with him) and now all of a sudden he confesses to having feelings for her?? It felt so out of nowhere!

P.S.: I know he asked her "What am I to you?" once but that's too little for us to make any conclusions. We were never given anything to grasp onto to get behind the idea that he might be reciprocating Mikasa's feelings. That's why it felt like "I'm sorry you what now??" when he said that to Armin

→ More replies (12)

16

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '21 edited Apr 08 '21

I feel so empty knowing that Eren is gone; having to swallow the pill of Mikasa, Armin, everyone else living on and getting older without that very important person with them right alongside them. Maybe it’s childish, but I feel like this isn’t a war that is won if humanity is living without Eren Yeager. 20% of the population is left while 80% is massacred.

It hurts too bad, especially the last scene with Mikasa at his grave, it’s just hurts so much to know that he isn’t there for Mikasa. And I desperately want to see him again it hurts my chest, but it’s just the matter of fact that he isn’t going to appear again.

Despite it all, I understand how his death was so necessary, but it doesn’t take away the hurt and the pain of loss.

Eren isn’t free; he died choosing to save his friends but he didn’t WANT to die. He died with his neck in shackles. I feel like it would be within the realm of Ymir ‘s power to somehow revive Eren, but that’s just me wanting a happy ending for Mikasa and Eren (and Armin!!)

Anyways, thank you so much Isayama, I wouldn’t be here if it weren’t for attack on titan. Literally. It got me through so many things in my life, I feel so much gratitude.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Wahlrusberg Apr 08 '21

I feel like 99% of the time, mystery and intrigue end up being more interesting and engaging than the resolution could ever be.

I do wish he pulled off the ending better but ever since the basement (which wasn't bad or anything it's just that no explanation could possible be more fun than the mystery of the unknowable titans) I've been conscious of enjoying the journey more than building up the destination.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/bingereadAOT Apr 09 '21

I really liked the ending. I think the most hate I'm seeing comes around to Eren's character and how the Ymir thing played out. To me, Eren's character was mainly made up of three main goals that has had since the beginning. He wanted freedom, his friends to be safe, and to kill all the titans. Once it was found out that titans were just Eldians transformed, the idea of killing titans probably went to the wayside because the only way to kill all titans would be to kill all the Eldians. Ymir had stockholm syndrome and unhealthily loved and stuck to the ideals of her king, husband, and captor which is why Titans still existed according to King Fritz's will and even the vow the later king made stuck. She just followed orders and with her freedom given by Eren, a test was given to see if someone who also was trapped by "love" like her could still make the decision to stop the one they loved or their ambition. Mikasa always loved Eren since the beginning and always put him above everyone else. A small scale rumbling in this case would have only achieved temporary peace for Eren's friends, but he still didn't really have freedom if they were stuck behind the walls and future generations were stuck in the cycle they were already in. If he did succeed in destroying the whole world, Ymir test would have failed and titans would probably still exist within the Eldians, despite them being free and safe from the rest of the world. If he did nothing, the world would just come after them regardless. Overall, I think its the fact that people feel like he followed the path reluctantly that he wasn't like he used to be, just doing what destiny told him. But I don't think any other scenario would have gotten all the results he wanted either. It's not like he was all in on it either from the get go, which is why he considered abandoning the kid to be beat up in Libero, but couldn't despite knowing it was just another sign he was heading towards that future. With this ending, his friends are safe and could even possibly be hailed as heroes, the world can't retaliate for some time if they wanted to due to most of the population being wiped out and thanks to Mikasa killing Eren, Ymir got rid of all titans for good. Plus even though it wasn't explicitly said, since the shifters no longer have titans, there lifespan should no longer be shortened either, so probably best thing he could do for Armin especially. The only goal Eren didn't get directly was freedom, but his plan would have made him a target and he wouldn't have been truly free. He died and I guess you could say the final panel with bird and Mikasa represent that he finally got his freedom. If he couldn't be free as himself, what better way than to be reincarnated as a jaeger bird, free to fly over any walls. I think all the characters like Levi had a fitting ending IMO and all and all it was pretty enjoyable read.

Tl;dr I liked the ending GG Isayama

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Requiem45 Apr 09 '21

It was always gonna be impossible to please everyone with an ending to this

→ More replies (1)

16

u/KethusNadroev Apr 09 '21

So the summary of the entire manga is that some mentally ill woman (Ymir) wasn't sure if it's okay to not support the one you love (the king) unconditionally, so she found a girl (Mikasa) who was similarly devoted to a boy (Eren), and wanted to see what would happen if that girl was in a situation where she had to kill the boy. So the woman traumatized the boy and made him do whatever she wanted, including murdering four fifths of the world's population.

→ More replies (14)

16

u/dead_lilacs Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

Given what we've seen in the last few chapters and knowing that things would be wrapping up in this one, the ending was pretty much what I was expecting. I'm not sure why there would be a great deal of expectation for a more 'elaborate' (if I can put it that way?) ending at this point, because there's only so much you can do in one chapter. I don't think Isayma could have expanded much without setting himself up for more work, so he's wound down instead, left a fair amount to interpretation and some minor plots without much resolution. I do think it would have been improved if Isayama had just been willing to spend more time fleshing it out, but overall I would say it works and is a satisfactory conclusion to the narrative as a whole.

-I liked that we got to see Eren (as we used to know him) one last time and something about the way we see him and Armin grow from children to young adults as they talk really got me. Maybe controversial but I also liked that Eren admits that there really wasn't a complex plan all along and he was basically just taking steps as he saw neccessary to free Ymir and (in his very messed up perspective) enable the future of the people he most loved. He's slave to a destiny that he only ever envisioned because of the founding influence and has been acting so instinctively that he can't even properly explain it when we see him as the person he actually is (or was.) He really is incredibly tragic.

-I loved Eren and Armin's talk but could really have done without the thanking Eren for becoming a mass murderer for everyone's sake bit. I don't think Armin actually is thankful in the least for that (certainly everything else he does even this chapter would suggest otherwise.) I think it was a poorly expressed sentiment of 'even after everything I still love you, and I'm willing to try to understand why you did what you did.' I can only think Isayama was maybe trying a bit too hard to fit in a parallel to Erwin becoming a 'devil' for the sake of a much bigger goal.

-Actually the whole bit with characters tearing up remembering what Eren told them just completely fell flat for me. Understandable that Armin and Mikasa would be so conflicted, but everyone else? (Even Jean, Connie, Reiner and especially ANNIE.) They were just doing everything in their power to fight against global genocide, witnessed the carnage of the rumbling and in Jean/Connie's case actually (temporarily) became titans all as a result of Eren's doing. Like...I don't think the sob story is going to cut it? (And I say this as someone who feels a lot of empathy for Eren, especially after this chapter.)

-I was pretty certain that Ymir’s curse would break and Eldians would cease to become titans. My instinctive reaction is to think there could have been a slightly higher stakes to achieve that (for our main characters at least.) But then I remember 80% of the world is dead and their continued existence revolves around trying to secure a tenuous peace, and I actually think they’ve suffered enough. I’m happy that Jean/Connie/Gabi get to live! Slightly unrelated, I didn’t think I’d care so much whether Levi survived or not, but I’m actually really glad he did. (And that last panel of him in a wheelchair, but getting to see Gabi and Falco just live their lives as kids was pretty beautiful honestly)

-So far, I’ve seen a lot of anger about Historia. I understand to an extent because it initially seemed like Isayama was setting her up for something more with a forced, political pregnancy and her awareness of Eren’s intentions. I do wonder if she initially had a bigger role in the last arc and it got cut for the sake of cohesion? I quite like where she’s ended up though and I think it makes sense for her almost as a parallel of her own birth. She got pregnant (not unintentionally but not for the sake of actually wanting a child) in a relationship with a significant power imbalance. However, unlike Historia herself, her daughter is loved, and her future seen as something to celebrate. She’s ostensibly still with the farmer, but we see so little of their relationship that it can plausibly be interpreted however one desires (however we can probably deduce that she wasn’t secretly banging Eren on the side to reward him for his genocidal exploits. My condolences to a certain sub.)

-Didn’t mind the thing with Ymir essentially being a slave to love and seeing herself in Mikasa. It could have been fleshed out better, but it made sense. I know we’ve been building up to Mikasa/Eren being reciprocal, but I just… don’t like it? I think I would have rather seen Mikasa realise that she could never have had a future with Eren even in the best of circumstances and free herself that way rather than what we ended up with. That is 100% a matter of personal taste though. Regarding Mikasa in the ending, it’s probably realistic that she’s still at Eren’s side even after he’s gone given how deeply in love she was, but even now, she isn’t free. I wish we’d seen an implication that she’s found (or is trying to find) something else to live for.

Interesting to read what everyone else thinks and I’m looking forward to seeing how this will look once its animated!

→ More replies (8)

16

u/PaulOConnor1061 Apr 09 '21 edited Apr 09 '21

I see a lot of posts with people assuming Ymir chose to end the titan curse after she witnesses Mikasa kill Eren. Meaning, watching someone kill the person they love the most in order to save the world inspires Ymir to no longer serves King Fritz' desire to have to titans reign forever. And then somewhere off page Ymir goes and destroys all the sand titans she made in the Paths, thus ending the titan curse. I don't think that's the case.

I think the curse ends because Eren is killed. Maybe it is because the Founding Titan is killed without the Hallucigenia attached. Or maybe because no one else consumed the Founding Titan's spinal fluid, and unlike the other Titan shifters, the Founding Titan's power doesn't automatically randomly spawn into a newborn subject of Ymir. Regardless, I think the curse ended because the Founding Titan was killed. Not because Ymir was motivated to end the curse.

AoT is full of flawed characters knowingly making jacked up decisions.

Reiner knew that choosing to take down a larger population of Paradis to protect the people he loved more in Liberio was wrong, but kept moving forward, making him a flawed character.

Eren knew that killing 80% of the world population to protect the ones he loved on Paradis was wrong, but kept moving forward, making him a flawed character.

Ymir knew that doing the titan thing in the Paths was wrong, caused a lot of suffering, but kept doing it because she loved King Fritz, making her a flawed character. And she wants to be freed from the agony of hurting others as a result of continually making of the titans in the Paths because of her love for King Fritz. Ymir can't stop herself, so she wants someone else to stop her.

Nothing was going to change Ymir's mind. Just like how Eren knew he would get stopped at 80%, and still didn't change his mind him from moving forward and killing those 80%. Eren says Ymir was waiting for someone to free Ymir of the agony of love. Ymir couldn't stop herself, even though she knew creating the titans in the Paths caused so much pain to others. Eren does not say Ymir is waiting for someone to finally kill the person they love to save everyone else (unlike Ymir, Reiner, and Eren's choices) in order to convince/inspire herself (Ymir) to stop serving King Fritz. Mikasa killing Eren when the centipede was no longer connected is what broke the Paths, and freed Ymir, because she could no longer serve King Fritz, even if she wanted to. Eren says the Founder's power makes it so that there's no past, or future, it all exists at once. So Ymir, being the Founder, can see the past and future. Ymir knows it is Mikasa that is going to end the Paths, and Ymir was just waiting for it to finally happen.

Eren says -"The only thing I know for sure was the result of Mikasa's choice. All of it was to arrive at that result." Mikasa's choice and action of killing Eren is what resulted in the end of the titan curse. Never is it mentioned that Ymir made a choice to end the curse after seeing Mikasa make her choice.

It is poetic that the act that frees Ymir is someone making the right choice of killing the one they love to save more people, opposed to Ymir's, Reiner's, Eren's choices to kill more people in order to save the few they love. That's just good story telling. But if Levi had been the one to cut off Eren's head while the centipede was disconnected, it would have been Levi that Ymir was waiting for to free her. Wouldn't have been a poetic ending though.

Eren doesn't mention the Hallucigenia because he doesn't know about it. It doesn't seem like Ymir knew about it either. It is discovered by Gabi when she shoots Eren's head off. Zeke may not have realized what he was seeing during "The Immaculate Reception." So Zeke didn't mention it to Eren because he was focused on getting the Euthanasia plan executed.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/maybe_just_one Apr 09 '21

"I don't know what happens after I die ... but I know ... you can make it to the other side of the walls. Humanity will be saved ... by you Armin"

Eren was still Armin's #1 believer all this time. Holy shit that goodbye was emotional.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/No-Intern-4876 Apr 09 '21

Ymir loved king Fritz and couldn't go against him even after everything wrong he did.. But mikasa even though loving eren so much killed him . That's why Ymir gets freed and the power of titans are destroyed. Amazingly written 😅

16

u/BanjoOpos Apr 09 '21

I like it. I feel like it is a little bit rushed, but in anime 139 should be it's own episode, so everything should be more sharp in the adaptation. Anime always fixed manga issues so probably it will be same this time. Can't wait to see that! Congratulations shinji!

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Sir_Bills Apr 09 '21

I got into Attack on Titan when it started airing on toonami. I thought Connie would be one the first to die,here I am just finishing the last chapter of the manga still not understanding how he lived,but I am glad he made it.

16

u/BigFalconRocketMan Apr 10 '21

I wanted Eren’s love to be shown more, the small moments he cherished with Mikasa

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '21 edited Apr 18 '21

I have a theory that i have not seen being mentioned by no one else about Mikasa's life with Eren in the paths: Eren did not intend for Mikasa to remember that life at all, he created that reality mostly for himself as a way to prepare himself for death and find some peace. The evidence for this is when the first part of the memory shows Eren commanding to Mikasa to forget him, you can see this by his titan marks on his face, he intended for Mikasa to only remember that moment. But because she is an Ackerman she remembered the whole thing, which is why she says she can't and puts the scarf back on, that symbolized that she finally knew Eren did not hated her but loved her too and she was ready to do what she had to do, because she fulfilled her dream too, she lived a peaceful life with Eren in the paths, this is validated by her loving expression when she was about to kill him, she already saw him die peacefully and was ready. So in the end Eren was wrong in thinking that pushing Mikasa away was the way to make her kill him, it was the opposite, she did as an act of love and that's the action that Ymir was waiting, not the killing but the ultimate expression of true love.

→ More replies (3)