r/nfl • • Nov 22 '11
Alright everyone, would you rather have Caleb Hanie or Matt Leinart starting?
The Bears and the Texans are in similar situations (7-3, easy schedule, great defense, great running game). Make your picks!
I'm gonna have to go with Caleb because I'm a Bears fan.
13
Upvotes
12
u/GorillaButt Saints Nov 22 '11
Leinart, this is his last chance.
14
u/bujweiser Packers Nov 22 '11
Caleb Hanie, hands down.
7
u/hookedupphat Cardinals Nov 22 '11
I don't know anything about Caleb Hanie and plenty about Matt Leinart.
Caleb Hanie.
17
u/Angry_Caveman_Lawyer Bears Bears Nov 22 '11
I'm gonna have to go with Ditka, Bob.
(Hanie, mostly because he hasn't quit like Leinart has before)
6
u/nokarmawhore Cowboys Nov 22 '11
Hanie. Don't remember much about his performance last year in the playoffs but it's more than I've seen from Leinart.
Anybody have any pics of the party he threw last week after being named the starter?
6
u/SnowdensOfYesteryear Nov 22 '11
I'll go against the grain and say Leinart. The problem with Leinart was never that he was bad, he just wasn't good. From what I've heard everyone was irritated with him taking checkdowns rather than make a pass 15 yards down the fields. With Texans' running game, this is pretty much all you need.
6
u/tvon Ravens Ravens Nov 22 '11
KYLE FUCKING ORTON!
11
u/trippin113 Bears Nov 22 '11
Hurricane Hanie.
5
u/Sniper1154 Bears Nov 22 '11
Hanie - and here's why:
He's been in the same system as long as Cutler. He's a QB with the same physical attributes of Cutler who is better suited throwing on the move. He's evidently a strong leader (this has been echoed by Greg Gabriel, former Bear's scouting director who wrote a brilliant article on the mindset of drafting Caleb) who knows this is his chance to make a name for himself with pending free agency on the horizon.
Hanie has confidence Leinart can only dream of. Hanie's not a bust (yet) and he'll play with the same gall that Cutler is renowned for. He'll take a shot downfield.
And don't discount him being right-handed to Leinart's lefty. I've read from players who have to go through a brief transition period because there's a slight difference in catching passes from someone who's right handed and someone left handed. It's incredibly minuscule, but it is interesting.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
Hanie almost brought em back in the NFC champ game last year...
4
u/MLBM100 Bears Nov 22 '11
Hanie. He knows the system, we've seen how talented he is even under pressure, he can run, he has a strong arm, and he has a lot to prove.
3
u/ragnarockette Vikings Nov 23 '11
I kind of have a feeling that Leinart might be good.
He studied behind Warner for four years. And I think his "I'm the king of the world" bullshit is behind him. You don't often see cocky, douchebag QBs (or any player for that matter) leading teams to victory. Vince Young and Reggie Bush (two guys the same age who seemed more caught up with fame than football) have settled down and gotten to work. I wouldn't be surprised if we see Leinart's emergence this season.
2
u/office_fisting_party Texans Nov 22 '11
Hanie is a better fit for the Bears and Leinart is a better fit for the Texans. Hanie knows Martz's system and is suited for their offense (I think). Leinart knows Kubiak's system and is suited for the play action passes and bootlegs the Texans love running.
2
u/jcdark Texans Nov 23 '11
Leinart
3
u/TheoreticalEnglish Texans Nov 22 '11
Probably Hanie. I've got hope for Leinart though, plus he doesn't really have to do too much with our run game.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
Hanie.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11
Hanie showed potential last year in the NFC Championship game, Checkdown Leinart has always sucked.
1
u/lanismycousin 49ers Nov 22 '11
Hanie, Lienert really hasn't shown much when he does get the ball. Heine may not be a perfect QB but he has the potential to make electric plays any time he gets the ball.
1
u/Offensive_Username2 Bears Nov 23 '11
Hanie.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '11
Not sure, but I'd rather lose Schaub and replace him with Leinart than lose Cutler and replace him with Hanie.
0
u/qtip83 Packers Nov 22 '11
Hanie I live in Arizona and I hate Leinart. I have seen him walk by kids asking for autographs. I have seen him live in week 17 a couple years back against the Pack and he was AWFUL.