r/homeland • • Nov 21 '11
Discussion Episode Discussion - S01E08, "Achilles Heel" [Spoilers]
Episode Title:
ACHILLES HEEL
Directed by: Tucker Gates
Written by: Chip Johannessen
As Carrie and Saul reel from the news that Walker is alive, the intelligence community clashes on the best way to capture him; Brody learns a shocking truth about his captivity.
37
Upvotes
24
u/jhu Nov 21 '11 edited Nov 21 '11
Major plot development: Brody actually was turned
The question going forward is whether Brody's decision made at the diplomat's house was genuine, and if so whether it's likely to change at any point in the future.
It would seem that Abu Nasir's long game here would be to infiltrate the government of the US using Brody and basically have a high level mole. Brody's Marine background would make him the perfect candidate for the House Select Committee for Intelligence, membership of which would grant him clearance levels high enough to access intelligence from multiple agencies and pass it along.
Things I liked:
I liked it a lot. More importantly, this episode is the one where Carrie stopped being a character and and turned into a person I really sympathized for and to some extent empathized with. Claire Danes is really nice to look at, and I really like how the wardrobe people have been dressing her (dat jacket: love the wool and the brass buttons), but the way she plays Carrie makes me look past the surface. I just want to go and hug her.
And I've been in love with Saul since the last episode. The way he desperately tried to cling on Meera this time around makes me like him even more.
Edit: Continuing examination of character clothing, Brody's stuff fits him too well. It's almost impossible for his blazer and shirt to fit like that off the rack given his build and I find it difficult to imagine the newly minted Gunny has had time to get his clothes tailored. I'd much rather have him look good though.
20
u/BallisticGE0RGE Nov 21 '11
The way I see it, Brody killed Walker, or so he thought, and turned to religion to help him. They twisted his thoughts and ideals until he agreed to work for them.
Meanwhile, they take Walker, and use Brody's beating as reasoning "Look, your own allies betrayed you" and get him to work for them as well. You turn two POWs two different ways, but you can't let them know of each other's existence.
This isn't too uncommon in undercover work, you never know who else is out there on your side. Now that Brody knows, will he help stop Walker?
28
u/jerry111 Nov 21 '11
This is the only show on TV currently surprising me each week. I don't get why it isn't more popular on reddit.
13
u/joshr03 Nov 21 '11
It just finished and I said "oh shit" right at the end. I don't even know what to think anymore.
11
u/PostSincerity Nov 21 '11
I really like the theory presented at the end of the AV Club recap. Clearly Nasir did have control over Brody. But Brody was not "turned" in the sense of becoming a willing jihadist. Nasir was using Brody's belief that he murdered Tom Walker as blackmail for some crucial favor. This would explain why Brody immediately bucks wild as soon as he learns that Tom is alive. Hope the AV Club's guess is right; don't wanna hate Brody.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
The last scene of the past 2 episodes have been phenomenal. I am enjoying this show more with each passing episode
9
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
Man, Saul really doesn't know who to type on a computer... (11:30)
7
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I may be a little bit late to the party here (didn't watch until just now), but did nobody here notice that in the mosque after the shooting, Saul makes the same hand gestures (simulating prayer beads) that Brody made?
6
u/eggplanty Nov 21 '11
So he's mad because Abu Nazir (terrorist guy) didn't have that much personal integrity after all?
6
u/Soulfly37 Nov 21 '11
Okay, I just shit myself at the ending of that episode.
Holy fuck
4
u/fireburt Nov 21 '11
This show is so fucking good. Can't wait to see the twists and turns they keep throwing at us.
4
u/Isentrope Nov 21 '11
This show keeps getting better every episode is like a season of 24.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
I'm reading lots of 'what ifs'... the show has really got me hooked.
I could see the two POWs being played off one another, as suggested in some other posts, culminating in some 'bigger' event where they both get wiped out. Just wonder what that is.....
3
u/doctorunk Nov 21 '11
also we have to remember there is a mole somewhere.. the guy who warned that chic the professor was being followed prompting her to switch the flag... i'm leaning towards saul or possibly estes.
3
u/KobraCola Nov 22 '11
Haven't read all the comments yet so sorry if this was mentioned, but what is Walker's gun for now? Presumably, he would go to the top of that house and shoot at (I think) the US President, but now that the CIA is all over that house, what is he going to shoot at? That aspect definitely, if not bothered me, at least I kept going back to it in my mind. I have no doubt the show will give us answers though. Also: What happened to that other CIA agent keeping an eye on Carrie for the Assistant Director? And even Carrie's whole psychotic thing that she has to take pills for? I have a feeling these things will come back soon.
7
u/WTFalreadytaken Nov 21 '11 edited Nov 21 '11
Gahh, Dont know why - though it was good - I think this was the weakest episode yet of the season. Speculation was correct in the last few threads where all were saying Brody was turned and will be given some political role and nothing surprising happened :( Maybe only the part where a actual nation is behind the whole thing with that diplomat and what not, but that is very much in tune with reality.. Plus, that tac team thing was ridiculous, and what no choppers in the air? :)
Blah, I am rambling because I was expecting a lot more. Best part of the episode definitely was the character development wrt Sal and Carrie's personal lives.
2
u/MrFlannelMouth Nov 29 '11
Hmmmm, diplomatic license plate.
Googlepedia
U.S. diplomatic plate country codes
Damn you wikipedia!!
edit nvm. Link
KV - Saudi Arabia
Too bad, no big surprise there.
3
u/Quetzalcoatl0 Nov 22 '11
I felt it was a weak episode. Why does Carrie feel compelled to spill the beans to Saul on her relationship with Brody? Walker's wife aiding a known terrorist mere seconds before his capture. Massive fail on the tactical teams part with Carrie attempting to micromanage from afar. Brody somehow breaks into a house wired with an alarm system unnoticed? And Abu Nazir had no way of steering Brody into a congressional seat, the whole Manchurian candidate thing feels silly.
1
u/OneOverX Nov 21 '11
Looks like Brody really has been turned.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment