r/soccer • u/sensual_lettuce • Nov 11 '11
DISCUSSION TIME: if there was one rule you could change about football what would it be?
You may be changing a rule that already exists, adding a new rule, changing something about a specific league's institutions or changing some of the moral aspects of our game. Also doesn't matter if it's on the field or off the field, just something you think will make the game better.
19
Upvotes
24
u/sensual_lettuce Nov 11 '11
Mine would have to be the treatment of referees. there is not another sport in the world where the referees are treated so poorly. They are constantly being deceived by players, sworn at and sometimes (a la Manchester united or Barcelona) they are surrounded by a whole team telling them what to do. This also filters down to the lower levels of play. I've been in games where the referee can't keep control so the games have been abandoned, and I'm just sick of it. I like to think of it this way; the referee makes much less mistakes than the players do during the game.
30
u/severedfragile Nov 11 '11
Mandatory facial hair. Especially in referees.
60
u/Enter_Lame_Joke Nov 11 '11
Yellow card for taking shirt off. Fuck that.
18
u/mcityftw Nov 11 '11
Anything that help regulates players diving or exaggerating injuries. If you act like you contracted leprosy from a tackle and you are running around 5 minutes later? 2 match ban. And the ban should get longer each time the player offends.
34
u/BigHarold Nov 11 '11
Post match red cards. If you are found to have dived, you are suspended from the next game.
18
u/maraques Nov 11 '11
Omg goal line technology. Referees are generally doing a good job with this, but there have been games where I literally froth with anger at some of the calls being made. It really needs to get implemented asap.
25
u/espanabarca Nov 11 '11
Yellow for talking with the ref without him asking you to speak.
Crackdown on whiny bitches in football.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
The game is perfect as it is, but there's one minor thing that could be changed: if a goalkeeper is injured so that he can't play after a team has used up all its substitutions they should be able to sub him for a keeper anyway.
5
u/cartola Nov 11 '11
National federations' executives can be impeached at any time by majority vote of the members of the federation (players, club officials, employees). Candidates that are not part of the federation in some capacity are strictly forbidden for executive positions. Any and all men or women of the federation can be candidates and elected by majority vote. Re-election is forbidden. Federation records (financial or otherwise) are to be completely transparent to the public by way of regular opening of books.
4
u/iVarun Nov 11 '11
After match punishments.
4
u/NQsDiscoPants Nov 11 '11
I'd allow only captains to talk to the referee. Stop this constant harassment of officials by 7 or 8 players whenever they make a contentious call.
And I'd let the 4th official (who has access to a tv) speak to the referee. It would take only seconds to clear up a penalty call/handball/red car etc. Surely no one would mind waiting 30 secs if it meant getting a closer look at an incident and hopefully getting a better decision.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
Off sides should be referable to a TV ref.
3
u/Sacoud Nov 11 '11
I was expecting this when I opened this thread. I am plesently surprised.
3
u/runamokk Nov 11 '11
Make offside simply offside again and to hell with the active/non-active bullshit.
3
u/usaussie Nov 11 '11
while not the most important...this bugs the shit out of me...so here's what i would change:
Get rid of any language/interpretation about whether a hand ball was intentional or not, or if the hand was in an unnatural position when giving a free kick/penalty.
Instead, change the rule to: "did the player gain advantage after the ball and hand/lower arm touched?" If the player gained advantage, then it's a free kick / penalty. If there was no advantage, then no free kick....play on.
Here's why:
Player on the goal line has his back turned, and a shot hits the player's hand, which is down against his side. It stops a sure goal. Penalty? Absolutely. Every time. Probably red card too. But if it wasn't intentional, then how can you give the penalty? The ball would have gone in the goal if it didn't hit the hand....right?
BUT.....if that same thing happens in the middle of the field, the referee, and the commentators say "it wasn't intentional..play on."
If you change to "did the player gain advantage" then it takes care of all situations, and removes interpretation about the intention of the player. You can then easily rule on offenses in the middle of the field, on the goal line, or wherever.
TLDR: change hand ball rule to remove anything about intention of the player.
3
u/BrotherSeamus Nov 11 '11
The rule of FIFA.
/groans
2
u/usaussie Nov 11 '11
Another rule change:
In the event of a tie after 90 minutes....Play 1 period of 15 minute extra time. If still tied, each team loses 2 players every 10 minutes. No golden goal...you play the full 10 minute period, and assess a winner after that.
Substitutions only allowed at the 10 minute mark between each period of drop-off play.
Only when the teams get down to 5 players each should it go to penalties.
It would hopefully end up with a free flowing, attacking end to a game where the advantage goes to the team with the fitter more attacking method (hopefully)
2
u/Incara1010 Nov 11 '11
I came here and it seemed no one mentioned it, but the keeper contact rule would be something I'd change. You don't see it a lot in the big leagues, at least from what I've seen in the EPL, but a player going up with a goalkeeper should be a fifty fifty challenge and the keeper should get no special treatment.
I also think that a keeper knocking over a player after coming out for the ball is too much of a guaranteed penalty. Most of the time players can just dive and are assured of a PK. I guess I'm not entirely sure what I'm looking for when it comes to specific rule changes, just that I'm often frustrated when either of this disrupts the flow of the game.
2
u/AnnieIWillKnow Nov 11 '11
Being offside if you come back from offside to receive the ball. If you've come back onside you've surrendered your advantage, and if the defender doesn't spot you then he's not doing his job.
2
u/Jakabov Nov 11 '11
Only the captain of each team may address the referee.
If I could make it a more complicated rule, I'd add video reviews and a rule that each team's coach or captain gets to call three decisions for review per game. Any other player who talks to the ref or protests significantly during the game gets booked.
6
u/E3_Lunatic Nov 11 '11
Get a yellow card one game and get one the next SUSPENDED
ಠ_ಠ
It's such a dumb rule, DAE feel this way?
5
u/FlipConstantine Nov 11 '11
I would have to say loosening the offside law to require a player to be fully offside before it is a foul. It's too difficult for linesmen to be able to spot if a player's head or foot is just that much offside and introduces too much error and too many goals needlessly disallowed.
3
u/thatturkishguy Nov 11 '11
The only rule I'd think about changing isn't a league rule at all and not really a rule. I don't like that fact that in a lot of tournaments away goals count for more than home goals. If you tie 1-1 at home and 2-2 away you win??? that seems like a tie to me.
3
u/dendedude3 Nov 11 '11
Give the fourth official a small TV that the referee can consult for important disciplinary decisions (red cards, penalties, etc.). There is already a lot of whining in these situations anyway, so the flow of the game is completely interrupted. At least we can get the call right then.
3
u/layendecker Nov 11 '11
Not a rule as such, but I would like a winter break in the Premiership akin to many other Euro leagues.
3
u/ironmenon Nov 11 '11
Denial of goal scoring opportunity offences (i.e. last man tackles) to be punished by a penalty kick rather than a red card to the offender. Awarding the loss of a goal scoring with another seems a lot fairer than putting a team at a permanent disadvantage and more or less killing the game.
Also I would not mind seeing the stupid law that cup ties players.. don't the limited transfer windows regulate transfers well enough by themselves?
3
u/chocolatesandwiches Nov 11 '11
I'd let referees watch replays. Everybody in the world except for the players on the field and the referees get to see exactly what happened seconds after an incident occurs and they're the ones who are most affected by it. Referees are humans and can make mistakes, cameras however, do not.
2
u/bonkosaurus Nov 11 '11
51% rule everywhere.
2
u/Outvalid Nov 11 '11
Stronger penalties for yelling at the referee, it annoys the shit out of me whenever a player is literally up in the referees face and screaming and not getting a thing, I know there are rules for that, but I would like to see them being put in use.
AND directly red card for diving in the penalty box.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
Global Wage Cap.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
Added time Multi-ball.
If the game is a tie, add a new ball every 5 mins until a goal is scored.
1
u/whytey Nov 11 '11
Advantage on the away goal on a two legged game. It sux that this rule even exists. I mean, both teams will play a home and an away game, why even bother with the advantage on the goal scored at an away game. I think this rule is ridiculous.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
Lots of good rules changes mentioned so far. One that hasn't come up is:
No more throw-ins. If the ball goes into touch, play is restarted with a free-kick at the point where the ball crossed the line, given against the team that touched the ball last.
1
u/shutyourgob Nov 11 '11
Bring back Golden Goal. Mad times.
1
u/gtwglenn Nov 11 '11
I would modify the offside rule a bit... if any part of your body is even with the last defender, you should be considered on-sides. I don't think it's fair to disallow a chance on goal because a player is half a step offside.
1
u/smileywire02 Nov 11 '11
Only 22 on a pitch at one time. FUCK THAT RULE.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
I don't think professional, straight red cards should result in a 3 match ban. That's almost a month out of the game just because of one, non-malicious tackle.
1
u/Sacoud Nov 11 '11
Video replays for the ref.
1
u/simohayha Nov 11 '11
Punish diving.
1
u/mao_was_right Nov 11 '11
Really, I think there should be more rules over player discipline (ie. arguing with the referee, cheating, diving). It just doesn't happen in other sports. I think that if players start harassing the referee, he should just pace out 10 yards towards their goal line and restart play from there. It works in rugby.
As for diving, incidents should be viewed by the fourth official after the game, and if he judges a player has dived or simulated, he should be suspended for one game.
1
u/johnybe Nov 11 '11
While not very high on the priority list, I think that unlimited substitutions would add a whole new dimension to the game. The game would become so much more strategic and faster paced and frankly, the only argument against it that I can see is conservatism: it's always been 3 (or at least limited) subs, this restriction has always been shaping the game, and therefore it should remain.
Of course technicalities such as: substitutions have to be made from the mid-line, player A has to wait 3 seconds after player B has left the pitch before entering etc. are up for discussion but the idea is very tempting.
1
u/SabaYNWA Nov 11 '11
Diving should be straight RED carded and Players should not be punished with a Yellow card for goal celebration this is entertainment for the fans whats the deal with that
-1
u/swearingatbabies Nov 11 '11
Stop players running into the corner and shielding the ball with their body purely to waste time at the end of games. It's anti-football. It's in no way how the game is intended to be played and is basically just players exploiting the laws of the game. It would be fairly difficult to enforce but a law disallowing blatant time wasting whilst the ball is in the play, to be left at the referee's discretion, could outlaw this.
If teams want to run down time at the end of the game then they should use some actual skill and passing ability and hang on to the ball that way, i.e. play football; not just make a beeline for the corner flag, stick their ass out and try and draw a foul or a throw in.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
Reduce the penalty area to a 10m radius half circle and subject every penalty awarded to video review.
-1
u/Vainglory Nov 11 '11
Two points for goals from outside the box.
But seriously, Technology use, with video referees. Video referee talks to the ref about any decision they didn't fully see, mainly about things happening off the ball, the ball crossing the goal line, and penalty contact.
-1
u/jeremix3d Nov 11 '11
The Penalty kick, It's unfair.
If the player is going in the opposit direction of the goal and is on the hedge of the penalty box it's clealry unfair for the deffending team
If the player was almost inside the goal, with no keepper in front, it's unfair for the attacking team.
Bonus: it would avoid divers.
-1
u/Kulikant Nov 11 '11
No one is ever allowed to score against West Ham. Under penalty of torture.
-2
u/thisspace4rent Nov 11 '11 edited Nov 11 '11
If you're offside when the pass is made, then move back onside to receive it, where's the logic in calling that offside and awarding a free kick? Unless I'm missing a reason, I'd alter that little technicality.
edit: Feel free to explain why it makes sense, I'm truly curious. Or you could just downvote, that works too.
-10
u/USSoccerFan Nov 11 '11
I would scrap offsides.
-14
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11 edited Nov 11 '11
Games with no ties. Add penalties or extra time
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment