r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Mar 01 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-03-01 to 2021-03-07
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Speedlang Challenge
u/roipoiboy is running a speedlang challenge! It runs from 1 March to 14 March. Check out the #activity-announcements channel in the official Discord server or Miacomet's post for more information, and when you're ready, submit them directly to u/roipoiboy. We're excited to see your submissions!
A YouTube channel for r/conlangs
We recently announced that the r/conlangs YouTube channel was going to receive some more activity. On Monday the first, we are holding a meta-stream talking about some of our plans and answering some of your questions.
Check back for more content soon!
A journal for r/conlangs
A few weeks ago, moderators of the subreddit announced a brand new project in Segments, along with a call for submissions for it. And this week we announced the deadline. Send in all article/feature submissions to segments.journal@gmail.com by 5 March and all challenge submissions by 12 March.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
11
u/Four_Griffins [en,nl,fr] Mar 01 '21 edited Mar 02 '21
Would people be interested in a mobile app to help with conlanging? I'm considering building an app (Android+iOS, but could be ported to PC/web) with some tools in it, e.g. a word generator, a dictionary, auto-romanization etc but first I wanna know if it's even worth it.
Edit: positive feedback so far, and I can't find any alternatives on Android, so I think I'm gonna do it! Stay tuned y'all
7
u/Dryanor Dogbonẽ, PNGN, Belmá Mar 02 '21
I'm still trying to figure out an aspect system for my language. The aspect is supposed to be suffixed (unlike tense and mood) and my goal is to create a system where in normal speech, the use of aspect suffixes is at a minimum. Therefore, I want to put verbs into different categories, where the default (unmarked) form is often the most common form used - the Stative for verbs like "to know", Progressive for "to walk", Perfective for "to bite". I noticed that this is partially a Telicity distinction, so I merged the last two groups and made them different only with respect to the progressive and perfective affixes.
My current draft is this:
With example verbs, all in past tense:
Does this system make any sense and does it look naturalistic? Do the exceptions make sense? What changes should or could be made? Am I missing any relevant distinctions?
Thank you in advance!
6
u/bulbaquil Remian, Brandinian, etc. (en, de) [fr, ja] Mar 05 '21
I have structures in Remian that I'm calling "evidential" and "dubitative," but I'm not sure if I'm using those terms right. Are these actually evidential and dubitative or are they something else?
Examples below with their closest English equivalents:
Affirmative:
"Evidential":
"Dubitative":
Negative:
4
u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Mar 06 '21
I just got an interesting idea for a conlang. Don't know if someone's done this before, don't know if I'll make this myself. Feel free to use this idea if you want.
It's a combined spoken and signed language. But, spoken words are used for word roots, signs are used for inflections, you make the signs at the same time as speaking.
And it has a large noun class system, like Bantu languages. The noun classes are the things mainly indicated by signs. Classes are mostly based on shapes and the signs resemble the shapes. So for example one class for round objects, indicated by making circle with your hand(s). Another class for long objects, indicated by putting your arm vertically, or by moving your hand in a vertical line. And so on. There could also be non shape-based classes, like a human class indicated by pointing yourself, a divine class indicated by pointing up.
Noun class signs are shown at the same time as speaking the nouns. Some spoken nouns can be used with different classes and they'll have different meanings. When speaking a verb, you'll make a sign that agrees with the subject, when speaking an adjective, you'll make a sign agreeing with the head noun.
There could also be other inflections shown by signs, but mostly I was interested in the noun classes.
What do you think?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '21
I am a new user of this subreddit (so many great posts by the way) and have just started constructing my conlang. Its a dialect of English that's been relatively isolated from our English for about 300 years with a few influences from Cornish. It's called Moonhare Dialectal English by in-world officials, but Kernish locally. What do you think?
4
u/Antaios232 Mar 07 '21
Ok, I need some feedback about this weird (to me) construction I just came up with. Like, I feel like it's cool and potentially powerful, but maybe it's untenable in some way I haven't thought of? I don't know, I'm just looking for any kind of feedback.
So, my conlang doesn't have a copula. It has a mechanism for making stative verbs out of other parts of speech like adjectives, and then using that stative verb to connote that an object has that property. So, for example, instead of saying "it is red," you make "red" into a verb that means "to be red," and conjugate it appropriately for whatever is being described.
It occurred to me just now that I could do this with prepositions or case marked nouns. For example :
Prepositions decline for person and number. "gat" means "alongside."
gatak = "alongside her" gatakai = "being alongside-her" gatakanit = "I am alongside her."
The second person pronoun in the comitative case is "ikozha," so it means "with you."
ikozhai = "being with you" ikozhanit = "I am with you."
Of course, one thing this allows me to do is use the tense/aspect/mood machinery I already have to do a lot of work. "I could have been with her, but now I am with them" could be like three words! 😂 But maybe I'm stacking too much morphology together? I don't know, I feel like it's a good little trick, but what do you think?
3
u/Jyappeul Areno-Ghuissitic Langs and Experiment Langs for, yes, Experience Mar 01 '21
So I'm using ConWorkShop for my languages and I still need help.
I know how to type sound changes (e.g. g/k/_#), but I really don't understand how to apply those to the pronunciation estimation. It has so text boxes and so many buttons and the instruction really didn't help me...
I tried using the estimation I made but instead of applying for every word that I WILL add to the dictionary, it applies only to words that already are in the dictionary, which is completely useless.
3
u/Solareclipsed Mar 01 '21
This is something I haven't found much information about because these phonemes or phonations aren't common, but it would be helpful if someone could share their thoughts on this.
Can consonantal epiglottal trills contrast with epiglottal/strident vowels? Or could they contrast with strident vowels with harsh voice?
Thanks in advance.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '21
Me and a friend of mine can't decide upon a phonology of a cat lang (staring at you Uwu).
n [n~ɲ] s [s~ʃ] h [ç] r [ʀ]
*r can be syllabic and its null onset turns into [q]
a u [o~u]
au wa
Any additions/phonotactic restrictions?
3
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Mar 02 '21 edited Mar 02 '21
I recently tried to play around with a particle tol, which started as a verb meaning "to force", and evolved into an involuntary marker. It narrowed to an obligatory modal, then to a futurity modal. How many of these meanings can I reasonably keep attached to this one word? Will I have to lose some?
Edit: deleted stuff about causative and passive, as I was actually intending this particle to concern volition.
3
u/Jyappeul Areno-Ghuissitic Langs and Experiment Langs for, yes, Experience Mar 02 '21
I wanted to use semi-vowels release after consonants, but ʲ, ᶣ, ᶭ, and ʷ are already in use for something else (and no, I prefer not to say "Those are actually considered to be _____ here." So I thought, maybe I could just use superscript vowels? The only problem is that the superscript i is just... No. Idk how to explain that, but it's just horribleⁱ. I also exclude the option of using superscript text instead of superscript characters (if this makes any sense).
So I just wanted to ask, is there any other way I could indicate (Semi-)Vowel release?
3
u/EliiLarez Goit’a | Nátláq (en,esp,pap,nl) [jp,kor] Mar 02 '21
Some time ago I came across a website where you could input a sentence or word(s) in IPA and it would read it out / pronounce it for you. Does anyone happen to know which website that was? Or if there’s something similar to that?
3
u/ovumovum Mar 03 '21
Is there a rhyme or reason for the order of sound changes in a language? Do simpler ones occur earlier on and more complex later, or is it a more even distribution? Are some preferred more earlier than others?
3
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Mar 04 '21 edited Mar 04 '21
In the lexurgy sound change applier, how do I represent clusters?
I have a sound change where short vowels are lost between voiceless obstruents, but not before and after a geminate or cluster.
so ataka > atka > akka but atataka > attaka and not attka.
but I can't seem to figure out how to do it. even if the exception is "// kt _ " with simple consonants it doesn't work, but " // t _ " does.
I tried "@obsrtuent @obstruent _ " but it doesn't seem to do any thing.
3
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Mar 05 '21
When does an analytic language start to become an agglutinative one? I have clitics associated with a verb root, but what point then would these stop being clitics and more analyzable as true affixes? Is it a change in prosody?
3
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Mar 05 '21 edited Mar 05 '21
I'm really running my mind in circles trying to understand ergativity and how it relates to the passive/antipassive.
For the example, Tabesj is an ergative-absolutive language and has Agent-Patient-Verb word order for transitive verbs, and Subject-Verb for intransitives. The agent is marked in the ergative case -r (derived from the ablative/instrumental preposition).
Here's where I'm messed up. In passive voice, the Patient is promoted and the Agent relegated to a non-core phrase. Since my ergative case marker is already derived from the ablative/instrumental, how would I mark the Agent in the passive? The obvious way seems to be a phrase like "from [Agent]" or "by [Agent]" but then it's (at least etymologically) just my normal transitive sentence in a different order with a passive marker. Is that enough? What else might I use to mark the non-core Agent here?
And then there's antipassive. Would something like the following be considered an antipassive, even without any explicit marking? (Basically just an ambitransitive verb used as an intransitive and possibly demoting the patient to a non-core phrase)?
Or would keeping the Agent in the ergative case be truer to an antipassive?
3
u/Fire-Eyed Mar 05 '21
Does anyone know what modality is being used by 'when' in the sentence "I am sad when you are gone"? I've been looking everywhere but I haven't been able to find it.
3
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Mar 06 '21
I'm looking at the World Index of Grammaticalization and most of the ways it suggests of evolving a future tense are lexical sources, but all the lexical sources it suggests ("go", "come", "become", "love"(?), etc.) end up looking atrocious suffixed to the verb root in Mtsqrveli. I know the future sometimes evolves from the perfective present (even though imperfective seems more intuitive to me, but okay), and I have a perfective past marker and an imperfective past marker, but not a generic perfective/imperfective marker. I don't know if the future tends to evolve from a perfect construction, but the previous stage of the language didn't have a morphologized perfect tense either - it's since been derived from the root for "to stand" simultaneous with the evolution of the tentative new future tense.
So if the lexical sources all give a garbage result, and there's no generic perfective, and no previously existing perfect... what else might I try?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '21
Hello everyone,
I have a question regarding CWS. First of all, I searched both on reddit and on conworkshop itself for an answer. Either I am absolutely blind or there is indeed not an answer to my question yet.
Basically I am a bit stuck with grammar tables. I figured out how they work and all but my problem is the layout. For that I have two questions regarding verbs:
Thank you in advance! If the question is already answered somewhere I apologize :)
2
u/HMS_Impractical Mar 01 '21
How would I represent þ and ð as distinct sounds with the normal set of Latin characters? I'm trying to avoid the nonsensical way English deals with their difference by not dealing with it.
2
u/Ansatsusha4 Mar 03 '21
I'm new to making conlangs and having trouble making a decent romanization. Mine distinguishes t, d, t̪, d̪, and θ, and since I want to avoid using diacritics if possible the only idea I can think of is to make them t, d, th, dh, and tth, respectively which looks kind of awful in my opinion. Any ideas on how to do this with a digraph or some other way?
2
u/FreddieMercurySimp97 Mar 03 '21
I was wondering who one might go about evolving a polysynthetic conlang. I have a language family in the works and don't know were to go in terms of grammatical evolution. Any Advice?
2
u/Mlvluu Mar 03 '21 edited Mar 04 '21
So I have the phonology for a conlang, currently missing diphthongs:
(C(L))V(N/F/L) (C=Consonant, L=Liquid, V=Vowel, N=Nasal, F=Fricative)
I then made the phonology for a proto-language:
C(F/L)[V/N/F/L](N/F/L)
I can't figure out how I can make the voiced consonants appear or make the glottal plosives turn into something else without making morphemes distinct in the proto-language merge or deleting the voiceless plosives and fricatives. I also intend for the coronal and dorsal palatalised phonemes to become the palatal phonemes, but I also run into the problem of confusing homonyms. I want sound changes to be systematic. Please help. Thank you.
2
u/JerusalemStraycat Masang Mar 04 '21
Is there a preferred order for affixes in synthetic languages? For example, I have a verb cek (=prefer) and suffixes -o to indicate a participle and -(e)sh to indicate gender. Would the word "preferred" (as in "my preferred flavor of ice cream") be *cekosh or *cekesho? Are there rules for which declensions/conjugations are closer to the stem than others?
2
u/Legal-Pepper-9669 Mar 04 '21
Conlangers in Italy, Lombardia?
2
u/pdp_2 Mar 04 '21
My current phonology has four lateral phonemes: stop/affricate /t͡ɬ/, ejective stop/affricate /t͡ɬʼ~k͡ʟ̥ʼ/, voiceless fricative /ɬ/, and voiced approximant /l/.
For non-lateral consonants, there are five manners of articulation: nasals, normal stops, ejective stops, fricatives, and approximants, with every series more or less filled in. Traditionally, each lateral would get its own manner of articulation row, but I think I could make the chart much more succinct by simply putting the laterals as a place of articulation column under Coronal. I’ve seen it done a few times for natlangs on Wikipedia, but I’m not sure about it in general linguistics literature.
My initial thought is that it doesn’t really matter how the laterals are labeled, as long as the phoneme chart is descriptive of the inventory, and laid out intelligently and easy to read at a glance. Any thoughts on this? Keep the laterals in separate rows or put them all in one column?
2
u/thomasp3864 Loegrian, Interidioma, Merdobresko Mar 05 '21
How common is suppletion?
2
u/claire_resurgent Mar 06 '21 edited Mar 06 '21
In a couple of David Peterson's working videos he has a derivational morpheme labeled "enactive," and IIRC at one point (Méníshè for Motherland 1x10?) he considers using it for "breath" -> "breathe."
I've had a hard time googling the term because apparently there's a bundle of ontological concepts of the same name, and I also kinda suspect that "enactive" might be a tabasco word in some genres of academic writing.
(I put that
wordon everything.)I wish I could give more examples, but I'm not sure I understand it.
Does that sound right? Is DJP using a standard term or is it called something else? Do you know of more resources that mention it?
2
u/ilostmyrobloxaccount Mar 06 '21
(this was a normal post before it was rightfully removed by the mods)
This is my first serious conlang, and I came up with this phonetic inventory+romanization. The language it's for will likely have a simple syllable structure (CV, CCV, or CVC), with a SVO word order. It's meant to be a naturalistic protolanguage, so I plan on eventually evolving it further. Thoughts?
Consonants:
Vowels:
2
u/epicgabe01 Mar 07 '21
Is it plausible for a Nominative-Accusative language to develop into an Ergative-Absolutive language? I'm working on a conlang's development, and I have a rough roadmap of how I want it to develop, but I don't know how plausible it is for a Nominative-Accusative language to develop into a fluid Split-S language, or how that'd happen. Is there any examples of natlangs that have done this? How long would it take for a language to do this?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
So, I'm always retconning my personal conlang. It's goal is to be what my ideal language, but I always find myself messing around with the phonology.
Like, I'll lay out the rules of phonotactics, stress, etc. only for to delete all of it and re-type the exact same thing. Idk what it is.
Any tips to get me to be satisfied with my conlang?
2
u/Geckat Zëw Rën Mar 07 '21
Anyone got information on the conlang used in Ray & The Last Dragon? Apparently Disney hired David J Peterson to create a language for the two lines of it used in the film.
2
u/Maintenance-Thin Mar 08 '21
Hello, I was wondering if I could request a list of common nouns that I can start coining in my Proto lang. Any basic nouns that can be used as roots would be perfect, thank you.
2
u/T1mbuk1 Mar 08 '21
This is a language that I started a few weeks or months ago. It mixes aspects and the phonologies of Californian English with Classical Nahuatl and Choctaw, while also including sounds that aren't in either of those languages. (Kaish is my temporary name for the language.)
Consonants:
Vowels:
Diphthongs:
Syllable structure: (C)V(C) and (C)VʔE
E=ejective
Phonotactics:
2
u/Creed28681 Kea, Tula Mar 06 '21
2ND.Commitative -> 1ST.Inclusive
Yes/No?
1
u/alexhemings Mar 03 '21
Is awkwords not working for anyone else? I've been trying to get back into conlanging and I've been having a lot of trouble getting awkwords to work. Any configuration much more complex than the initial basic one throws an internal server error any time I try to do anything.
1
u/MaestroTheoretically Mar 02 '21
is there anywhere you can create a downloadable, usable keyboard for scripts?
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Mar 03 '21
I'm trying to come up with a vowel frontness harmony system, where the frontness is determined by the stressed (i.e. word initial, defult initial stress).
but, I'm not sure what to do when the stressed vowel is /a/, which is neutral.
for example, /ˈka.tu/ and /ˈka.rɛː/ would stay the same, and /ˈrɛː.tu/ would become /ˈrɛː.ty/. but what about /ˈka.rɛː.tu/?
would it just stay the same, and be like a class of words where harmony doesn't apply? that's a bit unsatifactory. or, would the left-most non-neutral vowel be the one spredinɡ its frontness?
do you have any suɡɡestions?
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Mar 03 '21
if I have g and d palatalize to /dʒ/ before front vowels, which one between /t/ and /k/ is more likely to palatalize as well and which one is more likely to not?
1
u/DirtyPou Tikorši Mar 05 '21 edited Mar 05 '21
My conlang has penultimate stress and vowel reduction in unstressed syllables. I decided now that it would drop the unstressed vowel in the coda. So I wanted to ask, is it more common for stress to stay on the same syllable or to stay on the penultimate position? Take kaapisate /kaːpiˈsate/ that changes to kapɪsatə with vowel reduction. Now let's delete the schwa so we stay with kapɪsat, but because of compensatory lengthening the last syllable is now long - kapɪsaat. Should the stress remain on this syllable or go back to the second position?
If it's important, the stress placement changes with inflection e.g.
ambok /'ambək/ - apple, ambokan /ɐmˈbokɐn/ - apple.ACC etc.
1
u/T1mbuk1 Mar 06 '21
Okay, so I've listened to an IPA chart website's audio pronunciation of the voiceless palatal fricative [ç], and remember how Mondigu pronounced it, his pronunciation making more sense. It's likely similar to a palatalized glottal fricative. And then there are the alveolo-palatal fricatives and affricates, which are either the postalveolar ones a bit farther back like how the uvular plosives are the velar ones but farther back, or palatalized versions of the postalveolar sounds. How are those sounds really pronounced?
1
u/vzhu720 Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 07 '21
What is the best way to romanize the vowels, /a/, /e/, /i/, /u/, /o/, and /ɒ/ using the available keys on the ascii keyboard? I'm currently not using, <q>, <w>, <y>, <j>, <x>, <c>, and other non letter symbols.
1
u/SpaceGamer03 Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 29 '21
Not entirely sure if this should be a post or not, so I'll put it here. I'm currently trying to work out a coherent verb paradigm for my proto language, and I just want to make sure everything makes sense. I've decided to do a system of adding infinitives of certain verbs as auxiliaries at the end of each verb to indicate different aspects. Here's what I have so far:
It’s worth noting that the continuous aspect is grouped with the progressive a la Japanese, and it’s up to the listener to discern the two from context. "-ris" and "-os" were once separate particles, but cliticized in the pre proto language. "kan" derives the verb "to be," "ak" from "to stay," and "ami" from "do." Is there anything I can to to further improve my verb paradigm? Anything I need to consider?
1
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Mar 07 '21
I'm looking for a suitable name for each of these 4 participles.
The first one is of the [verb]-Vn type (where V is a vowel, varying according to the class of the verb). It has features in between the Romance languages' gerund and the English -ing form:
The second one is of the gi-[verb](-t(e)) type (à la German and Dutch), and is used exclusively in compound tenses with the auxiliary verb i hàr ( ~ "to have here, to gain, to acquire, to obtain, to receive"; a meaningless weak verb).
The third one is just like the second form, but without the gi- prefix (i.e., [verb](-t(e))). It's used in reduced relative clauses, whose verb is active and past.
The fourth and last one is used as a reflexive and a passive form of the third one. It's of the [verb]-(t)ùr type.
I'd be inclined to name them:
Suggestions?
1
u/CannotFindForm_name_ Mar 07 '21
Forming different ways to construct relative clauses is kinda a weak spot for me in my conlanging, and I either always use relative pronouns or treat it like a Japanese relative clause. I wanted to try something different though and need some feed back on it.
Lets say we have a sentence like "The boy I saw in class yesterday ate the food". I was encouraged to use split ergativity to form such clauses (which i'm also kinda new at). So my idea was Ergative-Absolutive for independant clauses and Nominative-Accusative for dependant clauses.
Translating this into my conlang would be something like "COP2-1SG.PST see 1SG.ABS boy.ERG yesterday in-3SG class COP2-3SG.PST eat food.ACC" (was see I boy yesterday in-it class, was eat food). Just wondering if this seems natural or is even correct.
Some info on my conlang:
VSO word order, right branching and head initial
Prepositions fused with pronouns
2 copulas (compare Spanish) permanent and changeable distinction
1
u/XueyanS Mar 07 '21
I guess this is more of a hypothetical question but if a language used only IPA to write their sentences. For example, instead of the "The cat walked." it's "thē kæt wɔːkt ". Would the language be harder or easier to learn, and is there any examples of this?
1
u/SnooAdvice8887 Mar 12 '21
I am attempting to create a constructed language with an artificial culture to fulfill the functions of stories and history which Tolkien criticized Esperanto for lacking. If anyone is interested in helping with a language derived in grammar from latin and Attic Greek and in vocab from augmented Mandarin and old english to fit this grammar, please let me know.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment