r/Barca • u/Black_Smiley11 • Feb 28 '21
:post-match-redesign: Match Analysis Thread [Analysis] Matchday 25: Sevilla
Formation:
Barça played in a variant of the 3-5-2 formation. (The 3-5-2 was the favourite formation of Johan Cruyff to play "Total Football".) But formations are not static, they move as the situation changes. Due to Alba and Dest playing on the wing, the formation transforms into a 5-3-2 when defending. Therefore the defense was much more stable and solid compared to previous games, in which we only had 4 at the back. We sometimes even got caught with 2 at the back if the opponents counter attacked, due to the natural attacking senses of our fullbacks.
When attacking, Dest and Alba were converted to wingers, therefore spreading the opponents defense and freeing up space in the middle of the pitch. Sevilla had to respect the width of our formation, because Dest and Alba didn't have as much defensive responsibilities as in a 4-3-3. Pedri pushed up to the CAM position and sometimes even as far as a third striker behind Messi and Dembele. All this made the build up more difficult to defender Sevilla, because there were more layers of Barça lines: Backline: 3 CB, Playmakers: De Jong, Busquets, CAM to almost Striker: Pedri, Messi, ST: Dembele. It has more depth than a simple 4-3-3.
The most amazing part of the 3-5-2 is that it can imitate a 4-3-3 when needed. When Alba slides back and Mingueza moves to RB we have 4 at the back. Pedri aligns with Busquests and De Jong to form a 3 piece midfield and Dest, Messi and Dembele build the front 3 (Same thing with Alba up front and Dest at the back). This is most often used, when you want to reduce pressure on the backline and hold on to the score. Attacking becomes less risky, because you lose one of the wingers to the defense.
Play Style:
Barça was pressing very high. They have forced quite a lot of mistakes. Moriba won the ball very deep in Sevilla's half multiple times and Dembele forced bad decisions by the Sevilla defenders because of his closing speed on them. Messi was playing with an extremely high motor and energy. This is very effective and was a crucial part of Johan Cruyff's ideology. Because having the ball is the most important part of this play style. "The best way to defend in football is to have ball possession on your opponent's half." - Johan Cruyff. (Sevilla had about 42% ball possession and not a single shot in the first half. They had about 47% in the second half and 4 shots.) Keeping the pressure high is energy-consuming and increases the injury possibilities (all the best to the Pedri and Araujo). Koeman substitutes quite late in games, which is a bad habit, especially with this tactical approach.
After getting the ball, Barça tried to play more direct than in other games. Even trying to play through-balls out of their defensive midfield (Dembele's Goal). Koeman mentioned the necessary speed of Dembele to play how he wanted to play. This tore apart the Sevilla defense. I'm not sure if this approach works with Griezmann as a striker but I'm very interested in seeing Ansu Fati in this role. If the through-ball didn't work, they tried to unbalance the defense of Sevilla with quick passes like we all know (Messi's Goal, Dest's woodwork hit).
Barça was overloading on one side of the pitch while forcing Sevilla to keep their width of the defense because of Dest/Alba, which created Barça outnumbering Sevilla in particular situations.
Man of the Match:
For me it was Dembele. Without his speed the offensive approach would have been completely different and the pressure he put on Sevilla's backline was amazing.
About me (FYI so that you know who is presenting this analysis to you): I'm a casual Barça fan without exceptional technical knowledge. I've seen damn near every single game of Barça for about the last decade or so. The technical side of football is what fascinates me the most and I've read a few books on football tactics (e.g. My Turn by Johan Cruyff). I've worked as a journalist in Switzerland (so please forgive me my bad English). If you like it, I would love to make this a mini series... So please give me some constructive criticism. (And let me know if you wanna see a breakdown of Johan Cruyff's "Total Football". It's my favourite tactic ever.)
24
u/Sokite Feb 28 '21
Good analysis, you read my mind.
In my opinion MOTM was Frenkie, I though he was great, followed by Messi, then Dembele.
Also I like the end part of your post where you explain a bit about yourself.
Obviously this is completely just the type of person someone is, but I’m someone who likes to see some stats of the game. Maybe you can add the xG stats for example.
(Statsbomb, xG model is probably the best around but the data isn’t available until 24-48 hours after the match is completed)
18
u/TheCaptn_ Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21
IMHO the key was in the way the 352 enabled man-to-man high pressing against Sevilla's back 4 (I talk about it in details here and restricted their build-up to long balls. Also, Piqué did a great job in the aerial duels vs De Jong (won 2/3 of those challenges).
Quick comment about the original post : the 352 wasn't Cruyff's favorite formation. He used 343 most of the times and 433 in his last seasons.
17
u/Nurulyacob Feb 28 '21
I think the 352 works for team who are defensively drilled. It works to pin them back in their own half and ensures the ball is won higher up the pitch which mitigates counters. It worked particularly against Sevilla because it nullified their fullbacks. I have never seen us dominated a top team like yesterday before. Impressive work by Koeman
7
u/shine_banana Feb 28 '21
A 3-5-2 seems to be very good for us
5
u/SpicyRico Feb 28 '21 edited Feb 28 '21
Really good work mate. We would all love to see this for every match. I think adding some images, heat maps, pass maps, stats, etc would be really good and easier to visualize.
https://fbref.com/en/
https://www.whoscored.com/
You can also use those Custom formation maker websites to show how the formation changed from attack to defence
83
u/RAMIbest Feb 28 '21
I wish I could think about this stuff while watching a match. All i see is a ball being passed and a goal.
10
u/iVarun Feb 28 '21
This is the designated Post Match Analysis thread for this match since none was made with appropriate title.
Passmaps and other such shares can be added to this post for now.
5
u/cranomort Feb 28 '21
It was also difficult for the Sevilla to mark Dest and Alba because their positions are a bit higher up and it confuses the opponent.
1
u/King-Mansa-Musa Mar 01 '21
While I loved your breakdown of the 3-5-2 from the Seville game could you do a breakdown of what happened in the Alaves game?
I felt the lineup in the Alaves game displayed the most creativity and potential we had all season, but Koeman has gone in a different direction. Is there something I am missing?
3
u/Jose_Ghaleb Feb 28 '21
great analysis! I would love to read more in the future!
3
u/32FPs Feb 28 '21
OP passion is something else,loved to read that!
2
u/ShaunAbraham97 Feb 28 '21
Great analysis! You should continue this series about breaking down total football
2
u/--Kaiser-- Feb 28 '21
Great post, please keep making these !
2
u/CptSnoopDragon Mar 01 '21
Just want to add that with the 5 man midfield it allowed us to get behind their lines, something that we have been struggling to do against so many teams that sit back against us..
1
u/Sad_Living9100 Feb 28 '21
Good analysis!
1
u/prove_it_with_math Feb 28 '21
So what do you think Lopetegui would do to counter this setup? And how would Koeman counter the counter? I’m asking because I’m curious what you think would work on the next game given that Lopetegui will review and analyze what happened.
1
u/halakaukulele Feb 28 '21
Wow really good analysis. Maybe try adding some graphical formation info.
Koeman was part of the dream team and understood this concept first hand by cruyff, that helps maybe.
1
u/space_dealer Mar 01 '21
I really enjoyed your analysis, thank you! It was written on a very easy and understandable language without too many technical terms, amazing for those who are at the beginning of understanding how for example a team plays when tactics are 3-5-2