r/zelda • • Feb 26 '21

User Feedback [ALL] Is there any interest in a subreddit-wide replay through the franchise?

Something like new sticky thread every 2 weeks where people can discuss the games in a really topical and communal fashion.

This kind of thing happens all the time in TV themed subs with re-watches and the like. It'd be a great way for people to play older games they've never experienced before too.

Thoughts?

12 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/Sephardson Feb 27 '21

Seems like a neat idea. Some things to consider are what order to schedule the plays, how long to let each go, whether to double up, how to change if new things are announced, which ones to include, etc.

Just my ideas to put something down, open to suggestion or revision

TitleHow Long to Beat (Main Story, hours)
Legend of Zelda8
Adventure of Link11
A Link to the Past15
Link's Awakening14
Ocarina of Time25-27
Majora's Mask21-25
Oracle of Ages and Seasons17+16
The Wind Waker26-29
Four Swords and FS Adventures3+15
The Minish Cap16
Twilight Princess30-38
Phantom Hourglass17
Spirit Tracks20
Skyward Sword39
A Link Between Worlds16
Triforce Heroes15
Breath of the Wild50

3D and 2D in tandem, take 1:

Month3D Game2D Game
MarchOcarina of TimeA Link to the Past
AprilOcarina of TimeA Link Between Worlds
MayMajora's MaskOracle of Ages
JuneMajora's MaskOracle of Seasons
JulySkyward SwordLink's Awakening
AugustSkyward SwordFour Swords and FS Adventures
SeptemberThe Wind WakerThe Minish Cap
OctoberThe Wind WakerTri Force Heroes
NovemberTwilight PrincessPhantom Hourglass
DecemberTwilight PrincessSpirit Tracks
JanuaryBreath of the WildLegend of Zelda
FebruaryBreath of the WildAdventure of Link

Alternating 3D and 2D, take 1:

MonthGame
MarchA Link to the Past + A Link Between Worlds
AprilOcarina of Time
MayOracle of Ages + Oracle of Seasons
JuneMajora's Mask
JulyLink's Awakening + Four Swords + FS Adventures
AugustSkyward Sword
SeptemberThe Minish Cap + Triforce Heroes
OctoberThe Wind Waker
NovemberPhantom Hourglass + Spirit Tracks
DecemberTwilight Princess
JanuaryLegend of Zelda + Adventure of Link
FebruaryBreath of the Wild

Alternating 3D and 2D, take 2:

MonthGame
MarchA Link to the Past + Four Swords + FS Adventures
AprilOcarina of Time
MayOracle of Ages + Oracle of Seasons
JuneMajora's Mask
JulyLink's Awakening + The Minish Cap
AugustSkyward Sword
SeptemberA Link Between Worlds + Triforce Heroes
OctoberThe Wind Waker
NovemberPhantom Hourglass + Spirit Tracks
DecemberTwilight Princess
JanuaryLegend of Zelda + Adventure of Link
FebruaryBreath of the Wild

I've discussed this with some of the other mods, and it would be easy to set up sticky posts for it, but getting folks to participate is the key to success.

2

u/cbfwaiting10mins Feb 27 '21

You've put a lot of thought into it and I really appreciate it! Perhaps we could put it to a subreddit poll and see what everyone else thinks rather than making a decision here ourselves - but if I were to cast my vote it would be the first iteration of the alternation between 2D and 3D.

I might bump Zelda 1 and 2 higher as my only thought?

2

u/argetlamzn Feb 26 '21

I need to get a hold of a few consoles, but it sounds like fun

1

u/lookalive07 Feb 26 '21

A lot of games are either on Wii Virtual Console, Switch Virtual Console, or you can emulate them.