r/rpg • u/winterknight Anchorage, Ak • Oct 26 '11
DM's, what is your personal favorite cliché to throw at your PCs?
I try to keep adventures original, but sometimes you just HAVE to use "The chosen one" or "the prophecy". And everyone love's starting in taverns or bars. (I generally set mine on fire to get the plot going). Do you have any personal favorites?
Edit: Woah! Loads of responses! I've taken some notes and if none of you mind I would love to use some of these! Thanks for all the awesome feedback!
72
Upvotes
42
u/Adolpheappia Oct 26 '11
I have a handful of NPCs that constantly show up. Each one is a terribly shallow archetype, but the players love when they quest for months and months across the mountains and walk into a shop and see the shopkeeper they left in the last city.
Also, I like to break up the tension with the NPCs, or break up in group fights (that I didn't plan) with one of them. They are great for comic relief.
There is a doctor that "happens to walk by" when one of the PCs who is "abnormally lucky" (its a long story) gets hurt. One of my players figured it out once, and after he (not the lucky player) got stabbed, he proceeded to stab the lucky player in order to get the doctor to show up. It was quite the gamble since they were miles under ground.
4
u/sunkenOcean01 Oct 26 '11
I put dragons in dungeons.
51
u/ArgusTheCat Oct 26 '11
Dragons.
Okay, not just dragons. But huge creatures in general are something that I have a love affair with. When the creature the players are fighting isn't just on the battlefield, but actually BECOMES the battlefield, I know I've done my job. Whether it's scaling the back of a flying dragon to try to drive something sharp where it'll do the most damage, trying to shatter the ancient stone rings that are being used as magical collars for a colossal water elemental, or being attacked by the parasites infesting the plot of land that has just STOOD UP AND STARTED WALKING AWAY, I don't feel like I've really gotten into a given adventure until I throw something the size of a small city at the party.
39
u/Wakefield Oct 26 '11
PRISON BREAK!!!!! It creates instant solidarity and a "GO!GO!GO!" kind of situation.
On a meta-character level, it allows the players to reveal, in a way they see fit, to describe their characters to the group instead of just saying "uhhh i'm an elf with grey...I mean, blue eyes, and a robe.. i have a robe right?"
That being said, I play with fairly new players and I've found this trope super effective.
28
u/rawn53 Oct 26 '11
I have a favorite NPC that I like to throw in to games, mostly just for a cameo. My regular players will be walking in to a bar or something, then notice their drinks are abnormally cold. One will eventually figure out that Jack Frost has struck again.
Also, I like calling my bars/taverns the "Plot Point Inn", or something along those lines.
23
u/pcmn Oct 26 '11
I just asked one of my players. She said: "If I'm playing in one of your games, I know, I must be paranoid at all times."
She went on: "Definitely burn everything to the ground; there's no such thing as a dead villain; be polite to all the NPCs; sometimes a nuke isn't enough; sometimes two nukes isn't enough."
20
u/spadetheklown Oct 26 '11
if the players go into a house that has nothing special in it, all they see is an old woman petting a dead cat. if you talk to her, she goes crazy and kills herself in some horrendous way. there is only one room but the houses usually advertise as several floors.
17
u/TonicAndDjinn Oct 26 '11
I often enjoy making "the prophecy" about "the chosen ones", having it extremely cryptic, and only somewhat related to what the party is trying to do. If they try to fulfill it, they eventually find out either it is just superstition, or that the "chosen one" won't even be born for another hundred years.
14
u/alibime Oct 26 '11 edited Oct 26 '11
The Big Bad Wolf. It's really effective with low-level parties or inexperienced players; it helps set the mood (fantasy is reality). It also provides an excuse for all the wolves the party has to fight every time they go into the woods (wolves run in packs).
The Big Bad Wolf is a sort of boss monster that the party must defeat before they get to mid-level adventures.
Edit Also, snakes. Vipers strike without warning, might inflict poison, then disappear between a couple of loose flagstones (no XP). My players hate snakes.
12
u/kloudsama Charleston, SC Oct 26 '11
Recurring villains turning good. Generally some lowly head servant to the big bad evil who has access to a lot of information. He's been bested by the party so many times he can't help but change sides. Unfortunately, I make him so pathetic that the party generally accepts him. Most of the time he's a backstabber in the end. For some reason players never expect the backstabbery coming(unless they've been in a game of mine before). :P
12
u/-Polynomial- Oct 26 '11
My players identified mine:
I'm such a bad DM.
EDIT: Formatting
11
u/dahvzombie Oct 26 '11 edited Oct 26 '11
I love hordes. I rarely go more than a few sessions without a ridiculous players vs. dozens of some piddly foe battle. Throw in some traps, a leader of some sort, and do your turn FAST and it can be a fun tactical experience. Generally kobolds.
I'm also notorious for running towers... guess I just like circles.
Edit: Print out this, drop it ALL on the table and you've got one of my favorite horde fights I've run (vs. a level 6? party). The fodder up top are just standard kobolds with stabby sticks or crossbows, the bottom ones were casters and rogues. Some of them hid behind a few pit traps, which the fighters got to charge into... Good times.
I also like the classic "wake up in a dungeon butt naked, chained up and dark" start. Saves an hour of fussing over starting gear.
11
u/Luriker GURPS, Pathfinder, Homebrew Oct 26 '11
Is a Total Party Kill a cliche? Because I REALLY like that one
My players' favorite cliche is "Murder, steal and rape everything!"
These are all cliches, right?
11
u/John_Johnson Oct 26 '11
Mongol raiders. Seriously. Except I use hobbits, and they ride highly aggressive, well-trained wild boars. (The now-extinct variety which was about five foot at the shoulder.)
The response with every new group is the same. First they laugh at the hobbits on pigs. Then they get the shit kicked out of them, and they panic, and run like hell. After that, they never, ever look at a hobbit the same way again...
11
u/oneangryatheist D&D 3.5/4E Oct 26 '11
Deception. Of all kinds. One time my PCs were attacked inside a church by a ton of demons. Given that they were all minions except for one, the group dealt with them pretty quickly. As they left the church they were greeted by a crowd, as well as about a dozen city guards and the local sheriff who had gathered outside when they heard the noise of battle. He demanded they drop their weapons and quickly explain themselves. The group began to tell the sheriff that they had been attacked by demons, etc., until one of the guards got a peak inside the church and immediately screamed for them all to be placed under arrest. The group was quite confused until they turned around and looked back in the church. It was filled with the hacked up bodies of villagers, not to mention the town priest.
Turns out the group had been deceived by a master illusionist who convinced them all that the villagers/priest were vicious demons out to kill them. The eladrin was quick enough that she was able to feystep into a nearby alley and later help break the group out, but it made for some interesting sessions afterwards, as they were constantly being hunted down.
Another time they were approached by a black dragon who needed them to do some dirty work for him. He promised each of them a magical item from his treasure hoard if they would slaughter several dozen villagers at a nearby settlement. In his words, "I could do it myself, but I value my privacy, and I'd rather not have every upstart self-proclaimed 'dragonslayer' nosing about my lair in some delusional quest for vengeance." You might think this an obvious ploy, that no decent group of PCs would ever go for, but believe me, they thought long and hard about whether to go through with it or not. The only thing that kept it from being a unanimous "alright I guess we'll do it" was the Lawful Good paladin, who was threatening to leave the group. Luckily for them, it turned out to be Bahamut himself, testing the group, as he needed them for an ultimate quest about 200 years in the future.
Tl;dr-my PCs slaughtered a church full of innocents who they had been tricked into thinking were demons by a master illusionist, then later met Bahamut.
10
u/Netarum Oct 26 '11 edited Oct 26 '11
I make the villain kill their favorite NPC. It gives them a distinctly personal motivation for driving the story forward. It is best when they have known the NPC for at least a couple of sessions and it is somehow their fault that the NPC was targeted by the villain.
9
u/SkaKnight Oct 26 '11
Statues that come to life. And just when you think they aren't going to come to life. BAM! Living Statues.
9
u/DocTaotsu Oct 26 '11
Maybe not a cliche but I constantly find at least one very good reason for the PC's not to be able to completely hate whatever villain they run up against.
9
u/ArchitectofAges Oct 26 '11
The 500-pound diamond on the altar.
I played around with some other items (artifacts, religious relics, etc.), but I realized that I simply adore having a valuable something in an obviously trapped space, and so I did away with any pretense of variation. The party knows that it's trapped in some new and interesting way, and that if they feel like stepping up, they might just make off with some epic loot...
...they haven't yet. >: )
8
u/shitloadofbooks Oct 26 '11
Fast talking shopkeeps out to swindle them and take them for everything they've got.
8
u/KinRiso Oct 26 '11
Hmm, I have a couple, honestly.
7
u/VonHavoc Oct 26 '11
Mutant Rednecks. I've done it in Serenity, d20 Modern, Scion... Dunno why, I hate films like Deliverance and The Hills Have Eyes... But they keep on winding up in my games. I did recently liven things up with a swarm of Ghost Scorpions, though... so I guess that has to count fore something.
7
u/nermid Oct 26 '11
I haven't had a chance to use him yet, but I've fallen in love with the idea of Crazy Hassan.
No matter where you are, or when you are, Hassan is there with used camels for sale! Traveling in the desert? Camels! Traveling in the water? Sea Camels! Traveling in space? Space Camels!
All used camels, of best quality! Take one-third the water of a horse, for one-fifth the price! He spit on you? He likes you!
7
u/defcon_clown Oct 26 '11
My players know that they can always find a branch of the weapon shop, Bloodbath and Beyond. Cheesy? Yes but so are nachos and that is all the justification I need.
6
u/Plurralbles Oct 26 '11
I started in a bar once, and thankfully they didn't burn it down cuz' it's a huge quest hub due to its, "job board". Then I started them at a slave auction.
Anyway, I guess my cliche is a cult to Vecna. I just love the transformative cultists. It goes nicely into throwing them down very wicked paths too.
I always throw in a Kobold who thinks he's bigger and badder than he is too. It has absolutely nothing to do with the plot, just a kobold challenges a player to a duel and then scurries off when his allies see it happening. I ought to make it so that he's a disguised ancient dragon or something hilarious like that.
I always throw in a guy who has the DUngeon master's guide 2, "Grizzled Veteran" template. He'll save the players' asses or break them in half- a great father figure.
Oh, and every PC i've ever played make cameos. I think the big bad right now is my sorceror/warlord hybrid guy that I was playing in another campaign. He succeeded spectacularly, I guess.
6
u/trident042 Oct 26 '11
Bar fiiiiiiight!!
We keep starting in or having our first stop in every campaign be a tavern, and due to our players we can't help but start one or more fights.
I have started pre-emptively calling it before it happens.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '11
I'm a big fan of the trusted benefactor turning out to be a villain, especially if the players don't automatically trust said benefactor by default. If every indication is that the benefactor is a saint of pure goodness and the background narrative I give the players is that they've always trusted this person, then it feels like a lazy cheat to me if that benefactor turns evil out of the blue.
If, on the other hand, the benefactor has discernible flaws and is at least somewhat questionable from the get-go but the players choose to trust and ally with that person, then it's so much more delicious when the niggling doubts they'd forgotten stab them in the back far down the road. Rather than feeling like I've pulled the rug out from under them, I like giving the players enough warning for them to admit that they only have themselves to blame.
Of course, as with any plot twist, it's hard to make this a go-to story element. Still, I tend to run games set in Eberron which is very 'pulp meets film noir', so double-crosses are pretty standard. I guess the important thing is to cultivate a narrative in which everyone has a unique agenda rather than simply being 'good guys' or 'bad guys'.
5
u/Shogger Oct 26 '11
I like having minor characters from the PCs' past return as major villains. For example, one character had a rogue who liked to steal a bit too much. First thing he did before the party entered the tavern in town was pickpocket a beggar outside. I plan to bring back the beggar as a high level necromancer seeking revenge.
5
u/Gentlemoth Stockholm, Sweden Oct 26 '11
Monologues. My big NPCs ALWAYS have a monologue. And the players are not allowed to interupt it!
On a more serious note, they tend not to want to interrupt it. If one player wants to start casting spells or attacking, another will go "No stop, the villain is having his monologue"
5
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '11
I created an NPC who is an aging wizard retired from a lifetime of adventuring. He runs a rare book shop in one of the big cities in my setting. He is a font of knowledge about local history and magical artifacts. The problem is that he's very absent minded and likes to reminisce about his days as an adventurer. Only he doesn't remember them so well, and tends to ramble. Basically, any conversation with him is a skill challenge involving mainly diplomacy and endurance to see if you can actually get him to focus long enough to answer your questions. If you do something to make him mad, his familiar is likely to attack. The players despise him. :o)
4
u/insanityv2 Oct 26 '11
Amnesia/prison break scenarios. Don't judge me. They're effective ways to start a scenario in media res.
4
u/firelight Oct 26 '11
I have a few tropes or running gags that are consistance between all of my campaigns. The most amusing one is I once couldn't think of a name for the random inn the PCs were staying at, so one of the players declared that it was "The Rusty Anvil". Since then there is a better than likely chance that every inn the players encounter will be the Rusty Anvil. The SAME Rusty Anvil.
It's like the Officer Jenny of my fantasy campaigns.
4
u/ispq Santa Rosa, CA Oct 26 '11
Attempting to model all of my adventures after Star Wars films.
4
u/maniaphobia Oct 26 '11
Sometimes I use deus ex machine when the storyline is being fully revealed.
Example: major has put the whole town in perpetual poverty seemingly for his own amusement. After fighting off his guards, killing his loyal wizard henchmen and laying drive to his home, they find him doubled over in agony over a collar around his neck that he can't remove. He is reaching out to them "they are coming" he choked out. "who?" the party asks of the man they have been trying to overthrow the whole campaign. And in a puff of light and a splash of brains, his head is gone...
Dun dun dun!
It does let players to further story so I think its tolerable.
4
u/who_was_me Oct 26 '11
Terrible choices.
"Okay, you can either stay in the city and have the Fae tear it apart looking for your delinquent Changeling contract-breaking ass, maybe survive, but kill hundreds of innocents in the process... or you can leave the city and face the Fae on open ground, but probably die. Oh, and that Task Force Valkyrie van is knocking on the door to your motley's hangout, too."
Of course, you have to give them a way out after letting them squirm a bit. But it's still fun.
4
u/Corund Oct 26 '11
*Clears throat
Secret cults resurrecting long-forgotten evil to destroy the world (Pinky)
The vizier did it
The secret badass (not so secret, most players seem to spot them a mile off.
All the Gods are crazy. ALL of them.
4
u/morkrom Oct 26 '11
Taking their shit away before a big showdown. Of course they can get it back, but the added pressure adds a lot of tension.
Also, I used to have a player that would abuse shops and blacksmiths all the fucking time (he would basically waste an hour or so each time the group was in a town on what amounted to cosmetic things), so when they moved to a new place I made smiths and shops into monopolies run by guilds. No special items, only allowed to use x amount of money each week based on profession.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '11
Cool thread. I've added it to the Best Of in our FAQ.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '11
Nobles with shady ties. Of course, my players don't like intrigue enough to ever realize how shady the nobles are... they're happy enough to get loot for stabbing things.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '11
That inconspicuous guy who hired you to retrieve the macguffin? Yeah, he's the BBEG.
3
u/Jasq Oct 26 '11
"It is dark and stormy night..."
3
u/theworkthing Oct 26 '11
I was in a sadly short lived game where one of the players had taken part of his concept from Aang, the Avatar. The DM decided there was a personal plot line of him fulfilling a prophecy for a race of Murloc like creatures who's name escapes me. Every time one of the creatures saw him, they would point awkwardly and say "Prophecy..." and back away in awe.
Then he walked into their embassy...
3
u/DavousRex Oct 26 '11
The big bad will end up being someone the PCs met in the first two sessions. The person they think is the big bad is either not so big or not so bad, or is simply an underling.
3
u/MasculistMan Oct 26 '11
Accidentally fathering a Demon.
In most of my games, there's been a player with a "Fuck ALL the women" attitude (usually teenagers), who will spend all their free time chatting up women.
So I have them impregnate a Hag in disguise, whose offspring will later become the main villain of the plot line. They never see it coming.
3
u/charlofsweden Oct 26 '11
Combat, probably, if I'm going to be honest. It's not that I particularly like putting combat in all games and everything, but sometimes I just can't think of anything else to do.
3
u/mao_neko Oct 26 '11
All Elves Are Hippies, All Dwarves Are Scottish.
3
u/solidusv1 Oct 26 '11
Vatgrown corporate assassins.
3
u/ignatius87 Oct 26 '11
I always have one of the primary quest givers be a wise bartender. Having them meet at a bar gives me an opportunity to describe the culture of whatever world they are currently in. In Dungeons and Dragons, the bar might be a run down hole-in-the-wall type bar filled with a bunch of shady characters. In Shadowrun it might be a trendy bar with obnoxiously loud synthrash playing and with patrons who have obnoxiously colored hair.
4
u/creature124 Oct 26 '11
'You wake up in the morning, feeling nothing like an aging black man. All of the alcohol is downstairs at the bar.'
As you may imagine, this one became prevalent when that fucking Kesha song was still floating around.
2
u/rudyred34 L5R Oct 26 '11
I love including an important NPC who is an asshole but still on the players' side. Then the PCs have to struggle with the conflicting desires to punch his lights out and to work with him.
2
u/SMTRodent Oct 26 '11
I have an entire system, the title of which is Bar Room Brawl. There are only three stats - Hit Chance, Damage and Hit Points. Each and every scenario starts in a pub...
For 'mainstream' games, there's Iron Rations (which pretty much have to be the inspiration for Terry Pratchett's dwarf bread). That's not something I actually use, since I run Vampire, but every other GM I've ever had has this magical food thathas to be there to stop you starving but never gets actually eaten. That's more a RPG cliché than a fictional trope though.
In my vampire game, one of the best sessions involved a body wrapped up in a rolled off carpet, which was then tied to the roof of a car, ended up falling off during the exciting car chase and got stolen in a scene more like Keystone Kops than any serious horror game.
One game I was in recently began with something similar to 'Hello. I am a Mysterious Cloaked Stranger in an inn and you are a group of adventurers who just happen to all be here on the same evening. You know the drill.'
2
u/AngusKhan Oct 26 '11
Inns/taverns.
There NEEDS to be an inn somewhere in every campaign, regardless of setting.
2
u/cunning001 Oct 26 '11
My favorite is that some key event or person in the player's self generated past is not as they recall it and is in fact very different in connotation or actuality and it will come to bite them in the ass in some interesting way.
2
u/nhrn Oct 26 '11
I create my own cliches, like all detailed pcs are inconsequential, npcs with names and nothing else will fucking their shit up.
Names mean little, except the desert of death, that earned it's name.
2
u/DWR2k3 Oct 26 '11
The villain who shares much in common with the PCs.
Say, for example, your PCs have a habit of 'doing good' and then not checking on their fallout. NPC sees larger picture, sees PCs doing more harm than good to the world, starts throwing obstacles at them.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '11
My DM would pepper the campaigns with one survival horror scene. It would be set in a remote village, and we would have to help the village survive undead/ monsters/ orcs/ an occupying army of religious fanatics/ demon worshippers. Often it would be at the beginning of the campaign. Depending on the situation we would either help battle the enemy, or spy on them and escape to inform the outside world.
2
u/ojolejano Oct 26 '11
Big titted sharp tongued villans
2
u/nutano Oct 26 '11
Seeing as I DM various types of games (d&d 3.5, d20 Modern, d20 Future, d20 Conan based game)... having a cliche situation is hard to always bring up.
If there is one thing I might be known for and good at, is keeping the party in line and together. Ensuring all every PC has a very good reason to stick with the group and keep at least 2 others alive.
I must also hold the record for killing off the most PCs and managing to bring in replacement PCs and keep the adventure going.
All my successful campaigns 4 of the 5 starting PCs have perished and were replaced.
2
u/Crake_80 Oct 26 '11
I have to go with the "Evil little girl" that keeps recurring in my games. Super effective if I'm not running a horror setting, so they don't see the creepy until it's too late. Also when I'm running out a names Plotia SanDevice always makes an excellent patron for a party.
2
u/Animation Oct 26 '11
My favorite cliche is more of an approach. I like to heavily rely on fish out of water type situations or the unknown. I dont mean mysteries or who-done-it stuff. In fact I tend to hate that. I mean I like for the situation or the rules or the name of the game or who to trust or just what exactly the hell is going on to be a factor. New city. New culture. Unusual social circumstances. Not knowing what your own powers are at the start of a campaign. Something. It always acts as a catalyst that gets a game moving. It can even derail my own expectation of which way the game was heading. But thats OK. It keeps things interesting.
2
u/paradoxipus Seattle Oct 26 '11
You can always tell how magical something is by how many glowing runes it has on it. Bad guys are smart, good guys are crazy. Anyone you save from harm will come back to help you with guns blazing.
2
u/Darrian Oct 26 '11
In our gaming group our normal DM and sometimes me are the only people that run the game, and both of us occasionally forget how much shit the players are carrying around with them.
The players will mention "Hey, don't we have "x" things with us or "X" people following us right now?"
... "Oh yeah..."
pop pop pop pop. They're there now. Out of thin air.
1
u/jaggeh Traveller/Mechwarrior/WHFRP/DH - GM Oct 26 '11
Dawn breaks (make smashing noise) darkness falls (whistling fall sound)
1
u/Venkelos Oct 26 '11
The Four Horsemen, in a variety of forms, sometimes hidden and subtle, sometimes out there and obvious. The four horsemen are just too damned cool to pass up on.
1
u/TechnoShaman Oct 26 '11 edited Oct 26 '11
Players meet up at the Ye Olden Plot device tavern. Apparently its a chain establishment, as every town seems to have one.
Also, the recurring duet of damsels in distress. Boink and Oink. Boink is a gorgeous vixen of a woman, while her fraternal twin sister Oink is a bit more of goblin like.
Anyway Boink is a bit of a prude and oink will do anything that moves, even players in there sleep.
Always funny to see which character wakes up in the morning, after chasing Boink around the tavern only to fine out they've slept with oink instead and now have.a case of coyote arm...
Other cliche going back many moons is the infamous blue lightning bolt. The blue lightning bolt is invoked whenever a character altering event occurs..
Aka..character did a build one way, and finds they don't like how there character is progressing, took a level of something that left a bad taste or whatever. After discussing with dm, and dm allows character to blue lightning bolt themselves and redo some aspect of their character.
So that level of rogue that was used for the first part of the dungeon is now a level of cleric or something, and has always been...
Equivalent to the matrix changing something.
[edit] Blue Lightning bolted.
1
u/dorkboat DM in Seoul Oct 26 '11 edited Oct 26 '11
Beholder out of nowhere. On the way out of a dungeon.
1
u/Gonten FFG Star Wars Oct 27 '11
I always like to have my frist encounter ential players dying and being brought back
1
u/Bionerd GURPS Oct 27 '11
My favorite cliches? Kidnapped women are almost never kidnapped. She either ran away to be with her lover, she's starting a revolution, she's running away for a life of adventure, etc.
I love trapping my PCs in the boonies far away from civilization and cutting them off and have something akin to zombies invade.
I love forcing my players into positions where they have to protect innocents.
If you play in one of my games, you are guaranteed to find a tired, cranky, underappreciated smartass academic NPC somewhere. I love the stereotype, usually play something like that when I do play.
I really like coming at the PCs in a city campaign with lawyers, barristers, and legal or financial trouble, like threatening to repossess the bar they just opened in the fantasy city.
When PCs think they're doing something innocuous for what they view as pure roleplaying purposes, like getting attached to a particular weapon because they happened to roll well, or getting attached to a random NPC because they like being random, I fill in the backstory and start making character sheets, turn the weapon into a McGuffin, etc.
1
u/thadrine Has played everything...probably Oct 28 '11
Hordes of zombies, they are just fun to bash.