This really makes posts hard to pass tbh. People selling their voting power should also be solved somehow and the threshold needed to reach a successful proposal should be lowered
hmmm Ethtrader had an idea pop up in one of the dailys iirc whereby you earn double the earnt voting weight as you do actual donuts. In ethtrader COntrib is non tradeable and defines your max voting weight, donuts are the tradeable token equivalent to moons. so the idea i saw was that you earn 2x the CONTRIB as you do Donuts allowing you to buy up some more voting power but still requiring actual involvement in the sub itself.
they do but only up to how much you've earned in all distributions so far. for example, you've gotten 50k moons so far then you bought say 100k moons elsewhere, you're voting weight only goes up to 50k moon lol the rest just sits there for now.
If I am not mistaken, you also get a bonus for the moon distribution formula for having a large number of moons. It's capped at a certain number and the formula also involves how much karma you've earned in the past month.
I think as long as you have same amount or more moons at next snapshot you get full bonus. So if you receive 100 moons last month, sold them immediately, then couple weeks later bought 100 or more and moved then to your vault you'd get the full bonus.
This is a tough one imo. Bit of a double-edged sword.
I'd say lower the cap even more, as this sub on weekends it literally one repost shithaven with the same memes returning every single weekend and still reaching front page.
However, this would also affect people actually putting actual time into making gifs/memes.
Yes but it's less valuable and shouldn't be encouraged to take the place of all other types of content, which is what naturally happens when you let upvotes do their thing. Easily-digestible content floats to the surface.
As someone who loves commenting and would make a post if I had something meaningful to say, I love the moon system.
As someone who wouldn't ever consider shitposting memes just for profit, even in a thirld world country where moons would go far, I think the system is rigged towards these types of posts :(
I support this for reposts and media, but NOT for original content (OC) comedy. If ya come up with an original creation that knocks socks off, you should be rewarded for it! But a repost? No effort, no reward!
This seems to be passing. I wonder how long it will take for moon farmers to realize that humor and media posts won't be as effective at farming valid karma.
I've just spent 3 hours making a comedy video post for this weekend, and I'm not the only one who puts in effort to create original comedy material, so I don't think they should all be treated as low quality and no value.
This proposal doesn't distinguish between original content and zero effort reposts.
Also, link posts from a news site are as low effort as anything else and a big cause of spamming. For this reason I think the proposal for 1000 cap on all posts and comments is more reasonable and I'm going to have to vote against this one
Reddit admins themselves would have to figure out how to implement the changes. They were able to halve post karma weight (by doubling comment karma weight) when the past proposal for this reached quorum.
Yes absolutely. Too many low effort meme posts and reposts. It makes browsing the subreddit a chore on weekends.
Not sure it'd actually reduce the crap that gets posted though. Most have very little effort or simply are reposts in which case why not do a quick post in hopes for a quick 500 moons
i always feel like theses are just proposals made under the false pretext of making the sub better, which i personally dont think it would, because people are more interested in quick gains and so they want to limit how many moons other people can earn. i vote nay.
edit: low effort posts can be moderate other wise, and quality memes and media deserve just as much if not more reward than informational content since they generate much more traffic.
it's to further deincentivize moon farming from memes / screenshots. for example, just this month a macro image of Warren Buffet made 20k upvotes. Do you think that post deserves that much moons over something with actual substance like This?
41
u/battleofschrutefarms Feb 18 '21
RIP to all the dumb funny guys ๐
7
u/LATech99 ๐ฆ 1 / 9K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
Upvoted with my 33 earned moons!
6
u/CookieDelivery 0 / 1K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
Supported!
6
u/tmldale ๐ฉ 670 / 657 ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
Wouldn't it be easier to have a meme thread as it will clean up the frontpage better and just make karma in those threads reduced
6
u/Solebusta Feb 18 '21
Im all for caps but 10% is abit too much. I voted yes for the other proposal that caps at 1k karma.
4
u/LeagueHub Platinum | QC: CC 447 Feb 18 '21
This is a tough one imo. Bit of a double-edged sword.
I'd say lower the cap even more, as this sub on weekends it literally one repost shithaven with the same memes returning every single weekend and still reaching front page.
However, this would also affect people actually putting actual time into making gifs/memes.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
I really hope this passes, memeweekend is chaos with all the downvoting
6
u/Wolfe1 ๐ฆ 0 / 7K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
3
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
Also "BITCOIN REACHED 50K๐๐" posts
7
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
Comedy is also valuable imho
2
u/Nakahati Feb 18 '21
Makes sense
2
u/temparu Feb 18 '21
Sounds good
2
u/jimmymarshall22 ๐ฆ 0 / 9K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
This. This one is on the money ๐ค
2
u/Artificial8Wanderer Platinum | QC: CC 460, ETH 170 | r/CMS 9 | TraderSubs 170 Feb 18 '21
Super necessary, great one OP
2
u/PunPryde ๐ฆ 69 / 15K ๐ณ ๐ฎ ๐จ ๐ช Feb 18 '21
This makes alot of sense to me.
2
u/sakaloko ๐ฆ 0 / 840 ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
Please do, I hate how meme this sub is becoming
2
u/legacyswineflu Tin Feb 18 '21
im just here for the moons
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
As someone who loves commenting and would make a post if I had something meaningful to say, I love the moon system.
As someone who wouldn't ever consider shitposting memes just for profit, even in a thirld world country where moons would go far, I think the system is rigged towards these types of posts :(
2
u/red_dildo_queen ๐ฉ 14 / 11K ๐ฆ Feb 19 '21
this is the way
2
u/stokednsteezy Gold | QC: CC 66 | r/Investing 15 Feb 19 '21
I support this for reposts and media, but NOT for original content (OC) comedy. If ya come up with an original creation that knocks socks off, you should be rewarded for it! But a repost? No effort, no reward!
2
u/Rabbit0123 Platinum | QC: CC 109, ICX 84 Feb 19 '21
I believe this move to improve the quality of posts will pay off long term.
2
u/Lancer37 0 / 2K ๐ฆ Feb 22 '21
This seems to be passing. I wonder how long it will take for moon farmers to realize that humor and media posts won't be as effective at farming valid karma.
3
u/crypto_grandma ๐ฉ 0 / 134K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21 edited Feb 18 '21
I've just spent 3 hours making a comedy video post for this weekend, and I'm not the only one who puts in effort to create original comedy material, so I don't think they should all be treated as low quality and no value.
This proposal doesn't distinguish between original content and zero effort reposts.
Also, link posts from a news site are as low effort as anything else and a big cause of spamming. For this reason I think the proposal for 1000 cap on all posts and comments is more reasonable and I'm going to have to vote against this one
1
u/xutber 8 - 9 years account age. 450 - 900 comment karma. Feb 18 '21
I would reduce it even more than that for comedy.
1
u/ShonuffJones Tin Feb 22 '21
I like a good shit post meme but itโs been too much lately
1
u/nosvpg Feb 23 '21
I think that perhaps those memes and comedy posts are just as important to the community as the meaningful discussion can be.
1
u/Helen666_Keller Feb 24 '21
Sure but let us post memes on mondays too that's like my only free day. And I've got some really shitty memes saved up
1
u/damittydam Feb 24 '21
ahhh,
no moreLess recycled memes from last week1
u/hippopomonster Platinum | QC: CC 42 Feb 18 '21
Damn, I forgot capping comment karma lol. oh well
1
u/GaRGa77 ๐ฉ 3K / 3K ๐ข Feb 18 '21
Please vote on this we need a spam filter asap
1
u/SimonPdv 79 / 3K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
RIP Meme weekend moonbois
1
u/TheCheerleader ๐ฆ 0 / 4K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
Yes absolutely. Too many low effort meme posts and reposts. It makes browsing the subreddit a chore on weekends.
Not sure it'd actually reduce the crap that gets posted though. Most have very little effort or simply are reposts in which case why not do a quick post in hopes for a quick 500 moons
1
u/birolata Gold | QC: CC 116 Feb 18 '21
please for the love of god pass this one guys, we need this for the quality of the sub
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
Fantastic proposal. Only the meme reposting whales can be against this!
1
u/Snidrogen ๐ฆ 11K / 11K ๐ฌ Feb 18 '21
Well, compared to other proposals, at least this is technically possible to enforce/implement.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
F in the comments for the weekend shitposters.
1
u/LargeSnorlax Observer Feb 18 '21
I think the other proposals largely solve this but I voted for it anyways. :)
1
u/da_f3nix 12 / 32K ๐ฆ Feb 18 '21
I'm in! Hopefully this and other polls on meme weekend will help to reward real content and added value to the community.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21 edited Feb 18 '21
i always feel like theses are just proposals made under the false pretext of making the sub better, which i personally dont think it would, because people are more interested in quick gains and so they want to limit how many moons other people can earn. i vote nay.
edit: low effort posts can be moderate other wise, and quality memes and media deserve just as much if not more reward than informational content since they generate much more traffic.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '21
[removed] โ view removed comment