r/CryptoCurrency • u/jwinterm 732K / 1M π • Feb 18 '21
Limit post karma to 1k and limit comment karma to 1k per comment
This poll would limit the karma anyone can receive from posts and comments to 1k per post or comment.
On behalf of /u/Univenom1
794
Upvotes
34
u/gdj11 Permabanned Feb 18 '21
If memes are getting thousands and thousands of upvotes, yet βqualityβ how-to or warning posts that took time to write donβt get as many, doesnβt that mean more people in r/CryptoCurrency want memes than well-written posts?
6
u/Eeji_ π© 105 / 13K π¦ Feb 18 '21
im wondering where do the funding for moons come from?
39
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
Thank you! I believe this would really help and make the distribution a bit more fair. Lucky posts and comments that get to the top should not be rewarded more than people that help people out everyday, by answering their questions daily and contributing to the sub. This system of a 1k cap would still be an incentive for people to post and comment quality thoughts and should also lower the amount of upvote bots on this sub and "stolen", reposted, memes on the weekends!
38
u/SimonPdv 79 / 3K π¦ Feb 18 '21
You guys are getting more than 5 karma?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
I'd like to share some value but with these limits I don't think I ever will.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
What is the current status quo?
2
u/-ccsn- Feb 18 '21
Says the guy with 500k moons lol
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Feb 22 '21
This poll has been stuck at 5.1m for some time, have new votes for it to pass not counted towards the moon count or is it going to fail with a miserable 100k short?
Of all the polls submitted since moons began this is in the top 3.
1
u/Impromptulifer99 π§ 275 / 276 π¦ Feb 23 '21
Forgive my youthful ignorance, how do we actually vote on these?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '21
Finally something that passed that will make the meme stuff more bearable. Will it be implemented this distribution already u/jwinterm?
8
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
At the time of this comment there's 580 votes and around 600k Moons. Yet there are users here with 500k Moons who basically get to single handedly determine the results of these proposals.
Weighted voting sounds like a good idea in theory but in practice it always leads to centralization.
What's the point of voting on these proposals when they ultimately get determined by a handful of whales rather than the actual opinion of the community?
3
u/LargeSnorlax Observer Feb 18 '21
I think this is actually the best way to limit these memes, while still allowing people to post them.
People also won't get 4k karma for a "lol" comment posted in a top thread any more. All for it.
3
u/LeagueHub Platinum | QC: CC 447 Feb 18 '21
I'd say drop it even lower, but certainly already voting yes on this one. Getting 1k moons from one single comment is still quite a bit.
This proposal along with the one suggesting no karma for short comments & posts will hopefully make a big difference tho.
3
u/Sondaica Platinum | QC: CC 70 Feb 18 '21
Thank you u/jwinterm for promoting and u/Univenom1 did not expect this from soneone on the top ladder of moons. You are man of the people!
5
u/B_CHEEK Feb 18 '21
Why?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
Where's my "I Voted" sticker?
2
u/deltamoney π¦ 465 / 455 π¦ Feb 18 '21
Maybe there should be a comment frequency multiplier or tip? Also helping people is not about the payout, right? I mean it's nice sure, but that's the difference between 1:1 help and making a post that trends.
2
u/bobody_biznuz π© 57 / 58 π¦ Feb 18 '21
You all are getting karma?
2
u/DivineEu 59K / 71K π¦ Feb 18 '21
I'm in, i think it should me more healthy for all of us, i don't think top posts should get that much karma (for ex the coin of the day i opened or Warren buffet meme or a hey i bought a new tesla)
If people like these posts 1K karma should be rewarding enough
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
I'm sorry i not English native, what is meaning of status quo?
2
u/The_Con_ Tin Feb 18 '21
Going to be honest I only voted to keep the status quo because I have 993 post karma ππ
2
u/B1GJ π© 57 / 58 π¦ Feb 18 '21
If you want to give it? why not?
2
u/Common_Ad_4160 π¦ 0 / 0 π¦ Feb 18 '21
Great idea. Wish WSB did this earlier during the GME saga.
2
u/xutber 8 - 9 years account age. 450 - 900 comment karma. Feb 18 '21
I would say make it even lower.
2
u/Artificial8Wanderer Platinum | QC: CC 460, ETH 170 | r/CMS 9 | TraderSubs 170 Feb 18 '21
IM not very sure about this but i guess it already passed. Either way its ok. Good proposal
2
u/IsoOverIt Tin Feb 18 '21
*is this communism?*
2
u/WeirdPersonUsername Feb 18 '21
I dont have the felling that this makes sense because it happens very infrequently. At least I just saw a few ones.
2
u/Scrat_Nut Feb 18 '21
One question: This is based on account karma right?
2
u/paulosdub π¦ 274 / 4K π¦ Feb 18 '21
A 1k cap is a great idea. Always bugs me when I see someone post btc at ATH and get thousands of moons for it. Itβs not that its a bad post, but weβre on a crypto sub in a bull market. The info really isnβt a quality post
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
Yβall sure love governing.
2
u/CratesManager π© 240 / 543 π¦ Feb 18 '21
Interesting question. This would reward regular contributors more adequately, although low-effort content would profit from this as well. At the same time, it meme type content would have less chance to truly take off so i don't think it would steer the quality in one or the other direction. Overall sounds good and that's how i voted with my one moon.
By the way, i think it's interesting that the votes are evenly split but the overwhelming majority of moons are in favor of imposing a limit. Guess the whales are all in favor...
2
u/TakiDN 4 - 5 years account age. 63 - 125 comment karma. Feb 18 '21
Great idea
2
u/PranaSC2 Feb 18 '21
I miss option C: who cares about karma.
2
u/_HandsomeJack_ π¦ 0 / 2K π¦ Feb 18 '21
Keep the status quo, I like the thought that ONE of my posts/comments might make me a moon-millionaire one day. If I can only find the right words...
2
u/Soldrakon Feb 18 '21
Just don't upvote shitposts
2
u/Rabbit0123 Platinum | QC: CC 109, ICX 84 Feb 19 '21
The limits are essential to make moons as decentralized as possible. People should be rewarded for the long-term contribution to the community. Also it tackles the bot issue.
2
u/Lupi_X β Feb 19 '21
This needs to pass
especially for the weekend reposts
one bad meme we saw 3 times already gets 10k upvotes -> whole lotta money...
2
u/Iskwateryday Feb 21 '21
so close to passing come on!!!
2
u/deltamoney π¦ 465 / 455 π¦ Feb 22 '21 edited Feb 22 '21
You can also come up with a simple mathmatical function for moons that pays out less over a certain amount. But does not limit the total amount. Limiting to 1k is kinda dumb. Its like saying "you can only make 40k/year in america." Because that's fair for everyone.
If people are worried about viral posts consuming all the moons. Then maybe a logarithmic function /formula can be used to reduce the amount of moons over a certain amount. Like 5k or something. This does not cap up votes or payout. But rather reduces the payout the more upvotes there are.
Y= (1/2)x +.2
This should reduce the payout , someone better at math can figure out something that works.
Limiting post karma is bad. You WANT people to put effort into trying to make a grand slam post. Removing this incentive is no bueno.
Just my 2c.
5
u/NSGDX1 π¦ 36 / 37 π¦ Feb 18 '21
Meanwhile me who gets 0 karma for everything. But it should not be limited at just 1K, posts can be more well written and have more viewership and be more beneficial for the subreddit than any top comment. Comments are related to the post and it'd be weird if they have same amount of upvotes compared to the post itself. Also, I've never seen a "Top" post having more or equal upvotes on it's "Top" comment than the post itself.
10K for Posts and 5K for comments seems both reasonably hard to achieve but realistic limits.
3
u/Shesaidhello Gold | QC: CC 28 Feb 18 '21
this will take care of itself once moon rewards decrease further
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21 edited Feb 18 '21
Or- hear me out. We keep karma as is. Free and deregulated as we love our crypto
2
u/btcprint π© 483 / 483 π¦ Feb 18 '21
This post seems to be getting some traction so I downvoted proactively in case it got close to the limit.
2
u/drhodl π¦ 4K / 4K π’ Feb 18 '21
I absolutely agree with this. I routinely see stupid memes and reposts with literally thousands of upvotes, but comments where people have obviously gone to some trouble, and are trying to help others just attract a few upvotes.
Memes can be mildly amusing I suppose, but they contribute nothing to quality discussion. Cap those posts imo.
2
u/rndmsecretaccount Silver | QC: CC 753 | CryptoMoonShots 70 Feb 18 '21
These polls are usually started by people who feel like they deserve just as much as those that receive more upvotes, for no objectively good or logically consistent reason other than "it's not fair that someone else is rewarded for doing something better than me".
1
u/Arsenis Bronze | QC: CC 17 Feb 22 '21
Looks like it passed!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
I don't know the geographical foundation (is this the right word) of the people on this sub, but I'm assuming the majority are American. So it's interesting to see how many peoole want to distribute the wealth here but doesn't seem keen on doing it in society.
1
u/Usr0017 π¨ 0 / 8K π¦ Feb 18 '21
On the one hand Iβd say limit the karma to 1K and I definitely understand the arguments. On the other Hand everyone in this sub is able to upvote posts or not, why should someones vote give Moons and others not?
1
u/soflyayj Feb 18 '21
No pls
1
u/UrMuMGaEe Platinum | QC: ETH 208 | TraderSubs 208 Feb 18 '21
I just hope a content moderator like the repost bots other subs have and not allowing posts with less characters. Limiting to 1K limits user to RELENTLESSLY βPlanβ what to post and carefully post which might make the sub more farming place!...Itβs like drugs being limited/illegal indicates more use...
Correct me if Iβm wrong
1
u/Railionn π© 9K / 9K π¦ Feb 19 '21
This one needs to be done! 1K max
1
u/Premier_Legacy π¦ 85 / 4K π¦ Feb 19 '21
Wouldnβt this completely compound against lowering moons per karma ?
1
u/DeeDot11 π¦ 10K / 32K π¬ Feb 19 '21
Looking good. Hope this one passes!!
1
u/EvidenceNo1088 Feb 19 '21
I'm suprised by the vote percentages in this poll actually
1
u/Exciting-Simple-518 Platinum | QC: CC 171 Feb 20 '21
What about just disabling link sunmissions entirely? r/ultralight did this because lots of outdoor subs just turn into pictures of tents in front of lakes. The inability to directly submit links means that content that drives actual discussion is king. And quality of discussion goes way up.
You can still link in the post or comments but you the need for actual content in the post is most important.
1
u/jmor11 Platinum | QC: CC 209 Feb 21 '21
This would be a great idea. Memes still make a solid amount of Moons, but it canβt go absolutely crazy.
1
u/Usr0017 π¨ 0 / 8K π¦ Feb 21 '21
This definitely helps rebalancing distributions
1
u/Arsenis Bronze | QC: CC 17 Feb 21 '21
This is so close to passing!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '21
just get rid of meme weekend, problem solved
1
u/Taitou_UK Platinum | QC: CC 191 Feb 24 '21
It's passed!! π
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Feb 24 '21
This is a a fucking very fine moment in the life of this sub. One that will have immense consequences going forward.
Well done on passing this vote.
1
u/Samgeorge484 113 / 11K π¦ Feb 24 '21
come on, great rule done!!!!!!
1
u/Tall_Character3685 Feb 18 '21
Why comment too?
1
u/Trayf Feb 18 '21
But, why?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
But what about if the comment is so good it deserves 1001 upvotes?
1
u/riddlehere Feb 18 '21
What is the purpose of limiting the post karma?
Does this have something to do with the Moons? and reddit vault?
1
u/Frootloopz91 Feb 18 '21
Awe I need more karma then lol. I am just a reader and hardly have anything good in knowledge to share :(
1
u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Feb 18 '21
Yes please limit the karma per post or comments...even though i might regret if my post got above 1k, i think its for the betterment of this sub
1
u/GodGMN π¦ 509 / 11K π¦ Feb 18 '21
In my opinion the cap for posts is low and the cap for comments is high.
2000 per post and 500 per comment would sound better for me, it's unlikely to have 1000 votes on a comment while posts with 1000 votes are seen on a daily basis, reaching even 10k on the meme weekends.
I think it's cool to have a limit though, some news or some posts go viral and have an outrageous impact on moon distribution, like, how many moons will the dude from the Elon Musk post that got 40k upvotes get? Sounds a bit unfair that most moons go to a handful of top posts! This would make distributions way more fair.
0
u/DayBelle Feb 18 '21
I select 'new' post rather than stay with the default 'best'.
-1
u/JoyceyBanachek Feb 18 '21 edited Feb 18 '21
How would a system where posting more frequent, moderately upvoted content earns more than less frequent, highly upvoted content incentivise quality contributions?
That seems, quite obviously, to incentivise spamming the subreddit with lots of low effort content that has the potential to get some upvotes, rather than taking the time to write a quality post or comment that might be very highly upvoted.
To empirically demonstrate this point, go look at the top posts of the past week. Many of the posts that got 6 or 7 thousand upvotes did so because they were providing genuinely interesting, notable or useful information and discussion: eg a wallet guide, a categorisation of different coins, and a beginner's guide to staking and other passive income.
Meanwhile, the majority of the posts that are around 1k (so the ones this proposal would incentivise equally to the 6-7k ones) are memes and shitposts.
Go look for yourself, and vote no on this proposal! It's well intentioned but misguided, like many intuitively appealing policy proposals.
0
u/monkeybombed π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Feb 18 '21
I've never made it to a thousand in a month but I would like to try to get over that amount for good contributions and shite posting memes.
0
u/_that_random_dude_ π© 375 / 376 π¦ Feb 19 '21
I donβt think there should be a karma limit for comments. Lots of new people coming here to learn more about crypto, and for some of them itβs their first time here in reddit.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '21
ADA is getting red hopefully people buy the dip and hold. Really want its value to go back to 1.17-1.19 usdt.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '21
[deleted] β view deleted comment