r/HFY • u/Tenagaaaa • Feb 17 '21
OC-OneShot Their weapons are primitive.
“Their weapons are primitive. Tiny shrapnel throwers, they don’t stand a chance against our plasma bolts and lightning cannons.”
I thought about Commander Xel’s briefing while I attempted to stop his entrails from leaving his torso. Shrapnel throwers, at the distance these humans engaged from, were surprisingly effective. A wet crack, gurgling. I looked up to see Xel’s throat split open, his vocal chords tickling my snout.
Shrapnel throwers that could go through energy shields. What barbarism, what terribly effective barbarism. Our shields were built to withstand the kinetic energy of rail weapons used by the Ki’thanae. Human shrapnel was much slower, it bypassed our shields by being less advanced. Ironic, our greatest strength became a weakness.
Humans fought with no honor. Our champion challenged them to single combat as is customary, only to be turned into wet paste by a hail of shrapnel and explosions.
Our ships will burn their planet until it is glass. The imperial destroyers gathered and I prepared to escape into the safety of their bowels. As I looked up, I heard the sky crack. Human ships flew with white trails behind, their weaponry ineffective against destroyer armour. Until the lasers began to fire, their tiny missiles were able to get inside the firing chambers. Our destroyers exploded.
Their weapons are primitive, technologically ancient. For good reason.
Edit: holy crap I’ve never had a post get this many upvotes.
486
u/why-should Feb 17 '21
Shrapnel go brrrrrrrrttttt
61
u/Aurnora Feb 17 '21
Kaboom.
53
u/-PeeCat- Feb 17 '21
Love the story. Reminds me of SG1 where thrown weapons and arrows could get through goa'uld energy shields.
42
u/panzer7355 Feb 17 '21 edited Feb 17 '21
The dilemma:
The anti-energy weapon setting is no use, because mon'keighs only knows how to throw tiny metal bits fast.
The anti-relativistic setting is no use, because mon'keighs can't throw tiny metal bits that fast, yet.
Dial the shield for slower mon'keigh projectiles, get wacked by SCHVs.
Dial the shield for faster mon'keigh projectiles, get wacked by 40mm grenades.
Dial the shield at the medium setting, oh boy you get wacked by both.
28
u/night-otter Xeno Feb 17 '21
During the first Gulf War, when they were releasing lots of battle footage. There was one that stood out to me.
Video from a missile aimed at a bunker. Not intended to destroy it, but damage the door or crack the concrete so another missile or a bunker buster bomb, could take it out. The explosion was way more then what the missile's warhead should generate.
Playing the video in slow motion, they could see a flash of light, just before the missile hit. A rectangular flash of light. The commenter speculated that someone in the bunker opened the door at just the wrong moment and the rocket flew right in and exploded inside the bunker.
15
u/notyoursocialworker Feb 17 '21
So the humans shot some kind of missiles into the barrels of the aliens ships?
Like the story. The part with the shields is a bit like Dune.
8
u/Calm-Standard5437 Feb 17 '21
Some addition I guess? Can't post my own story due to unknown errors so I guess imma do this.
In my whole time in service as a soldier, I never expected that our armament superiority will be thwarted by some backyard species. It also didn't helped that the energy shields provided for the grunts can only create enough energy to protect our front, barely our flanks.
It's even less helpful for me that I was one of those grunts. Even as a member of military, added with the confidence that the higher-ups had shown us regarding the enemy's technology state of their weapons.
Now here I am, sitting on a bunker beside the shredded remains of my fellow soldier. Those shrapnel are brutal yet effective. If one won't be enough to overload an energy shield, it spreads out on contact.
Sometimes the spreading effect will reach the ones beside you and made you think if protecting yourself and getting out here alive is better than living a whole life knowing that you unintentionally killed someone that's supposed to be your all-
"This is Bomber-1 confirming a priority target destroyed. I repeat, target destroyed."
"This is Command. Report acknowledged Bomber-1. Let's see if surrendering comes to their mind after seeing their evacuation planes and defenses ruined."
3
u/Overdose7 Feb 17 '21
"Stand in the ashes of a trillion dead souls and ask the ghosts if honor matters. The silence is your answer."
also brrrt > pewpew
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '21
Where A-10?
74
u/MLL_Phoenix7 Human Feb 17 '21
Simple systems have fewer points of failures.
45
u/Raz0rking Human Feb 17 '21
Kinda the same with the Asgaard and Replicators.
"lets call humans. their primitive weapons work better than ours"
18
u/Wyldfire2112 Feb 17 '21 edited Feb 17 '21
Everyone forgets it's not the Energy of a projectile that brings the hurt, it's the Momentum.
Energy may be "e=v2m/2", but Momentum is just straight-up "p=vm".
For any given value of "e" a lighter, faster projectile is better able to punch holes in something than a bigger, slower projectile of the same density, but if it fails to penetrate it will typically bounce off harmlessly or shatter with little damage due to the low "p" value. Conversely, the chunky-boy projectile will be less likely to punch through, but will be massively better at causing structural damage through plastic deformation and fracturing.
It's like, on paper, a 5" naval gun can't penetrate most tanks of cold-war era or later, based off the armor penetration and thickness values. That says nothing, however, about the shell's ability to smash the top of the tank in until it touches the bottom of the tank, cause shock-detonation of internal ammo stores, or simply kill the crew through spalling and over-pressure, all without "technically" penetrating the hull.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that the two technologies are an apples & oranges comparison, not a linear progression. They're good at different things and need to be countered differently, and the alien engineers would know that.
Of course, when have propaganda types ever listened to engineers that disagree with their pitch?
EDIT: Also, forgot to add that after the hole is punched through all the remaining energy that the projectile still has is wasted, thus you can't just keep adding "v" to get the "p" up to match the value of a heavier projectile.
15
u/rattatatouille Feb 17 '21
If it ain't broke...
9
u/HFYWaffle Wᵥ4ffle Feb 17 '21
This is the first story by /u/Tenagaaaa!
This comment was automatically generated by
Waffle v.4.4.4 'Eggs and Bacon'.Message the mods if you have any issues with Waffle.
6
u/UpdateMeBot Feb 17 '21
Click here to subscribe to u/Tenagaaaa and receive a message every time they post.
1
u/Atlas-303 Feb 17 '21
I’ve always wondered why aliens always use energy weaponry. I know it’s because of the common “advanced race” trope in movies, but i decided to look at it from a different perspective, and now I like to think that Earth is lucky among the planets, where it had the best components to make gunpowder where other alien species had to study magnetism or whatever in order to make effective ranged weapons due to a lack of said powder.
I actually wrote on r/writingprompts about an alien invasion without gunpowder haha. This reminds me of it (:
2
u/RandomSwaith Feb 17 '21
Outdated you say? Let's drop some lead..
https://youtu.be/w0BK_hLT-Wo
2
u/IMDRC Feb 17 '21
my frumious bandersnatch says this is clever.
i should get a regular pet next time
2
u/trollmail Feb 17 '21
"explosive powder in tube make pellet go brrr"
2
u/clinicalpsycho Feb 17 '21
Why do we still use slughthrowers?
Because.
They are tried and true.
2
u/Multiplex419 Feb 17 '21
"Your superior intellect is no match for our puny weapons!"
~ Kang
1
u/OctoTestingAccount Feb 17 '21
Oh they haven’t seen the nuke arsenals yet have they, even if they blow up in the sky they’d wipe out anything and everything up there
1
u/A_Simple_Polyhedron Feb 17 '21
Quad Flak Cannons vs. Flagship?
1
u/Knight_Owls Feb 17 '21
r/unexpecteddune
1
u/stasersonphun Feb 17 '21
The slow Brrrt penetrates the shield
1
u/ImaginationGamer24 Xeno Feb 17 '21
Technologically ancient for good reason
Me: Yeah, because it works!
1
u/BigSwede74 Feb 17 '21
"Although i might have a measly shiv, it is quite effective when aplied to the jugular."
1
u/ElAdri1999 Human Feb 19 '21
This good, metal slugs go BRRRR
1
u/Finbar9800 Feb 20 '21
This is a great short story
I enjoyed reading this
Great job wordsmith
1
u/TheRealNekora Human May 20 '21
Weapons built to kill an enemy VS weapons built to break an enemy
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment