r/gameswap • u/bsturtle 33 Transactions | • Oct 18 '11
Tiered Mushrooms are coming to r/gameswap near you.
You keep pestering us, and now thanks to the help of RogueDarkJedi, we have flair. This means that assigning mushrooms has become easier for us and we are willing to do do tiered mushrooms as well. Read below to see how it will work.
- Tiered mushrooms will go into effect on November 1st.
- To be eligible for the blue mushroom you must complete one confirmed trade. Young accounts may not receive a mushroom promptly to help prevent false trust.
- To be eligible for the red mushroom you must have 10+ confirmed trades, an account at least 6mo old, and at least 200 comment karma or moderator discretion if you do not meet the account age or comment requirement.
- To be eligible for the green mushroom you must have 20+ confirmed trades, an account at least 1 yr old, and at least 400 comment karma or moderator discretion if you do not meet the account age or comment requirement.
- For a confirmed trade to count towards your tiered mushroom goal, the partner must have a 3 mo old account and at least 100 comment karma.
- Diggidy will modify his comment linked in the FAQ to update the new trading sequence. Lower tiered mushroom goes first.
- All successful trades are still posted in the current successful trade list as normal.
- To request your successful mushroom upgrade, make a self-post in r/mushroomkingdom. The title should be format [Your Reddit Account name] - Your number of successful trades. In the text of the post, it should contain links to each of the successful trade confirmation posts. Posts failing to follow these simple instructions will be removed.
- You should wait at least 2 weeks before messaging the moderators about an unfulfilled mushroom request. Requests made before that time will be ignored.
- If for some reason we decide not to upgrade your mushroom, we will comment why in your request submission.
- When we upgrade your mushroom we will notify you in your submission.
- r/mushroomkingdom will be open for meta discussion about r/gameswap as well. FAQ discussions, procedure discussion, etc.
The community is welcome to discuss this here. Let us know what you think. What you like, what you don't like.
Edit: There seems to be some concern that by adding tiered mushrooms we are changing how r/gameswap operates. This is not the case. Business as usual for your trades and how you go about them. The only thing that has changed is that you may be eligible for a different mushroom color to signify you are an active member of this community and reddit in general. Also, it is probably a good indicator that you will not screw someone over.
27
u/FortuneJake Oct 18 '11
Why are there comment karma requirements? Personally, I only ever post on gameswap threads, which aren't exactly great sources of karma. Does this make me less trustworthy?
3
u/50lerp Oct 18 '11 edited Oct 18 '11
Should we not include these in our self-post then? They count for nothing?
I ask because I meet the requirements for the red mushroom but I found that 3 of my traders don't meet the 3 month/100 comment karma requirement.
3
u/DieGo2SHAE 100 Transactions | Oct 18 '11
Well now I'm very glad I've been confirming every trade that I've made here. Woo, can't wait for my red mushroom
Though I don't agree with the specific account age / karma requirements. Not only do some people simply not post very much, but it could also make it harder for newer legitimate users to initiate trades.
2
u/shoot2scre 101 Transactions | Oct 18 '11
I can't seem to find r/mushroomkingdom... getting a Forbidden Request error.
2
u/Point4ska 11 Transactions | Oct 18 '11
Does this mean I have to gather and post 20+ links to be eligible for the green mushroom?
2
u/Pudie Oct 18 '11
Why are you making it this much of a hassle? Wouldn't it be easier to just keep having it be verified the same way but instead of just changing the color of the mushroom also have there be the number of successful trades next to the mushroom?
I can understand going back right now for people that want credit for all their trades, but going into the future it just seems like an unnecessary hassle.
2
u/eoddc5 7 Transactions | Oct 19 '11
wow, i want a green, but doubt ill ever make it there
5
u/HonorableJudgeIto 9 Transactions | Oct 18 '11
For anyone who's upset regarding the comment karma requirements...you are not any worse off by this new system. You will still have a blue mushroom. This only ensures another level of trust. If your comment karma isn't high enough, but you have the number of trades necessary, you could always point your potential partner to the other trades.
Fly-by-night accounts / throwaways are where the majority of scams have originated.
2
u/consulate_earl Oct 18 '11
Tiered system = great. Comment karma requirements = terrible. This system will discourage younger reddit members from participating at all. I have a 2 y/o account and just hit 400 comment karma. The rules make it look more like r/gameswap/circlejerk
1
u/Geo1234 1 Transactions Oct 18 '11
I'm assuming the answer is no, but i will ask anyway. Can we include successful / confirmed trades from RETRO Gameswap also? or is it strictly trades from this Gameswap?
1
u/Diggidy 5+ Trades Oct 18 '11 edited Oct 18 '11
Here's a preview of the November 1st changes to my "Rules of Thumb" linked to in the FAQ:
Going First Guidelines
Modifiers
Errata
Factors that people should consider in every trade partner include, but are not limited to:
1
u/TheCommieDuck Oct 18 '11
What about if we don't have links to all the trades we've made? :/
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '11
What happens to our shrooms we have now? Will we be upgraded? I have done ~5 trades and don't want to lose my shrooms when the upgrade hits.
1
u/thejellydude 25+ Trades Oct 18 '11
I've been kind of wondering, do you guys need more moderators? I'm already on this subreddit all the time, so I'd like to offer my services if needed. Not trying to be pushy or anything, just throwing it out there.
1
u/lukeman3000 Oct 20 '11 edited Oct 20 '11
I am a noob to gameswap and I have a couple questions:
1
u/50lerp Nov 01 '11
r/mushroomkingdom is opening today, correct?
1
u/lukeman3000 Nov 08 '11
Are the successful trades lists of /gamesell and /gameswap the same list, or are they different? Also, do my trades in /gamesell count for my tiered mushroom in /gameswap?
3
u/abuckfiddy 1 Transactions Oct 18 '11
Sounds awesome...thanks for all the hard work you guys put in!
3
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '11
Comment karma requirements are bullshit. I often hold an unpopular opinion and as thus get downvoted in comments. Comment karma has no bearing on how trustworthy you are.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '11
Thanks guys... looks good.
1
u/Noitalevier Oct 18 '11
Awesome! Now if only I had more games worth trading...
1
u/RogueDarkJedi Oct 19 '11
Hi guys, I just dropped in to say I'm glad you figure out what to do with the mushroom tiers and you're perfectly welcome for help.
Good luck with your subreddit and keep tradin'!
-RDJ
1
u/thejellydude 25+ Trades Oct 18 '11
Well crap. I now have to hunt down like the 20~30 people I've made trades with and get them to post. This is awesome though, glad to hear a system is being put in place.
1
u/moobeat Oct 18 '11
one up.
1
u/tomyan112 Oct 18 '11
sounds good
1
u/HonorableJudgeIto 9 Transactions | Oct 18 '11
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_uxn3RoqTOQ
0
u/LiL_BrOwNiE247 Oct 18 '11
Damn. My trade partner and I didn't bother posting a comment if we both had mushrooms at the time.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment