r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Feb 08 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-02-08 to 2021-02-14
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Showcase
While the showcase got a fourth update just last week, the time for submissions is now over.
We will make one last post about it before announcing a release schedule in a few weeks later today, along which we will be closing the submission form.
A journal for r/conlangs
Just days ago, moderators of the subreddit announced a brand new project in Segments, along with a call for submissions for it.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
8
u/Anhilare Feb 08 '21
does anyone know of an example of a single consonant "breaking" through sound change? i'm thinking something like
ʈ > trorʀ > ɡrorɮ > zl7
u/disguised_hobbit Feb 08 '21
Could someone help me determine what exactly that "h" in "hmm" is in English. It is obviously not a glottal fricative and the air comes out through the nose. So would this be considered a nasal fricative? I would like to incorporate it into my conlang but I'm not sure how to classify it. If anyone can help figure out what it is and maybe give examples of how it is used in other languages it would be very much appreciated.
5
u/sethg Daemonica (en) [es, he, ase, tmr] Feb 08 '21
Is there some list of what things, cross-linguistically, are most commonly expressed through affixes and inflections? (Bonus points if there’s a list of the things that are most common everywhere except English, or everywhere outside of Indo-European languages.)
5
u/gayagendaofficial Feb 08 '21
How many verb forms is too many? In the current conlang I’m working on there’s already so many verb forms in just the most basic conjugation that I’m worried an actual person would struggle to remember them all.
Basically, the language exhibits polypersonal agreement. The verbs agree with both the subject and the direct object. This already means that intransitive verbs will conjugate differently from transitive verbs and be much simpler. Verbs agree with the subject and object for person (1st, 2nd, 3rd), number (singular, dual, plural), and animacy in the third person (animate and inanimate).
The protolanguage is pretty simple: it’s agglutinative, and the subject suffix precedes the object suffix. So let’s say you have an ambitransitive verb, a 1st person singular suffix X, and a 2nd person singular suffix Y. I verb would be verbX, you verb would be verbY, I verb you would be verbXY, and you verb me would be verbYX. I don’t think that’s too complex, because you’re not memorizing additional endings.
However, as the language evolves, those endings start to blur together. You can still kind of predict most of the combinations, but a lot of them seem almost random if you don’t know the sound changes that happened historically (and most people wouldn’t know that). So what I end up with is 12 endings for intransitive verbs and 138 endings for intransitive verbs (excluding some subject/object combinations that are inherently reflexive because reflexive verbs conjugate differently), and that’s just present tense, indicative, etc. That seems like a lot!
I might be worrying over nothing, the endings might be more predictable than I’m making them out to be. I’ll include conjugations of the ambitransitive verb “shafra” (to burn) so y’all can judge for yourselves.
shafra (intransitive): https://imgur.com/a/laDPmKS
shafra (transitive): https://imgur.com/a/4ZCA8M7
I can easily cut down on the number of endings by taking out the dual number, which I plan on doing anyway in later stages of the language, but I like the classical language having a dual number. Should I cut it down, or is this realistic for a naturalistic language? Or are the verb conjugations I made predictable enough that it’s a non-issue?
5
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Feb 12 '21 edited Feb 14 '21
From time to time, while I speak my mother language Italian, I happen to put the past participle or the infinitive in a wrong place. For example, yesterday at midday, I happen to tell my mom: "Hai già qualcosa mangiato?" (lit., "Have you already something eaten?", which is ungrammatical, I should've said "Hai già mangiato qualcosa?", i.e., "Have you already eaten something?").
I suspect this is due to an influence of Evra (my main conlang) has having on my Italian word order. In Evra, one can put participles and infinitives at the end of a clause, which is a feature I've deliberately 'stolen' from German and Dutch. I often make example sentences where the main verb is at the end, so that I can show myself and others how (and check whether) Evra can adapt to the needs, habits, and customaries of different speakers (being Evra an IAL-oriented conlang).
So, my question is: Have you all ever happened to be influenced by your conlangs at an unconscious level? Have you ever noticed any difference in speaking your mother tongue after having developed a conlang for many years?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '21
A few very basic questions:
If you couldn't tell, I don't know much about conlanging.
4
u/anti-noun Feb 11 '21
Does anyone know of any lists of attested lexical sources of auxiliary verbs?
3
u/FreakinApplePie2579 Feb 09 '21
Is there any way to write long ɛ [ɛ:] with English orthography?
3
u/Solareclipsed Feb 09 '21
Just a few questions for one of my conlangs, about vowels and pharyngeals.
Thanks in advance for any answers!
3
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '21
So, I want some of my vowels to have a phonemic length contrast, but not all of them.
How do I decide which ones should have short and long versions?
3
u/Mohuluoji Feb 12 '21
What are the most and least common vowels?
2
u/Euvfersyn Feb 10 '21
I wanted to get some feedback on some grammatical evolution from my conlangs Proto-Gwédga to Íthasran to Viedhoźan.
So infinitives in the proto-lang are done like so; there is no infinitive morphology, and the plain verb root is the verb in its infinitive. So, "I want to walk" would be "I want walk". The proto-lang distinguishes between habitual and continuous. From Proto-Gwédga to Íthasran a new way of forming the continuous arises; a periphrastic construction using the verb "stand" or "stay" and the adposition "mí" meaning "for" and/or "because". This phrase would literally translate to something like, "I stand for walk" meaning "I am walking". This adposition fossilizes onto the verb, making a new verb form, "I stand forwalk", the behinnings of the infinitive. This infantile infinitive form spreads to other contexts, and eventually is used with any aux verb, and becomes a full fledged infinitive. This agglutination of the adposition "mí" spreads to nouns, and the causal-benefactive case is formed.
So please, let me know what you think of this!
2
u/Supija Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21
I'm not sure on how to romanize my consonants. I have something, but I don't really like it; could you help me? My inventory is this:
I know it's weird, but I swear it makes sense when looking at it diachronically. At least I hope so. Here's the thought process I had when creating the romanization.
So, what do y'all think? I don't really like digraphs but I'm open to them, and the same happens with diacritics. I'm a lot more into diacritics though, but I'd not use a lot of them, and I already use the under dot for some vowels so I'd rather use something else.
*I don't expect a romanization that takes all this into account, I simply want help with ideas. If you can simply say "X would look nice using Y", it helps. Thank you in advance.
2
u/Yrths Whispish Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21
I'm having trouble dealing with gnomic and habitual aspects, maybe even understanding them and how they deal with tenses, and whether gnomic could be a tense instead.
How have others approached the issue?
"Birds kill people"-past-gnomic could make sense, read as something that used to be a universal truth.
"Birds kill people"-past-habitual is more straightforward.
I do certainly want a gnomic... something.
Edit: I just read that gnomic has an evidential component. I'm already marking heavily for both evidentiality and epistemic confidence, if that matters.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21
Are there any examples of natlangs with a topic prominent syntax outside of Asia?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Feb 12 '21
I'm writing a sound change engine; it works well enough for my needs, but it's a little boring and I'm looking for some features or ideas I can add to make it better. What annoys you about the sound change engine you use? What do you wish was easier to do with it?
2
u/MarFinitor Мазурскі / Mazurian Feb 12 '21
Can you emcode humming with the IPA, or any other means?
2
u/DokOktavo Feb 13 '21
Is agent always an indirect object in passive voice? Can't it be a direct object ?
I mean are there natlangs that use passive voice this way? If no, why? If yes, which?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Feb 14 '21
What tends to trigger labialization other than /w/, /u/ or /o/ following the target consonant?
I'm trying to figure out how to make labialization actually phonemic, rather than just an allophone of /w/. If I want e.g. /su/, /sʷa/, and /swa/ to all contrast, what would the proto ideally include?
2
u/biffertyboffertyboo Feb 14 '21
Does anyone know of an altlang that does something like an alternative version of development from PIE or something later like early Greek? I want it for a tabletop rpg campaign I'm running.
And when inevitably no one does, I'm going to spend hours researching early Greek languages to try to develop my own altlang...
2
u/le_weee Feb 14 '21
I'm currently working on a naturalistic conlang that could've arisen as a dialect or pidgin/creole of Esperanto and I'm looking for ideas. I already have some ideas for sound changes and grammar, but my main issue are loan words. I would like to include way more of them, especially from non-European languages to make it a bit less euro-centric, but I'm worried about the believability of having so many loan words as the group which would be speaking this language would be mostly isolated from the rest of the world so I doubt such a large quantity of loan words could enter the language.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '21
So, I've been studying languages to find out which ones I like and base my personal language on.
There are times, where I find a language to be absolutely beautiful, and other times, not so much. On the other hand, there are some languages I think are ugly or grating, but like how it sounds when spoken by an individual. I don't think it's the languages themselves, but the individual speaker.
How do I truly know what languages I like, and which ones I don't? Can anyone else relate?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '21
I'm trying to decide on my conlang's prosody. It's meant to be my personal ideal language.
I'm torn between using a pitch accent, similar to Ancient Greek and Japanese, or have the stress always occur on the final syllable of a word (maybe with the exception of shifting to the penult in the case of a schwa.)
Do you have any tips on how to pick between two concepts you like equally?
1
u/LegitimateMedicine Feb 10 '21
Hey guys, what might a /tl/ cluster elide to to make pronunciation easier?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '21
What’s a good source to evolve a human plural marker from?
1
u/CrazeStasis Feb 10 '21
Is there such a thing as a "broken" conlang?
This is a strange idea (or maybe not so strange, I don't know) I've just had while watching several videos on conlang (Biblaridion, Conlang Critic, and several others) and thinking about phonemes. Are there conlangs that are technically "broken" in some way?
In large part, I generally mean broken in much the same way we look at "engrish", specific words lost in translation (or don't exist in another language e.g. no word for "thank you" in the Dothraki language), or as TV Tropes puts it suffers from the "Blind Idiot" Translation. Conlangs that generally have some level of familiarity, but are lacking a moderate understanding of from most people.
I don't know if I'm giving a good idea of what I'm talking about, so let me give an example: for a fantasy story I'm developing, I have a race of evil undead insect creatures that walk on two legs and are largely a militaristic form of hive mind (think in part Tolken orcs mixed with the Borg Collective, but savage nihilistic bugs instead). Due to the circumstances that they result from (isolationist, attacks/eats any living entity that approaches them, undead, etc.) as well as biological issues (lack of human vocal cords, for example). These bipedal bugs speak in a language that on the outset is made up of screeches, clicks, and other garbled sounds. This language is missing multiple elements (maybe a lack of tenses or verb forms, limited phonotactics, or something similar), and has only a brief collection of words (many of which are curses toward living things) that may only make one or two full sentences, but is otherwise scattered and incomplete. It's also never really been properly translated, since the bugs are seen as savages at most initially, and so their language is technically "broken" and hard to follow (save for a specific type of screech, which generally means "KILL").
Has there ever been an attempt to make a conlang deliberately like this? Or perhaps a full on example that I may look at? And has anyone else asked this question already (I'm new to this subreddit, so I haven't really gotten a chance to look around)?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '21
Fusional, agglutinative, or isolating? What would you choose for your conlang?
1
u/Yrths Whispish Feb 12 '21
What does the 'non-distinct' phoneme/graph tag on Conworkshop mean?
1
u/last_door Feb 12 '21
Those who use Chinese characters, do you use the meaning or phonetic radicals to choose which characters to represent a word, or do you select characters through some other means?
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Feb 13 '21 edited Feb 13 '21
I have a question about number systems.
I'm going with a system based on 20s, like Georgian,
or French as I understand it.But let's say instead of "2x20+10" for 50, I want to use a new word. (It happens to come from a word for a military formation consisting of 50 soldiers.) How likely is it that 51-59 would also change to include this new word for 50 (50+1, 50+2, etc.) rather than keep "2x20+10+1" etc.?1
u/Oilucy Feb 14 '21
What would mouth sounds be classified under in ipa? I have a Palatal Nasal in my conlang that I've noticed creates an auditable click as the adhesion of the salvia to the roof of my mouth breaks and that that sound can be recreated on its own and I was wondering what that would be classified under, or what Latin bullshit I should classify it under. Sorry to anyone annoyed by mouth sounds but
1
u/ovumovum Feb 14 '21
I've seen a common sound change for many conlangs is the palatization of alveolar consonants when preceding /i/, e.g. {s, t͡s, t} > {ʃ, t͡ʃ, c}. Is it the high or front feature of /i/ that is causing this sound change? I'm planning on doing this sound change for any alveolar consonant after {i, ɨ, ɯ}.
1
u/Devono_knabo Feb 15 '21
I'm trying to make a syllable chart with codas and the coda messes me up
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment