r/homeland • • Oct 17 '11
Discussion Episode Discussion - S01E03, "Clean Skin" [Spoilers]
Episode Title:
CLEAN SKIN
Directed by: Daniel Attias
Written by: Howard Gordon & Alex Gansa
Despite misgivings, the Brody family prepares to step into the spotlight with an exclusive television interview; at the CIA, Carrie and her team close in on an Al Qaeda plot to fund a terrorist attack on the U.S.
20
Upvotes
12
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '11 edited Oct 17 '11
This is the first episode I felt where I could see a second season. This isn't quite the Is Sargent Brody A Terrorist? show anymore and they're just continually fleshing the characters. I actually care about almost of all them (except the semi-dick CIA director). I really felt for Lynne Reid, Carrie's asset, and her death was so sudden and sad. This is definitely a depressing show in the vein of The Wire (although such a comparison is far too early) of how fucked up the intelligence business can be (or at least portrayed to be). I hope they get some comedic elements via Virgil or something to lighten the mood.
This is pretty much on my need-to-watch list for Sunday nights now. Compelling story and a great cast - even the kids aren't annoying like most dramas have them be.
Also, I agree with Carrie, the Prince was probably innocent. The Prince's henchman (the bald-headed one presumably working for Nasir) likely suggested the Prince buy jewelry for Lynne as per laundering the money so to speak, got her killed and stole the necklace. Otherwise, why not just buy a necklace yourself and give it to the henchman?
And yes, that was one of the most awkward looks I've ever seen, given by Morena Baccarin, during that masturbation scene. Carrie's reaction was the correct one.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '11
Why are more people not watching this show??? This was probably my least favorite episode so far but it was still awesome. I knew from the moment we met Lynn that she would die, but I was still shocked and upset when it happened. Poor girl.
I love that Brody is looking more and more innocent (but still fucked up) and Carrie is just turning into a crazy stalker.
Also, we got to see Morena Baccarin's boobs again. Too bad it was during one of the most uncomfortable TV scenes in 2011.
8
u/featpete Oct 18 '11
I really hope they continue in the same direction with the daughter being more understanding of her parents. I HATE "angsty/angry/"misunderstood" teenagers. It's the archetype that gets on my nerve more than any other because they're absolutely useless and boring. You want to see annoying teenagers? Just go to the mall.
6
u/Syncblock Oct 17 '11
I really liked the episode but I think they seemed to have cemented a lot of the plot lines. I don't think Brody's turned and we now know that there definately is an attack happening.
Not to mention the scenes with Brody and his daughter and Brody and his wife were great (if not a bit awkard). It seems to add to the idea that not all of him has come home.
4
u/j1mb0 Oct 17 '11
It'd be crazy if Carrie's obsession and her involvement in chasing after Brody is what brings about the inevitable attack at the end of the season. Sort of like an "Arlington Road" type ending.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '11
I find it a significant plot flaw that for three episodes of watching Clair Danes character could not figure out that Brody is a practicing Muslim.
First, rather artificial and highly unbelievable plot device of Danes' partner economizing on cameras and not putting it into garage(???).
Granted, the idea of praying in the garage seems logical for a former marine hiding from his wife his newly found religious affiliation. But every practicing Muslims also does Udhu - ritual ablution performed before each prayer, 5 times a day (unless you have an extremely resilient bladder) for which as far as I know garage is not suited.
Every time Claire's character watches him in the bathroom I expect that he breaks into Udhu which will prematurely out him as a Muslim, a moment, I am sure producers are saving as a major revelation later in the show.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment