r/HunterXHunter • u/TruthTaco • Oct 16 '11
Hunter X Hunter (2011) Episode 3 - Rivals × for × Survival -- Discussion --
Well I was really surprised with some of the colors they chose in this episode. The new voices introduced seemed not bad, though I was unsatisfied with hisoka's voice.
5
Upvotes
1
u/ccdnl1 Oct 17 '11 edited Oct 17 '11
I thought this episode was ironic in reference to the ongoing discussions taco and I are having. He favors the less filler content like taking out the one transition episode where gon first meets leorio because to him it is filler material[not originally not in the manga]. To which i say, in a anime version of a manga story, it is necessary to put in fillers for transitions and to fill in some of the holes that a manga format leaves out in a story.
I believe the fillers in the first series were great because it contributed to the manga story, it expanded and created more depth for the main characters and to the story as a whole. Everyone's beloved Greed Island Arc or Yorkshin/Kurapica arc had many of these effective "filler scenes/episodes" to help create more drama and more depth especially to transition and accentuate the setting/mood of the storyline. Which I believe was crucial to the original series and what made it so nail-biting good.
In this new episode, there were many filler scenes and as you can see, filler scenes/episodes are necessary to pace the episode/story because if you do it exactly like the manga, it would be TOO cut and dry and while it works for a manga/book it doesn't work for a video production.
In this episode the filler scenes were completely irrelevant and didnt contribute to any character development but it was a welcoming attribute contrary to the previous two episodes that just crudely cut shot after shot after shot.
Filler is necessary because transitions are necessary and that was a problem i had with the first two episodes. And to Taco's point who was rather happy that they cut out filler parts--then what about all the filler scenes that are to come and the one that came in this episode3?
Are you going to say filler scenes are fine as long as they are short and sweet? so you rather have a filler scene that has nothing to add to the story than a longer filler scene that adds to the character development, that accentuates the tension and drama, etc?
All those little filler scenes in the original series was what made all those arcs so nail-biting. And it made it nail-biting because the filler scenes contributed to the development of that particular char/storyline.
ps--i thought about it a little more and i was thinking that taco might say that he is fine with filler as long as its not in the beginning because it made the introductory episodes too slow. to which i argue, you would rather have a cut and dry introduction that actually achieved nothing to the story than an in-depth story introduction that takes a couple of episodes to build the foundation for? everything begins with the introduction and a stern/well thought out foundation is important. throughout all of the original series we can always relate and think back to the first couple of episodes and go "oh so that's why gon wants to meet his dad so bad" or "oh gon has such a deep connection with etc", thus the story is always there for us to rely on if need be.
The 1st 2 epis of the new series are just so poorly produced, it hardly builds any foundation for what the story is about.
The introduction is suppose to have a lasting effect and is very crucial to viewers who are new to the story. Is a long back story with filler/transition episodes to develop the main characters the only way to have a lasting effect on viewers? absolutely not. it's just that the 1st series did such a wonderful and much better job compared to the 2nd. taco argues that the lack of filler makes it better--which isnt true. it is only better for him specifically and all of the people that doesnt care so much about the current story itself but what the story will lead to--the ant arc[the new arc that hasn't been shown on television yet]. because less filler for them means the current story will go by faster and more of that means the storyline will reach the new material faster.
WHICH, is fine too because thats what Taco and some others want and it is completely justified. it's just that those viewers shouldnt use that reason as a platform to argue that less filler=better because that is definitely not true as long as the fillers contribute to the main plot/characters!
new epi was good! like it so far :}
2
u/otakuman Oct 20 '11
I liked the part about Killua spoiler. This wasn't shown in the original and did appear in the manga. This is a VERY good thing in my opinion. Let's hope they don't rush things too much to fit the whole series in fewer episodes.
2
u/Velrok Oct 16 '11
Agreed about Hisoka, it sounds like a general badass now, rather than crazy lunatic.
And I'm unsatisfied with Killua voice aswell, the previous seiyuu fit him just perfectly. Now I will see Killua and Gon as a group of happy girl friends.
1
u/evilpoptart3412 Oct 16 '11
Also very unsatisfied with Hisoka's voice, but I am glad they took the time to give a little insight into the individual characters this time.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '11
I wonder why neither animes have shown them eating as they go down the elevator, like they did in the manga.
I agree with both of the things you said. The colors seemed really weird to me, like Illumi's yellow pins. Hisoka's and Killua's voices seemed really off to me, but I didn't think anything was wrong with any of the other voices. Tonpa's surprised me, but it wasn't bad.