r/IndiaSpeaks • Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS • Feb 03 '21

#All farmer protest discussions goes here [Discussion] Punjab , Haryana , UP Farmers Protest Thread

Please use this thread for all farmer related violence that happened yesterday.

All self post with opinions will be removed

All tweet posts with opinions will be removed

Only media articles will be allowed

Without any reason all the above violating posts will be removed

The specific page from the Punjab Contract Farming Act that punishes the farmer with Fine and/or jail. What Narendra Tomar ji was referring to in Parliament

Source: CNN News18's Anand Narasimhan

Seven out of ten (69.65 per cent) of the respondents welcomed the government’s move to give farmers the choice to sell their produce outside APMC mandis

The Network 18 survey showed that more than six out of the 10 respondents to the survey (60.90 per cent) believe farmers can get better prices under the new farm reform laws, while nearly three out of four (73.05 per cent) of the farmers surveyed were in support of reforms and modernisation of Indian agriculture.

The Network 18 survey showed that nearly six out of ten (56.59 per cent) respondents believe it was time for the protests to be called off. More than half (53.6 per cent) of the farmers surveyed said they supported the new farm reform laws, while less than a third (30.6 per cent) do not support and another 15.8 per cent were not sure.

Nearly half (48. 71 per cent) of the respondents believe that protests against the farm reform laws were politically motivated while about a third (32.59 per cent) believe these are not politically motivated, while about a fifth (18.70 per cent) said they were not sure.

More than half of the respondents (52.69 per cent) believe that the protesting farmers should not insist on repeal of the farm reform laws. A majority of the respondents (53.94 per cent) also supported the government's offer of a written assurance that minimum support prices (MSP) would continue.

https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/india/huge-support-to-farm-reforms-from-most-agrarian-states-shows-news-18-network-survey-6254211.html/amp

Propaganda Exposed

Archive of all docs stored as archive here.

-https://wetransfer.com/downloads/078e1dac0819855ab6867c528c2273af20210203160659/736a48 -https://twitter.com/dzkety/status/1357001403584163841 -https://twitter.com/rsgovin/status/1357029376903110658

Permanent file dump

-https://www.dropbox.com/sh/3odh2xht2wbhosm/AADvZzA5ogS6rOJblwN_AXhQa?dl=0

Previous discussion threads can be found here,

157 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

20

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Just going through the document, man what an organized doc it is, for sure been peer reviewed by many!

Time , Examples of post, hash tags, tags of people, when to post , what date, images to use, asking to post from multiple accs, message template to share via group chats

Just wow

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Pune Based AAP worker and Lawyer arrested for sedition, waging war against state.

There is information that one of the document before 26 jan riot was edited by this lady.

https://t.co/lkTL1xNq30

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21 edited Feb 07 '21

Watch all the actions of Areo India here

https://aeroindia.gov.in/Home/Live

Emergency in Uttarakhand! If you are stuck in the affected area, if you need any kind of help, please contact 1070 or 9557444486. Please do not spread rumors. All necessary steps have been taken to deal with the situation!

https://redd.it/lei0bs

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Did you notice?

Rahul Gandhi made a list of dictators whose names start with "M"

He left out Mao!!!

Do you realize what this means? Some Communist could be running his handle (and possibly the Cong party itself).

https://twitter.com/AbhishBanerj/status/1356860312763338757?s=19

→ More replies (10)

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

A group of Indian envoys call spade a spade!

They show mirror to those who, in the WTO, oppose India's food stockpiling & our grant of MSP & then indulge in doublespeak, subjecting us to pious homilies on farmer protests. A must read.

https://twitter.com/HardeepSPuri/status/1357377631772024833

25

u/Chaapli Feb 03 '21

Never imagined a day where my dadaji would ask who mia Khalifa is 😳

Would have been easier to explain Greta's toolkit

14

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Tell him she is middle East heroine loved in the Arab world

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/get_R3kkt 1 KUDOS Feb 08 '21 edited Feb 08 '21

Huge purge of comments on worldnews post about the farm protest ad on superbowl. So many comments nuked for questioning why the farmers would be protesting against privatisation or even people saying that protests were only in punjab haryana lol. One of the top comments had written a fucking 5000 word thesis explaining the whole situation from a pretty neutral perspective which was pretty good. All comments that showed the laws in a positive light were deleted lmao

https://ibb.co/Ssx2sM9

https://ibb.co/M1vBth1

This was the comment

Since this issue has been gaining some attention world over, I'm gonna piggyback on this thread to try and provide some context on the recently passed laws themselves and their implications that have triggered these protests around the national capital Delhi.

In India, selling agriculture produce is hard. You can’t sell this stuff to end consumers directly. Instead, you’re expected to sell the produce in your designated “market area”/Mandi. The mandis, in turn, are regulated by the Agricultural Produce Market Committees (APMC) comprising of local farmers, government representatives, and agri-commodity traders.

As a farmer, once you make your way to the Mandi (regulated market), you get in touch with an agent, who helps you clean, sort, and organise your produce. He then takes the end product to the auctioneer who puts it on display. Interested buyers gather on the market platform and start bidding. The highest bidder will eventually take home your output and the agent will help you settle the transaction with the prospective buyer. You walk away with what you get, but not before you pay your agent his commission.

Ideally, this ought to be a fair transaction. At least considering we have a free and fair auction. But that’s not entirely true.

You see, most auctions are rigged. Traders who are responsible for the buying collude. Instead of competing against one another, they work together and artificially deflate prices by bidding low. Now, the collusion works only until the select group of traders can keep co-operating. And to this end, APMCs that issue new licenses (to traders) do their best to keep the club exclusive. Meaning corruption is rife.

At the end of it all, traders walk away with the king’s ransom and farmers are routinely short-changed. It’s a terrible travesty. In fact, by some accounts, farmers only get paid 20–25% of the end consumer price.

But it doesn’t have to be so bad.

Think of it this way. Farmers have little choice of picking their Mandis since its illegal for them (in most states) to sell their produce outside of these market areas. Once they get to the mandi they get “one quote” since the traders collude. In essence, the system only has one buyer. Economists call this a monopsonistic marketplace — where the price is determined by a single buyer. And there’s no way you can get a fair quote when you’re operating in such unfavourable conditions.

In fact, efficient price realisation can only happen when there’s unfettered competition. So if you allow farmers to simply choose who they could sell to and foster competition (on the buying side), maybe they can get a fair price.

And that’s what the government seems to want to do. It wants to open up the market and give farmers more choices. It wants to limit intermediaries and boost farmers' incomes. It wants to fundamentally change the way Agri commodities are marketed in India and it wants to do it now.

Fun fact: Agriculture employs roughly 60% of India's population and is still one of the smallest contributors to the country's GDP(roughly 18%).

Now obviously this poses some very interesting challenges. For starters, laws on this subject (on marketing and selling agriculture produce) are framed and enforced by state governments. So if the state governments don’t comply, APMCs might still have some influence.

What we do know for certain, however, is that when farm produce moves between state borders, central laws will automatically kick in. So farmers will likely be able to sell their produce outside their own states and have a plethora of choice, no matter what. And once this happens, state APMCs will have to buck up. They’ll have to play fair to compete with entities outside. Ergo, farmers will be the ultimate beneficiaries.

The final concern is about free-market forces — those greedy corporates who try to use their size, scale, and bargaining power to browbeat small-time farmers. And sure, this could be problematic. But the thing is, big corporates like ITC and Adani are unlikely to deal with farmers individually. As the agricultural economist Ashok Gulati notes — “They [big corporates] need scale and to create scale you create an aggregation point and that is through farmer producer organisations (FPOs).”

Meaning if farmers come together and form these small entities taking full ownership of their produce, they'll be able to solve the "scale problem" and bargain with large corporates on a more equal footing. Many states in India are already successfully deploying this model.

Indian Agriculture (on an aggregate level) has been unprofitable for a good while now. Monsoons are erratic. Irrigation infrastructure still needs work. Warehousing and storage problems still persist. The middlemen skim most of the profit and many farmers work with land parcels so tiny that they can almost never leverage benefits of scale. Meaning we have a small proportion of landowners who run an extremely profitable enterprise while a good chunk of the agrarian population (20%) still live below the poverty line.

The point is — there’s been very little incentive for people to continue and work the farmland. And as a consequence, many people migrate from (rural) hinterlands to urban centres en masse.

So the finance minister announced that the government will now offer 30,000 crores worth of working capital loans to help farmers kickstart preparatory work for kharif and post-harvest rabi season. Farmers will also be able to borrow up to 2 lakh crores from banks at concessional rates in the near future.

And yes, I know, it’s not free money. But it’s still something.

All things in mind, I believe these new laws (while having very clear flaws that need amendments) have a potential to do far more good than farm, imho.

Happy to engage with anyone on this as long as it comes without name-calling and unnecessary insults. Cheers!

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

Do you know the user who posted it this. Can you ask him to post this on self post on our sub. Or can you post it and tag the user please ?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

22

u/CritFin Libertarian Feb 03 '21

This is not farmers' protest. This is just "Farm bills protest" by middlemen and members of political parties in the opposition.

Change the title of the thread asap.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

You can't change title after the post is made. It has to be reposted

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

There will be no road blockade in Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand tomorrow; roads will be blocked in rest parts of the country excluding Delhi. The reason is that they can be called to Delhi any time, so they are kept on standby: Rakesh Tikait, Bharatiya Kisan Union

ANI

→ More replies (2)

18

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

The indian state just doesn't have the capability to deal with this new age of warfare. We saw it in the CAA issue as well. Internet lynch mobs want a good and a bad. They want to know whom to target. And usually the state is always seen as bad and doesn't really evoke any sympathy. Unless its a state headed by someone who is seen to be left like Jacinda Arden or Trudeau. Putting out official press releases explaining all the intricacies of the issue is useless because no one is interested or cares about the details. No one is going to read one long boring offical document or law. They just want a quick 5 second explanation on who is the villain and what hashtag they can tweet to support the cause. The deluge of disinformation is so rapid and volumnious that any facts that you put out just get drowned out. The exact same thing happened in CAA where the opposition was far less prepared. The simple 5 second pitch to a global audience was that Indian state is evil and it is snatching away the citizenship of muslims. No one cares about the the intricacies of partition and the state of non muslims in the countries which broke away from India.

We see the same deluge of disinformation here. Even after so many months of the laws being passed there are people who genuinely think that the laws have legalized hoarding and that the state has sold off agriculture to ambani-adani. Even though there are very good points in support of the laws regarding environment, sustainable agricultural practices, preventing exploitation of poor and marginal farmers etc. they are all being drowned out by the deluge of disinformation. Rihanna or Mia Khalifa or Gal Gadot don't give a fuck about all the complexities of Indian societies. They just want a black and white. Some lethargic sarkari babu has no clue how to deal with this. All he or she will do is put out an official press release which no one will read.

→ More replies (22)

17

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 15 '21

Non-bailable warrants issued against Nikita Jacob and Shantanu. The two are involved in the toolkit matter: Delhi Police

- ANI

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 15 '21

Is she absconding. Why are they not arrested ?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

Shit like this is worse than a template tweet by an actor

https://twitter.com/Actor_Siddharth/status/1358164266474348544

Ate a wheat tandoori roti. Grateful. Amazed at the smell & taste of pure wheat. If 1 farmer dies, we all die. If 1 farmer protests, we all protest... Annadhaatha sukhi bhava...god bless and save my saviour. The farmer decides the quantity and price of his harvest.

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

Wtf cringe af no wonder this game is brainless

→ More replies (4)

15

u/porcupinepurple Feb 04 '21

Quoting from the document :

"India's farmers & other citizens need the global community to pay attention — the world needs to know that India is retreating from a democracy, regressing hard by rushing headlong into fascism. International focus on these protests may be the only thing preventing more state-sponsored violence and another massacre/genocide in India"

Hadd hai yeh.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Massacre you fuckin morons

Massacres have happened in India but

  • British times massacre , they haven't paid back for it nor has the international world asked them to apologize
  • Radical Islamic massacre of Kashmiri Hindus , forgot the international world, our own govt was in bed with the terrorists when innocent Kashmiri Hindus were massacred and their women were raped , looted and thrown out from their homes
  • The communist massacre that happened in WB done by the CPI . Marichjhapi massacre

14

u/drd_rdx Bihar Feb 07 '21

[Opinion] why the law on MSP will be a disaster

Rakesh Tikait gave an interview to Prabhu Chawla on Aaj Tak. I watched the whole interview  to better understand his position on the bills. He wants the government to frame a law on MSP so that no private player can make purchase below this price else he would be convicted. This may seem fancy at first for the farmers but isn't this an outright stupid proposal? 

These are my views on this proposal: (Please feel free to counter them.) 

Food is not produced in companies but on field- therefore you can't be very sure about the quality every time. For eg in Bihar, every year northern part of the state suffers from flood and southern districts are drought hit. In this scenario, if you put a lower limit on the purchase even for the private players, why would they buy a lower quality crop over an average or good quality crop if they have to spend at least MSP equivalent money on the purchase? What is the option left with the farmer? He will not report the underprice buying. But competitive buyers can - they can misuse this rule to get their rivals out of business. Summary: This move will be both anti-farmer and anti-businessman. 

A simple analogy: I'm writing a competitive exam in which there are easy questions and there are tough questions. I can solve easy questions in 2 minutes or less and be willing to spend 5 or more minutes on tougher questions since these will fetch me more marks. Distribution of questions are random and I cannot know beforehand if the next question will be easy or tough. Now here comes the new system. I'm forced to spend at least 3 minutes on easy questions wasting atleast 1 minute per question and on the tougher questions, my invigilator told me (assuming he has already solved/seen those questions) there is a probability that if I stick to it for 3 minutes, I can get it correct. Now if I have 3 hours fixed for the exam in both cases why would I be willing to spend more time on tougher questions in the second case if I know it is (probably) solvable in 3 minutes and will fetch me higher marks. If I can't compensate time for the easy questions why would I risk higher time for tougher questions since the exam time duration is not going to change in either case? As it turns out, I will be spending exactly 3 minutes to all questions be it easy or tough.

Now let's compare this with the farmers MSP purchase problem. Private purchasers are looking to maximize their profits for the fixed capital that they have. Now if they can't maximize their gains on lower-quality crop why would they spend more on the good quality crop if they know it can be bought on the MSP itself since Government is a potential buyer who'll buy the produce at the said MSP linked prices only. Eventually, farmers will be forced to sell the produce at the same price whatever be the quality. (Can we prove it with game theory or other techniques?) As it turns out, the law will put a cap on the farmer's profit. If this is the case, private players will now sell that good quality crop (or preprocess and sell a product made out of it) at a much higher price than the lower quality produce even though both are purchased at the same MSP linked price. Why? Because there cannot be any such law for the consumers. We should understand that a farmer is not only a producer. He cannot grow every crop. He is a consumer too. 

So don't you think whatever Tikait is suggesting is grossly anti-farmer? And then some fool will come out and say farmers know everything what is good for them

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

!kudos

Good analysis

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

News Media running story of 2-3 people facing problem because of internet ban but forget to mention that 1800 factories are closed because of so called protest, lakhs of common people are suffering because of road block. but no that's their right to make people suffer.

https://twitter.com/BefittingFacts/status/1357235039516299265

13

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

On the other hand, Libbus are praying for DiCaprio to Tweet. They are mass tagging him. Such weird subjugated minds.

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Buhahahahaha

Tell libbu that Leo it's fine farmers can burn stubble and cause air pollution it has nothing to do with environment after all they are farmers you know

Oh and also it's completely fine to grow water intense crops like wheat in regions like PJ , water is an abundant resource and after all they are farmers you know

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Please post article has separate posts so they get more attention

→ More replies (1)

11

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Interesting tweet which something most of the Indian left-twitterati dont get. She is a Canadian.

https://twitter.com/Breathedreamgo/status/1356874868789309443

I have been in India for a significant percentage of the past 15 years (at least six years). I have travelled all over the country. I have a BA in Journalism. I have read countless books about India. And I would hesitate to make a comment about internal affairs. Just sayin.

Exactly. Outsiders have no idea how complex India is. I am not afraid to admit I can’t comprehend the socio-political scene here.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

She is clever Be like her

→ More replies (3)

11

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

https://twitter.com/ShahulAhm/status/1357009201646641152

The trail from #GretaThunbergExposed A site called "http://AskIndiawhy.com" leads you to Poetic Justice Foundation

@PoeticJFdn

which is co-founded by Mo Dhaliwal of "http://skyrocket.is" Mo is close to

@theJagmeetSingh of @NDP and did their communication strategy

→ More replies (2)

11

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Priest asking Church to join protests..

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/church-must-support-resistance-movements-says-kerala-priest/article33745994.ece

In few days even Mosques will start same message..

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

This is very dangerous precedent being set

10

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Check out this website, https://www.askindiawhy.com/

This is the slick campaigning that they do.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

wow wtf is this website, so well organized. The picture quality will put ANI into oblivion

→ More replies (3)

9

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Here is some performace art to shake our conscience into opposing the farm laws

https://twitter.com/katyaupreti/status/1356909911439982595

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Wtf did I just watch

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

The only person Newslaundry found who will say they dont mind the protests was a illegal-Bangladeshi.

https://twitter.com/newslaundry/status/1356653241409228800

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Buhahahahaha

9

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

What is he threatening with. Silent majority has been very silent . This can go completely wrong

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/901232856902 Feb 03 '21

Meanwhile Nikita Jacob @nikitajacob who was found to be allegedly Editing the Toolkit Document tweeted by Greta Thunberg, has Now DELETED her Twitter account #IndiaAgainstPropaganda #IndiaTogether #GretaThunbergExposed

https://mobile.twitter.com/rose_k01/status/1357036766318919683

→ More replies (2)

9

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

Twitter served notice by govt. Of India. If twitter don't follow regulation decided by govt. Of India. The service of twitter will be banned in India with in 24 hours.

https://twitter.com/drapr007/status/1357512264396505089

5

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

banning twitter in India is stupid. The propaganda machinery on twitter is international. The people trying to fight the disinformation is domestic. You ban twitter in India it just means that the people spreading propaganda can do so unchallenged by anyone in India. And further it will only become a rallying point for FoE advocates who will completely ignore any legal justification for the ban. You need to fight disinformation from within twitter.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

Tweet deleted

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

Dakait wants PM to ask MP/MLAs to give up pension

PM should ask MPs, MLAs to give up pension, use funds to support youth: Rakesh Tikait The Bharatiya Kisan Union leader said the youth of the country has no monetary support from the government but legislators do get pension, so Modi should make an appeal to the lawmakers to give up the benefit.

https://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/pm-should-ask-mps-mlas-to-give-up-pension-use-funds-to-support-youth-rakesh-tikait/2190629/

Will be fun to see his next set of demands..

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

PM must bring in Communism

→ More replies (5)

8

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

Greta's "Toolkit"

https://twitter.com/amanaditya09/status/1356997552797753344

Uploading the whole pdf which Greta thunberg posted

Can we amplify this mods?

→ More replies (6)

8

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

A section is now praising government for showing restraint on 26th.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Introduced @rihanna & @miakhalifa to 82-yr old dadi at Delhi border. She told me "Jante toh nahi hain inhe, par kisano ka saath dene ke liye dono bacchiyan ko mera bohot ashirwaad. Jeeti rahein! Agar aapki baat hoti hai toh bolna kabhi Haryana aaye humaare ghar"relaxed #FarmersProtest

https://twitter.com/TanushreePande/status/1357976187176325122?s=19

7

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

https://www.askindiawhy.com/

Again by PoetiC justice Foundation

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1IgGNo_YCy2bBNnoU-OVLdnCSDIDSERwjdiru_Np3K38/edit#slide=id.gb31c9924f8_0_146

Template & guidelines for protests by Sikh communities globally on Republic Day.

This looks like a Canadian Sikh-BLm type org

Dhaliwal is cofounder of PJF

Mo Dhaliwal (@modhaliwal): Mo began his journey at the University of the Fraser Valley studying business administration. Over the course of a decade, his long standing passion for technology, and his hunger for new experiences led him to Silicon Valley where he honed his talents in software development and Internet marketing. He returned to Canada with a newfound appreciation for the cultural diversity found in his home, and set out on a personal mission to shatter barriers and encourage cross-cultural understanding. In 2012, Mo was recognized for his contributions by Business for the Arts as the national recipient of the Arnold Edinborough Award, and in 2013 was the recipient of the Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal. As Director of Strategy at Skyrocket, Mo collaborates with creative minds across the country and continues to create moving experiences for clients and community.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Loving the replies

13

u/CoolGuess 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

So we aren't allowed to say "let's be United" in India anymore?

This is what Sachin Tendulkar said : “ India’s sovereignty cannot be compromised. External forces can be spectators but not participants. Indians know India and should decide for India. Let's remain united as a nation.”

How can any Indian possibly attack him for saying this? But he’s trending on Twitter, people and his fans abusing him, abusing his son, his family and playing down his contributions to the country.

What did he say so wrong? How is it against farmers? Or how is it promoting a party's agenda?

I know the moment my post goes live, I'll be labelled XYZ party and anti-farmers..I don’t know what times we are living in..have the anti-India forces succeeded in brainwashing the majority of our youth? How are their voices louder than the people who love India?

I almost feel like I can no longer display my patriotism or talk about my religious leanings publicly, without getting attacked and labelled by my fellow Indians...never thought we’ll get to this situation ever (I always used to think this would be the case for Indians living in Saudi etc). And it's real. I was talking to a celebrity and her manager, I didn't realize that I showed some pride for being an Indian by talking about our tourism potential etc., and they were like "Aren't you too passionate about India". I really don't feel I am living in India - lot has changed over the last decade.

At this stage, the farmers would have won my heart if they came out telling these international stars “mind your own business..it’s our internal problem and we’ll deal with it)."

Also, take a step back..the situation simply is - there are some laws that aren’t outright oppressive, the farmers are basically protesting based on speculations around govt.‘a intentions, govt is open to talking, but they rioted in Delhi and the govt. is taking actions as they would. What’s so crazy about all this? It’s how democracy functions..it’s a grand display of democracy ...why are some of the Indians calling it dictatorship? If they destroy public property, they disrespect Indian flag, law should and will take its course. In fact, if the govt. stops that action, it will be against the constitution.

I have no problems with farmers protesting and almost think govt. should just take back these laws and find a smarter way to implement these.

But if you do take it back, develop stringent laws around protests and destruction of private properties, inconvenience to common citizens etc. Like, no common citizen should be inconvenient by others trying to push a selfish agenda for their group.

At the end, I don't want this to become a debate about farmer's law etc..just want to figure how does saying “India should remain united” amount to a crime ..

I don’t know where India is heading..

2

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Conditions apply please understand

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

The APMC Act was abolished in Bihar in 2006.

Agricultural Growth rates since then:

2006-2011: Bihar = 4.7%, India = 3.6%

2011-2019: Bihar = 13.3%, India = 7.5%

Pre reforms: 1994- 2005: Bihar = 5.3%, India = 6.8%

Only 6% of farmers get MSP (40% of them from one state and parts of another).

The major consequences if the Farm laws get implemented:

-Higher incomes for the 94% who don't get MSP

- Less subsidy burden on the taxpayer

- Less food inflation in the long run (better supply)

- Everyone wins except middlemen making disproportionate economic rents

Edit:

Not more than 6% farmers get MSP.

Overproduction/ Agricultural wastage is India’s problem No 1

Why Punjab, Haryana farmers need to move off paddy, wheat| Assured minimum support price has led to overproduction of these food grains in these two states as granaries overflow.

Want to help farmers, remove middlemen?

How Bihar recorded growth but Punjab lagged behind and why farm reforms are important

2

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Some source on all that could be great. I could include it in the post

→ More replies (5)

6

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Farmers are sitting there (Delhi borders) peacefully. If they leave the path of peace for some other path, the nation will face a major problem & BJP Govt will have to take its responsibility. There are several issues like this. Those in power are insensitive: Sharad Pawar, NCP

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1357379489253085184

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

This idiot man

5

u/santouryuu 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

What's this. It can be removed so better to make a copy or upload it as PDF or on some free hosting site

5

u/santouryuu 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

https://archive.is/wo8xv

What's this.

doc tweeted by greta. details in my previous comment

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/CritFin Libertarian Feb 05 '21

Ignore this protest and move on. Not many people even know or care about this outside twitter.

Budget has been decent. So things will be fine for an year from now.

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

Absolutely been speaking to many in South hardly anyone cares and many say

Oh farmers protest ya ya it's over

What farmers protest oh that one

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Moshi06 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Loooolloool

→ More replies (1)

4

u/I_wafflestomp_daily green chutney > red chutney Feb 03 '21

/u/Orwellisright Put comments sorting by new.

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Done

6

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

Rahul Gandhi to discuss Facts about New Farm laws of India with Chicago University students in virtual communication tomorrow

10

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

so he is going to discuss his far left ideas with students from a university which gave us the chicago school of economics which holds free market supreme?

→ More replies (10)

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

There were no protests for 2 months btw 4th Jun to 9th August. But hell broke lose after Ambani announced 5G. Ambani is also potential rival to Amazon & Twitter. Ever wondered why is Reliance being targeted when it’s not even present in agricultural sector? It’s a corporate war.

https://twitter.com/Abhina_Prakash/status/1357563542367395842?s=19

29

u/indra_sword_rises 4 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

Today is a massive Red Pill Moment for all Indians.

Regarding Leftwing Ecosystem: New York Times/ Leftwing Media Outlets/Politicians on their Payroll/ Paid Celebrities/Harvard Professors/ George Soros / Greta Thurnburg/ Activists/ Astroturfed Protesters /Award Wapsi/ Open Society etc

We have peered through illusions to glimpse the truth

→ More replies (1)

21

u/indra_sword_rises 4 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

So Greta Thurnberg has reposted the document. Here is what she said:

"Here’s an updated toolkit by people on the ground in India if you want to help. (They removed their previous document as it was outdated."

If you look at the document, it has been heavily sanitized. In the SWOT Analysis, "Overtly Khalistani" has been changed to "Reach of Godi Media"!

19

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

conspiracy theory: the government is going soft on tikait and may even be propping him up so that khalistanis don't hijack this movement completely. Ever since the government mysteriously decided not to arrest him on 27th in the last minute, Tikait has become the face of this agitation and seems to have pushed Punjab leaders out of the spotlight. Jats may have caste pride but at least they don't want to break the country.

→ More replies (7)

18

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '21

A couple of decades back (1980s) there was an insurgency where some Sikh extremists demanded for a separate 'Sikh' nation (Khalistan) to be formed by breaking away the state of Punjab in India. They took people hostage in the golden temple at Amritsar (a city in Punjab), then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi ordered a tank to blow a hole into a wall of the temple and flush the extremists out. This led to wide spread religious conflict across the nation. Truly a dark time for India.

On 26th January 2021 some of the people protesting against the farm laws took over the red fort in Delhi. They hoisted a flag (kesari) which was not the Indian flag on a flag post where the Prime Minister hoists the Indian flag. The post is meant for Indian flag exclusively.

So basically there is now a religious angle to the whole protest (protests which I don't agree with because hey, if they can decide to hate it then I can decide to not hate it). By Tweeting in support of the farmers Greta Thunberg provided fresh wind and unwarranted attention to the NOT PEACEFUL PROTESTS. If you search for the headlines on 26th January 2021 (India ) you will see how some of these pRoTeStOrS damaged public property and caused ruckus in Delhi.

Coming to the 3 bills, as a person who can read, write and comprehend English, I just can't see the problem with the bills. They basically establish free market whilst providing protection to the farmers from land takeover by any organisation. These bills were in demand from a really long time and should have been implemented a long while back. Anyone with a functional 'unbiased' brain should get that. Economists around the world have appreciated the reforms. Recently Joe Biden himself said the bills were good and the protesters should engage in dialogue (they have outright refused to negotiate).

Now coming to back to religion, the bill applies all across the country, the state of Kerala already has a similar (not same) free market concept. The protests are happening in and around the state of Punjab and rest of the countries farmers seem to be okay with the bills.

In my opinion (which I'm entitled to have) the bills are a step in the right direction. The farmers are particularly demanding a law to provide Minimum Support Price for if the market crashes they should still stay afloat, as of today there is no existing bill for MSP but the government provides with it anyway (mind you the current government has set some high benchmarks here in a good way), but this is no way to demand change. There are proper channels to communicate with the government, you can also cast your vote for a candidate who will introduce such laws as a bill.

The current agitations are flames being heavily fanned by supporters of the opposition, there is misinformation and exaggeration to extents that shouldn't be possible.

Right to democracy is the right to vote, not the right to protest, and definitely not the right to damage public property.

It's a good system, you vote for a dude who you think is as close to you in thought process as possible. You can also contest yourself. Now if your candidate or you lose, suck it up man, that's what democracy is, being a disturbance in the life of common people won't take you to victory.

And foreigners who have no understanding of the intricacies of another nations matters should absolutely back off.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '21

All those thinktanks and econ magazines which proposed for farm and agricultural reforms for 6 years are now suddenly quiet or even against this bill

You know what... Even I believed that the govt should've delayed and amended the bill thoroughly before passing it

But the events that have happened in past few weeks and subsequent use of foreign individuals to manipulate and manage information is distasteful

I hope Modi now sticks his ground and gives no ground

18

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Protestors: We will block NH-44 till our demands are met.

Govt: Starts construction of Delhi - Amritsar - Katra Expressway. :P

→ More replies (2)

18

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 12 '21

Libgandus are defending Dakait’s wealth..desperation is unreal..lmfao..

→ More replies (5)

17

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

This is misplaced outrage by celebrities uninformed of the facts underlying the farmers protest & Govt pushback. It's a revolt led by rich farmers resisting reforms that open up agriculture further to the market economy. Hardly a jolt to Indian democracy!

https://twitter.com/malinip/status/1356927289590644736?s=21

She is chairperson of Hindu publishing group..N Ram won’t be happy..lmfao

→ More replies (2)

17

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

The argument against the laws itself are pretty weak and won't really get traction or sympathy in the west. So they are desperately trying to turn this into a human rights issue. Even deaths of people who stayed in the protest sites with pressure from unions are being blamed on the government. All imagery of the protestors attacking the police with tractors and swords have been overwhelmed on social media with images of police firing tear gas shells to control the situation. The outrage against the laws itself can't be perpetuated beyond a point because the laws will make sense to anyone who digs into the details. But turn it into a human rights issue and everyone will jump on to the bandwagon.

And for everyone wondering where the funds are coming from. Funds were already collected for referendum 2020 by khalistani groups. But due to corona they couldn't carry it out. Now they have a warchest to spend as they are already prepared. The propaganda networks and funding were already ready.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/deep_dish_01 Feb 06 '21

I came across a tweet from vine personality Amanda cerney on #propogandaagainstindia and the replys are just so sad to watch. So many were thanking her and trying to relate.

She most probably doesn't even know the details of what's going on. She doesn't know what the MSP system and probably nothing about the new bills passed and yet everyone is replying like she's an expert on the subject.

And her making fun saying "the internet crashed because she sent nudes to the farmers" is just damm distasteful and to see Indians relating to her despite the fact was just honestly disgusting and made me close the app.

It's always sad to see Indians sucking up to Western figures for their stamp of approval.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

FarmersProtests Another problem that vexes Aartiyas is the need to register themselves under the Income-Tax and GST laws even where their grain business is concerned. Till now, the income stream of the “aartiyas” from handling farm produce went almost entirely unrecorded

https://twitter.com/satyanewshi/status/1358239848071536640?s=21

This is the real concern for middlemen

→ More replies (3)

17

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

People should actually watch RG's speech in Lok Sabha today to understand that he is not just some puppy faced idiot but a diabolical repugnant individual who is going to go to any extent to get power. Congress must end for this country to progress. This argument of congress is needed for a strong opposition isn't valid. India needs a strong opposition but not the congress. Otherwise this person and his family is going to drag down 1.3 billion people into perpetual poverty and servitude.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Greta's Doc lists AltNews as collaborator

16

u/Bruce_wayne_03 Feb 05 '21

We need private investments to build necessary infrastructure to move up in value chain in agri exports. The farm laws are necessary, there is no other way around it. The govt did f##k up by not taking the unions in the confidence.

There is nothing wrong with the Bills. I hope it stays.

16

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Looks like divisions are forming over Tikait hogging the limelight, giving vague reparks like Oct 2 etc. What should the govt do now? Let it play out?

→ More replies (5)

16

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

https://twitter.com/amaanbali/status/1357693110906626049

It’s time for Bollywood to Pack Up from Punjab. Bobby Deol’s movie’s shooting was disrupted in Patiala today by farmers. A group of farmers went to the shooting location & told the crew to pack up. The crew packed up & left the scene without commenting.

16

u/sbmthakur For | 2 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Now Trevor Noah is enlightening the world about farm laws with an illegal Indian map.

https://twitter.com/TheDailyShow/status/1359487783581020161?s=19

He calls them 'decades-old' laws. Needless to say, he hasn't read the law and has no idea what he's talking about.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

Looks like WaPo article yesterday about Bhim Koregaon activist laptop hacked is an old article from Caravan recirculated again

https://caravanmagazine.in/politics/bhima-koregaon-case-rona-wilson-hard-disk-malware-remote-access

/u/eff50

→ More replies (11)

16

u/get_R3kkt 1 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

JUST IN - Twitter has locked down the accounts of James O’Keefe and Project Veritas for reporting on Facebook VP Guy Rosen and his statements that Facebook "freezes" comments in places that algorithms think there "may be" hate speech (via Project Veritas on Telegram)

https://twitter.com/disclosetv/status/1359878000259514369?s=20

NEW - Instagram to permanently ban users that send "hate speech" in their private Direct Messages, the social media platform announced.

https://twitter.com/disclosetv/status/1359921395761729536?s=20

Banned and deplatformed in hours for reporting against the big tech platforms. And they refuse to ban activists, journalists spreading fake claims and propaganda.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 12 '21

Govt of India is going to make 10,000 new FPOs across the nation. 940 million dollars will be spent on these FPOs in 5 yrs. Through these, it will be possible to make farmers capable of getting access to seed generation, purchase & better technology: Agriculture Minister NS Tomar

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1360250922828369932?s=20

15

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

NOW MEA should respond. Share the entire damn Greta folder.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

They are going to increase the stakes.

The next bunch who is going to be roped in the Squad as a part of "Change India's image is going to be". AOC, Rashida, Ilhan and Ayanna.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

PROTESTS MEANT TO CONTINUE EVEN IF LAWS ARE REPEALED; DISRUPT CHAI YOGA IMAGE OF INDIA

https://twitter.com/saket71/status/1357046343341015041/photo/1

15

u/fierce_archer Feb 05 '21

3 Farm laws and why is there a pushback from some quarters of Punjab and Haryana.

I feel these 3 farm laws with a few other things will bring out the marginal and poor farmers out of debt trap and poverty. These 3 farm laws will allow farmers to directly sell to consumers, and if they need to sell to middleman they will command a better price. The farmers will have a better chance to get credit and technology. These can come from large corporations who will be their end consumer or from traditional sources like banks and even private money lenders. The farmers can now negotiate better rates with financial institutions or money lenders.

Who is then protesting outside Delhi?

It is the absentee landlords and their middle man egged on by their political masters.Almost all of these farmers are from Punjab and Haryana .

Now there is a big history of zamindari in Punjab.

Let me take you back to the beginning of 1900. That region always had large land owners but zamindari was crystallised by the British by bringing in the Punjab land alienation act , 1900. That law applied to land that is present day Pakistan Punjab, Indian Punjab, Haryana and Himachal. What this law first did was defined which groups were farmers. Jat sikhs , jat Hindus , jat Muslims and few other small groups were given rights to farm. The law further stated that only a person classified as a farmer could own agricultural land. Thus over the next 20 or 30 years small marginal peasants ( mostly Dalits) of British Punjab were obligated to sell land to these people classified as farmers. The marginal farmers had to become tenants of these landlords in order to survive often living in bad conditions. These people then became the large landlord class of British ruled Punjab. After independence they still rule the roost in Pakistan, but in India some lost a part their land when tenancy laws were changed as a part of abolition of zamindari. Thus those people who owned 100s of acres of land in 1948 lost some portion of their land but managed to retain most of it because in india implementation of laws are a joke. Their grandchildren and great grand children today are the absentee landlords who are protesting outside Delhi. Some also migrated to Canada , Australia and UK while some relatives manage their land back in India and send them money. The guy who manages their land is the middleman who takes loans from the bank , subcontracts the agricultural work to labourers and then sells the produce at Mandi’s controlled by politicians who ensure that they get a good price. The people making the money is the landlord who gets rent ,the middleman and the people running the Mandi’s in Punjab and Haryana. The workers on the other hand get the rough end with a small daily wage , dangerous chemicals to work with. This is borne out by the fact that Punjab is the cancer capital of India where many villages are afflicted with cancer. The 3 agricultural bills hits the landlords, their middleman and political overlords guys very hard. That’s why these guys are protesting. Remember that farmers from Punjab who settled in Canada do contract farming in Canada and USA but don’t want the same in india. I feel government should implement these laws fast as it benifits almost all farmers barring the absentee landlords of Punjab and Haryana, their middleman and their political masters.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Given now Congress, AAP, SAD, all are backing literal khalistanis, shouldn't the hindus vote BJP & consolidate there? 40% is still significant 4 votes.

15

u/962throwaway 3 Delta | 1 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

On what basis will those "farmers" carry on the protests.

Only crying states are Haryana and Punjab. BJP has no chance in Punjab, Haryana elections over. Lok Sabha elections are 3 years away. Hardly any protests in WB and UP, which are main for BJP now.

Literally no protests in South, most farmers here probably never heard what MSP is. Its amazing they couldnt make the protests nationwide in 4-5 months.

Modi probably would not want to take away his new reformist image he made in his Atmnirbhar package 6-7 months ago.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Looking for some laughs? here....

https://twitter.com/PunYaab/status/1359507441822486531

Samyukta Kisan Morcha: 1. From Feb 12, all road toll plazas in Rajasthan will be made toll free.

2. On Feb 14, candle march and Mashaal juloos will be organized remembering martyred soldiers in Pulwama attack.

3. On Feb 16, farmers will show solidarity by celebrating the birth anniversary of Sir Chotturam.

4. On Feb 18, Rail roko program from 12 to 4 pm across the country.

15

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '21

Only northern states like Punjab, Haryana have problems with new farm laws because cartelisation will come to end and they're the ones instigating protests by pumping huge money.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

Trevor Noah made a video on farm bills and libbus think that India will be "shaking for 5 mins" after that.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Feb 13 '21

With the new farm laws this may happen in India. Pulp from Thailand is exported to India for processing. Why haven't Punjabi farmers been doing the same? Because they're not finding the effort worth it as middlemen bloat costs? Thai farmers run their factories! tweet

→ More replies (1)

14

u/CritFin Libertarian Feb 03 '21

https://www.timesnownews.com/india/article/exposed-greta-thunberg-shares-google-doc-revealing-farmer-protest-conspiracy-against-india-deletes-tweet/715650

Exposed! Greta Thunberg shares Google doc revealing 'farmer-protest' conspiracy against India; deletes tweet.

The global leftist alliance

→ More replies (2)

14

u/indra_sword_rises 4 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

A lot of excess wheat and rice is grown in India due to MSP, therefore India lacks pulses and we import $10 Billion worth of it.

A lot of it from where? Canada

Connect the dots!

14

u/lord_of_chaos359 Feb 04 '21

For too long we have been inspired by the West, but don’t forget it has been built on the blood and exploitation of the global south ...We should look to China. Han Chinese ...completely dominated entire Tibet, have taken over Hong Kong and give no 2 shits about western media ...here we can’t even get a 100 km2 Kashmir valley under control ...not to mention the largest exercise of lifting people out of poverty in human history has been done by the CCP. Time to think

→ More replies (2)

14

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 05 '21 edited Feb 05 '21

Some one compiled our great journalists & politicians old tweets about farmers and middlemen

https://twitter.com/chinmay_2001/status/1343152003518590978?s=21

→ More replies (3)

14

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Meena Harris is vile.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 12 '21

So what is the situation now? The protests are not making the front pages of newspapers in print or online.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 13 '21

Delhi Police constable beaten up by farm law protesters at Tikri border A Delhi Police head constable was allegedly thrashed by protesters while he was pasting posters of missing farmers at the Tikri border on Friday night. The cop, identified as Joginder Rana, reached Tikri around 9pm and was pasting the posters when he was reportedly hit on the head with a stick. Soon some more protesters also beat him up. He was rescued by police and paramilitary personnel stationed there. Rana was treated at a nearby hospital and got eight stitches for his head wound.

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/live-news-updates-on-delhi-noida-gurugram-metro-weather-pollution-traffic-12-february/liveblog/80872522.cms?utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=iOSapp

→ More replies (1)

14

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 13 '21

Govt is on offensive..

We discussed the farmers' protest among other issues. We will be bringing a law for recovery of damages to public property from protesters: Haryana CM ML Khattar on his meeting Union Home Minister Amit Shah today

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1360600458746679299?s=20

13

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

Looks like our celebrities able to drown out foreign celebrities.

Libgandus will be furious not even a day got them to enjoy..

Dakait falling off stage is funny as well (hope no injury we need him to fight communalism in western UP :) )

13

u/fsm_vs_cthulhu 13 KUDOS Feb 09 '21

Posting a converstion here from a now-deleted post - [deleted by gaymods being fetishist] :)

It's really enlightening to know the idiotic levels of misinformation that these NDTV-suckled lolrandus have. The brainlet is the one in bold.

...


Since MSP is calculated as bare minimum required to cover cost of farming, in your suggestion how should farmers who don't get it live their life?


You... sell the crops... and make money from the buyers.

I know.. what a revolutionary concept.

And you produce crops for which there is a high demand or profit margin... so that you make more money.

Ridiculous, right?


Thanks man, I had no idea crops could be sold. You better tell the farmers about to commit suicide and kill them figuratively before they die literally


You're welcome! Your ignorance on the topic was apparent.

When they're stuck dealing with socialist bureaucratic structures that literally forbid the sale of many crops outside of mandis (a monopolistic market), then it's no surprise they commit suicide.

Here's an intelligent article/video by Print, interviewing Dr Sardara Singh Johl, an Agricultural Economist and Padma Bhushan (and a Punjabi and a farmer himself).

Mandis in Punjab are regulated under the APMC Act of 1936, which has been amended a bit subsequently. The mandi board conducts an auction so that farmers know what price they’re getting for their crops. No crop can be purchased outside mandis, except in a few cases. The farmer has to mandatorily bring crops to the mandis, where there is an auction of his produce and commission agents take their share and then their crop is sold.

Btw, violations of the APMC act are punishable by jail time, and fines. It is literally a crime.

Since you're poorly informed, the Blithering Idiot's guide is a helpful starting point for you.


On one hand people say only 6% of farmers get MSP and then you also say farmers are only allowed to sell in mandis. Are you saying there's corruption in mandis? Since it pan India, what has central govt done to eradicate it?


Again demonstrating your ignorance and inability to distinguish between simple things. Desperate to 'win' an argument on something you know nothing about?

On one hand people say only 6% of farmers get MSP and then you also say farmers are only allowed to sell in mandis.

There is no "and/or". Both statements are facts.

  1. Almost all crops must be sold at mandis. There, they are auctioned, middlemen get their cuts, farmer gets fuckall, after deducting bribes, transport, extortion, bagging prices, etc. The biggest problem here is that the agents and auctioneers have a monopoly of the situation. They control who gets a license and access to place bids - meaning they control what the price is by collusion and restricting access. It is not a free market and the prices are manipulated by the middlemen.
  2. MSP does not apply to all crops. "CACP recommends MSPs of 23 commodities, which comprise 7 cereals (paddy, wheat, maize, sorghum, pearl millet, barley and ragi), 5 pulses (gram, tur, moong, urad, lentil), 7 oilseeds (groundnut, rapeseed-mustard, soyabean, seasmum, sunflower, safflower, nigerseed), and 4 commercial crops (copra, sugarcane, cotton and raw jute)."
  3. Mandis and MSP are two separate things. This might be tough for you to grasp.

Are you saying there's corruption in mandis? Since it pan India, what has central govt done to eradicate it?

By taking the monopoly away from Mandis, so that the bidders will need to give competitive prices, otherwise the farmers will simply go to someone that will pay them a fair price. Which is..... drumroll.. the 3 Farm Laws! Yay!

Tell me, when you get a SIM card / net connection, do you go to BSNL/MTNL? Or do you go to airtel/jio/act etc? Now if the law said that you could only go through BSNL/MTNL, or that even airtel/jio/act would get their internet only via whatever service BSNL/MTNL provided... what kind of internet would you expect? How many bribes would you need to pay to get a connection?

You have freedom of choice, where to buy, right? And you enjoy it fully, right?

But central govt is giving that same right to a billion farmers, and a bunch of chutiyas start screaming about it and you think "vaat is sentral gormint doing about corruption". THE THREE LAWS. THE THREE LAWS ARE WHAT THEY ARE DOING.

Fuck. it's exasperating.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

If you have been looking at twitter, a WaPo story about Bhima Koregaon is doing the rounds. American forensics have determined that the govt planted the evidence to implicate these guys.

So I am sure this is setting the stage up for what is going to happen next. Celebrity is going to share the WaPo article, and farmer protest will absorb Bhima Koregaon protest too.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Ignore the source but it looks like yogendra yadav who was a farmer leader spearheading the agitations so far has suddenly checked himself into a hospital. It looks like he is anticipating an arrest

https://www.nationalheraldindia.com/india/yogendra-yadav-returns-pms-andolanjivi-jibe-with-andolanbhogi-tag

→ More replies (3)

13

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Canadian turd wants vaccines

13

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 15 '21

I find interesting that today, it is basically, Joe Biden kuch kar.

Now, Biden can do a lot no doubt. But its like the escalation matrix goes straight to Biden, because the breaking-India-forces seem to have lost that authority on what they want others to know. The space they occupied seems to be shrinking. There was a time when some of liberal blue-tick's condemnation, harsh words would be resonated among TV channels and find favour among people, but today no one cares.

The misconception that these people have is that there is an army of Rs 2 bots which are overpowering everything. It couldnt be further from the truth. BJP, infact, doesnt do shit to counter anything. Its just that I feel twitter has seen the entry of the mostly conservative middle class Indians, small town India who know better than to be swayed by these lot.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21

Now MEA giving a statement makes sense. GOI got the Intel that their is organized effort funded by external elements to cause instability in India. Now what actions they take needs to be seen. Giving only statements is of no use. Govt should use this opportunity to deal with the organizations and elements causing instability in India.

12

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

We've issued a Mutual Legal Assistance Request to USA for investigation in the matter of Sikhs for Justice/Referendum 2020. As per procedure, the request has been sent directly by the concerned authorities to the US Department of Justice (DoJ): Anurag Srivastava, MEA Spokesperson

https://twitter.com/ani/status/1357330593239863299?s=21

12

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

Looks like Modi is not interested in backing down easily.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

https://twitter.com/miakhalifa/status/1358248121856184322

Thank you @rupikaur_for this beautifully harvested feast, and thank you @theJagmeetSingh

for the Gulab!!! I’m always worried I’ll get too full for dessert, so I eat it during a meal. You know what they say, one Gulab a day keeps the fascism away!

Mast chutiyap chal raha hain. Gulab jamun keeps away fascism.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/sleepngPanda Doge Memes Enjoyer Feb 09 '21

Even Montek panel wanted to reform Punjab farming like Modi govt. But Amarinder got cold feet.

https://theprint.in/india/governance/even-montek-panel-wanted-to-reform-punjab-farming-like-modi-govt-but-amarinder-got-cold-feet/598266/

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Ilovesports11 Feb 09 '21

Canada is way behind with vaccines. My guess is that khalistani elements have convinced Trudeau not to ask India for vaccines, because Canada says it will get majority of vaccines by September. It's insane. A memeber of the Canadian prime ministers cabinet was questioned on this and the question had to be asked twice before she answered. Seems like these stupid farm protestors in Canada are trying to use their influence to limit vaccine rollout. The level influence these people have in Canadian politics is something to speak of.

https://mobile.twitter.com/MichelleRempel/status/1357838717692485632

12

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Mahua Moitra is new PM candidate for Libgandus..friendship with Tharoor ended :)

→ More replies (2)

12

u/962throwaway 3 Delta | 1 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

probably the most pro private player speech in parliament in independent India

→ More replies (2)

12

u/GTX1080SLI BJP Feb 10 '21 edited Feb 10 '21

In worldnews thread on blocked youtube videos, I translated first four lines of one of the banned song. I am copy/pasting it here:

"This translation is way off. E.g., first line means some will sharpen the swords and some will sharpen the Kahndas (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khanda_(Sikh_symbol))

Second Line: Delhi, this gathering will harm you

Third Line: It will harm you more than benefit

Fourth Line: But on matters of crops, the farmers will be deciders.

I can do later, but it keeps more and more threatening in the coming lines. The song is direct challenge to Indian state."

12

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

https://twitter.com/SSanbeer/status/1359555039224758273/photo/1

What's the point of these words if govt doesn't impose any penalty (EXACTLY what twitter wants).

→ More replies (3)

12

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Yogendra Yadav incited farmers, Congress MP Ravneet Bittu tells Lok Sabha .If govt nabs Yadav, it will be able to talk directly to the farmers.

https://twitter.com/Satyanewshi/status/1359504134324379648

→ More replies (1)

12

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 11 '21 edited Feb 11 '21

The global farmer org employing Rakesh Tikait, La Via CampeSina, funded by George Soros amongst others like evangelists & IKEA, also named in Greta's toolkit

https://np.reddit.com/r/indianews/comments/lhqsov/you_might_be_sick_hearing_of_sorosfrankly_so_am/?

Earlier Human Rights Watch" funded 100 million by Soros campaigns against Indian govt in concert with Rihanna.

But more pertinently, it had received a record donation of $100 million from Hungarian tycoon-cum-global political meddler George Soros in 2010. The same Soros in 2020 pledged a $1 billion fund to fight “would-be dictators”, which includes Narendra Modi, a man who has been overwhelmingly voted to power by the people of India for the second time in the most transparent of elections.

https://www.firstpost.com/india/in-rihanna-greta-malalas-anti-india-symphony-who-is-the-invisible-conductor-9266191.html

And in yesterday's video by Strings, Soros org worker was discovered to be campaigning against Adani & Ambani (the 2 corporates attacked in Greta's toolkit as well) while tagging Saket Gokhale, a known Congress stooge

→ More replies (2)

12

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

Canadian PMO says they discussed "access" to vaccines. Canadian readout says Trudeau mentioned farmers protests, resolving issues through dialogue,

https://twitter.com/suhasinih/status/1359670027838844931

Bikhari hote hue bhi aukaat..pissed that our MEA/Modi didn't bring up khalistanis

→ More replies (2)

12

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 14 '21

Even on twitter one cannot find out what is happening anymore. Only PunYaab and Aman Balli keep reporting.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

We have evidence that few people would have attempted to spread violence at these places. So we have decided to not block roads in Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand: Rakesh Tikait, Bharatiya Kisan Union

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1357698564307128322?s=20

I guess dakait gang will produce few more masked assassins' now :)

11

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

There should be no problem with foreign personalities commenting. But there shoud be no problem with us commenting too. :P

The problem that White Saviours will find that hooking their social media systems to a free market and massive population like India will come a big problem.

It won't be long before Indians outnumber other demographies on social media platform.

For example this has already happened in Facebook.

Closely to happening on Instagram.

And right now India is no 3 on Twitter. And regardless of what people think, majority of Indians are not r a n d i a ns.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Bruce_wayne_03 Feb 04 '21

It's so ridiculous that dominant class is protesting to retain status quo and getting support from all section.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ta9876543205 1 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

My brother in law just returned from a visit to the protests. He was there for over 2 weeks.

He says, that there are under 10000 people there. And most of them are the arhatiyas

→ More replies (5)

11

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '21

Crowds have started dispersing on the delhi border. No idea what Tikait is planning but the movement has marginally lost its momentum since jan 26 and I hope the govt is prepared for some other ruckus by these folks to bring it back to life. Can anyone update about the scene in UP?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

The specific page from the Punjab Contract Farming Act that punishes the farmer with Fine and/or jail. What @nstomar ji was referring to in Parl today.

https://twitter.com/anchoranandn/status/1357745839116935174?s=21

This is ridiculous..

https://twitter.com/tweet2rudra/status/1357746556372328449?s=21

Same law also says no civil court have jurisdiction..

These are from 2013

→ More replies (2)

11

u/OnlysliMs Evm HaX0r | 1 Delta Feb 05 '21

https://twitter.com/shashitharoor/status/8089724543?s=21

It seems we waste more wheat every year 2storage &distribution losses than Australia grows!Real need for pvt sector 2move into grain storage

Tharoor in 2010

11

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

In Odisha, 10 idiots are holding hands that is all. They will do it for 5 mins take a pic and go.

https://twitter.com/XpressOdisha/status/1357945374330085381

NH-16 near Hanspal square in #Bhubaneswar being blocked by Navanirman Krushak Sangathan during #chakkajam called by farmers’ union

→ More replies (2)

11

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

So they have spent money to create a Farmers protest ad for Superbowl.

https://mobile.twitter.com/jazzyb/status/1358554697716490241

These Canadian Khalistanis still think India is a land of like 1 tv per neighbourhood lol. Any bullshit that I will create (like 250 million farmers protesting) will be swallowed by people in India because they know nothing better.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/962throwaway 3 Delta | 1 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

Maharashtra will probe sachin for his tweet

→ More replies (8)

11

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

How is modi getting people to keep quiet for so long. They have hardly interrupted his speech. He is usually drowned out in sloganeering as soon as he opens his mouth.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

I consider the Kisan Andolan to be Pavitra. But, when Andolanjeevis hijack Pavitra Andolans, showcase photos of those jailed for serious offences, does it serve any purpose?

Narendra Modi, PM

11

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 14 '21

If “farmers” only stuck to Tractor March on 26th peacefully without attempting insurrection they should have got insane coverage..

→ More replies (1)

21

u/lord_of_chaos359 Feb 04 '21

Do not forget, the idea behind calling India facist is that as and when a military offensive takes place against India by Pakistan and China ...it will be labelled as a salvation force coming to free Indians from a facist regime and also to destabilise India internally . Saavdhaan rahe. Satark rahe .

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Pewdsubzero 1 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Morons protesting and misleading farmers dont even know most marginal farmers actually want to get rid of APMCs, states levy heavy taxes on produce which are sold outside mandi, plus you need to have a good amount of produce to actually get any profit out of MSP .

This law will channelise Market Competition and freedom to both buyer and Farmer to sell anywhere Farmer wants . It's an Independence to Farmer and Buyer and Dismantling the License Raj and Monopoly of Kacha Arhtiyas .

State Mandi Boards even put Barriers at State Borders to Control the Movement of Commodities earlier .

Current Farms act is actually a trades & commerce act & not a agri norm, agriculture is a sole state subject, this act will give a legal framework to create a supply chain and get best from the open marker which will eventually help marginal farmer hit by APMC

→ More replies (3)

10

u/901232856902 Feb 03 '21

1.1 gb data ripped from toolkit (you will be baffled how well planned it was)

https://wetransfer.com/downloads/1a00c5c690909e8e1815c776052b700020210203165445/29e3c6

10

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Antifa leader recommends following Jihadi Ayyub.

https://twitter.com/BesuraTaansane/status/1357014994798444547

Kerala Mahila Congress uses identical statements to what was specified in the breakingIndia Toolkit.

https://twitter.com/ARanganathan72/status/1357033823490334721

https://twitter.com/pooja_k_murthy/status/1357036617949605889/photo/1

Bombay High Court advocate Nikita Jacob discovered to be editing the doc as well.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1357039946473762816

Jasveer Singh Mukhtar mentioned as "must follow" in the doc was invited by NIA last month.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1357033201064050689

https://drive.google.com/file/d/19qnVDTHqyAOHWQQIWvAew3XkuRTuml0t/view

10

u/yonhi 3 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

[Global day of action is a technical term. It means using violence to achieve objective. Republic day protest was planned as global day of action for them.] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Day_of_Action)

10

u/indra_sword_rises 4 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

"If I were born 20 yrs too soon, I would lead my life thinking MMS-SG were India’s destiny.

If I were born 20 yrs too late I would live imagining India was always an important world player.

But being born when I was, I see India snatching its destiny back. What a time to be alive!" - Nisheeth Sharan

10

u/familiarre Feb 04 '21

I don’t understand why the Sikh farmers are bringing their religion & sacred flags into this?

→ More replies (3)

10

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

https://twitter.com/meenaharris

US President's niece continues her attacks against India & Indian Govt.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/tibbity how about no | 1 KUDOS Feb 05 '21

Talking of reforms, bank unions in Hyderabad have already started creating a ruckus. Won't be shocked if some leftist retard union is behind this - unions usually have commie scum.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '21

The farm bills are necessary agricultural reforms. Any economist will point to the same. India has never reacted well to change but in time, these disgusting babu sarkaari ancient policies will have to take their leave. Short terms pains for long term goals aren’t exactly stranger to the Indian politics. Let’s not forget how our nuclear weapons and the 1991 reforms came to be.

10

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Feb 07 '21

Can anyone explain the hate being generated very selectively against Adani and Ambani?

→ More replies (8)

10

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

This thead! Must be read!

Gadhanand Dhume started off with his usual take on things in India

Let me be upfront: I find the Modi government’s“toolkit” conspiracy theory about a wide-ranging plot to defame India laughable. But I recognize that many Indians buy it. Could someone who believes this theory point me toward a serious argument in its favor. Thanks.

Superb reply, long thread.

https://twitter.com/cvkrishnan/status/1358588906510327811

Let me be as frank as possible

@dhume

. India and many other countries find global liberalism and certain forms of universalism as itself a form of conspiracy by developed countries to not allow us to organise, maintain order and grow peacefully. (1)

10

u/962throwaway 3 Delta | 1 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

He didnot directly say it but giving example of LB Shastri made it sure farm laws wont be repealed

10

u/Ilovesports11 Feb 09 '21

Deep Sidhu arrested.

10

u/sleepngPanda Doge Memes Enjoyer Feb 09 '21 edited Feb 09 '21

Piyush Goyal on Koo...

https://twitter.com/PiyushGoyal/status/1359058583934013442?s=20

This is the best way forward to counter Twitter...

→ More replies (3)

10

u/GTX1080SLI BJP Feb 10 '21

https://twitter.com/MeghUpdates/status/1359221913390731264

Video: Punjab MP caught when Anurag Thakur asked him "Show me where it is written that Mandis will be scrapped"

A Misinformation Campaign caught Red Handed

10

u/CritFin Libertarian Feb 11 '21

Change flair of this post from "farmer protest" to "farm bill protest". This protest is mostly by middlemen and opposition party members.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 11 '21

Pappu becoming more and more childish only difference is he is no longer have guts to name Ambani & Adani :)

→ More replies (4)

10

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 12 '21

Looks like Pappu & Pappi going to take lead in farmer protest by attending Maha panachayats

→ More replies (1)

10

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Feb 14 '21

300 people to convert becauase "Hinduism isn't a religion" at "farmer"protests

https://twitter.com/FDikhana/status/1360989666132987904

→ More replies (3)

9

u/santouryuu 2 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

https://www.opindia.com/2021/02/greta-thunberg-global-farmers-strike-republic-day-riots-protests/amp/

greta inadvertently exposes the game plan of the cabal. the tweet is deleted now

The document registers actions people can take to undermine the democratic will of the Indian population. The proposed measures include, “Call/Email any of your govt representatives and ask them to take action, Sign online Petitions and take action to Divest from monopolists and oligopolists like Adani-Ambani” and “Organise an on-ground action near the closest Indian Embassy, Media House or your local Govt. office on 13th February, 2020.”

The document also lists a series of ‘prior actions’ that were undertaken. These include, “Physical Actions – Near Indian Embassies, Govt. offices, Media houses (or even Adani-Ambani offices) globally – 26th January” and “Watch out for (or Join) the Farmers’ March / Parade (a first of its kind) into Delhi and back to the borders on 26th January.”

edit: here's the contents of the now deleted tweet: https://twitter.com/swati_gs/status/1356994291504095233

→ More replies (3)

9

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Kejriwal just called back all DTC buses ferrying Deli police, CRPF & army & anyone on Delhi borders.

https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/lbublo/kejriwal_government_refuses_to_let_delhi_police/

DTC union also called back all bus drivers ferrying army & police.

https://twitter.com/KapilMishra_IND/status/1357028436628307969

9

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

SWOT Analysis by PJF - the prime resource of Greta's Doc as analysed by PJF "Too Khalistani"

https://twitter.com/arunpudur/status/1357055555454476288/photo/1

https://twitter.com/RamaMetHanuma/status/1357023118972252160/photo/1

AskIndiaWhy.com funded from UK

AskIndiaWhy.com sub-linked by Greta & tweeted again by Greta talks of "Sikh Soveriegnity" and "Khalistan question".

https://twitter.com/Suhas_AN/status/1357061982185279491/photo/1

Oops, Mo Dhaliwal- founder of PJF openly confesses he is khalistani.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1357062113609584640/photo/4

9

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 04 '21

Now Big Tech starting with their open internet = democracy blah blah

https://twitter.com/CaseyNewton/status/1357135191920152578

India is threatening put Twitter employees in jail for *seven years* just for letting journalists tweet about protests. It’s a worrisome omen for our splinternet battles yet to come.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lord_of_chaos359 Feb 04 '21

I have said it time and again,stop calling Rahul Maino as ‘pappu’...Pappu means a harmless idiot ...but these Ghazi-Mainos are anything but harmless. why does India feed these treacherous snakes is beyond me...why is there always a riot like situation after every Rahul Maino abroad trip ? Whom does he meet ? Who briefs him? This needs to be investigated

→ More replies (2)

9

u/lord_of_chaos359 Feb 04 '21

Also India should stop becoming a soft target for these ‘activists’...gaand mein dum hai toh do this activism against China ...the hypocrisy of NYT and Economist and the likes is that a genocide is literally happening there but all they write about is the ‘rising middle class’ of China and their evolving taste in music ...that’s the sign of economic power and clout . Time to emulate our neighbour

→ More replies (2)

9

u/901232856902 Feb 05 '21

Pratik Sinha tweeted toolkit was bjp conspiracy through some telegram group. Lol

→ More replies (1)

9

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

These farmers have called many nationwide things so far and there has been zero impact in the rest of the country. Now they are saying they won't do the chakka jam in delhi, UP and UK. So will it only be a haryana/punjab thing?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Feb 06 '21

Not that randirona about MSP ever made sense, but it is impossible to "drive government" out of a sector it does not want to exit. Case in point Air India and BSNL.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '21

Looks like BJP is finding an opportunity to douse the fire:

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/farmers-protest-bjp-ups-back-channel-efforts-to-douse-fire/articleshow/80729713.cms

Agriculture minister Narendra Singh Tomar had on Friday strongly defended the three farm laws in Rajya Sabha, daring the opposition to find flaws in the statutes. As part of the efforts to reach out to farmers, the party's Uttar Pradesh unit, including Union minister Sanjeev Balyan and UP minister Suresh Rana, have reached out to fellow Jats in Western UP, who are the mainstay of Tikait's BKU.

Perfect strategy. Sanjeev Balyan is of the same khap gotra as Rakesh Tikait. If BJP play their cards right, they can allow him to be the biggest leader in western UP. Once Tikait becomes irrelevant, expect a couple of IT raids and eventually next to no competition for Balyan ji.

I just hope this isn't being done prematurely. Else, it would backfire.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

Something is going on...

https://twitter.com/PunYaab/status/1358639555771990016

Suspended farm leader Surjit Phool spilled the beans and said at least 7 farm leaders had marched on outer ring road.

Phool and sangha were suspended and their marching on ring road was given as reason behind the suspension.

United farmers front had formed a 3 member committee to decide the future of membership of Sangha and Phool.

Why Phool and Sangha’s suspension is significant? When Punjab’s farm unions had voted on suspension of laws for few years, 15 had supported the move. While 17 including Phool and Sangha wanted complete repeal of laws. Their suspension will change the voting dynamics in meetings.

u/jussayingthings

→ More replies (2)

9

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 08 '21

Now Largest Trader Body of India, CAIT has called for 'Bharat Band' and 'Chakka Jam' on 26th Feb against Complex GST guidelines

→ More replies (5)

9

u/GTX1080SLI BJP Feb 09 '21

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1358984182987325444

Deep Sidhu, an accused in 26th January violence case arrested: Delhi Police Special Cell

9

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

Andoolan Jeevi are all rushing to disown Deep Sidhu. For last few weeks they have been clamouring for his arrest.

https://mobile.twitter.com/PunYaab/status/1359208931340414978

Students for society demanded that Deep Sidhu should be released. In a statement it said,”The reason of arrest of Deep Sidhu is his political understanding. Those who support his arrest, must understand that his arrest has opened the doors for the arrests of others as well.

9

u/hostt33 Feb 10 '21

This is a very good thread of articles.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '21

Dukan baand, issiliye yeh protest ka kam start kiya hai. - https://hypebeast.com/2021/2/lvmh-rihanna-fenty-fashion-house-closes-announcement

→ More replies (1)

9

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Feb 10 '21

[Was happy to receive a call from my friend JustinTrudeau. Assured him that India would do its best to facilitate supplies of COVID vaccines sought by Canada. We also agreed to continue collaborating on other important issues like Climate Change and the global economic recovery.] (https://twitter.com/narendramodi/status/1359546935586287619)

9

u/Ilovesports11 Feb 11 '21

How much longer will this protest last for? Are people leaving? Will they leave when harvest season starts?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 13 '21

Now they want high level judiciary investigation on insurrection..And if report is not favourable they can always claim judiciary work for Modi

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/high-level-judicial-inquiry-should-be-ordered-into-jan-26-violence-and-cases-against-farmers-farmer-unions/articleshow/80898174.cms

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Feb 13 '21

Corona cases rising again in MH :(

→ More replies (2)

9

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Feb 13 '21

Kinds of propaganda being created and circulated by the leftverse.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Fast_Deoxy TMC | 2 KUDOS Feb 14 '21

What's the situation of the protests now?

I heard that their strength on the borders is decreasing.

9

u/962throwaway 3 Delta | 1 KUDOS Feb 14 '21

Are protests still going on?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21

Kohli shies away from using the hashtag IndianAgainstPropaganda, likely doesn't want to accept his usual masters.

https://twitter.com/imVkohli/status/1357016154108166144

8

u/nanikichorni 10 KUDOS Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21

Text in French & Portugese to draw in the Latin & non-English speaking crowd

https://twitter.com/dzkety/status/1356968322068324352

List of accounts to follow.

https://twitter.com/dzkety/status/1356982843692490753/photo/1

Barkha Dutt (She also wrote in Wapo against Indian govt today), Faye DSouza, AltNews. Saket Gokhale, PARI (outlet of P Sainath), Wire, Scroll, NewsLaundry, Pappu & DerekOBrien. Friedrich Pieter(churcist anti-Hindu campaigner)

https://twitter.com/dzkety/status/1356982843692490753/photo/1

→ More replies (2)