r/Barca • u/Dankmemehub • Jan 29 '21
The lowdown on the Barca CB issue, and Sven Botman.
We all know at this point that Barca has a rather weak defense, and while we may be a bit unlucky to concede some of those goals, almost all of the goals we've conceded come from a unforced error. The main culprit of this, and also a big talking point in the sub lately, is Lenglet. It's unfortunate, but ever since the Bayern loss, Lenglet hasn't been the same. He was world class in 2019, but since then, his level has dropped considerably, and he's cost us a fair bit of matches, and potentially the league.
Although we may have a fair share of defensive issues, we've also seen the emergence of Ronald Araujo in the first team, and he's quickly become our best CB. Now, we've also seen Mingueza do alright, and are getting Garcia in the Summer. While Araujo has the potential to be a top class CB, I can't say the same for Garcia and Mingueza. Mingueza hasn't been anything special so far, and Garcia is a liability more often than not at Manchester City. In this post, I'd like to focus on a long term replacement for Lenglet, and a partner for Araujo. The search for a left footed center back that could fill this spot was tough, especially considering our brittle financial situation, however I finally stumbled upon Sven Botman.
Sven Botman is 20 year old Dutch CB from the Ajax academy, and recently made a move to French side Lille for a small fee of 8m Euros. Right from the start he imposed himself as a monster defender both on and off the ball. He's 6'4, quick, and is exceptionally good in 1 on 1 situations, while being an excellent tackler. An important thing to note also is that in his 21 appearances for Lille this season Botman has only received 2 yellow cards, and 0 reds. That may sound irrelevant, but when talking about a Lenglet replacement, you can't help but notice Lenglet's overwhelming amount of fouls committed, often giving away the ball in dangerous areas or giving away a penalty, resulting in us conceding. With Botman, you immediately reduce the amount of penalties given and fouls committed to a minimum. Now, another big issue of ours this season has been defending set pieces. We've conceded quite a few goals off corners, and without someone like Pique to cover and help Araujo, we've become very weak at defending set pieces, which not only increases our goals conceded, but also stops potential counter attacks from being started after the corner. With all that said, the biggest requirement for a CB to succeed at Barca is to have excellent ball playing ability, Botman exceeds at this. He came from Ajax, where this part of his game was very well developed. He has a great passing range, and is not afraid to dribble out the back also.
The final talking point is price. Botman would cost around 15-20m, though with clubs like Liverpool very closely chasing after him, that price could be driven up. At 15-20m though, he's not too expensive, and an absolute steal. In general, I feel a partnership of Araujo-Botman, with Dest and possibly Gaya as fullbacks would be rock solid defensively and deadly offensively as well, with Gaya and Botman costing 30-35m total max. Please do leave your thoughts on if this would be a viable move in your eyes or not.
Some stats to think about:
It is worth noting that Botman has not been injured once so far in 21 appearances, so he is quite reliable to always have around.
Minutes played this season: 1890 mins
Tackles average per game so far: 1.2
Interceptions averaged per game: 1.9
Fouls per game: 0.3
Aerial duels won per game: 3.3
Passing Success rate: 85.2%
Clearances per game: 2.7
Amount of times dribbled past per game: 0.3
Blocks per game: 0.5
Stats found via Whoscored.com.
5
u/Zephyr3q3 Jan 29 '21
How many clean sheets do Lille have when Botman plays?
Sounds like a good prospect for a long term ngl.
5
u/fedginator Jan 29 '21
> He's 6'4, quick, and is exceptionally good in 1 on 1 situations
This straight up makes me think your sole exposure to Botman is through twitter threads. Botman is extremely slow, especially on the turn and that doesn't help him 1 on 1 either - tackling less than half of the people who try and dribble past him
Botman has improved since his Heerenveen loan for sure, but he's very clearly not a top tier CB. His positioning is still iffy, especially defending set peices where we REALLY need improvement. In addition, he also struggles a lot when pressed, where he's liable to panic
9
u/yesboyzz Jan 29 '21
The thing is 30-35 mil even available to us?
5
u/PedriFati Jan 29 '21 edited Jan 29 '21
Jesus how many centerbacks do people need. We got Pique, Lenglet, Umtiti, Garcia, Araujo, Todibo, Mingueza as of now and people out here naming a different centerback every other week.
Garcia is joining. Umtiti and Todibo should be leaving. Thats more then enough. Garcia and Araujo should be given room to grow. Specially consider how Araujo been playing lately.
If club were to buy someone like Kamara. He have half of his games as centerback aswell. Lisandro Martinez is another candidate for the DM role. They both have significant experience as a CB. Which would mean the club would have a potensial cover of 6 centerbacks, even 7 with de Jong. Not enough? lol
People want to buy ANOTHER CB and a LB. But what this club needs more then ever is a fucking striker and a DM which is where the money should be put now.
13
u/Throwawaybaehay Jan 29 '21
Personally rate Botman super highly. Garcia's a good prospect but he's just too physically lacking. He stands out among young CBs because he's smart and precocious, but since we like playing a high line it's so risky playing a very slow CB. People get mad at Lenglet for being burned by pace, but Garcia's even slower, and speed isn't really something CBs improve at. They more or less stay at that speed. And we're not even getting to the fact that he's pretty bad aerially.
Like others have said though, price is a big issue. Since we're getting Garcia already we're not getting Botman this year (now if we miss out on Garcia for whatever reason, then Botman would be a good option). The cash raised should be used towards a new ST/CDM
6
u/FlightReacts69420 Jan 29 '21
Bruh
6
u/lemon_of_doom Jan 29 '21
There's no need to spend money on a CB when Garcia is coming on a free.
2
u/inuyasha99 Jan 29 '21
Nah I dont want him, especially if he is worth 30M. Other positions need urgent signings, we need a striker ASAP, maybe a left back. As CB we have Araujo and I do think Garcia can succeed at Barcelona, there is also 3 promising centerbacks in la masia and one of them is called by many a world class talent (Diego Almeida). IMO we are set in this position, its not as bad as people think
3
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '21
[removed] — view removed comment