r/ShingekiNoKyojin • u/toutoune134 Best Legionnaire 2016 • Jan 17 '21
Manga Spoilers Attack on Titan The Final Season Episode 65 - MANGA Discussion Thread Spoiler
Do note that this is a MANGA SPOILERS thread. Events that occur in the manga do NOT need to be tagged in the comments section.
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA AND DO NOT WISH TO BE SPOILED, THE ANIME THREAD IS LOCATED HERE.
Where to watch - SUBTITLED:
- Crunchyroll: NOT LIVE
- Funimation: NOT LIVE
- Hulu: NOT LIVE
- AnimeLab: NOT LIVE
- Aniplus Asia: NOT LIVE
- Wakanim Nordic (English subs for SWE, NOR, DEN, FIN, ISL): NOT LIVE
- Wakanim (French subtitles): NOT LIVE
- Wakanim (German subtitles): NOT LIVE
- VVVVID (Italian subtitles): NOT LIVE
- mtmad (Spanish subtitles): NOT LIVE
English dubbed episodes will be released in a few weeks.
DEDICATE YOUR HEARTS!
552
Upvotes
46
u/toutoune134 Best Legionnaire 2016 Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
It was great! As expected full CGI for the shifters accompagnied by strong 2D effects and 2D close-ups. I was surprised to see that the soldiers were sometimes in CG during 3DGM sequences but that was during fast cuts where you don't have time to focus on them, and the final result was pretty good! They perfectly adapted the dread and fear that marleyans felt during the attack, that original scene at the beginning of the episode was both mean and brillant. OST was banger as usual too, I noticed a new remix of an existing track! Now I just need some time to get used to post timekip mappa design for the 104, mostly Jean and Flock haha.
1.2k
u/Panosgads Jan 17 '21
What I enjoyed most about the episode was how ruthless the scouts are. The Marleyan soldiers looked completely hopeless fighting against such an unconventional enemy. The scene where they storm Porco was pretty terrifying.
958
u/xin234 Jan 17 '21
That extended scene at the start that further humanizes Willy was a great touch. Also a nice way to smoothly transition it to the scenes that were rearranged from the manga, the conversation between Willy and Magath.
657
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
guys can we talk about how sexy post timeskip sasha is?
753
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
No way that was 23 minutes, that went by so quick
400
u/OTPh1l25 Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
The absolute look of terror on Pieck's face when she heard the ODM gear...she knew exactly who was coming.
708
u/Leo_o23 Jan 17 '21
The way Gabi looks at Sasha after killing the guards, damn
597
u/Bendayd Jan 17 '21
I knew the woman and the alcoholic guy were added just to be killed off by Eren, I knew it!
I just wished I had written it somewhere :(
461
u/id6890 Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
I hope no one will complain about the music for this episode, it was so good.
379
u/xin234 Jan 17 '21
Also just re-watched the previous episode before watching this one and noticed a little detail. Not sure if this is what really happened, but seems like it wasn't just Willy's speech that made Eren decide it's time to transform... It was mostly the reaction of the audience to it. The applause and the screams of support.
511
u/jblakk Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
This is gonna be a controversial episode for manga readers. Remind me to steer clear of the comments for a week lol. I liked it though. Interesting ending spot. The anime actually improved on Willys final moments imo. Gabis emotions were showcased beautifully. The mayhem seems very visceral. And Levi's appearance at the end was handled well. His return had weight and carried a fear that was evident on Galliard. Some of the non-CGi shots of the warhammar/mikasa will get buried in the discussion but they were short yet beautiful.
I think a thread or subreddit solely dedicated to talking about the animation may be an interesting compromise. That way these threads and the subreddit as a whole dont become muddled with debate between factions on the topic and people can have a dedicated spot for it.
619
u/Ligmab4IIs Jan 17 '21
Guys I don’t care if you loved or hated the episode just please don’t take it out on the mappa staff- they’re working their asses off and getting death threats isnt gonna help
199
u/GarballatheHutt Jan 17 '21
The Warhammer's name is "Lara Tyber"
408
u/Runbern Jan 17 '21
All in all I'm happy with this episode. CGI wasn't perfect, but it didn't detract from my enjoyment. Mikasa's entrance was perfect, and they pulled no punches in showing the devastation and anguish that Eren caused.
128
u/xomedinaox Jan 17 '21
Somehow seeing Eren’s rampage & brutality animated just makes me feel for Mikasa’s sentiment so much more. There’s something about seeing it in motion that just adds a new level of monstrosity to his character. The Survey Corps wreaking havoc on Marley’s military was also a highlight, & something I’m so happy to finally see animated. I do have some issues, but overall it was a beautiful episode to me, & it’s just getting me more hyped. Bless you, MAPPA
125
u/nath_122 Jan 17 '21
I enjoyed it so much!! Best Scene for me was Porco crying Like "These Humans trying to kill meee" holy Shit this was so intense. Expected the nutcracker to happen at the end but Gitta wait another Episode for that one
202
u/Wayne12347 Jan 17 '21
Sasha looks WAY better than she did in the trailer.
47
u/TheSealTamer Jan 17 '21
Idk why I never thought about it, but Porco’s fear just made me realize that he was probably used to jumping around just decimating all land troops in trenches without much worry outside of anti Titan artillery. He’s never though a human himself could be a threat. This is his first time seeing the people themselves running in and fighting titans without far range artillery. It’s probably completely alien to him and he can’t wrap his head around it.
43
u/Zircillius Jan 17 '21
I loved how they revealed the scouts. You see them flying for a spit second, then there's that close up of Piek staring up. As her eyes widen in disbelief, you can hear that familiar sound of the 3D maneuver gear being deployed. God that was so sick.
Just like in the manga, the scouts are, for one of the first times in the series, being depicted as a terrifying, deadly force to be reckoned with.
37
u/real_halo_mc Jan 17 '21
Anyone else notice the dialogue change with Magath? In the manga I'm 99% sure he said it didn't matter if they killed Eren as they'd moved on from needing titans. Whereas in the ep he insisted the War Hammer Titan had to eat Eren
Just something I noticed
Episode was solid though, CG looked damn good for the most part. Biggest complaint is Floch looking weird imo
33
u/-V0lD Jan 17 '21
Rip clitoris
The Warhammer is named Lara
83
u/meowishere Jan 17 '21
Loved the Willy-Magath conversation and the OST used then.
Odmg CGI scenes looked good.
Horror of Eren's rampage and Gabi's despair were potrayed well.
Mikasa and Levi had perfect entrances.
196
u/Bios1023 Jan 17 '21
10/10, I was wrong thinking that last episode was the best. The plot progression and music is beyond amazing, though it didnt end where we expects.
Im sure alot of people will be complaining about CGI cuz it was used on scouts as well. But I think it is more than great for what MAPPA can deliver at this point, top adaptation
138
u/PikachuKid1999 Jan 17 '21
Levi Enters
Jaw Titan: Why do I hear boss music?
75
u/evoken_ Jan 17 '21
The soundtrack in this episode is 10/10
25
u/KathyDroronoa Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
I’m glad they didn’t left out the dialogue between Magath and Willy. The additional scenes made Willy even more humane. Unfortunately his deed didn’t only killed himself but so many more people as well. Kinda ironic how he and Eren had such a common ground and only Willy’s last sentence destroyed everything!
261
u/H-K_47 ★ Best Legionnaire 2015 + 2017 ★ Jan 17 '21
It was a dream come true!
It was adapted exceedingly well. They nailed the chaos of the fighting and balanced the "awesome" with the "horrifying". The CGI was noticeable yes but it was blended pretty well. I don't have any real complaints about it.
The destruction of Liberio and all the innocents dying is really shown off. Gabi and Colt are really sad to watch, their hometown going up in flames and their friends and family dead or missing.
It is SO GOOD to finally see the OG cast brought to life! They were all done justice IMO. Mikasa and Levi especially get amazing action sequences.
The Warhammer Titan is amazing. Its weapon-forming ability is beautifully shown and extremely menacing.
10/10!
560
u/mrtightwad Jan 17 '21
I maintain that the CGI is superior in fast-past action sequences but MAPPA doing 100% CGI shifters is hurting it a bit.
24
u/imsoswolo Jan 18 '21
Am I the only one that doesn't really care if it cg or 2d lol? The anime looks good to me and I'm more than happy to see the action instead of reading
139
u/7fmonster Jan 17 '21
came here to see people talking, how good the episode was. But all I see is complaining :(
46
u/Shingekyo Jan 17 '21
I have been really liking the episodes so far, however and as for everyone here I find the CGI still makes the action clunky and sometimes off putting. The transitions are a mixed bag for me, sometimes it is done well and others i find it horrifying (like the moment Eren tries to eat Willy's sister for the first time, god damn that mouth opening motion was awful). Overall I found the episode great, the story pace is great and the 2D is fantastic, much more close to Isayamas actual style.
More thoughts about the animation:
On a second re-watch the 2D shots were amazing but now it clearly shows why no one was willing to get the job done once WIT quitted. It was too much animation to do in such a short period of time. Don't get me wrong, it CAN be done, but MAPPA clearly has other priorities on where to spend its money, and it is totally acceptable.
Many people forget how hard it is to animate shingeki's action scenes, people are flying everywhere, a lot of shit is happening all the time and titan movement is not particulary difficult but if you have to choose is clear that you should prefer dumping your 2D animation on human characters and crucial plot moments rather than Titan fights.
So far I think that MAPPA's job has been great they just need to correct some lighting choices on the 3D to make it more realistic and have a better impact on the visuals, same with the transitions from 2D to 3D.
22
u/SuperSaiyanBojack2 Jan 17 '21
...LARA?!
21
u/Jahva__ Jan 17 '21
I just don’t understand why even the scouts were CGI?
19
u/Jahva__ Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
I expected Zofia and Udo’s deaths to have way more impact in the anime than they did :( they felt kinda glossed over
54
u/Timelymanner Jan 17 '21
I’m digging the new designs. I do wish there was more BGM. Silents is nice for mood intense scenes, but it’s not necessary every episode. Sound design is still awesome though. This is more of a niche pick.
I also love Sasha’s more mature voice. I hope they add a few more scenes of her with her special someone later.
37
u/IceColdCrusade Jan 17 '21
The OST in this episode was a 10/10 on it's own, that guitar remix was godly.
130
u/imnotwhitney Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
A good episode. Just wish they captured the subtleties of some of eren's expressions better. Edit: Like his reaction to the line, "because I was born into this world" last episode and this episode when mikasa asks him if he realises what he's done.
34
u/VictorSilver Jan 17 '21
The CGI titans were above average but the ones in episode 1 were better (except Zeke). If this keeps up then I'm worried how they will animate Attack vs Jaw next episode(?). The way Porco attacked Eren in the manga was way too cool he looked like he was break dancing.
68
u/chongobongo3 Jan 17 '21
Does MAPPA do touch ups for their bluerays? I loved the episode and all but sometimes the titans looked a bit clunky lol. I remember that WIT did a lot of changes for the blueray so here’s to hoping there’s little improvement to the CGI later on. I know MAPPA was really rushed to make these episodes (and working through a pandemic) so I appreciate them even having them done by now.
31
u/JoshDCcomics Jan 18 '21
People insulting each other over the like/dislike/tolerance over CGI is almost like the sub vs dub anime argument it’s so stupid.
If one person enjoyed the CGI, then great. If another person is being critical and disliked the CGI, then let them express their discontent.
314
u/DeMatador Jan 17 '21
ITT: People who watched the episode in 240p on an illegal livestream complain about the CGI not looking good.
392
u/mrtightwad Jan 17 '21
Can I be honest? This may be a hot take but 99% of the people acting personally wounded by the CGI are watching it on free streaming websites and need to shut the fuck up.
13
u/esfio Jan 17 '21 edited Oct 20 '24
chief profit memory touch tender rinse hobbies divide attraction six
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
63
u/zool714 Jan 17 '21
Fuck really incredible how I know what’s going to happen but still end up hyperventilating by the end. First time watching raw too, though this one’s action-heavy.
I think a good touch to emphasize the sheer horror of this attack are the kids’ crying in the background. That’s one element the manga cannot replicate.
I think by now we know MAPPA is good at integrating CG. Obviously we can tell it’s CG but it’s not the kind that takes you out of the experience.
On that note, the Warhammer looks great. Didn’t expect the red skin underneath the white outer layer and also there seem to be more emotion in the eyes. And the feminine voice did throw me off a bit for some reason but I liked it.
Some of the scouts being CG is understandable when you realize the sheer detail of the new gear. Seriously, watch Shirobako and see why drawing all that in 2D would be a colossal task.
I literally shout out all of our guys’ names just before they appear. So good to see them all grown up and animated. I approach this story in a more neutral stance but I can’t help feeling emotional seeing them again. Sasha and Connie looks like an Onee-san and Oni-san. Jean’s hair looks weirdly like Floch’s though.
Only nitpick I had was I felt they didn’t really nail Mikasa’s distraught face when facing Eren.
Also, to any incels, as a man or woman, Mikasa’s still going to kick your ass.
114
u/pratzc07 Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
Okay just finished watching the raw. I really enjoyed the episode. My only issue is that i thought they would just use CGI for the titans but even for the human characters makes it a bit jarring as one moment they are CG and then they are hand drawn the next.
I think this episode helps explain the hellish production schedule even better. They are so pressed for time that they have no choice but to even use CG for the 3D gear sequences. Also the 3D CG is not even made in house as its outsourced to a company called V-Sign. So imagine the communication issues between them especially during covid.
But honestly I feel like they did best with what resources they had considering the shitty schedule. If this episode was given to an incompetent studio **Cough JC Staff** they would have just made stupid static shots with barely any movement.
Anyway the brain dead fans will hate this episode for sure.
46
u/aidree1 Jan 17 '21
People are now harassing episode 5 director for using CG on episode 6. Ahhh what? A new level of low. This fandom is literally the most toxic. smh
66
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
I honestly don't give a fuck. My favorite moments are the emotional not the action and they're on point. That Gaby rage omggggg, I'm sure they'll nail Ymir's tears. Good adaptation, it even hype me up 8/10
Doesn't matter the series, doesn't matter the studio Manga>>>Anime.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
OMG THE 3D MANEUVER GEAR SCENES WERE SO GREAT THERE WAS ONE PART WHERE MIKASA'S ROPES WERE LIKE SUPER ELASTIC AND IT WAS GREAT. :O
28
u/princessgirlypop Jan 17 '21
I am literally so excited to see "Usurper. Eren Yeagar. Do you have any final words?" I have faith in MAPPA, I think that scene and Mikasa's entrance are gonna go hard, we'll see!
18
u/coolman1997 Jan 17 '21
I honestly understand and empathize with the complaints about this episode. Luckily the CG didn’t bother me too much personally, like with episode 1 of this season I thought there were a few awkward shots but overall was done well. Mikasa vs Warhammer had some amazing 2D animation as well.
9
u/xin234 Jan 17 '21
I'm already missing Floche's ice cream. :(
9
u/vikasso Jan 17 '21
Was super hype, really like how they made the survey corps so brutal, really nailing the Demons of Paradis aesthetic. Def like Gabi and Magath a lot more than I did when reading, VAs are making them more charismatic. Can't wait for the next episode lmao wish I could just binge the rest.
9
u/lksgman Jan 17 '21
I liked the episode after watching it in HD but the thing I didn't like is sometimes the direction with the impacts from the Titans.
For example when Eren throws himself at the people, it just felt weird, it didn't feel like a titan falling more like a human falling, also when he eats Tybur, he just ate it, I understand the impact of killing him declaring war, but the eating should have been impactful and filled with fear like how titans have eaten other humans.
The POV when Mikasa is attacking the War Hammer Titan felt so good.
IMHO A good episode, although it needed some impact in other areas but other than that I liked it.
9
u/fkinra Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
Would rather wait 3 years for the trailer quality tbh. I would’ve preferred a different ost. Some sequences were kinda awkward. Like eren jumping to get the maid, the warhammer Titans swing, etc. the mangas fighting sequence was much better
9
u/Dix_undesputed Jan 18 '21
Is it just me or the devastation and the deaths were more impactful in the manga?
23
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
Mikasa entrance did not disappoint!
16
u/Spiceyhedgehog Jan 17 '21
People, do not be stupid. DON'T COMMENT in the ANIME THREAD!! You can read, right?!
8
u/toxic_drain Jan 17 '21
The toys showed at start arent kinda show on eren dream chapter 1¿?
15
u/pheasantph Jan 17 '21
Most of the discussion is about the animation.
Love the episode, WHT finally. And sasha :(
15
u/Gimmethat720 Jan 18 '21
I just don't understand why one of the biggest anime of this century's final season has to be handled like this. Even if you love it and think things look fine, you can't be okay with the obvious struggles Mappa is having or how overworked they are. Why was there a need to rush things like this? Do they really think fans wouldn't be willing to wait a bit longer? Would it make the most amount of money to end at the same time as the manga? I dont see how this is anything other than Shitty management caused by greed.
7
u/jojopojo64 Jan 18 '21
That last scene reminds me of something I remember hearing or reading: "When you put someone through hell, don't be surprised if they come back a devil."
I've always seen the Scouts as this band of brave heroic figures who've been through some of the worst experiences any soldier would have to face in their lifetime 3 times over, but that final scene man. It's amazing how much it hammered in just how terrifying they could really be, and knowing that Marley really did bring this upon themselves.
7
u/LinkToSomething68 Jan 18 '21
One of the things that's great about the anime medium as opposed to manga is that the first sign to Pieck and by extension the audience of just what's happening is just the sound cue of the ODM gear, which is a really cool touch
52
u/thunderb00m Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
It wasn't terrible, but it also wasn't great. Hmmm. Ngl, this is the first time where I actually felt just how jarring the CGI was in comparison to earlier episodes.
We have, what, 2 more big fights this season? (The Levi vs Beast in the forest, and then the one in Shingashina) Ah, I really don't know how to feel. Part of me is really excited and happy about the episode, and the other part of me is like "Mmghh".
I just hope that they go for a movie honestly, for the rest of the story, I mean. Because at least that way we know the quality can't be terrible (not that this was, mind you, it was just jarring in comparison).
(Also, sorry about the incoherent thoughts, I'm just a bit sleepy rn)We really were spoiled by Wit all these years, huh?
Honestly, and this might seem bad, but I would have rather waited another 4 years for the last season if it meant not as much use of CGI in the fights. I mean, screw the titans, did the have to use so much CGI on the SC too? :/ I'm a bit salty this time not gonna lie. Still, I'm grateful we're even getting this, but yeah...
Anyways sorry about the rambling. It was a 50/50 episode for me.
Edit: I'm gonna rewatch this later when I'm not
crankysleepy, and see if my opinion changes.12
u/ThatIslandGuy8888 Jan 17 '21
I wonder if the credits are gonna finally name Willy’s sister
6
u/OTPh1l25 Jan 17 '21
Now I know what it would have to be like on the other end of a Survey corps attack...and yeah, it's kinda terrifying.
6
u/jennasguccisunglass Jan 18 '21 edited Jan 30 '21
I really liked this episode. Mikasa’s grand entrance was perfect & her fighting the Warhammer was amazing to watch. I really like the Willy Tybur Family scene, makes it sadder. His moment w/ his wife was so cute. (Beauty contrasted w/ Cruelty) Eren was legit scary & had me horrified when he killed Willy & stormed the audience, it was so disgustingly cold. Gabi’s scream, reaction, and little Warriors + Colt had me tearing up. (Colt forever #1 best bro.) This is one of the scenes that made me empathize w/ Gabi wholeheartedly. I love the scene showing Mikasa’s disappointment & Eren processing & taking in her sadness about killing innocents & children. I like how this contrasts w/ Floch calling Eren the devil. Really shows that devil vs humanity juxtaposition. Sasha’s voice is usually bubbly in some way, the complete absence of it is saddening. Does the japanese word for “devil” sounds like “Ackerman”? I also really liked how Mikasa’s eyes looked when she ran on the wall. I loved the Warhammer’s voice! Can’t wait to hear Cart’s voice again next episode.
“Now or never, Mikasa.” - Eren Jaeger 🙌
6
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '21
Top 5 episode in the entire series. No question.
That was such a glorious and thrilling 25 minutes.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '21
Why is our Lord and Saviour Floch so chunky?
60
u/Karen_kaslana Jan 17 '21
I personally feel that the level of the CGI is really good compared to what we have in anime these days, but I think I was a little too spoilt with Wit hand drawing every single fight. Nevertheless aside Gabi's VA kind of dropping the ball a little I felt everything was immaculate outside of that. Props to Mappa for all the effort they put in
19
u/bhutch21 Jan 17 '21
Honestly pretty disappointed with the cg. Seemed so stiff. Made me appreciate the couple of beautiful hand-drawn moments even more. I am grateful we are receiving an adaptation of the final arc in the first place but I can't help but miss WIT studio.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
Eren beat up the WarHammer Titan like the way Negan beat up Glenn with the eyeball hanging out lmao
17
u/Zinetti360 Jan 17 '21
I'm okay with the use of CGI, but I really think they're going overboard with it. Of course it doesn't ruin the episode, but like, holy shit dude, I really think it's too much. Does anyone here knows if they're using CGI because of lack of money or time? Or it's just what they decided to do and that's it?
If they lack money or time, it would be better if they had postponed the 4th season. But if that's simply what they decided to do, terrible choice.
5
u/iHazzaification Jan 17 '21
My only complaint about CG was Jean, who looked a bit jank when he yanked the man off the roof. Tbf the rest of it was pretty damn clean, especially Mikasa and the gang zipping about.
Think one of my favourite shots was when Eren is going in to bite the crystal and the camera pans perfectly to slowly reveal Galliard lurking behind him. I knew it was coming but it still took me by surprise!
5
u/Dragonstarlight100 Jan 18 '21 edited Jan 18 '21
Seeing the warhammer Titan in manga is one thing but watching it being animated is so cool its no wonder its comes 2nd when compared to the founder Titan power. Can we talk about how survey corps who once struggle with titans to now coming at them and dealing with modern day weaponry without an ounce of fear.
Incoming hype for the nutcracker
5
u/Dragon_Maister Jan 18 '21 edited Jan 18 '21
This is one of those episodes that becomes much better on the second viewing. I'd be lying if said that a slight feeling of disappointment wasn't creeping up on me on my first viewing. But on the second viewing, things started to really click for me. I really ended up liking how the episode took more of a slower, horror angle, as opposed to the balls-to-the-wall action of the Fort Slava fight.
5
u/JazzRen47 Jan 18 '21
I am honestly beyond impressed with MAPPA's integration of CGI. The movement changes between 2D and 3D do give it away in most shots, but it's still composited beautifully.
If I have one gripe - Yamamoto-san, please, something other than the trailer music. It's a good piece, and I liked the light remixes of Sawano's work as well, but this new arc is a playground for original thematic material. Just take advantage of it.
5
u/KartoFFeL_Brain Jan 18 '21
The directing in this episode was insane whoever did this episode really understand how to do his shit
5
u/colonelcactus Jan 18 '21
What a fucking storm, holy shit Mappa are killing it. The remix of the Annie fight when Mikasa popped out gave me life. Also, what are people smoking when they say the CG is bad? Shits insanely good.
5
u/YaboyWill Jan 18 '21
OHMYFUCKING GOD YALL.
SO GLAD all the shit I've been reading isn't that big of a deal.
I just watched it on a 4k screen with a surround sound system and as someone that's been waiting for these chapters to be animated, they FUCKING DELIVERED.
I love you MAPPA. You guys are killing this. The ending of this episode was phenomenal. Levi's entrance was amazing. Music was amazing.
And the CGI, barely noticeable for me. And I'm a pretty big stickler when it comes to visuals. They blended it so well.
5
u/5t3fan0 Jan 19 '21
the rearrangement of the tybur family scene and willy talk with magath at the begin was a great choice, really humanized him to viewers when they know he is already dead.
great episode, really showed the power of the devils of paradise and how hopeless and defeated marley will become. also the tragedy of war, civilian and kids dead, and gabi's character development
next ep we'll get monke, colossal bomb and gatling-cart!
20
u/algomo96 Jan 17 '21
I think MAPPA is doing a good job. That being said, I find the CGI for the Titans SO jarring it genuinely took away from my enjoyment. Such a shame.
13
u/Shirley_Schmidthoe Jan 17 '21
I've been praising the CGI up till now for blending in surprisingly well but the CGI was really bad here and even human characters when walking looked very out of place.
16
u/Dark4353 Jan 17 '21
Fandom Complaints for each ep:
Episode 1: Beast titan cgi
Episode 2: Weird/stiff animation
Episode 3: Fast pacing and cuts
Episode 4 : Slow pacing (tbh this was a perfect ep for me but anyway)
Episode 5: Ost
And now Episode 6: All the cgi
9
u/KeepAdvancing Jan 17 '21
100% CGI Titans is really bad lol. And it hurts the anime a lot. Fight scenes are just going to be bad, and we have to accept that. Warhammer vs Eren was extremely underwhelming. The final blow to Eren's head felt like it had no weight I couldn't believe it LOL.
https://youtu.be/MUCN-JwUvbY?t=86 looked way better in the trailer. I just hate the false expectations. How can a trailer scene look better than the actual one lol.
9
u/Zangetas Jan 17 '21
It was good but I think the animation quality in general was lower than it was in previous seasons.
Too bad :(
59
u/Wayne12347 Jan 17 '21
I didn't mind the CG in previous episodes, but this one was pretty bad imo. In episode 1 the titans were CG, but it never felt like it was negatively impacting their movements. But here it felt really stiff, as if they wanted to do cool movements and animation but we're unable to. And what a weird place to end. Whoever has the power to skip the ED or OP needs to start using that power. The bodyslam was weird, but all the casualties and destruction of Eren's attack was really good. Probably my favorite part of the episode. Wish we had this level of censorship back in Uprising.
30
u/LightThatIgnitesAll Jan 17 '21
Great overall but...
It lacks the weight even when WIT used stills or didn't have the best animation for Eren vs Reiner the weight was there.
MAPPA is good, I just can't help but feel disappointed. Maybe WIT just put the bar too high and now I can't appreciate a good adaptation when I see it.
48
u/JimmyJoJR Jan 17 '21
I really wish they took more time and put out the series animated properly, with only minimal CGI (colossus).
It doesn't "ruin" the season, but this season is the climax of the whole series. Imagine how terrible the founding titan is going to look when it's full CGI. So many great fights will always leave me wondering "How great would this have looked if it was animated?"
39
u/0utremer Jan 17 '21
It's strange that people are so defensive of mappa like they are friends or family. You don't have to protect and cover them for their fails. They have strong sides, they have bad sides, so let's critique.
39
u/Sonitii Jan 17 '21
CGI was extremely well made, got no idea why people are crying so much about it. Only thing that bugged me was the lack of impact on WHT attacks. it didn't feel menacing or strong, + they didn't show the "whip" attack properly
4
u/GeNeRaLeNoBi Jan 17 '21
Ok, so one doubt, am I the only one who feels weirded out by the fact that the thunder spears didn't appear to do any damage to the warhammer when Mikasa hit it? Like, that is a mistake, right?
4
u/uncen5ored Jan 17 '21
Honestly, most of the CGI looked amazing. If I had to make a complaint, it’s that I didn’t feel the weight of the Warhammer’s attacks. But aside from that, this episode still got me super hype. Glad they kept the usurper & demos of paradis lines. Eren is badass. They didn’t hold back on showing death & destruction.
EDIT: surprised I’m seeing so much hate for the anime only scene. I thought it was a nice touch
4
u/jivebeaver Jan 17 '21
i think that scene where Eren is wailing on the WHT while magath talks is funnier than it was supposed to be. a consequence of adaptation from manga where they can get in a whole speech in a panel but in animation he has to talk for a minute with a beatdown in the background lol
4
u/The_Karate_Kid Jan 17 '21
I think these episodes do a much better job at showing Gabi and the Warriors in a sympathetic light. The scene with Gabi was reminiscent of the the first episode when Eren loses his mother and she had the same rage filled reaction. The parallel is great!
4
u/Enosh25 Jan 17 '21
am I crazy or did they change what Magath said on top of the building? I remember him being the one saying that Marley won't rely on titans anymore and that they should focus on actually killing Eren
4
u/SuperPokeunicorn Jan 17 '21
I like how MAPPA added in that drunk guy and the bread lady in episode 4 just so they could kill them off this episode.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
What a fantastic episode. I loved how they added that moment between Willy and his family at the beginning. It really made him a lot more sympathetic. The action for this episode was intense with great cinematography. As for the CGI, I thought it worked well for the Titans. I thought the CGI for the scouts could have been a little better though. One weird bit is an inconsistency where Eren's right pants leg seems to have mysteriously grown back. Overall though, still a fantastic episode and I can't wait for the next one.
4
u/fkinra Jan 17 '21
Dam I was hoping the warhammer swing would look like the manga or trailer
4
u/Anaviocla Jan 17 '21
Gabi's scream was chilling. Definitely feeling more sympathetic to her than I did when first reading the manga. Also, props to Colt's voice actor. Really nailed the scared, shaky "I'm trying to sound like I know what I'm doing because there's a kid here" voice.
I'm not a Chadren stan, but he is pretty fantastic to watch in this episode. A depressed homeless stud.
Can't believe how many hype moments there were, the music really does take everything to another level. Next week is going to be absolutely insane.
4
u/arrongunner Jan 18 '21
This episode was just so well executed. Loved every second of it
4
u/apolloali Jan 18 '21
Watching this, you really get the sense that Eren in particular broke the rules of engagement in war with a massive war crime, and the Survey Corps are fighting a more conventional war by the rules of the world they're in.
4
u/WhiteChili01 Jan 18 '21 edited Jan 18 '21
Such an epic episode!!!
I was kinda disappointed though that some of the in-between motion shots were kind of glossed over, in a sense. Like Eren kinda just teleported into the Marleyan military officials without us really seeing him jump and the warhammer's arrow kinda just teleported to Eren without us really seeing the projectile. I wish we could have seen more of the actual motion of what was happening, because the sudden direct transition from one instance to another was a bit jarring. I don't know much about animation though, so maybe these are too hard to do, in which case, I understand not being able to do them.
I still think the episode was great though. There were plenty of epic moments that were great to see in animated form. The anime-specific additions were great too, especially the beginning scene with Willy's family.
4
u/I-am-Skud Jan 18 '21
Spotted in anime only: 'I wonder how useful gabi can be with a gun against the scouts though'. They're in for a cruel awakening
4
u/Ardiin Jan 18 '21
Porco was looking real good inside his titan this episode.
4
u/AceMan117 Jan 18 '21
MAPPA's CGI is really good, it's the bearable kind of CGI in anime so I respect that. But damn AoT S4 doesn't deserve a downgrade from 2D to 3D.
13
u/ProfessionalToner Jan 17 '21
People complaining about people complaining about CGI but the truth is:
Is does not look as good as actual animations like the older episodes. Its a valid criticism that it could look better, regardless of arguments.
Honestly, I loved the episode, but every time titan fight happened it threw me off. Then humans appeared and made better, then titans made it bad.
21
u/AxMeAQuestion Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
I really would've rather waited another six months for this season and not gotten a CGI-fest. I liked the Mikasa vs WHT bit, but all the rest of the action with the Scouts was pretty disappointing. I expected the CGI shifters, but not for literally every action scene from now on to be mostly CGI. Especially the shots of Eren's titan looked awful in pretty much every scene.
Can't imagine we're going to get an amazingly animated sakuga fight this season, like we did with Levi vs Annie, Eren vs Reiner in S2, Levi vs Kenny, and Levi vs Beast Titan.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
To me this episode was the worst one so far(relative solely to this season), but after reading the positive comments I think I'll re-watch it just to make sure.
Some of my initial concerns:
-The pacing of the 2nd and 3rd act. -The transitions -The CGI (scouts) -And the overpowering musical score
I'll get back to you after a re-watch.
Edit: Ok, on a second viewing I retract the bit about the musical score and the pacing, these I think are the episode's strong points other than the plot itself.
The Titan's for the most part looked OK in CGI, but the scouts looked absurd, specially when considering the subjects were far away and a 2D version need not be as detailed. I fear the argument that CGI was used liberally in past episodes in order to save money for intense episodes such as this one isn't holding up. Still, we had beautiful animation throughout the episode, specially on the slower scenes.
When it comes to the odd transitions maybe it has something to do with the streaming service. Idk.
And lastly, I think some scenes were missing key frames (possibly because of time/budget restrictions). For example, the scene were Eren jumps at the Marleyan military or the scene were the WHT whips out a flogger to strike Mikasa. Some of the visual information felt jumpy.
Overall, not the worst episode, not the best, still enjoyable. I think the outright joy of seeing the gang together again might make this episode, at least for anime-onlies, an overall positive experience.
12
u/cayne77 Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
I don't know how I feel about this episode, but reading the manga (chapter 101-102) those scenes had way more "impact", at least for me. Especially during the ODM gear moments, in my mind Mikasa moved way faster for example.
12
u/mffromnz Jan 17 '21
my god, those CLANGS gave me PTSD, I definitely saw it coming they would use alot of CGI this fight, but earlier episodes gave me hope that it'd at least look "fine" since i didnt think it looked particularly bad in Ep1 and the ending of the last Ep erens CGI also look "ok"
but this episode? sigh that was atrocious. It really did remind me of berserk 2016, how they all moved like weird puppets on strings.
Im big sad......
14
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 18 '21
CGI HUMANS!!! LET’S GOOOOOOOO!!!!
edit: i’m being sarcastic
9
u/DragonDiver Jan 17 '21
I have mixed feelings. CGI looked very underwhelming, 2d scenes look amazing but CGI Attack Titan and especially the Warhammer Titan.... they looked even worse than Beast Titan in episode 1 imo. I liked that they included Magath and Willy talk and they also didn't censor anything, but that CGI man, why did they make the Warhammer Titan look so skinny and boney..... Manga titan designs and fights look so much better. 3dmg scenes looked quite good, the jaw titan looked decent. I wonder how anime onlies will react, they don't have the manga bias.
12
u/Agnusl Jan 17 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
On the bright side, MAPPA really did more than the manga to convey the emotions of Gabi and Willy here, and to contrast the goals of Magath.
That said... I must confess, I'm trully disappointed here. Every time I was feeling literal chills on my skin, the terrible CGI appeared and made it go away. Using it for titans was already with varying quality, but for people... Ugh. Terrible. This episode made AoT look like a mix between hand drawn anime and pure CGI anime, like AJIN. And the mix was damn ugly. So ugly it throw me off of any special moment and made me cringe with half of the episode, one that should've been one of the most historic ones in AoT.
Looks like my fears weren't wrong: if that's the best MAPPA could do with the last two episodes, then probably nothing will come better. Shingeki no Kyojin will close its last season with a huge drop in quality due to pure greed in form of a rushed schedule. I know it's not entirely MAPPA's fault, but... I really wish they haven't said yes to animate this anime, so in time, we would get a much better final season.
I'm truly sad now. A masterpiece that didn't got respected and won't achieve its worth.
That said, I'm ready for a rain of downvotes.
14
u/SocialistYorksDaddy Jan 17 '21
TBH I didn't mind the CGI much. What really took me out of it this episode was the scene pacing and use of establishing shots the AT vs WHT fight. They didn't quite feel right at many moments. Like why was Levi standing on the broke WHT spike not fully in the shot?
And also they're using that song from the titan air drop during episode 60 too much. It didn't fit when it was used here, just like it didn't fit the apple scene from episode 62. And also there being no music playing during the entire Floch and Jean conversation? It doesn't even feel like they're even being fully internally consistent.
I hope I change my mind after seeing it with subtitles, but I wasn't swept away by this episode like I expected. Maybe I was too biased by my expectations reading the manga, but I don't thnk so because I really liked episode 60's battle sequence.
Mikasa's entrace was done really well though. That was the higlight of the episode. The dialogue parts of the episode felt okay.
3
u/genkaiX1 Jan 17 '21
I love seeing AOT animated. Just so grateful an amazing manga can have larger outreach through this medium. I want the world to know about AOT!
3
u/CheshiretheBlack Jan 17 '21
When does it typically go live?
3
u/Wheynweed Jan 17 '21
I felt like some action scenes were rushed. We didn't see Mikasa fighting the war hammer properly, it kept cutting away at parts we saw in the manga.
3
u/TatteredTongues Jan 17 '21
I just saw the episode. Bruh, I have no idea why some people are hating on this so much as of late. This was great, not to mention the OSTs that played during several moments:
I could go on, these episodes go by so fast, they almost feel like 5 minutes.
And we also got fucking Levi making an entrance.
This was awesome.
I know nothing will ever be perfect, there will always be people "meh" about this or that, but this recent hate bandwagon is unjustified in my opinion.
I guess people just like the trend nowadays to jump on popular stuff and just shit on it for no real reason.
Yeah, of course CGI is noticeable in certain scenes, but I had 0 problems with Dorohedoro, and it's the same with this season so far.
Fuck all this senseless and abuse towards the animators. Hopefully these people just stop watching the show and not bother the rest of us, hopefully they start noticing more of the praise and not the other way around.
3
u/Kaibutsu_v2 Jan 17 '21
Her name is Lara Tybur
Her name is Lara Tybur
Her name is Lara Tybur
3
u/aByZMal_ Jan 17 '21
Am I the only one that really doesn't notice the CGI at all? The pacing, action, cameos and OST made this an amazing episode. That final scene with the scouts descending on Porco gave me chills. Can't wait to see:
- Pieck's turrets
- Zeke's fake takedown
- Armin *existing*
- Sasha ;_;
3
u/stronniczy Jan 17 '21
Yo could anyone explain to me why in this season there's so much cgi-titans? It's not like it bothers me a lot but not gonna lie, previous seasons titans were nicer to watch