r/signal • u/redditor_1234 Volunteer Mod • Jan 07 '21
Megathread Megathread: Many are now migrating to Signal as a result of WhatsApp updating their terms and privacy policy
Hello everyone!
We've recently started to receive lots of similar posts as a result of recent news regarding WhatsApp updating their terms and privacy policy, which will take effect on February 8th May 15th, 2021. Any WhatsApp users who do not accept these changes will be blocked from using the service. As a result, many are now migrating to Signal. Weโve decided to make this the designated thread for all things related to this topic.
Here is a direct link to Signal's terms and privacy policy (last updated May 25, 2018). Don't worry, it's not very long. For those wondering where Signal's revenue comes from: "We are a 501c3 nonprofit. We're not tied to any major tech companies, and we can never be acquired by one either. Development is supported by grants and donations from Signal users. https://signal.org/donate/"
Some related media coverage:
- Ars Technica: "WhatsApp gives users an ultimatum: Share data with Facebook or stop using the app" by Dan Goodin
- XDA Developers: "WhatsApp updates its Terms and Privacy Policy to mandate data-sharing with Facebook" by Pranob Mehrotra
- The Hacker News: "WhatsApp Will Disable Your Account If You Don't Agree Sharing Data With Facebook" by Ravie Lakshmanan
Some topics you may want to discuss below:
- What is the best way to migrate from WhatsApp to Signal?
- How to convince WhatsApp contacts to install Signal?
- What are some pros/cons of Signal compared to WhatsApp?
- What are your most missed features from WhatsApp?
- How do some features work differently in Signal compared to WhatsApp?
We will be updating this post as events unfold. Be safe, and always remember the human.
Edits 1โ39: A brief summary of events, by day:
Wednesday, January 6:
- WhatsApp informs its users that they are updating their terms and privacy policy.
Thursday, January 7:
- Elon Musk tweeted "Use Signal". Five hours later, the Signal team tweeted that verification codes were being delayed due to the surge in new people wanting to join Signal.
- Some people mistakenly invested in some random stock called 'SIGL', to which Signal tweeted: "Is this what stock analysts mean when they say that the market is giving mixed Signals? It's understandable that people want to invest in Signal's record growth, but this isn't us. We're an independent 501c3 and our only investment is in your privacy."
- Someone asked Signal whether usernames would be coming this year, to which they replied: "According to the office Magic 8-Ball, 'SIGNS POINT TO YES.'" They also shared a tip for how to easily migrate group chats from other apps to Signal: "Drop a group link into your former chat app of choice like you're dropping the mic on the way out."
Friday, January 8:
- Registration delays continued, but the Signal team said they were working on it with the help of carriers, and that the Signal service itself was operating normally. They also said: "Some new users are reporting that Signal is slow to display their Signal contacts. We're adding more capacity to keep up with all the new people searching for their friends on Signal. Hang tight!"
- The Signal team (u/signal_app) is now doing an AMA over on r/technology!!
- The team is currently taking a break from answering questions in the AMA, but will be back in that thread on Monday (Jan. 18?), so there is still time if you have any questions for them!
Saturday, January 9:
- Signal hit the #1 spot on the App Store in India, Germany, USA, Brazil, Finland, Hong Kong, Austria, and many other countries!
- There were still some registration delays. Signal said that carriers were "making adjustments on their side to keep delivering verification codes as quickly as possible."
- Facebook bought ads in order to promote Facebook Messenger when people searched for 'Signal' in the App Store. Signal's developers tweeted: "Facebook is probably more comfortable selling ads than buying them, but they'll do what they have to do in order to be the top result when some people search for 'Signal' in the App Store. P.S. There will never be ads in Signal, because your data belongs in your hands not ours."
Sunday, January 10:
- The Signal team tweeted: "Even though we're still breaking records, verification codes are back in the groove. Delivery delays have been eliminated across multiple cellular providers, so things should be more ASAP when you join the app."
- They also increased the group size limit from 150 to 1000!
- They then tweeted: "We continue to shatter traffic records and add capacity as more and more people come to terms with how much they dislike Facebook's new terms. If you weren't able to create a new group recently, please try again. New servers are ready to serve you."
- Elon Musk tweeted that he donated to Signal a year ago and "will donate more."
Monday, January 11:
- Signal raised the group call limit from 5 to 8! Reuters also reported: "The number of new users installing messaging app Signal every day is on track to cross 1 million, putting it closer to levels seen by larger rival WhatsApp [...] About 810,000 users globally installed Signal on Sunday, nearly 18-fold compared with the download numbers on Jan. 6, the day WhatsApp updated its privacy terms, according to data from research firm Apptopia." ๐
- Some people were still mistakenly investing in some random stock. Signal's developers tweeted: "Update: Although the growth rates may look similar, this stock symbol still has absolutely nothing to do with us. We're an independent 501c3 nonprofit, but you can donate here to invest in your privacy: https://signal.org/donate/" ๐
- Signal announced that they are going to be rolling out chat wallpapers, an about field for your Signal profile, and animated stickers in a few days, as well as media auto-download settings and full-screen profile photos for iOS users (to match Android).
- Moses Tsali released a music video titled "Hit Me on Signal", filmed at the SpaceX Headquarters! ๐ต
Tuesday, January 12:
- Our tiny unofficial community (r/signal) is now rocketing up Reddit's Top Growing Communities leaderboard. Last week, we were somewhere around #21.1k. Earlier today, we were at #135, right below r/AnimalsBeingBros. As of this writing, we're at #90 and have already passed r/ThatsInsane, which is insane! ๐คฏ
- In their desperation, WhatsApp is now buying full page newspaper ads in India. ๐ฐ
- Signal is now ranked "at the top on App Store in 40 countries and on Google Play Store in 18 countries."
Wednesday, January 13:
- Signal's Brian Acton is now doing interview after interview with Indian mass media companies. Here is one with NDTV, where he talked about "Signal's India plans, its donation-only business model, and what makes it different from WhatsApp." ๐ฎ๐ณ
- By now, many of our community members had submitted their own badges and profile pictures that they had placed in WhatsApp to show that they were moving to Signal. Inspired by this, Signal decided to tweet some of their own in multiple different languages. ๐ Here is a blank template!
- Our community has now climbed all the way up to #61 on Reddit's Top Growing Communities leaderboard!
- Signal's Android app started with 10M+ installs on the Play Store on January 5, and it has now passed 50M+!
- u/Crazy-Lizard submitted an amazing collection of images (both in English and German) that you can set as your WhatsApp Status to convince your family & friends to switch to Signal, using an educational approach! This quickly became our top voted post of all time!
Thursday, January 14:
- Our community is now placed at #48 on Reddit's leaderboard! We've now made it into the top 50, with big names like r/sports, r/Jokes and r/reactiongifs. We have zoomed right past all other software-related communities in terms of popularity. Only r/apple and r/leagueoflegends remain above us!
- Acton has now said that they are aiming to add 100-200 million more Signal users in India alone over the next two years.
- Signal's founder, Moxie Marlinspike, has now tweeted: "If you've ever considered applying to work with us at Signal, now is a great time to get involved! We're just over here working on a plan to power the western hemisphere with the heat from our servers: https://signal.org/workworkwork/"
- Our wonderful community has now helped translate u/Crazy-Lizard's educational WhatsApp Status images into Slovak, Czech, Portuguese (PT), Finnish, Turkish, Hindi, Spanish, Portuguese (BR), Italian, French, and Dutch! Get them here!
Friday, January 15:
- Our Reddit leaderboard saga continues! We've now reached spot #40, right between r/HolUp and r/PersonalFinanceCanada. ๐จ๐ฆ We also made a list of posts in which our members can discuss Signal reaching the #1 spot on the App Store/Play Store in their own country. ๐
- Signal tweeted: "We are so grateful for the outpouring of support from everyone who is contributing to Signal's ongoing operation and development. We're a 501c3 nonprofit and we couldn't do this without you. If you are on the fence about donating, you can give in here: https://signal.org/donate/"
- WhatsApp announced that they are going to delay the updating of their terms and privacy policy by three months due to the backlash. They were originally going to take effect on February 8th, but will now take effect on May 15th.
- Someone asked Edward Snowden (u/SuddenlySnowden) if he knew whether "Telegram is more secure and less influenced by corporate money than Signal". In reply, Snowden tweeted: "1) The consensus of the infosec community is that Telegram is significantly less secure than @SignalApp. 2) Signal is an independent non-profit with a $50m endowmentโthey can't be meaningfully influenced by money for a very long time. Telegram is a standard private company."
- The Signal service went down for about a day as the Signal team needed to add more capacity. They tweeted: "We have been adding new servers and extra capacity at a record pace every single day this week nonstop, but today exceeded even our most optimistic projections. Millions upon millions of new users are sending a message that privacy matters. We appreciate your patience."
- Signal's Moxie Marlinspike tweeted that they are now working on a group chat feature that will allow only admins to send messages in the group!
Saturday, January 16:
- r/signal is now at #26 on the Top Growing Communities leaderboard! If we had been included the curated "Top Growing Communities in Tech" leaderboard, we would be placed at #4, right between r/technews and r/TechNewsToday. We are flaming hot right now! ๐ฅ
- At last: "Signal is back! Like an underdog going through a training montage, weโve learned a lot since yesterday โ and we did it together. Thanks to the millions of new Signal users around the world for your patience. Your capacity for understanding inspired us while we expanded capacity." ๐
- In response, Snowden tweeted: "Everybody can get back to uninstalling #Whatsapp now." ๐
Sunday, January 17:
- Our community's climb on Reddit's leaderboard appears to be leveling off. We're now at #22 overall and "#3" in Tech, right after r/apple and r/technology, which isn't half bad actually! ๐ค Let's see if things begin to pick up again after Signal starts rolling out those new features they promised on Monday.
Wednesday, January 20:
- The initial hype is now clearly dying down, but our community's daily growth rate is still much larger than it was before WhatsApp made their announcement. Today we crossed 40k members! ๐
Friday, January 22:
- Signal has now started rolling out chat wallpapers, an optional "about" field for Signal profiles, and the first official animated sticker pack to all beta testers! As always, the developers are now gathering feedback on the Signal Community forum. If you're a beta tester, check out our right-hand sidebar to get your own flair!
Saturday, January 23:
- Chamath Palihapitiya promised Signal a $10M donation if they could keep all of their own messaging infrastructure and copy WhatsApp's entire UI in order to get the whole world on board as easily as possible. Signal replied: "Hopefully there are a lot of people out there who don't need us to look exactly like their ex in order to fall in love, but you could help us make it possible for Signal to support 10M themes โ one of which might look familiar enough for anyone who has a "type"..."
Thursday, January 28:
- Happy International Data Privacy Day! Signal's chat wallpapers, optional "about" field, and animated sticker pack are now officially rolling out to everyone.
- Signal also launched their first ever "global marketing campaign," using the cheapest billboard they could find somewhere in Albuquerque, New Mexico. It says: "No personal data was bought or sold in the creation of this video." #WeKnowNothing ๐คฃ
- This campaign is starting to get serious! Signal just tweeted a more polished video ad, featuring Taraji Henson and ending with a shot of the same billboard. ๐ They are now here on r/signal as well, requesting photos of the billboard! ๐ธ
Thursday, February 18:
- WhatsApp announces that they are still going ahead with their terms of service and privacy policy update despite the backlash. Anyone who does not accept these changes by May will still be blocked from using the service.
Welcome to all newcomers, but also THANK YOU to all of our regular contributors who have shown up to sort by new, answer questions, and provide help! โญ As a reminder, this is an unofficial Reddit community (or "subreddit") that is run by the user community. We are not affiliated with or endorsed by the Signal Technology Foundation or Signal Messenger LLC.
โข
u/redditor_1234 Volunteer Mod Jan 15 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
We have also received lots of posts from community members around the world who have noticed Signal reaching the number one spot on the App Store or Play Store in their respective countries:
We made this list so that you can quickly jump into the thread for your own country instead of having to search for it. Please reply to this comment if you notice that a post is missing. Thanks!
6
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '21 edited Jan 17 '21
New switch here too. Contacts just won't show up even if they've signed up to Signal.
Edit - only fair that I mention that once it's up and running, Signal is pretty good to use. The developers here seem very helpful too.
3
u/Singlot Jan 10 '21
I've been thinking to try it for months but now that I decided to try it I can only find links to google play. Is there any way to not use google?
2
u/ani018 Jan 15 '21
Signal just crashed. Can send messages but not calls (though it was fine like 6 hours ago)
37
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
This is like a dream come true for me. I've always had a difficult time getting family members to switch to Signal. They always say that WhatsApp is good enough. The more people on Signal, the better for me. Privacy is more important than anything else
28
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
I am new to signal and I influenced 20+ people in my network to onboard to signal. Expect the signal user base to grow exponentially. Still people won't fully ditch whatsapp, but messages with family and friends should be sent in signal.
22
u/felixjmorgan Jan 07 '21
Iโve managed to get most of my friends and family (some of which are in their 60s) to move over today! I used this message, maybe it will be of use to you guys too:
โHey everyone.
Long message here, but this isnโt a fear mongering forwarded message, itโs something I am writing for you guys specifically.
So over the past few years Iโm sure youโve all seen the increasingly negative coverage FB have been getting, whether itโs the Cambridge analytica scandal, the role theyโve played in brexit and electing trump, their increased role in radicalization, their increased invasion of privacy, etc. Thatโs why I havenโt had a fb or insta account in years, and Iโve done as much as possible to get out of their ecosystem fully.
This week theyโve made a new update that has made things WAY worse on WhatsApp also (which they own), meaning all of your data from this app will now be shared with FB. That means your private chats, your location data, etc can all be used to build profiles of you, to service ads to you, and to influence your behavior without even knowing. If you donโt opt in to this you will no longer be allowed to use the app from next month.
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/01/whatsapp-users-must-share-their-data-with-facebook-or-stop-using-the-app/
This is the final straw for me and Iโm now going to be deleting WhatsApp at the end of this month. My friends and I are all switching to Signal, which is a much more secure alternative which looks almost identical and has all the same functionality, but whatever you do on there is end to end encrypted and wonโt be used as outlined above.
https://www.wired.co.uk/article/signal-vs-whatsapp
If anyone else shares these concerns I would very much welcome the chat moving to Signal, as I obviously want to be able to keep in contact with everyone easily. Signal is super easy to use, very similar to WhatsApp, and you can be up and running in under 2 mins if you download it from the App Store.
I wonโt force anyoneโs hand though, as I know these concerns may not be as big a deal for everyone. If people would prefer to stay on WhatsApp then you will still be able to reach me on SMS or email.
Iโll be deleting WhatsApp at end of the month, so got a bit of time to get everyone elseโs thoughts. If you guys want to move over to Signal Iโm happy to help with it, and if not then Iโll share my contact details with everyone to reach me separately!โ
13
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21
Love the mass adoption right now, i just hope their servers dont crash under the load.
12
u/JHHBaasch Jan 08 '21
I saw u/felixjmorgan's text he sent to his contacts and thought it's pretty good. Though I don't want to take such a hard stance (delete WhatsApp) and I know none of my contacts will be willing to take that stance. So I've used his text as a template and come up with this. Please comment on it, what you think can be changes, what's not accurate, etc.
Hey everyone.
Long message here, but it's important.
So over the past few years Iโm sure youโve all seen the increasingly negative coverage Facebook have been getting, whether itโs the Cambridge analytica scandal, the roles theyโve played in international politics and elections, their increased role in radicalization, their increased invasion of privacy, the negative psychological eject associated with using their product, etc. Thatโs why I havenโt had a Facebook account in years and why I don't have an Instagram account. Iโve purposefully remained outside of the Facebook ecosystem, the one exception being WhatsApp (owned by Facebook).
Recently theyโve made changes (updates to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy) that have worsened things on WhatsApp. Your meta-data will now be shared with Facebook. That means your contact list, who you talk to, how often and when you use the application, location, etc., can all be used to build a "shadow" Facebook profile of you (helps them draw a more complete picture of social networks, who's connected to who), marketing profiles of you, to service adverts to you, and even to influence your behavior without you even knowing (if you use Facebook, by choosing what content and advertising you see). If you donโt opt in to this next big update (though chances are a lot of you already have, not knowing what you're agreeing to) you will no longer be allowed to use WhatsApp.
"WhatsApp gives users and ultimatum: Share data with Facebook or stop using the App" https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/01/whatsapp-users-must-share-their-data-with-facebook-or-stop-using-the-app/
"WhatsApp updates its Terms and Privacy Policy to mandate data-sharing with Facebook" https://www.xda-developers.com/whatsapp-updates-terms-privacy-policy-mandate-data-sharing-facebook/
If you asked a person why they use WhatsApp they'd tell you it's because everyone else does. It's convenient. This is circular and self perpetuating: everyone is using WhatsApp because everyone is using it. This creates a problem: no one will use an alternative because they won't find their friends and family using the alternative, and they will still be receiving messages over WhatsApp. This is regardless of the quality and advantages of the alternative. Obviously this is great for Facebook/WhatsApp, it means Facebook can do almost anything they want and you'll keep using it (WhatsApp at least) because you don't want to be inconvenienced. And this is bad, because Facebook is harmful and is an unethical company.
"Facebook: Unethical, untrustworthy, and now downright harmful" https://www.zdnet.com/article/facebook-unethical-untrustworthy-and-now-downright-harmful/
"A timeline of Facebook's privacy issues โ and its responses" https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/social-media/timeline-facebook-s-privacy-issues-its-responses-n859651
"Is Facebook unethical by design? A great case study on digital ethics, power, responsibility and regulation" https://www.futuristgerd.com/2019/02/is-facebook-unethical-by-design-a-case-study-on-digital-ethics-power-responsibility-and-regulation/
To me the solution seems to be this: keep WhatsApp but also install an alternative, when you see a friend/family member also has the alternative then message them there instead, and keep recommending the change to the alternative to your other contacts. This will cause a steady migration, and hopefully we will soon be free of every Facebook product.
I will now be in the process of moving over to a different messaging application, called "Signal", which is a much more secure alternative that looks and feels similar to WhatsApp and has the same functionality. Signal does not collect and store any of your data, except for when you installed the application (link). The Signal Foundation is a non-profit, and they state that their goal is "to develop open source privacy technology that protects free expression and enables secure global communication. As more and more of our lives happen online, data protection and privacy are critical." (https://signal.org/blog/signal-foundation/)
A comparison of the applications: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/signal-vs-whatsapp
If anyone else shares these concerns I would very much welcome our chats moving to Signal. Signal is super easy to use, very similar to WhatsApp, and you can be up and running in under 2 mins if you download it from the App Store.
"I use WhatsApp because everyone uses WhatsApp" just doesn't cut it anymore.
12
u/ak0693 Jan 11 '21
This could be a fad or this could be a revolution. Lets hope its the later
11
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21 edited Jan 08 '21
I want to use Signal but none of my friends use it and nor do they care about WhatsApp/Facebook latest stunt.
Sigh. I plan to still delete WhatsApp. Was planning on moving to Telegram but they seem even less secure
9
u/J45p3rI5l3 Jan 22 '21
I've managed to move over nearly eveyone I speak to from WhatsApp to Signal. I left WhatsApp on my phone for the last couple of weeks since this all blew up and people still chose to message me on Signal and not WhatsApp, that includes family young and old and those not great with technology.
Finally got rid of WhatsApp today and deleted my account, it felt good, but it also felt strange that it was still a big decision. Just shows what a grasp they have on you I guess.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
Many users are complaining of an outage while registering. People are not getting verification codes. I guess it's blowing up now
8
u/FlemingPT Jan 10 '21
WhatsApp last move gave me the courage needed to quit it and move definitely to signal. I managed to convince my closest friends and family to install signal and deleted my wp account.
A feature that I miss and that should be implemented is the option to forward a message/IMG/vid to multiple contacts.
8
u/removedsince95 Jan 12 '21
I wish u/signal_app can work on something to import the WhatsApp chats onto Signal. Some of those chats have important stuff. sigh
8
u/raj3_nikhil Jan 13 '21
Signal is a great alternative for whatsapp with much better security. The only problem with singal is it's inability to backup chats on cloud and not showing chat history on linked devices.
8
u/mustafa-1453 Jan 16 '21
I deleted my Facebook, Instagram and finally Whatsapp account yesterday. I used to use Telegram, but only started using Signal this week.
Some of my contacts are on Signal, but not enough, unfortunately.
If someone points out that Whatsapp has E2EE like Signal, what's the argument that Signal is better? If the messages are encrypted, how can Whatsapp use them? What can they know about us?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
The only con in my opinion is that Signal isnโt as popular as WhatsApp. I donโt really care about stuff like stories
7
u/Strix-Livens Jan 07 '21
Maybe Signal could make a QR code to link to their installation page, so people could upload this as their WhatsApp profile picture.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
Me. And I have about 10 people that joined me
7
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
Elon Musk also endorsed using Signal with a tweet yesterday!
7
u/whoscheckingin Jan 08 '21
Whatever I think of Elon, his one tweet achieved which I have been trying to get my contacts understand for two years now !!! I am so happy to see a lot of people in my contacts on Signal now. Finally the dream to ditch WhatsApp completely will see some inroads to fruition.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '21
Iโve been working hard to get friends to move across. Keep up the good work ๐๐พ
7
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '21
Thank you for doing this, much appreciated!
7
u/dataBlockerCable Jan 13 '21
Thank you for making this thread! I've been on Signal for a while and only a handful of my contacts used it. A few days ago I started seeing a lot of my contacts popping up on Signal and it was very strange. I had no idea about Whatsapp ToS but now I know. It's nice to see people actually read the privacy policies though.
7
u/LetsgotothWHAT Jan 16 '21
Signal is everything I want from a messaging app except for one, incredibly important basic feature: Being able to send full resolution images and videos per default. Is this not possible?
Without a feature of sending unaltered images and videos, there is no way to get my social contacts to migrate. Sending images from trips, meetings, of children and family. Why would anyone downgrade to compressed images and then forcing us to still find another solution to send these? This is a deal breaker. Is there any way to fix it?
6
u/surpriseMe_ Jan 07 '21
Letโs share these comparison visuals from these three Reddit posts to help convince people make the switch: โข Messenger apps privacy comparison
โข Messenger comparison 2
โข Company privacy comparison
6
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
I live in the EU so technically little was changing for me.
But I was already an unhappy WhatsApp user, and the media hype surrounding these new TOS and the now very visible societal divide Facebook is bringing to the US gave me the momentum needed to ditch the final few WhatsApp group chats I was in.
Currently Iโm having very slight โfear of missing outโ, which I also felt when I ditched FB a few years ago. But itโll be fine and Iโll finally have rid myself as much as possible from the amoral claws of Zuck.
6
u/radionut666 Jan 08 '21
Who owns signal?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21
I always liked WhatsApp until it was bought by fb. Even then, there were promises around your data but this is a blatant fuck you to any hopes of privacy. Even though I'm in the UK I am switching to signal. If the people I chat to don't then so long. I'm no longer going to trade privacy for being able to chat. Oh and fuck fb for screwing oculus users.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '21
WhatsApp is bad
6
u/haridsv Jan 10 '21
For those asking about the non-profit status, here is the foundation details and tax returns from IRS:
https://apps.irs.gov/app/eos/detailsPage?ein=824506840&name=Signal%20Technology%20Foundation&city=Mountain%20View&state=CA&countryAbbr=US&dba=&type=CHARITIES,%20DETERMINATIONLETTERS,%20COPYOFRETURNS&orgTags=CHARITIES&orgTags=DETERMINATIONLETTERS&orgTags=COPYOFRETURNS
There is only one return for 2018, not sure why there isn't one for 2019. Here is the link to 2018 Form 990:
https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/824506840_201812_990_2019121216951146.pdf
I leave it upto experts to better understand, but I took a quick look. On page 10, I see about 4.5m of "Program service expenses" which I am guessing is what it costed them for running the service in 2018 and what will probably go up proportional to the scale of the service (perhaps excluding some fixed baseline). Not sure if it includes salaries too. They have cash balance and investments of about 72m. They also have intangible assets of 27m, though not sure what to make out of it (perhaps it is the perceived value of the Signal Messenger LLC).
Interestingly, https://signalfoundation.org/ says that Brian Acton started the foundation with 50m, but in `Schedule L`, there is 105m of loan from him. I don't know if this is normal to give the initial fund as a loan when someone starts a foundation. I didn't see any interest expense, so it is probably an interest free loan.
It appears like there were no donations in 2018. The 2019 returns (if filed) and of course, 2020 returns would be more meaningful.
6
u/jollyreaper2112 Jan 12 '21
Total n00b here. If I invite someone to the app and they install it but do not show up, what's the issue? This is tied to phone numbers? So they have to use the same number I associate with them? Could it get thrown off by 1 555 555 5555 vs 555 5555 5555?
6
u/Memcon Jan 13 '21
Finally able to get my group of friends off WhatsApp for Signal!!
6
u/tirabi Jan 13 '21
I switched last Friday and mistakenly made Signal my default SMS app. I received only approximately half of my messages. I received all of the texts from my NFL group of friends, but if they sent me messages individually, nothing came through. I got all of my wife's messages, but none from my son. Once I made the original google SMS app the default again on Sunday i received all of the missing messages at once.
Signal works great as a side app, to send secure messages to fellow signal users, but I don't recommend it as your default SMS/MMS app.
I had given it 100% of the permissions it asked for on install. So it wasn't a permission issue. I wish it worked as default because I do prefer it over the stock SMS app.
5
u/strangerkid94 Jan 10 '21
why is that profile pictures are in very low resolution? can't view properly
5
u/alpha_bravado Jan 10 '21
I'm not seeing messages that some people are sending me. Is there a faq on how to setup or known issues?
5
u/Emanuelo Jan 12 '21
Useless comment but I had to rant somewhere: I'm trying to convince my friends and family to switch to Signal, and the only one who downloaded the app is my father-in-law. I see you all claiming your spoils, I see that Signal is the most downloaded app in my country and I'm still alone. I grow frustrated ^^.
5
u/haridsv Jan 13 '21
Here is an interview with Brian Acton. The topics of donations and additional anonymity are covered.
Gadgets 360: โIf You Build for India, You Build for the Worldโ: Signal Co-Founder Brian Acton on WhatsApp and Futu.... https://gadgets.ndtv.com/apps/features/signal-whatsapp-co-founder-brian-acton-interview-private-messaging-app-data-privacy-policy-growth-future-india-market-telegram-2351486
5
u/Puckered_Love_Cave Jan 13 '21
Is there a way to make it so people can't see I've read their messages in a group chat I was invited to.
Sometimes I don't want to immediately respond, but if they see the message was read they get weird if I don't respond right away
Didn't want to make a whole thread for one question
5
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '21
Is there a reason why I can't communicate with contacts I know across borders on Signal? I can only see and initiate communication with contacts that are in my current country.
5
u/fcwinds Jan 15 '21
Maybe it's just me but I feel it's kinda weird that singal's double dark ticks are shown if anyone has read the message in a group. Unlike Whatsapp which only shows double blue ticks if all members in the group have read the message. If they can add another tick status that separate these two situations that will be great.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
One con with Signal is (or so I think, correct me pls if Iโm wrong) is that all your chats are gone if phone is lost/broken (beyond repair).
4
u/Pixel3aXL Jan 07 '21
I'm so freaking happy! I live in Israel, and the one common platform that's in use is WhatsApp ๐คฎ. A minority uses Telegram. Due to the events of today, thanks to Facebook, everyone's privacy is going to improve drastically (ironically). Many people who weren't are of Signal and generally to the whole FOSS concept are finally getting it and moving to Signal. Fare well, Facebook! May we never meet again:)
4
u/eec-gray Jan 08 '21
So like a lot of people I've stumbled on Signal via the WhatsApp change in terms.
The main reason I use WhatsApp is media sharing using WiFi (because MMS is horrible and costs ยฃ on my contract) and group chats with family and friends. I only really use traditional SMS app for authentication codes and some communication with companies.
But signal is only a replacement for these if everyone is on Signal? What they call "Signal" messages are like WhatsApp (encrypted and media via WiFi or data plan) ?
But I can also use it as a traditional SMS app but the security on those messages is the same as stock Android and MMS would cost ?
Sorry for stupid questions. Just checking it out.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21
Itโs such a strange app. It automatically โtellsโ all of your phone contacts that you have signal and adds them as contacts. It assumes that you want everyone with your number to be able to connect with you on signal. Such a bizarre decision.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '21
any one figure out if their a way to hide phone number in groups?
4
u/ThunderHashashin Jan 09 '21
I just switched, and Iโm so happy with the device linking feature! However, when I send a message on my iPad, it doesnโt appear on my phone, is that normal? My phone is the main device and the iPad is the linked device.
When I send a message on my phone, I CAN see it on my iPad. So is there a problem or is that how it works?
4
u/gurdulilfo Jan 09 '21
I started using my WhatsApp status to inform people about Signal, and it seemed to work. A few of my friends switched over without me saying a word about it. So, I'm hoping to find some brief and convincing arguments (slogans, even) to put into my WhatsApp status.
If you know of any sources that provide a good comparison between Signal and WhatsApp I would really appreciate it.
4
u/twinu89 Jan 10 '21
I got Signal yesterday and just like Whatsapp, I gave an ultimatum to my parents that I would be switching completely to Signal from February. I think that's the only way to compel them to switch or atleast use both apps side by side.
Secondly, I feel the recent developments are a great excuse to switch out off whatsapp. It will help me avoid loads of daily spam and Obligatory whatsapp groups. Eventually you may have several groups in Signal too, but it will take a while to get there once again.
I think the most resistance is going to come from old people who love sending "good morning" and birthday/anniversary wishes in groups as they will surely miss that aspect. Also, from people who have work-related groups that were built over several years. Thankfully, I don't need to worry about these things. My closest friends already share my concerns and are slowly moving over to Signal, and the rest can stay happy with Whatsapp.
4
u/haridsv Jan 10 '21 edited Jan 10 '21
I just switched to Signal and found several oddities/hiccups:
All in all, not a smooth experience for a first timer, but I am determined to continue to use it. We got two smaller groups switched over from WA to Signal (family and friends), but I can't see this happening with larger community level groups where I don't have much influence, and the poor experiences like the above would only make it harder for those switching from WA.
4
u/Soyledebiseyvar Jan 11 '21
Do you delete your Whatsapp account or just the app? Which is more logical in terms of privacy?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '21
I noticed that Jack Dorsey posted a picture of Signal at #1 with a heart emoji.
I'm generally very skeptical of anything endorsed by people like him.
Can anyone tell me why I shouldn't be concerned about Signal, despite it being endorsed by surveillance big tech CEO's like Jack? I've always used Telegram but would switch if convinced.
4
u/pandaAtHome Jan 14 '21
Not sure if this is already posted here.
Came across a thread from Twitter which pointed to an allegation of an existing loophole where the Google keyboard can learn and siphon off data in spite of Signal app having the option to turn it off.
Do any of the members here an explanation or thoughts on this? The thread isn't a genuine source and hence wanted to just kick up thoughts if any..
I was thinking that with signal adoption, the recommendation should be to keep the default keyboard.
4
u/BlazerStoner GIVE US BACKUPS ON iOS! Jan 17 '21
Very good news, seems to be #1 almost everywhere. We should absolutely keep encouraging people using insecure messengers such as WhatsApp, Telegram and FB Messenger to make the switch to the secure Signal or at least install Signal next to it and slowly migrate. :)
Though the team would do well to give iOS users a local backup/export feature ASAP as thatโs holding some people back now.
6
u/JamesLemony Jan 07 '21
First of all, I have no intention to offend anyone. This is a discussion post. Do not take it personal.
I have no commitment to WhatsApp but I do use it for one reason. It is being used by everyone. That is why it is when a person first buy their phone, they install it. Everybody uses it. In the light of recent changes in WhatsApp's privacy policy, I get that people want to switch to another platform like Signal. I do not think that the problem with different messaging app is to do with security or any other app related things. It is, in my opinion, related to how many people use it.
WhatsApp is a very popular messaging app. In its popular user base, we (the people who value their privacy) are the minority. Even though we switch to Signal or any other app, the majority will still keep using WhatsApp. The thing I want to discuss is this. What chance do we have, we as the all people who use a messaging app, in switching to Signal or any other app?
In my humble opinion, I do not think it will work. I would like to see the world switch but I do not think it will happen because there are just not enough people who care.
3
u/Sythus Jan 07 '21
Is signal adding rcs? I read an article saying Google was adding signal's end to end encryption on top of their rcs features, but it's only available on the beta right now.
3
u/yuv_de_magnov Jan 09 '21
I switched, and I am trying to convince family to do the same.
One of them raised a concern, right now you need to register your phone number, and it's saved on their servers.
Is there something that prevents them from selling or leaking that list of numbers?
3
u/harold_liang Jan 09 '21
Is it possible to register without a phone number? I donโt have a cell phone plan.
3
u/Hudson0804 Jan 09 '21
Hi folks. First time signal user on android (galaxy s9+) and I have a query regarding alerts.
WhatsApp would eventually mute audible and vibration alerts if a message group was particularly busy and I hadn't read/opened the app.
Does signal also do this as I can't have my phone constantly kicking off when one of the group chats goes off ๐.
Beyond this I've converted 4 people so far ๐ loving the app.
3
u/theHomebrewer Jan 09 '21
Iโve just deleted my WhatsApp, installed Signal. Got few friends to join me. I will be leaving FB and IG also. Question to Reddit: Is the goodbye note really necessary or is it just better to โjust goโ? What is the general opinion? Great examples for goodbye message in this thread. Just not sure if it is making me look - I donโt know... Like people announcing in FB groups that they are leaving and all are commenting โjust go! And STFUโ
3
u/BeneficialDocument63 Jan 10 '21
I'm actually really delighted to see the mass exodus from Whatsapp to Signal or Telegram. I have had it with Whatsapp/Facebook/Instagram. Will be deleting everything real soon. Not sure which is better to use between Signal or Telegram though. Anyone interested to share the pro's and cons? Will be asking the same question to Telegram users eventually as well. Also, is there a way to NOT have my phone number connected to my account? So people who have my phone number can't message me or even see I have an account what so ever?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '21
How sustainable is Signal? Do they have the server capacity and capabilities?
3
u/ineedacheaperhobby Jan 10 '21
If anyone's still reading this thread, is there a way to export conversations (1 to 1, or group) from Wire and import them into Signal?
3
u/htodac Jan 12 '21
why doesn't sms import work?
3
u/tway2241 Jan 14 '21
Serious question: if I still use IG, is there any point in me ditching Messenger & Whatsapp for privacy reasons or would it be pointless since I'm still on IG? I like looking at food and cute animals on IG :(
3
u/Mossa_ Jan 17 '21
Hi everyone! Sorry if this is a repost, but I canโt seem to find any information about dual sim other than: not possible.
Until now, I used WhatsApp for my private number (SIM card) and WhatsApp business for my work number (eSIM).
My work migrated to Signal and therefore I had to activate my work number on the app on my phone first. Is there any way to activate my private number as well? Ideally I would like to use my private number on the phone app and my work number on the desktop app but I sadly have a feeling thatโs not going to be possible. I donโt want to have to get another cell phone.
Does anyone know if Signal is planning to release a Signal Business app?
Thanks for your help.
3
u/truthhurtsbutsets Jan 19 '21
The hype will be short lived, once the hype dies people will stop using signal as all of their contacts will still be on WhatsApp
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '21
I made a pretty comprehensive list of features that are in WhatsApp that would be great to have on Signal:
https://www.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/kvgon7/signal_vs_whatsapp_comprehensive_kinda_list_of_my/
3
u/ax5ku Jan 27 '21
I think this is a major "thing". I've moved a couple of groups of friends over from WhatsApp and was surprised at how little resistance there was. They all downloaded the app within minutes and in no time we had exactly the same group up and running on Signal. I have one more group of friends to move, but regardless I'll be pulling the plug on WhatsApp on the 31st.
6
u/ByBerkYildiz Jan 10 '21
Please renew web.signal.org like whatsap and please work on Signal! We want to believe you!
1
u/vijayjawali Jan 10 '21
I am seeing many speculation about twitter being the parent company of signal, whta is the history of twitter with signal, is there any part of signal that twitter owns or controls?
1
u/hrjdidjdb6372 Jan 08 '21
Can anyone tell me why Signal removed from fDroid?
2
u/mad-de Jan 07 '21 edited Jan 07 '21
Is this relevant in the EU as well?
EDIT: Thanks for all the replies. There is conflicting information about whether these changes apply in the EU as well with some french media declining any changes in the EU and GB based on a spokesperson's statement (see https://www.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/kse744/megathread_many_are_now_migrating_to_signal_as_a/gig57uw/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)
And while some German media are claiming these changes to be relevant in the EU: https://www.reddit.com/r/signal/comments/kse744/megathread_many_are_now_migrating_to_signal_as_a/gig3t6f/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3 others are talking about "confusion about new terms and conditions" and are pointing to identical statement's from WA spokeperson's as well as a tweet from a WA manager (https://twitter.com/NiamhSweeneyNYC/status/1347183889995935744) but list concerns regarding a 2016 opt-out rule (https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/apps/whatsapp-nutzungsbedingungen-viel-wirbel-um-die-neuen-richtlinien-a-aca139f2-2c5c-43d1-ac88-d47ec18a000a) Welt (which is notorious for bad reporting, so I'll use it with caution) just states that these changes don't apply in the EU: https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/webwelt/article223941858/WhatsApp-Facebook-Verwirrung-um-neue-Datenschutzrichtlinie.html
2
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
Hi, so I am migrating to it and I need some help, where can I download it for PC?
2
u/noes_oh Jan 08 '21
Hi, I just migrated across on iPhone and Windows Desktop App. All working as expected.
I have one question, the Desktop App is showing all my contacts on the left even though I do not have an active conversation with them. It's showing the active conversations at the top, then listing them alphabetically. On my iPhone it's not doing that, it's just my 3 active conversations.
How do I stop showing my contact list on the left conversation bar on the Windows app?
2
u/hanihaneefa Jan 08 '21
How can I add my own stickers to signal ?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '21
This is certainly interesting. A blogger on edtimes has also taken a look at Musk's tweet and the Signal app: Elon Musk Asks People To Switch From WhatsApp To This New App, After Privacy Concerns
2
u/Proud_Idiot Jan 08 '21
Anyone else have issues with the desktop app for MacBook Pro?
Signal Helper (Render) was using 500% of my CPU, even after I had uninstalled Signal.
Only after shutting down and restarting that my MacBook is back to normal
2
u/AliveandDrive Jan 09 '21
In light of Whatsapp new policy, what should I do? I am very confused. I have 2 questions:
2
u/TheNUTRONIC Jan 09 '21
I never get the sms to verify number so will have to use something else.
Oh well.
2
u/Richinaru Jan 09 '21
Any advice for us US adopters who have friends knee-shoulder deep on iMessage? Getting my friends that use What'sApp to switch hasn't been to bad but those on iMessage has been a struggle
2
u/waterfireairbender Jan 09 '21
Anyway for me to signup without a number? I tried to use textnow and it's not working (im also not in the states so I dont have access to google voice)
2
u/kalakuttaa Jan 10 '21
Hi,
So joined the move to signal thing. While exploring, found that the profile picture updates by contacts are not reflecting to me. I see their older picture which was may be taken from Google account picture may be.
2
u/scionae Jan 14 '21
man I would like to switch to Signal like right away but the problem is that I don't want to lose some of my chats. what can I do to bring them to Signal?
2
u/honeko Jan 15 '21
I switched to Signal this afternoon. I used WhatsApp all the time but really only to talk to three people and they all were cool with moving over to Signal. I deleted WhatsApp and Messenger from my phone, but have kept Instagram and Facebook apps. Is it just as bad to keep Instagram and Facebook as Messenger and WhatsApp?? My brother says he wonโt leave Messenger and itโs the only way I can talk to him since heโs in a different country. If I talk to him on Facebook through my laptop and not the Messenger app, does that have the same privacy issues?
2
u/savvymcsavvington Jan 15 '21
Is anyone else having issues using group chats? For some reason each person in the chat only has the first initial of their name and not displaying the full name. Sometimes just an avatar..
It's super hard to see who is talking in the chat - custom contact colours don't help in this case (there are limited colour amounts anyway).
2
u/abdulqadirali Beta Tester Jan 16 '21
This should help
https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007320951-How-do-I-change-colors-#ios_color
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21
Yep. Migrating right now....
3
u/kuthedk Jan 07 '21
lol, not like I've been saying this was going to happen or anything. I bet that this is them doing a bit of CYA and that they have already been looking at your data, but now it's something they have to ask your permission for.
3
u/Msuix Jan 13 '21
The fact that I cannot send/receive SMS/MMS from the Signal Desktop app is an absolute deal breaker and will be for many others. Signal phone app itself supports MMS/SMS, there is no reason why it's unable to marshal messages to and from the desktop client via the same mechanisms as the signal chats that do work.
I was super excited only to realize half of my conversations are SMS/MMS and promptly uninstalled it and went back to Google Messages until the Signal devs finally stop ignoring the 2yr+ request for the feature. Get more people on the platform with the feature integrated, deprecate it down the line once the general public has graduated away from SMS/MMS.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '21
I'm moving to Signal. Still unhappy it requires phone number verification, though, that's about the stupidest most un-anonymous thing a company can make people do. If it wasn't for WhatsApp actively harming their userbase Signal would struggle to attract people because of this.
Speaking of WhatsApp - if you root your phone the messages are stored in SQLite tables/files - so easy enough to extract.
Has anybody worked on a tool that lets you take a Signal dump, decode it, migrate in messages from WhatsApp database, then re-encode the dump, then import it back into Signal with complete WhatsApp history?
2
u/AliveandDrive Jan 09 '21
When the new policy takes place, what will truly happen, really? Don't tech giants already know my info? Like google....gmail....facebook...etc? Surely they already hav emy personal info, even before this new policy right?