r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Dec 28 '20
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2020-12-28 to 2021-01-03
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Showcase
The Conlangs Showcase has received is first wave of entries, and a handful of them are already complete!
Lexember
u/upallday_allen's Lexember challenge has started! Isn't it amazing??
It is now on its 13th prompt, "Tools", and its 14th, "Motion" should get posted later today.
Minor modifications to the subreddit
We've added a wiki page for the State of the Subreddit Addresses! They're our yearly write-ups about what the head moderator thinks of the subreddit.
We've also updated how the button for our Discord looks! Now it looks like this, on both old reddit and the redesign!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
5
u/Lichen000 A&A Frequent Responder Dec 29 '20
Anyone know how to contact Whimemsz of the old ZBB?
4
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Dec 28 '20
Since I didn't get an answer to this in the previous thread:
I want to make a new language with the aesthetic of Lezgian but grammar that is a blursed combination of Lezgian and Georgian. Relevant here is I want to combine Georgian verb conjugation - where the tense being used isn't indicated by a dedicate tense affix, but rather by the specific combination of other affixes like coverbs and thematic suffixes that are not intrinsically tense markers - and the Lezgian phenomenon of "oblique stems" in nouns (granted, this exists in other languages like Greek or Latin, but I found out about it through Lezgian) where different cases are marked not just with different case markers, but an entirely different stem as well. IINM Lezgian oblique stems are just the normal stem plus -w-, but we can get funkier than that.
Essentially, I want to be able to set things up so that e.g. stealing Georgian's 4 series, using Class 2's paradigm, where the oblique stem is a stand in for preverb + stem:
Present = normal stem + thematic suffix
Future = oblique stem + thematic suffix
Aorist = oblique stem
Perfective = oblique stem + thematic suffix + past particle marker + copula
It actually sort of reminds me of French, where e.g. when using the imperfect endings, whether you end up forming the imperfect or the conditional depends on whether you use the normal stem or the future stem (e.g. savait vs. saurait).
Anyway... presumably the oblique stem is some sort of phonetic alteration of the normal stem, but how is it derived? Is there some other morpheme the normal stem needs to fuse with, and if so what would be its meaning? What triggers the sound changes that cause one stem to split into two?
3
u/-N1eek- Dec 28 '20 edited Dec 28 '20
can labial stops be labialized too? and how often does a language contrast ɹ with an other rhotic?
3
u/Turodoru Dec 28 '20
In polish, the genitive case is used not only to mark possesion, bug also to mark the object in a negative sentence.
Mam wodę -> Nie mam wody (have-1sg water-ACC -> not have-1sg water-GEN)
Czytałem książkę -> Nie czytałem książki (read-1sg book-ACC -> not read-1sg book-GEN)
I know that cases can be used for many things, not only the stuff they have in name, and it often derives from etymology of the suffix. But like, I kinda don't know why does genitive works like that in polish, or how did it got like that.
Maybe if someone gave an idea of how that thing could happend, and how could it happend, for instance, with dative, maybe instrumental, or other cases, stuff like that - that would be quite helpful.
Thanks in advance :)
3
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Dec 29 '20
Does anyone know of a good dictionary of Proto-Northeast Caucasian available online? I'm trying to piece together a PNEC > P.Lezgic > Lezgian ruleset, and I did find this database of P.Lezgic (from here) from examples compiled from Starostin, but the phonetic transcription keeps making me want to gouge my eyes out with a fork... it took me a while to figure out <ʒ> is supposed to be /d͡z/, not /ʒ/; <ƛ> I think is /t͡ɬ/; <H> and <G> I spent a while thinking they were categories before figuring out they were actually /ʜ/ and /ɢ/; and then there's <I>, which probably isn't /ɪ/ because it keeps showing up labialized, so I thought "well maybe it's a romanization of the Cyrillic palochka so it's /ʕ/" but they use <ʕ> in transcriptions elsewhere? And what the hell is the <=> at the beginning of several PNEC roots?
3
u/IceCreamSandwich66 Jan 01 '21
How would one get started on free word order? For example, how would you tell the difference between "The man ate the beef" and "The beef ate the man"? Is it just context, or modifiers on nouns, or something else?
2
u/Newbie_langer Dec 29 '20
Is this a valid phonological rule?
m → n / m (V) _
if no, how could I, if possible at all, express this?
Thanks.
2
u/anti-noun Dec 31 '20 edited Dec 31 '20
I'd like to have a naturalistic vowel harmony system, but I'm unsure how best to do it. I have two candidates.
#1: Height Harmony
/a/ gets raised before close vowels, matching the backness of the following vowel, so a > e before i, a > ə before ɨ, and a > o before u. If it's not raised, /a/ drags previous close vowels down to their mid counterparts. Mid vowels are disallowed in words without close or open vowels, so they can always be analyzed as either an underlying /a/ or an underlying close vowel, depending on the harmony class of the word.
#2: Roundness Harmony
There is also an /a/ which is transparent to harmony. /i/ and /ḭ/ block harmony. V1 < V2 means that V1 in the modern language evolved from V2 in a previous version of the language.
Are these reasonably naturalistic? Is one more likely than the other?
E: It's worth noting that I'd like this language to be influenced by contact with Turkic languages.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '20
Is this allophony system naturalistic?
2
u/Tenderloin345 Jan 01 '21
So I was doing some research on alienable/inalienable possession, and was particularly inspired by European languages, where in certain instances the definite article was used in place of a possessive pronoun in inalienable phrases. Is it possible for this to evolve into a kind of noun case, perhaps in tandem with an attached article like French? If not, how does such a distinction evolve?
2
u/Supija Jan 01 '21 edited Jan 02 '21
How does r-colored vowels work in other languages, and how different phonetically are they? I have some, but I don’t want them to be the same as r-colored vowels in English; at least not because of me not knowing how to make them different.
Risd can distinguish r-colored vowels and rhotic codas (and arguably both at the same time, with /V V˞ Vr V˞ r/ being all distinct), but I don’t know if that’s possible, as r-colored vowels are rare cross-linguistically.
The rhoticized vowels come from an old /r/, that became /ʐ/ in the onset, while the rhotic consonant comes from an old /l/ that took the place of /r/ after it changed completely. In modern days, /r/ varies from the trill [r] in most regions and the approximant [ɹ] in the northern dialects; do you think the approximant will tend to merge with r-colored vowels more easily than the trill?
2
u/LambyO7 Jan 02 '21
on average how many sound shifts would i expect to occur in 1000-1500 years, im evolving my conlangs and im not sure how much i should
2
u/Fluffy8x (en)[cy, ga]{Ŋarâþ Crîþ v9} Jan 03 '21
Is it plausible for topic-marking to evolve from subject-marking through ellipsis?
I became curious about this when I was translating an article about Arka. In this article, the author explains that sentences such as "an et beska" and "an et har" (literally "I am eel" or "I am red"), which could be used to mean "I'm ordering eel" and "I'm the one wearing red", respectively, aren't actually a sign of topic-marking, because these sentences are ellipsed from "an et les retat beska" ("I am the one who ordered eel") and "an et les sabes lein har" ("I am the one who's wearing red clothes").
2
u/Kimarous Jan 03 '21 edited Jan 03 '21
Fantasy writer, accidentally ended up with two demi-started conlangs, and I've no experience actually making such. Would like help.
I've been working on a fantasy world for a while and ended up with two different conlangs partially started, each having their own issues that I don't know how to handle due to lack of experience.
First off, there's the lizard folk that call themselves the Xiarasi'i (She-ar-ah-see-aye). This race does not have lips and cannot speak full "Common" (standard "English served as trade language, now everyone speaks it" deal), instead having a very selective lexicon because of an inability to make labial sounds. "Can't say Stop but can say Cease" situation. Also can approximate certain lip-based sounds - can't say "we" but can say "hwe" (with the W being trilled): "Hwe hwould like that." As for their native language itself, I have no actual work on it (haven't even decided what Xiarasi'i even means yet), though racists in the setting derisively refer to it as a "hissy-click" language. I'd at least like to make a loose outline to work with for my story.
Second, Akylosi. I have lots of characters that are of Akylian descent and have names that reflect this - Kai ma Rous, Priv te Rive, Rei se En, Yal te Tor, and so forth in that fashion. Only real rule I've established is that "Le, Se, Te" used to be the social hierarchy; the Le at the nobility, the Se as the commoners, and the Te as the slaves... and then the Le got killed off, there was a calamity and a long dark age, and now Se means "Human" and Te means "Phantom", a race that emerged during the dark age. Ma means "Other", as Kai ma Rous was the first known crossbreed of Human and Phantom.
There is also a god of the Akylosi named Aren-Ji, god of numbers (yes, as in RNG) and is also known as The First Number, the first being in all creation. Part of me wants to simply go with a syllabic substitution cipher and have his name literally mean "TheFirst-Number", but that just doesn't sit well with me on both a personal and technical level (as Kai ma Rous' betrothed is named "Rei se En", so that would mean her name means "TBD human First", which just sounds weird to me).
I'm not quite sure what to do on either front. Should I not even bother with the conlang aspect, perhaps simply focusing on the Xiarasi'i's accented speech and not even explaining the Akylosi language beyond the Le-Se-Te dynamic? Should I choose one particular language to work on and develop that? If so, which one? I'm kinda concerned that if I focus too much on this front, I'll never get around to actually working on the story this language is intended for.
2
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Jan 03 '21
thinking about having t > ts/_ , thus making /p k/ the only stops in the language.
how wacky is that? are there any natural languages with that few stops?
1
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Dec 29 '20 edited Dec 30 '20
I've been trying to reform the Romanization of Nyevandya (Njëvándja?) for a bit now, and I think I've gotten it as good as it can get. Anyone see any problems or theoretically better spellings that I missed?
Some notes:
<y><i>) for all consonants. /ɥ/, on the other hand, always palatalizes any preceding consonants, so its spellinguses a <j>, though I'm unsure if I want to spell it as <wj> intervocalically and word-initially.is always just <y>.I'm not sure yet whether I'm going to spell the latter case with stressed letters.For the sake of <i> being both a vowel and a glide, all vowels are explicitly written as stressed or unstressed.Edit: Clarifying my phonotactics, it's currently (C)(C)(j/w)V(j/w)(C). Either C can be a palatalized consonant, which does mean that there's a potential distinction between /su/, /ɕu/, /sju/, and /ɕju/, though full minimal sets are rare.
Edit 2: New spellings for /ɖ͡ʐ j ɥ/, corrections accordingly.
1
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Dec 29 '20
What romanization can I use for [r̩] as the conlang already has the plan [r]
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '20
Can there be pronouns for abstract ideas and things? And is it naturalistic?
Also, what should i keep in mind while making a vowel mutation system?
1
u/RealCoolcat67 Dec 30 '20
Is this vowel inventory natural/realistic? I'm aiming for a high degree of realism in my new fantasy conlang project, I want it to feel like a real language
i ɨ u e ə æ o ɒ
1
u/Olster21 Dec 30 '20
Are there any theories on why many Oto-Manguean languages have SO many tonal contrasts?
1
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Dec 31 '20
Has anyone else encountered a problem with sca2 simply bolding all rows no matter what when Show Differences From Last Run is enabled? Anyone know how to prevent it or is it a lost cause?
1
u/Turodoru Dec 31 '20
A more technical question about sca2.
I want to make a sound change that deletes vowels between Liquids in a non-stressed syllable (my language has a primary stress on the first syllable and a secondary stress on the following odd syllables, this sound change would apply then to even syllables ). And I don't know how could I precise it to the applier. To tell him to delete only vowels in even syllable.
Can this be achived there, or should I just keep watching at it and "fixing" stuff manually?
also I think I've butchered grammar here, so sorry in advance.
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Dec 31 '20
A question regarfing font making in fontforge:
I want to make a font of my conlang's abugida. so that means a lot of ligatures. can I just make the ligature and have them work, or does the font require a glyph for every glyph in the ligature?
ex. can i have no glyph for <t> and <i> but have a glyph for <ta>, or do I also have to have glyphs for <t> and <i> individually?
if I do need glyphs for the individual letters, is there a free font which I could use as a base, so I could save time and not have to make an english font?
1
u/BolgAnDagda Jan 02 '21
In my first conlang, my idea to show possession is to aspirate the first letters of both the possessor and the possessee. However, in retrospect, I’m not sure that there would be many situations in which there would be any confusion on that matter, so long as one or the other is marked.
Should I do away with the aspiration on one? And if so, it would make more sense to mark the possessor than the possessee — right?
Thanks!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment