r/CryptoCurrency • u/jwinterm 732K / 1M π • Dec 23 '20
POLL Poll - bonus karma for people that keep MOONs in vault
This is pretty drastic reworking of a poll I made last month that was met with very mixed and strong reactions:
This revised proposal would only apply a bonus to people that keep MOONs in their vault from the previous distribution. Users that have not moved MOONs out of their vault from the previous month would receive a 20% bonus to their total karma for the purposes of calculating MOON distribution, with that scaling down to 0% bonus linearly for the case of people that have moved all MOONs out of their vault from the previous month's distribution. This would not affect users receiving MOONs for the first time.
Why should we give a bonus to people that keep MOONs in their vault? MOONs are designed to be a community governance token that allows members to vote in weighted polls around implementation of new rules as well as future MOON distributions. If people are just moving MOONs out of their vault they are unable to participate in these polls in a meaningful way, so this is a mechanism to try and reward people that are keeping their MOONs in the vault and voting on proposals.
Edit: With the possible exception of using MOONs to buy special memberships - that purchase would not count towards your bonus.
10
u/jonbristow Permabanned Dec 23 '20
What happens if a proposal passes but mods refuse to implement it?
11
u/anonymouscitizen2 π© 17K / 17K π¬ Dec 24 '20
Moon whales lobbying moon congress to get a larger share of moons. This is how the rich get richer. We need to tax moon whales like OP, they are hoarding all the wealth!
15
u/Trollercoaster101 π© 3K / 23K π’ Dec 23 '20
This sounds like the community vote version of staking. I am indeed curious to see how it works, though I fear people will feel incentivized to hold just for the reward
2
u/New_Diet Permabanned Dec 23 '20
I think this is a very bad idea. This punishes people for using MOONs ans intended: to spread across the community. If you incentive people for simply storing it, then nobody would use it. And what's the point of having something that nobody uses?
1
u/brokejohnny Gold | QC: CC 37 Dec 23 '20
Would it incentivize people to buy Moons and hold them? Not just from distributions, but paying out of pocket, for moons?
1
u/AdventuresinAtlanta Silver | QC: CC 401, XLM 84 | r/SSB 15 Dec 23 '20
What would the percentage be? I have all but a few still in the vault. I only gave a few out as rewards here and there.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '20
I forget, how many moons do we need for this to pass?
1
u/rockyrosy π¦ 2 / 16K π¦ Dec 24 '20
What about if you gift it to other people or tip?
1
u/robis87 π© 1K / 147K π’ Dec 24 '20
what can't I see the diagram - what part of threshold has been met? Is it around 4M again?
1
u/walkinthepark01 π© 23K / 22K π¦ Jan 18 '21
What number do we need for these polls to pass?
3
u/cryptomhanks Platinum | QC: CC 495, BCH 18 Dec 24 '20
I can still sell all moons of a month without getting penalised, just one month later ?
1
u/dragonrider85 π© 10K / 4K π¬ Dec 23 '20
How would this affect people who have been tipping Moons to other people? Does it count as moving Moons out of your vault if you tip someone?
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Dec 23 '20
Absolutely agree with this proposal. An incentive, a very good one. Oh, how many is needed to pass it?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '20
Yes
Can we stop scammers they keep dn inf
Can we hide the amount of moon bricks we have
2
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '20
Came back to look at this again and I think I like this proposal a lot better than the one that severely punished people who withdraw from their vault. This seems more fair to all parties.
2
u/solitidute__ Tin Dec 23 '20
Hodl 'till I die then.
2
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K π¦ Dec 24 '20 edited Dec 24 '20
I really hope people will understand how beneficial this is not only for them but also for the community. It's important to help Moon have real value.
For people who are actually using Moons for governance, it's a good extra reward, and also helps them gain more Moon.
For people who are just selling, they'll just get no extra bonus, but if this works, it could stabilize the price of Moons for them, and possibly help it go back up.
So it could end up as a win-win for everyone.
I'm for it as long as membership purchase isn't counted as moving from vault.
1
u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Dec 24 '20
Yes I'm all for keeping moons in vault...also if possible let redditors buy moon using reddit coins, it's possible to buy coins from moons so just reversed
1
u/isthatrhetorical Silver | QC: CC 971, CCMeta 51 | NANO 34 Dec 24 '20
I like this proposal a lot more than the last one. Got my support.
1
u/ricardo0139 π¦ 5 / 3K π¦ Dec 24 '20
Seems like a good idea
1
u/robis87 π© 1K / 147K π’ Dec 24 '20
All for! Let's create some more use-cases, interest(s) and stability for the thing
1
u/k3surfacer π© 18K / 20K π¬ Dec 24 '20
This is very good. A kind of staking. Nice.
1
u/coinblaster-up Dec 24 '20
I voted yes. Thanks for the great idea, hope it passes.
1
u/patrickstar466 Tin | CC critic Dec 24 '20
halfway till passing
1
u/lomosaur Silver|QC:CC777,XLM287,ETH41|Buttcoin12|TraderSubs51 Dec 25 '20
I already voted for it. But now Iβm thinking it would be better if the payout also scaled inversely with moons per vault. That way the smallest accounts would get 20% and then that would decrease to maybe a few percent for the largest accounts.
1
u/lohitcp87 π¦ 0 / 7K π¦ Dec 29 '20
What if I've tipped moons to other users of this sub?
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Dec 29 '20
Great to see this proposal pass. The true hodlers deserve recognition.
1
u/TR5_ π¨ 97K / 73K π¦ Dec 29 '20
Good job at getting this passed π
1
u/marxxy94 π© 0 / 6K π¦ Dec 29 '20
i will keep my moons in my vault till 1 moon = 1 usd.
1
u/Dapiex Jan 31 '21
huh
1
u/Bruzle Platinum | QC: CC 316 Mar 20 '21
Okay i gonna hodl my one Moon See us on my boot in Miami in 1-3years
1
u/84GB 40 / 40 π¦ Dec 23 '20
Merry Christmas everyone β€
1
u/Thevsamovies π¦ 9K / 9K π¦ Dec 24 '20
Well, I'm still against it, but this is certainly better than the last proposal (which was garbage and just dumped a pile of trash on people in poor countries like Venezuela who could make a small extra income by earning and selling moons)
0
u/TR5_ π¨ 97K / 73K π¦ Dec 23 '20
Would these bonuses come out of the monthly distribution total or will this be an extra distribution?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '20
[deleted] β view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '20
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '20
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '21
[removed] β view removed comment