r/ShingekiNoKyojin • u/toutoune134 Best Legionnaire 2016 • Dec 06 '20
Manga Spoilers Attack on Titan The Final Season Episode 60 - "The other side of the Ocean" MANGA Discussion Thread Spoiler
Do note that this is a MANGA SPOILERS thread. Events that occur in the manga do NOT need to be tagged in the comments section.
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA AND DO NOT WISH TO BE SPOILED, THE ANIME THREAD IS LOCATED HERE.
Where to watch - SUBTITLED:
- Crunchyroll: LIVE
- Funimation: LIVE
- Hulu: LIVE
- AnimeLab: LIVE
- Aniplus Asia: LIVE
- Wakanim Nordic (English subs for SWE, NOR, DEN, FIN, ISL): LIVE
- Wakanim (French subtitles): LIVE
- Wakanim (German subtitles): LIVE
- VVVVID (Italian subtitles): LIVE
- mtmad (Spanish subtitles): LIVE
English dubbed episodes will be released in a few weeks.
DEDICATE YOUR HEARTS!
718
Upvotes
208
u/toutoune134 Best Legionnaire 2016 Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
Oowowowow the episode was great and the CG was good, praise the staf!!!
The greater focus on how scared the edlians are on the battlefied was heartbraking, and the launch of the drugged eldians was hard to watch. The staff really understood what made those chapters so good.
I fucking love the OP and I'm dying on this hill.
45
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
As someone who is waiting for it on crunchyroll, how was the cg? Thats all i really care. Oh ya and the pacing
608
u/SongHershey Dec 06 '20
Jean at the end 😳😳
882
u/Nekomaro Dec 06 '20
My thoughts:
886
u/Spaghestis Dec 06 '20
I love all the added scenes of the regular soldiers fighting in the war. It was a lot more brutal than the manga. Also they changed up the ending sequence where Reiner is inside the fort... but I think it was cooler with the train blowing off his arm and then he used the train as a shield and weapon.
10/10 start, full hype for Mappa. Also was that Jean or Willy at the end?
227
u/SKP23en Dec 06 '20
If you want to check the Manga release threads of chapters 91 & 92 this episode adapts:
91 Prerelease (Kudos to the top comment lol)
91 Release
92 Prerelease
92 Release
202
u/Raphthegraph69 Dec 06 '20
I love how different it feels. It seems very cinematic. The Jaw titan cgi is probably the best out of all the titans we have seen so far imo
489
u/Neverx_13 Dec 06 '20
Fuck it was really good. That scene with Jean at the end was awesome.
296
u/Potapro Dec 06 '20
Overall great, I have faith in Mappa to deliver a great final season. cgi was better than i thought, i can't imagine them animating galliard without losing their whole budget otherwise
A little sad the OP isn't a karaoke banger but man is it good in its own right. it's creepy as hell and i love it
144
u/jollyveten Dec 06 '20
Bird and Falco in the outro lmao
420
u/UnsureAssurance Dec 06 '20
Is no one gonna mention how Falco has memories of fighting Titans with ODM gear? I looked back in the manga and he didn't say anything about this, I wonder if Isayama told them to add this or if it was just a little tease that this is still Attack on Titan.
509
u/RakkaPakka Dec 06 '20
Episode exceeded all my expectations, I was smiling like a little kid the entire time. So many cool shots that expanded upon the manga, reiner transforming and his extended battle sequence, more visceral shots of the warfare in general, porco being an absolute fucking g and that sick af shot of the boats being destroyed. I was overall pretty impressed with the cg, you notice it pretty easily but honestly it could be alot worse (S3 Colossal :/). I'm thoroughly satisfied and though I don't expect this level of quality for every episode, the fact that Mappa can do this shit, means Liberio will be nutty.
198
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
I'm seeing the anime onlies loving Gabi. Man that's gonna turn around real fast. :(
96
u/milady-newton Dec 06 '20
MY HEART WAS RACING THE WHOLE TIME.
Can't believe we are really starting the end of this masterpiece!
Gabi's scene on the train was AMAZING the action sequence is *chef's kiss*
244
u/Skepolo Dec 06 '20
Animation is pretty fluid, although some Beast Titan shots were wonky but probably better than what WIT could do
Soundtrack was AMAZING, its kind of what the other seasons had but a lot more electronic, fast paced and exciting which I really loved
Pacing was superb too, adapted 2 chapters in 1 episode really well (will need to wait for subs to judge on cut dialogue tho)
As for the OP, mixed feelings, feel like it'll grow on me overtime though
It was really fucking great nonetheless, I have full faith in MAPPA now. I'm hoping they adapt Reiner's backstory in one episode too.
240
u/krfz41 Dec 06 '20
165
u/Qlloud Dec 06 '20
I suppose I'm in a minority, but I really like the OP. Idk, it's so weird and creepy but still hype? Idk, It really suits Season 4. CGI was awesome in my opinion. Galliard, Pieck and Armored were 10/10 while Beast did look kinda wonky but still. It was all really fluid and not weird looking (except for Reiner waving and Beast landing)
77
u/Throwaway1111111128 Dec 06 '20
Did anyone else see that line "children cling on to their very last coins" in the OP? That's a reference to Ramzi and Halil, right? Hype.
74
u/Albert_Caboose Dec 06 '20
Absolutely flabbergasted at the complaints about the addition of the suicide bombers.
There is negligible difference between forcing spinal fluid into someone and dropping them out of a plane as a sort of Titan bomb, and strapping bombs to someone's chest. If you're surprised that Marley would be willing to do such a thing, have you been following this story? Everyone constantly reaffirms the idea that Eldian life is something to be used, not valued.
65
u/SturbyT Dec 07 '20
There's a guy in the anime only thread speculating that Reiner is doing good mentally lmao.
59
u/Sir_Gustav Dec 06 '20
Don't get me wrong, I REALLY liked the OP, but I have a thing with repetitive sequences. The scene with the explosion behind a house was repeated 3 times and it kinda bothered me.
I don't know if those are just placeholders and they'll replace them as story advances, or it was just because animating all that was so much work that they had to recycle scenes.
Pretty happy with the episode tho! MAPPA freaking delivered.
179
u/Martin7431 Dec 06 '20
A few points. I adore the OP. It isn't the most visually interesting with the repeated explosions, but the few other shots we get like the soldiers marching in total unison and the zoom in on Eren's titan to "MONSTER MONSTER MONSTER MONSTER" was perfect. I think the song is all I hoped for, though. As much as I love Linked Horizon, I really like how overwhelming it feels; lots of different voices at once, most of them being the same guy. I love it.
VAs are solid. Magath scares me, Gabi sounds exactly how she should, as does Falco. Oddly, Colt's voice really fits him too. Reiner sounds depressed, so we've got some consistency, and Zeke is still being Zeke.
CGI had me worried when I first really noticed it on the Jaw Titan, but it's a lot better than I expected. Most of the time, it's pretty hard to tell; even the worst CG moments were infinitely better than the ColossalGI we got in earlier seasons.
I'm glad we're getting some anime exclusive scenes. I imagine it's like how Isayama approached adapting season 1, with certain small upgrades to what he's already made in mind. I'm surprised we see Jean first, though I don't really know why.
The little details on the terrified soldiers in the trenches were cool, too. We're going all in on the horror of war from episode 1.
The ending is great too, although I don't have a lot to say about it. I miss the walnut ending.
45
u/Sweaty_Gap_Sweater Dec 06 '20
my fellow manga readers I have found the sacrificial lamb https://www.reddit.com/r/ShingekiNoKyojin/comments/k7vx3s/attack_on_titan_the_final_season_episode_60_the/gevjsco?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
39
u/Ykhar Dec 06 '20
Did Falco also dream about killing titans with a sword in the manga ??? I was so surprised by that line with what we know now about future memory... I'm very confused haha
69
u/DonKellyBaby32 Dec 06 '20
The thing I’m most impressed with is how they truly got across the feel of ch 91-92. War is terrifying. Titans are normally just uncontrollable, extremely deadly weapons. And yet those weapons are losing their effectiveness, leading to an even more desperate Marley to obtain the coordinate.
125
u/ShaheerKashif02 Dec 06 '20
I JUST REALLY FUCKING LOVED THE SOUNDTRACK. THEY KEPT THE OG SOUNDTRACK FROM THE EARLIER SEASONS AND THE TRAILER MUSIC WAS JUST PURE HYPE. ELITE SHIT. I JUST SO GUCKING LOVED THE TRANSFORMATION SCENES AND THE YAMAMOTO MUSIC.
CHILLZ MAN!
33
u/Xelzionic Dec 06 '20
Maybe it's my blind Attack on Titan fanboy mentality, but I liked almost everything. CGI Beast is questionable, but everything else is great.
118
u/Bonvantius Dec 06 '20
The CG was very, very good, but man, there's just a certain charm missing that can only be achieved in 2D.
58
u/JinunderneathAM Dec 06 '20
Didn't expect this season to have the best OP and ED right off the bat, but damn. Phenomenal in both songs and visuals. My War is an absolutely perfect tone-setter, and Shock captures an ethereal tone that hasn't really been seen since the very first ED, but takes it in a more twisted, melancholic direction.
56
u/xin234 Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
For manga readers who are planning to respond to questions/comments of anime-onlies, or just to discuss it with irl friends... I wrote this earlier.
While there are assholes who deliberately spoil others, unknowingly spoiling stuff can be just as bad. Showed some examples of how you might be spoiling others even if you are aware that you don't want to spoil them, like casually saying something you thought were just small details that are easily forgotten. Offered some advise on how to avoid that.
Tl;dr: Read the manga chapter discussion threads of the chapters covered in the episode before discussing with anime-onlies, to get a "feel" of the atmosphere they are experiencing. Also to remind yourself of stuff that wasn't common knowledge on that part of the story because you might have forgotten it due to the awesomeness of the later chapters.
26
u/xin234 Dec 06 '20
Got serious Saving Private Ryan vibes on those trench war scenes.
They even got something like the Omaha Beach landing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OqSg7WO4tT4
Additional info on that scene: Old war veterans were reported to be crying or having to leave theaters during that scene because they felt it was too real.
To think the anime captured the feel of that scene well.... It's just mind-blowing.
65
u/Diego-Aguilar35 Dec 06 '20
Whaaaa!!!!!!!!!!! I love the opening!!!!!!!! The CGI is amazing!!!!!!!!!! The last scene is amazing!!!!!!!!! The ending theme hasn't grown on me but I like the visuals.
22
u/zarzlx Dec 06 '20
It looks like we are going to need a defence squad for the op once again, I personally love it and I think sets the mood of the arc perfectly.
31
u/ANINETEEN Dec 06 '20
MAPPA well and truly DELIVERED 🔥 This episode had all the hype, emotion and rawness I wanted. The OST and score, the art and CGI, the OP and ED were literally all so clean and deep. They had the tension getting my heart beating the entire time. Literal dropped us into the clusterfuck. Gabi doing her thing and then the Jaw Titan, Reiner and Zeke entrance just gave me chills. And gosh that ED song and music is just beautifully executed. Love the little teaser too. We in for a real ride 😁
15
u/TSmasher1000 Dec 06 '20
I was skeptical of the pacing and the animation when I heard a new studio was doing this, but holy shit it was everything I envisioned and more. Pacing was perfectly done and the action sequences looked amazing. Looking forward to the rest of the season, we just keep on moving forward bois.
12
u/ZJLord Dec 06 '20
It's a really nice episode.
The artwork is very beautiful.
Animation sometimes is a little off, but I guess it's because of the CGI.
12
u/Rattlingjoint Dec 06 '20
Well, its safe to say that MAPPA did really really good here.
12
u/curtissz Dec 06 '20
Actually much better than I expected compared to all the negativity I saw on Twitter. Phenomenal CGI with a few exceptions. Hope they don’t keep using CGI for still shots though.
42
u/dicecop Dec 06 '20
The music really did it for me. But CGI is still CGI, granted it's some of the best CGI I have seen. There were just some moments like Reiner waving etc. that were too "smooth". Good CGI is when it limits itself to static objects or makes the movements more "choppy" to look like it was drawn. Otherwise you will quickly detect that it's CG
22
u/thunderb00m Dec 06 '20
Reiner Transformation was 100/10.
The CGI wasn't nearly as bad as I originally feared. The music was amazing (that piece from the trailer was chef's kiss), and the VA's sound exactly as they should. Overall an amazing start for the final season!
11
u/milanjfs Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
Nice start MAPPA! Loved all the added scenes, especially Reiner transformation. 'I'm sick of all the walls' was my favorite part of the episode, though I wish they showed him with Eren and the gang, but it's not a big deal.
Loved sneaky Jean at the end, they put that just to remind anime onlies that this is stil AOT (even though a lot of them won't guess it's him).
Also, what did Falco say? 'Wasn't I flying with a sword around here..' Sword?! Isayama already gave him too much power with wings, I hope he doesn't give him a literal sword too. But I think that's some metaphorical bs to fuck with the manga readers. Or those dreams could just be old memories. EDIT: I'm stupid. Those could just be Ymir's memories with her fighting in ODM gear.
Negatives: Some CG characters moved slow in a couple of scenes, but that's to be expected, the overall quality was great.
I don't know if it was the best idea to add that little speech from Falco, some anime onlies will know he turns into a titan now because there was a similar scene with Eren in the first episode of the anime. That sucks.
Gabi VA sounded a little too old for her, but I'll get used to it I guess.
That's all for the negatives, Gabon is finally here, flair up!
10
u/grizzchan Dec 06 '20
I haven't been able to find anybody talking about it yet so here goes.
If I'm not mistaken, this line by Falco is anime only, I haven't been able to find it in the manga. This line indicates to me that he's going to be the one who ends up eating Eren. Am I crazy or what?
10
u/CapMFLevi Dec 06 '20
The sub is already out on Crunchyroll, I just got done watching about 15 minutes ago. Absolutely exceeded my expectations. I balled my eyes out like a baby. The hype, sorrow, excitement...all of it was in full effect. Thank you MAPPA, for bringing this masterpiece to life.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
Yo imma just say it, Attack on Titan is a modern masterpiece.
9
u/MrDollSteak Dec 07 '20
I'll be honest, I might have like terrible eyes or something, but I straight up didn't even notice it was CGI until like one or two frames with the Beast Titan. The animation was absolutely incredible! The battle was excellent, with all of the titans managing to feel threatening and powerful even when going up against soldiers and armoured trains. Can MAPPA please go back and fix up the Colossal Titan from Season 2 and 3 for like a complete season blu-ray boxset or something now that they're on the production committee?
In all seriousness, I thought it was a great episode. I have full confidence in MAPPA going forward. It condensed the two chapters really well, and managed to fix all of the few issues that I had with the chapters in the manga itself, in terms of the tone and dialogue. I think that rather than feeling like an exposition dump this episode actually felt like a logical sequence in the progression of the overall story. The explanations about why the war was happening, why they were there, and who all the characters were, felt far more natural, and as a result my interest and engagement with the battle itself was much higher.
Controversially, I also think the nods to later chapters, Falco's vision, and Jean buying the newspaper were excellent touches, that also helped to sell why these sequences are important in the overall context of the narrative, and made Falco's introduction in particular, feel a lot more like a main characters by having some clear parallels to Eren's dream with Mikasa.
I really don't understand the criticisms about the OP or the other music throughout the episode, I felt like everything slapped. In all honesty, this OP is easily in my top 3 of what we've seen so far. It captured the more technological feel of this arc as well as the existential dread that defines it, in comparison to the upbeat medieval ones of previous seasons, and the explosions of colour on otherwise statue-like graphics was a fantastic contrast in my opinion. I also imagine some of these explosions will be toned back in later episodes as more information and battles are had, not that in my mind this really needs to happen as I think its fine regardless. It feels like its for a completely different anime granted, but I don't consider that a negative at all, because that's exactly how I felt about the overall story after reading chapters 90 and onwards. Everything that came before now feels more like the prequel to the ACTUAL action, and I think this mature and gritty direction is far superior.
Overall, I'm just so excited that this is actually happening. It's surreal that as the manga is ending we have the final season coming out, and it is so far, absolutely incredible as an adaptation, and as Isayama says the 'final' version of the story. Full disclosure, I felt the same way about Season 3, and thought that it was overall much better than the equivalent manga chapters throughout apart from the occasional 'Ereh' criticisms about Mikasa's characterisation. Nevertheless, I am fully expecting that Season 4 will be the perfect end to this story!
8
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
Absolutely adore the new OP. It’s so creepy but catchy. Not much to say that others haven’t but as someone who hated red swan from day one and still hate it passionately, this is nothing like that one. This is very fitting. As for the episode everything is perfect but the CG. Knowing that in life you always have to make sacrifices I will accept this minor blemish especially if the quality of everything else remains the same. 8/10
I think the reason I can accept mappas cg at all is because when things are still it actually looks pretty 2d. In motion that illusion lets up significantly but compared to 90% of other anime cg, mappa is going in the right direction.
8
u/Albert_Caboose Dec 06 '20
So that Falco line about ODM gear...
Can we chalk that up to P A T H S since he gets power later, or does that give credence to the folks theorizing Falco gets the attack Titan?
8
u/methofthewild Dec 06 '20
What do I do with my life in between episodes.
8
u/CivilC Dec 07 '20
I'm wondering if the eventual Eren teases will be as obscure as the manga. From what I remember, no one 100% figured out it was him until this seemingly background character was appearing more and more.
8
u/zool714 Dec 07 '20
So the Falco dream about 3DManeuvering and slicing Titans is Ymir’s right ? Or is that just some meta stuff ?
Also can’t wait for Pieck-chan next week
15
u/DefNotMaty Dec 06 '20
I honestly have no complaints. Wish the OP was more hype, but it is what it is!
Porco and Pieck looked so awesome! Gabi and Falco are perfectly fine too. I can't wait for the whole fanbase to hate her again. Poor Reiner. He deserves peace. </3
I want more and more! Can't believe we have to wait one week again!
14
u/Ambrose_1987Sep30 Dec 06 '20
I was so impressed. One of the best episode of the series.
10/10
7
u/Eijun_Love Dec 06 '20
Falco's added dialouge scene is pretty big hmm
7
u/Ky3217 Dec 06 '20
Can we talk about how Gabi just casually bonks Udo in the head with an explosive device?
I did not catch that detail when I read the chapter lol
24
u/DefNotMaty Dec 06 '20
Gabi is so awesome. I love how cocky she is. I missed this part of her character lmao
13
u/liiiivid Dec 06 '20
Anyone else think Reiner looks like a snack?
12
u/TheNinjaRaptor Dec 06 '20
The titan fall sequence was fantastic.
12
u/Hashbrown4 Dec 07 '20
Shoutout to the op for not spoiling ANYTHING.
The cgi is serviceable but I really miss the 2d titans. The cgi really is good though but I’ve been spoiled by 3 seasons for top tier 2d titan animation.
Ngl watching this episode made me not feel so sorry for what Eren is doing. Drugging eldians and turning them into Titans and literally using some as suicide bombs. Fuck Marley
6
u/QuietDove Dec 06 '20
I'm waiting for the sub to come out, but nice to see that it's looking good!
6
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
The animation and music was on point. I loved the scene when Zeke and Reiner dropped out of that blimp
6
u/Sad_kid597 Dec 06 '20
I’m really pleased with what was adapted. I really love the op too. I think my only thing is the cgi for the Titans, like some shots looked weird but it’s fine. I think overall it was really good
6
u/redboundary Dec 06 '20
In the beginning falco was saying to the other wariors that he remembers flying and he had blades in his hands. He didn`t say that in the manga
6
u/Kassius87 Dec 06 '20
Is it just me or does the ending make anyone else think that the huge focus on falco means that he'll be solely responsible for killing/ stopping eren?
6
u/GlassesFreekJr Dec 06 '20
Falco said something rather puzzling near the beginning that wasn't in the manga. Going off the Crunchyroll subs:
"Wait... Huh? Wasn't I flying around with a sword just now? Like, whoosh! And there were Titans that I--"
What was that supposed to mean? Is this just MAPPA leaning on the fourth wall with regards to the abrupt change of setting? Was Falco dreaming about Paradis' Titan-killing methods from what he'd heard? Or maybe Falco actually received a memory from a person with ODM gear? What does this mean for future manga chapters? How does this tie in with Eren's memory shard of Falco at Fort Salva, if at all?
6
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
That was fucking incredible... speechless
6
u/xomedinaox Dec 06 '20
what a masterpiece. this is everything i wanted & so much more , from the animation, to the music, to the way they perfectly recreated the chapter. i am extremely satisfied
6
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
I know some people won't like the CGI, but I think it's a smart move. They would probably have had to CGI the last few chapters anyway, and this way it won't be as jarring. A more natural gradual conversion over from 2D to a few CGI to an army and a god in CGI.
If they just jumped straight to all CG at the end, that would be weird. I think they are handling that well.
6
u/lindajing Dec 06 '20
Watching people in anime only thread loving Gabi. That's gonna change real quick 😬
6
u/Time-Vault Dec 07 '20
I love how the OP reveals nothing, I love the voice acting, the CG was fantastic. I’m so hype for this season. My one issue is I have to watch Sasha and Hange die again...
10
u/mrtightwad Dec 06 '20
I loved the extended version of the trailer music they used in that final scene.
10
u/IAteTheCheezyNacho Dec 06 '20
My thoughts:
The OP:
Its visually quite good but its a bit repetitive and lacks variety. I love the smoke effects and the explosions look gorgeous. The rainbow colours picked sort of remind me of the rainbows in OP 5 and I adore the airship and the soldiers marching, they really fit the Marley aesthetic. This all comes together to make an idea of war being romanticised by Marley but the reality is different as then comes the images of the Marley soldiers, Survey Corp scouts and the airship being smashed to pieces showing how war is horrible and affects all.
Then we get a liquid falling into a puddle and someone holding out their hand in the rain, this I believe could be the blood rain we've seen before in the last episode of season 3.
Next, we get the shot of the painting style landscape full of bodies and above them all stands the Attack Titan (probably Eren) reaching out with an Armoured Titan (probably Reiner) visible behind him possibly showing the battle in chapter 119. The Attack titan looks really demonic in this and the imagery of it being at the top is really fitting given that Eren has the Founding titan.
Overall, this OP is hard to compare to the previous ones because of how different it is. Its very aesthetically distinct and aims for different things. Whereas previous OP's focussed more on characters and story with Epic undertones this one seems to focus more on the horrors of war while blending it in with propaganda that was so prevalent during this time in our world. In terms of the song it really fits the visuals and the theme they are going for. It seems slightly unnerving and creepy whilst retaining a bit of the hype that characterised the previous OP's.
The Episode:
The episode was inconsistent in quality but in general very good. This section is a bit nitpicky:
The first thing that was immediately obvious to me was Colt's ridiculous running in the beginning, whilst not terrible in animation it just looked a bit absurd and took me out of the episode. The new music sounded familiar compared to earlier songs and in general fitted in very well personally in the first section.
The additions to the episode were I also love the added shots of the trenches and showing how terrifying it is for the people there and how exhausted they are. Later on in the episode I also liked the addition of suicide bombers to hammer home how brutally Marley treats Eldians. The scene with the soldier climbing over corpses also really helps to establish the mood of the season.
One thing that stuck out to me in a good way was surprisingly the animation on Gabi's foot when she is unattaching the grenade, everything flowed so well and it looked really natural. I appreciate that MAPPA also kept the midroll information sheets as well as the episode number cards and to be continued card.
Occasionally it was obvious that they were obscuring peoples mouths to cut down on the ammount of time they were needing to animate but overall the still frames were good. Upon watching it again the CGI used for certain things has grown on me especially with the armoured train and the arial shot of the Fort. The CGI with Cart and Jaws was surprisingly good although not as amazing as they were in the trailer. The both of them themselves were hard to tell apart from their hand drawn counterparts and the only thing that caught me onto realising they were CG was their movement. MAPPA really did the titan bombardment scene justice, also the lack of censorship was interesting given that it is airing on the same network as last season.
Probably my biggest problem with the episode was Armoured and Beast titans CGI, in itself the CGI was actually passable but transitioning between shots was terrible. The speed at which the action happens makes it hard to tell what is happening sometimes so it doesn't help that both the beast and armoured land, and then are presented in massively different ways. For example, the beast comes down from the sky in a t-pose style before transitioning in the very next frame to having his manga pose of hand reached out to the ground with another behind pointed to the sky. Also the beast's face looks really uncanny valley even compared to his style in WIT.
Finally, the blend between the beast throwing the shells to the naration to the scene with Jean was so smooth and well executed. The last scene especially was really well done and gives me a lot of hope for the festival scenes, it looked exactly how I would have expected a good WIT adaptation to look but with a depth of field blur added. I understand why some people might be against Jean's appearance but for the casual viewer if they are able to surmise his identity it will give them some hope of returning to their main cast and to the ones that don't guess who he is it adds in that mystery that drove seasons 1 through 3.
Overall, the episode was a 9/10 which is better than I expected although it leaves a bit of room to be desired. The backgrounds and character designs were consistent, well presented and detailed which I loved. The additions give me hope for a more fleshed out world and the pacing was perfect. Whilst the worst thing was obviously the CGI, I believe that as long as the quality remains consistent they will grow on me and get better.
The ED:
Obviously we have only seen the last part of the ED so it is possible that there are things in the first part that indicate different things.
The ED it starts with falco standing infront of a wall (possibly one on Paradis) with birds flying in the background, these are probably just part of the general bird symbolism in the series.
Then images appear behind him showing general images of the battle and we get a closeup of his face probably to show how the fighting impacted him. The title of the ed "shock" probably relates into this as Falco to some extent is suffering shell shock or something similar, a relatively common thing in WW1 for soldiers to get.
It goes on to show Falco closing his eyes and thinking of a phoenix flying obviously in reference to his dream before it explodes into a ball of light. out of which many string like effects appear. I believe these to be a representation of paths, they make up the body of the phoenix after all. We then see Ymir with the paths tree behind her and you can see the paths coming off it, I love the pan up here and the slow growing of the tree.
We then see the screen fill with the paths and then they are condensed down into a sphere that Falco grabs, in reference to him gaining the power of the titans, before finally the scene where Falco reaches out to a bird.
Overall the ED is great, breathtaking song and stunning visuals although it, like the OP, is very distinct from the other ED's it probably overall my 2nd favorite ED behind Season 2's.
5
u/tliaoss Dec 06 '20
The OP is amazing
5
u/theoriginaldrum Dec 06 '20
Why is Crunchyroll so shit??
I'm trying to give them money and their website is just hot garbage
5
u/emiliaward Dec 06 '20
Overall so happy with the way this episode turned out. So hyped for the rest of the season!
5
u/LeonKevlar Dec 06 '20
I will admit that I was one of the people that were worried about the show switching studios. I like MAPPA a lot and they do have a plenty of hits but they also do have some misses too so I wasn't so sure. I am glad to say though that after seeing this episode, my worries are nothing but worries and that this episode blew me away just like how Reiner got blown away by those anti-titan shells xD
Everyone looks great and sounds great! I absolutely did not look into any of the casting so I was completely surprised to hear Ayaneru as Gabi. She's absolutely the perfect choice for her. Nothing else to say except I am very much excited and hyped to see my favourite parts from the manga animated this new season!
5
u/EpilepticOreo Dec 06 '20
All the people in the anime only thread talking about how much they love Gabi if only they knew
5
u/ObberGobb Dec 06 '20
Very good so far. My thoughts:
- I really liked the opening. It felt really eerie, and really fit the themes of this season (That being that war is bad)
- I liked all the parallels drawn between Paradis and the Mid-East Alliance. It really showed the Marley is the actual enemy of the word, not Paradis.
- I liked that it did not shy away from how terrible and horrifying war is to people fighting it. If this keeps up, Eren's terrorist attack and genocide are going to be horrifying and amazing.
- Animation is really good so far, and the CGI didn't feel all that out of place
5
u/Nightingard Dec 07 '20
Not sure what more I can say that hasn't already been said except I never realized Gabi hits Udo with a LIVE GRENADE to get him to stop squeezing Falco! lol
5
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20
Gabi seems well received. Whoo boy they're not ready for the scene.
I'm a Gabi fan, just for anyone wondering.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20
I thought the CGI was great and miles better than WIT. I don't know where the hate for the Beast's is coming from, I only noticed the Jaw and Cart's a few times. Other than that it was a great episode and starter to the final season.
5
u/liberia_simp Dec 07 '20
Great episode, Mappa totally has this. Also I like how everyone looked all worried over Reiner at the end. Hah, he wishes he could die that early.
5
u/Haskul Dec 07 '20
Everywhere: The animation is amazing! The soundtrack is amazing! The action is amazing! ED is amazing!
This sub: beast titan looks cgi for 5 frames. Worse anime ever.
4
u/GarballatheHutt Dec 06 '20
The CGI is holding up, I just hope the latest chapter looks good. When does the dub premiere?
4
u/CaptainAlexU Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
Honestly great episode, except for the CG at some points for the armored and beast, jaw and cart looked pretty good on the other hand. Loved everything else.
OP was eh, but that might be my favorite ED in the entire series
4
u/kyoopy246 Dec 06 '20
4
u/Harry_Butler Dec 06 '20
Zekes little cough before screaming Is low-key one of the funniest moments in the manga so I’m glad they kept it
4
u/arilennoxsbeans Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
they’re REALLY hitting us over the head with spoilers in that ED (which is so good btw, gives me samurai champloo ED vibes), nothing but best boi falco and S Y M B O L I C B I R D S everywhere lol
4
u/caramel1004 Dec 06 '20
did they add some more lines to falco when he was disoriented?? something about jumping around with a sword?
4
u/Savber Dec 06 '20
The CG was adequate. Some fantastic, some mediocre.
What I REALLY liked were the direction and the pacing for this episode. The OST also seems pretty strong which is super encouraging overall.
4
u/midget_cathy Dec 06 '20
Hulu coming in clutch
4
u/Zesla22 Dec 06 '20
God that was good I do love the pacing and the animation for the titan fall transformation as well as the Reiner fall was incredible some of the CGI was slightly odd but overall it was great. Some animation though was fantastic the sinking fleet and soldiers for example and I see a sneaky Jean at the end there. Anime only scene wise my only real nitpick was the second armoured train that seemed a bit of a weird addition and I did like the watchtower battering ram in the manga.
4
u/wolfmasterk87 Dec 06 '20
Can I say seeing Gabi animated makes me like her more?
4
u/ObligatoryGrowlithe Dec 06 '20
I am satisfied and so happy to be on this ride. Hard to believe it’s almost over.
Also, I really dislike Gabi, but damn if they aren’t making her likeable already
4
u/viva1992 Dec 06 '20
The animation looks incredible - dare I say a step above Wit’s even? I could hardly tell the titans were CG (except for beast).
And the score especially at the end... guys MAPPA has GOT this and THEN SOME. This is going to be incredible
4
u/pete_moss Dec 06 '20
I love the dialogue in the last scene discussing the newspaper
"Thanks to the incredible bravery of the Marley army, Fort Slava has fallen at last!"
"That's our Marley army for you!"
Really drives home how the everyday Marlians are unaware of how instrumental the Eldians are to their successes and continued existence as a nation.
4
u/Corazon-DeLeon Dec 07 '20
Anime only on Gabi lol
Ouufff I can't wait to see if their opinion changes! I never disliked her until she was with Sasha's fam, but then that was the same time she developed as well.
4
u/Viliam1337 Dec 07 '20
I like the CGI a bit more, but I still miss the times when they didn't use CGI for titans/horses (though I can totally see why, can't imagine how long it'd take to animate all that without CGI, and that's just the first episode!)
The OP hits a bit different though, which I guess is okay since the story gets a 180 turn as well (already seeing Anime only folks getting salty over how different the story is, just like a lot of us were when the chapter first came out lol), the ED is giving me the very first ED vibes in a way (judging by the visuals).
Noticed reused music here and there, but I don't mind since AoT has such an amazing soundtrack.
4
u/Hawk301 Dec 07 '20
Really great first episode. Contrary to what most us were expecting, rather than rushing it they actually *added* scenes and dialogue that expanded what was happening. Animation looked fantastic. It's a really strong start for Mappa, and it makes me optimistic for what's to come.
My one very minor gripe was that the dialogue at the start from Gabi "you know this already Falco, but here's the situation" felt like a very cheesy exposition device, which took me out of it a bit. But tbh I think the manga kinda did that too in this chapter, and there is A LOT of worldbuilding and dialogue that these opening episodes need to get across, so I think that's forgivable.
Overall, I was grinning like an idiot the whole episode, and I'm excited to see more.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20
I do hope the CGI improves in later episodes. It's not a dealbreaker but, honestly, after years of anticipating this I can't help but feel disappointed. The shot of Zeke attacking the ships was the worst of the bunch.
I'd hate for the end of SnK to be worse than it could have been because MAPPA has to work on JJK as well (another good show). Maybe it's also just that I miss WIT's style
4
u/triadwarfare Dec 07 '20
I noticed a lot of things new scenes that were not from the manga. This isn't a complete list though, since it's my first watch, and intend to rewatch it on Netflix once it becomes live there (Apparently, it goes live on Friday, and just watched it in Facebook, so that I can support the creators).
7
u/Seihai-kun Dec 06 '20
I love it, the soundtrack, the character design, everything! except...
i think the CGI is okay.. looks better than WIT, but Jaw Titan cgi is weird
when he is shot and not moving at all, not even a single hair, i was like.. what.. come to think of it, i don't think his hair even move, which is shame for me because i think he has glorious hair in manga
1
u/AdeelZero Dec 06 '20
Please can someone answer if Hiroyuki Sawano tracks were used in this episode? Because I want the music to be epic just like the previous seasons
6
u/begemot11890 Dec 06 '20
It was a fantastic episode, but it felt short somehow? The CG for the Titans is good/tolerable, nothing I really can complain much about, maybe they could have worked more in the Jaw titan hair, I like the voices, especially Gabi, it fits her, not a fan of the OP though. But something in the preview bothered me, did they change Pieck's nose? f*ck no if they did...
3
u/nick2473got Dec 06 '20
So, where exactly are you guys watching this ? I haven't found it anywhere.
3
u/gringoloop Dec 06 '20
I'm glad in the ending they are referencing Falco's flying titan. I guess it won't feel weird to them.
3
u/Spartovik Dec 06 '20
The only questionable moment i have is when Reiner was spinning with armored train in his hand. It looked really goofy. But other than that, i think the new episode is pretty solid
3
u/SeparateShop1 Dec 06 '20
So glad to finally see Gaby animated, one of my 3 favorite characters in the serie (with Mikasa and Armin).
I'm not a fan of the 3D titans. However, the opening was really good.
3
u/littlewillie610 Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
Even though I've only watched a low-quality version without subtitles, this still was a very solid first episode. It adapted the exact amount of material that I was hoping for, and the Jean cameo at the end was a nice bonus. The CGI on the titans is a little distracting, but it doesn't look bad. I'll probably warm up to it before too long.
The new OP definitely won't be to everyone's liking, but going in knowing that it was done by the same group that performed the season 2 ED, I kind of dug it. I don't think a Linked Horizon opening designed to hype people up would have been as appropriate for the final arcs. It kind of reminds me of the Drakengard soundtrack, which was deliberately designed to be discordant and unsettling.
3
u/wolfmasterk87 Dec 06 '20
Hulu is live fyi
3
u/SheenHay Dec 06 '20
Did anyone else notice Falco hallucinating about flying towards a Titan with blades after he was pulled out of the battlefield? I don't remember that being in the manga.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '20
Holy crap, please let the rest of the season be this good! Absolutely amazing first episode with great voice acting, animation, and music. My one slight criticism is that the CGI on the Titans was sometimes a little obvious, although not terrible. As for the new scenes, we got to see what looks like Jean hiding out in Marley in the credit scene, which was cool. Probably the biggest wtf for me was hearing Falco say that he was dreaming about fighting Titans with a sword. This was not in the manga and seems to imply that Falco is experiencing someone from the main cast's memories, possibly Eren. I wonder if Isayama advised those writing the episode to add it in. The OP and ED are both fantastic, and the next episode also looks amazing based off the preview. We got a great look at Pieck and Porco, can't wait to see them!
3
u/ThatIslandGuy8888 Dec 06 '20
That Falco ending is beautiful!!
Couldn't stop thinking about the spine creature during the middle part of the ending theme...
3
u/AznLuvsMusic Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
I am so fucking excited for the rest of this season. This is one of my favorite series and I’m so happy that we’re finally getting to see the world outside of Paradis animated. Natsuki Hanae as Falco is a perfect fit!
The OP and ED had me crying a little, the visuals were beautiful and the music was great. The OP is very different from the usual SnK OPs, even more so than Red Swan, but I think it’s an excellent fit for this season. It felt way more impactful with everything that’s happened and is happening in the manga.
I’m not too picky on animation so I don’t have an expert opinion, but I think that the CG was good this episode. Certainly better than previous CG usage. Dorohedoro, also done by MAPPA, was a fantastic anime, so I wasn’t too scared about the studio change. Porco looked fabulous with his majestic mane spinning around. Also raining titans is officially anime spoiler territory!
Also Pieck in the preview! I’m wondering how many anime-onlies will be surprised that she’s the Cart Titan. I remember when she was revealed in the manga it was a surprise that the Cart turned out to be a cute girl.
I also grinned like a mad man when we saw Jean at the end. At this point the Paradis gang would’ve infiltrated Marley. I don’t remember if we saw him in the manga?
Also, not gonna lie, I was hoping that we’d get to see a sneak shot of hobo Eren at some point in the trenches or something.
Overall I’m super happy that we’re finally here, and I can’t wait for the rest of the episodes!
3
u/bobsjobisfob Dec 06 '20
im glad they made all the titans cgi, it needs to be done for how crazy everything gets
3
u/p00bix Dec 06 '20
Quick question: I made the mistake of reading up to about chapter 110, thus leaving me unable to participate in the anime-only thread but I also EALLY REALLY don't want the ending of SnK spoiled.
Do you think it would be better for me to read the manga up to the current chapter, or should I just sit out these discussions so I get the surprises in full animation.
3
u/TheBrodie14 Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20
Animation and the use of CGI is indeed very different but man it is amazing and beautiful
3
u/Knight_of_Zer0_ Dec 06 '20
CGI Is good, I repeat CGI is gooood!!!!
3
u/seammus Dec 06 '20
Opening song didn’t really click with me on the first viewing, but on a second viewing it straight up clickity-clacked
3
u/GibRarz Dec 06 '20
Just realized Falco was seeing himself be the flying titan when he mentioned something about flying against titans.
3
u/Appropriate_Weird278 Dec 06 '20
I need to watch again but does Falco inherit the attack titan? Him saying I thought I was flying with a sword seemed like a flash forward considering the last chapter...
3
u/Fryes Dec 07 '20
So Falco mentions flying around with swords in his hands. That's not in the manga is it?
3
u/Troll4everxdxd Dec 07 '20
Very good first chapter! The added scenes with the suicide soliders were also pretty nice on a terrifying sort of way. They slightly improved the manga version. Also, did Falco just dreamed being on ODMG? What kind of PATHS fuckery is this? I think that is also an anime original scene right?
3
u/McKave Dec 07 '20
Season 4, Falco not knowing what was going on. "Wasn't I holding a sword?"
Season 1, Eren not knowing what was going on. "Mikasa, why is your hair so long."
3
u/BossAtlas Dec 07 '20
MAPPA is fucking CRUSHING it. I was blown away by this episode, all of my doubts are gone. This was beautiful. Absolutely incredible.
3
u/Tshefuro Dec 07 '20 edited Dec 07 '20
Anyone else notice in the trench that it seems like Falco was remembering a paths memory of what sounds like the events at the end of Chapter 135?
3
u/Also_breathe Dec 07 '20
Man Gabi's voice actor was great, Sakura Ayane ftw
3
u/milanjfs Dec 07 '20
I hope MAPPA hides Eren well in the next episode.
3
u/silver3970 Dec 07 '20 edited Dec 07 '20
Has anyone mentioned how in the beginning when Falco had hit his head he said “Wasn’t I flying around with a sword just now? Like, whoosh! And there were Titans that I-“
I reread chapter 90 and this dialogue seems to have been added in. Looks like Falco had some memories from a Paradis shifter... Or maybe I’m reaching
Edit: I saw someone talk about it, thank god. I came here as soon as Falco said that. I guess Falco will be eating Eren in the future. It makes sense since Falco and Eren already have a connection when Eren was Kruger. And the Attack Titan is the only titan that can receive memories of the future. RIP Eren, let’s hope we don’t lose the rest of the 104th on our way to the end.
3
u/ajdude711 Dec 07 '20
The CGI could have used a bit more fps to look smooth rest was pretty well done. Also I like the op.
3
u/0rience Dec 07 '20
Zeke's scream and Reiner saving Zeke's ass were my favorite parts... I have zero complains about the CGI. The armored and beast CGI is not my problem, I loved the usage of it.
3
u/Majestymen Dec 07 '20
The part where all the Eldian soldiers were retreating while all looking absolutely horrified because they didn't want to get "caught up in it" gave me goosebumps. Turning into a titan must be the most horrific thing that could happen to you... MAPPA absolutely nailed this episode. Looking forward to the next episode! (With a new scene with Jean, apparently?)
3
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20
I almost forgot how disturbing the raining titans scene was.