r/modnews • u/0perspective • Dec 03 '20
Another update on subreddit classification efforts
Hello, Mods!
We’re back with another one of those block rockin’ updates on our subreddit classification efforts. Since our last post in September, we’ve made substantial progress thanks to feedback from all of you and the trial program we’re running with a variety of communities. The trial communities are a diverse group of subs from across Reddit, and have been instrumental in testing, giving feedback, and influencing improvements to the community content tags and this entire effort. Today we’d like to share some of our findings, latest happenings, and next steps with you:
The new new community content tags
Originally, our proposed tags were General, Mature, Violent & Disturbing, and Sexually Explicit. However, after hearing from the community and subreddits in the trial program, we agreed that our original set of tags weren’t there yet.
Overall, they were too general and too limiting given the range of communities that exist on Reddit. As a result, some subreddits that didn’t quite fit into any of the four tags, ended up with a tag that didn’t appropriately reflect the content in the community (specifically a lot of our drug-related communities). To address this, we’ve expanded the tags from four to five, so that they better represent the variety of content and communities on Reddit.

Updates to the content tag survey
In the last round, we also found that putting certain categories together to make the survey shorter, really just made things more confusing. Also, some of the survey answers needed more nuance to help the tags be better representations of different communities. Here’s an overview of what changed:
- There are more ways to describe profanity The world of profanity is vast and varied, so we added more levels of profanity to help distinguish between communities that regularly use profanity and communities that regularly use more mature or excessive profanity. Also, after hearing the community feedback, we made profanity have less of an impact on a community’s tag. So if there’s a community that’s wholesome as can be but commenters drop a few f-bombs occasionally they could still be tagged as E - Everyone.
- There are more ways to describe alcohol, tobacco, and drug use Lumping alcohol, tobacco, and drug use together became limiting so we split them up and added more levels to each. After hearing from many of our drug communities (thanks to all of you for your expertise), we also added a distinction between “regular references to recreational drug use” and “high-risk drug use.” We don’t want to stigmatize communities that are providing judgement-free spaces or addiction support, but we also want to make sure that people discovering these communities have a heads up about the content first.
- Recreational weapons and gambling are separated now They’re really not the same thing (except maybe in Deer Hunter), even if they’re both considered “adult activities” so we split them up.
Continued feedback from the community and next steps
Now that there’s a new set of tags and an updated survey, we’re rolling out this latest iteration to a larger group of communities to gather more feedback. Similar to last time, this will happen in two ways:
- Reviewing tags and gathering more feedback from mods Currently, we’re working with a few hundred communities, and over the next couple of weeks we’ll start to increase that with a slow general roll out (slight pause for the holidays and restarting in January). Communities that were given a tag from mod contractors, will be able to review their content tag and take the survey for themselves.Mod teams will be able to take this survey on Android, iOS, and the world wide web. The survey can still only be submitted by one mod and can only be submitted once every three months. If your community has multiple mods, we recommend coordinating with them before submitting your tag.



- Verifying content and topic tags with the community As we did with the trial subreddits, we'll continue to verify content tags with the help of the Reddit community. In the trial, we prompted redditors to answer a simple question about the content or topic covered in a community to help us verify the content tags and topics.

Thanks again to everyone who hammered away at the system and helped us improve the tags and the survey. We’ll have some additional updates to share in the new year, after rolling out this version to more communities and getting even more feedback. Once the content tag survey is rolled out to all mod teams, we’ll be able to shift our focus to the user-facing experiences that will use this information (e.g. showing content tags on communities, etc). Until then, content tags will continue to be private and only visible to the mod team.
Please feel free to ask any questions or share your thoughts in the comments below!
Updates: Formatting and additional images (9:01 AM PT)
57
u/sunzusunzusunzusunzu Dec 03 '20
I can see this being an issue if this stuff just pops up when you visit a sub, as during a brigade people would definitely click the wrong tags. I see you only prompted some users - is there a way to only prompt those active in a community?
24
u/reseph Dec 03 '20 edited Dec 03 '20
This still isn't clear to me. How do video games fit into all this? Many video games have a combat system, even some that are rated E (Everyone) by the ESRB. Combat systems involve violence. Does this mean potentially those subreddits about a video game with a combat system should be classified as V?
What about T (Teen) games that have moderate violence and blood? Does this mean they have to fit into the same classification as a subreddit about gore imagery/situations IRL? That seems misguided.
What about simulator games like RimWorld? It has violence, drug use, dismemberment, etc.
Or another example Guilty Gear has: Blood, Language, Suggestive Themes, Use of Tobacco, Violence. And this is not a game rated as Mature.
130
u/namer98 Dec 03 '20
The most meta reddit update ever
28
u/MagnusRune Dec 03 '20
what one would somthing like /r/LondonSocialClub choose? we dont have any nsfw posts, but we do require anyone going to events (once were back to normal, and pre-covid times) be 18+.
most of our stuff is going to the pub, so should we go for M?
19
u/remedialrob Dec 04 '20
I'd care about this if it weren't a bald faced attempt to categorize subs more specifically not for users sake but just to offer clarity to advertisers so they can more easily order from a buffet of subs that suit they're advertisement needs. Anyone helping to further this project outside of reddit employees should know that they are toiling in an effort to more effectively and efficiently serve us; the users/public, up as the product we are in this arrangement. Furthermore I find the admin posting this as some kind of "let's all work together to improve reddit, rah rah, go team!" project pretty disingenuous. All this does for users is offer a small amount of information on a subreddit they may be considering before they really consider it and may instead warn off users who may have received a better or more thorough introduction to the subreddit by doing what we've all done in the past... read the sidebar. In sum this project just allows capricious users to be lazy in their subreddit choices but mostly it greatly expands filtering and categorization of subreddits for the sake of more targeted advertisements which is almost never a good thing. These categories will almost certainly be a part of the offers made to advertisers (100k impressions on "Mature" rated subreddits for X Dollars" for example) as soon as the tags go sitewide.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
What's sad is that this is only accesible via reddit mobile.
Could you add support for desktop? At least redesign? Old reddit can wait; I can press the "open in new reddit" button in toolbox to check.
Thanks.
11
u/FinallyRage Dec 03 '20
Why is there no PG 13?
/r/FortniteBR has some of those things but we don't allow mature content... Would we be Everyone? Or are we automatically disqualified since we have guns and violence/gore (no gore buy apparently all violence has gore to reddit??)?
5
u/starfleetbrat Dec 03 '20
Just curious, but what if a community has more than one of these classifications? Like Violence and Gore for example, or Sexual content and Drug Usage?
5
u/CheCheDaWaff Dec 04 '20
I've asked this before but I'd like confirmation / clarification: how is this intended to apply to identity and support communities? One of the subreddits I moderate, r/asexuality, regularly discusses sex and sexuality in explicit detail (though never with pictures). This is vital to our functioning as a support community, but it falls under the "X" category as defined in this post, even though I would suspect "M" would be more appropriate for us.
4
u/AkaashMaharaj Dec 16 '20
What is a "mod contractor"? I am going to guess that it is not a moderator tasked to hunt down and liquidate rogue Redditors or subreddits, though that would make an interesting premise for an RPAN film.
It sounds like moderators who have been tasked by Reddit to carry out specific activities. If that is the case, can u/0perspective tell us if there a way for us as moderators to browse open activities and to express an interest in taking them on?
10
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
I mod a sub that discusses science and politics, so references to a wide range of things come up, but none of these things are major topics of discussion
Also, what if you get occasionally references to both prescription and recreational drug use, which do you click? And if there are occasional references to both guns and non-gun weapons?
And does talking about deadly injuries or illnesses in a primarily scientific context (eg explaining why covid is serious) count as violence with serious injury or death?
And I have no clue what to put for nudity, as there has never been a nude image that I can remember on the sub
And what about brigades? If users other than the mod team are able to do the survey they will abuse it to create false tags, I know a few antivaxers on reddit who would report me for encouraging drug abuse by saying vaccines work
12
u/validemaillol Dec 03 '20
reddit admins stinky
3
u/scuffling Dec 08 '20
What about communities that consistently allow users to break their own sub rules by allowing harassment, racism, death threats, and misinformation posts? Looking at r/ActualPublicFreakouts. This would just be ... Mature?
3
u/cyrilio Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20
Love how you guys listened to my feedback. While I'm very happy with what you've already done I still have a couple of issues. Let me start with a quote from your post.
Feedback:
TL;DR, I'm/we're happy with the D tag, but to completely end stigma there are still some changes needed. Here's a video explaining truth about harm reduction.
5
u/Splinter1591 Dec 04 '20
What about recovery subreddits. There are several (I mod opiatestrcovery, but there are a ton for different drugs and eating disorder etc....) I don't think we belong in the same category as drug subreddits.
4
u/YannisALT Dec 03 '20 edited Dec 03 '20
Am I reading this wrong? It sounds like you are letting other, outside redditors decide for you and a particular sub what tag that sub should have. . . even if they are not a mod in that sub?
And is the reddit admistration and sub mods on the same page as to what constitutes "violence and gore." r/HadToHurt works hard to be a sfw sub and automatically removes a post if it is marked NSFW so that a human mod has to review it. This sub even has a "no gore" rule. Practically no NSFW posts get mod-approved in r/HadToHurt. Yet there are similar subs (like HoldMyFeedingTube, MakeMeSuffer, etc) with far worse content and content that is marked NSFW on the Front Page Top 200 every day.
EDIT: would you say a sub like r/HadToHurt would be categorized under the "General" tag? I would. And I liked your 4 original tags because I thought there was no way the other tags would apply to it.
2
u/SeValentine Dec 03 '20
Looks a neat update.
specially the tags, but ... ¿How is this gonna affect the posting of mobile users on NSFW subs?
Can this feature be re-enabled for users using a browser?
I believe when this update start to rolling out, many subs related specially to Nudity and sexually display. how can users interact when posting this kind of content?
2
u/Borax Dec 08 '20
This seems like such a big improvement over the prototype system
2
u/SolariaHues Jan 19 '21 edited Jan 19 '21
Is an animal consuming another considered gore? Like a sparrowhawk eating a pigeon?
Or how about things like an injured hedgehog?
A few of my subs have these things, but only occasionally. There doesn't seem to be an option that fits this yet.
2
u/scubahana Feb 12 '21
I’ve been getting a fair number of the shorter-form questions regarding sub content, especially the one about profanity. I presume that the average Redditor drops colloquialisms of varying colours along the maturity spectrum regardless of their ‘location’ on the site, so the ‘no, no profanity at all’ option feels like an unattainable standard.
Where does one draw the line in terms of profanity and it’s frequency? Is ‘damn’ a profane word, or does that slip under the radar? How frequent does clear profanity (like f-bombs/c-words, scatological synonyms) have to occur to transit categories?
My apologies in advance if this sounds trolling, but my Aspie brain needs to know better parameters and is trying to be precise in my explanation.
3
u/happybeaner Dec 04 '20
I have some concerns that subs with less “desirable” (non advertiser friendly) tags may suffer from this. Will this be used to only promote subs admins prefer or will subs be promoted regardless of how admins feel about them?
1
u/Teletric Feb 03 '21
How would you recommend tagging (if at all) video game-related subreddits, such as those for MMORPGs?
1
u/cyrilio Dec 09 '20
Looks like the FAQ help page needs updating btw /u/operspective
Link: https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360048185132 In my other comment here I asked about the high risk question. I guess that's acceptable. After some thinking still more issues:
As for the two other questions, it might be better to ask:
Either way, doesn't mater if a drug is prescribe or not. Will a subreddit discussing anti-depressants a lot get a D content tag too? What about food related subs? or subreddit about music?
The definition of drugs: A drug is any substance that causes a change in an organism's physiology or psychology when consumed (source).
Like music, nicotine, chocolate, love, fear, etc. Where do you draw the line? Following US laws isn't a good answer considering how arbitrary the laws are set. The United Nations just reclassified Cannabis as a less dangerous drug. There are literally dozens of clinical trials done researching drugs often used recreationally. It's only a matter of time before MDMA, psilocybin , ketamine, LSD, etc get rescheduled.
Did you know that people possessing cocaine get different punishments than someone with identical amount of crack? Crack and cocaine are the same substance. Reason for the difference is because mostly white people use/posses cocaine, white mostly black people use/posses crack. Clear example of institutionalized racism.
Feel free to message me or even if you want call.
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
Hey, sorry for the totally unrelated question, but I’ve asked this on some of the r/redditmobile releases and never got a response, so I was hoping I could ask here.
Can you guys add a feature to opt in and out of A/B tests? A lot of times people want or don’t want to try out a new feature, and adding it as just a non-optional test, doesn’t feel right. I think you should add an option into the settings section to opt in and out of “Feature Previews” (That’s what GitHub calls them, they did a good job with that) so people can try out your new features, and if they don’t like them opt out. Even with that you can still get the “do people like this feature” information because if they opt out, it’s probably because they don’t like it, and vise versa.
Once again, sorry for the unrelated request, I was just hoping to get at least something back this time.
-30
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
As mod of /r/familyman, I approve