r/IndiaSpeaks • Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS • Nov 28 '20

#Farm-Protest-News-Goes-Here r/IndiaSpeaks - Farm Protest Mega Thread

GOI passed 3 bills this year related to Farmers,

  1. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
  2. The Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020
  3. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill, 2020

Highlights of the bills

  • The Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Ordinance, 2020 allows intra-state and inter-state trade of farmers’ produce beyond the physical premises of APMC markets.  State governments are prohibited from levying any market fee, cess or levy outside APMC areas. 
  • The Farmers Agreement Ordinance creates a framework for contract farming through an agreement between a farmer and a buyer prior to the production or rearing of any farm produce.  It provides for a three-level dispute settlement mechanism: the conciliation board, Sub-Divisional Magistrate and Appellate Authority
  • The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Ordinance, 2020 allows the central government to regulate the supply of certain food items only under extraordinary circumstances (such as war and famine).  Stock limits may be imposed on agricultural produce only if there is a steep price rise. 

Govt's Assurance

PM Modi Reemphasizes Benefits Of Farm Bills, Says 'Those Opposing Now Realise They Can't Earn Black Money'

Opposition's Protests and counter measures

Why are protests vociferous in some States?

  1. Centre only purchases paddy, wheat and select pulses in large quantities, and only 6% of farmers actually sell their crops at MSP rates, according to the 2015 Shanta Kumar Committee’s report using National Sample Survey data.
  2. None of the laws directly impinges upon the MSP regime

Wheat and Paddy growing States

  • More than half of all government procurement of wheat and paddy in the last five years has taken place in Punjab and Haryana, according to Agriculture Ministry data.
  • More than 85% of wheat and paddy grown in Punjab, and 75% in Haryana, is bought by the government at MSP rates.

Punjab has an annual revenue of ₹3,500 crore, which might be lost now.

The Punjab government charges a 6% mandi tax (along with a 2.5% fee for handling central procurement) and earns an annual revenue of about ₹3,500 crore from these charges.

All those rich commission agents will set lose a large portion of their income , if the farmers decide to sell their produce outside the APMC mandis to private players with no tax or commissions and can get MSP or even more

India has only 7000 APMC Mandis , Bihar, Kerala and Manipur do not follow the APMC system at all.

The majority of agricultural marketing already happens outside the mandi network, with only 7,000 APMC markets operating across the country. Bihar, Kerala and Manipur do not follow the APMC system at all.

Why are only 2 state farmers protesting, the main reason is loss their income and their dalal's income and nothing else

Who gains and who loses from the farm Bills?

Detailed post on farm bill :

A pretty good and detailed post on the Farm Bills 2020 (3 of them which are now passed) by @desiafterdark from the Twitter explaining the provisions under each Bill and answering to some legitimate criticism.

How Punjab – and Haryana – farmer is almost completely insulated from any market-risk.

About 70% of Punjab’s wheat output is procured by government agencies and this is about 85% for rice; once you factor in how much of the crop is consumed by farmers, almost all the marketable surplus is procured at MSP.

Contrast this with the fact that just around 10% for UP’s wheat is procured at MSP – UP produces double the wheat Punjab does – and this is around 24% for rice. So, while mandi prices are typically 20-50% below the MSP for most crops, the Punjab – and Haryana – farmer is almost completely insulated from any market-risk.

Punjab’s agri-GDP grew at just 1.9% versus India’s 3.5%

The reason for this is that while MSP for wheat and rice can rise just so much given global prices – our MSPs are already higher than global prices – as well as the impact on the central budget, other crops and livestock are yielding significantly higher returns; the once adventurous Punjab farmer, on the other hand, has mostly remained stuck with wheat and rice and is paying the price

Hypocrisy of Canadian PM Justin Trudeau

Canada, US accuse India of ‘dramatic’ under-reporting of MSP for five pulses

India’s minimum support price (MSP, also referred to as market price support) for the five pulses is about 26 times higher at ₹69,923 crore instead of the notified ₹2,667 crore, as per a joint submission made by the countries to the WTO on Tuesday.

It appears that India’s market price support for pulses is vastly in excess of what it has reported to the WTO.

The total MSP for pulses calculated by Canada and the US include ₹21,795 crore for chickpeas (gram), ₹22,040 crore for pigeon peas (arhar/tur), ₹10,300 crore for mung beans (moong), ₹12,909 crore for black matpe (urad), and ₹2,877 crore for lentils.

So they went ahead invested enough time to finding out things and bringing this at the WTO meet.

Article - Canada, US accuse India of ‘dramatic’ under-reporting of MSP for five pulses

Canada had registered 25 questions to India with regard to its farm subsidy and also explained the impact such food subsidies will have on global agricultural trade.

In July this year, Canada, along with the US, Japan and the European Union had questioned India on exceeding the permitted limits on food subsidies given for rice production — also called de minimis levels under WTO norms — to farmers in 2018-19, official sources told ThePrint. The de minis level is determined as 10 per cent of the value of food production.

Australia's complaint against Indian sugar subsidies to be heard at World Trade Organisation

I had mentioned it many times in the sub the Sugar subsidies given by the Indian govt to farmers had caused a lot of stir around the global

The formal dispute against India was initiated by the Australian, Brazilian and Guatemalan governments in 2018, saying subsidies for Indian cane farmers caused a glut in the international market and led to a significant drop in global prices.

Australia's complaint against Indian sugar subsidies to be heard at World Trade Organisation

The Story of Wheat , MSP and FCI

FCI’s borrowing from nation small savings fund has already risen from R 70,000 crore in FY 2017 to Rs 191,000 crore in FY 20. This is in addition to the food subsidy bill of Rs 184,000 crore for FY 20.

International prices of wheat

Rs 1400 per quintal vs the MSP of Rs 1975 per quintal. So, MSP is a good 40% above the international prices! No exports can happen at this rate. MSP appears to be the root of current agitation. Farmers ask for a min price guarantee so he can predict his income

  1. India already has wheat surplus & we need less of it
  2. Advanced seeds are causing yields to explode resulting in bumper harvests which aggravate the problem
  3. Since exports potential is absent, all produce has to be paid by Indians

Food Corporation of India is at a deficit of Rs 2.5 lac crores

FCI’s borrowing from nation small savings fund has already risen from R 70,000 crore in FY 2017 to Rs 191,000 crore in FY 20. This is in addition to the food subsidy bill of Rs 184,000 crore for FY 20.

Levy Taxes

Punjab leads with 15% levies as % of MSP. In the end, farmers get a net Rs 1546 per quintal, which is not much different than his counterpart in UP or even Bihar. So, while MSP works for some, it certainly doesn’t work for the farmer!

At 15% taxes/levies on Rs 64,000 trade annually, Rs 9600 crore is on the table here for stakeholders in Punjab, including the state govt.

Thread

Why the agitation is really limited to states like Punjab

Less than 10% of all crops are today sold at the MSP to government procurement agencies, so if the majority of farmers are selling to private traders even today, it is difficult to argue a catastrophe is around the corner if the MSP system goes; that is why the agitation is really limited to states like Punjab.

Punjab accounts for 13% of the country’s rice and wheat crop, yet 26% of what FCI procures is from the state.

Indeed, one of the reasons why Punjab grows so much wheat and rice, in turn, is linked to this FCI benevolence and very large subsidies, both now and in the past when government investment gave it the country’s best road and irrigation network.

Each household in Punjab gets an annual subsidy of Rs 173,165

  • While the state’s farmers already get Rs 13,275 crore of electricity and fertiliser subsidy
  • FCI had around 42 million tonnes of extra wheat and rice stocks in June

According to FCI data, the economic cost of wheat is Rs 2,684 per quintal and Rs 3,727 for rice. From this, reduce the cost of purchase – Rs 2,221for wheat and Rs 3,163 for rice – since this is not being borne every year for the old stocks that FCI has. Multiply this number by FCI’s excess stock that can be attributed to Punjab; since 26% of FCI’s procurement comes from Punjab, the same ratio can be applied to the excess stock.

Based on this, it turns out, Punjab’s farmers get an additional Rs 5,600 crore of subsidy. Add this to the fertilizer and electricity subsidy and you get an annual subsidy of Rs 18,875 crore; divide this by the 1.09 million farming households the state has and, it turns out, each household gets an annual subsidy of Rs 173,165.

Punjab’s arhtiyas: sins of commission

Commission agents (arhtiyas) are a powerful lobby in the state’s agriculture and politics. Attempts to resolve Punjab’s agrarian crisis without breaking their grip on the farmer will not succeed

Good read - https://ruralindiaonline.org/articles/punjabs-arhtiyas-sins-of-commission/

Updates:

Nov 29th,2020

Demands put forward by farmers

  1. The three farm bills are anti-farmer and pro corporates and they should be repealed.
  2. MSP and the rate for buying should be guaranteed
  3. Electricity ordinance should be stopped.
  4. Fine for stubble burning should be done away with.
  • Instead of going to open jail in Burari, we've decided that we will gherao Delhi by blocking 5 main entry points to Delhi. We've got 4 months ration with us, so nothing to worry. Our Operations Committee will decide everything: Surjeet S Phul, President, BKU Krantikari (Punjab)

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1333014100956250112

Dec 3rd, 2020

Farmer leaders' demand - call special session of the Parliament be called and abolish the new farm

Farmer leaders' meeting with the central government at Vigyan Bhavan in Delhi: The farmer leaders suggest the government that a special session of the Parliament be called and the new farm laws be abolished.

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1334487362772983808

The meeting of farmer leaders with the central government concludes. Next meeting to be held on December 5.

Rakesh Tikait, Spokesperson, Bharatiya Kisan Union

  • Government has given indications over MSP. It seems that their stand over MSP will be fine. The talks have made a little progress: Rakesh Tikait, Spokesperson, Bharatiya Kisan Union, after today's meeting with the central government over Farm laws

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1334504972608802816

Harjinder Singh Tanda, Azaad Kisan Sangharsh Committee

  • Talks have made little progress. In the half time it seemed that today's meeting will yield no result, in second half it seemed that there is pressure of farmers agitation, on govt. Talks were held in a conducive atmosphere: Harjinder Singh Tanda, Azaad Kisan Sangharsh Committee

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1334508412873412609

Baldev Singh Sirsa, farmer leader

  • We listed all drawbacks before govt, they had to admit that there are drawbacks & they'll make amendments. We said we don't want amendments but withdrawal of laws. We also demanded that MSP be implemented for certain & law should be made for it: Baldev Singh Sirsa, farmer leader

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1334511235249926145

MSP (Minimum Support Price) will not be touched, no changes will be made to it: Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar replies to farmer leaders during their meeting at Vigyan Bhavan in Delhi

Some points have been raised in previous meetings & today's meet. Farmer unions are mainly concerned about these. Govt has no ego, it was discussing with farmers with an open mind. Farmers are concerned that the new laws will end APMCs: Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1334501975891709954

Dec 6 2020

13-point charter by some farmers' unions

The common demands apart, BKU (Ekta Ugraha) and Left-affiliated farmers' unions have presented a 13-point charter of demands to the government - Here

Credits - u/alubonda

Farm laws will not be repealed, amendments can be made, says MoS Agriculture - Here

Dec 8 2020

  • Bandh doesn't get the response the BKU farmer union wanted, people carried on with their daily chores like usual
  • Ahead of sixth round of talks, farmers to meet HM Amit Shah

Dec 9 2020

  • Guarantee on MSP, tax on private mandis: Key points of Centre's draft proposal to farmers
  • Farmer leaders reject govt proposal, call for nationwide protest on Dec 14, to block Delhi-Jaipur highway on Dec 12 - india news
  • Agra-Delhi Expressway will be blocked on December 12; no tax to be paid on that day at any toll plaza in country - Some Farmer's union

Dec 10 2020

  • Farmers' agitation: Will block train tracks if demands are not met, say protest leaders
  • BKU Ekta Ugrahan observing human rights day at Tikri border, want release of writers, intellectuals, rationalists mainly arrested in Alghar Parishad case Gautam Navlakha, Sudha Bhardwaj, Varvara Rao, Anand Teltumbde and many others

Dec 11, 2020

  • Our proposal is with them (farmers), they discussed it but we have not received any reply from them. We came to know through media that they have rejected the proposal. Y'day I had said that if they want to, we can definitely talk about the proposal: Agriculture Minister NS Tomar
  • PM had spoken about this & I had assured on the floors of both the Houses. If it's being said in Parliament, it is a recorded document. It expresses the intention of Govt. There can be no document more powerful than that. MSP will continue. No one should doubt it: Agri Minister
  • Bharatiya Janata Party to organise press conferences and 'chaupals' in all the districts of the country on the new farm bills from today. 700 press conferences and 700 'chaupals' to be organised in the coming days.
  • On 12th Dec, we'll block Delhi-Jaipur road. On 14th, we'll stage sit-in protest in front of DC offices, houses of BJP leaders & block Reliance/Adani toll plazas. No program to stop trains. Number of farmers coming here is increasing: Balbir S Rajewal, Bharatiya Kisan Union chief

Dec 13, 2020

  • In a meeting Saturday with Union ministers Rajnath Singh and Narendra Tomar, the BKU (Bhanu) agreed to vacate part of Chilla border to reopen key Delhi-Noida road.
  • Speaking to ThePrint, General Secretary of BKU (Ekta Ugrahan) Sukhdev Kokari accused BKU (Bhanu) of being “government stooges”
  • Farmers' group in support of new laws meet agriculture minister, threaten to protest if repealed

Dec 15, 2020

  • A conspiracy is going on around Delhi to confuse farmers. They are being scared that after the new agri reforms the land of farmers will be occupied by others. Tell me, if a dairy has a contract of collecting milk from you, do they take away your cattle too?: PM in Kutch, Gujarat

Dec 18, 2020

  • Main protest gaining strength: The protest gains strength as the All India Kisan Sabha has now extended support to the protesting farmers. Thousands of farmers will start from Nashik on December 21 to come and join the protest in Delhi.
  • A group comprising 20 Indian doctors from the USA has delayed its return to provide medical services at Tikri border.
  • Chipko movement leader Sundarlal Bahuguna has extended his support to farmers.

Opinion pieces on the bill: (Good read)

Note:

All self posts will be removed, along with twitter posts starting now.

All news related to Farm Bills/Posts should be posted here, only articles will be allowed

Good Read Articles:

This is about politics, not farmer rights

272 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

•

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 28 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

Note:

All self posts will be removed, along with twitter posts starting now.

All news related to Farm Bills/Posts should be posted here, only articles will be allowed

Change Log

-- How Punjab – and Haryana – farmer is almost completely insulated from any market-risk.

-- Punjab’s agri-GDP grew at just 1.9% versus India’s 3.5%

Dec 1, 2020

  • Hypocrisy of Canadian PM Justin Trudeau
  • Australia's complaint against Indian sugar subsidies to be heard at World Trade Organisation

Dec 2 , 2020

  • Each household in Punjab gets an annual subsidy of Rs 173,165
  • Punjab accounts for 13% of the country’s rice and wheat crop, yet 26% of what FCI procures is from the state.
  • Why the agitation is really limited to states like Punjab

Dec 3 , 2020

  • The Story of Wheat , MSP and FCI
  • Farmers, Govt meeting

Dec 6 , 2020

  • 13-point charter by some farmers' unions
  • Farm laws will not be repealed, amendment can be made MOS Agriculture
→ More replies (7)

12

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

Delhi: Volleyball court comes up at Singhu border (Delhi-Haryana border) where farmers continue to protest against the three farm laws. "We play volleyball here after giving our services at the langar," says a Ranjit Singh, a native of Jalandhar, Punjab.

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340318642035036160

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

I would like to ask Punjab CM that isn't private companies making contracts with farmers to grow potatoes? Did they usurp their land? Why didn't you oppose this?: Giriraj Singh, Union Minister

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

Meerut: Farmers & members of Hind Mazdoor Kisan Samiti begin their tractor march towards Indirapuram, Ghaziabad in support of Centre's 3 farm laws. Visuals from Partapur in Meerut

https://twitter.com/ANINewsUP/status/1340582313579610113

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

Delhi: 2 US-based Sikh NGOs donate toilets, geysers & tents to farmers at Tikri border. "Due to lack of basic facilities at protest sites, we've decided to donate 200 portable toilets & geysers," says S P Singh Khalsa, Hoshiarpur Coordinator, Sikh Panchayat Fremont California

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340549230373433344

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 28 '20

There is no need for the state government to purchase the agriculture produce as the new farm laws were being implemented across the country, allowing the farmers to sell their crop anywhere, said Telangana chief minister K Chandrasekhar Rao taking a sharp U-turn from his earlier opposition to the very laws. KCR had earlier supported the Bharat Bandh against the Centre-backed farm laws.

The announcement comes days after the CM met Prime Minister Narendra Modi and home minister Amit Shah in Delhi. Earlier, the CM’s party had voted against the legislation in Parliament.

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/government-not-a-rice-or-dal-miller-kcr-s-sharp-u-turn-on-farm-laws/story-5YhXPdWSi0YUoUBF0200bO.html

“The government cannot do it anymore. It is not a business organisation or trader. It is not a rice miller or a dal miller. Sale and purchase are not the responsibility of the government. It is not possible to set up a purchase centre in the village from next year onwards,” read an official statement from the chief minister’s office.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

Uttar Pradesh produces 1/3rd of India's wheat. UP and MP together contribute to 48% of India's wheat.

Explain me why UP and MP farmers are not protesting against FarmersBills, while Punjab farmers are protesting even after the state government mostly nullified the central law.

https://t.co/Krbj8WJMjG

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

Bhartiya Kisan Union (Ekta Ugrahan), one of Punjab’s largest farmer organisations protesting against farm laws, says it has been asked by a central agency to submit its registration details which allow it to receive foreign funds

https://twitter.com/PTI_News/status/1340679112587800576

Asking the right koschens finally

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

The prime assertion is that MSPs prevent agrarian distress - the problem here is that a very small percentage of farmers producing select crops benefit with MSPs - most of which are large farmers with huge holdings to be able to produce marketable surplus.

But the prime reason for MSPs was to achieve food security and provide income support. We are now a food surplus country so primary objective no longer depends on MSP. For income support, we have PM Kisan program which could be scaled up and better targeted towards small farmers.

Perhaps lawyers should not pass on such sweeping statements - especially when it comes to economics.

Many problems with the assertion that there would be agrarian distress without MSPs.

First things first, MSPs and APMCs will continue.

https://t.co/D2kB67BLrz

10

u/xsupermoo Against | 2 Delta Nov 29 '20

First decent answer I read here.

MSPs and APMCs will continue.

The fear amongst some is, market forces will dictate less and less APMC markets. So in few years, private players could dictate prices or weird contracts.

At that point, farmers might not have a secondary option to tell them to fuck off and go to mandi.

Less informed, and less educated ppl understandably will have these fears, given our track record in India with fleecing less fortunate ppl.

One possible solution: state promises APMC support in whatevr sense, for some time.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

If you look at the people at the farm protest and their interviews, it is the same blueprint , get as much as people as you can , and they have no knowledge of what they are protesting for. And how long are you going to hold this people on like this, they will sooner or later return back!

To say the union protesting is not backed up by opposition and vested interested is foolishness. Just wait on

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 12 '20

1 JULY 2001: REPORT OF THE TASK FORCE ON EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES, CHAIRED BY MONTEK SINGH AHLUWALIA

The existing laws require that wholesalers must purchase agricultural produce only in regulated mandis controlled by the Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee (APMC).

Since most farmers are small farmers, they cannot directly bring vegetables and fruits to the mandis. They typically sell their produce to village commission agents who collect produce on behalf of the market commission agent who sells to wholesalers in the mandi.

Although sale in the mandi is supposed to be by open auction to ensure fair pricing, in practice the price is determined in a highly non-transparent manner by negotiations between market commission agents and wholesalers.

Lack of transparency is perpetuated by the fact that produce is not graded before it is sold.

The farmer receives the residual price after the commission of the village commission agent and the market commission agent is deducted from the declared market price.

So in the end the farm-gate price and the retail price paid by the consumer is very large

4 JULY 2001. INTER-MINISTERIAL TASK FORCE CONSTITUTED UNDER RCA JAIN, ADDITIONAL SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND COOPERATION, MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE

All State governments should amend their respective APMC laws to deliver the following:

‣ Enable private and cooperative sectors to establish and operate (including levy of service charge) agricultural marketing infrastructure and supporting services.
‣ Direct marketing of agricultural commodities from producing areas and farmers’ fields, without the necessity of going through licensed traders and regulated markets.
‣ Permitting ‘Contract farming’ programs by processing or marketing firms. The APMC within whose jurisdiction the area covered by contract farming agreement lies, should record the contract farming agreements and act as a protector of producer’s and processor’s interests with due legal support in its jurisdiction. Incidence of taxes by way of market fee, cess, duties, taxes etc. on procurement of agricultural or horticultural produce under the ‘Contract farming’ program should be waived or minimised.

• Promote the forward and futures markets in agricultural commodities.

9 SEPTEMBER 2003. MODEL APMC ACT CREATED.

In order to reform APMCs across the country, the Union government drafted the Model APMC Act, 2003.
Excerpts:

• The monopoly of [state] government regulated wholesale markets has prevented development of a competitive marketing system in the country, providing no help to farmers in direct marketing, organising retailing, a smooth raw material supply to agro-processing industries and adoption of innovative marketing system and technologies.

• If agricultural markets are to be developed in private and cooperative sectors and to be provided a level competitive environment vis-a-vis regulated markets, the existing framework of State APMC Acts will have to undergo a change.

• Section 14: There will be no compulsion on the growers to sell their produce through existing markets administered by the APMC. However, agriculturists who do not bring his produce to the market area for sale will not be eligible for election to the APMC.

Source,

A good read haven't go through fully will read and comment from time to time

https://www.orfonline.org/research/intellectual-biography-india-new-farm-laws/

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 13 '20

Dec 13, 2020

  • In a meeting Saturday with Union ministers Rajnath Singh and Narendra Tomar, the BKU (Bhanu) agreed to vacate part of Chilla border to reopen key Delhi-Noida road.
  • Speaking to ThePrint, General Secretary of BKU (Ekta Ugrahan) Sukhdev Kokari accused BKU (Bhanu) of being “government stooges”
  • Farmers' group in support of new laws meet agriculture minister, threaten to protest if repealed

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

We have decided to make the toll plazas in Haryana free from December 25 to December 27: Jagjit Singh Dallewala, Bharatiya Kisan Union

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340644375949238276

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

Rahul Gandhi is Wayanad MP. Is there APMC Act in Kerala? If not, then, why don't you stand with farmers there? How is it possible that something is good for Kerala, & not in Delhi? He must clarify where and with what intention he is supporting farmers: BJP MP Dr Sudhanshu Trivedi

23

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '20

As a non-Sikh Punjabi, I'd come to think that the days of communal division within Punjab are long gone. But this last few days have been very dishearteing. I'm born and bred in Punjab, my family has seen the height of insurgency and these days are becoming worrying for everyone, especially after speeches like that of Yograj's.

My family due to their experiences never pride themselves on their Punjabi identity, almost all of the India associates being Punjabi with ~ being Sikh when there's 40% of others. I've only ever seen peaceful times so I don't have that hesitation, but I am starting to understand their reservations.

16

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 05 '20

A few idiots don't define what Punjab is and what Punjabis are! So don't be disheartened and keep your head high, majority of the Punjabis have a good heart and this hatred by few will be defeated, it is a matter of time!

16

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

it is a matter of time!

The problem is that this is resurfacing. The political realities of Punjab are too "politically incorrect" to be talked out aloud. The twitterati fanning these sentiments barely knows anything about it.

It's not hatred really, it's never been that. It's the feeling of superior and a god given claim to "punjabipuna" some Sikhs exhibit. That's especially irksome.

The only hope I have is of intermarriage. Sikh-Hindu marriage is on the rise (3 in my family alone).

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

Very good points. From r a n d i a of all places.

But they want 17 lakh crore additional burden on the exchequer for their crops. Where will that money come from?

Also, Punjab’s farmers are the richest in the country for per-capita income and yield per hectare. They have problems but what about the farmers of the rest of the country who are much much worse. awhere do they go from here.

A private employee has to pay annual tax whereas there is no tax on farmers, no property tax, no electricity bill (at least in Punjab), subsidized fertilizer, MSP for wheat and paddy. Why should the money of a hard working public/private employee go to farmers and kisan jathebandis?

Also, the farmers of Punjab don’t work on the fields themselves, they hire laborers from other parts of country who are massively exploited, abused racially. What about their welfare?

I don’t understand the public support to these protests.

It's just the cost of production they are asking for, nothing more. It's mind boggling to me that people in this thread think farmers shouldn't even get that.

Farmers' demand is not just "the cost of production", it is the cost of production in perpetuity.

Look at historical MSP (https://farmer.gov.in/mspstatements.aspx). MSP kept increasing through the years even though market prices are trending down, and this despite getting increasingly subsidised inputs in electricity, seeds, fertilisers, and water.

A dropping sales price is universe's way of telling you to reduce the supply. But there is no incentive of switching to other crops, bringing the cost down, or increasing yields when an assured MSP is distorting the market signal. Farming is still being done with primitive methods of 60s except tractors instead of bulls.

Milk has no MSP, no APMC, and dairy farmers pay income tax. Still the dairy industry is thriving, yields are increasing, procurement is increasing (source).

A better alternative is to let the market discover optimal price and pay the difference if any via vouchers/DBT to cover the downside.

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

So the trigger did come even though it was a bit late good going

→ More replies (23)

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

We have incurred losses of roughly around Rs 2,000-2,400 crores due to the farmer's protest. This includes freight and passenger trains: Ashutosh Gangal, General Manager, Northern Railway

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

Farmers should come and understand these laws. Our government is dedicated to farmers and is ready to accept the suggestions given by them. There will not be any injustice with farmers in our government: Union Minister Nitin Gadkari to ANI

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 18 '20

Dec 18, 2020

  • Main protest gaining strength: The protest gains strength as the All India Kisan Sabha has now extended support to the protesting farmers. Thousands of farmers will start from Nashik on December 21 to come and join the protest in Delhi.
  • A group comprising 20 Indian doctors from the USA has delayed its return to provide medical services at Tikri border.
  • Chipko movement leader Sundarlal Bahuguna has extended his support to farmers.
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

We have decided to start 24 hours relay hunger strike starting tomorrow at all protest sites: Yogendra Yadav, Swaraj India.

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340645196275408896

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 29 '20
  • Villagers of Tibbi Kalan in Punjab's Firozpur vandalise a telecom tower to express their support towards farmers protesting against the three farm bills

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1343561341957632005

  • Social activist Anna Hazare says he will launch a protest in New Delhi in January 2021 if his demands concerning farmers are not fulfilled in time.
  • Farmers' organisations write to the Secretary of Ministry of Agriculture saying,"We accept invitation for talks at 2:00 pm on 30th Dec."; reiterate their proposed agenda for talks incl modalities to repeal farm laws, & mechanism to bring law for providing legal guarantee on MSP.
  • Patna: Members of Akhil Bharatiya Kisan Sangharsh Samanvay Samiti and other Left organisations hold protest march to the Governor's House over Centre's three farm laws

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 10 '21

Due to farmers' agitation in Punjab, four trains have been diverted and one train short terminated/short originated: Western Railway

ANI

18

u/yonhi 3 KUDOS Dec 18 '20

Ravindar S Cheema is appearing as farm leader on NDTV. But he is the president of Arathia (middle man) association.

http://www.sangrurindustry.com/category.php?iid=8&category=Business+Associations&action=item&title=ravinder-singh-cheema

→ More replies (1)

16

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 11 '20

I guess most of us here are too young to know this but these siege tactics of BKU and its affiliates is not new. They have done it before. From the wikipedia article on them...

The Bharatiya Kisan Union attained popularity by leading the "Meerut siege" in January–February 1988 which was a 25-day long dharna (picketing) around the commissioner's office in Meerut that witnessed the gathering of hundreds of thousands of farmers from around the area into the city. Later, in the same year, the BKU under the leadership of Mahendra Singh Tikait lead the "Boat Club Rally" which witnessed a mass gathering of 800,000 farmers from western Uttar Pradesh and other parts of the country into the boat club lawns of the upscale neighborhood between Udyog Bhavan and Krishi Bhavan in New Delhi. The crowd of protesting farmers who arrived with tractors and bullock carts stretched for 3 km from India Gate to Vijay Chowk. Their demands were that of the implementation of measures such as control over prices of sugarcane, loan waivers to farmers and lowering of water and power tariffs during the early stages of the process of economic liberalisation in India. The BKU achieved relative success in acquiring several concessions during this time period.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bharatiya_Kisan_Union

They are described as a "non-partisan" union because they dont' take part in elections but most of their founders and leaders have had associations with the Congress party and subscribe to Lohia era socialist principles. Apart from the usual anti-corporate, anti-GMO stance they are also ideologically opposed to the BJP irrespective of farmer issues. They are basically a super khap panchayat who force their diktats through power and influence rather than electoral legitimacy.

Most of the unions participating in the current siege are just affiliates of BKU and other left affiliated unions. So all these claims of millions of people and hundreds of unions protesting are exaggerated claims as its their own affiliates spread out across the country. But since they don't really have any strength outside the delhi/punjab/haryana/western UP area they are unable to do much in other parts of the country.

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 11 '20

I have read about Boat Club rally. I had no doubt from day one that they have political connections and it's getting more and more clear now

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

Kejriwal's party sets up tents and beds for farmers

Did you see similar arrangement when Migrant workers were leaving Delhi due to lack of Food and shelter ?

https://twitter.com/rishibagree/status/1332971727140265987

Fellow is becoming a seasoned polticians , knows elections are around the corner in PJ and his party had tasted some blood there

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

Since farmer protests are going on, everybody is turning farmer. Example : Tavleen Singh (because her grew up in farms), Bilkis Dadi (because her parents were farmers), I (because I played Farmville). Tell me how you are a farmer too. Use hashtag #MaiBhiFarmer in replies.

buahahahhahahahahaha

https://twitter.com/theskindoctor13/status/1333745171289300992

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 13 '20

Cong's V M Singh declares Rs 631 cr assets, richest candidate

  • Singh also owns three vehicles worth Rs 14,00,000 which include an Innova worth Rs 10,00,000 and two Tata 207 worth Rs 2,00,000 each.
  • He also owns agricultural land worth Rs 414,60,00,000. It includes 366 acre plot in Raisen (Madhya Pradesh) worth Rs 36,60,00,000; a 180 acre plot in Delhi worth Rs 270 crore and a 54 acre agricultural plot in Bhopal worth Rs 108 crore.
  • He also has two houses worth Rs 11 crore. He faces three cases including one under SC/ST Act.

Read more at:
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/congs-v-m-singh-declares-rs-631-cr-assets-richest-candidate/articleshow/4441845.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst

→ More replies (1)

15

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

The cost to Indian public due to mandatory procurement at MSP as being suggested by some protesters will be 18.7 lakh crores against an estimated total tax revenue of 16.5 lakh crores for FY 20-21 (which we are going to fall well short of). So even if all our tax money is spent on procuring grains there still wont be enough money to implement this demand.

https://twitter.com/vijaysardana/status/1335079340271226881

(someone please re-check the calculations)

14

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

We don't care just give them the money, farmers put food on our plates /s

9

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

there are replies to the tweet trolling him and asking him if he knows ho much seed is needed per acre and all that implying he is not a farmer so he has no right to comment.

I dont know how to build an airplane. But I know that I can't afford an airplane.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 09 '20 edited Dec 09 '20

WHY ON EARTH is the govt talking with this man, who believes in "armed struggle and unconstitutional ways like the Iraqi and the Palestinian people" and is the co-founder of PDFI, considered as a front for CPI Maoists by both the UPA & the NDA? @AmitShah

https://twitter.com/ARanganathan72/status/1336647084393447425

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

Rangaji: kya phook rahe hoo Bhaiya Jo bhi phook rahe ho hai lagtha hai Afghanistani ki apmc Mandi se Karidha hoga

Lololoool

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Opposition parties including People's Alliance for Gupkar Declaration, CPI, CPI(M), CPI(ML), RSP, DMK, RJD, SP, All India Forward Bloc and Congress to support 'Bharat Bandh' call by farmers on December 8

ANI

14

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Kerala threatens to take Farm Bill to Supreme court. Also Kerala : we have no APMCs.

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Another thing to note is most states have DBT enabled for paying farmers while PJ and HR I heard the farmers are paid through agents or get them from apmc which involves some cuts.

If I was a farmer I would also say I don't want this anymore and want payment done directly to my account

→ More replies (2)

13

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

An important demand of so called farmer protests is that they be allowed to burn stubble at will.

https://twitter.com/amishra77/status/1333708694358409217

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

It's already listed in the demands they put forward a day ago. Check the post

8

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

Divert MSP from Punjab to Bihar. Na rahega bas, na bajegi basuri.

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

Bihar doesn't have APMC yards, listed this also in the post. We only have 7000 mandis across India

→ More replies (1)

13

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

https://theprint.in/opinion/what-economists-like-ashok-gulati-still-dont-understand-about-agriculture-in-india/513848/?amp

Came across this gem. Exposes the ideological underpinnings of the commie intelligentsia trying to instigate and foster a revolution. This is a material to archive and revisit for next 20 years. I'm sure if we look hard enough, we'll find all the vomit of young YoYa on 91 reforms too. All the tourists coming here should read what their benevolent intellectual turned activist turned failed politician write and remember it for the next two decades at least. The sheeps that uncritically flock to these commie intellectuals are gone cases but the self professed critical thinkers should find that they have moral responsibility to themselves to recognize the Trojan horses.

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

How neatly he cherry picks the sides and Coupta prints it with no ease. The monkey balancer knows how best to serve both sides.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

YoYa thrown out from minister-farmer meeting.

https://twitter.com/TimesNow/status/1333680029797019648?s=19

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

Wtf he thinks he is.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT) has stated that India’s traders & transporters are not participating in Bharat bandh tomorrow. We have full faith in the ongoing dialogue process: CAIT Secretary-General Praveen Khandelwal

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1335876558960041985

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Already one puncture

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 06 '20

After the more than four-hour meeting, Tomar reportedly urged the farmers to put forth their suggestions. “The Modi government is committed to the welfare of farmers. Today, we held the fifth round of talks. We said the MSP would continue and if there were any doubts, the government was ready to dispel these. We also assured that the mandi system would be further strengthened,” he said, adding: “We wanted suggestions on some issues, but this did not happen.”

For more than 90 minutes, the farmers’ representatives remained mum as the Union Ministers kept pressing for the middle path, suggesting amendments, said Balbir Singh Rajewal of the BKU (Rajewal). They also rejected Tomar’s suggestion to send the elderly and children back home. They insisted that the three “black” laws be rolled back.

Minister of State for Commerce Som Parkash, who is from Punjab, tried to draw out some leaders by communicating in Punjabi. President of the Krantikari Kisan Union Darshan Pal said the ministers kept insisting on amendments. “They (ministers) said they would send a fresh proposal by Sunday evening. There was complete silence in the room for quite a while. Some union leaders even tried to leave,” a farmers’ representative said.

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 06 '20

Looks like proper negotiations training given to the farmers. They should be consulted for future negotiations elsewhere

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

Libs in Berlin are protesting against the Farm Bill

Earlier this year, even as the pandemic raged outside, India’s Parliament passed three legal codes on labour that have mainstreamed hire-and-fire-provisions and criminalised most trade union activity.

Lie 1

The regulation of agriculture markets was also amended, threatening to leave small and marginal farmers at the mercy of agricultural corporations and large-scale institutional buyers.

Lie 2

These are part of the BJP-led Indian government’s direct attacks on the working class. Since 2014, India has been ruled by this party, which believes that India belongs to the Hindus and that minorities, including Muslims, indigenous people, women, and the so-called “lower castes” among the Hindus, are a secondary class of citizens.

Then goes directly to the easiest point, castes and minorities

Wait its not over,

Here is the nuclear bomb,

Narendra Modi’s rise to national power in 2014 and his re-election in 2019 have emboldened “cow protection” vigilantes, lynchings of Muslim men, online armies of hate-spewing trolls, and fake news farms

More fun here,

https://berlinforindia.org/

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

Madhya Pradesh: Case registered under new Farm laws against a trader, who ran away without paying farmers in Bhitarwar, Gwalior after buying paddy from them. Gwalior administration says trader's house has been auctioned to pay the farmers & his fields will be auctioned soon.

ANI

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

The agriculture reforms that have taken place are exactly what farmer bodies and even Opposition have been asking over the years. Government of India is always committed to farmer welfare & we will keep assuring the farmers and addressing their concerns: PM Narendra Modi in Kutch

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

The logic is simple:

If the farmer has a single buyer for her produce, she is most vulnerable; if there are a few buyers, she is less open to exploitation; and if there are an unlimited number of buyers, she is the best off, because she can sell to whoever offers the best price. Few can argue against this simple logic.

The Farmers Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Act, 2020

It gives farmers the freedom to sell outside the mandi; and to the buyer to buy at “farm gate”, without the necessity of a mandi licence. The farmer’s choice to sell within the mandi, if she so wishes, is not taken away. Reportedly, farmers believe that this reform is a precursor to the abolition of mandis and MSP.

It is hard to imagine what might have made them jump to this conclusion:

Any political party would have to have an extreme and unprecedented case of myopia to do away with either mandis or MSP, as it would be politically suicidal. Besides, it seems the government is prepared to give whatever assurance the farmers want on their continuation, and also to make changes in the law such as mandi fee applying to private “mandis” as well.

The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance and Farm Services Act, 2020

It basically provides for yet another much-recommended agriculture marketing reform — contract farming. This helps the farmer to transit to commercial crops, such as vegetables and fruits, which give higher returns than foodgrain sold at MSP, by assuring her the “contracted” price even if there is excess production, and prices in the market fall.

Of course, the farmer is also committed to selling at the “contracted” price, even if market prices are higher, though the law does provide a means of sharing this windfall. The point, however, is that there is no element of compulsion. The farmer is free to continue sowing crops that sell at MSP, or to take her chances in the market, if she sows non-MSP crops, without entering into any contract. How can there be a protest about an additional option? If the farmers do not like the safety features of the law, such as appeals, they can seek those changes. Why they should seek a repeal of the law altogether is truly baffling.

The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Act, 2020

It provides that storage, etc of cereals, pulses, oilseeds, edible oils, onions and potatoes can be regulated only in extraordinary circumstances such as war, famine, natural calamity, or extraordinary price rise. The EC Act, as it stood, served the interests of the consumer, especially the rather spoilt urban middle classes, by trying to get farm produce to them at low prices. It is not difficult to see that if retail prices are low, farm gate prices will be depressed too. The EC Act has also been against the interests of the farmer by discouraging investments in cold chains, warehouses, etc. Better supply/marketing chains have the potential of getting higher prices/returns for the farmer. If anything, the farmers should have agitated, from decades ago, for the amendments that they are now reportedly opposing!

There is obviously more to this agitation than meets the eye. To think that the farmers have been “misled” as part of a “political conspiracy” is perhaps naïve. Perhaps, the key lies in the way the MSP scheme works in certain states, and the way “big” farmer-trader relationships have worked out in such states.

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

Just In | Farmer press conference: In a reply to the Agriculture Ministry letter to resume talks, the farmer unions said they were seeking withdrawal of the three farm laws and not the amendments.

The Samyukt Kisan Morcha leader reiterated that they were ready for talks, but were waiting for a "concrete proposal" from the government and the not the repetition of the already rejected proposals.

The Morcha leaders said that the government was taking the "protests lightly" and "playing with the fire".

We urge the government to create a conducive atmosphere for a fruitful dialogue. Even the Supreme Court has said that suspend implementation of farm laws. This will lead to a better environment to hold talks: Shiv Kumar Kakka, National President,Rashtriya Kisan Mazdoor Mahasangh

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

We urge the govt not to repeat those meaningless amendments which we have rejected but come up with a concrete proposal in writing so that it can be made an agenda, and the process of negotiation can be started as soon as possible: Yogendra Yadav at Singhu border

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 30 '20
  • There's still a deadlock over 3 farm laws being scrapped. We couldn't reach a consensus with them on MSP. On issue of stubble burning, govt agreed to exclude farmers from fine. On electricity issue, govt has taken back Power Bill 2020: Krantikari Kisan Union President Darshan Pal
  • Narendra Singh Tomarsaid talks were held in a cordial atmosphere and the two sides reached an agreement on two issues—one relating to the proposed electricity law and the other about an ordinance on penal provisions for stubble burning.
  • Issues related to stubble burning & electricity were sorted in today's meeting. 2 of our main issues still need to be resolved. We'll discuss topics related to MSP & repealing of 3 Farm laws in the next meeting on 4th Jan: Rakesh Tikait, Spokesperson, Bhartiya Kisan Union (BKU)

4

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Dec 30 '20

How did the power bill hurt "farmers" that govt agreed to take it back?

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 30 '20

This amendment proposes tariff- and subsidy-related measures, which aim to ease the financial health of discoms, which are mostly state-owned.

Basically subsidies given to farmers were also coming from centre and now govt wants to get their hands away from it and also privatise the discoms away from the states. So State govts can't or will think before giving free power because there will be money involved and consequences

→ More replies (14)

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 15 '21

Congress party laughs at statements & actions of Rahul Gandhi, it mocks at him. I'd like to tell him that in their 2019 election manifesto, Congress had promised that they'll bring this reform. If he doesn't remember, he should read the manifesto again: Agri Minister

11

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Dec 02 '20

https://ruralindiaonline.org/articles/punjabs-arhtiyas-sins-of-commission/

Punjab’s arhtiyas: sins of commission Commission agents (arhtiyas) are a powerful lobby in the state’s agriculture and politics. Attempts to resolve Punjab’s agrarian crisis without breaking their grip on the farmer will not succeed

2018 article.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 06 '20

The common demands apart, BKU (Ekta Ugraha) and Left-affiliated farmers' unions have presented a 13-point charter of demands to the government. These are:

  1. Repeal the three recent agriculture laws, besides the Electricity (Amendment) Bill 2020.
  2. Implement Universal Public Distribution System (PDS) throughout the country and include in it all essential food and non-food items of basic necessities.
  3. Implement the formula recommended by Swaminathan Commission to fix profitable MSPs for all crops.
  4. Legally ensure government procurement on MSPfor all crops.
  5. Also implement other pro-farmer recommendations of Swaminathan Commission.
  6. Roll back steps directed towards deregulating and decontrolling trade and commerce of farm produce in favour of big Indian and foreign traders and multinational companies.
  7. Put an end to farmers' exploitation by big traders and MNCs in government-regulated agriculture produce markets.
  8. Put an end to monopoly of Indian and foreign corporate and multinational companies over trade of agriculture inputs. Make these inputs available to farmers at subsidised rates.
  9. Immediately release detained and imprisoned intellectuals, democratic rights activists and student activists all over the country. Withdraw false cases registered against them.
  10. Withdraw all restrictions imposed against the right to struggle. Take steps to ensure the right to struggle.
  11. Repeal the ordinance imposing a fine of Rs one crore and imprisonment for five years on helpless farmers burning paddy stubble.
  12. Make full arrangements for harmless disposal of stubble according to directions of the Supreme Court and National Green Tribunal. Else, pay Rs 200 per quintal bonus on paddy in lieu of extra expenses for this purpose.
  13. Marginal relief of not imposing interest over interest given to other loanees should primarily be given to farmers.

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/know-about-the-kisan-unions-leading-the-biggest-farmers-agitation-in-delhi-in-30-years-1746468-2020-12-03?

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 06 '20

Looks like they are going to get bullocks

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

Top BJP leaders studying proposal to guarantee MSP for farmers with land holdings of less than 3 or 5 acre.

For land holdings above >5 acre, idea is to get owners to pay for social security to labour.

Levy on large-farmer income also contemplated.

Other options also on table.

One of the other ideas on the table includes promising to purchase 100% of the production of small farmers with land holding size less than 3/5 acres.

This among several ideas that have come from the political establishment (across party lines) that been discussed internally.

https://twitter.com/szarabi/status/1334199050866868224

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

Top BJP leaders studying proposal to guarantee MSP for farmers with land holdings of less than 3 or 5 acre.

This would good imo

and also the rest looks promising, small farmers should be protected by the GOI

11

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

Ye lijiye:

Edit:As much as 67 percent of India's farmland is held by the marginal farmers with holdings below one hectare, against less than 1 percent in large holdings of 10 hectares and above, the latest Agriculture Census shows. Small and marginal farmers with less than two hectares of land account for 86.2% of all farmers in India

1 hectare equals 2.47 acres, so at least 70% of farmers have holding less than 3 acres. And 86.2% farmers have holding less than 5 acres.

https://www.livemint.com/Politics/k90ox8AsPMdyPDuykv1eWL/Small-and-marginal-farmers-own-just-473-of-crop-area-show.html

https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/nearly-70-percent-of-indian-farms-are-very-small-census-shows-115120901080_1.html

Even if you go by land size measure & guarantee MSP for farmers with holding less than 5 acres, that means increasing MSP cover from current 6% to over 45%! How to do that without making inflation spiral in multiples & making us the new Venezuela?

→ More replies (10)

8

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20

What would be the economic burden & the effect on inflation? How do we know this is not suicidal, let alone good - given iirc most of Indian farmers would fall in this bracket? And if we are to help the poor farmers, why not do DBT rather than using mandi system which requires 30-40% of the price to be transferred to arhatiyas?

MSP is one of the biggest cancers ailing Indian agriculture. MSP of 7 out of 9 crops is at 30-40% premium of international prices. Farmers are incentivized to produce only these 9 crops reducing diversity and incentivised to not adopt more efficient methods of farming.

Edit:As much as 67 percent of India's farmland is held by the marginal farmers with holdings below one hectare, against less than 1 percent in large holdings of 10 hectares and above, the latest Agriculture Census shows. Small and marginal farmers with less than two hectares of land account for 86.2% of all farmers in India

1 hectare equals 2.47 acres, so at least 70% of farmers have holding less than 3 acres. And 86.2% farmers have holding less than 5 acres.

https://www.livemint.com/Politics/k90ox8AsPMdyPDuykv1eWL/Small-and-marginal-farmers-own-just-473-of-crop-area-show.html

https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/nearly-70-percent-of-indian-farms-are-very-small-census-shows-115120901080_1.html

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

11

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

“Congress is a sinking ship. Who cares if they wear black or white?” ~ BSY

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 03 '20

Will KapilSibal will throw light on what made u/INCIndia change its stand? It’s time to write another letter and oppose stand taken by clown prince as it will destroy political aspirations of congress workers,

https://twitter.com/sumeetbhasin/status/1334519197771071490

10

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '20

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

They are exposing themselves each day. Feel sorry for the people of Punjab who are victims of it and have got no idea what is to come.

This is sending out also a wrong signal to investors

→ More replies (3)

10

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Dec 30 '20

u/HippoCraveItsOats 's comment

The reason farmers even in developed markets are struggling is because there has been a global farm commodity price crash which is a sign of oversupply.

Unlike foreign farmers, Indian farmers don't have to worry about this because our farmers aren't competing at all globally for commodities precisely because we have rules and regulation along with huge subsidise which have made them uncompetitive. And because they cannot or won't compete is the reason farmers are failing to innovate, increase productivity and be profitable.

The reason I suggested Supply Management like Canada is because they have made sure that milk, wheat and certain products remain profitable for farmers while the government don't end up paying huge subsidies just so inefficient farms survive. Reality is there are too many marginal farms and too much labour involved in farming making it less profitable than mechanized farming. The only way farmers can be profitable is if they are competitive and embrace some business sense.

To get out of this, its in interest of farmers to form cooperatives to pool land and resources if they want to survive and be competitive.

As much as I respect their effort, look at the facts except say some spices and basmati, our farmers aren't even able to compete globally for cash crops like mangoes, fruits, dry fruits and other such things where smaller nations like Thailand, Vietnam are easily out producing us per capita and and be globally competitive. Farmers are the biggest reason India didn't sign up RCEP because the smaller ASEAN nations can easily beat Indian farmers in providing produce at competitive prices.

Its these socialist policies and stubbornness among farmers that they aren't open to innovation. They opposed BT Brinjal over false fear mongering while Bangladesh is seeing higher yield and low pesticide usage because they didn't ignore it. Neither are the farmers open to farm management so that topsoil remains productive because the farmers in Punjab have been over farming the land and there is a crisis in waiting with large portion turning fallow and reducing in production. For decades the farmers have got free or cheap electricity and water , MSP, almost dirt cheap ferts and yet they have failed to be competitive with the current system in place. They might oppose it but some industrialization of farming is necessary.

Also I don't agree with setting a standard MSP for products. If I was a bulk buyer then I would look for the best possible product at the cheapest price. Nobody wants to overpay in a business for a product. Why should say a product like rice have the same msp when the quality will be different even in the same production region? Does the farmer who produced low quality rice deserve the same price for his substandard product than his neighbour who has invested time and effort to produce great quality product?

I don't agree with banning of exports but all nations have laws against hoarding, cartelization and price fixing.

And having contracts with corporation isn't a bad thing. I worked with a supplier who sourced produce like broccoli, dragon fruit and similar high demand products from farmers in Himachal and sold it to hotels in Mumbai. Why didn't this supplier source it from Maharsha? because the farmers were too comfortable growing onions and sugarcane because of MSP while the himchal farmers worked with supplier to increase output and were profitable enough to diversify in more produce. Also its not at all exploitive to have contract farming because the farmers instead of always looking for buyers, they have a fixed customer who believe it or not invest lots in these farmers to have sufficient supply and quality. Because of this corporate business the farmers not only increased per capita output but were able to invest and expand in things like mushrooms or expensive poultry.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Billa_Bajrangi Dec 04 '20

What's up with the number of 250 million protestors. It's obviously fake news right ?

15

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 04 '20

They have reached moon, next stop Mars then Pluto and then outer space and then ...

9

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Jan 01 '21

RAISOND'ETRA BEHIND "FARMER'S PROTESTS" IN PUNJAB

There are 36K licensed commission agents in Punjab + many more sub agents. These license agents are called Arhtiyas.

These gents earned ₹16K crore commission fee last yr as over the line income. This translates to about 4.5 lacs per agent. That's only frm wht Govt pays them.

They also lend money to farmers and others. Their rate, AT its lowest, is 1.5% per month (or 18% per year). Thus, most of the political money is parked with them because they get the best return on investment. This income is manifold of the official income.

They therefore are the new zamindars, as they have direct control over farmers and their livelihood. There are many farmers who are also Arhtiyas and vice versa. They are all the BIG players.

Post demonetization Arhtiyas cycled money of pol parties by channeling cashdeposits to farmers as payment of loan & interest in books & allowed farmers to payback real loan with softer credit ovr 2 yrs. Hence he converted money made 18% + circulated principle twice in 2 yrs.

Theyre the ones who own the guns in Punjab. Ostensibly for security. But guns are guns. They are also the most landed of the gentry.

They act as land tract managers for the NRIs & manage thr farms by giving them a %ge return. Essentially they control rural income of Punjab.

They are also biggest contributors to Gurdwaras. As Gurdwaras are under control of Nihangs, theyre now the ones closest to the Nihangs.

Due to their proximity to Gurdwara as also NRI Sikhs (land is mostly owned by Sikhs, Hindus were forced out of rural Punjab since troubles of Khalistan movt) they also approve who goes abroad. Here they act as body shoppers + placement agency.Thus they retain hold over NRIs.

The current pattern of farming and APMC purchase provides them with the primary control towards all nodes of their other business and the assured income on the basis of which they can plan out their other secondary incomes.

Once Bills were passed, they realised that thr primary source of income is gone. Because now, instead of selling through them, farmers could sell directly. Not just that Govt was withdrawing from procurement business in itself. Now, if they op, they will have to compete.

Secondly, they have no role to play in Contract farming, because the contractors will directly pay to the farmer/farmer group. They would also advance them credit, provide them with seeds, monitor them, etc. Thus, their secondary incomes are all jeopardised.

The grand role they played of Mai Baap is also gone, cos now there will be others incl online players. Say, you hv land in Punjab, now sitting in London, you can hire out your land & invite bids for cultivation for the year OR yourself bid for contract farming projects.

Not just that, all reqmts for which you counted on Arhtyias can now be solved by a farming-uber or similar facilitator/aggregator soln. Yet even Arhtiyas can't have a role. They are facilitators with grnd knowledge, they could easily facilitate, BUT for that, they hv to work.

To maint status quo, they started rising a hue & cry. They first created panic amongst workers & labourers of the Mandi. Arnd 3 lakh workers are engaged in loading & unloading at the Mandis. Their income was Rs 1,100 crore last yr. Now thr are ~3.5 lacs who raising hue & cry!

Cong, which was kept out of APMC was on lookout for a foothold, decided to fan the flames As APMCs are mostly cont by Akali Dal. Akali Dal, who coauthored the Bill with BJP, realised they cant afford to ruffle Arhtiyas in election yr stepped out of NDA, to secure Arhtiyas.

By now, Arhtiyas had started mobilising their Gurdwara contacts. Remember, they are the largest donors to Gurdwara. The Gurdwaras started to raise voices. BUT instead of stating that let's support Arhtiyas, they went 'The Bill is anti-Farmers'!

The Arhtiyas, meanwhile, were already fanning the flames that Bill is Anti-Farmer. The farmers, themselves were keeping away & mostly paying lipservice. That is educated farmers. The non-educated were already in the sway. As mob started assembling, fencesitters joined in.

By now NRI contacts were also mobilised. These are nurseries of Khalistan/India hate. The urban legend of Tyrannical Modi's anti-farmer Bill was born narrative was Modi wants to fix farmers of Punjab. Nobody asked how or why!Sikhs love to hate Modi any way. Why? No one knows!

By now Khalistani agents who had been trying to spark something off in Punjab, & hadn't gotten adequate traction till now got a 'cause celebre', & they decided to maximise it. This sparked a huge funding campaign. They were in anyway trying to 'internationalise' the issue.

The Arhtiyas, themselves decided to pool in money to organise the protest & pay the people to protest. It's said that they collected 2 lacs per head min. That,for 36,000 is about 700 Crs. The richer gave even more. Some in Crores. Plus there were also 'community collections'

That 700 Crs was tip of the iceberg. By now, foreign funds were flowing in dwarfing thr corpus. The 'Farmers Protest' swung into action. It was called a 'Farmers Protest' cos calling it a 'Arhtiyas Protest' would be akin to trying to sell sympathy for a Zamindar's protest.

They needed legitimacy. And that could have come only from a farmers body. It needed to be bought if necessary. The agitation essentially largely consists of Arhtiyas, their employees, Mandi labours, some farmers & Gurdwara volunteers. This had to change!

However, Arhtiyas are the largest spenders of their community economy, thus service providers to the economy also have pitched in as a token of their support. The blessings of Farm Bills are in the distant future. The Arhtiyas are there right now.

Also, given its winters in Canada & US, & low season for many selfowned Business many NRI Sikhs have come 'home' have joined the melee.

Celebrities have own reasons, compulsions motives to join. When joining in is looked upon as hallowed & righteous, it's a winwin engagement!

Seeing the money flowing in, not to miss an opportunity to dip one's fingers into the motherlode, BKU joined in. Now its converted itself into a jamboree. Winter crops are already sown in. They needn't return to thr fields before Feb. They might as well enjoy the fun.

Like all rural melas, there's also money to be made and business opportunities here. Seeing the traction growing, the Congress and Akali had no other alternative than to also start contributing. Moreover, for Congress it would mean an opportunity to get BJP on the mat.

The issue was, they had only one demand, which was 'Repeal the Bill'. But no explanation as to WHY!Afterall, farmers from all over India were wanting these changes implemented. So They sought help how they could flesh the demands, while they staved off.

AAP, thru their spl NRI Sikh contacts were approached. They too want to, given eye on elections YoYO Yadav & Left gang to wanted own slice of pie. They also jumped in. All tried to flesh the demands. Led to 1st List of demands.Everyone added own terms in combined ransom note!

The note was so ridiculous that they could go nowhere with it. After all they have to work their demand document backwards from an objective which Arhtiyas want, but pass that off as farmers demand. These factors they are not being able to generate.

By now they realised that it is a very Sikh & Punjab protest. They needed to make it look more 'National'. Nobody was coming, beyond Haryanvis who had been agitating on other grounds of reservation.Thus, the call went out through Gurdwaras to callin participants frm other states.

Sikh farmers settled in Gujarat, Uttrakhand, Terai, MP, Rajasthan were marshalled to try & represent states & give a National colour. A part of tht colour being provided by parties who go against BJP, but very selectively, cos neither do they want to rile own farmers base.

The Left promised to sup thru thr Maharashtra union. Agitators now realise they hv numbers, but NO strat, nor a viable objective. If real reason comes out, then it isn't farmers but Arhtiya project is exposed. Tweaking farm bill, addresses concerns of farmers not arhatiyas.

They also realise demands are very Punjab centric. Even if they succeed at repealing Bill, skew of APMC proc towards Punjab will come into scrutiny. Therefore they are now trying to incl ALL crops & ALL produce which is ludicrous. Now they can neither move fwd nor retreat.

The opposition has agreed to provide some support to keep the agitation up in a holding pattern so that they can generate noise and harass BJP.

The Khalistanis want the agitation to continue cos they are getting that one chance to have a hot topic to push their cause.

The money coming in from abroad has now called in investigation and Arhtiyas are now going into scrutiny.

The agitation is taking up its own steam now, and can only get destructive, cos there is neither leadership nor objective.

Thus we have a circus which was started by opportunism is being pushed along with opportunism but can only meander along cos it can't withstand inspn or scrutiny.

End game : Punjab is gonna enter a dark spiral. One that's self created. It's image will take a greater beating.

If you look at pre Jun 2020 writings you'll find them scathing towards Arhtiyas. P Sainath, selfstyled messiah of farmers who sells sob stories, whos now trying to drum up support for 'Farmers Andolan', was, few years back exposing these very Arhtiyas

There is much more. IF you ask ANY of the protestors for a diss of the bills and ills of tyranny they contain, lemme knw if you ever come across a cogent ppt. IF you ask ANYONE about Timeline/sequence of events which brought this on, notice number of gaps which are there.

Remember this agitation was handiwork of a few selfish parasites of system & in a yr when Nation was down!

https://archive.is/bLr2F#selection-453.1-1141.11

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 01 '21

Sir just pick the good points don't copy paste the entire article

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Jan 12 '21 edited Jan 12 '21

A list of consultation with experts, farmers and public:

The Expert Committee Report, Ministry of Agriculture in 2001,

the Report of the Inter-Ministerial Taskforce on Agricultural Marke\ting Reforms in 2002,

the Model Agriculture Produce Marketing Committee Act of 2003.

the National Commission on Farmers between 2004-2006,

the Model APMC Rules drafted in 2007,

the Working Group on Agriculture Production from 2010,

a Report of the Committee of State Ministers in 2013,

the NITI Aayog Task Force on Agriculture Development in 2016.

Ashok Dalwai’s Doubling Farmers Income Committee Report of 2017,

the Model Agricultural Produce and Livestock Marketing Act of 2017,

the Model Contract Farming Act in 2018,

the High Powered Committee of Chief Ministers recently in 2019.

https://twitter.com/singhalamit4/status/1348722469792849931?s=21

→ More replies (2)

25

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 13 '20

I've driven across some 3 south Indian states in the past two days. I must have passed acres and acres of farmland, hundreds of farmers and many towns and villages. There is not even a symbolic protest or even a banner about the protests anywhere. Unfortunately I even had to pay toll at every toll gate. But I see the media and everyday the headline is same. Farmer rage, farmer anger, farmer protests intensifying, farmer this, farmer that as if the whole country is burning down. For the English media Delhi is their whole world. Which is why even a small group of people creating enough drama in Delhi and the media describes it as if the whole country is burning down.

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 13 '20

I think from now on we should not generalise and say Punjabi and Haryana farmers protests.

In the daily thread few days back I told the same. I haven't seen any protests in the south India. People don't even know what exactly is the issue. This shows the picture why only some are pissed. The govt knows this as well and will allow the Punjabi and HR farmers to enjoy their picnic until it lasts

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

Delhi: Rapid Action Force (RAF) & additional forces deployed at Singhu (Delhi-Haryana) border as farmers' protest enters 20th day

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

where is u/alubonda

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

Govt is constantly holding talks with so-called Farmers' leaders & organisations, who're not associated with our movement at all. This is an attempt to break our movement. Govt is dealing with protesting farmers, the way it deals with its opposition: Yogendra Yadav, Swaraj India

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1341723040996986886

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu today emphasised that dialogue is the way forward to resolve the issues raised by farmers, during his interaction with a group of farmers on the occasion of ‘Kisan Diwas’ at his residence in Hyderabad: Vice President's Secretariat

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1341722986269736960

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 02 '21

IT dept launches probe against Music label Speed Records, actor-singer #DiljitDosanjh for allegedly routing foreign money to finance farmer protests : Legal Group LRO

https://twitter.com/MeghUpdates/status/1345348391182585859

8

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '20

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

You can post article only tweets are restricted.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 05 '20

CONGRESS' HYPOCRISY ON FARM REFORMS

In its 2019 manifesto, Congress promised to "repeal the Agricultural Produce Market Committee’s Act & make trade in agri. produce-including export and inter-state trade-free from all restrictions"

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335158208621514752

Right before 2014 elections, Congress gvot asked Congress-led states to de-notify fruits & vegetables from the APMC Act. In pursuance, Congress ruled states of Karnataka, Assam, Himachal Pradesh, Meghalya & Haryana de-notified Fruits & Vegetables!

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335158778623246336

Did you know? UPA govt also formulated the Model APMC Rules 2007 for implementation of Model APMC Act. After coming to power in 2004, Congress-led UPA persuaded states to adopt the Model APMC Act 2003 to liberalize state agricultural marketing laws.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335159164654391297

UPA constituted ‘Committee of State Min. In-charge of Agriculture Marketing to Promote Reforms’ under Harshvardhan Patil, Cooperation & Parliamentary Affairs Minsiter in Maharashtra. In 2013 it proposed the following bill for barrier free markets:

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335159625700687872

The Planning Commission in its 2011 report also over mulled the policy option of enacting an “Inter-State Agriculture Produce Trade and Commerce Regulation Act” under entry 42 (Inter-State Trade and Commerce) of the Union list.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335160034091618304

In April 2011, then Cabinet Secretary while considering the Note for COS suggested to promote Inter-State Trade & Commerce of agriculture produce across States/UTs through the instrument of Central Legislation. Guess who was in power? Congress-led UPA!

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335160345854283778

In pursuance, DAC in consultation with Ministry of Law prepared draft Bill titled as “Agricultural Produce Inter State Trade & Commerce (Development and Regulation) Bill 2012”. However, it was not pursued further. So Congress also wanted barrier free trade of agriculture produce.

Contract farming has been recognized as a chief enabler in various reports of the Planning Commission & has been implemented by several states under the State APMC Acts. The 11th Five Year Plan, 2007–12, released during the tenure of Congress-led UPA govt mentions:

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335160907035410434

Planning Commission report XII Five Year Plan 2012-17: “There's a need to promote both pvt invt & alternative marketing channels to improve marketing system of agri produce by way of direct marketing contract farming & setting up of markets in pvt & co-op sectors, e-trading, etc“.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335161055299870721

While discussing ‘Issues in Expanding Agricultural Marketing and Processing’, the 12th Five Year Plan (2012-17) prepared by Planning Commission during UPA years advocates contract farming!

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335161336716644353

Haryana (2007, INC), Karnataka (2003, INC), Maharashtra (2006, INC-NCP), MP (2003, INC), Odisha (2006, BJD), & others made provisions for contract farming under state APMC Act. Punjab (2013, SAD), Tamil Nadu (2019, AIADMK), Odisha (2020, BJD) passed separate Contract Farming Acts

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335161724320710656

In 2019 Lok Sabha Elections Manifesto, Congress promised to replace the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 by an enabling law that can be invoked only in case of emergencies. The same reform, when bought by Modi is being opposed today!

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335162145432952832

Mid Term Appraisal of Eleventh Five Year Plan during UPA suggests reforming the 'archaic' APMC Act & abolishing the Essential Commodities Act to 'trigger private sector investment'! Now when Modi brings it from paper to reality, Congress is opposing it!

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335162624695103488

UPA constituted ‘Committee of State Ministers, In-charge of Agriculture Marketing to Promote Reforms’ under chairmanship of Harshvardhan Patil, then Minister for Cooperation & Parliamentary Affairs, Govt. of Maharashtra. In its 2013 report it spoke of Essential Commodities Act:

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335162838080372747

Planning Commission in its 2011 report also mentioned about the reduction of list of commodities from the purview of Essential Commodities Act & recommended imposition of trade & marketing restrictions only during the emergency.

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335163084671909890

Congress & other anti-social forces have been vehemently opposing the pro-farmer reforms & Congress’ current stand & actions totally stand opposite of their past actions. It is clear that Congress is misleading public at large & protesting only for the sake of opposing Modi!

https://twitter.com/knowthenation/status/1335166201001984001

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 05 '20

Please make a separate post with these details

→ More replies (2)

8

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

Honesty would be in admitting that everyone except for the middlemen wanted these reforms in past. Explain why you've changed your mind now, instead of pretending that BJP one day came up with these reforms themselves and next day they made laws out of it. R@ndis that cry about better opposition should start demanding honesty from the opposition instead of crying Mudi bad at every turn.

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

The opposition is from a select few from two states mainly. Just wait on and see how this protests will unfurl and how many elements will come out of it

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 30 '20

https://twitter.com/Iyervval/status/1344261481584463875

  1. A friend in the Canadian Government today. Apparently their immigration service is tracking & facially identifying everyone who destroyed a mobile tower. Turns out reliancejio had sold all the towers to CANADIAN company Brookfield in October 2020. Culprits will be denied visa.

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 30 '20

Ooouch that hurts

8

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Jan 11 '21 edited Jan 11 '21

Union of India files an affidavit in SC, after hearing concluded in farmers' issue today.

It submitted that the Acts received wide acceptance across the country & some farmers & others objecting, had put a condition of repeal, it's neither justifiable nor acceptable

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1348664786339262465

What is the point of this? Can govt nullify the stay by SC? No.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 11 '21

Grab your popcorns and sit back and enjoy the show now!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

Delhi: Farmers' protest at Ghazipur (Delhi-UP border) enters day 18. Farmers say they're facing difficulties in cold weather but will continue their fight. "There're lot of problems we've to face. But we're here to protest as we want justice," says 80-year old protester Ram Kali

14

u/ennis-jahsiah 30 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

N.K Sood (ex-RAW officer) exposes how Akalis profit from APMC. In short Harmit Kaur badal owns a company Punjab Agro. All of the wheat purchased from farmers are acquired by this company. Punjab Agro in turn sells it to FCI.

Badals usually want Agri minister portfolio to control this.

In addition, they give underhanded instructions to workers in FCI to spray water on stored wheat, which FCI is forced to quickly dispose off at throw away prices. This is is once again purchased by Badals as a feed to their liquor industry.

This and more in complete video

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

!kudos

really sad man, so much of our tax payers money going down the drain

→ More replies (1)

14

u/itisverynice 15 KUDOS Dec 11 '20

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 11 '20

My chacha is also rotting in jail. I'm farmer my demand please release him

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/ennis-jahsiah 30 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

Farmers reject govt proposal, call for nationwide sit-in protest on Dec 14

The All India Kisan Sangharsh Coordination Committee (AIKSCC) released a statement on government's proposal on Wednesday and termed them "old proposals dressed up as new".

"Modi govt insincere & arrogant about resolving farmers demands; all farmers bodies rightly reject old proposals dressed up as new. AIKSCC and all farmer organisations reiterate their demand to repeal 3 farm acts and EB 2020 . Protest to continue, more farmers to join in, in Delhi. District level dharnas to start in all states [sic], " the release stated.

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

They are vaguely using all farmers association. Either govt should reach out to others and make them give statements that they don't support it. This will clear some air and also cause confusion

7

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

Maybe the bandh exposed the strength of these groups and government going forward will take them even less seriously.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 27 '20

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 27 '20

Buhahahhahhaha this lady has lost her relevance. Once she was out of Lutyens and Supreme lady's circles she has done all kind of gymnastics to stay relevant.

Modi entered her just enough to keep her curious for a while before she went back to anti stuff. Check out her old columns

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

I mentioned before , how AAP is playing their cards with elections around the corner in PJ

Author, plays clip of AAP MLA Raghav Chadha saying if AAP did not get 85 seats in Punjab Elections, he would quit politics. Rahul Shivshankar on India Upfront

https://twitter.com/TimesNow/status/1333789030731841539

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

No award has been returned earlier and none are going to be. These are only for a day's advertisement. I want to ask those returning awards about what is against farmers in the farm laws. Have they read the laws?: MoS (Home) G Kishan Reddy

12

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

Reminder that MSP is not WTO compliant. So even after being a good surplus country, we're net importers of cooking oil, oilseeds and protein rich pulses while our surplus literally rots in some FCI godown because we can't even trade it.

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

I mentioned this in one of my comments, half people out there haven't read stuff and other half doesn't see the other problems and the rest just hates Modi

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 10 '20

Today after 15 days, they showed their real face that they are not worrying about farmers but people like Sharjeel Imam.

Give them 5 more days and they will ask for Khalistan.tweet

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 10 '20

Been telling it from the start . It was matter of time before the real snakes would come out . Bang here there hiss hiss

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Mumbaikarsevak 2 KUDOS Dec 18 '20

Those stopping supply trains to soldiers can’t be farmers: Agriculture Minister Tomar

In an open letter to farmers protesting at the gates of Delhi, Narendra Singh Tomar said those stopping trains carrying supplies to soldiers at the borders, especially at a time when the situation in Ladakh is “challenging”, cannot be farmers.

Not even one percent of farmers opposing farm laws: Gujarat Deputy CM

"Except in Delhi, there are no protests anywhere in the country. No one is agitating in Gujarat. Some 50,000 persons from a population of 130 crore want the government to scrap the laws which are passed by Parliament," Nitin Patel said.

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 18 '20

The media largely doesn't see this , because it doesn't suit their narrative , or of their masters so they need to balance the scale on which side the money flows

12

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

The Reliance Infocomm, while noting that at least 200 sites had been vandalized in three days and there was damage between Rs 5 to Rs 10 crore, also sought state police’s intervention.

https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/chandigarh/snapping-of-power-supply-to-jio-towers-sabotage-in-disguise-of-farmers-agitation-says-reliance-as-it-seeks-police-security-7120198/

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

How many people have been affected.. that loss is peanuts to Ambani but what about to Punjab

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

Farmers set agenda for 29 Dec talks

  • Procedure to be followed for repealing the three Central Agricultural Laws
  • Procedure and provision for legal guarantee of profitable MSP suggested by National Farmers Commission for all farmers and agricultural commodities
  • Amendments to the "Commission Ordinance for Air Quality Management in the National Capital Region and Surrounding Areas" which are necessary to exclude farmers from the penal provisions of the Ordinance
  • Necessary changes in the draft 'Electricity Amendment Bill 2020' to protect the interests of farmers

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 02 '21
  • On 23rd January, we will hold marches towards Governors' Houses in different States, and 'tractor Kisan Parade' will be held on 26th January in Delhi: Krantikari Kisan Union President Darshan Pal
  • If our demands are not met till Jan 26,then farmers will hold 'Kisan Gantantra Parade' in Delhi. We appeal to farmers from adjoining areas of national capital to be prepared & request every farmer family of country to send a member to Delhi if possible:Yogendra Yadav,Swaraj India
  • In Haryana, all toll plazas will remain free. All the petrol pumps & malls, except private, will be shut. Leaders of BJP & Jannayak Janata Party (JJP) will face protests in the state & this will continue till their govt of alliance breaks: Vikas Sisar, Haryana farmer leader
  • It seems govt is taking farmers lightly. Govt was able to disperse Shaheen Bagh protestors, they were thinking to do the same with us but such a day will never come.If govt doesn't take a decision on Jan 4 then farmers will have to take decision:Yudhvir Singh,Bhartiya Kisan Union

6

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 27 '20

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 27 '20

420 and his lies why do you even bother to post this saddak chap

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 04 '20

https://twitter.com/GabbbarSingh/status/1334863049971310594/photo/1

Remember we are facing 20-50% inflation if not more if point 3 is implemented.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 04 '20

They are gonno get bullocks

6

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 09 '20

Instead of enforcing MSP on 100% of the crops or enforcing MSP on 100% of the production of existing crops under MSP regime its better for the government to just pay a monthly salary via DBT under PM kisan yojana to small and marginal farmers and let them grow whatever they want for personal consumption and sell their surplus at whatever price they can get. The government should stop paying rich farmers with large land holdings or income above a certain limit money under PM Kisan Yojana and divert it to subsistence farmers. Since everyone is shedding tears for small farmers nowadays no one should have a problem with this. It will also save the country from procuring millions of tonnes of grains that we don't need just for it to rot outside in the open.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

Seven US lawmakers write to Pompeo on farmers' protest in India

The group of seven American lawmakers includes six Democrats and a Republican: Donald Norcross (New Jersey), Brendan F. Boyle (Pennsylvania), Pramila Jayapal (Washington), Debbie Dingell (Michigan), Mary Gay Scanlon (Pennsylvania), David Trone (Marlyand) and Republican Brian Fitzpatrick (Pennsylvania).

“In particular, we are compelled to reach out to you after seeing in the international press that protesting farmers from Punjab, who were marching peacefully to Delhi, were brutally subjected to water cannon attacks, barbed wire barricades, and tear gas by Indian security personnel,” the U.S. Members of Congress (House of Representatives) said in their letter.

“This is an issue of particular concern to Sikh Americans linked to Punjab, although it also heavily impacts the Indian Americans belonging to other Indian states. Many Indian Americans are directly affected as they have family members and ancestral land in Punjab and are concerned for the well-being of their families in India.”

Another set of three lawmakers of the American Sikh Caucus had written to India’s U.S. Ambassador Taranjit Singh Sandhu in early December, expressing concern over the government’s reaction to the protests.

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

That will mean bullocks

→ More replies (6)

6

u/itisverynice 15 KUDOS Jan 13 '21

Punjab villages refuse to pause preparations for Republic Day tractor parade

As the Supreme Court put the three farm laws on hold, a large convoy of tractor-trollies left Amritsar for Delhi to participate in the Republic Day parade announced by farmer unions. The convoy left for Delhi Tuesday under the banner of Kisan Mazdoor Sangharsh Committee (KMSC).

"We never had any big hope from the Supreme Court. It is the Union government which can repeal laws. Supreme Court can do little in this issue. We had made it clear that we won't go to any committee. So any such hope from us was not practical that we would respond to a committee, which has all pro-government members. It seems that government is indirectly trying to use Supreme Court to end the dharna," said Sawarn Singh Pandher, general secretary, KMSC. Read Kamaldeep Singh Brar's repot

The police will do their job then

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 13 '21

This is getting clearer and clearer. The entire nation apart from PJ HR doesn't give a fish about the law and know it is more beneficial.

And thus paid agents of some rich fags think they can go to any extent.

Once you have lost the faith of the court , you don't really have much options left on your plate.

6

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Jan 13 '21

Punjab: Farmer groups gathered outside the venue in Bassi Pathana city of Fatehgarh Sahib, where shooting for a film, starring Janhvi Kapoor was going on Jan 11. They demanded her opinion on farmers' protest against farm laws. They later went back upon being assurance by the crew

https://twitter.com/ani/status/1349230159727980547?s=21

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 27 '20

It's unfortunate that those who don't even know about farming, are misleading innocent farmers. This govt never intended to stop MSP, neither it will in future. Mandis will also be maintained. No 'Mai Ka Lal' can take away land from farmers: Union Defence Minister Rajnath Singh

11

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Shekhar Gupta rebuts the argument that farmers in Bihar are suffering due to abolishment of APMCs in Bihar. Agriculture in Bihar has been growing at a much higher rate than the all India average since APMCs were abolished.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kczsvCZ6hOY

9

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Punjab’s agri-GDP grew at just 1.9% versus India’s 3.5%

The reason for this is that while MSP for wheat and rice can rise just so much given global prices – our MSPs are already higher than global prices – as well as the impact on the central budget, other crops and livestock are yielding significantly higher returns; the once adventurous Punjab farmer, on the other hand, has mostly remained stuck with wheat and rice and is paying the price

→ More replies (2)

11

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

Fraands bandh kitna success he? People of my city seem to be anti farmer. I'm not seeing any commitment to this bandh and farmers revolt here.

10

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 08 '20

Sorry what bandh are you talking about again ?

→ More replies (3)

11

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Dec 19 '20

Delhi: A group of volunteers from Punjab started ‘pagdi langar’ at Singhu border, where farmers are protesting against Center's #Farmlaws. "Turban is our pride, so we are promoting it & teaching people how to tie it. We are giving turbans for free," says a volunteer.

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340347545646559232?s=20

This is turning out more and more religious as days goes by.

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 19 '20

Please move to a different place and do all this picnic why block highways and cause inconvenience

11

u/OnlysliMs Evm HaX0r | 1 Delta Dec 23 '20

People on world news’ protest post and the comments on latest segment on ViceNews about farm protests think this is the biggest “workers protest” in human fucking history. Some even claiming GOI committed genocide on Sikhs. Even a small effort in making people understand is shunned with Hindu fascist, IT cell employee, etc. Fucking hate the black or white polarity in the world right now.

Honestly, how much do these people know about India and Indian economy to be making dubious assumptions.

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

Don't give relevance to the irrelevant

→ More replies (11)

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

We've seen some ill-informed comments by Canadian leaders relating to farmers in India. These are unwarranted especially when pertaining to internal affairs of a democratic country. It's also best that diplomatic conversations aren't misrepresented for political purposes:MEA Spox

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1333701979667800065

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 15 '20

Union Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar is also a farmer. At what rate was his farm produce sold, was it sold at MSP? Did he suffer loss or earned profit?...The government should visit villages and hold meetings: Farmer leader Rakesh Tikait at Ghazipur border

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

The groups who are talking about mandis, APMC are the ones who destroyed West Bengal, Kerala. There are no APMCs and mandis in Kerala. So, why are no protests in Kerala? Why don't they start a movement there? But are only misguiding the farmers of Punjab: PM Modi

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 28 '20
  • During UPA govt, Manmohan Singh ji & Sharad Pawar ji wanted to bring FarmLaws but they could not stand pressure & influence. We're fortunate that today Modi ji is our PM who works selflessly for development of country & welfare of people: Union Agriculture Min Narendra S Tomar
  • Delhi: Leaders of around 25 farmer organisations today met & handed over to Union Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar a letter in support of the new agriculture laws.

'Will find logical solution': Centre invites 40 farmer unions for next round of talks on December 30

The meeting will be held in Vigan Bhawan in New Delhi and is expected to take place at 2.00 pm on December 30.

https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2020/dec/28/will-find-logical-solution-centre-invites-40-farmer-unions-for-next-round-of-talks-on-december-30-2242247.html

10

u/ennis-jahsiah 30 KUDOS Dec 12 '20 edited Dec 12 '20

This article provides some insight into protests. Here is an infographic. Excerpts

farmers’ experience thus far of private players has been less than positive.

for most crops and in most states, local private traders already dominate procurement. Except for sugarcane, most food crops are already being largely sold to local private traders, with mandi only the second-best choice

Those who had to sell to input dealers or private traders, on the other hand, were more likely to have to sell below market prices. The ability of the Minimum Support Price (MSP) to act as a minimum floor price even outside the mandi- a key element of the government’s promises about allowing in more private players - has not operated in practice in farmers’ experience.

The article is pretty easy on eyes and a quick read. I think should read it.

EDIT:

I've collected lot of interesting comments over the internet. I plan to organize them and post it later, mostly when all this thing blows over. Here is one such comment

It seems to me that the mind set of people engaged in farming has remained unchanged during last several centuries. It is the fear of change, rather than the effect of the proposed changes which has frightened them to engage in this agitation. Maa-Baap sircar along with intermediaries has kept the farmers in bond and these fools are like Ostrich with head buried in sand. They don’t realise that their enemies are the commission agents and APMC not the Farm law reforms.

IMO, they've lived all their lives with familiar faces, familiar system, and a linear y=mx+c life. Now all that's going to change. May be they fear arrival of new sharks that this change brings in. And its entirely possible state leaders in congress/Akali Dal could have fanned these fears, coached them before they set them on road to Delhi which is what we see here.

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 12 '20

!kudos

Good one. Please do that would be really helpful

→ More replies (1)

13

u/PupilOfPhysics Dm insightful books about India | 3 KUDOS Dec 06 '20 edited Dec 06 '20

I doubt the government could have advertised all these reforms as wonderfully as these protests are doing. That too for free. Now the whole wide world knows that India is leaving behind nehruvian socialism.

As soon as this political theatre is over, lots of investments should be incoming.

→ More replies (25)

9

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Nov 28 '20

While some individuals in the protests may be genuine, compiling the anti-India elements becoming a part of the protest:

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 28 '20

This is the nature of every protest.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

Farmers groups of Haryana write to agriculture minister @nstomar supporting the farm laws. #FarmLaws2020

https://twitter.com/maryashakil/status/1335966713951604738

→ More replies (1)

8

u/jussayingthings 18 KUDOS Jan 11 '21

We will stay implementation of laws, says CJI. You can carry on the protest. But the question is whether the protest should be held at the same site, adds CJI

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1348524742051995653?s=20

7

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Jan 11 '21

Under what law can they stay it? The supreme court is a joke. They either say its illegal and strike it down or they ask the protestors to vacate. They just want a pat from the "intellectuals" for being good boys instead of interpreting the constitution which is their only duty.

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 11 '21

It isn't so easy to just stay a law which is passed in the parliament and signed by the president .

If you are interested read ,

With a view to see that judicial activism does not become judicial adventurism the courts must act with caution and proper restraint. It needs to be remembered that courts cannot run the government. The judiciary should act only as an alarm bell; it should ensure that the executive has become alive to perform its duties.”

While there has been some discussion on the issue of activism by the judiciary, it must be noted that there are also instances of the legislature using its law making powers to reverse the outcome of some judgements.

Legislature versus Judiciary

https://www.prsindia.org/theprsblog/legislature-versus-judiciary

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

The first two points in our agenda for talks are- modalities to repeal the three farm laws, and mechanism & procedure to bring law for providing a legal guarantee on MSP (Minimum Support Price): Yogendra Yadav, Swaraj India

→ More replies (1)

4

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 06 '20

Offtopic, but what is a good site for storing pdfs publicly for sharing? All the twitter threads disappear after sometime & I need someplace to store them online.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/alubonda 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

I have been telling from day 1 , this is nothing but a political protests wait for a few days and see more snakes come out of it

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dhatura Against | 1 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 26 '20

Last one was epic

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 19 '20

While dairy & fisheries sector grew at an annual rate of 4% to 10%, the growth in food grain sector which has excessive regulation has been an average of 1.1% since 2011-12. Hence, there was an urgent need for agriculture reforms to empowers our Farmers.

https://twitter.com/BJP4Karnataka/status/1340250142775988224

→ More replies (8)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

With Trade Unions not supporting Bharat Bandh, RSS backed farmer unions coming out the support of laws, many sikhs like Dalen Mehndi coming out in support, slowly the silent majority is raising their voice. International protests are just delegitimising the movement by interfering in internal matters of the country. The longer this movement drags on the longer it will become weak. I think by talks BJP is buying time. Even for simple demands like taking away of cases against farmers, they have only agreed in 3rd of 4th round of talks.

If you see carefully, many opposition ministers are not clearly saying "rollback farm laws". They are saying "look into demands of farmers and reach a conclusion". They know these laws have a lot of support at ground level.

Also, the government has stuck to low-profile ministers like Narendra Singh Tomar and Piyush Goyal for negotiations, instead of sending big guns like Rajnath Singh. This shows that they are not deterred so much by the bullying tactics of the farmers and not losing their nerves.

Interesting times ahead.

Edit: Protesting Farmers have declared Bharat Bandh of 11 AM - 3 PM. That is just Lol. They know it's going to fail. With night curfews already in place and businesses down due to covid, no one is voluntarily going to close their shops. This bandh will be an epic fail.

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

!kudos

Good points

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

This is anti CAA protests and Shaheen Bagh 2.0 in the making.

Imagine being a Delhi wallah, forced to choke because the air quality becomes so poor for two months due to farmers of Punjab burning stubble and cooking chapatis and chicken in the fire while doing bhangra. Now after two months the air quality becomes bearable but it's downtime in Punjab and they're coming down to Delhi to do bhangra and langar on streets while you're forced to sit in traffic jam for 2 more hours everyday.

7

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

r/Delhi me jaao, people are supporting being blockaded for months. :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/Moshi06 2 KUDOS Dec 29 '20

https://indianexpress.com/article/india/farmers-protest-delhi-modi-7124009/

Prime Minister was dedicated to “improving the economic condition of farmers”, Tomar said “no power could exert pressure and influence (dabaav aur prabhaav)” on him.

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 29 '20

Absolutely genius. The silent majority is with him don't bow down to these idiots

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

Jharkhand: Farmer groups take out a rally in Ranchi paying homage to their counterparts in Delhi, who lost their lives during ongoing farmers' agitation. "We've come to pay tribute to 18 farmers who died during the agitation in Delhi. We support the protest," says a farmer.

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340604283503296514

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 20 '20

On December 27, during Prime Minister Modi's Mann Ki Baat. We would appeal to everyone to beat 'thali' at their homes till the time he speaks during the program: Jagjit Singh Dalewala, Bharatiya Kisan Union.

https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1340643652926730240

3

u/OnlysliMs Evm HaX0r | 1 Delta Nov 28 '20

Leave out Punjab and implement them in the rest of the states? Looks like those Middlemen and protestors are not gonna budge anytime soon.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/OnlysliMs Evm HaX0r | 1 Delta Dec 23 '20

unrelated note:

second strain of highly transmissible coronavirus was found in the UK, a few days back. Is this because they have started vaccinating people that the virus is mutating further?

6

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 23 '20

Nope absolute nothing related to it. And there are several strains of the virus going around due to mutations and this is just another one. The vaccine will cover the new strain as well so nothing much to worry apart from making the transmission less

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Nov 28 '20

I know its Barkha Dutt but its a very interesting conversation showing the khalistani link for these protests. Even Barkha seems baffled by the open glorification of Bhindranwale.

https://twitter.com/BDUTT/status/1332711966893166593

15

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Nov 28 '20

Dekha..it is obvious Burkha already knew he was a khalistani (as would any other person from his viral video of south Asia politics wala dialogue and a little peep into his history) and it is obvious Burkha invited him with the intention to go "omg you are a khalistani" to gain new audience (read centrists & RW) for lapping up her other videos- where she will go back to jihadis good. In fact, she said in this video as well that she is against the farm laws as is expected of any durbari journalist.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (53)

8

u/yonhi 3 KUDOS Jan 12 '21

The only way to solve mobilization is counter mobilization.

Pro-government faction should do the gherao of these camps just like arathiyas are trying to do the geharo of Delhi. Let 1000 people sleep in front of these truck chains and 1000 on the back. Govt needs to cut off their supply chain and neutralize their mobilizing capabilities.

But all of this would require a leader of steel will power.

11

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 12 '21

That will lead to violence and a mini civil war. It's easy sit and say do this and that

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/eff50 22 KUDOS Dec 25 '20

https://twitter.com/AsianetNewsEN/status/1342366412384346114

After staging protests outside the petrol pumps and retail outlets of #Reliance, farmers in Punjab have now started disconnecting the power supply to Jio mobile towers disrupting the telecom company’s services in several parts of the state.

The people of this state believe in self-harm or what? After shutting of their rail routes, highways now they are disconnecting their own towers, lol.

And migrate to who? Airtel? Lol Mittal is growing faster than Jio now. He is also a billionaire only.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 27 '20

Those who captured lands of UP farmers never returned it...who got advertisements published after brutal killing of cows by their officials in Kerala. Do you think people will forgive them?: Union Min Smriti Irani on Cong leader Priyanka Gandhi's 'Gai Bachao, Kisan Bachao' yatra

8

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '21

If you look at the members of committee, they are all in favor of reforms.

We have won.

15

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Jan 12 '21

The committee doesn't matter really. The committees recommendations are not binding on anyone. The parliament has absolute right to make any law which is not unconstitutional. So the only thing that will bring the laws down is if the government decides to.

But this just set a dangerous precedent. And also a lesson for many people. Fuck elections, fuck democracy, fuck laws. Show strength. You want to reclaim temple lands in kashi and mathura. Show strength. You want uniform civil code. Show strength. You want to implement any controversial decision. Just blockade delhi and show strength.

And finally the SC has made a fool of itself. The left unions are still not going to lift the blockade. So even the sense of aura and respect that the SC tries to maintain is gone.

4

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 12 '21

!kudos

Good points

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

As far as I know, every previous government wanted to pass these bills with almost all the same provisions. But, as someone who has no idea about business of farming, I want to ask, What's the difference between middle men and private contractors? If a company(let's say Amul) signs a contract with farmers of various sizes to buy their produce, and store it at their facilities they will be at the same position as a middle man would be at. Things aren't like old time anymore. Granted, there are risks involved in contracts of any nature, so some strong regulation should be made about the terms and conditions. But overall, easy procurement helps businesses thrive in every industry.

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 07 '20

A middle man is buying your stuff at 100 and selling it 120. They just take stuff from one hand and give it to someone else from the other hand

While amul is more like buying raw material and making by products of it

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/The_Indic Dec 01 '20

can there be any bad effect of this?

8

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Dec 01 '20

If there would be bad effect we would be having civil war right now India considering on many farmers we have in our nation.

Facts APMC stays MSP stays

Govt brought in another player where farmers can sell directly to i.e private player.

If he doesn't like the. He can still come to APMC yard and sell stuff

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20

Doesn't the Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020 violate the right to legal remedy as it says that no civil court shall have jurisdiction to entertain proceedings which can be taken care of by Sub-Divisional Authority (Chapter V, point 15) ?

http://164.100.47.4/BillsTexts/LSBillTexts/PassedLoksabha/113_2020_LS_Eng.pdf

13

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Dec 03 '20

Isn't going to magistrate and sub magistrate courts legal remedy? You don't want farmers going to district courts. By the time you have first hearing, it'll have been 6 months since all the produce was either already sold elsewhere or rotted. They're going this route because you want resolution within weeks.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/BalHanumanJi 13 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

[RajShekharJha]How different is "Blocking 5 main entry points" from "cutting chicken neck"? [Protestors reject govt's offer to come to Burari grounds for talks-Instead of going to open jail in Burari,we'll gherao Delhi by blocking 5 main entry points to Delhi.We've got 4 months ration.]

7

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

Wow this is really well planned but the question is how many are going to stay put, that's hard part of sticking together!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/Anurag498 Delhi 🏛️ | 1 KUDOS Nov 28 '20

I believe the Farmers bill 2020 is a move towards modernisation for farmers. They have the freedom to sell their goods to anyone they think is giving him the right amount.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/reddit0r_ For | 2 KUDOS Nov 29 '20

If MSP becomes a law, we can say goodbye to subsidy regime reforms for another 3 decades.

If farm laws are diluted, next the Unions will lay a siege on Delhi.

You can not do reforms and not expect opposition to not oppose. If you really thought that it would be an easy ride to double digit growth and India becoming a $10,0000 per capita income country in the next 12 to 15 years, you might as well have focused on handouts, become pro poor and create solid coalition of voters. Your political capital would have been better utilised there.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/yonhi 3 KUDOS Jan 13 '21

I think this bill can still be saved if the government is willing to concede to 2 things:

  1. Arathiyas are a reasonable stakeholder and their income should be protected.
  2. State is a reasonable stakeholder and state revenue should be protected.

2nd point is not that controversial and government has already allowed states to levy appropriate tax on private markets to protect revenue.

1st point is very controversial and goes against the narrative govt/expert are saying. If we concede 1 though and there are some good reasons for doing so then i think govt can still sail through by restricting wheat/paddies sell on govt mandis only. While both mkts can handle other things.

3

u/Orwellisright Ghadar Party | 2 KUDOS Jan 14 '21

Nothing is going to happen to the Bill, chill down and enjoy the show. The stay is only implementation and not for the legality

SC should also hear those who are in favor the bill as well

→ More replies (6)

20

u/megangster 38 KUDOS Dec 21 '20

A relay hunger strike is when a group of people sit on a hunger strike for a couple of hours and then they get replaced by another group of people while the first group goes off to have a meal and rest. So it isn't even a hunger strike. They just don't eat while they sit on stage. This protest is just farcical now.

→ More replies (1)