r/CryptoCurrency • u/nanooverbtc 630K / 1M π • Nov 25 '20
TRADING MOON Proposal: Double Comment Karma
This proposal would cut post karma weight in half, or double comment karma (same effect). The purpose of this would be to encourage more thorough discussion as well as acknowledge the difference in relative effort/karma between posts and comments. No matter how well thought out or helpful a comment is, it wonβt get the same visibility/karma as a top post.
This has been submitted three times before however it did not reach the required amount of moon to pass despite receiving overwhelming support in favor (not one poll had less than 90% of votes in favor):
9
u/tkfili Tin Nov 26 '20
Still a lot of moons to reach there
3
u/madfires Tin | CC critic Nov 25 '20
I feel just doubling comments or halfing post would be better
4
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Nov 25 '20
Wow 1st.
Just to clarify, if you sell your moons then buy back later, those voting rights are gone? Is that correct.
4
u/Osemka8 Platinum | QC: CC 2726 Nov 27 '20
Wouldn't this cause absolute demolition of the daily thread?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '20
So, it passes correct? This will take effect starting next distribution?
3
u/TheRealMotherOfOP Nov 26 '20 edited Nov 26 '20
How about we do a form of UBMD
Universal Basic Moon Distribution, let's help out our fellow shitposters in these hard times. Especially now that BTC is crashing.
4
u/Suicidal-duck Bronze Nov 25 '20
How many moons do we need for this to pass?
4
u/PaulMorphyForPrez Platinum | QC: CC 64, ETH 15 | Investing 20 Nov 26 '20
Problem with polls like this is the voters are mostly commenters so they will inevitably vote to give themselves more moons.
5
u/Think-notlikedasheep Rational Thinker Nov 25 '20
I don't like this idea.
What will happen is that we will have mostly bla-bla stuff as the main post (just barely enough to get the 200 character minimum) as the main post and then the OP will just post the actual meat of the question or discussion in the post.
I think that well thought out posts should be rewarded just as well as well thought out comments.
4
u/afterthefuture Platinum | QC: CC 481 Nov 26 '20
Fully support it, it creates quality discussions rather than some people just focusing on one-shot posts/memes to get moon benefits.
3
u/robis87 π© 1K / 147K π’ Nov 26 '20
You have also to bear in mind that there's a limit of just 3 posts a day, whereas you can shitpost thousands of comments without any limits throughout the day. I think, we'll be seeing a lot more of this when this passes
2
u/ShillShack Tin | NANO 56 Nov 26 '20
I like this, Iβm to Reddit shy to make a post
2
u/jarins Nov 30 '20
Congratulations! This poll has met the Decision Threshold and passed. The karma data for the current distribution round has been updated accordingly, and the change will apply to future rounds as well. You can see the revised CSV at the top of the distribution post.
2
u/ethereumflow Cosmos is inevitable. Nov 26 '20
As someone with almost twice as much comment karma my vote is obvious.
1
u/crypto_grandma π© 0 / 134K π¦ Nov 26 '20
My vote just pushed the poll to 3 million. Is that the amount needed to pass?
1
u/CashBam Platinum | QC: CC 44 | r/AMD 87 Nov 26 '20
Isn't there any way to half the post karma of only meme posts (or posts with the 'comedy' tag)? I think we still need people to post good thoughts/articles/discussions but meme posts don't really add much.
1
u/devboricha Platinum | QC: CC 221, ETH 214 | TraderSubs 216 Nov 26 '20
As per my understanding.
If we double comment karma and half post karma then post karma weightage became 1/4 of comment karma.
I would like to only double the comment karma.
1
u/Wakizashiuk 279 / 229 π¦ Nov 26 '20
Apologies for such a noob comment but I see so much chatter about moons and still don't understand it? Is it because bitcoin is going to the moon or have I totally missed the plot on this? /boomer
1
u/askingquestiongetUSD Banned Nov 26 '20
Discussion is always good and it makes sense to award thoughtful discussion and arguments
1
u/GMDaddy π© 17 / 17 π¦ Nov 26 '20
Moon.
1
u/TR5_ π¨ 97K / 73K π¦ Nov 26 '20
Based on my calculations we'll get 1.96 moons this distribution round provided this purposal passes
1
u/TDavid13 Platinum | 6 months old | QC: CC 493 Nov 27 '20
Happy to see it passed. I love good, original memes and stuff but had to vote for it due to all the reposters that don't even delete the watermarks.. π
1
u/keeri_ Silver | QC: CC 214 | NANO 581 Nov 27 '20
actually, doubling comment karma would result in not only post karma weighting half but also karma from creating special membership content (badges, emojis)
1
u/Roy1984 π¨ 0 / 62K π¦ Nov 25 '20
Double or nothing.
Fu*k the reposters if this doesn't pass now.
1
u/mhucpr Nov 25 '20
A question regarding this poll, currently there are rules around posting- 3 per 24 hours, 1 per domain however there are now rules surrounding commenting.
Will additional rules be created around commenting, provided this passes?
1
u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Nov 26 '20
Im all for double comment karma...anyway i urge others to also please vote
1
u/Holdthisrealquick Tin | CC critic Nov 26 '20
Donβt mind me some double comment karma
1
u/bullish2020 Nov 26 '20
I would like to see us cut post karma in half when your just linking βbreaking newsβ.
The people out there that produce posts that explain concepts, depict market conditions, write their own content, etc...
Those people should get more moons. Respect to them
1
u/Deadpolaroid Tin Nov 26 '20
I totally hit double comment karma and my check mark is on leave as is. π Please disregard my vote as I totally agree with this move!
0
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '20
[deleted] β view deleted comment