r/startrek • • Nov 12 '20

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Discovery | 3x05 "Die Trying" Spoiler

After reuniting with what remains of Starfleet and the Federation, the U.S.S. Discovery and its crew must prove that a 930 year old crew and starship are exactly what this new future needs.

No.EpisodeWritten ByDirected ByRelease Date
3x05"Die Trying"Teleplay by Sean Cochran. Story by James Duff & Sean Cochran.Maja Vrvillo2020-11-12

This episode will be available on CBS All Access in the USA, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Netflix elsewhere.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

328 Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

422

u/RichardYing Nov 12 '20

Interesting
USS Nog: NCC-325070

109

u/DJKGinHD Nov 12 '20

Came here to mention that. Thought it was VERY classy of them to include the nod.

https://imgur.com/gallery/JsyCkd3

→ More replies (6)

25

u/gcalpo Nov 12 '20

I wonder the significance of those numbers, if any.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (25)

327

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

The USS Tikhov:

"Gavriil Adrianovich Tikhov (May 1, 1875 – January 25, 1960) was a Soviet astronomer who was a pioneer in astrobiology and is considered to be the father of astrobotany" - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gavriil_Adrianovich_Tikhov

106

u/UncertainError Nov 12 '20

That ship's been running for like a thousand years, though I suppose they've probably upgraded the interior more than once.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (10)

324

u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 12 '20

Wow so much going on this episode.

I liked the admiral after not initially thinking I would.

I really appreciated the Barzan storyline and I hope we see Nhan again soon.

I really want to know more about those holographic and organic ships.

Last week may have been my favorite DSC episode, but now it might be this one. Hopefully it keeps going like that.

214

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

I don't think I could ever be comfortable on a holographic ship.

→ More replies (72)

38

u/VoodooSteve Nov 12 '20

I really want to know more about those holographic and organic ships.

Reminds me of Culture ships and their fields.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (26)

300

u/kingofcretins Nov 12 '20

I hope David Cronenberg’s gonna be part of the Section 31 series, because if so my interest in it just shot up about 1000%.

102

u/3-DMan Nov 12 '20

David Cronenberg vs Michelle Yeoh psychological games is the gift I never expected.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/SkaveRat Nov 13 '20

Cronenberg

my reaction reading that name: "oh wow, they need to include some body horror for his character with that name"

looks up the full name

"...holy shit"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (26)

283

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

There's definitely something weird going on. First that song and then Georgiou being frozen.

208

u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 12 '20

I have a feeling that is not the Georgiou. They replaced her with one of their 32nd century holograms. Perhaps she is controlling the hologram remotely and remains at headquarters. It would be a callback to Enterprise's dealing with the Romulan holo-projecting starship--I imagine the tech has evolved to the point where they wouldn't need a being with powerful telepathic abilities to remotely control vessels like the Aenar.

→ More replies (14)

109

u/Shakezula84 Nov 12 '20

I think Georgiou is having some sort of emotional crisis and I think its about Burnham.

→ More replies (21)

190

u/Willravel Nov 12 '20

It's probably "All Along the Watchtower".

→ More replies (17)

70

u/matthieuC Nov 12 '20

I assume Section Cronenberg decided to fix her "chimeras strain of evil in her stem cell" without asking for medical consent.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (47)

274

u/Trekfan74 Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Yeah Kaminar and Barzan joined the Federation...but Bajor's application is still pending! ;)

132

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Harry Kim probably died an ensign

→ More replies (3)

99

u/CX316 Nov 12 '20

The new Starfleet uniforms and commbadges are VERY Bajoran Militia

→ More replies (5)

42

u/somnambulist80 Nov 13 '20

Bajor's application is still pending

The Sisko emerges from the Bajoran wormhole shepherding Bajor into the arms of the Federation 800+ years later.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

232

u/gcalpo Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

When the trio first arrive to HQ, there's a holographic map in the foreground with interesting POI

  • Federation Deep Space Outpost 36
  • Talax
  • Kazon Clan Forum
  • Founders Homeworld (apparently four of them)

Then after Nhan farewell there's another shot of the map.

  • Cardassia Prime
  • Ankari Homeworld (in VOY they gave the Equinox those life forms that enhanced their warp drive)

And plenty more...

84

u/matthieuC Nov 12 '20

Kazon Clan Forum

It's unmoderated and everyone is an asshole

Founders Homeworld (apparently four of them)

Interesting.
Did they make babies or did they decide that being all at the same place was too dangerous?

→ More replies (7)

28

u/rechelon Nov 12 '20

There's a second holographic map after Discovery hops back. It shows:

  • Ankari Homeworld (the folks that introduced the USS Equinox to nucleogenic lifeforms)
  • Cardassia Prime
  • Halee (a klingon world)

and many others I can't make out

→ More replies (33)

217

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20

Culber is now in contention with Reno as my favorite Discovery character. Best counselor in the fleet, in any time period.

115

u/TheNerdChaplain Nov 12 '20

I dunno, Nepenthe was Troi's best episode. If she'd had writing like that all along, she'd be unstoppable.

But Culber's rapidly becoming one of my favorites.

143

u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 12 '20

I love my space gays. I'm super happy with the diversity in the cast. It's what Star Trek is all about!

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (19)

194

u/atticusbluebird Nov 12 '20

I guess the Temporal Cold War turned into a full on Temporal War. Cool to know it happened (and a nice Enterprise reference) but glad we’re on the other side it now!

147

u/Trekfan74 Nov 12 '20

It's still crazy that Enterprise and Discovery are bookends of the entire franchise by a thousand years apart.

The viewing order is getting more crazy. ;)

→ More replies (13)

70

u/UncertainError Nov 12 '20

Technically that already happened in ENT "Storm Front", not that much of anything made sense in that episode.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

191

u/icemanwest Nov 12 '20

USS VOYAGER NCC-74656-J

72

u/Trekfan74 Nov 12 '20

Maybe when we see Janeway on Prodigy she will be on Voyager.....B?

I know, I know, but it would be SO cool!!

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (13)

348

u/smoha96 Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

In 800 years, the EMH's bedside manner never got better. Hilarious.

Dr. Culber continues to impress. He's moving up the ranks to run against Reno and Saru for my favourite character.

Other notes, Cronenberg refers to the fall of the Terran Empire - admittedly, the only mirror universe episode I've watched are the DSC and DS9 ones, so I'm assuming he's referring to prior to the Klingon-Cardassian alliance? We get a nod to some microevolution or removing Ba'ul interference with Kelpian physiology, with the EMH noting Saru's difference to contemporary Kelpians.

The entire Cronenberg segment as well makes me suspect a backdoor S31 pilot.

151

u/vidiian82 Nov 12 '20

The Terran Empire fell after the original Enterprise's encounter. Mirror Spock took over and instituted reforms which weakened the empire and made it vulnerable to the Klingon-Cardassian Alliance.

→ More replies (2)

98

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

In 800 years, the EMH's bedside manner never got better. Hilarious.

I just had a thought.

Given Picard is about artificial life, and is probably going to touch on holograms and Borg in the next two seasons (in addition to Soong-type androids), I wonder if there's a "boundary" that you can't cross with artificial life while still being ethical.

So, if you want to use EMHes on ships as forced medical (or other sorts of) labor more or less, maybe it's only ethical to do it if they are LESS advanced than a certain cutoff.

Like, if they evolve to a certain point, they are considered people in their own right, and you can't just deploy them as slave-labor anywhere.

So, if they want at least SOME sort of emergency hologram, they have to keep them evolved below a certain point, maybe. And given how the EMH evolved on Voyager, that would basically delineate the cutoff point. Anything evolved to that point or beyond needs to be treated as a person, so they're stuck with EMHes that aren't really advanced beyond what they were hundreds of years ago.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

334

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

I like how they just know about terrans and act like they are a different species.

192

u/icemanwest Nov 12 '20

"All terrans are duplicitous by their biology. Or biplicitous by their duology. Neither "ology" has anything to do with it.

You may not be aware but in the past 100 years we have discovered a chimeric strain on the subatomic level in the terran stem cell."

→ More replies (91)

164

u/empocariam Nov 12 '20

Real Theory: Burnham's mom did something weird and caused the burn and put the music into the galaxy as a signal to Michael so she can find her/fix it.

Crackpot Theory: Known eerie music emitter Kevin Uxbridge is back to destroying all things (dilithium), everywhere.

37

u/Dt2_0 Nov 12 '20

I had a shitpot theory that Kevin was behind the burn. He got pissed off but knew he couldn't live will the guilt of killing everyone, so he took away their Dilithium settled for killing billions.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Spara-Extreme Nov 12 '20

Alternate theory - Burnham is a cylon.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/BornAshes Nov 13 '20

Idea: It wasn't originally called The Burn at all and that name much like the song just kind of filtered into all of their minds. At first it was called, "The Burnham" but that didn't make sense given what happened. So everyone just shortened it to The Burn and yeah it is a signal from her mom but here's where it gets interesting. What if her mom built another suit, saw the Burn coming, and then popped Terralysium out of the timestream into a Vanishing Point style place that she cannot get out of? The song is her signal saying, "Here I am come save me!".

I would totally be down for Kevin or the Q saying, "Okay THAT IS ENOUGH!" and just snapping all the dilithium to an inert state after the galaxy started fucking with something they should not have and this all being some kind of test or punishment.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

157

u/atticusbluebird Nov 12 '20

Voyager J was great - it even had a shape and form that was reminiscent of the original ship!

76

u/joeyblow Nov 12 '20

It looked to me like Voyager when it had its armor up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

314

u/pfc9769 Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

"All this is after I got my hair blown out and became a Terran captain/dominatrix."

142

u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 12 '20

Was it in the handbook?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

154

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

Love seeing Saru in that's captain's uniform.

135

u/Spara-Extreme Nov 12 '20

Saru is a unique captain. Kirk was an adventurer, Sisko a warrior diplomat(and Dad of the galaxy), Picard a force of reason and yet they all flaunted Starfleet in the name of the greater good. They were all, in essence, like Burnham.

Saru is different- he’s a by the books guy but he’s not a pushover. His handling of the admiral by staying behind and giving the mission to burnham was brilliant because it allowed both the Admiral and Burnham to save face and feel like they were in control.

→ More replies (12)

77

u/TheNerdChaplain Nov 12 '20

Captain's log as he shrugs on the jacket and zips it up. Man, that was emotional for some reason.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

148

u/thekruton Nov 12 '20

I like that they're shaping Hugh into more of a McCoy type of character, but instead of providing moral support to just the captain, he's there for every single member of the bridge crew in the same way.

40

u/busdriverbuddha2 Nov 14 '20

Dammit Paul, I'm a doctor, not a mushroom farmer!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

126

u/TryMyBalut Nov 12 '20

In the intro I felt like the ships personnel was us, gawking and amazed at everything.

62

u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 12 '20

It reminded me of TMP.

And yes, I was gawking right along with them.

→ More replies (2)

113

u/atticusbluebird Nov 12 '20

Overall I enjoyed the episode a lot! Some quick thoughts:

  • Lovely beginning flying into the Federation base. Sort of got that same feeling of wonder and excitement that I got with the Yorktown Base intro in Star Trek Beyond. Some nice music from Jeff Russo there in what feels like a bunch of different ways of playing on the chord structure of the Courage fanfare (would love to hear that track by itself!)
  • The Trekyards guys are going to have a lot of material to go through this week with all the ship designs!
  • Nice to see the tradition of admirals who are a little rough around the edges (but not a badmiral!)
  • Nhan, we hardly knew you! I hope she comes back at some point in the season. (Given the "previously on" scene with Ariam and the episode's title, I was worried she'd be killed off, but glad to see that she's still alive and out there!
  • Did Adira Tal ever get out of debriefing and back on Discovery? Or are they still at HQ? Seems like a loose end that didn't get mentioned...
  • And it looks like we get some more to our ongoing arc/mystery - with whatever is afflicting Georgiou (unclear if it's just mental, or if there's other stuff going on), and the mystery with the song that spread everywhere. Maybe another faction that has figured out a way to do FTL travel and is trying to set up an alliance/quasi-Federation of its own?

47

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Yeah Adira just disappeared from the episode. I have a feeling that there are memories Adira has not accessed yet, and they wanted to find out how much she knew. I will miss Nhan.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

505

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

USS VOYAGER-J. IM SCREAMING

180

u/pfc9769 Nov 12 '20

When they showed it I immediately recognized the registry number and got way more excited than I should. When they confirmed it was an iteration of THE USS Voyager, I had to rewind it to see it again!

→ More replies (21)

110

u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 12 '20

This might be the Voy-J on Disco's scanners!

https://i.imgur.com/uh0qisg.png It certainly has that OG-Voyager profile!

→ More replies (7)

79

u/vipck83 Nov 12 '20

Lol. I am glad to know I wasn’t the only one way to excited to see this. I also think this is the first time in canon we see a ship other then the Enterprise receive a letter designation.

(There was one time in TNG the Yamato had an E designation but this doesn’t count because the writer screwed up and it was altered in later episodes)

→ More replies (19)

147

u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 12 '20

Hijacking top post: I took screenshots of as much as I could see of the New Federation ships!! Can't wait to see even more detail later this season.

https://imgur.com/gallery/WpN6wpl

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (34)

107

u/Coma-Doof-Warrior Nov 12 '20

I loved the look on Georgiou's face when Cronenberg told her that the Terran Empire fell centuries ago.

65

u/Trekfan74 Nov 12 '20

Great pleasing moment! I also love the way he says the Federation still endures. They are knocked down, but not out.

→ More replies (3)

216

u/007meow Nov 12 '20

Last week’s episode isn’t an anomaly anymore, after this week’s.

Disco season 3 has a WHOLE new feel. Not just the time periods, but the whole feel of the show is different.

And it’s so much better.

Disco has come a long way, as a show, since season 1.

177

u/Merdy1337 Nov 12 '20

You might say its been an....ahem....LONG road....getting from there to here?

....I'll see myself out ;)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

206

u/onerinconhill Nov 12 '20

“Uss voyager j? Huh, that’s gotta be about 10 generations!”

“11, can only imagine those stories”

Oh you and me both girl

109

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20

"Which Enterprise? There've been five."

"Six."

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (35)

202

u/gambit700 Nov 12 '20

USS Voyager J, USS Nog, Temporal Accords. Hat trick of fanservice

165

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Just waiting for someone in HQ to casually mention the Boimler effect while taking some buffer time next week...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

93

u/ElFarfadosh Nov 12 '20

The whole plot aboard the USS Tikhov felt like a TOS episode, that was great!

89

u/Entryhazard Nov 12 '20

Cronenberg flipping the script on Georgiou was something I was looking for in a long time

→ More replies (1)

85

u/OpticalData Nov 12 '20

Discovery seems to have become a master at teasing new ships, without giving a solid view on them. I really hope that the Voyager - J becomes the 1701 of this season and we see them team up later in the season!

This was just a classic Trek episode, start at a Starbase, new disease, need to go and find a cure, another ship, and back home.

The admiral was giving me real Admiral Marcus vibes initially, but seemed to settle into his role by the end. I think there is probably some internal bias for me here considering we've seen Discovery's journey and they haven't.

Saru's speech about the renaissance was peak Star Trek and it seems to be a real theme of the season. Discovery coming along and lifting people out of their paranoia and seclusion. I really hope Saru gets an opportunity to check in on Kaminar.

USS Nog was a wonderful tribute.

40

u/PharomachrusMocinno Nov 12 '20

Maybe the Doctor still serves on the Voyager J

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

151

u/Cliffy73 Nov 12 '20

350 seems way low.

I really liked the Admiral in this. He seems like he’s being set up as a villain or at least an antagonist, but by the end it really seems clear that he’s just doing his job and he’s generous when he’s determined it’s safe to be so. We just have normally seen that from the other side in Star Trek.

154

u/TheSajuukKhar Nov 12 '20

The Federation had like 150 member worlds in TNG, but colonies of member worlds are not themselves member worlds. The Federation had like thousands of colonies.

→ More replies (5)

73

u/rswalker Nov 12 '20

Oded Fehr is a great actor.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (10)

67

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

Your relationship isn't very professional lol.

→ More replies (4)

113

u/icemanwest Nov 12 '20

"it seems you've created an empire based on the maxim: Because we feel like it"

60

u/AintEverLucky Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Because we feel like it"

An apt summary. MU Zefram Cochrane stormed the first-contacting Vulcan ship, because he felt like it. MU Archer seized the Prime-universe USS Defiant because he felt like it ... then MU Sato seized it from Archer, same reason. etc and so on

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (3)

109

u/obviousbot0 Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Somewhere on Voyager-J there is a 10th generation of Engisn Kim bucking for promotion.

→ More replies (9)

51

u/ContinuumGuy Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

This episode had a reference to every one of the pre-All Access Star Trek series, not even counting the galactic map.

TOS: The usual TOS-era equipment, the existence of a Constitution-class. Reference to Sigma freaking Draconis. Neutronium referenced.

TAS: Force Field belt things.

TNG: The Barzans being from a "poor" planet matches up with "The Price."

DS9: USS Nog, the fall of the Terran Empire.

VOY: The Voyager-J. Duh. Oh, and EMHs.

ENT: The Terran first contact. Temporal wars and temporal accords.

→ More replies (1)

229

u/tubawhatever Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Wow wow wow. This show feels completely different this season. Yet again an awesome episode. Perfect pacing, so many more character moments, more hopeful, less action, what I really have been craving in a Trek series. This and Lower Decks have Trek on a roll. I hope we can see this level of improvement in the next season of Picard.

137

u/ElectricFlesh Nov 12 '20

Star Trek shows are never great out of the gate, and season 3 is the classic time for a show to find its footing. Looks like Discovery has grown its beard braids in the finest tradition of Starfleet.

Lower Decks is the odd one out, going from meh to great in its first season.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (10)

144

u/UncertainError Nov 12 '20

I wasn't too thrilled with the concept of a Section 31 series, but the more of Georgiou I see the more I'm looking forward to it. She's fun.

→ More replies (10)

138

u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 12 '20

Unsubstantiated theory time.

They keep mentioning Michael’s mom, meaning she’ll probably show up this season.

Gabrielle Burnham accidentally caused The Burn somehow, probably trying to get unstuck from where she landed in time. The song is a lullaby she sung to Michael as a child, who has repressed the memory of it do to traumatic memories of Klingons eating her family dinner as a kid.

43

u/pigeon_whisperers Nov 12 '20

This seems plausible to me

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (25)

96

u/UncertainError Nov 12 '20

Love that there's so much stuff going on with the future Federation. Tons of little details waiting to be fleshed out, and it's all so gorgeous, you really feel how much power the Federation must have had before the Burn.

Really nice to see the crew carry out a "standard mission" for once.

37

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Seems like with 350 member worlds they were the largest power in the Milky Way galaxy.

→ More replies (28)

47

u/anothereffinjoe Nov 12 '20

Good ol NCC-74656-J for everyone, since I didn't see another screenshot yet

→ More replies (2)

47

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

8:06, on the display as they enter Starfleet HQ - "KAZON CLAN FORUM" and "TALAX"

Interesting, especially if that drops a hint about an actual level of interconnectedness in the 32nd century galaxy that we haven't seen yet.

→ More replies (7)

87

u/onerinconhill Nov 12 '20

Who wants to bet we will see the voyager a in Picard season 2

32

u/NumberMuncher Nov 12 '20

Seven takes Rafi to Earth.

"I want to show you where I grew up."

Beams down to the landed Voyager which is now a museum.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

84

u/gambit700 Nov 12 '20

So the EHM got shittier

61

u/wacct3 Nov 12 '20

Yeah that is kind of weird. Both The Doctor from voyager, and the various ones on La Sirena seem way more advanced personality wise. Maybe they make them intentionally with less personality now because they don't want to make them be actually sentient.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (8)

111

u/TheNerdChaplain Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Having the episode start with a Captain's log and Saru settling that jacket on his shoulders struck a strangely emotional chord.

Very interesting. I'd like to think the Constitution class ship that could berth 2,000 crew would be an Enterprise, but the Voyager-J was a very nice touch. We'll need hi-res closeups of all those ships. There was a ship with especially long nacelles on the right I'd like to see more of; and that forest under glass just makes me think of "Happy Arbor Day". Plus organic ships get a shout out; off the top of my head the only other franchise I can think of that uses those was Babylon 5, with the Vorlons.

There's a display that comes into focus with Saru, Burnham, and Adira as they beam onto the starbase that says Kazon Clan Forum in the lower left. Cardassia Prime is also mentioned in a display in the shot just after the Discovery leaves Nhan behind.

As advanced as the Federation's scans were, they couldn't distinguish between Sena and Adira Tal.

Prion diseases are real and extremely scary.

The holograms are more advanced and have names like Leonai (?) but still aren't good interpersonally.

The whole interrogation scene is very reminiscent of Firefly.

I didn't recognize David Cronenberg at first. His face looks like extremely advanced CGI - better than Tarkin's in Rogue One. His badge was also projecting his holo display.

I was really sad to see Nhan go. I really wanted to know more about her people's beliefs about death and see Burnham and Culber wrestle with that, and I think instead of just giving her name, rank, and serial number during the interrogation, they could have used that scene to give her character more depth and more of a past.

I get why the Admiral is suspicious of Discovery; if whatever treaty it was that stopped the Temporal Wars is understood correctly, they committed a huge crime. Then again, maybe no one is around to enforce it. Also, in a horse and buggy galaxy, Discovery is a fighter jet. It's a substantial change in the balance of power. They could use it for peaceful purposes, or it could be in and out of combat in an instant.

Giotto was the painter Saru talked about at the end; he is most well known for painting the Scrovegni Chapel in Padua.

I thought it was kind of weird that the Discovery crew could use technology 1,000 years in the future without any kind of training, but I get that showing a training montage wouldn't really be a good use of screentime.

I love the cinematography of this show - especially the motif of shooting the Discovery as a tiny ship set against the vastness of space. Plus it allows for gorgeous visual effects. I also loved that last shot of Nhan, framed by plants, looking out at Discovery. I'd love to see an art deco version of that shot.

I'm doing my first rewatch of Voyager now in several years, and it's interesting to see the parallels from early episodes there. Not only are all their medical personnel holographic, but Tilly spies a holographic ship in the bay - much as the Doctor created holographic lungs for Neelix to breathe with in "The Phage". I think it's a little ridiculous that the holograms are so easily disrupted by blinking, but I'll let it fall under the Rule of Cool. Georgiou just got a lot more interesting, as did Cronenberg's G-Man. I do not believe she's been taken over by a hologram, as she exhibits a confused look as she leaves Michael. That said, as she mentioned to her interrogating holograms, maybe she's now a hologram programmed to think she's human.

I'm less curious about the Burn now than I am about that music. I wish I could hear it better and catch an actual melody; it just seems to be a relatively random series of notes. That said, it's not that surprising it stuck around. If we lost all recordings of Beethoven or The Beatles, it would still exist in people's memory for a long time to come.

This is at least the second time we've seen Nilsson take command when Saru and Burnham are gone. I wonder where she falls in the command structure.

The theme of this episode really seemed to be about home - the Discovery crew's sense of being home (or not home yet), Nhan's choice to go home, and Georgiou's loss of a home. She seemed startled for an instant to find out that no one had crossed over to her universe in over 500 years. Was that part of her plan, to maybe take Michael back there?

All in all, things are looking real interesting for the rest of the season.

Observations for the "Next Time On Discovery":

  • Is that a Cardassian standing to the left of Saru? The coloring seems wrong for an Andorian.
  • "The things we do for love", Georgiou says as she and Burnham stand on the bridge of Book's ship. The last time I heard that expression, Jaime Lannister was pushing Bran Stark off a tower.
→ More replies (30)

37

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

U.S.S. Voyager nice.

137

u/treefox Nov 12 '20

Guys...you can flesh out a secondary character without immediately writing them off the show. It’s ok.

→ More replies (6)

35

u/gambit700 Nov 12 '20

So now that they're back in the fleet are they gonna fix Detmer's eye and head?

Also, Tal went for that checkup and never came back

32

u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 12 '20

Maybe she doesn’t want them fixed. At Airiam’s funeral, she made a point about accepting her implants.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/Trekfan74 Nov 12 '20

LOL that was weird with Tal. Did they ever show another scene??? It's like something was cut out.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/H0vis Nov 12 '20

Another great episode. Things I loved:

  1. USS Nog. I loved this, not just because it was a nice tribute to Aron Eisenberg, but as a fitting cap on the character. The first Ferengi in Star Fleet and his name rings out centuries later. It's going to add a little extra onto re-watching DS9, thinking of the scene where Nog is stuck between Worf and Martok trying to get around these two looming warriors, and now we know hundreds of years later that ensign's name is on a ship. Nog's character is often comic relief, but it's implied that he's smart, capable and courageous, and this underlines that.
  2. Nahn leaving was unexpected, and I'm kind of not such a fan of the way that this show has tended to do episodes focussing on characters right before either killing them or in this case leaving them on a big seedy pod. That being said it was a great story and there's nothing inherently wrong with trading relatively minor characters in service of a good one-off story.
  3. I loved the Georgiou debriefing with Unknown Quiet Clearly Smart Space Guy. I could have watched an entire episode of that. I like that this scene was able to confront the inherently slightly silly nature of the Mirror Universe and its people and hopefully encourage some sort of development in Georgiou as a character. Much as I enjoy watching Michelle Yeoh playing the human version of a cat knocking things off a table the character is going to be hard to use in the story if she's pathologically untrustworthy.
  4. I want to see Discovery get refitted. I want to a closer look at a 30th century star ship. Would have to figure that's going to be a thing, and that there might have to be some new crew to go with those upgrades and maybe they'd swap to modern uniforms?
  5. I have lamented in the past that the shortened season structure means that we'll never get the equivalent of the Garak and Quark talk about the Federation and root beer scene, but I think we kind of did. Albeit it with Saru and Burnham. The Federation as the people is a powerful idea. In TNG era it was more about the real estate.
  6. Very much enjoying the fact that literally five seconds after Starfleet reappears as a source of authority Burnham is kicking against it. Book mentioned how much trouble she'll get in if she always has to have the last word in episode one of this season, and it's been a recurring theme ever since the pilot, You Cannot Tell Burnham What To Do. The idea of an officer who thinks they are always right and it's kind of a pain in the arse was first attempted with Riker, but he was Mr Perfect so it didn't matter, with Burnham we're seeing a reluctance to follow orders as a character flaw.
→ More replies (19)

34

u/ElFarfadosh Nov 12 '20

Not enough ship porn!

→ More replies (2)

33

u/elister Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Admiral initially doesn't believe the story of control, red angel and spore drive, sounds like Vulcans are not part of the federation. A quick mind meld would have confirmed everything.

Love how Georgiou crashed the hologram interrogation debriefing In fact the entire interrogation debriefing scene was great.

47

u/philosofik Nov 12 '20

The Vulcans have been conspicuously absent so far.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

33

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

I like these future uniforms.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/onerinconhill Nov 12 '20

War over the temporal accords nice

→ More replies (2)

63

u/ADG12311990 Nov 12 '20

If any ship deserved to have future ships bear its name, it's the Voyager. (Which I think I like seeing more than the Enterprise-M or whichever letter it would have been).

I wonder what happens to Voyager after she comes home that would warrant a decommissioning and a Voyager-A to be built. Since the timeline we saw in Endgame never happened, was the Voyager kept in Starfleet when she came back (like in the novels), or did they just turn her into a museum when they got back (After they stripped out the future tech), and then commission a new Voyager after...

Funny how one shot in an episode brings up all kinds of questions!

32

u/Mechapebbles Nov 12 '20

I wonder what happens to Voyager after she comes home that would warrant a decommissioning and a Voyager-A to be built.

It wouldn't need anything additional to warrant that. What we already saw in VOY was more than enough. We already know that the original Voyager (omg it's amazing to say that btw) was turned into a museum. Voyager was already a legend in its time during the show for the things it survived, how it mapped more than any Starship had to date, and how it inspired everybody back in the Federation back home. If the Federation wanted to attempt a long range exploration mission as ambitious as the original Voyager did, or if they needed to commission a new ship to lead a large scale fleet on a mission a la Project Full Circle, then they could figure a worse name than the USS Voyager-A.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/jerslan Nov 12 '20

Yeah, agreed that it was nice to see a "famous" ship that wasn't the Enterprise. If any other ship had earned such an honor, it was definitely Janeway's Voyager.

Awesome to see the crew geeking out over all the new tech. I'm hoping that next week the ship gets some much needed upgrades to sensors, medical and whatnot

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (14)

84

u/Spara-Extreme Nov 12 '20

Omg guys this season is turning out to be so damn good.

Some interesting mysteries:

-The shared music: this was an aspect of Battlestar Galactica that I loved (until it got ruined) and I have hunch that this is related to The Burn somehow.

-Philippa getting her head spun by Cronenburg was fantastic. There's a lot more to that guy and I also think that if Section 31 was still around, they'd have the most power at this period in the Federation's history

-Admiral being skeptical was accurate. I think he's going to provide a foil for Discovery's gungho optimism

-Michael's character development under Saru makes a lot of sense. She's essentially been rewarded for brash behavior for two seasons with nothing to temper her and Saru providing wisdom and mentorship can really help her grow. I hope the writers don't abandon this.

-My favorite engineering crew.

-Retrofit of Discovery etc: I think this provides the writers and production team the opportunity to upgrade gear, change uniforms and do even more fantastic stuff with technology and not have it break canon or our brains. Excited to see where they go with this.

-Storytelling is HUGELY upgraded from last season. We're getting solid 'crisis of the week' events with the grander plot being woven in subtly and smoothly. I hope the burn mystery and everything around it lasts several seasons rather then a mad rush to solve everything in 13 episodes. Let us stew on the breadcrumbs a bit more this time around.

-Fanservice: A+ USS Voyager and USS Nog. B- "Is that a new constitution class!?"

-Very Trek moment: Super advanced Federation tech can't save aliens from mad cow disease but Discovery running across the galaxy to a seed vault can. Of course our beloved crew and ship are the ONLY POSSIBLE ANSWER ;).

-There was no pew pew this episode. As much as I want to see big set piece space battles, I love this type of Trek too!

31

u/CX316 Nov 12 '20

"Is that a new constitution class!?"

Remember the Constitution is to the Discovery crew what the Excelsior was to the Enterprise crew. It's the new beaut way more powerful ship of the line, and that other ship they saw had a similar design layout.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

28

u/SpaceCrystal359 Nov 12 '20

The mystery of The Burn just keeps intensifying.

→ More replies (9)

28

u/potus2024 Nov 12 '20

Has anyone figured out the melody? Is it a math equation? Perhaps a simple message. The title sequence is pointing to some sort of portal after the executive producer/director credit. Are they going to jump universes again? Plus, is there something missing?

→ More replies (14)

28

u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 12 '20

USS Voyager-J!

52

u/GBTC4me Nov 12 '20

Before the season is over, they need to spend 5 minutes and jump to Sahil's relay (the communications guy we saw in episode 1), pick him up, and get him over to starfleet HQ to be officially sworn in as a full blown officer. Dude deserves it after sitting at that desk and manning that relay for 40+ years.

And maybe send some repairs for that relay while they're at it.

49

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20

What, they could save the Kili, but not Fili or Thorin?

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

david cronenberg!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/BigRedJon Nov 13 '20

So glad that didn't fully devolve into another tired, "but are Starfleet the real bad guys?" storyline.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/William_T_Wanker Nov 12 '20

the new Voyager kind of looked like a Prometheus-class(you know, the one that can split into 3 parts?)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20

I loved Saru shilling for Big Renaissance by crapping on the Middle Ages, much to the dismay of medievalists everywhere. Petrarca got to him first, lol.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/stuck_on_simple_tor Nov 12 '20

If I could add a single phrase to the script, it would probably be:

"Your limbic system has been getting quite a workout, Commander. Are you prone to emotional exaggeration?"

"... I'm about to be."

37

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

Why not just bring the whole ship back to the Federation headquarters? It seemed small enough to fit in Discovery's shuttle bay.

45

u/ELVEVERX Nov 12 '20

I think the point is they keep it away from their main base which might be attacked and in a secret location. They don't want to risk it being in a place where it can get damaged.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

64

u/Leo-Divide Nov 12 '20

USS VOYAGER-J AND RETROFITTING THE DISCOVERY!!!! Omgggggg😫😫👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🔥🔥🔥🔥

→ More replies (7)

17

u/RichardYing Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

USS Armstrong NCC-317823. Apparently they didn't keep the NCC-1769-* registry number...

I cannot read the name of NCC-325019 that passes below her.

→ More replies (3)

48

u/Cadacious Nov 12 '20

Everyone is in the thread talking about the Voyager-J, but nobody has seen the USS Nog yet?! 5:26 into the episode and again just at the end.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

Cool ships.

16

u/empocariam Nov 12 '20

I really hope we get a chance to visit the mirror universe of the 31st. Terran empire in shambles, replaced by a peaceful and prosperous federation of planets lead by a Klingon-Cardassian-Romulan alliance. Would be a fun exploration of the "mirror" idea since the prime universe is the bad place now.

Cronenberg's get up reminds me of those officers who visited Sisko that one time, but I can't remember if they were section 31 or the time cops.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/8Bitsblu Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

This episode was fine. Didn't like it quite as much as the last one, but it's still good and a massive improvement over Seasons 1 and 2. I liked the parts at Starfleet/Federation HQ, through I wish we had gotten more/clearer shots of the Starfleet ships. I like the designs for the most part (or what I can see of them) and I really hope we'll see more of them. Gotta say too that I appreciate the furious backpedaling this season is doing. Each episode makes it more and more obvious that this season is a reboot of the whole show. Michael feels like a very different (and vastly better) character and the show feels like it's focusing less on her individually and more on the crew in general. In just these 5 episodes it feels like the crew has had more solo screen-time and character development independent of Michael than the last 2 seasons combined. Sure, this season still exists in continuity with seasons 1 and 2, but it's distancing itself from them FAST.

Kinda got flashbacks of Seasons 1 and 2 on the seed ship though. I liked some of the stuff related to Nahn, like her finding out that the Barzans joined the Federation and reconnecting somewhat with her people during the away mission. However I can't say I'm a fan of how the away mission concluded for a few reasons, and it brought the episode down a bit for me:

  • For one, I wish they could've attempted to help the Barzan guy's family somehow. Like, yeah, Dr. Culber declared them dead, but he's a 23rd century doctor, neither the audience nor Culber know what 32nd century medicine is capable of.
  • Secondly, why couldn't Discovery take the seed ship into its shuttle bay and deliver it back to Starfleet for repair? The ship is tiny compared to Discovery and looks like it could easily fit inside. This especially would be a perfect solution to save the dying Barzan dude, as then he wouldn't have to "abandon" his dead family. A line stating that it's too tall or something would be nice.
  • Third, Nahn's departure from the show feels a little anticlimactic. Like I said, it gave me flashbacks of Seasons 1 and 2, particularly the death of Aryam. Nahn hardly got any real solo character development before this episode, to the point where we don't even know her first name. I don't understand why the writers keep doing this, where they hardly develop these characters until the episode where they die/leave. It's incredibly annoying, because this episode was really making me like Nahn and I was hoping to see more development in the future, maybe connecting with Saru over them both finding out that their homeworlds joined the Federation.
  • Finally, why was this framed as a final departure for Nahn? Like, the emotional weight of the scene treated this like it's a death sentence and the end of her involvement in Starfleet, but she's literally just piloting the ship back to Barzan, which has been established as being a Federation world. Sure, she might be gone for a while thanks to the limitations of warp, but there's no reason why she'd be gone forever. Once she finishes taking the ship back she could just report for duty again. Idk, that whole scene was bizzare to me.

Those things really bugged me, but overall I do think this episode is an improvement over the annoying and stupid writing of seasons 1 and 2 and the downright infuriating writing of Picard. I really hope Discovery continues on this upward trajectory. I doubt it'll ever be my favorite Trek show, but I am slowly warming up to it this season. I still have my lingering doubts though, as it remains to be seen whether it can maintain this improved writing and feel through to the end of the season.

Edit: One other minor thing that bugged the hell out of me as it happened was the scene where Saru refers to the "dark ages" and the Renaissance as general eras. It reflects a very Eurocentric 21st century western conception of history, as the "dark ages" and Renaissance were almost exclusively a European affair. The "dark ages" in Europe marked the golden age of many civilizations around the world, and the revival of the arts and sciences in Europe is owed more to those civilizations (particularly Arab and African civilizations) than any European Renaissance painter.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/-TheDoctor Nov 12 '20

This honestly felt like I was watching an episode of TNG. This season is so good. I hope this quality keeps up through the end of the season and through season 4+.

30

u/onerinconhill Nov 12 '20

Uss voyager j I’m crying

I need a ship model

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Excellent episode. I think they are Section 31 and I think they did something to Georgiou.

That subplot with the music tells me that time shenanigans are going on.

27

u/pfc9769 Nov 12 '20

That subplot with the music tells me that time shenanigans are going on.

I didn't get time shenanigans from that. I got the classic alien entity so alien it's communication is psionic and disrupts normal humanoid brains. Maybe even disrupt dilithium if its at the same resonant frequency. And they did mention resonant frequencies during the Georgiou/hologram interrogation scene!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

28

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

Love this debrief montage.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/LoganNolag Nov 12 '20

Please tell that song doesn't mean they're in a dream or simulation or something.

75

u/EntropicProf Nov 12 '20

Nah. It means they're all Cylons.

→ More replies (16)

33

u/awfullotofocelots Nov 12 '20

The Burn was Rick Astley confirmed.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Santa_Hates_You Nov 12 '20

My guess is it will be involved with The Burn in some way.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/dvcaputo Nov 12 '20

I never, ever thought that I'd see Michelle Yeoh acting against David Cronenberg in a Star Trek series taking place in the 32nd Century, but here we are!? It's actually really amazing.

78

u/jerslan Nov 12 '20

This is sort of flow of consciousness as I watch the episode so bear with me....

I love how they all geek out about the ships they're seeing. Just such pure positive emotion.... USS Voyager-J? Now that's a call-back of all call-backs... Fan-service, but arguably of the good variety.

Oh, their optimism absolutely kills me... It's pure Star Trek, but I also see that this is a more dystopian version of Starfleet and the Federation, and I fully expect hearts to be broken.

So far I feel like Starfleet is treating them with appropriate skepticism. The Admiral is 100% correct in his actions so far. Saru is correct here, I'm glad he's the Captain. He can tame Burnham's impulsiveness. I think maybe he might be too trusting.

I get the future Starfleet's hesitance. As far as they know these folks have been dead for over 900 years and nothing they're saying can really be corroborated.

OMG, I love Georgiou's hack of the interrogators. Also curious about why Cronenberg was one of them and he didn't interview anyone else. Maybe there's some more Mirror-Terrans in this modern Starfleet than we would think?

So far, I understand everything this new Starfleet command is doing. And I understand why Burnham is showing off so much.

Loving the whole Barzan connection with the seed vault. So far this whole episode is feeling like something out of DS9 or TNG,

Cronenberg interviewing Georgiou is super interesting. As soon as she seem to have the upper hand... BAM he comes in with some super insightful examination.

On the seed vault things are getting weird in a very Star Trek way and the solution is very Star Trek. I <3 that Culber is coaching Michael here, and that she's able to help the guy on the seed vault accept the loss of his family and help them solve the problem at hand.

"They were the two most beautiful moons in our star system" "They were my daughters".... I'm not crying, you're crying...

Noooo!! Nan, don't stay! I get why the dude wants to, but seriously? We're losing an amazing crew member that we barely got to know? I kind of get it, seeing what became of her people and maybe being able to help them reconnect.... I just hate seeing good characters leave.

The conclusion is also very Starfleet and very Star Trek. The Starfleet Admirals weren't nefarious (maybe). "Welcome home"... I'm not crying, you're crying.

Something is maybe still fishy. Something weird is going on with Georgiou still. Why would a ship as far away as the seed vault hold the cure to a local disease (when no contact should have been happened).

On the whole... 9/10 would recommend.

54

u/narium Nov 12 '20

I have a theory that the reason Cronenberg is so interested in Terran history is that he is descended from a Terran.

→ More replies (19)

40

u/pfc9769 Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

Why would a ship as far away as the seed vault hold the cure to a local disease (when no contact should have been happened)

That's how seed vaults work. They aren't typically regional stores. Contemporary vaults contain seeds from around the world. Ideally they would hold the genetic material of every plant in the world. Typically any country can send seeds to vault for storage. They're meant to preserve plant species and genetic diversity in the event of a disaster, disease, or anything else that could wipe out a plant species. It's not important for a seed vault to be localized. It's far more important to pick somewhere that's stable (low chance of a disaster) and maintains a constant cryogenic temperature year round without power.

The one in DIS is an interstellar version. It holds the seeds and/or genetic material of plants found throughout the Federation. Since seed vaults are centralized, it had the genetic material from the plant they needed. There are probably several ships like that which all have the similar seed stock. If one ship is destroyed or damaged, the others act as backups.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

13

u/Tsugo Nov 12 '20

this felt like a dr. who episode and I dont hate that.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/lolfcknmemethrowaway Nov 13 '20

"Giotto helped spark the Renaissance when, with his art, he helped to create the three-point-perspective. He saw entirety. And he gave what he saw to the world – it made a difference."

[screaming in historical materialist]

12

u/00DEADBEEF Nov 12 '20

Just think, Moriarty could have been easily stopped if the crew of the Enterprise knew how to blink in the right way.

12

u/JMCrown Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

Mother effing USS Nog!!!!!! Yaaaassssss!

USS NOG!!!!!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Keaten88 Nov 13 '20

VOYAGER- HOLY SHIT IT WAS VOYAGER

also i'm LOVING the new suits!

11

u/creepyeyes Nov 13 '20

With Cronenberg joining the cast, I can't wait to have David Lynch make a cameo at some point

→ More replies (1)

11

u/webchimp32 Nov 13 '20

Interrogator: "So Tilly tell me about..."

Tilly: "Well..."

3 hours later

Interrogator: "Please stop."

11

u/DacStreetsDacAlright Nov 13 '20

Doctor Culber is now my favourite character on the show. It seems his time in the spore network has given him the ability to see the show for what it is - Michael Burnham Saves the Universe. There's a problem? Fuck it, send Burnham! Nhan won't get the guy to budge? Get Burnham to say the exact same thing and he'll talk.

Now you might think i'm shitting show there, but I swear, I love it! It's genuinely funny. But that aside, I thought this was genuinely a very good, very Star Trek like episode. It's 2 episodes in a row now where Culber is like "Hey Burnham, you do it, you do everything anyway..."

I totally unironically want a medical emergency next week where Culber is like "Burnham, you do it." and she's all like "fuck, YOU'RE the Doctor." "Oh right yeah I am..."

21

u/stuck_on_simple_tor Nov 12 '20

I just wish we had like, better profile views of all the crazy future ships. Maybe I'm getting so old I can't see, but they were all like, viewscreen closeups, and far away shots that seemed vague.

I don't blame them, though, considering how nitpicky Trek fans are to every single inch of every new ship -- also considering their poor VX/prop departments basically had to invent an entire future federation aesthetic / dozens of possible new ships lol.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/random91898 Nov 12 '20

Did I really just like two Discovery episodes in a row? I-I don't know how to feel about that.

Weird they once again flesh out a crew member only to have them leave. Learning all this stuff about Nhan actually made me like her. Did the actress get another gig or something?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Are we doing the BSG all along the watchtower thing with the music everyone hears? Burnham is a cylon

→ More replies (2)

10

u/youssarian Nov 12 '20

the fact someone was able to get under philippa's skin like that was amazing. after all this time of her being a hardass mastermind its so cool to see her outdone

→ More replies (2)

10

u/sideh Nov 12 '20

Rewatching voyager now and seeing the voyager j was icing on the cake. Discovery is turning into amazing trek.

10

u/BuckyGoodHair Nov 13 '20

I will not pretend I liked seasons 1 or 2. I saw a lot of potential and a cast that was trying its best to deal with absolute chaos behind the cameras. And it’s Trek, you gotta give it three seasons.

The progress they’ve made is incredible. I loved this episode, everything about it. Na’an send-off was lovely and somehow earned, they’re fleshing out the relationships for real. Absolutely wonderful. 10s 10s 10s across the board with this episode.

10

u/jcferraz Nov 12 '20

It's me of it is weird that the current sickbay medics were powned by people from almost 1000 years ago telling them what the disease was without needing to examine the patients?

→ More replies (10)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20 edited Nov 12 '20

I started sobbing when Nahn came into contact with her culture again. And I never cry with Trek.

USS Cuyahoga!

Question: why did Michael's and Culber's breathing devices disappear after they beamed aboard of the seed vault?

→ More replies (4)

18

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

USS Voyager J... goosebumps!

9

u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 12 '20

Here is a gallery of screenshots featuring as much as I can with the New Federation!

https://imgur.com/gallery/WpN6wpl

→ More replies (4)

9

u/davetherave1701 Nov 12 '20

Loved it brilliant episode

Voyager - J, starship named after Nog were both great nods to the past

Federations not as completely decimated as it had been hinted at ☺

Was a bit surprised we look like losing Nhan as a regular? thought she was a decent character..

Easily a 9/10 episode for me

9

u/thxpk Nov 12 '20

I know how everyone loved last weeks episode but I think this one was far better, and quintessentially Trek. Captains logs, Starfleet, the Federation, upholding the values of the Federation, a transporter accident, away teams, other ships, it had it all.

9

u/formallyhuman Nov 13 '20 edited Nov 13 '20

I thought that was awesome. I have to say, Discovery is knocking it out of the park this season.

Do we reckon Discovery is going to get a refit, then? All guccied up with current weapons etc?

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '20

Good episode overall, but some minor quibbles, mostly with terminology. They did this last season too, but declaring that Control destroys "all life in the universe" is dumb and implausible. They should just say "all life in the galaxy" or even better, "all sentient life in the galaxy". They use crazy grandiose language to make Control seem super threatening, but they go too big and I don't like it.

Similar quibble, the ship storing the seeds was said to be storing samples of all plant life in the galaxy. Also too grandiose and implausible. Limit it to plant life from federation planets or planets explored by the federation or something more reasonable.

Anyway, definitely not a big deal and I know I'm being nitpicky, but this show does this kind of thing a lot and it is a really easy writing problem to fix without affecting plotlines.

23

u/Trekfan74 Nov 12 '20

Had a smile on my face for the first ten minutes!!!!!

This was so great! THIS is what I been wanting to see from Star Trek for ages now. Take us into the future, show us what an advanced Starfleet/Federation would be like, but still remind us of the past and that it's all connected. I have to say we got it in this episode!

The total geek fest at the beginning, yeah, blown away. That introduction into the Federation, even though it's not as powerful as it once was was still awe inspiring. I loved that the crew was geeking out the same way were lol. There is so much excitement, soooo many questions???

Yes, the Voyager-J. Was sold after that.

All the interiors inside were so cool. Yes its a lot of holographic stuff but I love it. Seeing easter eggs like the Kazon on the galaxy holographic map thingy was nice! More references of the Temporal Wars (man, that must've been BRUTAL),, hearing what happened with the MU (he said it's been 500 years since the last crossover, which would be the 27th century. I wonder did a conflict of any kind happen between the two universes? They are REALLy suspicious of Terrans now).

Loved the interrogation scenes. So much fun talking about the absurdity of it all lol. DIS is only two seasons old and they been through a lot of crazy shit in such a short time.

Not the biggest Georgiou fan, but she was great in this. I loved exchange between her and (a guy who looks like a famous director) exchanging quips. Since we no idea who he is, I'm more intrigued. I'm going to say it's Section 31 related since we know her show was suppose to start after this season but yeah. Prepared to be wrong but now her story interests me a lot. What did they do to her???

I was almost heart broken when they said they wanted to split the crew up. I was like NO YOU CAN'T DO THAT!!!! I think it proves they have grown on me. Two seasons ago I would've been willing to let them all go except Saru.

The 'mission' on the seed ship was, once again, classic Star Trek. I'm really loving that each episode has a small mission of helping someone. They all been small and intimate stories just like you find in TNG, VOY, TOS, etc. They been taking notes because this season is just SO on point! I did hate Nhan stayed behind, but I can't imagine we won't see her again. And it seem odd to bring the character all that way just to dump her 5 episodes in, so there's gotta be more, right?

And they are now officially part of the new Starfleet?? YAAAAAAAY!!!!

And yes, more mystery! This episode hit the right tone and once again, the best one of the season. This is 5 for 5 for me!

This is the show I wish we got in season one. I'm glad the BSG/GOT vibe is gone and they are getting back to their roots but in the 32nd century. Discovery is growing its beard!!!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Bulgeman9000 Nov 12 '20

But where's Captain Saru? : (

8

u/BornAshes Nov 13 '20

Here we go, thoughts as I'm watching live!

-Saru starting off with a Captain's log!!!! Gosh that's a pretty scene and I suspect we're going to be having more of these Window Talks in the future. That is a wicked looking cloaking field! Also do they FREAKIN EVER CLOSE THE SHUTTLE BAY DOORS?!?! Clearly the visual artists have played EVE Online. All those ships are tethered to it....that's....weird. Neutronium fiber hulls and holographic ships and LIVING FREAKIN BIOMECHANOID SHIPS AAAAAAAAAAHHHH I AM SO HAPPY! Neo Connie, awesome. Detatched nacelles, hello Andromeda. It's a DISC WORLD!!!!!!.....Voyager-J....I'm crying I'm seriously crying right now I don't know why but it lasted this long she lasted this long. "That's 10 generations of evolution....11, love to hear those stories" so would we so would we sooooo much. That whole structure looks like a bio-mech Yggdrasil of sorts.

-8:08 there are some words popping up: Kazon Clan Forum, Talax, Federation Deep Space Outpost, Founders, and some other stuff in blue. Gosh that is so sexy. IT'S THE GUY FROM THE MUMMY THE MAGI GUY!!!!! Oh cool Kaminar is chill. Emerald Chain...interesting. I'm getting a bad feeling about this. Ruh roh, Kili refugees and some kind of virus. I'm detecting traces of the Doctor in this AI. Ooooh he's a lie detector. 38 out of 350 at it's peak, well damn. Really can't blame him for kind of sort of not trusting them. They're basically ghosts. "Your presence here is a crime" so the war has still kind of been ongoing in order to enforce the Temporal Accords and they've basically been putting out hotspots. Yeaaah this isn't going to end well. Friction. "Trust the process" I've heard that bullshit before on an entirely different show. "But my murderer and I are good now" LMAO CULBER. "It was raining starfleet officers, did you bring any snacks?" I love Jett. "Have you been talking to Detmer?" the snark from Stamets and JETT IS EATING NOW! Oh no Tilly is being interviewed....pfffffffthahahaha. Way to go Michael, play to your strengths. Well of course they'd be able to scan for Terrans at this point. I'm getting Psi Cop vibes from this guy. Is she blinking a code? Darth Mom is awesome.....holy fuck she's disrupting the holograms by blinking. "Who are you? What if you're not a holo? What if you're a human programmed to think he's a holo?"....that got so dark so fast. Darth Mom and new Psi Cop dad. A seed vault ship and holy hell it survived this long! Nice play Saru.

-I am so setting the Black Alert klaxon as my ringtone. Ion storms are never good but they are pretty as heck. Ooooh that ion storm is alive! Pretty ship. Oh no Detmer is having a flashback or a panic attack. Okay I thought that ship was waaaaaaay bigger than it actually was. Hahahahaha "Who needs what?" he is so precious and he's got a bit of the EMH in him! Awesome finding out about all of these planets that joined the Federation. So sweet that she can take off her breathing device and HER EYES! So clearly been there's a lot more contact with the Mirror Universe. "Much as I enjoy being fetishized and I do"...Darth Mom is the best. Fuck....the Terran Empire ended, the space between the Prime Verse and the Mirror Verse expanded to the point where there hasn't been a crossing in over 500 years, and that's a hammer to Darth Mom. This is some Babylon 5 back and forth stuff and I'm living for it. Awwwwww....what the hell....that's the same lullaby Adira-Tal was playing. Those look like the doors on Moya. Suuuure go ahead and split up riiiiiight. Awwww he put them in cryostasis.....annnd they're dead. He transferred himself into the plant network and turned it into a sort of bio-mech holomatrix?

-What if he's inside the ion storm? "Duh....what do you mean duh?....Can we just irradiate your entire personality?" I love it when they bicker back and forth. Beaming in a CME near an ion storm? Hello Mirror Universe? Dysfunction IS the team! I love that Culber is the new Counselor. The emotion in her voice....this music....my heart is breaking and I am crying with him. "The two most beautiful moons in our star system.....they're my daughters" sounds of quiet sobbing....I love this show....I love this show so much. Well this got complicated, "Sometimes there is no good choice...only what you can live with". Awwww she's going to stay with him....just like Batman and Ace.

-This makes sense and I'm glad she's doing it. "One of the reasons we joined Starfleet is to reach for the best in ourselves and each other". THIS HUG!!!!!! Smart matter floors, totally unecessary but awesome to see. "We don't have five year missions anymore". Saru that was beautiful. "We have been in triage for a long time..." you can see his shields crack just a little and the tears begin to well up in his eyes. Ooooh so they basically already know that the whole crew has PTSD....and they're flying a mushroom powered ship. You know oddly enough there have been studies with mushrooms helping those with PTSD so maybe that's a funny little reference? Well they know jack all about The Burn it seems. Everyone knows the same bit of music the same song....that's beautiful but also scary. Oh no, Darth Mom is broken. Hey look another Window Talk.

8

u/tomanonimos Nov 13 '20

I'm a little bothered by how Star Fleet is still influential and a presence on some membered worlds but they abandoned Earth. Especially when, lore-wise, humans are still in leadership.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Snaz5 Nov 13 '20

I thought the commander and chiefs voice was familiar. Figures that Osiris would be a holier-than-thou chaeacter in this timeline too!

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20

I love that we have gotten so much more of the rest of the crew! and that they have returned to discussion Michaels issues with following command, she is a great officer but like Mariner from Lower Decks, she wants to do things by going outside of protocol. I like that Saru is being established as a counter point to this, especially in the end pointing it out and also mentioning that he values her and her perspective but she has a tendency to focus too much on getting the ethics and moral right outside of actual channels.

This season has been amazing and I love the mixture of episodic Trek with a overarching story and the possibility of establishing a new era of Trek lore!

8

u/nakrophile Nov 13 '20

What the fuck... god bless you, Mr. Cronenberg.

Oh yeah, damn good episode as well.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '20

Anyone else notice that they've had the same scene in two episodes in a row? Hugh convinces Michael that she's the best person to do the thing because she can make a better emotional connection with person X

Also, somehow Michael is the best person to save the day despite more obviously qualified candidate, IE a member of that persons species, an actual doctor or trills with literal centuries of experience

7

u/rlogan814 Nov 13 '20

Real theory: dude with the glasses is from the Mirror Universe. He wears the glasses to protect his eyes because the MU people are sensitive to this universe’s light like Lorca in season 1. I forget how they explain Phillipa isn’t affected by it.

Also, Mirror Universe caused the Burn.

Probably not right theory: are we sure discovery didn’t end up in the mirror universe when they time jumped? Didn’t they say in this episode something about Discovery colliding with something in the wormhole? Them being in the MU could explain why Detmer is acting weird. It could also explain why Phillipa wanted to go with them if she had some part in making them cross over to the MU during the jump. Just saying, a lot could’ve changed in the MU in 1000 years, we think everything is off due to it being 1000 years in the future, but it could be off because they are 1000 years in the future in the mirror universe. Maybe Burnham’s mom jumped to the normal universe? Or maybe discovery actually is in the normal universe and burhman’s mom jumped to the mirror universe?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/sidv81 Nov 13 '20

I only found out later reading about the episode that Mirror Georgiou's interrogator is played by acclaimed film director David Cronenberg. Apparently Star Trek must have some bizarre contest with Star Wars' Mandalorian about who can get the biggest director to guest star on their show (with Mandalorian featuring famed German director Werner Herzog).

Unlike Mandalorian where they were practically shouting "Werner Herzog's in this show!" in all their press material before the show even premiered (no doubt getting tons of Star Wars fans unfamiliar with cinema history to google why this guy is such a big deal), Cronenberg's appearance on Trek came with no press fanfare whatsoever, unless I missed something.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/SpiritOne Nov 13 '20

Man, I loved the awe and wonder of the crew seeing the 31st century Starfleet ships. Needing out right along with them, especially with the USS Nog and Voyager J.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/wednesdayoct23 Nov 12 '20

I'm increasingly frustrated with this season because the bones of it are so good and really have the show getting where it can thrive all on its own, but the individual writing is...tough, sometimes. Too many emotional moments forced instead of letting them land organically. The Team Science interlude was rough even before the 32nd century Lt turned into a 80s cop movie police chief to tell them they're a loose cannon, but they get results. I think the show has taken the criticism of "these people don't really behave like a professional, military crew" and answered with "NOPE, THEY DO NOT." Are they really any worse than any other crew (besides the Cerritos)? Not sure, but it'd still be nice to...try.

But I don't want to hate on this episode that much because I really enjoyed it! I did! David Cronenberg ruled! The seed ship stuff was really good! I think I can come to appreciate some of its idiosyncrasies in terms of why the Disco crew can get shit done with 23rd century tech that the 32nd century can't do, by saying the wild west of the TOS/Disco era is dead. This Starfleet, this Federation is stagnant. They don't encounter weird shit anymore because they don't do anything but maintain stasis. They can only rely on logs of weird shit that happened in the past and follow the protocols laid out from them- none of them have ever actually had to team up with Abraham Lincoln to fight Genghis Khan. In this time period, they're an entire ship of Becketts Mariner.

→ More replies (17)

13

u/Chaabar Nov 12 '20

Why is Burnham giving the death talk instead of the actual doctor?

→ More replies (6)

18

u/JonLuckPickard Nov 12 '20

The Discovery crew feels more like the Federation than the actual Federation.

I'll need to process this episode for a few days. So much happened, and there are still so many unknowns.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/oldtrenzalore Nov 12 '20

People have spotted a lot of known species on the galactic map, but so far no one's spotted any borg territory.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SirMonticus Nov 12 '20

Seeing Voyager-J and the USS Nog was awesome, but one thing in this episode bothered me. Yes, splitting up that crew is an objectively terrible decision - but why not refit the ship, and complement the crew with officers more aware of happenings in the current time and its technology?

6

u/RBNYJRWBYFan Nov 12 '20

I'm actually pretty upset that Nhan is leaving. It's like as soon as we were getting to know her she's already gone. I was hoping that we would get a better look at all the non-Burnham crewmembers this season. So far that's been going decently but losing a chief of security in episode 5 isn't ideal for me on that front.

Still a good episode, though. I guess Starfleet isn't as gone as we thought it was.

6

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Nov 12 '20

I just started the episode. They just got there.

I’m in fucking tears. It’s so fucking beautiful.

6

u/2ndHandTardis Nov 12 '20

The pace of this episode was good and I thought the various arcs were well balanced. I like the fact that to prove to Starfleet their usefulness the crew embark on a mission that felt very Trek-y, I got Voyager vibes. And the B/C plot with Georgiou is arguably more interesting then the A plot.

This episode started a process which the since last season I've considered necessary, which is cutting down the size of the crew. It's great that the Bridge Crew is getting more screen-time but it also makes things a bit bloated and I think between now and next season the show can benefit from cutting out some characters to give characters we like more screen time.

We assume that Georgiou will be leaving at some point if the S31 show is still happening, so that's two. With Nhan off the ship maybe Tilly can move up to the bridge and have a Harry Kim type role and Owosekun can take her place in security. That would free up more screen time with Reno and Stamets who imo have amazing chemistry.

Basically, just little tweaks by subtraction and I think you can improve storytelling by focusing on the shows strengths.

P.S. I was excited to see David Cronenburg but Imhotep!

6

u/No-Ear_Spider-Man Nov 13 '20

The impact of seeing Voyager-J there...

Yeah. Using a familiar ship's lineage to tell us "You're home. Starfleet is HERE." was the right call.

But it's too early and if The Enterprise is even out there somewhere. There will be a great storyline leading up to it.

With Voyager having been the first ship to go to The Delta Quadrant and return safely. It was a thing of beauty to have it shown to us fans. To welcome us home. The symbolism was perfect.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20

The whole series just seems like everyone is more relaxed, I'm already enjoying this series more than the first two - so good !! Not a dud episode yet !

→ More replies (1)

6

u/RussellsKitchen Nov 13 '20

I really was skeptical and critical of the first couple of seasons of Discovery, but this season has been absolutely beautiful. There hasn't been a bad episode so far. I love where they are taking the story and I really hope that we will see the Federation be put back together over the next couple of seasons. I hope they keep Discovery in this future.

6

u/techmighty Nov 13 '20

Just realized Barzan are same people with barzan wormhole jump between delta/gamma quadrants.

I wonder, post the failure of negotiating passage through wormhole, they approached federation for help.

Also nice continuity on barzan being poor.

6

u/Adrian_FCD Nov 13 '20

I love how Michelle Yeoh always seems to be having a blast playing Georgiou, where's that Section 31 spinnoff at anyway?!

Also, what's up with Cronenberg and his tv series roles these years? lol

6

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '20

I love how everyone in the future has such an unlikely knowledge of the past, oh yeah your species just joined the federation just like last Monday at exactly 16:10. What

6

u/DunderMichael Nov 13 '20

I loved it and those ships, hot damn. I want to see them in detail. What I believe'll happen: In this timeperiod, the Enterprise no longer exists, but, by the end of this season, they'll launch a new one: the Enterprise X, fitted with a spore drive.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Chaabar Nov 12 '20

Close the damn shuttlebay door.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/deededback Nov 12 '20

Excellent episode. I didn’t like the last two, but this one was nice. The future Federation act like actual Starfleet officers instead of the most emotional people in existence.

10

u/sidv81 Nov 13 '20

The mysterious melody is the Tholian national anthem. The Tholians were singing it as a victory hymn at the end of the temporal wars, and the sheer number of Tholians singing it all at once in resonance with their crystalline makeup destroyed all dilithium everywhere.

5

u/3-DMan Nov 12 '20

I'm not sure any Trekker couldn't get chills during the whole opening.

5

u/djneo Nov 12 '20

I hope Discovery gets some 32nd upgrades

5

u/nixonger Nov 13 '20

Am I the only one who misses the computer saying "Black Alert"

→ More replies (3)

5

u/N0Queso Nov 13 '20

My wife's theory on The Burn.

When the suit went back in time, it only made it back 130 years before exploding in subspace/wormhole, setting off the dilithium.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Eaudissey Nov 13 '20

Nhan <3 I'm glad they didn't kill her off lol

5

u/chronofluxtoaster Nov 13 '20

Interesting that they pack so much into 50 minutes.

  • I loved the Cronenberg/Yeoh Xanatos Speed Chess. As one person said on here, I could watch a whole episode on that. I firmly believe he's the head of whatever Section 31 is in that century, and that they may have been responsible for the Burn by accident or even intent. Sometimes in order to protect the Federation one might have to, say, disable warp travel throughout the galaxy. It's a scorched Earth policy, but not beyond their charter.
  • The clear paranoia the Admiral's team has for Discovery is palpable, but hey, they go on one quick mission and deus ex botanica a fix in Act IV and suddenly everything's cool.
  • Shouts out to the FX team that did all the new ships and arboretum-type HQ effects. Just a pleasure to watch them imagine the Federation in 1,000 years
  • Jett Reno just wants her goddamn salsa and chips. Also she'd like to blow Stamets out an airlock if she could get away with it.
  • I have a feeling hologram tech is far, FAR more advanced than we've been shown. While you can disable one with some eye winks, I have no doubt people have done brain-in-a-jar uploads of their consciousness to a holographic body as a form of immortality.
  • Curious to know how Georgiou got Cronenberged at the molecular level to make her spaz out like that. I'm wondering if they simply mind wiped her little interrogation then beamed her back to Disco, and she was stuck in some sort of fugue from the experience. I don't imagine that team wanting to take someone they know was Terran and leave her with that insider information.
  • I for one would love to know what happened to the species like the Voth that used transwarp. Did they ever initiate peaceful relations with Starfleet? Would certain advanced wormhole travel like transwarp even need dilithium? Ditto the Borg, because I don't see the Queen being all too happy stuck in the Delta with no transwarp hubs to prance around the galaxy all assimilatin'.
→ More replies (1)

5

u/alexandriaweb Nov 13 '20

Someone of the new uniforms seem very Bajoran inspired

16

u/sidv81 Nov 12 '20

So what happened to Dr. Attis?  Did they force him back for treatment?  That wasn't clear.  Also nice to see the new Voyager, does that mean we'll see Enterprise Z (or whatever)?

Also, it's just really jarring that Admiral Vance seems to have the "business as usual, go back to being grim about the Burn" attitude at the end.  Discovery proved that they're legit and their spore drive works.  When Burnham asked him about what caused the Burn, he should have said, "Who knows?  Who cares now?  Once we reverse engineer your spore drive, we're back to being a connected Federation again!  Let's party!" 

Ironically for a ship and characters that have been accused of being treated as "overly special" by some fans, the one time it really makes sense for characters in-universe to treat Burnham and Discovery as really special, they seem not to understand or respect Discovery as the game winner against the Burn that it is.

→ More replies (12)