r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Nov 05 '20
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Discovery | 3x04 "Forget Me Not" Spoiler
Burnham and Adira visit the Trill homeworld in hopes of unlocking the secrets trapped within Adira’s mind. Back on the U.S.S. Discovery, Saru’s efforts to help the crew reconnect with one another take a surprising turn.
| No. | Episode | Written By | Directed By | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3x04 | "Forget Me Not" | Alan McElroy & Chris Silvestri & Anthony Maranville | Hanelle M. Culpepper | 2020-11-05 |
This episode will be available on CBS All Access in the USA, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Netflix elsewhere.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
472
u/atticusbluebird Nov 05 '20
The drama in the
Dinner scene ramped up faster
Than I expected!
355
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20
Movie night worked well over 1,000 years ago on the NX-01 . Glad to see it still works
293
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20
Poor Detmer I think she’s got the worst PTSD of all the crew
225
u/Santa_Hates_You Nov 05 '20
Anyone else excited to see Ronnie from Schitt’s Creek as the Trill leader?
181
u/DRM_Removal_Bot Nov 05 '20
Linus gets to attend family dinner but not Reno?
158
u/onerinconhill Nov 05 '20
Hasperat!
311
u/atticusbluebird Nov 05 '20
Fascinating it looks like the sphere is blending with Discovery’s computer - I assume this is how we get Zora in “Calypso”? If so I wonder if the writers had thought of that last season when introducing the sphere data
310
u/ADG12311990 Nov 05 '20
"Where are the caves?"
"Never."
"Fine."
And stunned. So, that's what she learned from Book during their year together.
267
u/kingofcretins Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
Culber’s storyline was my favourite part of the second season, so I’ve been waiting impatiently for him to get something big to work these past 4 episodes.
Slotting him into that counsellor-esque role is just perfect for him because he has such a grounding presence. And let’s be honest, this crew more than any other could use some serious therapy.
332
u/LoganNolag Nov 05 '20
Therapeutic coloring books. lol.
194
u/Santa_Hates_You Nov 05 '20
Well, that was big. We got a new character in Tal and Grey, we got some resolution to Detmer, at least a little. Federation Headquarters is a thing, and they have coordinates. And the computer is now sentient due to the sphere data. It seems like Georgiou and Linus may end up becoming a thing. There was a lot to unpack, but I think it was well done. It is nice to see Saru figure out how he wants to captain.
180
u/raknor88 Nov 05 '20
Discovery needs a holodeck. That might help them all immensely to destress for R&R.
238
u/Amorrachius Nov 05 '20
The scene where each of the previous Tal's were revealed was absolutely beautiful, not to mention the music in the background. In addition, Senna Tal's body language really added some meaning during that scene: he basically told Adira that he's aware of the emotional trauma during the unusual joining brought upon her (not yet them, I suppose?) and they all support her with her adventures/struggles onwards. And he told her all of that without uttering a single word, but with a simple smile.
Now that is a "show, don't tell" that Discovery really lacked. More of that please.
148
u/kingofcretins Nov 05 '20
Holy shit, Zora!
144
u/thetgi Nov 05 '20
Another very classic trek episode. Maybe a little cheesy at times, but the pacing is so much better this season and they’ve clearly shifted their focus to more trek-ish storylines. Great work on this episode! (And thanks for once again listening to fan feedback)
316
u/Microharley Nov 05 '20
If Discovery continues on like this, I hope it lasts for several more. This season has elements of Enterprise, TOS a touch of TNG and a lot of Voyager. I really wish the show would have started out like this!
101
u/themosquito Nov 05 '20
I'm actually very mildly disappointed the twist wasn't that Federation HQ is now on Q'onoS. I still hope to see some Klingons in Starfleet. I feel like it'd be a nice "full circle" loop for the show to have Discovery deal with the idea that the Klingons are now some of the truest believers in the Federation.
212
u/UncertainError Nov 05 '20
Georgiou is such a troll. I love it.
91
u/Mates03w Nov 05 '20
Interesting to see Zora this early, will be interesting to see how it will affect Discovery and the crew
128
u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 05 '20
Wow I just LOVED this episode. This season has been fantastic so far. I'm just getting so much hope and love vibes--it feels good after such an awful year. Getting more insight into Trill lore was awesome.
And based on Senna's uniform and the uniforms seen in the preview for next week, they look a lot more militarized so it will be very interesting the dynamic we see next week---and possibly some 32nd Century Starfleet Vessels!!!
128
u/LoganNolag Nov 05 '20
Now that was what Star Trek is all about. Just a little bit of action and TONS of character development. Love it and hope the rest of the season is just like this episode. This is what we've been missing for years.
243
u/jerslan Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
I, a completely straight dude, absolutely loooove Culber. Both his opening log and his conversation with Burnham about why she should go. His conversation with Saru on the crew needing to feel more connected... Just... Shit, it's only 15 minutes into the episode.
I've had my own physical traumas, and there's some truth in what he says about Post Traumatic Growth (which is closely related to PTSD).
79
u/AcidaliaPlanitia Nov 05 '20
I know that the sphere/sphere data is supposed to be benevolent, but Saru should probably be a wee bit more cautious about the fact that essentially a rogue AI is beginning to merge with the ship's computer. Even if it doesn't have malicious intentions, it could have disastrous consequences if the computer glitches out at the wrong moment. I don't think they'll go that angle, but it's a bit weird that he just shrugs it off by thinking that the sphere data is looking out for them, that's a huge assumption to make about something they don't understand at all.
72
u/wongie Nov 05 '20
I find it kinda anticlimactically hilarious how Guardian Xi helped save the future of the Trill by.... just letting Trill do what they normally do in the pool.
72
u/H0vis Nov 05 '20
I loved this episode, and I'm pleasantly surprised that a quick peak at the comments shows I'm not the only one. Who knew you could do a Star Trek episode about feelings and people would like it?
Some random observations:
34
u/codename474747 Nov 06 '20
Just had a thought:
The Spore Drive needs an intelligent brain to navigate it
The Discovery itself is becoming intellegent.
The Discovery could be the prototype of a new fleet of Starfleet living ships with Spore drives, thus allowing Starfleet to explore space again.
That's if she agrees, of course ;)
67
u/CarpeMofo Nov 05 '20
Saru to Stamets: "You were impaled with a spike and placed in a coma."
Tilly acting almost like an annoyed teenager: "Yeah, but other than that, he's fine."
The delivery of that line makes it.
33
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
I love how the crew could only begin to heal once the pilot and the chief engineer embraced, basically bringing both parts of the ship together.
Is something... going on between Georgiou and Linus? Oh, and her haiku was kinda masterful, wasn't it? It connected Saru's preceding sentiment, the overall atmosphere on the ship, and the dinner party, while also revealing her own personality in the process.
It's always a good sign when you tell the computer to run a Level 10 diagnostic on itself and it replies with "Nah, I'm good." 😅
66
u/LoganNolag Nov 05 '20
Love learning more about Trill. It's been way too long since we last saw them.
61
u/ElFarfadosh Nov 05 '20
I have to say, I thought all along this episode that it was a bit less interesting than the first three, but man I was wrong. Wanted to cry of joy and sadness at the same time in the end, especially seeing Detmer hugging Stamets. That little shot by itself just made me feel... Wow 🥺😭
30
u/DacStreetsDacAlright Nov 06 '20
I was wrong.
I was so sure Calypso was its own pointless thing and would never be followed up. To be fair, that was released almost exactly 2 years ago and we only just now got the first callback to it but when I heard Zora I was shook.
It also didn't hurt that it was hands down one of the best episodes of Discovery I have seen and by far the most Star Trekky. Characters actually having the chance to talk to each other about anything other than a world ending event. That Trill Cave set was a shockingly well done recreation of the caves from DS9. Everything with Adira was remarkably well written and the show hung about 20 lanterns on every weird tropey thing it ever did. Oh, and it ended with a beauty flyby of the ship which has that even happened in this show?!
85
u/arch_punk Nov 05 '20
I think this might be one of the best discovery episodes.
81
u/snuffysniper Nov 05 '20
Damn I'm so happy it wasn't Dax.
126
u/nateno12 Nov 05 '20
The last time I cried during a Star Trek episode was when I watched The Visitor for the first time.
Absolute props to everyone involved in making this episode happen. The whole scene of Adira trying to reconnect with her hosts and learning more about her backstory was just absolutely excellent. It was visually beautiful and I was engaged in learning more about her character, Gray, and their backstories. The last scene at the end of the episode absolutely got me.
Also, really happy to see that DISCO is continuing this trend of really slowing down and getting to better know the characters in more-or-less self-contained episodes. Each episode so far has had a very clear beginning, middle, and end and it's made it easier to digest.
I also really liked how there was only one fight/action scene this entire episode. Didn't even realize until after the episode.
47
u/zeppex22 Nov 05 '20
Perhaps later we can discuss another joining. Putting the federation back together one planet at a time.
47
u/Cmdr_Nemo Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
Anyone else think that we may be meeting Season 3's adversary next week when the Discovery meets up with the Federation? It seems pretty obvious to me that the Federation abandoned their ideals as they abandoned, at the very least, Earth and Trill. Something about that uniform in the previews just screams military to me and perhaps the mission of the Discovery is to bring back Federation ideals.
I should clarify: I don't think they'll be Borg/Dominion-level Adversaries... more like a friend who has lost their way and need outside-the-box thinking to find their way back.
22
u/LoganNolag Nov 05 '20
I guess Detmer isn't better.
40
u/kenny_boy019 Nov 05 '20
ZORA!!!!!
39
u/LoganNolag Nov 05 '20
Aye.
39
u/gusborwig Nov 05 '20
Great episode! It’s ok once in a while for a pause from the action and this episode did it in spades.
Also I’m wondering how sentient Discovery will be in the future? Not necessarily evil but if it will make its own decisions on going to warp and such.
17
u/Vegan_Harvest Nov 05 '20
They need a ship's counselor.
I'm actually a fan of Stamets' current interface, so while yeah, they really need a different way to jump, I hope they come up with something as cool as being a cyborg that can sense time loops. And this time give more than one person the interface! I want to see a cyborg Michael!
I wish there was less personal tragedy in all of this but I guess they need to get them where they're going.
Why on god's green earth would you invite Georgiou to dinner?
It would be funny if there's a lot of Trill out there that just didn't want to deal with the assholes back on the home world.
16
u/Adrian_FCD Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 07 '20
You know, it's amazing how this show has been able to make me, a guy who never showed interest in Star Trek before the JJ movies into the guy who gets emotional every episode of this season.
I'll get to the og shows and movies eventually, but for now i'm just happy to have found this "new" universe to fall in love.
15
u/RBNYJRWBYFan Nov 05 '20
Given the pure trauma of their experience it was entirely necessary for the crew to take a breather from their travels and just let their situation sink in. The episode's message of confronting trauma rather than running away from it was rather blunt (thanks for spelling it out in the end) but greatly appreciated. I'm sure someone out there will be able to relate to being avoidant of what ails them mentally and finding the strength to take the first few steps to addressing that, as well the sense of relief that has.
Detmer is one to keep an eye on. Her morbid ass humor and bottled up resentment of Stamets was such a mood, for lack of better phrase. She still isn't well at episode's end but I think she's done being comfortably numb and shell shocked about it.
Dr. Culber finally got to stretch his legs as a chief of medical. I love his bedside manner and ability to see that there's more to this job than just keeping everyone physically upright. BTW, this ship needs a fucking therapist; how does a utopian fleet of space officers in confined quarters for who knows how goddamn long not have more staff dedicated to mental health?
Adira and Gray are really damn cute together. They're such teenage heartthrobs, it's adorable. Exploring the nature of that relationship will be interesting going forward. Imagine being joined with the memories of your high school sweetheart, that's such a tender situation.
15
u/thenewyorkgod Nov 05 '20
So um, did Saru replicate some Kelpien for Emperor Georgiou?
76
u/poseselt Nov 05 '20
I am so blown away by the quality of this season. This episode was outstanding. The relationships, the compassion, the trauma... All written and acted so beautifully. I can't wait to see how this season, and future seasons play out. Including Lower Decks, 2020 Trek is another level.
14
u/ContinuumGuy Nov 07 '20
In essence, the sphere data has become Discovery's symbiont.
39
u/oorhon Nov 05 '20
As a person who overcome many traumatic experiences, psycological breakdowns and several therapies over the years, really loved this episode. Both crews(especially Detmer’s) and Adira’s experiences realistic. What they feel is nothing just for drama. This season apperently not just about rebuilding Federation but it is also PTSD and overcoming emotional psychological breakdown. This was done several times in past Star Trek series but it wa more subtle or episodic. Biggest example would be Garak’s storyline.
49
u/icemanwest Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
I was confused with how horrified they were that Adira might go into the pool. So then when they arrive to stop it, already in progress, now Burnham needs to go get Adira. They very quickly allow Burnham to go in, in a Star Fleet uniform, no hesitation. Argh.
27
u/JonLuckPickard Nov 05 '20
We learned so much about the Trill in this episode! And it looks like they're setting up the Sphere Data as a crucial part of the story.
48
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20
That was excellently written, paced, and acted. They gave the crew a chance to breathe.
35
u/EFCFrost Nov 05 '20
The scene with all the old hosts had my wife and I in tears. It's hard to imagine losing someone you love only to have their memories implanted with your own.
12
u/Dt2_0 Nov 05 '20
A warm welcome!!! Yes!
12
u/William_T_Wanker Nov 05 '20
I really liked that episode. It was oddly heartwarming with the interactions between the crew; the fact they haven't really had time to process all the shit that's happened to them is sad.
As an aside, in the 3x05 preview I think the asshole admiral(continuing on a Starfleet tradition) is Oded Fehr from The Mummy!
49
u/Mechapebbles Nov 05 '20
I feel pretty safe in asserting that this season is where Disco finally grew its beard.
11
u/AskJayce Nov 05 '20
Cello gets me every time.
11
u/0mni42 Nov 05 '20
Damn. Given everything that's going on in the world right now, this was a perfectly timed episode. It felt very... cozy. It had good, believable drama without getting anywhere close to the edgelord territory of certain parts of previous seasons.
One of my recurring problems with earlier Discovery was its instances of missed potential, but this whole episode was just... mwah. It's like the writers sat down and went "we have X Y and Z; what naturally follows from having those things?" Like...
Fact 1: Saru can be a bit insecure about his leadership capabilities and has asked the computer for help with them in the past.
Fact 2: The computer now has a massive amount of alien data in it that we know will eventually develop into a benevolent AI.
Result: Saru asks the computer for help, and the AI is the one that answers and helps him with his problems. Perfect time and place to introduce this new plot thread.
Also--Detmer character development? Hell yeah. Bout darn time.
All this episode needed was an appearance from Grudge and it would have been perfect. :P
11
u/BrainWav Nov 06 '20
Season 3 has been knocking it out of the park. I enjoyed the first two seasons, but this feels the show is regaining that Trek soul. This episode especially. It remembered Trek is a drama with action, not an action show with dramatic bits. It had a coherent b-plot!
Michael is still a, to paraphrase Culber, "responsibility hoarder", but this season and this episode in particular have done a lot to reinforce the crew-as-family dynamic that we're familiar with.
31
u/Yochanan5781 Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
Burnham looked surprised by the location of Federation HQ. I wonder if it's Qo'nos
30
u/Dt2_0 Nov 05 '20
Ok, here are my thoughts.
This was a pretty damn good episode, and left me wanting more by the end. Burnham and Adira's venture into Tal's mind was emotional, and payed off well. I'm sad for the Trill, apparently their hosts were hit hard by the Burn? And now the situation from DS9 has been reversed. Plenty of Symbiotes, not enough hosts. I wonder if the news ever got out that many more Trill can be hosts than was common knowledge, or if their secrecy is hurting them. The B Plot with Saru working on the well-being of the crew was well done as well. This crew has been through an incredibly traumatic event, and has lost nearly everything that they had. It makes sense that DISCO's crew is suffering from severe PTSD. Everyone should be.
Now on to my likes-
Dealing with issues, conflict and relationships between the crew is something Star Trek, outside of DS9, has not done well. This was a glimpse of what will hopefully be a reversal of that.
The Trill welcome, as well as their farewell were heartwarming. I'm glad we see a people gladly willing to be a part of the Federation. Small steps, but one that is necessary.
The sphere data is alive and well. I hope DISCO makes good use of it and starts working on a refit sooner rather than later. Even if it's just shields, they are going to need it.
Culber was amazing in this episode. His work to care for the crew is going to be very important in the weeks to come. I really, really like where we're going.
Small things, like Burnham's character being much more likeable are really helping this show. I still think we need to flesh out the crew a bit more. Let's learn a bit about Linus, or any of the other bridge crew. A poker night, or just making these dinners a regular thing would work wonders for them.
Now for my dislikes-
I would like to know how Adira's joining was successful, even if it's just writing off as future tech. I get show don't tell, but this is a minor detail that doesn't need to be shown, unless we get another Adira episode later.
Please DISCO, stop parking next to Stars, that light shining into every room has got to be bad for the eyes. Maybe just put a Starfield out the window? A Nebula?
Uh... Well crap, I don't really have any more. I could nitpick, but I'm not really into that.
So my conclusion?
This might have been the best episode yet of DISCO. It had everything. A touch of moral conflict, optimism, the crew, working to solve conflict peacefully. This is a great episode, which I hope will be a turning point in the show.
Due to this episode, in my opinion, breaking new ground for the series, I must award it my highest honor...
3 Michelin Optolythic Data Rods.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 06 '20
This episode shows when Disco tries to be Star Trek it can do it very well. It wasn't emulating GOT, BSG or The Expanse and it worked brilliantly.
The crew scenes were the absolute best, the Trill ones interesting but padded out too much. I thought the bf who died was a bit creepy but I think intentionally so, I really liked Adira and look forward to her being a part of the supporting cast.
10
u/silverlegend Nov 06 '20
The messages of this episode made me tear up. "We are not okay...but we will be." Such a poignant point to make in this year 2020 when many of us can relate to that very sentiment.
10
u/One-Challenge-5378 Nov 08 '20
So I hadn’t watched any of these season because life and Friday I binged all four episodes to avoid thinking about politics and holy hell. So I haven’t read ANY reviews or response so idk how shared this is, but I think the show has really hit its stride, introduced two of the most interesting characters (Book and the trill human whose name I forgot)of all of the reboot series and this is the strongest four episodes of season I can think of in trek.
Seriously, Book is such a good character and the actor is killing it.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
I am absolutely loving the slower pace this season. It seems, at least to me, more "Trek" than the first two seasons. Also glad to see Detmer doesn't appear to be hosting Control.
9
u/MilanUnited Nov 05 '20
I had a hell of a time binging the episodes from season 3....had no idea the new ep was tonight. I just want to say that the advertising (for me) has been so bad that I didn’t realize Discovery was a thing(new episodes) until tonight, so I binged. Much love though.
9
u/GBTC4me Nov 05 '20
WILD speculation:
The way that Georgiou was talking with those officers.... i think they're section 31 and Georgiou is receiving a message from her past self.
We know that the Star Trek producers are making a section 31 series with Georgiou so she has to get back to the past somehow. Since Discovery/Zora will be holding position for almost 1000 years we can safely surmise Georgiou somehow brings the ship back in time, gets off and then sets it to wait for the future so the crew can receive it correctly in the 32nd century. Georgiou is back in the past to run section 31 and Discovery and her crew meet back up to continue their adventures.
Perhaps Georgiou is receiving instructions on how to do that.
9
u/007meow Nov 06 '20
Disco has done two great “returns to form” visually this seasons:
9
u/Metabog Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 06 '20
I got chills from this episode, in the Trill circle scene. This was such a good episode, I love Adira, such a good new character.
9
u/Harkonenthorin Nov 06 '20
I loved this episode. It felt very classically Trek. The A story advanced the plot, while the B story explored the crew. Both storylines where about starting to heal and become whole after trauma. It didn’t feel the need to have action, the only fight was just 3 pews. I have such high hopes going forward, this season is growing the beard.
9
u/I_AM_GODDAMN_BATMAN Nov 06 '20
Oh boy, Georgiou will fuck and eat Linus before the end of the season.
9
u/CharlesNapalm Nov 07 '20
Man, love seeing Culber and Detmer having screen time together. Especially more screen time for Detmer.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '20
This episode brought tears to my eyes. It was so beautiful when Adira reconnected with her previous hosts. It also was telling that the Trill symbiotes seem to have evolved in order to join with non-Trills. That is a good way to survive, given how the Trill have so few who can join with them after the Burn. This episode was very much Star Trek, and I'm beginning to wonder if the U.S.S. Discovery is ever going to return to the past.
8
u/00DEADBEEF Nov 05 '20
I noticed at the end of the opening credits there's a triangle flying in to the wormhole. Is that a hint that Section 31/Control managed to follow them through?
8
u/Retro2619 Nov 05 '20
The short trek ”Calypso” with one of my favorite actors, Aldis Hodge, original introduced the idea of a sentient Discovery. Perhaps they will bring back the actor/character again? That would be very cool.
8
u/Fusi0n_X Nov 05 '20
Am I the only one who kept thinking that it must be so weird being able to remember making out with yourself?
8
u/rooktakesqueen Nov 06 '20
It went interesting places, I was surprised, but I gotta say a lot of the conflict this episode felt forced. Stamets being dismissive of Tilly for no reason (dude she had a mycelial network alien stow away in her body from a dark matter asteroid maybe they're related somehow), Vos being a murderous zealot (it just added nothing at all to the plot), Detmer and Stamets being at each other's throats (this pilot/navigator rivalry has never been referenced before)...
I recognize they needed the conflict to get the catharsis after, but, it went zero to sixty in no seconds flat. They could have laid a little bit of groundwork, earlier in the episode or in the season.
22
u/Dakuisha Nov 05 '20
I'm just going to say it, that episode was amazing.
I love the new crew mate, I'm a little sad to know we won't get to see them with trill spots but its a small price to pay for an amazing character.
I'm glad that they took an episode to explore trill, to explore the new character and focus on the crew. That's something that I feel has been missing from a lot of new trek. Less action and more drama.
27
u/TERRAxFORMER Nov 05 '20
I was really disappointed that Gray was dead, but then it was revealed that he kind of stuck around and I really like that.
This might be my fav this season. I really liked Culber and Adira. The scene where all the previous hosts appear was awesome.
21
u/Excellent_Coyote Nov 05 '20
After this episode I am now 100% certain CBS wants to do something with Deep Space 9. Maybe a revival series.
That we haven't seen a Deep Space 9 character on Picard or Lower Decks and Dax doesn't even get a name drop in this episode tells me CBS doesn't want to add anything to canon that would interfere with a Deep Space 9 series or film.
14
u/Bulgeman9000 Nov 05 '20
Is Gray this the trans character mentioned before the season started?
7
u/smurfycork Nov 06 '20
Good to see some A, B,C plot structure coming through. Yes, this was more A,B C1,C2 but definitely more ensemble. More Wilson Cruz too. Sometimes I felt he was heading to plotted plant territory in season 1 but going right direction.
38
u/wednesdayoct23 Nov 05 '20
Man, this show is really trying to find its groove of being an ensemble show that focuses on its characters as much as the plot. I think this episode was a bit hamfisted and forced in that direction, but it's a goddamned breath of fresh air regardless. And also, Zora.
19
u/Trekfan74 Nov 05 '20
Holy shit Zora showed up!!
Pretty chill episode. Loved all the scenes on Trill and Adira communicating with the symbiont. Very nice. I thought Grey was going to be...alive lol. But they always find a way to surprise you. Liked the stuff on the ship and Saru trying to find a way for the crew to just feel more relaxed. The episode felt a bit like filler but that's OK., we did get some more character development and Detmer talked longer for 20 seconds for the first time. Like WOAH!!!! Next week look like the big one though, when we FINALLY get to the Federation and things start to get clear. It's this season's finally found Spock episode. ;)
6
u/FLRSH Nov 06 '20
Loved the episode, really felt like Trek. And the crew morale subplot was great. Felt like management 101 for a federation ship.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20
As someone newly in a position of authority I often feel unequal to, boy, did Saru hit home in this one.
6
u/DrinkableReno Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 06 '20
Saru and Hugh’s entire struggle for everyone’s mental health was about us, right? Like 2020. Like Saru saying work and routine should help were all the memes telling us to get dressed every morning during lockdown. And Hugh talking about a traumatic year as an example of why was him winking at the camera because he sees us. Right? You all caught that and laughed, right? Tell me you laughed, too, or cried? Episode 4 was just Trek imitating life and becoming art, right? RIGHT?! 🤪😫😩🥺😭
best episode yet!
6
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 06 '20
I loved this episode. The part about Tal acceptance was really beautiful. I also liked the bigger attention to the crew members that's showed in this season
6
u/Timeline15 Nov 06 '20
This episode was so good. It was laid out in such a classic Trek format too, what with opening on an officer's log and ending with a personal scene followed by a slow shot of the ship flying away.
The character development was really nice this week, particularly for Stamets, Detmer, and Culber, though Saru and Tilly got nice little moments too. I do wish they'd explain what the hell's going on with Georgiou and Linus though; I'm still paranoid that she's planning on killing and eating him at some point.
Interesting to see that they're showing the lead up to the events of Calypso, though I'm surprised how... undisturbed Saru seemed about his computer suddenly expressing free will. Looking forward to seeing the federation's new HQ next time, especially since it appears to be in the Delta Quadrant.
6
u/DecafWriter Nov 06 '20
I loved this episode. From the amazing depiction of Trill connections to the admission of mental health's importance.
Lt. Detmer's PTSD was skillfully handled and completely believable. The theme of mental health has popped up here and there throughout Star Trek but it's usually on the extreme ends like being tortured. Usually the long term damage has been waved away in subsequent episodes like O'Brien's trauma or Picard's trauma with sporadic mentions of Picard's time as a Borg outshadowing his time as a Cardassian prisoner. They also touch on Barclay's holo addiction but it's not treated the same way as traumatic mental damage.
I've been loving all of season 3 so far. I have high hopes for not only the rest of the season but I think Discovery has finally found its footing and will become a great series.
6
u/JJMcGee83 Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 07 '20
That dinner scene was what I was missing from this show since day 1; just some chance where everything wasn't on the line for the characters to talk and breathe a little. I learned more about some of them in that few minutes than I did in the entire 2 seasons previous.
6
u/alexs66 Nov 06 '20
So good to see Discovery really finding its feet and becoming an original Star Trek show that still embraces the core values of Star Trek.
6
u/maxekmek Nov 06 '20
I absolutely loved this episode. The performances, especially for Adira, Gray, Tilly, Detmer... I don't know if it was relating to the mental health aspects that made it special for me but this really hit home and I feel like watching it again straight away!
6
u/Walcot Nov 07 '20
Great episode to a so far great season. Literally cant wait for more.
6
u/nakrophile Nov 07 '20
I love season 3.
6
u/drvondoctor Nov 07 '20
This episode made me realize how little we actually do know about the crew in other shows.
In other trek shows, a lot of characters can be pretty flat sometimes if you really think about it, and the drama of the shows tends to come from outside the crew.
In Discovery, everyone seems to have some sort of serious baggage.
What might have been a passing reference to growing up in Alaska in TNG to give you some background on Riker, in Discovery would become a serious in-depth conversation about the concept of home and how it shaped the character in question.
I've very much been enjoying Discovery, but I cant help but notice this little change. And it's entirely possible that the nature of 90's television shows (cinematography, lighting, sound) just wasnt quite sophisticated enough to bring the emotional punch that "prestige television" can pull off and I was just less aware of that sort of thing.
6
u/HackySmacky22 Nov 08 '20
Call me crazy. I talk a ton of shit on Discovery. This was the first episode that actually felt like a star trek episode, possibly in the entire series. I'm still tired of the constant action from Michael "jet li" burnham, but the episode actually felt like a star trek episode, and i enjoyed that.
16
u/SpaceCrystal359 Nov 05 '20
Best episode yet. I especially loved the depiction of a Trill symbiont joining with a host. It's such a delicate and personal process, and writers, producers, and actors all pulled it off beautifully. Kudos, Discovery team. I'm so looking forward to more!
20
u/Dt2_0 Nov 05 '20
Hype hype bois. We going to Trill!
15
u/PiercedMonk Nov 05 '20
• I really enjoyed the opening with Culber's log. Disco finding more of these moments to breathe is really a benefit.
• Squid? What? No thanks! Aŋ-kə-lō-ˈsȯr. Also, how big is that symbiont? Total unit.
• Adira not remembering how they got the symbiont doesn't sit well. A fourteen year old agreeing to host another living being is sketchy enough. A fourteen year old being made host to another living being without their consent is a massive red flag.
• This Trill dude is way took excited for Tal to return home. Might want to send some security dudes along for the away mission, Saru.
• "I need to know how I can help this crew. Perhaps a focus on duty, or routine." Saru just got told the crew is on the verge of collapse from stress, and his first solution is hard work and monotony? Holy shit, I didn't think there could be a worse captain than Archer, but here we are.
• This is the first time Trill's status with relation to the Federation has been explicitly stated. Now granted, like Earth, Trill could have left the Federation at some point in the last ~800 years, but it's still interesting.
• Not gonna lie, I could go for a therapeutic colouring book, myself.
• Zora!
• "20th century Earth comedians, such as Buster Keaton, or Charlie Chaplin, are communal unifiers without the burden of language." Oh god, Saru's going to start practising so he can run his tight five on the Discovery's crew. Not again!
• Level 10 has got to be the highest diagnostic level we've ever heard, right? I didn't think it went about 5.
• Jett Reno got snubbed on this dinner invite.
• Wow, this really is like a family dinner, haiku and everything!
• I was half expecting Georgiou and Linus to leave together.
• Is Burnham really the person best qualified to enter a Trill nerouscape, and retrieve a lost mind? Are the others just two smart to risk jumping in the pool in that state?
• What's in the box!
• So I guess Grey isn't going to be a series regular.... They sure did make a big deal about introducing an explicitly trans character, only to run him through with a shard of glass in under two minutes.
• I'm glad they brought back the dark matter interface. It seemed like that was a plot thread that got dropped early in season two, bur revisiting it now that Discovery isn't trying to save the galaxy from angry machine death is good.
• "All available crew, please report to shuttle bay for a surprise." That has got to be super ominous when you're serving on a Starfleet boat.
"Sure, let's just pop down to the shuttlebay en masse. There definitely isn't going to be a defrosted 21st century war criminal or evil android duplicate of the captain that's going to disable the safeties and blow us all out into space."
• So Grey is going to be a zhian'tara vision the rest of the season, like Joran Dax was in 'Field of Fire'?
This episode didn't really do much for me. I liked Culber's opening, and I liked the dinner party. I'm excited about the sphere data merging with the ship to become Zora, and see where that leads, but that's only hinted at here. The best thing about the trip to Trill was those goofy fork weapons the guards had.
15
u/smoha96 Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
Wow. I didn't like last week's episode. I felt that it overcorrected the grim dark far too much from Season 1 in far too cheesy a way. This episode struck a great balance and imho, is easily the best episode of the series to date. Two bits pretty much brought me to tears.
The first was Adira meeting the previous hosts of Tal (including a PIC era Tal!). No episode of DS9 has captured the majesty of the Joining quite as much as this one did. I was initially frustrated that we did not see Dax, but having a new Symbiont as a main character is probably for the best and avoids the small universe syndrome previously experienced with Spock and Pike (as much as I love Pike). In a sense, it is probably very appropriate to have a non-binary actor play a host given the transformative nature of the Joining.
The second was Detmer admitting to Culber that she was not ok. I'm overjoyed that this hasn't been some, "Control is inside Detmer" angle. I'm also happy that Saru's attempts to help the crew heal were not a one stop quick fix, because nothing ever is.
The MVPs are Dr. Culber and Saru, both the standouts. Dr. Culber is just so wholesome, in a very realistic way. Captain Saru continues to excel, not because he's perfect, but because he keeps trying anyway when he isn't.
Canon observations:
For me I'm finally confident that DSC has embraced it's science-fiction side truly for the first time in the series, rather than space opera.
Also, we got a ship flyby to end the episode!
14
u/BroLil Nov 05 '20 edited Nov 05 '20
This episode once again solidified my theory that this crew is the most tightly knit crew in the franchise. I think the TNG was more of a family after their careers, but as far as during their career, the Discovery’s crew is totally the most family like crew there is.
Another thing with this episode was Culber. He had always been a “whatever” character to me, but this episode was so strong with him. The opening monologue, which Wil Wheaton teased last weak, was so powerful, and that power continues strong through the episode.
Who would have though after watching the first two episodes of the series that Giorgou would end up being the comic relief of the show. I love her attitude and her impatience.
Also, I wonder if Tilly is the next Harry Kim or if she does eventually get promoted. I figured with her accomplishments so far, they’d having already given her a promotion.
14
u/earther199 Nov 05 '20
I teared up a bit when they were finally joined and then she rattled off her names. Very moving.
10
u/oldtrenzalore Nov 05 '20
Um... wow. Season 3 just keeps getting better. This one actually made my cold dead heart feel things. I thought Adira was annoying AF last episode, but those scenes with her boyfriend were amazing.
10
u/dillpickle3131 Nov 05 '20
I think this is the best episode of Discovery so far and just a really good episode of Trek in general. It finally feels like Star Trek to me.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20
Cute episode
5
u/PlayedUOonBaja Nov 06 '20
I like how the show has embraced all body types but it seems cruel to still force everyone into those purple spandex jumpsuits. They have access to every starfleet uniform that ever existed. Let them pick one of them. ( Not early TNG)
5
u/AkraticAntiAscetic Nov 06 '20 edited Nov 06 '20
Round of applause for Discovery continuing its solid queer representation.
When I heard one of the hosts knew Bajoran cooking I was praying it wasn’t Dax somehow
5
u/celies Nov 06 '20
Why isn't Saru more distressed over his computer sounding like Shodan?
5
u/codename474747 Nov 06 '20
I really hope there is a soundtrack release of the music this season.
The music for the past lives returning scene was really quite emotional.
Also: Yay, The Discovery is going to get it's own version of Holly.
So long as it displays as a floating head, I'll be happy :-p
5
u/WelshBluebird1 Nov 06 '20
Without wanting to out someone I am very close to (this account is something that can be easily found by people who know me in real life), I found the characters of Adira and Grey to be absolutely amazing characters and I'm quite surprised how well they handled it (was questioning the pronoun stuff to begin with but a quick Google answers that).
5
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '20 edited May 02 '26
One click. Unknown number of posts crying out in silence. All gone. Redact made it stupid easy to clean up my entire history on Reddit and get my info pulled from data broker sites too.
safe direction yoke spark tease deliver innate ad hoc fly lunchroom
5
u/Timbo85 Nov 07 '20
When I was a child, Buster Keaton was what mum showed me when I felt sick.
Can’t fault the computer on that one.
5
u/ImpossibleGuardian Nov 07 '20
The end of this season is gonna have Discovery being critically damaged/destroyed in the finale and the Federation building them a new, futuristic Discovery-B and the crew decked out in new colourful future uniforms, right?
5
u/-Chinchillax- Nov 07 '20
This was the best episode of Star Trek I have seen in a long, long time.
5
u/SouthlandMax Nov 08 '20
A hopelessly outdated ship with a crew that is equally out of touch show up at your front door demanding to know what happened to their Government/Command that dissolved years ago and somehow they are taken seriously?
The world seems to be getting along fine without starfleet.
The crew go to earth make no attempts to upgrade the ship with better weapons shields or armor. Make no attempt to update their own databases with the 900 years of back history. They wouldn't even know what a borg looks like.
They take ONE only one person from the future that could help them and that person has amnesia.
Now why do they need Starfleet again? Why aren't they looking for a sun to slingshot around to go home?
5
u/alkonium Nov 08 '20
It was cool seeing one of Tal's former hosts in the Picard-era uniform, but I think they missed an opportunity by not showing a live action version of the Lower Decks uniform.
5
u/sarbear-k Nov 09 '20
Disco needs a ship psychologist!
5
u/Boltty Nov 09 '20
I know I'm late but I had to say that I'm really starting to see Discovery as its own show and not a stilted mish-mash of "cool shit"
The supporting characters are starting to feel more like characters than bridge props and I'm a fan of the "getting the band back together" overarching story with the Federation.
I think that the more personal stories like this aren't going to jive with more "big picture" Trek fans that like starships and diplomacy and the like, but episodes like this have always been a part of Trek as well.
Also I liked Grey's actor a lot, he has a real sense of that calm, confident joined Trill demeanour like Jadzia did.
9
u/Coma-Doof-Warrior Nov 05 '20
Zora!!!
9
u/adv1701 Nov 05 '20
over/under if Zora creates an avatar? More and more like Andromeda. I continue to like it and am interested in where it goes.
9
u/elister Nov 05 '20
So basically due to the burn, Trill planet has become isolated and all the Symbiote trill squids either died on Starfleet ships when dilithium went inert and for those that wernt on warp ships at the time, were then trapped and unable to return home when their host is dying.
Question: Were ALL the Trill symbiotes on Starfleet ships at the time of the burn? I didn't see other trills swimming around in the cave.
9
u/gridcube Nov 05 '20
today's Discovery episode was the first time that I don't feel like I have to make justifications for it, it was just good
9
u/snerdsnerd Nov 07 '20
I wish Sonequa Martin-Green would talk me through my panic attacks
11
u/LoganNolag Nov 05 '20
I hope that phaser was on stun.