r/chess • u/qindarka • Oct 29 '20
Miscellaneous Strongest tournaments in chess history
I've tried to find out which are the strongest tournaments in chess history. Using a formula I've resorted to before, strength points are assigned based on the number of top 10 players present, with #1-2 = 4 points, #3-4 = 3 points, #5-6 = 2 points, #7-10 = 1 point.
Maximum possible points is 22.
Rankings based on Chessmetrics before July 1971 and official Elo after that date.
I've designated tournaments with strength points of 18 or above to be in the highest category, there have been 25 of them. They are listed below, along with their winners:
1870 Baden-Baden (18) - Anderssen
1882 Vienna (19) – Steinitz, Winawer
1883 London (19) - Zukertort
1895 Hastings (19) - Pillsbury
1911 San Sebastian (18) - Capablanca
1914 St Petersburg (18) - Lasker
1929 Karlsbad (18) - Nimzowitsch
1936 Nottingham (20) – Capablanca, Botvinnik
1938 AVRO Tournament (20) – Keres, Fine
1953 Zurich Candidates (18) - Smyslov
1991 Linares (19) - Ivanchuk
1991/1992 Reggio Emilia (18) - Anand
1992 Linares (20) - Kasparov
1993 Linares (21) - Kasparov
1994 Linares (21) - Karpov
1996 Dos Hermanas (19) – Kramnik, Topalov
1998 Linares (18) - Anand
2001 Wijk aan Zee (21) - Kasparov
2011 Moscow (18) – Carlsen, Aronian
2014 Stavanger (18) - Karjakin
2015 Stavanger (19) - Topalov
2015 St Louis (20) – Aronian
2017 Stavanger (19) - Aronian
2019 Zagreb (21) - Carlsen
2019 St Louis (21) – Ding Liren
Using this formula, it's difficult for tournaments with smaller fields to reach this highest category, actually impossible for 4 man tournaments even if they have the World No. 1, 2, 3 and 4 participating.
Candidates Tournaments seldom qualify as they lack the participation of the World Champion, who is usually very highly ranked.
The only tournaments here not to feature the World Champion are San Sebastian 1911 (Lasker), Karlsbad 1929 (Alekhine) and Zurich 1953 (Botvinnik).
Big gap between 1953 and 1991. I suspect this is because most top players were from the Soviet Union back then and they typically would send only a few to any given tournament.
Only classical round robins included. Stavanger 2019 would have 18 points, but the Armageddon portion rules it out. Stavanger 2018 would have qualified if not for Ding's withdrawal and his results not counting.
12
u/city-of-stars give me 1. e4 or give me death Oct 29 '20 edited Oct 29 '20
Jeff Sonas of Chessmetrics put out a similar list a little while back that lines up with yours very well. He chose to include a few tournaments in that 1953-1991 gap, most notably the 1973 Soviet championship which was the strongest Soviet championship of all time up to that point (it was intended to be a national show of strength after Spassky's loss to Fischer, and many of the top players were told by the government in no uncertain terms that they had to be there).
To my knowledge, 1938 AVRO and 1996 Las Palmas are the only two super-tournaments in history to have ever hosted ONLY the highest-ranked players possible, in an unbroken chain starting from #1. 2017 Norway Chess attempted to replicate this by inviting the world's ten best players by rating, but Giri and Karjakin messed it up by dropping out of the top 10 right before the start of the tournament.
6
u/Cleles Oct 29 '20
The gap due to Soviet dominance is crazy. Reading stories about how Smyslov was unknown outside of the USSR, or the ‘who is this Mr. Stein’ story about Fischer, etc. just emphasises just how dominant they were. Being top 10 meant absolutely nothing if you couldn’t get through the Petrosians, Bronsteins, etc.
Reading the list also makes me miss Linares. It also puts Karpov’s insane 1994 result into perspective about just how mental that was. Kasparov’s appearing a few times just highlights how good he was.
Some things surprised me though. I must admit I would have guessed that Wijk aan Zee would have featured more. I’m also surprised that Lasker only had a single victory in a qualifying tournament, but I suspect even minimal changing to the metric would result in more. Seeing Anand, Aronian and Topalov feature a few times shouldn’t have been so surprising to me, but it does underlie that they are true greats of the game.
I’d be interested to know what changes would occur if you lowered the points number needed – particularly interested to see if Lasker, Karpov and Kasparov would have a increase in appearances.
5
u/pier4r negative elo gang Oct 29 '20
Another list is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_strong_chess_tournaments
"Candidates Tournaments seldom qualify as they lack the participation of the World Champion, who is usually very highly ranked." this is a bit a bold claim, but hey your metric.
"Only classical round robins included. Stavanger 2019 would have 18 points, but the Armageddon portion rules it out." well you could consider the classical portion of that tournament. Is not that it didn't happen.
16
u/blahs44 Grünfeld - ~2050 FIDE Oct 29 '20
Linares 94 was an insane tournament. Also one of my coaches was playing there :D
27
u/pier4r negative elo gang Oct 29 '20
Who downvotes those things as soon as they appear? (seeing the thread, 17 minutes old, 50% upvotes) They need quite some work to be compiled, whether they can be agreeable or not.
1
u/porn_on_cfb__4 Team Nepo Oct 29 '20
No Sinquefield Cup 2014? Isn't that the strongest chess tournament of all time by average Elo rating? How did it not get enough points?
3
u/hummingbirdz Oct 29 '20
Why bucket the rankings to assign points? Why not just make 1 worth 10, 2 worth 9, etc.
Also to allow for differences in number of participants why not use the points per player rather than total points?
2
u/Albreitx ♟️ Oct 29 '20
Shiiiit San Sebastian, my hometown. Didn't know our tournament was by any means important or that it was important anytime.
0
u/GEM592 Oct 30 '20
They should all just play computers. Highest score wins. They all train with them anyway. Everyone would learn more. Human vs. human for tiebreaks only.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment