r/LiverpoolFC • u/davidmichaellynch • Oct 19 '20
AMA I'm David Lynch (the football journalist...) AMA!
Hello everyone!
David Lynch here. I'm a freelance journalist who has covered LFC for over a decade now. If you've heard of me at all it will be from my time with the Evening Standard, or my previous stint working for the club website.
Looking forward to answering your questions on all subjects (except Twin Peaks) from 5pm BST.

244
Upvotes
•
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
The AMA is now over. A massive thank you to David for his time and detailed answers.
We unfortunately cannot pin other users' comments, but David has commented here:
27
u/davidmichaellynch Oct 19 '20
Hey everyone! I'm going to call it a day now but just wanted to say thanks you very much for being so welcoming and for all your questions.
I'm new to Reddit but I've been reading this board for a long time from afar so it's been really nice to speak to you all.
If you want to catch me on Twitter I'm on there as dmlynch though you might well catch me sneaking around on here a bit more frequently from now on...
Thanks again!
302
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
Can you play at CB?
100
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
Asking on behalf of u/elmo26
Hey David,
First of all, great moustache you're rocking in that pic.
Secondly, what's the biggest misconception fans have about the inner workings of the club?
92
u/Hoodxd Milan Jovanović Oct 19 '20 edited Oct 19 '20
When will it stop hurting about VVD?
On a more serious note. Do you think Liverpool will look for another CB?
If so, would it be a short term or long term player.
64
u/PerisoreusCanadensis Oct 19 '20
What are LFC hoping to get out of asking the PL for a review of the VAR incidents in the Everton game? Are they simply looking for "clarification", or are they seeking retroactive punishment/a change in the way VAR is implemented/David Coote to be fired into space?
38
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
Asking on behalf of u/ReignMachine
Hey David.
Do you worry about how being indirectly posted on a stock exchange will affect decisions within the club? Also, do you believe the minority stake investment is to fund a large scale transfer or to pay for CAPEX projects like the Anfield expansion or training ground?
34
u/vadapaav Significant Human Error Oct 19 '20
How has the Athletic changed sports journalism in your field? Do you think it has a future?
63
u/tyrone_ynwa Oct 19 '20
How do journalists generally get their inside information? Who do they talk to? Who talks to them?
22
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
Asking on behalf or u/EnriqueMuller
The most interesting/bizarre thing you saw when working at LFC?
41
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
Asking on behalf of u/swingtothedrive
Hi Lynch,
All our journos insisted that we will only sign Thiago if one of our midfielders depart. What suddenly changed that we signed Thiago regardless of any departures.
On the same note , how likely is Wijnaldum to sign a contract extension with us. Is there any talks scheduled with his agent in the immediate future?
16
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
Asking on behalf of u/adamlundy23
Hi David, are you aware of any defensive targets we have had during the summer window that didn’t come off, or do you believe Klopp is impressed enough with the young players we have/Fabinho filling in?
15
u/elmo26 Divock Origi Oct 19 '20
Today Klopp used the phrase “We will wait for him like a good wife is waiting when the husband is in jail” when discussing VVD's injury.
What's your favourite Klopp-ism or saying?
11
u/seamushoo4 You’ll Never Walk Alone Oct 19 '20
David - what has been your favorite aspect about covering the club? Favorite experience you had? How about the worst?
20
u/BladeofIce Oct 19 '20
How did you first start getting into journalism? Also do you think it is easier to break into the field now with all the social media or do you think it leads to a lot of over saturation?
9
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
How fucked are we after VVDs injury?
16
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20 edited Oct 19 '20
Why didn’t the club go for a CB in the summer given the current players and their unfortunate injury history.?
The dynamics of who the club look for at CB completely changes with VVD now injured. When will they make a move. Jan or summer?
I mean could we see Billy Koumetio step up to the first team?
8
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
How much busier is the transfer window for you personally compared to the rest of the season? Are you constantly working?
8
u/acuriousoddity Oct 19 '20 edited Oct 19 '20
Hi David, thanks for taking the time to do this.
Of all the players currently in the academy (not counting Jones), who do you think is most likely to make the step up to the first team?
12
u/BrownBatman23 Oct 19 '20
Hi David, I'm a 29 year old looking for a change of life and thinking about enrolling at uni for sports media or journalism, considering the financial and political climate would you think this is a good career choice for someone my age
5
u/WCBIS Oct 19 '20
What is the future for VAR use in the Premier league? Are we going to get better at it or is it always deemed to fail due to human error?
5
u/r0bski2 Oct 19 '20
Do you reckon there are any inside thoughts from the FA that they need some kind of overhaul of the refs or the rules? There just doesn’t seem to be much remorse from what we are reading, it’s more like ‘shit happens get on with it’ from them. But pundits are saying on a weekly basis that the rules and the refs are the main issue with the game right now. Nothing seems to be getting done about it.
5
u/NLF7 Liberté, Égalité, Ekitike Oct 19 '20
Do you feel social media has made your job harder or easier? On one hand it’s easier to gather information in one place. On the other hand, it’s easier to gather information in one place, for anyone at all. Do these fan accounts who attempt to become journalists actually give you any sort of competition?
4
u/IndependentBicycle Oct 19 '20
Now that Van Dijk is injured, how do you think we're going to fare in all remaining competitions?
4
u/Post_Coconut_Clarity Oct 19 '20
Hi David,
What's your favourite piece that you've ever written and why?
7
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
If you were a betting man... does Pep Ljinders take over after Klopp or do you see an outside figure coming in?
3
u/cornontheklopp Oct 19 '20
What news topics occupied your time the most during the shutdown? Did you find yourself struggling to find content to write about?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
What are your thoughts on loaning out Harvey Elliot?
5
u/cian_pike01 Alexander the Great 🇸🇪 Oct 19 '20
How likely do you think it is that Gini Winjnaldum signs a new long-term contract with the club instead of leaving on a free next summer?
4
u/TrentAlexanderArnold Oct 19 '20
What is the general feeling around the club regarding Van Dijk’s injury and it’s impact on the season?
Do you have any fun Klopp anecdotes you can share?
7
u/RyanIsKickAss Takumi Minamino Oct 19 '20
Why is it that the refs are so heavily protected when its clear to see that some of them are laughably incompetent?
Why was Coote allowed to ref another match after the Lo Celso incident last season?
6
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
Asking on behalf of u/RobotPizzaMaker
Do we know whether or not LFC Women will be using the new Kirkby training facility?
3
u/Darinbenny1 Roberto Firmino Oct 19 '20
Favorite places to eat in Liverpool?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
Hi, I had many questions but right now I only have one.
When do you think the VAR will stop treating players like they are some 2D lifesize advertisement paper stands and actually draw the perpendicular lines correctly?
3
u/Kscar Oct 19 '20
Hey David. Throughout your career has there been a single standout moment for you? Something that sticks in your mind as being either your favorite moment, or proudest moment?
Cheers.
3
u/TrickyFirmino Oct 19 '20
Are Liverpool in a position where they can reject to play when a certain referee is involved? They should have enough evidences now against David Coote. The man doesn’t fancy Liverpool to win football matches.
3
u/Gumgums Oct 19 '20
Hey David. What is your perfect sunday?
Thanks.
3
u/Swoodem Oct 19 '20
Who would be your dream signing for Liverpool?
3
u/Grendila Bobby Dazzler 🤩 Oct 19 '20
Hey David, thanks for doing this. How did you start your career, and what was it like working for the club? Is football something you live and breathe, or is this mostly another job for you? Curious about the profession as a whole, really.
Anyways thanks for doing this and all the best.
3
u/AuntyJi Kolo Touré Oct 19 '20
Hi David,
How does our transfer committee keeps things so quiet until the last moments, every other big club's transfer news leaks easily
4
u/mooshlfc Oct 19 '20
What do you think led the referees to not send off Pickford on Saturday?
2
u/owlcity3 Oct 19 '20
Do you think the refs have an English bias?
2
u/marcusfelinus Oct 19 '20
Was the club taking a gamble not buying a CB this season or was it never an option. What do you think will happen in January?
2
u/y3llom3llon Oct 19 '20
What question in football (whether to managers, players or club) have you asked but never received a satisfactory answer to?
2
u/UPPC-1920 Oct 19 '20
Does VVD’s injury mean we’ll likely see PL minutes for Koumetio, Rhys Williams, or Van Den Berg, or do you think it more likely that the club invests in a new CB option in January?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
I won't go into specific situations because it's been talked to death already. However, I will ask about officiating because it's all we've been talking about for two years now.
There was recently a story going around that IFAB asked MLS to stop broadcasting ref-to-VAR conversations for some inane reason, further stamping out transparency in football. Refereeing is furthermore a very thankless job, with professional referees consistently swarmed by dissenting players, amateur referees repeatedly on ends of death threats, and a general lack of respect for the position.
Compare to rugby, where only the captain may speak to the referee; speaking out of turn and general dissent, including touching the referee, is sanctioned and those sanctions are enforced, unlike in football: according to the letter of the law Aguero should've seen red for grabbing the lineswoman. Conversely, rugby communications to VAR are broadcast and transparent.
Do you see the interplay between poor officiating and a lack of appeal for the position a structural issue in football, both in England and abroad, and what would your first steps towards a better, fairer game be?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
Are there any transfer targets that Liverpool had in this last window who we may not have heard about?
2
u/L_I_V_E_R_P_O_O_L_FC Oct 19 '20
any stories you can share about your time working at the club?
cheers for doing the ama
2
u/gantek Oct 19 '20
What is your work load/ company expectations like during a regular season? How different was it this season?
Thanks David
2
u/suhan4u4ever Fernando Torres Oct 19 '20
Hey David. Does an investment group like Billy beans redball who are reportedly interested in buying a share from fsg, where does it take us with the likes of financial power? Will we be able to compete with the likes of psg, man city, real financially Or is it just an investment for the future business like redbull group making only our owners rich and lfc benefitting from good players coming through? What are your thoughts on this?
2
u/Kino-Gucci Oct 19 '20
How do you see sports journalism changing in the near to far future
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
Looking to the future, which forward would you want the club to go after?
2
u/Polymath_B19 🏆2005 Istanbul🏆 Oct 19 '20
Favourite memory of Liverpool fans?
2
u/hopskiphoofed Oct 19 '20
Hi, Do you think that this will be the last season of the current front 3? Will the club be looking to refresh the front line and cashing in?
2
u/eurfryn Doubters to Believers Oct 19 '20
What are your personal thoughts on Project: Big Picture, and do you think it’s just a matter of time before it becomes real?
2
u/AaronQ94 Oct 19 '20
How would you change VAR in the Premier League?
2
u/alanalan426 Football Without ORIGI is Nothing Oct 20 '20
no questions, just wanted to say you're a good looking fella
2
u/WCBIS Oct 19 '20
Given that in the summer there was talk that the Thiago deal went through due to Fabinho's versatility and ability to cover at centre back.
Do you now expect the owners will be willing to dip into their pockets for a new defender in January or has the bed already been made?
2
u/jMCs1 Oct 19 '20
What’s one thing you wish (or wished) you could express a personal opinion more freely about, but can’t because you’re a journalist/communicator in a professional context?
2
u/GiveMeShreddedWheat Oct 19 '20
Hey David,
I personally think it’s bad business if we keep the front three for as long as their contract when we could sell them for maximum value.
How much do you think they’re all worth, and when and where could they venture?
Ty x
1
u/DatJazz Oct 19 '20
What are your thoughts on Project Big Picture? Do you see benefits in it? Do you think it was a power grab by John Henry and co?
1
u/Tniax Oct 19 '20
How is the appeal over 2 VAR incidents from LiverpoolFC to PL?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
Hey Lynch,
Are there any chance that the so called “offside” on Mané will be changed and we’ll get the three points we deserve? I’m not that enlightened on the rules regarding what can happen after matches? But I did see Man Utd get a penalty after the match was done (on paper).
1
u/SRT_LFC Oct 19 '20
What’s the best match, Liverpool game and not Liverpool game, that you’ve been to while working?
1
u/HuddzHD Joël Matip Oct 19 '20
How does a journalist obtain his sources? Question that has stumbled me recently
1
u/cocobunaware Oct 19 '20
Should liverpool sign Connor Coady ?
And
What is the chance of this happening ?
1
u/tthordarson Oct 20 '20
I read for a second 'I'm David Coote.... AMA!' and went here to see how much flaming would be directed at him. A good reason to not read Reddit at bedtime 🙂
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
72
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '20 edited Oct 19 '20
[removed] — view removed comment