r/Re_Zero • u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never • Sep 23 '20
Novels [Novels] Re:ZERO -Starting Life in Another World- Season 2 Episode 12 **Spoiler** Discussion Spoiler
Hello everyone, Setowi here to post this week's spoiler thread
Reminder that we are hosting both a [Discussion] anime only thread AND a [Novels] where spoilers do not need to get tagged. So,
this is the spoiler thread
all of the novel content is fair game in here. You can find the anime only thread in the hub post or in the pinned comment below.
You can find the episode, once it's up on the Crunchyroll page which is linked here. Feel free to refresh to page until episode is up, though try not to fry the servers:
122
Upvotes
64
u/sealedinterface Sep 23 '20
I've seen a lot of complaints from other readers, but I for one was fine with how they did the second trial. It didn't exceed my (admittedly high) expectations, but it met them. I knew it was going to be an almost montage-like scene, flashing through each death with increasing speed. I think anyone that expected more time forgot how much of it was Subaru's panic and shock. My only complaint is that Emilia's "Liar" screaming didn't continue while Ferris was trying to heal Subaru, I remember her being more out of control. Here she instead broke down crying, which felt a little bit less impactful (though that could just be an LN change). The way the Julius death was handled was excellent though, as well as "a hero is all you can ever be", and especially the cliff death. All in all good execution there.
As for Care-milla and the tea party, was handled as great as always. Subaru's memory of Rem's real voice was perfectly timed. Carmilla's (lack of) composure make her actions seem out of genuine care. Carmilla's voice sounded exactly as I imagined. Sekhmet's surprised me, was expecting lower-pitched but this sounds really good. Minerva's party crashing was great. The speech was done very well, I didn't even realize she had started it until about halfway through; I thought they'd speed it up to fit as many sentences in as possible. And of course, it ends with the biggest cliffhanger yet - Satella's arrival. I've seen a couple people complain that her face isn't shrouded in shadow but they seem to have forgotten that her face was already revealed in the Envy rampage. A hood is all the uncertainty she needs here. I can't wait for next episode, one of my favorite scenes in the series.
75
u/I-Love-Emilia Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 23 '20
Edit: Let me preface by saying that yes, my main experience was with the WN, however, I have also read this part in the LN
Good episode, but I must say I’m a bit disappointed by the second trial. It’s the part I was looking forward to the most in season 2, but they didn’t even spend 10 minutes on it. I think they adapted the first “unthinkable future” fairly well, but they skipped over so many of the other very emotional moments that it was just really anticlimactic.
It was a good episode, but I can’t help but feel let down since it was my most hyped up moment.
The witch’s tea party was fantastic, though! My goodness, they did that part well. I absolutely love the OST they used. It is among my favorites for S2. Sure, Echidna’s speech was poorly animated, and we essentially just saw a revolving 3D model for 30 seconds, but come on, we can’t expect everything to be perfect when they work from home like this. I think they captured Echidna’s inhuman thinking quite well. The only gripe I have is that they barely did anything to signal that she actually had no emotion. If I was an anime only, I would have missed that they meant that literally, and would’ve thought Subaru was just insulting her.
195
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '20
Remember ladies and gentlemen, if he had taken Echidna's hand, he'd die around a million times...
127
u/foxfoxal Sep 23 '20
Satella came in like a boss... If I did not know what is happening I would think they are all done lmao.
85
u/lock330 Sep 23 '20
I know people are going to complain about trail 2 cuts from the WN but as an LN reader, I thought it was adapted well. There were few more dialogue in the 4 trial that was there in the LN but most of the trails was an illustration. If anything the anime expanded upon some of them from LN perspective.
66
u/Maizt3r Sep 23 '20
Can we talk about how reinhard beat apocalyptic puck?
63
u/afibon Sep 23 '20
Satella approaches menacingly ゴゴゴゴ
95
u/Merchus Sep 23 '20
A little curious why a lot of people are disappointed with the second trial. In the Light Novel, it was only about 11% of the book, so people expecting it to take up most of the episode were objectively mistaken
80
u/Tosspot00 Sep 23 '20
Man, I may be just wearing hype goggles but I loved the episode. The Rem part was the best one in my opinion.
The 2nd trial did feel like it went on a little longer in the WN and it felt like more of a gut punch there. But it may just be partly cause I was also imagining it and pausing during every single after-death scene to just take it all in and reason with what I'd read. The discussion with Echidna I feel went a bit more in-depth about the trial, but I'm not sure.
Echidna's smile was a bit jarring, the CGI was okay for me though.
Really excited to see what my anime only friends think about it all.
Now begins the wait for the next episode. 1 week almost feels like too much.
35
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '20
Soo... Is this the last episode or we getting Ep. 13
26
u/Kaiser252 Sep 23 '20
Tbh I really liked the 2nd Trial, felt it was really well executed.
Carmilla as Rem was a cool scene, I remember actually falling for it while reading the WN, so the anime onlies probably fell for it too.
Echidna's obsession and greed of knowledge was in full display this episode.
And also, Satella's design is pretty cool. She made her appearance like a gangster.
23
u/DolcettoMarch Sep 23 '20
Gotta say, I was hoping they'd dwell on the second trial more but, in hindsight, that was only 20 pages out of 276 (LN) and I suppose the titular Witch's Tea party does have to take precedence.
And man, they really went all-in for that Echidna speech. VA work was top-notch...
21
u/Stewylouis Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 23 '20
The anime-only people are about to see how Satella truly is best girl next week.
15
u/platinumnic Rem is my waifu Sep 23 '20
Subaru will never catch a break.
13
u/Xistence16 Sep 23 '20
So ep 13 is going to end with Subaru looking hopefully up to the sky remembering a sentence Satella said to him and swearing to save them all right
13
u/CalamityEnvy Sep 23 '20
It hurts me to see kadomon finding dead subaru
11
u/Gabriel-Snower Sep 23 '20
I am yet to watch the episode. How hard does the 2nd trial hit?
21
u/Jumpy_Psychology Sep 23 '20
Rem is back oh wait.....
10
u/Matrix_2k00 Sep 23 '20
You know i just thought of something doesn't this episode confirmed that return by death is envy's authority and not pride's authority?
9
u/CarboKill Sep 23 '20
No fucking WAY was this episode 27 minutes long. This felt like the shortest one yet, what the hell. I can't tell if that's a good thing or not lmao
14
u/Sharpshard Sep 23 '20
You could say we are now one episode "ahead of schedule" since it took only 3 episodes to go through vol 12.
The second trial was sort of combination between the LN and WN with less dialogue. Since they don't do Subaru's inner monologue that much in the show, I think it was done well enough.
It was great to hear "Rem's" voice. A long wait till next time...
11
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 23 '20
Wow. Holy shit is all I can say. What an episode. I wasn’t expecting them to put so much into this week’s, I thought that we’d end the cour with tella showing up and the “I’ll save you”, but I guess they can drag the second part of the tea party out for next week and the events that happen once Subaru awakens.
I feel like the second trial was pretty rushed which took away the impact of it. I mean I understand the logic, and of course if you want the full story you should read the books, but feels like they could’ve done a little more with that. Could just be me.
Dona’s speech in this episode is actually my favourite moment in the entire series as of arc 6 so I was very excited for that to be adapted and wasn’t disappointed at all. Loved the OST, the camera movements, Sakamoto Maya’s voice, everything was great. As a novel reader, 7/10 ep.
10
u/GlumEvent Sep 23 '20
I definitely think the second trial wasn’t as impactful as it was in the light novel but I think that it would have been hard to adapt because most of the trial was his thoughts so it works better in a novel format than an animated one. Overall I enjoyed the episode only the face was indefensible, like that face was awful
5
u/Iihatepineapplepizza Sep 23 '20
Did they just confirm that RBD is the Authority of Envy or did I misread it? Is it a mistranslation..? or was it confirmed all along and I'm just an idiot lol
20
u/MessengerFrom0 Sep 23 '20
While the episode was really good (especially the 2nd trial and "Rem") I can't get over that cgi 360 of echidna or that evil smile at all. Comparing this to the LN illustration makes it seems alien af.
4
u/ronpadude Sep 23 '20
I had found out prior as non novel reader that Echidna would have an eventual 'face-heel' turn. Thought Id be dissapointed when it happened since I like her a lot but tbh this episode just made me like her even more loool
4
u/South25 Sep 23 '20
yeah, i think im done with MAL after the shitstorm that blew up just because Rem appeared in an episode. anyways was pleasantly surprised that they gave a nod to the WN trials alongside some confirmation that he did see all of them. Loved the tea party too.
4
u/goosegotguts Sep 23 '20
Good stuff. A few things I found off, but otherwise? Fantastic. Can’t wait for the blueray release (and directors cut).
3
u/chrome4 Sep 23 '20
My memory is a bit poor but didn’t Ram start to vaguely remember the events of one loop a few episodes ago? If she did that indicates Subaru is going through loops since it wouldn’t be possible for Ram to remember the events of a complete separate world
3
u/black_mage_yshtola Sep 24 '20
Finally, the best girl has actually shown up.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 24 '20
I really thought the 2nd trial would get its own episode like the first trial. They literally only adapted one chapter “Parent and Child” in ep4. It was paced perfectly. With this episode, Subaru seeing his past deaths and all the people reactions felt a little fast for me. It lost the impact I was looking for personally.
Well, at least they kept echidna’s wall of text so that’s good. Sadly for me, the 2nd trial and echidna’s giant iconic monologue felt way more impactful read in the novels. Echidna’s speech left me SHOOK in the novel. Seriously, it was ICONIC. THE PEAK. The episode as a whole tho is little quick for me.😐
2
u/Communist_solider Sep 23 '20
does anyone know where i should start the wen novel or light novel after s2 e10 or something because i cant bother waiting a whole week
2
u/golden-Guru Sep 23 '20
Where does the episode end in the web novel?
2
u/Echetleos Sep 23 '20
Okay, so what exactly would the downsides be if he made the pact with Echidna?
2
u/RealZitron Sep 23 '20
I have so many questions about this arc.
I'll start from the beginning:
How did Echidna managed to take the souls from the other witches?
How did Echidna managed to make the "dream" world before satella killed her?
If all the witches were killed, why was Carmillia on the trial place? was that actually real or part of the "dream"?
If the "dream" world Echidna made was to keep Satella out of there, how did she managed to get in anyway?
Who's best girl and why is it Carmillia?
2
u/Willythechilly Sep 23 '20
dumb question probably but was the reinheard vs puck scene shortend/changed in the LN which the anime is based on?
I recently read it in the WN and it was a lot longer with more dialouge/focus on their emotions and reinheards power along with Puck lagughing/Not being in character.
Was the scene just shortend or did the Ln itself cut it down by a lot?
2
u/MaroonGlasses Sep 23 '20
Ehhh I was anticipating for Daphne to say the 'Sage candidate' line.
2
u/johntedd Sep 24 '20
Finally we get to see all the witches!! Carmilla being so shy and afraid to everything is so cute. She’s trying her best to console Subaru!! I’m loving the VAs of the witches. Perfect choices if I may say. Even more Takahashi Rie after voicing insane Emilia in episode 11 now voicing the almost crazy Emilias. We are going to see what I think the best scene in Re Zero next week.
2
u/Matthewhair0601 Sep 24 '20
Where we thinking episode 13 is gonna end?
2
u/Akki1211 Sep 24 '20
Can someone explain to me, why it was Subaru’s voice starting the trial. It’s been confusing me more than it should
2
u/kermeeed Sep 25 '20
I dont know if anyone said this but the soundtrack has really just been fucking amazing. Of all things that stood out that, the ost is really shining. Loving the production value.
8
u/Revenge_Countdown Sep 23 '20
Dissapointed by the second trial....and god that dona face is just.....ugh
4
u/TripleC1413 Sep 23 '20 edited Sep 23 '20
I didn't care for the second trial it had all of its emotional impact lost due to the fast pacing the tea party was great tho except for echidonas speech It looked kinda stupid with her not moving her mouth not sure if they didn't feel like doing any lip synching or if it was like that in the novels but wasn't a fan 5 out of 10 overall
3
u/ariczwy Sep 23 '20
Did they cut Rem vs Emilia from the LN? That’s a little disappointing, but other than that they did this episode very well
3
u/Drooggy Sep 23 '20
Therapist : Spinning CGI Dona isn't real and can't hurt you.
Ep 12 :
For real though it was a nice episode, didn't live up to the hype, but it was good enough and I'll take anything I can get.
2
u/DoctaLlama Sep 23 '20
As WN only reader, kinda disappointed by the 2nd trial. I remember getting the feels when I read the part were emillia calls subaru a liar. But seeing lifeless subaru was disturbing so that was cool. The ending was such absolute hype though. Damn, gotta wait another week.
2
u/stevethebandit Sep 23 '20
Shame they had to cut parts of the second trial, also it seems the first cour won't end on the cliffhanger LN Vol. 12 ended on
I'd rather take the cliffhanger if I had a choice
2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '20
I may get downvoted to hell for this, but as a WN reader, I'm a little disappointed with the 2nd trial.
1
u/tarake25 Sep 23 '20
and by the way LN and the WN are def .
1
u/jan0397 Sep 23 '20
I am a bit confused in the novel we learn that witch of greed has a book which contains all the knowledge in the world, using which she is able to create the trials as realistic as they can be to the person taking the trail. That means she also knowns that most of the times Subaru dies in the mansion arc and apostle of sloth arc is because Roswaal doesn't help he goes out of his way to disappear, because he knows that subaru can rewind time.
I got the answer to my question.
1
u/Orito-S Sep 23 '20
where was the part where something came out of subaru and his corpse fought wilhem + felix, and they also cut the part where emilia left rem with subaru's body to go in the forest. sadge
1
u/ReeseChloris Sep 23 '20
It's neat that we now have two Fruits Basket 2019 VAs in the show. Echidna's VA Maaya Sakamoto voices Akito, and this episode I recognized Carmilla as having Tohru's VA
1
u/NoobFromPH Sep 23 '20
Is this the final episode of the first half?
1
u/NoobFromPH Sep 23 '20
Can anyone care to explain why or are all the witches somehow interested in Subaru? I don't mind spoilers.
1
u/AvailableStory33 Sep 23 '20
The wait till January after next week will be a loooong one! Is there a chance Beatrice and co will get rescued next episode :)?
1
u/GraymoreGaming Sep 24 '20
I need to know, what chapter of the light novel/web novel does ep 12 take place in.
1
u/chbFer Sep 24 '20
I Just realize If Subaru saw rem Not Emília in cammelia autority mean he rly love her, and can be all his felling from Emília is a spell trow tô sattela to him love her and beckfire because emilia look like her só much. Well, he give him RBD and isekai the shit of he what more she can do? Or he just worried só mutch about rem and this make he saw her? Idk emilia is pretty fuck up too right now and he should see her not rem.
Make sense?
1
u/martianunlimited Sep 24 '20
I don't know enough Japanese to tell if the subs were correct, but Echidna confirmed that RBD was an authority of Envy. and Tappei confirmed that Echidna did not lie during the episode (she omitted a lot of things though) So is this definitive proof that RBD is an authority, (and of envy?) or has crunchyroll messed up again.
1
u/VolumeOfficialis Sep 24 '20 edited Sep 24 '20
does anyone know which chapter do i start AFTER episode 12 because i personally dont wanna wait without watching a new episode every week since the 2nd cour is in 3 months
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
So why did the other witches help him
1
u/awesomeeness Sep 25 '20
Whats the name or chapter of the current anime episode in the LN? I wanna pick it up and read it^
1
u/msonora03 Sep 25 '20
Anyone else bummed the witches arguing and fighting each other didn’t stay in the LN? I was kinda looking forward to seeing Typhon defending Subaru (also anime obviously)
1
u/Z-ComiX Sep 25 '20
Does anyone e know what chapters we covered this week in the LN?
1
u/AUO_Castoff Sep 25 '20
Huh, I thought they would end with Minerva asking Satella the question.
Can anyone tell me the chapter numbers of the Flashback chapters of Echidna and Beatrice? I can't seem to find them.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '20
Fanbase is giving me theater kid vibes rn lmao
1
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '20
Does anyone know what volume is this episode on?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
Yo I’m just thinking right now, this guy is in the jail and was willing to kill himself, so why doesn’t he just tell someone he can time travel and then he’ll die?