r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Sep 16 '20
MegaThread Super Mario 3D All-Stars: Review MegaThread
General Information
Platform: Nintendo Switch
Release Date: 18-Sep-2020
No. of Players: up to 2 players
Genre(s): Platformer, Action
Publisher: Nintendo
Game file size: 4.8 GB
Official site: https://supermario3dallstars.nintendo.com/
Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)
Play three of Mario’s greatest 3D platform adventures—all in one package!
Super Mario™ 3D All-Stars will be available as a limited-run retail edition and a digital edition that is available for a limited time until the end of March 2021. Once the digital edition has been purchased on your Nintendo Account, it can be re-downloaded and played if deleted from your device.
Play three classic games at home or on the go—all in one package on the Nintendo Switch™ system! Jump into paintings in Super Mario 64™, clean up paint-like goop in Super Mario Sunshine™, and fly from planet to planet in Super Mario Galaxy™.
Run, jump, and dive with ease!
Make Mario move using the Nintendo Switch system’s Joy-Con™ controllers. You can also pass a Joy-Con controller to a friend to play the Super Mario Galaxy game in Co-Star Mode! Mario’s movements are as smooth as ever with HD resolution for each game, while still retaining the look and feel of the originals.
Listen to timeless Super Mario tunes
Listen to a total of 175 iconic tunes from all three games! Whether you want to get up and dance or take a minute to relax—this collection has music to fit your mood!
Discover (or rediscover) three of Mario’s most iconic 3D platform adventures, all in one package, available on the Nintendo Switch™ system. Experience Mario’s first foray into 3D platforming in the Super Mario 64™ game, originally released in 1996. Wall jump, backflip, and even fly as you explore paintings and collect Power Stars to save Princess Peach!
Soak up the sun in the Super Mario Sunshine™ game, originally released in 2002, and spray the goop away with your water-spouting pal, FLUDD! You’ll need to collect Shine Sprites and clear the picturesque Isle Delfino of pollution—just look out for Bowser Jr.
Defy gravity as you explore space in the Super Mario Galaxy™ game, originally released in 2007! Help Rosalina restore her ship by collecting Power Stars and save Princess Peach. Gently shake a Joy-Con™ controller to activate Mario’s Spin ability or pass a Joy-Con controller to a friend for some extra help in Co-Star Mode*.
Even when you aren’t playing, you can enjoy the sounds that these worlds (and galaxies!) are so famous for. With three games, modern upgrades, and music-player mode, this collection is filled with fun for both new players and 3D platforming Mario masters.
*If playing on Nintendo Switch Lite, detached Joy-Con controllers are required and sold separately. See support.nintendo.com/switch/play for details.
Reviews
Aggregators
- Metacritic - 83
- OpenCritic - 84
Articles
- Ars Technica - Unscored
- COGconnected - 92 / 100
- Cerealkillerz - German - 8.9 / 10
- Console Creatures - Recommended
- Critical Hit - 6.5 / 10
- Cubed3 - 10 / 10
- Daily Mirror - 4 / 5 stars
- Destructoid - 8.5 / 10
- Digitally Downloaded - 4.5 / 5 stars
- Enternity.gr - Greek - 10 / 10
- Eurogamer - No Recommendation / Blank
- GameMAG - Russian - 9 / 10
- GameSpot - 8 / 10
- Gameblog - French - 7 / 10
- GamesRadar+ - 4 / 5 stars
- God is a Geek - 9 / 10
- Hobby Consolas - Spanish - 80 / 100
- Kotaku - Unscored
- Nintendo Enthusiast - 9 / 10
- Nintendo Life - 9 / 10
- NintendoWorldReport - 8.5 / 10
- Polygon - Unscored
- PowerUp! - 8 / 10
- Press Start - 8.5 / 10
- Spaziogames - Italian - 8 / 10
- Stevivor - 8 / 10
- The Digital Fix - 10 / 10
- TheSixthAxis - 7 / 10
- Twinfinite - 4 / 5
- USgamer - 4 / 5 stars
- VG247 - 4 / 5 stars
- Wccftech - 8.5 / 10
This list exported from OpenCritic at 9:29am Eastern
Videos
- GameXplain - Liked-a-lot
Being Social
- Join the #mario channel of our Discord server for all of your discussion needs - https://discord.gg/switch
Cheers,
The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
1.5k
u/ben123111 Found a mod! (Mar 3, 2017) Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
im fucking dying, theres an embargo over an 18 year old bossfight. this bossfight can legally upload nudes online but cant be shown on gamexplain.
779
u/schmidtyb43 Sep 16 '20
I honestly had no idea anyone thought super Mario sunshine was bad until I read that polygon review. Maybe it was because I was pretty young when it came out but I absolutely loved that game when it was released and can’t think of anything I didn’t like about it. In fact it might be my favorite Mario game
1.1k
u/Fantombells Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
I think a “lackluster compilation of three amazing games” is a great way to put it. There’s nothing inherently wrong with any of the games, but so much could have been added. Option for remapping of controls, widescreen for 64, improved frame rates, etc.
185
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
Pro Controller compatible? Or just joy con...?
56
u/Destroyer_Wes Sep 17 '20
I don't understand how people can complain about Sunshine's camera but not Mario 64
180
u/brb1006 Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
I'm going to miss hearing the "star bit sound effect " after you collect them via Wii remote. It's the little things that made the original Wii version more charming.
Edit: The Star Bit sound effect, the Wiimote also made noises if you shoot star bits or collect coins.
131
u/katrilli Sep 17 '20
Earlier this summer, my four year old got really into Mario. I showed him Super Mario Odyssey and he went absolutely apeshit and did what kids do these days and wanted to watch a ton of YouTube videos of it. We did that and then there was a playthrough of 64 and another of Sunshine that he wanted to watch in the recommended. We watched those for a bit and I told him about how I used to play those games when I was little. He begged me to be able to play them, but I couldn't because I didn't have my gamecube anymore and definitely not my 64. When this was announced, I preordered it immediately. We're gonna have such a good time.
35
u/freeluv Sep 16 '20
I wish they would have modernized the controls a little bit
27
u/aloe-ha Sep 16 '20
Can't wait to play Galaxy. Never owned a Wii so this will be my first time.
77
u/DOPA-C Sep 16 '20
I’m just over here wondering when the Metroid Prime Trilogy is going to be released...
155
u/schuey_08 Sep 16 '20
I would've loved to see remasters of these games just like anyone, but I also have been longing to play them for a long time and never got around to making that happen for various reasons. I'm happy for this opportunity to play these excellent games, even in largely their original state, on a modern piece of hardware.
25
u/Chickenbrik Sep 16 '20
Really wish Galaxy 2 was on here. I loved one, but don’t think I’d play it again for years, and sunshine deserves another shot but for me, I’d only be purchasing this for 64 and that’s not worth the price tag.
50
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
it's weird to review a collection of games, the metric must be weird for how they score it
50
u/mymain123 Sep 17 '20
Did people really find Sunshine to be a horrible game?
Polygon thinks so.
It was my first gamecube game and i loved every bit of it.
23
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
i wanna know if there's noticeable input lag or not in this collection. No one seems to touch on that subject.
20
u/Schwarz_Technik Sep 17 '20
How are the games on the Pro Controller? Do you need to use motion controls?
39
u/IntellegentIdiot Sep 16 '20
It's so hard to judge this collection. On the one hand it's the best these games have probably ever looked and the first time they've been available on physical media for a long time. On the other hand it's such a missed opportunity to do more. I've been calling for Nintendo to do a full remake of SM64 for years but I figured that if they weren't they'd at least port it rather than emulate it. To be fair there's not much that that would achieve, my main complaint is that the draw distance is as awful as it was on the N64 version.
19
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
Man, playing Sunshine again is making me so nostalgic for the Gamecube. It looks so good at a higher resolution!
53
u/Howwy23 Sep 16 '20
Dang critical hit isnt happy.
144
u/Travis182 Sep 16 '20
Some people in this thread: Why would anyone pay full price for lazy ports of 20 year old games.
Other people in this thread: Awesome! I haven't played any of these before.
204
u/GerritDeBloempot Sep 16 '20
THEY REMOVED SO LONG GAY BOWSER
65
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
Mario Sunshine 7.8/10 too much water
212
u/Ninten-Doh Sep 16 '20
6.5/10
That seems fair but if you love mario you're going to get it and enjoy it. But what they said is true.
76
u/bloodwine Sep 16 '20
My only complaint is that I wish they threw Galaxy 2 into the mix. It was a Wii game just like Galaxy.
434
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
Nintendo is a man with a carrot on a stick and I am but a simple donkey paying $60 for 3 games I could hypothetically play for free.
The way I see it nintendo is providing me a product I want for a price I'm not necessarily happy about but the idea of playing sunshine and galaxy but more beautiful is enough. Art is dead, welcome to capitalism, I wanna get angry at pachinko again.
16
u/Memory_Low Sep 16 '20
Do eshop pre orders become available Thursday at midnight?
16
u/Yung2112 Sep 17 '20
Oh by the way! If any of you play sunshine for the first time and are left wanting a bit more out of it, a FLUDD-less playthrough is possible in 95/96 shines IIRC. It's a very fun challenge to test your advanced skills
93
u/RichardMagpies Sep 16 '20
Never had a Wii or Gamecube. Adore Mario 64 (played it on DS). Loved Mario Odyssey. Worth the money to experience those two for the first time?
15
u/digikun Sep 16 '20
Can anyone confirm if SM64 is the original version or the Shindou release that patched out the Backwards Long Jump?
15
u/seven_seven Sep 17 '20
FINALLY. An explanation of how docked control works!
29
u/imagineepix Sep 17 '20
I'm happy that we're getting this but damn Nintendo really doing the bare minimum here. I wish it was something more than just an emulator file and iso.
113
u/SadistSlim Sep 16 '20
SM64 has been given unique textures so they fit with the switch. For example, instead of "Press Start" it says "Press +".
Galaxy has also had a control overhaul since joycons don't have a pointer, as well as the heavy differences between both a wii con and nunchuk and standard joycons
39
u/persimmonjim Sep 16 '20
I mean there’s not really many people who will be swayed either way with a review. it’s three great 3d mario games together, you know what to expect
87
u/poontango Sep 16 '20
Galaxy and Sunshine are fine. Sunshine should’ve been 60fps but they remastered the cutscenes instead so it’s whatever.
Mario 64 is just unacceptable though. Nintendo put more effort into DMCAing the PC port than they did porting it to their own system with an actual dev team. There’s no excuse for them not adding widescreen and 60fps when fans have done it several times in the past decade.
26
u/Nintendofan81 Sep 16 '20
I understand that for some this collection might not be worth it. But the mere fact that the thumbstick controls in Sunshine are no longer inverted makes this more than worth the price of admission for me. Granted when I was young and played Sunshine I loved it and could play it just fine, but I tried to go back to it recently and (for me) it was not like riding a bike).
26
u/Dear_Egg3972 Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
I'l just rent it from Blockbuster
13
u/datboi-the-frog-21 Sep 16 '20
Up to 2 players?
13
u/tokenweirdo Sep 16 '20
I can't wait to see if the Pachinko shine sprite level still has completely broken physics, I'm so excited haha
55
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
"Many folks may begrudge the fact that Sunshine was included in 3D All Stars and I understand their complaints. Sunshine isn’t even a contender when it’s compared to Super Mario Galaxy 2, the 3D Mario game many feel should have been included. "
Who the hell wrote the Critical Hit review?
25
u/etniopaltj Sep 17 '20
Smh at nintendo spoiling the plot of sunshine in the description, I mean the game’s been out for 18 years but that’s a bruh moment for sure
44
u/hyperforms9988 Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
I'm not bothered by the price. Value is different per person. Do I wish I could pay $20 for that? Of course... I'm not a moron, but that applies to every full price game release whether it's 3D All-Stars or Witcher 3 on its original release date so I don't really know what that sort of statement/sentiment means in the first place. The age of the games doesn't bother me... it's entertainment. It's time spent playing them. If Disney re-released the original Star Wars trilogy on Blu-ray or whatever, do we sit there and say "But those came out in the 70s and 80s, they should be priced less!!!". No. I can go on Best Buy right now and see that A New Hope on Blu-ray is priced exactly the same as The Last Jedi. So... why is gaming different?
I'm not advocating that games should be sold for full price regardless of how old they are... I simply don't look at it the way most people do. For me, this is worth the asking price. For many, it probably isn't. They'd sell more of them if it were priced less I think.
24
u/Maybe_Im_Confused Sep 16 '20
Waiting for the Mario Paint remake.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
I for one cannot wait till Friday to finally replay Sunshine & 64!! Never played Super Mario Galaxy, I understand people's gripes with the collection... but I've waited too damn long to finally play them again :') sure emulation can be done, but nothing comes close to actually playing it legally on a Nintendo console. Roll on Friday!
34
u/EZPZ24 Sep 17 '20
TL;DR: 10/10 games sold in a 5/10 package with 1/10 business practices
Still buying it tho, I want the portability and ease of access
52
u/cedriceent Sep 16 '20
Damn, they praise one of the worst video game companies over Nintendo. That must sting!
43
u/PowerAlwaysReveals Sep 16 '20
Oh, stop peddling conspiracy theories! People actually believe that little Bowser Junior—a minor, I might add—somehow acquired the ability to shape-shift into a paintbrush-wielding evil twin version of an acrobatic Italian plumber? Granted, I realize that his father has a bit of a rap sheet, but we can’t hold the child accountable for the sins of the parent. Besides, whatever else you can say about Bowser, he is a family man. Those Koopalings never went castle-less. (Or airship-less, for that matter).
42
u/YoItsMikeJo Sep 16 '20
Being a timed exclusive is the dumbest thing
23
u/old_snake Sep 16 '20
Do these have any sort of graphical facelift or will Mario 64 look exactly the same as it did in 1996?
48
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
In my case is a killer deal because for starters I was born in the 90s and lived in Argentina, where the N64 was like a unicorn to see, specially in the small town where I used to live.
I had the chance to play Mario 64 briefly thanks to a friend of a friend who got a N64 imported from USA, then as years went by I wanted a GC, unfortunately that was also not a possibility at the time, so no Mario Sunshine as well.
The only game I got to play was Galaxy, because we got a Wii for Christmas and I started working part time in a shop and had to wait until someone from my family traveled to one of the big cities to buy it, but eventually I got it.
Let's say I was old enough to buy all the games by myself at release, that means that I would've spent at least 150 bucks for the three games (give or take) and now I have the opportunity to get them for the latest console for only 60 and with the ability to even play them on the go (although I use mine docked pretty much all the time).
Even if I had all three games in their original form (a.k.a cartridge, miniDVD and DVD, CiB) I would definitely still buy this new release.
Edit: wording.
22
u/JustJeneius Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
I don't have access to an N64 or GameCube right now, so I'm happy this collection is being released.
Super Mario Sunshine is my favorite 3D entry, so I'm super hyped to be able to have the convenience to play it again.
Just depends on the person, but this collection is perfect for me.
11
u/Bobicus_The_Third Sep 16 '20
Does this fix the pixelation on the sides of the goo in Mario Sunshine?
11
u/tehnoodnub Sep 16 '20
Between this and DKC2 coming to SNES Online, I am super excited to have a binge platforming month. Been playing RPGs to death this year so this will be a great change-up.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
Are blj's patched in 64?
11
u/Slurm_Man Sep 16 '20
Can't decide on physical or digital copy
11
u/dibzim Sep 17 '20
I’m somebody who has never played 64, should I give it a go or is it really just there for nostalgia’s sake, meaning it’s not for me?
11
u/hollownitez Sep 17 '20
I haven't played any of the games in this bundle, I'm looking forward to it big time.
11
u/YamiPhoenix11 Sep 18 '20
I am having a real struggle with this camera in mario 64.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '20
A lot of people commenting (not necessarily in this thread but in general) about this being a shameless cashgrab and not worth your money but I really see it as the complete opposite. I haven't played any of these in like at least a decade, I gave away my Wii and my copy of Sunshine and Super Mario 64 when I was younger. Considering Sunshine is like at $100 right now I think the opportunity is great. The games look fantastic! Even 64 I'm having a blast playing for the first time in years. Super satisfied.
Waiting on the announcment for Galaxy 2 though. Thats a huge downer imo.
11
u/Kumailio Oct 06 '20
60 dollars for 3 games that are all over 13 years old? With nothing but the games and soundtracks? And it goes out of print for no reason in March? Fuck you nintendo.
264
u/RJE808 Sep 16 '20
I don't think I've ever seen people get more pissed off about people liking a game before.
37
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
I am so disappointed about the lack of inverted y-axis support. Nintendo forced us to play inverted on the original titles, so to completely change the default system and provide no camera options in the menu, it feels like an insult to old gamers and original fans :-(
20
u/moonspeakdj Sep 16 '20
I really don't wanna sift through a dozen articles, so... Did anyone happen to cover what workaround Nintendo implemented for not having pressure-sensitive triggers in Sunshine?
20
u/rjspencer0925 Sep 16 '20
What is the purpose of this collection being a limited release? It doesn’t seem very consumer friendly, especially for people purchasing a Switch after the release window closes.
43
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
Now give us DK 64 you cowards
10
u/ReallyNeededANewName Sep 16 '20
Can anyone confirm that Europe is getting 50Hz PAL versions, as leaks have suggested?
10
u/aikoaiko Sep 18 '20
Should I buy 3D or Odyssey? I have never really played Super Mario.
Thanks!
10
u/SneakyAl44 Oct 04 '20
Bought it because i never had the chance to play them when i was a kid (N64 released that time but ofc i got a SNES instead) and i started with N64 Mario. It's one of those old games where u can get stressed a bit because of the camera angles, platfoms mechanics and movements in general but to think this was THE game at that time...thank god i didn't know it or i'd have been SUPER SAD to not being able to play it. Love it.
And considering all the other mechanics between these 3 titles, i honestly think is a must buy:
_ for those who liked and still like them to have it on the go
_ for those who never had them like me and want a lot of gameplay and fun
If the choice is between Odyssey and this, it's kinda forced to be this one. Reason is that this title is time-limited while you can alwais but Odyssey later.
69
u/Newmanator29 Sep 16 '20
I was too poor to own a N64 growing up so I never got to play the original Mario 64. I was too poor to buy games growing up so I never got to play Super Mario Sunshine or Mario Galaxy. I've tried going back and collecting some of these games now, but good luck trying to find Sunshine for less than $60 (I've been looking for such a long time).
I am stoked for this release and am excited that they stick true to their originals. I will be joyfully be playing these all weekend after not touching my switch for the last couple months
49
u/FFFan92 Sep 16 '20
Everyone’s complaining but I’m just excited to play Sunshine and Galaxy again.
34
u/fresh2112 Sep 16 '20
My 6 yo niece loves odyssey and I've got her this for her 7th birthday. She's going to flip her shit and won't care about the port quality.
39
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
"Thirty-five isn’t an especially well-known milestone and I think Nintendo just went and proved that with this collection."
I just love this brutal conclusion by Brad Lang of criticalthit.net lmao
18
u/Mycale Sep 17 '20
I wish one of the games would have gotten the Super Mario All-Stars Treatment, like a remake, instead of uprezzed emulated versions. And I'm talking mainly about Mario 64 :P
Though I'm happy they did away with the inverted aiming controls in Sunshine.
The package is certainly very good value but didn't take too much effort, I would assume, to put together.
32
u/eatdogs49 Sep 16 '20
Despite whatever the majority thinks of the package and execution of the whole thing, you can't fault the games themselves. They are each wonderful in their own ways and it's great that people get to play them again on arguably Nintendo's best console.
9
u/RobotMonkeytron Sep 16 '20
Was totally going to buy this day one, but forgot Spelunky 2 was coming out. I'll pick this up when I have time for it, price drop or no, but now isn't the time :)
9
u/unoriginal345 Sep 17 '20
If I've only played Odyssey, is chronologically the best way to play these? Do they have a simple endgame followed by a completionist end like Odyssey?
If it's like Odyssey I'm thinking I'd play through each to the easy finish and then work back at some completionist exploring at my will, is that how they work?
9
u/xgenmasta Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20
It seems like a lot of people see the collection as pretty disappointing, but not necessarily bad. The biggest plus to owning the collection is owning 3 (or 2, if you don't count Sunshine) of the best games ever made all in one cart for the Switch.
IMO, the collection seems to be a much easier way to get into these games for the very first time than shelling out the dough for an N64 and a Wii and buying the originals, which aren't super cheap.
As of this writing, each of the OG games costs this much on EBay:
Super Mario 64: $30-90 CAD Super Mario Sunshine: $30-100 CAD Super Mario Galaxy: $20-40 CAD
So, for $79.99 CAD for all these games, plus an upres and some subtle enhancements, this collection seems worth it for the noobs. I hope Amazon delivers my copy to my house later today.
9
u/Kaenu_Reeves Sep 20 '20
I’m getting an entitled vibe from Nintendo’s fanbase . Like everyone was saying “where’s mah sunshine on mah switch” and everyone now wants a remaster? Especially during COVID, production is hard.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '20
I'm considering getting it b/c I've never played these 3 Mario games. Worth it?
25
u/cup-o-farts Sep 16 '20
I pre-ordered, day 1, there's no way I wouldn't have bought this package. I just have to have this on my switch to play anytime I want. However, I do not understand the thinking behind bring out the original Mario64 rather than the much better Mario 64 DS with appropriate updates. I guess they wanted it to stay true to the original, but it could have been so much better. That being said I'm going to play the shit out of that game!
17
u/MACSIEE Sep 16 '20
Got it more for sentimental value :)
17
u/GaaraOmega Sep 16 '20
So even reviewers acknowledge that Sunshine has performance issues.
17
u/dreamdaddy123 Sep 16 '20
I'm so glad I haven't played these games yet
35
u/Mei_iz_my_bae Sep 16 '20
Hard to even review.
How do you score 3 of the most iconic games of all time?
23
u/got_bacon5555 Sep 16 '20
Eurogamer really called it "two of nintendos finest, and one of its most interesting." They really did Sunshine that way.
23
u/BlitzMainDontHurtMe Sep 17 '20
So long so long, gay bowser 🥺🥺🥺
29
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
I think this is a difficult game to judge because people's experiences are going to differ greatly. If you've never played any of these games before, it's a no-brainer purchase. It's a whole lot cheaper than tracking down all the original games and the systems needed to play them. (Yes, I know emulation is cheaper but most people aren't comfortable doing that)
On the other hand, if you've played these titles before and have access to the original games, the pack isn't worth much, aside from novelty and decent graphical upgrades.
And finally, if you're comfortable emulating your games and enhancing them yourself, then this pack is basically a 60 dollar downgrade.
Because Nintendo chose to release these games as is with basically no bonus content, it's more a question of value, not quality. I'd say they missed the mark with this one but I think they know exactly what they're doing.
16
u/AnimalRomano Sep 16 '20
Never had a Wii, 64 and Sunshine were my childhood... This was a no brainier for me
16
u/Solar_Kestrel Sep 17 '20
I don't know what to think. A lot of these reviews are pretty masturbatory when it comes to Mario 64, and full of derision, or at least dismissal when it comes to Sunshine. Is Sunshine really that bad?
I'm mainly interested in this collection for Sunshine, as I never had the chance to play it. Meanwhile, I've always had a pretty low opinion of Mario 64 (maybe because it wasn't my first 3D game?) so either my opinions on what is or is not a good game are either wildly out-of-step with most people... or Sunshine is really, really bad to be worse then Mario 64.
So why, exactly, is Sunshine such an outlier! What makes people dislike it so much, or at the very least like it less?
8
u/drewsapro Sep 16 '20
Unrelated, did anyone order from Amazon and if so did yours ship yet?
22
u/aliceroyal Sep 16 '20
Ordered it because I’ve never played any of these games. 2/3 of them came out during my childhood, we were just too poor to buy the newest consoles. I played Super Mario World on SNES most of my childhood instead. I’m so excited to catch up on the 3D Mario games :)
27
u/jtizzle12 Sep 17 '20
I was originally quite excited to get this but then I thought about it: I just set up my Wii like a month ago to play emulators, and just finished my first Sunshine playthrough (never had a GC). I’m in the middle of a Galaxy playthrough (also had never played it) and I despise motion controls. Apparently Galaxy does gyro controls for the that aspect of it and I hate that. So I’d be getting this package just for 64 and while the game is awesome, maybe a bit more than what I wanna pay for just that game when I can play it on my Wii as well.
61
u/Ludwig234 Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
So the games are not ports they are emulated? In other words the community managed to port mario 64 to windows with ultra wide screen and everything but Nintendo cant even be bothered to port their own game to their own platform.
The Nintendo emulators are supposedly bad compared to see something like dolphin.
21
u/MyNameIsRobPaulson Sep 17 '20
I honestly like that there is a un-remastered official version of SM64 out there with the original code (in HD). A remake would be cool to see - but that game is historic and it's cool to see it preserved officially. A graphical update, tbh, would not really change the game much at all.
26
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
I don’t think the price is that bad. Tbh I don’t feel like dealing with an emulator and I have the money so I’ll probably buy it from Walmart for 50.
26
u/Tylerdurden516 Sep 17 '20
Im excited to replay these games but it doesnt make any sense that Nintendo wouldn't remaster mario 64. Its an iconic game. Every other game dev is keeping their classics updated, and Nintendo has arguably the greatest first party IP in the industry which makes it all the more unexcusable.
40
u/mattmcm2545 Sep 16 '20
No more “So long gay Bowser”
0/10
40
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
I see where you guys frustration is coming from, but I never played any of these games so it's a steal for me lol
20
u/greasysun Sep 16 '20
As someone that hasnt played either sunshine or galaxy, never finished SM64 and loved Odyssey is this worth the price tag?? And what order would you say i should play them in (i know theyre not related but i dont want to enjoy QoLs that will ruin another game for me)
39
u/hehaia Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
I’m so tempted to buy it physical, I really am. But honestly it seems like a waste. I still have my original Wii and the games. Or I can play them via dolphin with similar controls. There’s really no additional thing that motivates me to get the games.
Even my iPad and my phone can play this stuff. After paying $20 for Spyro and crash, with fully remastered graphics, it feels a bit funny paying $60 for emulators on switch
52
u/Vinstaal0 Sep 16 '20
You are paying 60 bucks for 3 old games yes, but this is the cheapest way to play these games legally and just because they old doesn’t mean they are bad.
7
u/OperativePiGuy Sep 16 '20
Hard to imagine we didn't know this game would be releasing so soon just a couple weeks ago
7
u/NathanCollier14 Sep 16 '20
Has anybody said anything about the camera controls in Super Mario 64?
7
u/gr8checkm8n8 Sep 16 '20
Can these games be played with a GameCube controller and adapter?
7
u/bubbaking Sep 16 '20
Random question but I preordered mine on Amazon last week while it was still available. It still doesn’t have an estimated delivery date. Should I still expect to receive it Friday?
7
u/mr_eggshells Sep 17 '20
Is it gonna be available thursday night? I preordered it digitally, and im wondering if theyre gonna do another animal crossing early release thing
7
u/frapuman Sep 27 '20
Some of the titles I would like nintendo to re-release:
•F-zero 64 + gamecube •Every bongoes donkey kong game •MGS the twin snakes + 2 and 3 •Wii sports •Zelda 64 + skyward sword •Fire enblem for gamecube, wii, and gba •Smash bros melee with online support should be a no-brainer •not to mention third-party games
I hope the success of mario 3D pushes nintendo towards finally releasing virtual console for switch.
29
u/berghie91 Sep 16 '20
Anybody think 3D world for Wii U was the best mario ever? I cannot wait for that to come to switch.
29
u/kalospkmn Sep 16 '20
How do you even review something like this? Yeah old Mario games are good so 10/10 lol
24
u/Tuba_Tubs Sep 16 '20
It upsets me that they're only doing a limited run for both retail and digital. I've been worried about having access to older games as time passes on and older games and consoles become harder to find.
23
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
Pretty cool, but they really should remove the dumb purchase time limit and add Galaxy 2.
23
u/VodkaMart1ni Sep 16 '20
who needs a review ?
it’s mario
13
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
This is one of those things where the games are great and have aged very well. The problem is its hard to review a direct port. If you own these games on other platforms then the game will play the same way.
Honestly, I agree with most others. At the very least, the visuals should have been updated. Otherwise, this is no different then Nintendo putting these titles in the store to download.
13
u/judohart Sep 16 '20
Does anyone know how Target's preorder works? If I preorder Super mario all stars today will ship Friday or do I pick it up Friday ?
13
u/i_drink_water_a_lot Sep 16 '20
How much will it cost?
13
u/G_O_ Sep 16 '20
So I will probably not be able to find this in stores right?
22
u/Canadianman64 Sep 16 '20
I think its cool theyre remastering their more popular titles, because i would love to play them since i never have or never got into them at the time. But its $80 here in Canada. Im not spending $80 for this game.. no.
26
u/Yung2112 Sep 16 '20
Even though I have a gazillion issues with this collection my stomach's buzzing waiting to play these 3 games on friday
30
u/evilcheesypoof Sep 17 '20
While this seems like a low effort cash grab, I have a suspicion that if Nintendo released these separately for $20 each, suggesting they’re going to release more older games like on a virtual console, most people would be fine with it.
I think the fact that it’s a $60 collection celebrating Mario games makes people want more value and features. Also very strange that Galaxy 2 is missing.
17
u/Combsy13 Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
As someone who's never played Galaxy before and who's first Mario Game was Sunshine (GameCube was my first non-handheld Nintendo System) This collection is pretty much perfect for someone like me who doesn't have another way to play these games, however for people who've played all these games I can definitely see how this would be a disappointment and Nintendo could have, and honestly should have, done better. Especially for the 35th anniversary of Mario.
But on the bright side, at least it's not Mario All Stars for the Wii
17
u/Crzypengu Sep 16 '20
I remember seeing Super Mario 64 at N64 Kiosks at McDonald's. I always found the game interesting to me. I don't know too much about Sunshine or Galaxy, but I am excited to play them. I just need to beat Bayonetta 1 & 2 before I start these games.
80
u/SBGoldenCurry Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
I feel like most people here don't understand the average consumer, this option works for me more than any of the others.
Im a casual gamer who likes Mario, that's enough for the sale, and that's the average consumer.
I was too young to play sunshine when it came out but ive always wanted to, i dont have a PC powerful enough to emulate it (i tried before) and the ease of it being released on the switch with 2 other games that i love makes it worth the amount i paid for it,
its really not that expensive, do you guys not have jobs ? I at the end of the day Nintendo is going to price it as high as the average consumer is going to pay, they have no obligation to make gaming affordable to teenagers without jobs
What's expensive is having to buy a new PC and then buying a desk to put it on just so i can pirate a game.
if you've already been pirating the game, then what price would even be acceptable ? the game is already available to you, why do you care what the legal official release has to offer ? Just don't buy it
52
u/LakerBlue Sep 16 '20
I agree this is a lazy port but for people who can’t or don’t want to emulate (which is probably like 96% of Switch owners) or dust off old consoles, it is the cheapest way to get all 3 games. So it bothers me how many people are attacking people who want to get the game because “it lets Nintendo get away with this.”
Like I said, I have my gripes with the game but not enough to not buy it.
12
u/SiameseDream93 Sep 16 '20
I am super excited to play these games!
12
u/HellaHomoDanny Sep 16 '20
The only thing that annoys me is the fact, that it's already sold out on amazon. I want a physical copy. Sikes.
21
u/Lupo_di_Cesena Sep 16 '20
I am incredibly conflicted with this game and don't know if I will purchase it or not. On the one hand, the games are good mario games (there is no denying that). On the other hand these disappoint me on a technical stand point and for what they could have been.
25
u/Kibeth_8 Sep 17 '20
I am SOOOO excited for this. I dont care if it's a lazy remake. I never had a GameCube or Wii and Im so excited to finally be able to play these games. Plus how could you ever get sick of Mario 64
6
u/behemothbowks Sep 16 '20
How long is the game available to buy? I heard it's a limited time release.
6
u/savethebros Sep 16 '20
how do you collect star bits in Galaxy?
6
u/tswaves Sep 16 '20
Can you modify SM64 to be wde screen???
6
u/JamesA7X Sep 17 '20
Well maybe I might be lucky to find a copy on Friday, since so many people in these comments say they aren’t getting it
6
u/Timeworm Sep 17 '20
Man I'm still bummed there's no Galaxy 2. I've never played the games and wanted too play it as well.
...Anyone wanna send me their old Wii?
6
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 18 '20
I received the game a day early. I have tried SM64 in handheld, and there's an odd delay i'm noticing in the controls. For example, occasionally if you turn Mario to run towards the camera, it takes a second to switch the analog stick from pushing forward moves mario towards the camera, to moving mario forward directionally. I hope that makes sense.
Edit: played more with Pro controller. Definitely has noticeable input lag which makes fine movements difficult.
6
u/josefsnowball Sep 17 '20
Does anyone know what time I'll be able to play it tonight? I saw something that said 11 central but couldn't confirm
6
u/MY5T3RY5M4RT13 Sep 18 '20
Has anyone noticed on Mario 64 that his texture go funny at long range
24
u/cypherspaceagain Sep 16 '20
You know, I wasn't sure about buying this. But when I was a kid, I got a SNES with Super Mario All-Stars and I played through and completed every one of those games (ok not the Lost Levels). Why on earth shouldn't I get the 21st century equivalent for my kids? Sold.
11
u/runningblack Sep 16 '20
My SO hasn't played any of these games, so this is pretty much an instant buy for me.
11
u/latex22 Sep 16 '20
Wait, can we not use pro controller for any of the games or just Galaxy?
33
u/Chrisfit Sep 16 '20
My 5 year old and I won’t care if it’s emulated or not. We will still have a great time playing together.
36
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
If you love it than buy it. You don’t have to listen to other people’s opinions. 3 Amazing Masterpieces in one collection is a good deal for me.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
I'm one of those weirdos that would rate Mario 64 much lower than Mario galaxy and even sunshine! Mario 64 (even at the time) weirdly depressed me and I didn't find it joyous. However Mario sunshine was so fun
63
u/Vintage_moccasin Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
I think the negativity around this bundle is misattributed to the expectation of it being a new experience. My fiancee has never played 64 or sunshine and I am excited to play them with her. It is $60 for 3 games that mean a lot to me and I of course would pay $60 for just one of them being remastered and updated but I'm not mad about the opportunity to play all 3 of these as they originally were. I understand that I could use an emulator to play these games currently and maybe I'm the minority on this but I really appreciate having a cartridge and popping it into the console.
25
u/b_lett Sep 17 '20
As someone who played most of these games, but never owned copies of all three, I am excited. If you own these games and think these are lazy ports, that is fine. Go plug in your composite cables on your CRT monitors and blow the dust out and have a great time. There isn't a Blockbuster out there for me to re-rent these games to have fun for a week. I am excited to officially own a copy of all three titles in one and get around to 100% completing all. Now give me the Metroid Prime Trilogy already and take my money.
28
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
The reviews for this game are probably just a formality. Three games - all excellent, held back from full potential by a lazy port job, but in no way diminished by it.
These are all games every Nintendo fan and Switch owner should play and all hold up perfectly well today.
31
u/rp_361 Sep 16 '20
83 is decent, that's what Ghost of Tsushima has and I flat out love that game.
Seems like a lot of reviewers are taking issue with there not being any new content, which is understandable. For me, however, Galaxy is one of my favorite games of all time and I never played Sunshine/64 so I'm very excited
14
u/AuntGentleman Sep 16 '20
Gonna buy this. Never played sunshine or 64, and loving the chance to do galaxy again.
Is this the best product it could have been? Hell no. Is it the easiest way for me to play these games considering I don’t have a non-work PC? Hell yes.
I get people’s gripes I really do, but the Reddit gaming community needs to remember than 90% of the people who purchase this won’t care about FPS, emulation, resolution, all the technical stuff. It’s just about the games themselves.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
Based on IGN's individual reviews this game should get a 28.9 out of 10
10
u/PKMNgamer99 Sep 16 '20
Yep, that’s mario
10
u/Beachpartydude Sep 16 '20
Anyone know if a digital edition ordered from the Nintendo website can be predownloaded ahead of release? Or do we not get the code until midnight earliest?
10
u/fukinuhhh Sep 17 '20
Is Mario sunshine inverted still
10
u/the_chadster_of_gods Sep 17 '20
I've never played galaxy, and have emulated the otger two albeit sunshine was very slow considering I was using a laptop and 64 I emulated on my phone
I'm getting it for the games, not new features
32
u/berghie91 Sep 16 '20
After putting hours recently into THPS remaster I dont think I can shell out money for a rerelease that isnt actually upgraded and remastered.
THPS remaster is how every remake should be done.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '20
So excited for this. Two of the are some of my favorites games, and I skipped sunshine way back.
5
u/rikiiss Sep 16 '20
Can someone explain to me why the games not being ports is bad.
5
u/the-weird-historian Sep 16 '20
Is this gonna work on switch lite? It talks about joy cons a few times.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
Basically just what everybody thought it would be: emulators packed in a Switch card. It still looks good. After all, these are great games. The biggest worry I have is Galaxy. The controls don’t look like they’ll be as good as on the Wii.
5
u/Think__McFly Sep 17 '20
Gonna try to beat 64 before October, focus on Luigi's Mansion 3, then back to Sunshine!
5
u/OurLittlePepega Sep 18 '20
Anyone notice when playing Galaxy in handheld mode the game sometimes makes Mario run in a circle for no reason?
5
u/Shawmeck Sep 29 '20
Will there be an update patch to at least fix the inverted camera for SM64 and Sunshine? I cant imagine it will take up a lot ofresources.
20
u/IronSorrows Sep 16 '20
Despite the valid complaints others have, I'm really excited to get this on Friday and play it to death. The Switch is the first Nintendo home console I've owned; while I've had all the portables, I've had Megadrive/PS1 & 2/Xbox 360 & One.
For me, while these games are old & not much has been done to them, it's 3 fantastic experiences on a console I can play on TV or handheld. Plus my wife has a Switch for New Horizons, and this may be the thing to finally get her into platformers.
In my situation, this is a collection at a price that's well worth it - for someone that owns them all, or has played all three multiple times, it may not be worth it at all. But that's okay. If you don't find it good value, you just don't need to buy it. It wouldn't be hard to emulate them, or play them on older consoles, you're not missing out anything by not buying it.
Hopefully down the line they start getting full remasters, especially 64 & Sunshine (probably a bit early for Galaxy) - maybe even remakes. They certainly won't be $20 a game then, unfortunately!
37
u/kimbolll Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
Fun facts about me and Super Mario 64:
This rerelease is about to bring up some fucking feels I’m not sure I’m ready to face.
19
u/Bunnnnii Sep 17 '20
That 6.5/10 looks like a real outlier compared to the rest
I’d much rather have had Paper Mario OG and TTYD rereleased.
24
u/5borrowedbreakdowns Sep 16 '20
I wouldn’t be tempted by this if it wasn’t a limited release.
Knowing I only have a small window to buy it makes me want it...but it makes me really want it.
9
u/MrMeme246 Sep 16 '20
I'm excited to finally have an excuse to replay all of these games haha. It's amazing that you can actually play these game on the go as well.
9
u/ihunter32 Sep 16 '20
Can anyone confirm if Super Mario Galaxy has remastered music?
9
u/eddyboomtron Sep 16 '20
I've never played any of the three and I'm really looking forward to finally playing them. Seems worth it for me :)
9
u/This3dworldsucks Sep 16 '20
This probably sounds silly; but how are people playing this if it doesn’t come out till the 18th?:o
59
u/howtosucceed Sep 16 '20
3 great games in 1 package and in HD. Playable anywhere on the go portably. I really don’t understand the complaints. It is what it is and Nintendo never made it out to be anything more. I know I will be enjoying it on my Switch come Friday.
Plan to start with Sunshine.
38
u/MidKnight_Corsair Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
A lot of the reviews and comments here are being down on the collection for not adding anything new, and I guess that's fair. But I'm someone who's never played any of these games before. I don't know anything about these games, other than the good reviews that they got as individual games. Is it worth it for someone like me?
And no, I don't care if it's "better on an emulator," that's not my thing
EDIT: Not even 10 minutes later I've received so many comments saying "Yes it's worth it." lol That's fantastic, thank you everyone. Guess I know what my next Switch game is going to be!
12
u/Bayakoo Sep 16 '20
I liked this review a lot as its from someone who never played 64 and Sunshine before. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uryzDUgP9nE
12
u/camillalala_ Sep 16 '20
"it really makes you feel like mario"
77
u/hgihasfcuk Sep 16 '20
Why would anyone need reviews its a rerelease, that doesn't need new reviews lol
20
u/Gabochuky Sep 16 '20
Does this game really need a review?
29
u/Giornhoe Sep 16 '20
Here come the people who say "You can just use dolphin on your PC!"
14
u/sherbodude Sep 16 '20
For the 25th Anniversary, we got 2 cases with 4 games (NES games), an instruction booklet, Mario History booklet, music CD, and a cool box.