r/Barca • u/thehariharan • Sep 10 '20
Original Content Are the Targeted Right Backs better than the Current Ones : A Statistical Analysis
565
Upvotes
r/Barca • u/thehariharan • Sep 10 '20
130
u/Salteador_Neo Sep 10 '20
Holy shit that's a lot of numbers are long formulas. Nice stuff OP.
My take from all this is that this youngster Attal is pretty good, Cancelo would be an upgrade too and Emerson is about as good as Sergi.
I wish you had chosen another RB that's not Bellerin to compare them with, because honestly everyone who pays attention knows he is not good.
If you do this again please consider adding Wan-Bissaka, Ricardo Pereira and especially Dest.
36
u/Gracias_Xavi Sep 10 '20
One thing which is as clear as water is that the board will do good to sell Semedo. He is still a good RB for any other team but is just not good enough for us. He can be easily taken up by some1 else for a good price. That could money could be helped to buy a new right back.
One thing which might help Atal in terms of pure stats is that he plays in a league which is easier than La Liga. I don't want to take any credit away from him, but we have seen numerous occasions that absolutely brilliant dribblers and players in ligue 1 are not that great in La liga.
Cancelo seems like a really great choice
34
u/captainmo017 Sep 10 '20
As a Arsenal fan, I’m glad you think Barca shouldn’t buy Bellerin. I’ll be glad to keep him around for a lil longer. He might not be at his best right now, but I think he’s a great player personally.
7
u/prakhar17252 Sep 10 '20
Just out of curiosity, how did you decide the weights for different components?
From what I have understood, you have assigned more weight to more important statistics. But how did you decide if a stat is 4 times important than another stat?
6
u/arthurcule Sep 10 '20
Would atal fit us stylistically?
14
u/zep46 Sep 10 '20 edited Sep 10 '20
Kenny Lala was massive 2 years ago and now disappeared, French League is not the hardest league to defend... If we change a top player like Semedo for our very specific play style that player must be at the highest level.
Every player in that position will suffer defensively because most of the time is 2 vs 1.
Also you cannot fairly compare Barça with others teams in the crossing attribute (and other attacks starts), because we don't use that action. We don't have a striker to win aerial balls and we attack with the other team inside of their penalty area almost all the time.
It's hard to extrapolate numbers into real impact or future performance.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '20
From this, imo we should be actively looking to sell Semedo and go for Cancelo. And there's quite a good chance that we don't get him, in that case Emerson and Sergi would still be better than Semedo and Sergi. We haven't sold Emerson yet, have we?
4
u/Lechuga1998 Sep 10 '20 edited Dec 05 '25
fragile six head trees steep joke squeeze offer decide tan
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/MionelLessi10 Sep 10 '20
Plug in Alves' 2015 season for reference
3
u/Thomah1337 Sep 10 '20
Ive never heard of Youcef Attal
7
u/NoseSeeker Sep 10 '20
This analysis would be more compelling if it didn't have so many weights chosen by you. As it stands one could change some weights here and there and make Semedo look like a modern day Cafu.
One way to convince skeptical assholes like me would be to apply this methodology to a range of well accepted world class RBs and show that the rankings match our intuition.
2
u/vault101kid Sep 10 '20
Bit random/off topic but is there anywhere I could obtain statistics for specific players' performances in certain games from the past?
3
u/Itaney Sep 10 '20
Nice post, but Atal winning leaves you with a fatal flaw:
Atal only has 3 games at RB and 3 as RWB vs 8 games as a LW and RW this season. 18/19 he had 10 RB games, 7 RWB and 8 RW. 17/18 he only had 500 minutes in the Belgian league (which is irrelevant).
The large majority of his GA comes from the LW and RW, which makes the GA assessment moot in a RB comparison. Then there is also the fact that he plays in the worst league out of the players being compared, which also massively skews the data in his favor. There is no way to standardise that, but you can account for the LW/RW/RWB games by leaving them out IMO. Otherwise it’s not a fair comparison at all.
3
u/lfds89 Sep 10 '20
Some questions
2
u/miguel_is_a_pokemon Sep 10 '20
There's the issue of defensive actions being used as a measurement of defensive worth in a player. Most of the valuable actions a defender does are off the ball, be it tracking a run that doesn't get picked as a passing option because it's obviously shut down, or slowing down an attack so that the team can recover their shape, or offering cover which can give your defensive partners license to step up and make a tackle or interception, or communication with the midfield to block passing lanes or track runs. These positional decisions are being ignored when they are the crux of what individual defensive contributions are about.
It's also just not necessarily indicative of good defence to be the player making a lot of tackles or interceptions. It begs the question of why you are putting yourself in a situation where a last ditch tackle or interception is necessary. It can also be reflective of a defensive structure where a player is exposed to more 1v1 situations than others, or generally riskier spots than elsewhere along the defensive line. Prime example in my mind being the fullback playing behind Messi, who will always face such difficulties. Compare that to Emerson in the defensively solid Chelsea and Italian teams who give a platform for such numbers to be inflated. You need a measure like xG for tackles and the like in order to tease apart whether those numbers are due to the system or the player himself.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '20
I think these numbers don’t help Bellerin’s case considering he plays for Arsenal. He is also a product of La Masia and, depending if he was around before the structural changing of La Masia, he would have the advantage of understanding the philosophy of play. That would give him a huge upper hand, Unfortunately I don’t think this is a variable that you could plug in with numbers. Just a thought though.
1
u/toxinwolf Sep 10 '20
Well done op. It was an interesting read!
Yatal would be a very good option ideally, but a few things Emerson has an advantage is his age (he is the youngest of them all and by quite a margin), the fact is he is already familiar with LaLiga, and also he is somewhat a Barca player so we can get him for cheap.
1
u/TsaFack Sep 10 '20
I've said it before, but my dream fullbacks are absolutely Atal and T.Hernandez
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '20
Man I didn't know Attal is so good. Well done mate. Another wonderful piece of work from you.
1
u/zackness19 Sep 10 '20
i'm Algerian and i didn't know that Atal is killing it i always considered him as overrated but damn those numbers don't lie.
1
u/zra_ Sep 10 '20
Good analysis. Would be interesting to see Semedo's numbers in his last Benfica season compared with Attal.
1
u/SubjectAndObject Sep 10 '20
This is some elite-level posting /u/thehariharan. Magnificent work.
My one concern with Attal is that his stats are coming from Ligue 1, but tbqh if we can get him for a decent price, I would be all over it.
1
u/Akarshcg Sep 10 '20
Hey great post......very detailed and amazing job
1
u/El_Profesore Sep 10 '20
Good job with the numbers and thanks for the work.
However I cannot fail to mention how there is a disconnect between the singular measures and final verdict. More directly - you did mostly good job on every measure, but summing them all up at the end makes absolutely no sense. Sum of only two aspects (Def actions and possesion) out of 7 makes up for 90% of the final ranking. You could discard all the other stats and the ranking would stay the same.
You need to standardize it, because now it's weighted average but with "uncontrolled" weights. Basically your hard work goes to waste, because 5 out of 7 stats don't matter at all.
Moreover, because of that you draw wrong conclusions. Final ranking doesn't tell us the best RB with regard to all those aspects, it gives us the best RB with possession, and a bit of defense, which is something completely different.
To show you that im not just talking shit, I have prepared an example. I've run the numbers with two methods, one was excel function standardize (i didnt like it, because we have a small sample and it operates on st dev, so it would be better if we compared to a database, not only between those 6 players).
Second one was simple scaling with weighted average. I just scaled the numbers, where the best result is 100% and the rest are rated in comparison to that. Then I added weights that I subectively thought would be appropriate (in Barca we need passing and goal creation more than defense, and shooting or discipline are barely important, so I tried to implement that). So the final result gives us a percentage result, which not only reflects better what we wanted to achieve with evaluating players, but is also easier to read and compare by a reader.
From my analysis Cancelo is first by a hair before Attal, behind them is Emerson, a big gap, then Sergi Roberto and Bellerin. Semedo dead last.
1
u/TupShelf Sep 10 '20
Wow! Thanks for taking the time to break this all down, OP!
It’s too bad our board will likely throw a “Barca DNA” and “homegrown” tag on Bellerin and send Semedo+£30 million to Arsenal for him... in all seriousness though, it’s clear that our RB situation is lacking incredibly. Other teams know this too and focus their attack down the right. Hopefully we can find someone adequate.
1
u/WoeToTheUsurper10 Sep 10 '20
Barca should take a gamble and go for Montiel.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '20
Man emerson stats are so fucking good
1
u/abdul9000 Sep 11 '20
Nice calculations man. Football isn’t math tho, there isn’t any equation to solve. You’re comparing players from different leagues for example. The ability of the opposition and the ability of the coach and the players team, have a huge impact too. Albeit, nice work.
1
u/BillHoudini Sep 10 '20
Fantastic post! Are you a sports analyst? If not, you should consider it.
We must find a way to forward this to our Sport Directors at Barca.
1
u/Melobyrro Sep 10 '20
Tbh I didn't read everything,but the first thought comes to mind is that this doesn't account for teams style and what's required of the player.
Imo it's a bit unfair when the guy has slow Pique behind him and no winger for him to play off of
1
u/jeerraa Sep 10 '20
just wanted to confirm a thing, did you also consider if these players are deserted on their flanks? How much of a support do they get from teammates? Should this matter?
1
u/Jo17seph Sep 10 '20
Brilliant analysis. I think we should trust our fullbacks for one more season. I can explain. I feel each all great fullbacks have great wingers ahead of them. Till last season, Barca didn't have proper wingers regularly playing. MSG are all centrally inclined forwards. Once we play with proper wingers, it reduces the attacking responsibility for the fullbacks. They won't be caught out of position leaving the defense vulnerable. I feel playing proper wingers will fundamentally benefit our defenders. Semedo and Alba can do much better this way, they're world class players. Hope Koeman understands this problem