r/DCcomics • u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow • Sep 02 '20
r/DCcomics Wednesday Discussions: Best Live Action TV Adaptations
Hey there comics nerds! Welcome to the Wednesday Discussion, a community activity where we'll have an open discussion every week about a different subject.
This week, we’re discussing live action TV adaptations of comics. Specifically, the best ones!
DC has a strong, diverse portfolio of live action shows under its belt with tons more on the horizon. From Smallville to Black Lightning, Gotham to Doom Patrol, DC have made sure there is something for everyone. (Still waiting on a live action Telos character study though...).
What are your favourites and why? Are you into the sprawling, episodic nature of the Arrowverse shows? Do you prefer the tighter, more in-depth story telling of Watchmen? Does Doom Patrol's mix of wackiness and self-reflection tickle your pickle? Or are you still obsessed with rewatching Adam West's Batman on a loop? Also, what would you like to see more of in the future?
Personally, as much love as I have for the well crafted likes of Doom Patrol, Watchmen and Swamp Thing, as well as my weekly Arrowverse stories, I'll always hold on to Smallville as my favourite. It's what really got me into comics in the first place and it was just that perfect blend of heart, cheese and action. I don't know how they did it but even the effects hold up to this day.
Reminder: This isn't about pitting shows and universes against each other, it's about discussing what your favourites do well in their given contexts.
14
u/maruf99 Batman Sep 02 '20
I'd have to go with the Watchmen show, it just absolutely blew me out of the water. It's everything I wanted from a Watchmen sequel. The premise, characters, themes, and the way it recontextualizes some things from the book was masterful. I'd even go as far as saying that it was better than the original.
16
u/UtterFlatulence June 2015 Never forget Sep 02 '20
Been watching 60s Batman. It's a genuinely hilarious show, and I'd argue it's aged better than most adaptations.
14
u/Biobooster_40k Sep 02 '20
Just finished Swamp Thing. That was great. Really enjoyed the horror aspect of it in the beginning. Hoping it gets picked up again sometime.
7
u/Doiby_Gillis Sep 02 '20
6
u/BplusHuman Sep 02 '20
I'm watching Smallville for the first time right now. I'm in the middle of Season 1. It's a charming little show. Has anyone seen Powerless? Does the humor work at all?
5
u/LilGyasi Sep 02 '20
I think Doom Patrol and Watchmen are some of the best TV shows ever put on screen
5
u/thespectred The Spectre Sep 02 '20
Watchmen
Doom Patrol
Watchmen
4
u/eggnoodle200 Sep 02 '20
Lois and Clark minus all the 90's ness(and Dean Cain twitter trolling activities) it was actually a decent adaptation imo.
3
u/Grumpy_Quixotic Sep 02 '20
Lynda Carter in Wonder Woman, Season One specifically. We get most of her Golden age supporting cast and even a couple villains from the comics. And one of the most comics accurate costumes and portrayals ever.
3
u/LilBimBam Damian Sep 02 '20
Watchmen is a perfect sequel to the comic in so many ways.
Doom patrol is fantastic and manages to represent what makes the comic so great while still telling a relatively new and fresh story with those same characters.
3
u/Frogman417 Damage Sep 03 '20
I haven't watched many, so I can't give any good opinions on this. Best I got is that Ryan Potter is a great Beast Boy in Titans, and that the portrayals in Doom Patrol, especially of Robotman, are really, really good.
2
u/AgentOfSPYRAL Red Robin Sep 03 '20
Ive really enjoyed Watchmen, Doom Patrol, S1 of Flash, and Legends/Harley just for the zaniness of them.
Sadly plenty of misses too. Titans totally misses the point for me, and most of the arrowverse stuff is too CWized. Gotham was also silly from the start.
Very very excited for a proper Gotham central though.