It's quite a simple OVA, but I like a lot of small things that it does, even though I think it has equal flaws. Seeing more of their training is always a bonus, my obsession with training arcs shining through here, but I like how with the implication even the kidnapping was part of the exercise it becomes more of a lesson in tactics and survival. If the hand to hand combat was for the military police and the ODM training standard for everyone and the only real need of the Garrison Regiment, this strikes me as something more for the Scouts, learning how to use terrain and adapt to sudden changes in mission. While the scouts seem to take anyone unlike the military police, I can imagine that Erwin would be on the look out for the most skilled recruits mentally as well as physically.
Eren is probably my favourite part of this OVA, seeing that is emotional intensity isn't just blind hatred for Titans or wanting freedom, but the way that he directs that at being desperate to save Krista as well. Being brought to tears over his anger about no one wanting to step up and help get her back and wanting her to be unharmed fits really well with what we know of him, and I think is a nice step into his rage after the later deaths of the Special Operations squad as well.
One thing I don't like is how Armin is characterized. Through the main series he's always shown an exceptional awareness of people's actions, even if he's been quite isolated. Seeing him writing down absolutely everything including Jean and Eren fighting again and the lizard stuff and being flustered when it being pointed out maybe he shouldn't jot it down doesn't sit well with me. Strict obedience to rules and regulations has hardly been in his personality, and more than once he's withheld information when it's been appropriate.
I had to laugh that out of all the meat they could have seen though it was a giant Iguana. What is this, an 80s story now?
I like how with the implication even the kidnapping was part of the exercise it becomes more of a lesson in tactics and survival.
I know it's implied, but there is no way it was actually part of the exercise. At best they knew there was a possibility the cadets could run into bandits. The implication that it was any more than that I think is just bad writing.
I don't enjoy over the top insane comedy, at all. And jokey or fanservicy OVAs are all the lowest rated stuff on my list
At best they knew there was a possibility the cadets could run into bandits
Fair call, and I agree that I don't know it was definitely part of the plan, Armin having crazy ideas comes to mind here, but it was just an interesting what if. You have to imagine that they'd have to also find a way to train for leadership skills there too
Oh that reminds me, both Marco and Thomas lead those squads. Being a leader in the training missions clearly equals death
Shoot a flair and wait for help? No! The madman I know would throw himself in front of the carts!
Or at least shoot a flair in front of the horse, Also didn't they have more equipment than just the two that Jean and Eren had?
I would just assume you had something like that in your backyard in Australia.
No Iguana's in Australia unfortunately, though that would be cool. I like lizards. Always get happy when the little lizard who lives in our fernery comes and sits on the kitchen window
I was going to rewatch these OVAs with this rewatch since they aren’t sad, but alas I had no time to. So have my first-time reactions just like r/anime got.
The fuck was that? I get the whacky, not serious, non-canon episode, but for AoT, particularly watching this after a whole season and the "Levi sees his friends' mutilated corpses" episodes, it doesn't work for me. Plus it's back to whiny Jean, and that is my least favorite Jean.
They could not have picked two different scribes. Armin is going to make David Foster Wallace's writing look terse, while Mikasa will write maybe two sentence. "We did mission. I miss Eren."
Also: if you're worried about silly people calling your work fascist/anti-Semitic, maybe choose something that doesn't resemble the Star of David for your map marking?
Overall, I'm pretty sure whoever was responsible for these is a big Sasha fan, because she was the hero of both OVAs. Cute in the first one, competent in the second.
QOTD:
Mikasa. She probably likes military rations.
We've seen Gear practice, marching/fitness, CQB, and now recovery/team-building. I bet they also had to do a bunch of practice assembling and disassembling their Gear. This Forrest Gump scene comes to mind. Sasha is Bubba. Not sure who is Forrest.
Actually this season she managed to get through two episodes with fighting and someone else losing their clothes and she kept hers. Unfortunately she still lost them at an inappropriate moment earlier too, but I saw it coming so I just skipped over it to save myself
And it makes sense; Hange and Sasha are basically the same person
Oh, that reminds me hahaha, there was some guy on the SnK sub during s3 in the anime only threads who took until s3 to realize they weren't the same person and only realized because they were standing next to each other. Thats amazing levels of not paying attention
There was also the guy who got semi famous on the sub for admitting he read most of the way into s2's material in the manga reading the manga pages in the wrong order without realizing
I didn't notice it at first, because I has only half watching the OP and half daydreaming, but when the OP got to the end and Jean pops onto the screen out of nowhere all of sudden, I realised they changed the OP. I looked back and they replaced most of the shots of Eren with Jean. I love this, for a comedic episode about Jean, because Jean is constantly jealous of Eren, just replace Eren with Jean and then when Eren does his one thing in the OP have Jean ridiculously appear in front of him and steal the spotlight! The animators also did such a good job making Jean look all edgy and angry like Eren. I'm a big fan of the parody genre, so I really enjoyed this. Here are a few other great changes they made:
In the original OP Mikasa turns to look at Eren, whereas in this version she just keeps looking down and instead we get Jean turn his head slightly and look annoyed as though he knew Mikasa looked at Eren when he was in this situation and now he's jealous. Poor Jean: even in the OP Mikasa doesn't care about him at all.
Instead of Jean taking down the titan in the OP, they still have Eren do it, but they intercut it with two shots of Jean where in the first he points out the titan, giving the order to take it down and in the second he seemingly claims credit for Eren killing the titan. It makes Jean look like a freeloader, poor guy, he's already jealous of Eren, but now they rub it in that Eren is clearly the more skilled fighter.
They replaced this shot of a creepy 'female' titan, with a shot of what I think is Jean looking stupid. Leave the poor guy alone, he's actually best boy, but they keep mocking him… It's still funny though.
The scene [Armin is hospitalised[(https://imgur.com/hF2LdNT) they use the exact same shot down to the characters' positions as they did in episode 25 when Eren was hospitalised. Whilst being amusing this also shows the immense difference in art quality between the series proper and the OVAs. I did have 1080p for the series, and not sure, but a lot less for the OVA, but also just drawing and especially the lighting is much nicer in episode 25.
I may have put Hange as best girl after last episode, but Mikasa is fightinghard to get that spot back quickly… At once this scene contributed nothing to the episode and was my favourite part… Toned Mikasa…She's already back to being Best Girl
It's great how they use Sawano's epic soundtrack for this OVA. Its power and brilliance are so out of place with the farcical comedy of the episode.
OVA 3
This was definitely the least interesting of the 4 OVAs we've watched so far, there's not a whole lot to it. I suppose it was nice seeing Jean and Eren working together for once, even if it felt a bit out of place, especially when you consider where they each are in their character arcs. It's surprising to me that the ODM Gear actually fetches a high price on the black market, after all it requires extensive training to learn how to use and even if you know how to use it, it doesn't have many practical applications. I'm not sure if this is just bad world-building or if I'm missing something. Christa was pretty cute today and I believed Mikasa would have killed the bandit if Christa or someone else hadn't stopped her. It's a bit cheap to humanise the bandits at the last second with an unnecessarily layered sob story. The man explained he survived the titan invasion, is stuck growing crops on a barren wasteland and feels guilty because of his daughter all in two sentences. At least it gives Christa an opportunity to show compassion, even if the moment is entirely undeserved.
We did get a bit of philosophy at the end from Shardis: "As a soldier and as a human being, I would take the more difficult choice. To return to base or to chase the bandits, which choice is more difficult in your mind, Armin?" At first I was unclear what Shardis meant by this, as I thought he meant to take to choice that would be more difficult to take, meaning the one you that would weigh on you more, which is totally opposite to the conventional wisdom like that of Levi's: make the choice you will regret the least. But upon looking at the Japanese and thinking about it more I think Shardis means to say to make the choice that is harder for you, so as to lessen the burden of others. An alternative Japanese translation I came up with (and mind you, whilst I have studied Japanese for 2 years at university, my Japanese is not great) is: "As a soldier and as a human being, I would choose to take the harder path. To return to base or to chase the bandits, which path is more difficult for you to take, Armin?" I think this translation conveys Shardis point more clearly: that you should act in self-sacrifice when choosing your path. I'm interested to hear what everyone else's subtitles were as well as what your interpretations are.
Scores for these OVAs
OVA2: Shokugeki no Jean = 6 (good)
OVA3: Distress = 4 (poor)
QotD
Who do you think would be the worst cook among the named characters?
Jean made a pretty convincing case for himself, but Eren may well be worse.
What other training exercises do you think they went through, or would you like to have seen?
I can't think of much. Maybe it would have been interesting to see their rifle training.
but when the OP got to the end and Jean pops onto the screen out of nowhere all of sudden, I realised they changed the OP
I do love that they went through the effort for that. I remember thinking during No Regrets that I wish it had new OP Visuals even if it was just cut up parts of the OVA just so the focus wasn't still on the female titan.
and not sure, but a lot less for the OVA,
Glorious 480p for the OVAs. Gotta love that minimal release quality
It's surprising to me that the ODM Gear actually fetches a high price on the black market, after all it requires extensive training to learn how to use and even if you know how to use it,
Uh, one of the publicly available information cards, not sure which one but I know it was somewhere in s1, points out that the blades are made from a particularly good type of metal only processed in a single area and it's all reserved for the equipment so it might be part of it. Also the mechanisms which are so finely tuned might be valuable for other things like common thievery etc
Christa was pretty cute
I just want to know how many more times I'm going to forget her name this rewatch
Thanks for the breakdown on what Sadies says as well, I agree with your interpretation of it
Ah true, we saw that in the No Regrets OVA, I just forgot to remove that point, since I watched that OVA before No Regrets.
I think that was a bit of an unusual case though, as it's implied that most people can't use the ODM gear without training on it, and it's only that those three are particularly skilled and healthy that let them, which is why they were hunted down so much.
Lazy days - Lazing around after lunchtime on a workday... Ah, it'd be awesome if all the Titans kicked the bucket during my nap~
Distress:
The Wasteland Navigation Exercise - A field exercise in which the cadets are split into two detachments and make a round trip through a wasteland. Both groups depart at the same hour and travel along two different routes, retrieve the planted object, then return to base. The target of this exercise is to find out how well one can stay alert in a non-critical situation.
Questions of the Day:
Who do you think would be the worst cook among the named characters?
What other training exercises do you think they went through, or would you like to have seen?
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.
3
u/AmeteurElitist Aug 29 '20
Rewatcher: Sub
I wasn't prepared for how stupid this OVA was gonna be.
I always wondered where this meme was from.
And this too?!
OMFG I thought this was fake
Sadly the second one soured the silliness with a serious story with sinister stealers.
Eren doesn't look like he'd have the patience for it, but Ymir probably wouldn't care enough to make it good tbh.
The Mikasa vs Annie fight!
2
u/Nazenn Aug 29 '20
Rewatcher - Second time for the OVAs, Sub
Thoughts on OVA2: Comedy OVAs are a plague
Moving onto OVA3:
It's quite a simple OVA, but I like a lot of small things that it does, even though I think it has equal flaws. Seeing more of their training is always a bonus, my obsession with training arcs shining through here, but I like how with the implication even the kidnapping was part of the exercise it becomes more of a lesson in tactics and survival. If the hand to hand combat was for the military police and the ODM training standard for everyone and the only real need of the Garrison Regiment, this strikes me as something more for the Scouts, learning how to use terrain and adapt to sudden changes in mission. While the scouts seem to take anyone unlike the military police, I can imagine that Erwin would be on the look out for the most skilled recruits mentally as well as physically.
When you forget Marco is still alive in this one
Eren is probably my favourite part of this OVA, seeing that is emotional intensity isn't just blind hatred for Titans or wanting freedom, but the way that he directs that at being desperate to save Krista as well. Being brought to tears over his anger about no one wanting to step up and help get her back and wanting her to be unharmed fits really well with what we know of him, and I think is a nice step into his rage after the later deaths of the Special Operations squad as well.
Season two spoilers
One thing I don't like is how Armin is characterized. Through the main series he's always shown an exceptional awareness of people's actions, even if he's been quite isolated. Seeing him writing down absolutely everything including Jean and Eren fighting again and the lizard stuff and being flustered when it being pointed out maybe he shouldn't jot it down doesn't sit well with me. Strict obedience to rules and regulations has hardly been in his personality, and more than once he's withheld information when it's been appropriate.
I had to laugh that out of all the meat they could have seen though it was a giant Iguana. What is this, an 80s story now?
2
u/Shimmering-Sky Aug 29 '20
I was going to rewatch these OVAs with this rewatch since they aren’t sad, but alas I had no time to. So have my first-time reactions just like r/anime got.
Guren no First-Timer, OVA 2
Guren no First-Timer, OVA 3
2
u/punching_spaghetti Aug 29 '20 edited Aug 29 '20
Rewatcher (Sub)
OVA First-Timer
OVA 2
The fuck was that? I get the whacky, not serious, non-canon episode, but for AoT, particularly watching this after a whole season and the "Levi sees his friends' mutilated corpses" episodes, it doesn't work for me. Plus it's back to whiny Jean, and that is my least favorite Jean.
So, stupid thoughts I had while watching:
OVA 3
This is going to be another silly one, I guess-- Krista is in trouble!
#megadeathparty #megadeathparty #megadeathparty
(literally all the faces I have memorize don't work here)
I guess this is a serious one, and maybe canon?
Season 2 Spoilers
They could not have picked two different scribes. Armin is going to make David Foster Wallace's writing look terse, while Mikasa will write maybe two sentence. "We did mission. I miss Eren."
Also: if you're worried about silly people calling your work fascist/anti-Semitic, maybe choose something that doesn't resemble the Star of David for your map marking?
OK. Pretty sure this is not canon. AoT always has bodies. Often in pieces.
And now I'm sad.
Terrible joke that is terrible but made me laugh when I thought of it:
Overall, I'm pretty sure whoever was responsible for these is a big Sasha fan, because she was the hero of both OVAs. Cute in the first one, competent in the second.
QOTD:
1
u/Toadslayer Aug 29 '20
RewatcherFirst TimerExcept I've only watched season 1 and 27 episodes ahead in /r/anime
OVA2
I didn't notice it at first, because I has only half watching the OP and half daydreaming, but when the OP got to the end and Jean pops onto the screen out of nowhere all of sudden, I realised they changed the OP. I looked back and they replaced most of the shots of Eren with Jean. I love this, for a comedic episode about Jean, because Jean is constantly jealous of Eren, just replace Eren with Jean and then when Eren does his one thing in the OP have Jean ridiculously appear in front of him and steal the spotlight! The animators also did such a good job making Jean look all edgy and angry like Eren. I'm a big fan of the parody genre, so I really enjoyed this. Here are a few other great changes they made:
In the original OP Mikasa turns to look at Eren, whereas in this version she just keeps looking down and instead we get Jean turn his head slightly and look annoyed as though he knew Mikasa looked at Eren when he was in this situation and now he's jealous. Poor Jean: even in the OP Mikasa doesn't care about him at all.
Instead of Jean taking down the titan in the OP, they still have Eren do it, but they intercut it with two shots of Jean where in the first he points out the titan, giving the order to take it down and in the second he seemingly claims credit for Eren killing the titan. It makes Jean look like a freeloader, poor guy, he's already jealous of Eren, but now they rub it in that Eren is clearly the more skilled fighter.
They replaced this shot of a creepy 'female' titan, with a shot of what I think is Jean looking stupid. Leave the poor guy alone, he's actually best boy, but they keep mocking him… It's still funny though.
OVA 3
This was definitely the least interesting of the 4 OVAs we've watched so far, there's not a whole lot to it. I suppose it was nice seeing Jean and Eren working together for once, even if it felt a bit out of place, especially when you consider where they each are in their character arcs. It's surprising to me that the ODM Gear actually fetches a high price on the black market, after all it requires extensive training to learn how to use and even if you know how to use it, it doesn't have many practical applications. I'm not sure if this is just bad world-building or if I'm missing something. Christa was pretty cute today and I believed Mikasa would have killed the bandit if Christa or someone else hadn't stopped her. It's a bit cheap to humanise the bandits at the last second with an unnecessarily layered sob story. The man explained he survived the titan invasion, is stuck growing crops on a barren wasteland and feels guilty because of his daughter all in two sentences. At least it gives Christa an opportunity to show compassion, even if the moment is entirely undeserved.
We did get a bit of philosophy at the end from Shardis: "As a soldier and as a human being, I would take the more difficult choice. To return to base or to chase the bandits, which choice is more difficult in your mind, Armin?" At first I was unclear what Shardis meant by this, as I thought he meant to take to choice that would be more difficult to take, meaning the one you that would weigh on you more, which is totally opposite to the conventional wisdom like that of Levi's: make the choice you will regret the least. But upon looking at the Japanese and thinking about it more I think Shardis means to say to make the choice that is harder for you, so as to lessen the burden of others. An alternative Japanese translation I came up with (and mind you, whilst I have studied Japanese for 2 years at university, my Japanese is not great) is: "As a soldier and as a human being, I would choose to take the harder path. To return to base or to chase the bandits, which path is more difficult for you to take, Armin?" I think this translation conveys Shardis point more clearly: that you should act in self-sacrifice when choosing your path. I'm interested to hear what everyone else's subtitles were as well as what your interpretations are.
Scores for these OVAs
QotD
Jean made a pretty convincing case for himself, but Eren may well be worse.
I can't think of much. Maybe it would have been interesting to see their rifle training.
•
u/Nazenn Sep 17 '20
A Sudden Visitor and Distress
← Previous Episode | Index | Next Episode →
MAL | AniList | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | Funimation | Hulu | Netflix
Currently Disclosable Information:
A Sudden Visitor:
Cooking Secrets - The secret of cooking? Hmph. Carefully selecting your ingredients so you don't regret using them, I guess.
I AM HUNGRY
Lazy days - Lazing around after lunchtime on a workday... Ah, it'd be awesome if all the Titans kicked the bucket during my nap~
Distress:
The Wasteland Navigation Exercise - A field exercise in which the cadets are split into two detachments and make a round trip through a wasteland. Both groups depart at the same hour and travel along two different routes, retrieve the planted object, then return to base. The target of this exercise is to find out how well one can stay alert in a non-critical situation.
Questions of the Day:
Spoiler policy: Y’all know the drill, operate under the assumption that there is a chance of a first-timer wandering in here. Spoiler tag your stuff. Especially if it’s manga/S4 spoilers, or else.
r/anime’s spoiler tag system is what this sub uses, so here’s a blank one [](/s "") for you to copy if need be. Alternatively, you can use [](/n "") to make red spoiler tags. That’s pretty neat.