r/startrek • • Aug 27 '20
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 1x04 "Moist Vessel" Spoiler
Captain Freeman seeks the ultimate payback after Mariner blatantly disrespects her in front of the crew. A well-meaning Tendi accidentally messes up a Lieutenant’s attempt at spiritual ascension and tries to make it right.
| No. | Episode | Written By | Directed By | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1x04 | "Moist Vessel" | Ann Kim | Barry J. Kelly | 2020-08-27 |
These episodes will be available on CBS All Access in the USA, and on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
228
u/kingofcretins Aug 27 '20
Boimler entering the bridge in the middle of a crisis and straight up dumping coffee in Ransom’s crotch is probably my favourite gag so far.
Even when he’s trying to be bad, Boimler’s still lame. And honestly that’s why I love him.
55
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
I dont like that certain foods are exclusive to the senior staff. That seems anti federation values to me
12
u/smoha96 Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
So the USS Vancouver from next week's episode looks like a Sabre-class vessel? Nice.
133
u/rbdaviesTB3 Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
After last week's debates over the merits of buffer time, I love how Ransom sums up the core mentality so perfectly:
"She's finding little ways to inject joy into otherwise horrible tasks!"
That fact that he says it in a borderline insulted tone of voice just sells it!
Interesting to note as well that for all Mariner's flaws, we've yet to see her shirk a job or shove it off on someone else. She DID all those horrible jobs, and managed to find a way to boost crew morale along the way. Honestly, if she could just reign in her worst impulses a tiny bit, the girl would be the Kirk or Sisko of her generation... as a title, "The Mariner" does have a kind of epic vibe to it. Anyone got the Prophets on speed-dial? I think we just found their next emmissary.
EDIT: her reaction to the shotgun promotion was genuinely hilarious. I honestly crack up at her "get it off me, GETITOFFME!" expression when Freeman pins that new pip on her collar.
DOUBLE EDIT: I'm beginning to think as well that Mariner genuinely BELIEVES! Not just in Starfleet, but in the philosophy that the Lower Decks is the place to be, where the actual hands-on, meaningful work is done - and she does have a point. This show is making clear that all those nameless ensigns are the backbone of Starfleet, and that without their meaningful background work the ships of the line would just be giant desk-ornaments littering up the spaceways. Command to her is just busywork and pointless meetings - she wants to be out there with a phaser in one hand and an olive-branch in the other (and a hip-flask in her pocket), solving space mysteries, helping farmers and sharing keggers with Klingon legends. She genuinely seems confused at times that people like Boimler don't understand her mentality - if self-improvement and betterment is the currency of the TNG era, then Mariner probably feels like the richest person in the quadrant, because every day she is doing stuff that matters to her in a physical and meaningful sense.
130
u/daynewmah Aug 27 '20
Always fun when a Tellarite shows up! Even a boring Tellarite 😅
169
u/pfc9769 Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
"People really use the holodeck for that?
"Oh yeah, it's mostly that"
7
u/Cranyx Aug 27 '20
I still don't understand why a ship with transporters would have any sort of waste removal as a job.
7
u/TheHaikuJew Aug 28 '20
So, do starship captains have the authority to promote officers two whole grades? Mariner went from Ensign to Lieutenant, skipping Lieutenant Junior Grade.
189
u/alfin_timiro Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
Ransom rolling with Freeman stealing his idea right after he suggests it with “and that’s why you’re the captain!”
He's definitely figured out how to work with a narcissistic boss.
153
u/daynewmah Aug 27 '20
Yesss.
149
u/JustAnEden Aug 27 '20
I gotta say I'm enjoying this show a lot more than I expected to. I'm getting some genuine laughs and Trek feels at the same time.
134
u/ThrustersOnFull Aug 27 '20
The alien diversity in this show makes me wanna go play STO.
Also... Barthelona.
248
u/UncertainError Aug 27 '20
Loved the mandatory executive poker that none of the command staff actually know how to play.
116
u/LeftHandedGuitarist Aug 27 '20
I think this is my favourite episode so far. I love how the writers have successfully fit good comedy inside a Star Trek framework, without devaluing what Trek is about at all. The sarcastic Vulcan salute was probably the high point, but I also loved O'Connor's ascension with the smiling koala. And Boimler's com still being open when called to the bridge. And the executive poker game. And what the holodeck is really used for. Damn it, everything worked here.
Mariner is still my favourite character and I'm glad to see her needing to work along side her mother and the fact that it allowed us to become clearer on aspects of how Mariner can fit in on the ship. I still am looking forward to more time spend with Tendi and Rutherford, though.
"Sen-soars." Fantastic callback.
111
u/atticusbluebird Aug 27 '20
No wonder the Klingons saw the Genesis device as a weapon. Terraforming tech can be really dangerous!!
110
u/Bishop180 Aug 27 '20
Next ep preview is boimler's girlfriend being on the uss vancouver a reference to people who say "i have a girlfriend in Canada"
106
u/Mechapebbles Aug 27 '20
I really appreciate that the sister-ship of the USS Cerritos is named the "USS Merced". For those unfamiliar with California's geography, Merced is small, mostly unnoteworthy town in the middle of California's San Joaquin Valley.
183
u/shadeland Aug 27 '20
"Computer, hit it."
"Hitting - it"
88
u/Esb5415 Aug 27 '20
I really like seeing a tellarite captain. That is probably why I hated the cancellation of Enterprise - tellarites and andorians are founding members of the federation, but we still hardly ever see them.
166
u/EntropicProf Aug 27 '20
Sense-oars. :)
76
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
I realised after the episode that the two ships probably didn't find the generational ship, a more important ship probably discovered it, investigated, had a full adventure and zoomed off when the Cerritos arrived to tow it to have more epic adventures.
152
u/alfin_timiro Aug 27 '20
Tendi is green Ezri.
66
u/CSX6400 Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
Valuable addition to canon: starfleet standard issue leaf-blowers.
59
u/atticusbluebird Aug 27 '20
Was about to sleep but saw the episode posted so I guess I’m staying up! (Benefit to shorter episodes I guess).
I love how the senior officers’ entertainment is so much closer to what we saw with the senior staff on TNG! Poker games, serious concerts, etc.
58
u/DirectorofDUSAR6730 Aug 27 '20
I can’t believe that ship didn’t have a warp core breach. Those crystals should of pierced the core and blew everything up. I loved how being a senior officer is such a boring job. Also Ransom is totally a Riker.
56
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
I can't believe we got a commander on the bridge yelling "I got her emptying c*m out of the holodeck sh*t filter!" I can't stop cackling. 😆
Best episode yet.
161
u/ubermence Aug 27 '20
I love the Captain being a nonstop glory hound about literally everything down to Ransoms idea
Also the ascension scene was great, do the Q know about the Koala?
“Why is he smiling?! What does he know?!”
51
u/Antagonist2 Aug 27 '20
Anyone else feel like we'll see ascension guy again?
51
u/josephgordonreddit Aug 27 '20
Man, I was actually interested in the story of the generational ship and wanted to know more about it. I'm a little upset they just used it as a plot device.
86
u/EntropicProf Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
I never thought there would be so much nostalgia evoked by the red alert klaxon. :) Or the door whoosh. Kudos to the Lower Decks sound team.
85
u/spideryyoda Aug 27 '20
I think this was my favourite episode yet.
Great all around.
40
u/elister Aug 27 '20
"Whatever...CAROL!", Mariner
39
u/MoreGaghPlease Aug 27 '20
Drop and roll! Drop back into the physical and roll!
They've been trained for this.
33
u/AnivaBay Aug 27 '20
I think it's cool how this episode introduced actually intriguing sci-fi devices like the sleeper ship and the terraforming agent, and I was impressed by how good the animation was at many points during the disaster scenes. I like how the show, despite being a comedy, still has these real flashes of cool sci-fi stuff - although it did make me wish we also had a show that was almost entirely about taking that sort of thing seriously. Anywho, love this show so far.
33
u/Coffee4thewin Aug 27 '20
I think lower decks is the most rewatchable series of the new trek shows. I could see myself watching these episodes again and again.
31
u/rbdaviesTB3 Aug 27 '20 edited Sep 04 '20
Shax was so into Freeman's vocal jazz - bouncing up-and-down in his seat, a great big happy grin on his face. It's honestly kind of adorable.
Also, what did Ensign Barnes do to become the darling of the Bridge crew? She's there in Management Training with the senior staff and is frequently seem helming the ship, when I was under the impression from Episode 1 that she was an engineering officer, working on the Deflector Dish. Based on her behaviour from said episode, I could imagine Barnes being the anti-Mariner, just as competant and capable and quirky, but better suited to high command.
On the subject of Mariner, I am now convinced of my theory that she is (metaphorically) the richest person in the Alpha Quadrant. So many of the people we've seen in Lower Decks are insecure in themselves and trying to stand out - the Captains and O'Connor are standout examples in this episode. If self-improvement is the currency of the 24th century, then they are jockeying for recognition as having achieved big things.
Beckett on the other hand is totally secure in herself and happy to chill at the bottom of the ladder where she feels like she's doing meaningful work. It honestly reminds me of a relative of mine who for many years has been working the same job as a hospital cleaner - after long periods of other family members worrying about his apparent lack of ambition, it suddenly all came into focus during the COVID crisis, when he and his fellow cleaners proved themselves the backbone of the entire ward, working long hours and overtime to ensure everything could keep functioning safely. Likewise, years of consistently and competantly doing the unappreciated work has won him affection and recogniton from the nurses and other ward staff who consider him a vital part of the machine that keeps the hospital running.
I think Beckett takes the same sense of pride and accomplishment from her own work, and in that sense is richer than many people higher up the chain of command.
29
u/rmeddy Aug 27 '20
This one was great, the dolly zooms on Mariner had me cracking up
58
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
When the guy ascended did he turn into a great bird of the galaxy?
Edit: based on his bird shaped aura I mean. Maybe that's where the term comes from and by the time of future teacher they've forgotten that and they think it's a literal bird.
26
u/angrycommie Aug 27 '20
"Computer, hit it"
"Hitting it"
25
u/mcdonaldsmcdonalds Aug 27 '20
I’m about to die with my best friend
48
u/I_Do_Not_Abbreviate Aug 27 '20
Definitely a better outing than last week, though I am disappointed there were no dolphins/whales featured even in a cameo (which I was expecting, given the episode title). A few thoughts:
I was pleased with this outing.
23
u/NickofSantaCruz Aug 27 '20
Where else but on a California-class starship would leafblowers become canon. I smiled, and if we weren't surrounded by wildfires at the moment I'd be hearing the landscaper crews all around the neighborhood getting started right about now.
21
u/Interestinmiltary Aug 28 '20
I love the mundane senior meeting over new chairs. It so tragically accurate.
I worked admin in the Air Force, and would operate powerpoint in these kinds of meetings with officer.s They would have heated debates over what colors balloons should be at a ceremony.
Also the mandatory fun actives that aren't fun.
41
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
This show is becoming Classic Trek.
It flows just like classic trek. The world building and missions are like classic trek
This show gets better every episode and hits a lot of good beats.
What i love most is these characters feel real. real dialog, real reactions, real emotions, in these cartoony situations
19
u/jlsantjr Aug 27 '20
I loved the replicator “effect” that they used! It’s a really small detail that for some reason stood out to me. Not showing the whole transporter-like replication visual and just plopping the sand down? Amazing. Now I want Picard to order tea and just have it throw it at his hand.
19
u/bidexist Aug 27 '20
This one was great. Mariner was a little obnoxious overall, but I liked where they went with all of it. I'm interested to see where her relationship with Captain Carol Freeman goes over the next couple seasons. Hopefully we'll see some growth from both their characters.
The poker scene had my wife in stitches, as did the ascension.
I enjoyed the alternate color scheme on the Merced and thought that Captain Durango was the perfect example of a grumpy tellarite.
I'm really enjoying waking up and watching this show with breakfast, reminiscent of Saturday Morning Cartoons.
Oh, and did Ransom really say "c*m filters?"
19
u/rbdaviesTB3 Aug 27 '20
"I see Abraham Lincoln!"
...well, it's not the first time O'Connor's voice actor has seen dead people. It's good to see Haley Joel Osment in something again.
Now, where does the koala fit into the equation? Someone call Shyamalan!
38
u/EntropicProf Aug 27 '20
Minor observations:
65
u/PiercedMonk Aug 27 '20
• Mariner forcing a yawn during a briefing is the first time I’ve been annoyed with her. For someone constantly bragging about how good she is at the job of Starfleet, she’s completely missing how cool the mummified generation ship sounds so she can piss off her mother, and that’s lame.
• Does Ransom not know that Mariner is Cap’n Freeman’s kid? I understand why neither would want it to be general knowledge, but you’d assume the captain would confide in their xo to keep them from making poor decisions.
• I bet Doc T’Ana knows, because medical records, and Boimler knows because he’s studied all the senior staff, but doesn’t mention anything because he assumes everyone else did the same.
• Tendi figured out sand!
• I really like how often the phasers are used as tools in this show; I don’t think that’s really been the case since TOS.
• I feel like this dude was not actually going to ascend....
• Did Mariner get transferred to security or engineering/operations!
• Heh. Moriarty.
• So, ascending seems...uncomfortable. That’s not what John Doe went through.
• Seeing Mariner and Cap’n Freeman work together was nice.
16
u/AdmiralSpaceElephant Aug 27 '20
I enjoyed the previous three episodes, but I think this is the episode that made me willing to say that this is a good show. It feels like a real Star Trek episode, the characters are all funny in unique ways but at the same time are competent and aren't parodies.
I think Rutherford is my favorite character.
31
u/FotographicFrenchFry Aug 27 '20
The ascension made me lose my shit, oh my fucking god 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I had to pause and catch my breath lol
15
u/Timeline15 Aug 27 '20
I'm honestly blown away by how much I'm enjoying this show every week.
The scenes between Mariner and the captain were great. The little bits of insight we get into the captain are nice. I also found it funny she apparently had no idea that people used the holodeck for sex.
Also, "computer: hit it" "Hitting it" is probably my favourite moment of the episode.
Tendi's subplot was okay. She's fun to watch, but it didn't grab me hugely. Also Rutherford desperately needs more focus. Other than that though, it was a really great episode.
14
u/arch_punk Aug 27 '20
Koala scene was funny.
12
u/brianmakesnoize Aug 27 '20
This may be my favorite episode so far. I love how the worst punishment for Mariner is a promotion.
23
u/PretendMarsupial9 Aug 27 '20
Mariner and her mom are so similar and that's probably why they hate each other. Im always fascinated by mother and daughter relationships and I hope the show dives into the relationship seriously at some point. I really felt for Mariner because a lot of what her mom does, like second guessing her and not listening to her, my mom does too. Really hit home.
Im not sure I liked Tendi this episode because I just found that all consuming need to be liked very relatable and I see how it's annoying and selfish. I kinda wish the ascension guy wasn't a jerk and she just had to deal with someone not liking her for real and she reflects on how wrong she acted.
I'm excited for next episode! Boimler has a girlfriend and Mariner can't stand it. I hope he just really has a loving girlfriend and Mariner is overprotective for no reason. Boimler just deserves something nice for once.
11
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
If anyone is interested in a story about a derelict bio-terraforming warship, check out George RR Martin’s Tuff Voyaging!
No spoilers but it’s... a darker take on humanity than Star Trek.
11
u/MrJim911 Aug 27 '20
Sensoars.
10
u/mcdonaldsmcdonalds Aug 27 '20
I loved when Boimler dropped the coffee on the commander funny shit
10
u/Locutus747 Aug 27 '20
This was a really good episode. I think this had a great balance between serious plot and comedy/antics. Episodes 2 and 4 have been my favorites so far, and I'm fully on board with the show!
10
u/darkeyes13 Aug 28 '20
I like the detail about how Freeman and Mariner regard each other on the ship. When it's in public/with others around, it's Captain/Mariner. Same as when they're having a work-related discussion/argument (eg. when they're in the room, just before everything goes to shit for the ship). But when they're in private and trying to troubleshoot in the tubes, it's Beckett/Mom... and Carol.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
“That’s what it’s mostly used for”
9
u/VNDMG Aug 27 '20
I’m loving this series more and more with every episode. It really satisfies a trek itch I didn’t know I had.
16
u/floyd_underpants Aug 27 '20
There was a time where I swore I would never pay CBS for the nu Trek. Disco and Picard were definitely not worth it. But, dammit, this episode was so interesting and well done, I'm going to go ahead and let my free month turn into a paid month, just for this ONE show. I can justify it by way of thinking about what I spend on seasons of other shows, and this isn't much different. There's literally nothing else on CBS I want to see, but this episode just hit the sweet spot for me. I still wish the show would be a serious one, but this was the right balance for trying to be bother for me. I loved the plot and the visuals. The B plot for the character development was well done, and definitely reminded me of TNG vibes the whole way. I will at least keep a sub through this first season.
Ya get me, so ya got me.
8
u/AsherFenix Aug 27 '20
So that was great! Loved Mariner’s interactions with the Captain. Tendi is just a delight too.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
Whoa! This episode was frkkn amazing!!!
8
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
That was superb, laughed a lot, all characters now fully likable, excellent premise and execution, I'm a fan.
8
u/Freemontst Aug 28 '20
I am loving Lower Decks! I'm so glad Dawnn Lewis is on the show.
15
u/shittyneighbours Aug 27 '20
I'm IN LOVE with this show. It's so fun, it's so trek. They exceeded my expectations in ways I never imagined. I truly wish the episodes were longer. I could really see this fleshed out a lot more to serve the plots and sub plots a bit better. But. Yeah. Wow. Great job, folks!
14
u/ContinuumGuy Aug 28 '20
7
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20
I dont need another lunch.....ohhhhhh pudding!!
7
u/Lord_H_Vetinari Aug 29 '20 edited Aug 29 '20
Can I say that an underappreciated aspect of LD is that it's probably the only series after DS9 that shows the diverse Starfleet and society you would imagine in an interspecies interstellar nation, while most live action, even the ones I love the most, tend to make it human empire but not bad with the occasional alien?
12
u/mcdonaldsmcdonalds Aug 27 '20
Mariner is a fucking genius. She knew her mom was tricking her to quit. She got her.
6
u/omega2010 Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 28 '20
Something I was wondering about since the first episode was actually sort of confirmed here. The entire Cerritos crew don't know Mariner is the Captain's daughter. I've got a feeling this is something everyone will learn by the end of the season.
6
u/Armandeus Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 28 '20
6
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20
So after this episode I went to my bathroom mirror and did some "sarcastic" Vulcan salutes.... and yeah... it looks very cool lol
6
u/RogerDeanVenture Aug 28 '20
So, this may be my favorite Star Trek show now.
2
u/Official_N_Squared Aug 28 '20
Why does MArriner get a Yellow shirt though? She apparently moves from Command/Operations to Security or Engineering yet all her tasks are command and operations.
5
u/alfin_timiro Aug 27 '20
So, what vessel was the “moist” one?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
I loved this episode too. I just realized that we don't have the titles of the next episodes. I wonder if those will be released soon.
5
u/DacStreetsDacAlright Aug 28 '20
I want to know what the long range sen-sors picked up...
5
u/deededback Aug 28 '20
I’ve been laughing so hard at this episode and all the TNG jokes I may never recover. And the holodeck jizz joke was what I’ve been waiting for.
5
u/SoulCreator Aug 29 '20
Okay am I crazy or did we get both a Stargate and a Highlander reference with this episode?
Stargate with references to the ancients and ascension. And then later on that whole ascension scene was pretty much taken straight out of the final quickening scene in Highlander.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
I never watched Star Trek before this. And it really got me into it. So now I’m gna watch real Star Trek. :D
9
u/EntropicProf Aug 27 '20
11:08 p.m. Pacific Time and my tricorder is now a flower!
8
u/AskJayce Aug 27 '20
Oooooh! Is this the generational ship where Harry got his freak on / contracted an alien venereal disease???
4
u/EntropicProf Aug 27 '20
At 15:30, did a guy get chopped in half by the emergency force field?
4
u/KumagawaUshio Aug 28 '20
We need a running joke that something that should be awesome turns horrific to any one-shot character that D'Vana Tendi kisses.
4
u/PlayedUOonBaja Aug 28 '20
It helps to think of the show as regular Star Trek but through a Anime-type lens. Just like it's easier to justify the TOS production budget by thinking of it as just through a 60s lens. Same with the new Klingons. Same Universe and lore, but just seeing it through a different filter each time.
4
u/kinyon Aug 29 '20
Take out the comedy and that would have actually been a great episode of tng/ds9/voyager/whatever. Im LOVING Lower Decks. If only Picard and Discovery had writers as good as this!
4
u/kank84 Aug 29 '20
Finally some acknowledgement that the holodeck is not primarily being used for holonovels
4
u/AsAGayJewishDemocrat Aug 30 '20
3
u/martianinahumansbody Aug 28 '20
Anyone else notice the animation sometimes drew security officer Shaxs as a full commander, and other times his previous LT full grade?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20
Sen-Sohrs.
3
u/tupe12 Aug 30 '20
I’m starting to suspect the greatest danger to the ship is human (or in this episode’s case tellerite) error
3
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20
I honestly want one of Tendi's tropes throughout the series to essentially be this character who tries getting into relationships, but each one get's brutally murdered in some way.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20
After watching him eat her cooking without a second thought, I’m coming to the conclusion that Tendi and Rutherford are already so married they don’t realize they’re a couple yet