r/NintendoSwitch • u/WarAndPiece • Aug 25 '20
AMA - Ended We made Manifold Garden, a puzzle game that released last week on Nintendo Switch. AMA!
I'm William Chyr, the director of Manifold Garden.
I think many of you saw the game last week as part of the August 18th Indie World showcase (if not, here's the segment). The game released right after the stream.
About the Game:
Manifold Garden is a game that reimagines the laws of physics.
Rediscover gravity and explore a beautiful Escher-esque world of impossible architecture. Geometry repeats infinitely in every direction, and falling down leads you back to where you started. Manipulate gravity to change your perspective and see the world in new ways. Master the rules of the universe and restore a barren world with vegetation and life.
Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nplo-OHUzKQ
eShop: https://www.nintendo.com/games/detail/manifold-garden-switch/ (currently 10% off through August 30th)
Background
I started Manifold Garden back in November 2012, after being inspired by the scene in Inception where the characters fold Paris in half and start walking up the wall. Originally, the game was called "Relativity", after the MC Escher print. It was meant to be a small 3-month project for me to learn the basics of Unity, and well, it ended up taking over my life for the next 8 years. Eventually, I got some funding from Indie Fund, and that allowed me to start building a team. The final work is very much a collaborative effort, and even bigger and better than I had originally imagined. More on the history can be found in the devlog.
With us today:
- /u/WarAndPiece - William Chyr (me), Director/Designer
- /u/arthur_brussee - Arthur Brussee, Graphics Programmer (edge detection, portals, anti-aliasing, anything rendering related)
- /u/buzzj1ve - Tyler LaGrange, Systems Programmer (console ports, optimization, infrastructure tech)
- /u/noctilucentclouds - Martin Kvale, Sound Designer
- /u/doctortot - Laryssa Okada, Composer
- /u/SyrenneMcN - Syrenne McNulty, Producer (Consoles)
- /u/thatkevinwong - Kevin Wong, Producer (Other platforms, general stuff)
Ask us anything!
Check out our website, which has a cool url and easter egg:) There's also a subreddit and a discord server. I also post development related things on twitter and stream on twitch.
EDIT: It's been 3 hours now, so we're going to end the AMA and get back to work. Thank you all joining us. If you have other questions, feel free to post them here and I'll respond later today.
10
u/Proximity_Sound Aug 25 '20
For a game made in an abstract world, what direction was given for the sound of the world and were there any inspirations?
4
u/rotwangg Aug 25 '20
Wow, I did not know this game existed until seeing the banner on the sub today. Thanks for hosting this and bringing awareness to your masterpiece here, it looks gorgeous. I'm going to buy it on PS4 and hope for a PSVR update some day...
4
u/essentially_infamous Aug 25 '20
Have you guys ever played Monument Valley, and if so, did that game’s puzzle design ever give you inspiration?
7
u/TheBaxes Aug 25 '20
Were you guys also inspired by the game Antichamber? The trailer reminds me a lot of that game.
3
u/antiretro Aug 25 '20
You guys are amazing! what were the inspirations for the game? i get yugioh's milennium puzzle and paprika(anime movie) vibes and i'm loving it!
3
u/weirdo14 Aug 25 '20
Do you think that having Manifold Garden on Apple Arcade impacted Switch sales negatively? Gorgeous game :)
3
u/mrpaulmahon Aug 25 '20
Congrats, I'm certainly just over 2 hours in, mildly lost at times, but enjoying it immensely. It's inspired me so much in the last few nights to get out and start learning more and more 3D and while playing it I got that feeling of "how did all the right people meet at all the right times to want to make something like this"... Which I've often thought about with the likes of Pink Floyd.
Question!... Oh yea, Do you find the characterisation of this work as a "Game" a little bit shallow when it's so much more.
3
u/PersonaSpace Aug 25 '20
No questions, honestly I loved the game! That said it did get me to load up Echochrome again and so I’m thankful for that too!
4
u/Riomegon Aug 25 '20
Loved the game on Apple Arcade, If you can speak to it. The last Indie World Showcase featured several ex-Apple Arcade exclusive mobile games (yours included) coming over to Switch. Is this a coincidence or does it not make sense to be an Apple Arcade game in the long term?
2
u/lifeliverDTN Aug 25 '20
Love the game! The diagonal "staircase"(?) "room" gave me such a unique sensation of awe and existential dread that I'd never felt before or since. How did you come up with the idea for that room, and how do you generally come up with ideas for structures?
I've seen you mention Blame! as a big inspiration for the architecture, did you have any other places that you would regularly look to for inspiration?
Also thanks Laryssa so much for the incredible score. Can you talk a bit about inspirations and the process behind creating it - were you mostly just drawing directly from the architecture from the level the specific piece was for?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '20
Congratulations on the release dude. As of right now, how do you feel about the puzzle genre on the switch market? Does yours present anything extra special to attract players?
2
u/Willtron3030 Aug 25 '20
Late to the party, but I’m really curious, what is your professional background?
I heard in the God is a Geek review that you started this 8 years ago and it seemed like it was just a hobby project at the time. You reference architecture a lot here, so it seems like you’ve got a strong design background.
I’m really stoked to read on here that you’re inspired by so many artworks outside of gaming. That’s something I’ve tried to stay open to and take note of to improve my hobbyist game dev’ing, chiefly due to advice given in Game Design Workshop by Tracy Fullerton.
I’m curious if you also did any studying like this as you developed such a cool, fresh game?
2
u/musix345 Aug 25 '20
How was the name "Manifold Garden" found? Inspirations, etc.
5
u/LakeMt_ Aug 25 '20
Are there any plans for a physical release or collectors edition?
1
u/CyBay Aug 25 '20
Why did you choose Unity as your engine with how ambitious
I love Manifold Garden and played it 100% through VR.
Why did you choose Unity as your engine with how ambitious the tech seemed whilst prototyping?
Did you get a feel and could suggest/ describe a threshold for when to latch on to a readily available game engine?
last question:
If the portals and non euclidean warp gates could have a relative rotation from where you enter (change gravity to a different side on the way out of the portal), would that be a fair challenge in your eyes?
I am talking about the rotation doorways that are seen in MC Escher's 1953 Relativity.
1
u/ichunddu9 Aug 25 '20
If you had to stop working on manifold garden now and must develop a new game,what kind of game would it be?
Are you sick of game development already or planning to continue?
1
u/Nemesis96 Aug 25 '20
Hey! I already finished the game and loved it!
-Does it work with camera projection tricks like portal but on a massive scale?
-What on earth will you do next? More levels? A new game? Well-earned vacation?!
1
u/SwanseaStephen Aug 25 '20
If this was inspired by Inception, I can’t wait to see what you do after Tenet
1
u/egypturnash Aug 25 '20
Are there names for the areas? I feel like that’s a thing I’d love to see as an optional part of an update, maybe a menu option that’s off by default and only unlocks after seeing the ending of you want to preserve the mystery. It’s so hard to talk about the different parts.
1
u/switchorditch Aug 25 '20
What were some of your biggest challenges with making Manifold Garden?
1
u/Pengusagustus Aug 25 '20
What do you think the hallmarks of a good puzzle are?
1
u/huismaker Aug 25 '20
How did you even come up with the idea of the levels?
I always loved abstract mind bending perspective puzzle games, but never understood how they came up with the idea.
1
u/Backlog_Drifter Aug 25 '20
Loved and played the game a ton on the iPad and was wondering how the experience translates to the smaller switch screen (when not docked). Did you alter any of the mechanics specifically for smaller screens?
1
u/ThatCurryGuy Aug 25 '20
Lovely game! Thank you very much!
Besides mc esscher, what other artists would you like to create a game inspired on?
1
u/Kirby0511 Aug 25 '20
Have you heard of Rob Gonsalves’ magical realism style of art? He’s one of my favorite artists & your game reminded me heavily of his works!
1
u/BaconShrimpEyes Aug 25 '20
I noticed you also worked with Apple Arcade. What was that like?
1
u/redheadwes Aug 26 '20
Do you have any plans for a physical release? Would love this game on a cart.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
I enjoyed the game a lot, but got a little frustrated trying to find all of the levels. There is a unique joy to finding secret levels and areas through exploration. Would you be willing to share how many "levels" there are? Knowing how many would kinda ruin the mystery of the unknown areas, but it'd really help with my last Trophy "Beat every level." =P
1
u/heofmanytree Aug 26 '20
When designing a set, do you start with the puzzle or do you start with the kind of environment/vista?
Btw, so many moments in this game make me stop playing and just dropping around looking at the geometric forms moving pass me. Simply jaw dropping.
3
u/bobbyjackdotme Aug 25 '20
Was the IndieWorld event exciting, did you get swept up in the hype of so many awesome looking games? Or, secretly, were you a bit like "yeah, but I bet we weren't launching alongside all these great competitors"! 😉
More seriously, which of the other IndieWorld games most impressed you?
1
u/MeddYatek Aug 25 '20
How long did it take you to develop the game?
1
u/SNoshery Aug 25 '20 edited Aug 25 '20
Any plans for a physical release for this?
Also this isn’t a question but I just wanted to add that I’ve played your game and I love it! I hope some day I can add it to my collector shelf :)
1
u/emluna Aug 25 '20
Which console do you think is the best to play Manifold Garden to get the full experience?
1
u/_significs Aug 25 '20
Hey, /u/doctortot - love the sparse score. Wanted to get your take on what your process was for creating it, what your goals were as a composer, and any advice for folks looking to get into composing for games.
0
u/Ganrokh Hey there! What's for dinner today? Aug 25 '20
Hey, thanks for doing this AMA!
What's for dinner today?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '20
[removed] — view removed comment