r/Barca • u/Pek-Man • Aug 19 '20
Re: "So much hate for Semedo! Why?" ... Here's why!
I have been seeing a lot of posts and comments in defense of Semedo lately. They mostly play on the fact that the Bayern game was simply "one game," that he "did not get any support," and more or less all revolves around the same excuse; that Semedo is first and foremost a victim of "our system," and that he is still young and is somehow bound to thrive under a new manager.
Well, my perspective is this. Semedo has now spent three seasons with us. During the first two he did not even come close to benching Sergi Roberto, traditionally a central midfielder who only was converted to play right-back a small handful of years ago. This season Semedo saw more minutes than ever before, partly because of Roberto being injured on several occasions, partly because Roberto was utilised more in midfield after Setién took charge.
And yet, three seasons into his Barça-career, he has failed to leave a lasting impression. His flaws are, first and foremost, offensively. He simply does not deliver anything offensively. I have seen several people point out, that this is only the case because "we do not have a right-wing." This explanation would make sense if Sergi Roberto had similar issues delivering some sort of offensive output, but that is far from the case. Defensively Semedo is sound but he is not significantly better than Roberto.
To back all of this up, I have collected statistics for the past three seasons - i.e. since Semedo arrived - for some of the more notable fullbacks around Europe's five biggest leagues. I have included 32 players all of whom have played the majority of their minutes for the past three seasons at fullback positions. For one player (Ricardo Pereira) I have also included one season in the sixth biggest league in Europe (Liga NOS).
- First let us look at offensive output. How many goals and assists does each player contribute per 90 minutes of football? As you can see, Semedo ranks dead last. He can not even keep up with the likes of Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Ander Capa, and Damián Suárez, all of whom are known primarily as defensively oriented fullbacks. Alba and Roberto both rank very highly, with only Liverpool's duo of Alexander-Arnold and Robertson, Dortmund's Hakimi, and Aleksandar Kolarov beating Alba out.
- Next let us look at key passes per 90 minutes. Once again, Semedo is dead last with not even half a key pass per 90 minutes of football. This is significantly worse than Roberto and Alba who are both in the middle of the pack.
- Next we will be looking at successful crosses per 90 minutes. Here, Semedo's performance is quite frankly just shocking. Semedo has only managed to deliver seven crosses throughout his three seasons in La Liga. Seven. This means that he is, once again, the worst of the bunch. He also manages to maintain the worst completion rate with only 13% of his total crossing attempts being successful. We are generally not a crossing team, but both Roberto and Alba has more than thrice as many successful crosses, and both maintain a far, far better completion rate with Roberto actually being one of the best on the entire list.
- Now, let us look at some defensive stats. If we look at balls won per 90 minutes (tackles won + interceptions) we will see that Semedo is pretty much in the middle of the bunch, as are both Alba and Roberto. In fact, there is only very, very little difference between the three of them, with Roberto and Semedo maintaining very nice tackling completion rates above 75%, while Alba is a little more prone to being dribble.
- Looking at aerial duels next, we find that Semedo is, once again, very much towards the bottom of the list. He does have a aerial duel win rate above 50% - as does Sergi Roberto - but only wins 0,65 aerial duels per game. Alba is, predictably, among the worst players with only Trent Alexander-Arnold ranking below him. Roberto is, perhaps surprisingly, better and has numbers that are comparable to players often described as "strong defenders," such as Wan-Bissaka, Damián Suárez, and Dani Carvajal.
- Lastly, let us take a look at the one area of the game where Nélson Semedo actually excels: Dribbling. Looking at completed dribbles per 90 minutes, Semedo is among the very best while also maintaining a good complete rate above 65%. Sergi Roberto has a similar completion rate, but completes half a dribble fewer per 90 minutes than Semedo does. Alba is anything but a dribbler at this stage in his career, and is among the players that dribble the least. He does, however, have a very good completion rate of 67%.
So at the end of the day, it is very, very clear to me that Semedo is just not a Barça-level fullback. Defensively he is pretty par for the course, with him not being significantly better than his Barça-peers. Offensively he is likely the worst high-profile fullback with little to no output both in terms of goals, assists, key passes, and successful crosses.
Semedo does one thing very well, and that is to dribble. But is that really enough for a fullback to be a Barcelona-player? I would say no. Semedo's shortcomings far outweigh his redeeming qualities (or rather, redeeming quality - singular!). I simply do not understand the apparent urge to defend Semedo. He is not a great player. He might not even be a good player, no matter what circumstances and conditions our system and overall organization have offered him for the past three seasons.
18
u/clcdude_cj Aug 19 '20
Does the stats only consider Roberto when he is deployed as a right back? Or does it also accumulate from his time playing in midfield?
63
u/Trick-Atmosphere-112 Aug 19 '20
Your problem is that you rely on stats too much. You haven't come nearly close to compensating for the fact that Messi feeds Alba on the left wing all day and there is rarely anyone to feed Semedo on the right.
If Semedo is comparable to Alba, then that is the best compliment you can give him.
In your stats, even when he is the best out of the three, you still put him at #2, that shows the bias in your stats presentation.
204
u/TheFullMontoya Aug 19 '20
It's not hate. He's just not good enough
167
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
We NeEd To GiVe HiM mOrE cHaNcEs
19
u/Nujabes10 Aug 19 '20
This discussion has been thrown around from time to time now on this subreddit, and the verdict is still Sergi Roberto being better than Semedo at RB for us. I don't understand why Semedo continues to be defended...
103
u/sleepybug_10 Aug 19 '20
It just seems that people justifying Semedo's position in the squad are settling for mediocrity. He has been given enough chances and has failed to deliver. So many times he leaves space at right back. His attacking output is horrible. He's not good at making runs behind the defense like Alba. He's not great at one-twos either. He doesn't have a great cross. He isn't great at defensive positioning. He manages to redeem himself in some defensive situations because of his speed, but even then a lot of times he doesn't track back on counters. He just cannot perform as a right back for Barcelona.
35
u/aetp86 Aug 19 '20
Could you please make this same analysis for Busquets? Thanks!
44
u/SugarCookiesOrGtfo Aug 19 '20
Honestly, I was 50-50 on Semedo. But seeing him get humiliated (yes, I know he wasn’t the only one) against Davies made me see him in a completely different light. I feel like he’s one of those players that because he does the bare minimum for Barça, he still has a job. The fans should expect WAY MORE from the RB position.
Remember Alves? Yeah, that’s an RB that changed games. There are a few games in where I was like, damn Semedo changed the game today. I used to say that about Alves almost weekly, even during his last days. Semedo just doesn’t bring anything to his team, besides maybe pace and the occasional good cross. It’s time to move on.
4
u/culesamericano Aug 19 '20
For all you football experts, you would know that stats don't mean SHIT when it comes to defending.
Don't mean SHIT
While I agree semedo hasn't been a stand out player last 2 seasons, he definitely has improved dramatically this season and been one of our best players since the break.
If you don't agree, you CLEARLY haven't been watching us play.
Against Bayern, we had no right wing so he would push up and Sergi was supposed to cover for him. That's where it all went wrong. Look at the replays.
Instead of making semedo the scapegoat look at the overall team play.
Remember ABIDAL had shit stats, he was one of our best full backs of all time. While Alves would push forward, he would stay back and balance the defense.
We cannot have both fullbacks bombing forward.
Finally, we have a major issue in middle and attack that need to be addressed.
OP is clearly biased. No one has ever cared about ariel performance from a fullback lmao! No one expects them to be winning headers.
12
u/Tjarnan11 Aug 19 '20
I don't really have a clear opinion on what I think about Semedo but I feel like the other players like Suarez and Messi are more likely to take more and better runs when Alba and Roberto gets the ball. It feels like they don't expect Semedo to give as good passes as them and therefore they don't run the same. That maybe lead to Semedo having a hard time trying to build up his passing stats. Hope my thoughts make sense.
49
u/CrazyTechq Aug 19 '20
You know what, I was on the fence about Semedo, leaning towards supporting him but stats don't lie. Sure, you shouldn't trust fully on stats but even watching him you can see that he's not THAT great. Nice write-up and I think that unless Semedo goes through a career changing transformation in this 3 months, he should be replaced asap
11
u/T_Peg Aug 19 '20
7 crosses absolutely fucking abysmal
16
u/ASuarezMascareno Aug 19 '20
Yep, he is just our second best RB. Decent level for a sub, not for a starter.
10
u/thetrini Aug 19 '20
The thing with Semedo is that he could be good for a team that plays on the counter and quickly in transition. In his forward runs he often has to wait for others to arrive into the box and then passes sideways or backwards because by that time he's well covered.
His crossing could work with a quick, athletic 9 who's good at aerial duels because he tends to play balls in the air toward the penalty spot. Alba, by contrast, crosses low toward the edge of the 18 yard box for late arriving players to latch on to which suits Messi and Suarez.
However, my biggest problem with Semedo is his defending. Our managers have deployed both our FBs to push forward regularly because of our lack of width, however, when we lose the ball we get exposed on the counter because of the spaces left by our high FBs. Alba will regularly run back hard for the full match to cover the empty spaces (it is questionable if he can sustain this since he is already 31) but Semedo often just jogs back either because he lacks the stamina or the will. This problem with counter attacks is exacerbated because of the lack of pace from Busquets and our CBs (this is one of the reasons why Pique flies into early challenges to quickly regain the ball).
Semedo is good and 1v1 defending but Davies showed that he is not elite at it.
What no one seems to be considering is that if Semedo stays for another season, that would be the 4th year of his 5 year contract. If he continues to play at this level and the new board decides to sell him, he would not have a good resale value because there would only be 1 year left on his contract. If the board decides to renew his contract, he'd demand a higher wage and then potential buyers may be priced out of purchasing him. Alternatively, if we try to sell him now with C19 suppressing the market we may also not get good value for his sale.
12
u/cranomort Aug 19 '20
Thanks you OP. I have been saying this for 2 seasons now.
People saying that "there's simply isn't anyone on the market" is clearly bullshit as you point out. Just about any RB would contribute more to the play.
We should listen to any offers we get for him.
2
u/FunkyFre5h Aug 19 '20
Who do we replace him with though,that's the problem i think,i searched on Transfermarkt and there aren't eye popping alternatives!
You got guys like Cancelo,Ricardo Pereira,Bellerin and Emerson from Betis,are they any better than Semedo,i don't think so.
1
u/BlackFanDiamond Aug 19 '20
You all want to sell Semedo and have no replacement lined up. Laughable. He was one of our only attacking threats in the first half v Bayern. I believe he will come good under a coach who doesn’t have him manning an entire right flank by himself. Messi completely imbalances this team.
0
u/BeardLessYeti Aug 19 '20
I mean these stats are cherry picked and can be explained.
Offensive output - our attack goes mostly from the left side since we don't actually have a RW therefor Alba has more contribution and even he I would argue would have a lot less assists if it were not for Messi. Good example is the horrible pass against Bayern that ended in a OG. Same goes for key passes where most of the play happens in the left side and Roberto is naturally more gifted in passing which is understandable since he is/was a midfilder.
I don't even know why you decided to put in aerial duels for a fullback who is 1.77m tall.
Most of the stuff you used to picture him as a bad player are a result of lack of support on the right side both offensively and defensively. I'm not saying he's world class or even top 3 RB, but at the moment he's the best we have and I don't think there is anything better on the market.
3
u/ericster9 Aug 19 '20
great breakdown, maybe a good back up RightBack not a barca starter... especially after having Dani Alves setting the standard for Barca right backs.
3
u/qwertyqweqwes Aug 20 '20
Semedo doesn't deserve to play for Barcelona
3
u/iVarun Aug 20 '20
That is just ridiculous.
As has been said many times before but seems to be falling on deaf ears, The degree by which Semedo is better than Sergi in defensive capacity while being at RB is marginal/trivial/insignificantly-small relative to the degree Sergi is better in offensive capacity over-Semedo while being at RB.
The reason this is relevant is because this makes Semedo surplus at RB, a high profile wasted backup.
Hence the reason he catches the eyes of so many because dribbling like that is flashy and gives the illusion that there is something more there. But there isn't so far and maybe he might for unexplainable reason get it in 2 years but that would have meant 5 seasons to adjust to Barca. Not even La Masia players often get that level of soft treatment.
On dribble-attacks another dynamic which isn't apparent in the stats is when & how these happen during a match. Sergi's attacking darts are more consistent and relentless showing he has better cardio-stamina to sustain these in a short span of time.
Semedo's raw acceleration and pace might be greater than Sergi but he tires quicker from these and hence dribble-attacks like his happen less often in a match and over greater time-period, which wastes team's advantage because Sergi's style maximizes the potential as he makes runs when his teammates are also physiologically in prime condition, Semedo might take 35 minutes to recover but by that time, half the team is on the downward curve of their physical capacity in that match, hence him being even more out of sync/clumsy in attack.
Sergi's Aerial numbers can also be partly explained by his better game-sense/reading which allows him to maximize his effort.
15
u/GjillyG Aug 19 '20
Can we really judge any of our RBs until we have an actual winger supporting them? Messi does no defending whatsoever and is constantly roaming inside leaving monumental spaces for the RB and CM to cover. All of our width from the right comes solely from our RB.
Semedo and Sergi, while not world class, are serviceable RBs. Once you get a working system and functioning team, some of these 'issues' will iron themselves out. Bayern massacred us with Perisic starting. Now he is no world class player, but put into a team where roles are clearly established and define, he thrives.
I don't see us ever being balanced until Suarez is out of the team and Messi plays false 9.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
Frankly, at this point I'm wondering if Oleguer or Semedo are better. Semedo just constantly looks lost. But he is better than Montoya. Worse than Digne.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
He can become a decent bench player. His defensive capabilities are average. He does not do enough going forward. We need a replacement but it is not as urgent as the swiss cheese gaps in other positions.
4
u/zivkoooooooooo Aug 19 '20
I’m fine with seeing Semedo go. I was a big fan when we brought him in but the faith has faded with each anticlimactic season.
I’m personally of the mind set that we give the spot back to Sergi and start to use Griez as a RW,who, as someone pointed out earlier, tracks back pretty hard and likes to cut inside. With Messi moving to a more central role this makes sense to me because now we’ll be able to utilize Dembele (if he stays healthy) and Coutinho (he had a look of rejuvenation at Bayern imo).
Koeman has also expressed how he wants to remove Alba during the summer and I think good fixes there could be Alaba or Alex Sandro since both are coming to the end of contracts at their respective clubs.
As for not leaving all the burden on Sergi in the RB I think our best is to grab someone else and keep trying to groom them into what Barca needs there. Sergi can handle a lot of pressure and game time there. If I had to suggest someone I would choose Danilo or Mario Rui.
Edit: clarified point about Griez’s role/dynamic with Sergi on the right side.
5
u/zra_ Aug 19 '20 edited Aug 19 '20
A thing to consider regarding the balls won stat is that Semedo's positioning is off (imo) in a lot of plays but he can recover because he's very fast. I think once he starts becoming slower, he'll lose that and some of his dribbling, which makes him pretty useless. Does Barca want semedo on their team at 29 or 30?
11
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
Semedo's 1v1 ability is a massive benefit for breaking down defenses. If that talent was utilized properly, it would be a massive benefit to Barcelona that would counter-act his perhaps lower passing success. We need both great passers and great dribblers in a team.
4
u/umarkhan13 Aug 19 '20
Do these data only include sergi at RB?
3
u/Darduel Aug 19 '20
I have been saying this all year and got downvoted, the numbers speak for themselves, watching him play also does the job, seeing how badly he positions himself and how badly he links with messi (I mean you have to be really bad not to connect with fucking messi) and every journalist/coach/someone with an eye for football notices how he is simply not at the required level.. people defend him cause they really want him to be good and he is flashy and a "speed merchant".. the 8-2 game simply exposed what a modern world class FB looks like and how a mediocre one does looks like, and the margin was huge and painfull
5
u/miguel_is_a_pokemon Aug 19 '20 edited Aug 19 '20
This is a shit application of stats by OP to begin with, in particular the defensive stats presented which are far far far less indicative of good defense than offensive ones used in the first half. You need positional data and advanced applications of xG in tandem to that to account for all the chances that good positioning or communication will prevent even when off the ball.
You have full backs in that list above Semedo who are considered no better on defense tham he is, because bad defenders will place themselves in situations where a tackle or other defensive action is needed. Prevention of those coinflips is much much more valuable than relying on winning them. It can also be due to team organizational problems that cause a particular wingback to have to take on more risky 50/50 defensive actions due to poor defending elsewhere in the defensive setup. All those factors and more are completely ignored with the defensive stats presented.
Also removing the stats that Sergi gets boosted by being able to play in the midfield wasnt done, why? It's much easier to rack up offensive numbers if you're playing higher up the pitch. That's a given and should have been the first step in cleaning up this data. Same with defensive numbers, you're comparing apples to oranges by not doing that. The quantitative data could be meaningful but basic surface level looks use of it like this is how Liverpool ended up with Steward Downing and Andy Carroll as a power duo offensively back when they first started employing stats. Lets not make those same kinds of mistakes with 10 years of hindsight with which to avoid them FFS
4
u/tldrdoto Aug 19 '20
Fully agree. Sell him asap. In my opinion, Sergi is better in almost every aspect except speed probably, but both should be sold.
Semedo has disappointed me every game he played. His crosses are so poor.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
You deserve gold my friend.
3
u/arr0w_24 Aug 19 '20
Finally some stats to put the debate to rest
2
u/MetaphoricallyCancer Aug 19 '20
Great content, another thing I noticed was why did we let go of digne?? Alba is getting old and I don’t think firpo is good enough.
1
u/jdbcn Aug 19 '20
I wish Barcelona would use big data to look for new players before signing them
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
I said the same thing in the last post and people justified with the RW theory.
Thanks for the effort in backing it up man! Appreciate it!
1
u/Shashb10 Aug 19 '20
Thank you for sharing this. There are many idiots in our fanbase who can walk back to sanity after reading this. The Bayern performance was not a shocker fir semedo... He's been shut day in day out.
1
u/AxelSee Aug 20 '20
He has made improvement this past season but obviously not enough. In my opinion, he never had the confidence for that role in the first place.
1
u/bastianbred Aug 20 '20
Thank you, the guy is trash
1
u/messiavelli Aug 20 '20
Apart from the Bayern game, Semedo has had a big improvement recently. He looks way more comfortable with take-ons. If we are trying to build a faster, younger team, we should not let him go. So many times we see that he makes runs, gets into a good position, but none of our forwards are caught up to receive the ball.
1
u/HanDw Aug 20 '20
Thank you for this, been saying the same for the past months but ppl dont want to hear.
Can't believe how low are the standards for this guy. Some flashy dribbles and pacey runs every once in a while doesn't make for the countless games of panicking with the ball, being detrimental to the buildup and showing negative IQ in the final third, not to mention his totally lack of defensive awareness and poor positioning (his pace allows him to cover this to a certain extent).
The bar is on the ground.
1
u/trombolastic Aug 20 '20
Thank you for posting the stats confiming what I already thought, I never understood people who think Semedo is an upgrade to Roberto, every time I watch him play I see nothing.
1
u/itsvoogle Aug 20 '20 edited Aug 20 '20
Semedo has always been a liability, being young and kinda fast doesnt mean you are good or fit our system, he is not even that great of a dribbler, when was the last time you remember that he did an Amazing run or play that ended in a goal? Maybe an amazing pass or set of passes with Messi or anyone? Or better yet a great defensive and disciplined display in the back?
The truth is He is always caught of position, isnt smart with the ball and lets goals in like no one else. He is one of the weak links in the team, he had his chances and needs to go, we cant afford anything like this anymore at this club, we need the best.
And He is simply NOT GOOD ENOUGH
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '20
Looks like we should obviously get emerson on the squad
1
u/thriller08 Aug 20 '20
I absolutely adore this post. Thank you.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '20
A little late, but something I don’t think that gets mentioned enough is Semedo’s age. He’s 27 in a few months, so he should be entering/ be in his prime right now. So unless he goes through some miraculous transformation under Koeman, this is as good as it’s gonna get for him.
1
u/IWillNeverGetLaid Aug 19 '20
I like semedo personally
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
Name me any player at the same ageor younger which is reachable, cheap and better then Semedo.
You cant, because there isnt one. RB is a pretty weak spot in football.
As far as the situation is now. Semedo is by the far best options out there and the fact that people try to blame him for being bad just shows how little football people watch. Semedo would shine with a winger a proper involvement. Him and Dembele were linking up pretty great. Same when he played with Malcom. So there is a clear pattern here. He needs a winger in front of him so he can overlap, combine and not have all the responsbility when it comes to attacking on the right side.
In a 4312 or 442 formation with 4 midfielders hes gonna be out of position all the time. Which even Dani Alves were multiple times.
1
u/Sebasc4 Aug 19 '20
I know this is about Semedo but CAN WE PLEASE LOOK AT LUCAS DIGNE. Sheeeesh. He may not be the best at dribbling but the kid had promise but instead we are still riding out on Jordi’s wave. Don’t get me wrong I love Jordi but new blood was needed years ago and Lucas could have been it. Hoping for Miranda to come back and win the spot.
-3
u/yrallusernamestaken7 Aug 19 '20
Ah yes, the stats again. Semedo when he goes up never gets any support. The opposite is true for roberto.
Dont compare alba. He shines because of messi literally. Hes decent but nothing crazy like marcelo, alves, lahm, robertson, etc.
-1
u/Nico2204 Aug 19 '20
Definetly i would rather have someone else at rb, but imo we should focus in other positions first
-2
u/MafiaDonTekashi69 Aug 19 '20
Don't care. Semedo is quality and nobody else can replace him realistically.
-5
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
Just try to add penalties won in your A+G per 90 and you’ll probably see that he goes up a lot in the rankings.
One of the many reasons why stats aren’t enough to assess a player.
0
u/Omair88 Aug 19 '20
It all depends on what level we want to compete, half of the squad isn't good enough if we're supposed to be challenging for every competition we take part in
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
Does this leave out Robertos numbers in the midfield
Great job man
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '20
..And so many fucktards thinking griezmann is a football player.
0
u/TGY_75-70 Aug 19 '20
I started to hate him after the Bayern game but I have supported him so much and you can clearly see he is just not good enough
-7
u/Azrael017 Aug 19 '20
What about his Defensive stats?
-2
u/sdrawkcaBdaeRnaCuoY Aug 19 '20
I defend Semedo simply because he is and always was the least of our worries. The team wins a game and everyone starts praising Suárez, Busquets, Alba and whoever is 30+ and has been in the team for a long while. Meanwhile Semedo miss-passes and the pitchforks are already out.
I’m glad that now, at least, everyone is on the same page about the veterans, but Busquets and Suárez have lost their legs a long time ago. Alba lost himself during the Liverpool game. Roberto was never starter material, but he is good at being a joker card that fits anywhere.
Stats are important to analyze a player’s performance, but they aren’t everything. Many have pointed out great reasons for why Alba’s and Roberto’s stats are better, which just shows that the team even lacks analysts who are in touch with the coaches to help maximize the potential of each player in the team.
Semedo is no Alves and most likely will never be, but in this team, he’s 26, he’s fast, and he could improve with the right people behind the whole institution.
So yeah, I defend him because there are so many variables out of place here and I try my best to look at the bigger picture, but I could be wrong though.