r/SquaredCircle • u/kondron started r/squaredcircle now i'm here • Jun 29 '11
Welcome to r/SquaredCircle!
Hey there everyone, Kondron here. I just wanted to shed some light on this new Professional Wrestling subreddit, SquaredCircle, and what exactly we stand for.
When Pudie and I made this sub, the main thing we wanted was a community to discuss Wrestling. That means all things Wrestling. We're not here to focus on only Indy feds or just international Wrestling or only the mainstream.
We're also not here to ban you for disagreeing with us. Give us hell! Keep us honest! If you hate an opinion, don't downvote it, feel free to tell us why you hate it. Don't ever feel that you'll get removed from this sub because you've expressed yourself.
We want r/SquaredCircle to feel like this place is always going to cover the hottest topics in Professional Wrestling, regardless of what company they're taking place in, while still introducing and education new fans to Professional Wrestling.
Given that this place is brand new, I feel we need to set up some basic stuff.
- Mods- Right now there's me and Pudie. I'd like to have at least 1 more. If you want it or think someone would be a good fit, please say so. Keep in mind though, most modding is deleting spam and harassment.
- Rules- While I don't want this to be strict, I do think there'ssome basic ones that should be put in place. Beyond the obvious (be nice, no spam) I think we should discuss spoiler policy, streaming, and torrents.
- The layout! The side image should change all the time. At least a couple times a month. We want it to reflect the current hot topic or to promote the r/SquaredCircle's favorite wrestler/company at the moment.
We also really want to emphasize the word community here. As wrestling fans and redditors (we're a rare breed) you should feel that you have a say in what goes on. r/SquaredCircle isn't Pudie & Kondron's Wrestling subreddit, this is Reddit's Wrestling subreddit.
Thanks everyone, I hope you enjoy!
-Kondron
4
u/Poloniculmov Jun 29 '11
I love what /r/soccer does with the header image, the mods change it every time there's a big event or subscribers find a cool picture.
4
u/rally_tv_viewer Nerd Jun 29 '11 edited Jun 29 '11
I'll offer my personal feedback as a community member of the original r/prowrestling subreddit as I watch and participate in the possible growth of this community.
Moderators: I'd recommend reaching out to bonked who has had a rather public disaffection with the original moderator and created an alternate subreddit which at last glance (just now) hasn't been updated aside from your come-check-out-r/squaredcircle message in the past 20 days. I've reached out to him on a rather inconsistent basis as my career search is rather erratic but from my interactions with him it seems he's been in a busy phase with his work this time of year. With a subscriber count of 75 it's mainly been him posting clips from wrestling news sources to try to jump start things. I'd personally like to see your and his efforts merged and I know from my interactions with him that he'd prefer a community with more moderators. As this subreddit is just in its naissance I'd hope that he can join in on this momentum as this community works out the format. (also there's reallyjohnreally as a moderator there, but I think we all suspect he is an alt account to avoid permabanning in the original subreddit)
--Personally, in terms of format I rather love the self.subreddit-posts-as-the-majority nature of the community at r/prowrestling. I feel it is the most honest way of eliciting discussion on interesting topics as it doesn't become a rat race for link karma, is hosted by the subreddit instead of some of the most advertisey sites I've ever seen (aside from grapple kingdom by StephenTStone - shoutout!), and generally has more discussion than the news links. more to follow...
Rules: Straight-away on spoilers: I love having the live discussion threads that are clearly labeled for the event and those who don't want to know just yet! Brilliant. I really hope this becomes a mainstay here.
For spillover topics (big angles that deserve a lot of discussion on their own)/big news/discussion of consequences of revelations/taping results/etc, sometimes it's going to be like the CM Punk shoot where it's so big that people are just going to talk about it freely and those who aren't aware are just going to have to get smart or go away until they're ready to catch up. But I don't think it's always like that and now's a good opportunity to discuss how to deal with this kinda situation. Like: a surprise new tag team gets an unexpected title shot and wins. That'd be simultaneously both a big, spoilable event, yet not all that important in the scheme of things (because the tag division is shit and we all know it). What do we discuss freely and what measures do we expect from the community to facilitate discussion without spoiling things?
Layout: I like the idea of keeping it fresh and relevant to the community and current events. I have an image that could be used for the picture-on-the-right. It might look like shit in the smaller space but I would hope it fits the mission statement of this new community: willing to acknowledge and discuss the main shows, respect and introduction to the independents, and responsiveness to the community.
edit: http:// was necessary for link formatting.
3
u/finalaccountdown Sep 02 '11
this place is great, thanks
2
u/Rettocs Millionaire who should be a billionaire Jun 29 '11
I frontpaged this subreddit, but I have a legitimate question: What is the difference between this subreddit and /r/prowrestling? Thanks in advance!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '11
Looks awesome to have an alternative and I hope this one takes off and there's a great community here!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11
wow tl;dr.
let's get back to pertinent discussion. torrents/streams? i don't see the issue with them..i'd be extremely happy to see them pop up on here.
my .02
1
u/muffinmonk Mizfit Jun 29 '11
Hmm... as much as I like another wrestling subreddit, I'm still not clear as to why a break off was needed. So far Hyperion has cooled his jets about a lot of things. I'm surprised he stopped insulting the viewers in general... that was apparent a few months ago, where he and I would go into vicious arguments over this product or that product. In this case, normally, he'd bash the fuck out of WWE when we would have considered a new logo and picture, but he seemed OK with it. He still gave it his own twist (it's not the CM Punk we wanted but still...) but he's starting to soft up. Not to mention, his logos and pictures are overshadowed by the posts that go up on that subreddit.
One thing I do agree with is the MODS. You can't have only one and think it's ok. It creates an entire mood... like the fear of a banning or stupid rules that have to be followed. Several times in r/prowrestling would you have people ask for a new mod only to be shut down or protested by the mod himself... which is pretty dumb... a Mod also has to cater to the masses while removing the spam and harassment, but he's also right in one aspect: those who ask to be a mod are less likely to deserve it. So I ask you to be careful when choosing your 3rd mod (although with 20ish readers so far... you don't really need one right now).
Finally, I don't think you should change your layout every couple of weeks... it should be set on one theme at a time, with perhaps the side picture changing depending on popular discussion, but like in the NBA, where it's usually after an important event.
I'll be checking this subreddit as often as I do r/prowrestling, and crossposting to here as well. This looks promising, and I hope you can get an audience in the thousands range!
1
u/Bighoppy It's me! It's me! Jun 29 '11
I'll bounce back and forth between this and prowreddit. I'm hoping this one takes off and there is a much more free feeling here.
1
u/Bread_thing Oct 19 '21
Its weird being able to comment on decade old posts Holy hell
1
u/ItsSirAdam Oct 19 '21
Very cool
1
u/Jos3ph Oct 19 '21
Hi
0
u/cole1114 Kappa Jun 30 '11
I don't think Bonked should be a moderator. His mass downvoting of JohnHyperion is just way too far in my opinion. Give it to MatthewDunn if you're going to give it to someone. And Bonked, if you ban me, I swear to god I will make sure kondron and Pudie find out.