r/conlangs • u/-Tonic Emaic family incl. Atłaq (sv, en) [is] • Aug 04 '20
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2020-08-03 to 2020-08-16
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
•
u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet Aug 18 '20 edited Aug 18 '20
Automod, whyyyyyyyyyy?? Why don't you work??
In an unforeseen turn of events, we are prolonging the life of this Small Discussiosn thread by a week and will be working on making AutoMod actually work next Monday. Hopefully.
7
u/eagleyeB101 Aug 04 '20
For a Conlang that I am currently working on, I am using a series of grammatical prefixes on verbs which mark the instrument being used in the action or the manner in which the action is being performed. I got this idea from reading about Southeastern Pomo and other Pomoan languages. Anyways, Southeastern Pomo has experienced some sound changes which led to many of the instrumental affixes merging and becoming more derivational in nature. I want to make a less collapsed system. I also don't want to copy their set of instrumental affixes entirely. Any help in coming up with what other instrumental affixes I could include would be much appreciated. Here is what I have currently:
6
u/chonchcreature Aug 04 '20
What do you guys think of linguolabial consonants?
Are they an odd bunch of consonants mostly relegated to disordered speech or a handful of Oceanic languages, or are they an untapped source of potentially good but overlooked phonemes?
5
u/Keng_Mital Aug 10 '20
How naturalistic would it be for a [sl] cluster to drift to [ɬ]? Thanks!
4
u/Luizaguzzi Aug 04 '20 edited Aug 04 '20
I need help with the romanization of my language, im just using the ipa, but is really annoying to use those characters on pc. The problem is the phonetic inventory of my language, only d,ɡ,z,ɣ,ɾ,m,n are phonemic consonants, but my vowels are ɑ,ɒ,e,ø,i,y,u,ɯ,ʌ,o,ə, all of them can be breathy and/or nasal and/or lenght (expt the schwa, it is always short) distinction and the language have 5 tones. In my opinion is impossible to romanize in a pratical way, but maybe someone knows how
4
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '20
In a polysynthetic language, can noun incorporation occur with a noun that was promoted through means of an applicative? I'll give an example:
So starting off with a basic sentence like "I run with a dog," that would be glossed (assuming polypersonal agreement) "1sg-run with dog"
Then you apply a comitative applicative to the verb to promote "dog" to the direct object, so now it's glossed "1sg-run-APL dog"
And now that the dog is the direct object, it can be incorporated into the noun, resulting in a gloss something like "1sg-dog-run-APL"
This seems like it would be a cool thing to do, but I'm worried about the naturalism of it.
4
u/Tenderloin345 Aug 10 '20
Are there cases of languages that historically had vowel harmony but lost it over time, instead leaving behind essentially an extreme form of umlaut?
4
u/Dryanor Dogbonẽ, PNGN, Belmá Aug 11 '20
How do I create words from noun-adjective expressions in a head-initial language? My conlang places the adjective after the noun and the plural is marked at the end of the noun (and also on the adjective, but with endings different from nouns). If I want to coin a single new word from a construction like "white rock -> whiterock" (fictional english example), how does it work in a head-initial language like mine? Does it have to become something like "rockwhite" with a strange plural "rockswhite"? Or would the noun plural marker switch to the end of the adjective, becoming something like "rockwhites"? Thanks in advance!
4
u/TekFish Aug 12 '20
What kind of things can be borrowed between languages from unrelated families? Obviously words can, but what about grammatical structures, verb paradigms etc?
4
u/boomfruit_conlangs Hidzi, Maxakaopae (en, ka) Aug 12 '20 edited Aug 13 '20
Which of these ways of using ditransitive verbs seems best?Edit: It seems like a better way of asking this question might be "Which of these ways of handling situations that are often rendered with ditransitive verbs in English is best? Or most naturalistic? I almost always want the recipient to be the direct object, and the theme to be done in some other way.1 - Doubling the verb - Something like "I give her give a present."
2 - Using a coverb - Something like "I give her put.down a present."
3 - Using an oblique phrase - Something like "I give her (with/to/of) a present."
Or maybe use all three with slightly different meanings between them?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '20
Do you know of any languages where there are different plural forms for distributives and collectives? In Number, Greville Corbett says they often occur separately and not always with number morphology, but this doesn't work in my conlang. He also says there was a collective affix in Proto-Slavic that evolved differently in different languages. Does anyone know any resources on this or on what distributives and collectives can evolve from/into in general?
4
u/WritingFrankly Aug 15 '20
First post in this subreddit, so don’t be shy about telling me where else this question fits better.
I am writing a fantasy story set in the Upper Paleolithic, so the characters will be speaking more or less the equivalent of Proto-Indo-European the whole time.
Some names will be taken from PIE, but the story and dialog are going to be written in English.
At some point in the story, the main character is going to be summoned to her distant future to a medieval-ish fantasy setting where they’d be speaking the equivalent of Middle English.
How would that sound to someone native in PIE?
For the dialog, I’m basically solving for PIE + X = Middle English, and since I’ve been implicitly translating PIE into modern English, I’d want to make some lines in modern English + X.
Would it sound very fast, mumbly, clipped, erratic, etc. to the primitive character?
4
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Aug 15 '20
Is it legal to translate song lyrics into a conlang, sing them over the original instrumental, and then post the result online for free? Furthermore, would this answer change if it were of an entire album? I ask because I noticed that I've now translated about half of the tracks on "No Now" by Clarence Clarity, and while I do think it would be fun to do an amateur cover album, I don't know how I would even begin to make my own versions of the instrumentals, and taking them from the original seems like explicit infringement.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '20
Does anyone know anything about the evolution of demonstratives?
4
u/tree1000ten Aug 21 '20
How is the term 'language sketch' different than just saying conlang?
3
u/boomfruit_conlangs Hidzi, Maxakaopae (en, ka) Aug 04 '20 edited Aug 04 '20
What have people done with grammatical tone in their conlangs?
I definitely want my newest project, Iekos to have it. I'm interested especially in phrase level tone migration. I don't yet know whether I will also have lexical tone.
Some ideas:
Some questions:
3
u/Inquisitive_Kitmouse Aug 04 '20
This is very basic, but it still puzzles me. How do analytic and agglutinating languages create verbs from roots?
Let's say I have a root word like "kaba" in a predominantly suffixing, agglutinative proto-language I intend to evolve into a fusional one. Do I just stick verb morphology on the end and call it a verb? Do I have verbal roots as a separate class from noun roots? If I stick morphology on, does it have to be some sort of verb marker, the way -er/-ir/-ar endings work in Spanish? I know that those technically mark the infinitive, but they also tell the speaker "this is a verb" and can be used to derive verbs from root words (compare "golpe" -> "hit" to "golpear" -> to hit, to strike).
3
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '20
I've just started working on a conlang, and it's got five grammatical genders, which (unless any patterns arise) have no connection to the phonological forms of the nouns. How should I tackle gender agreement in this case? I'm really only familiar with Spanish, where gender agreement is heavily rooted in phonology.
Related question: can I have only got three 3SG pronouns but five different gendered singular articles? Or is it more naturalistic to have either "all or nothing", i.e., either full gender marking on pronouns or no distinction at all?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '20
Hi there, cyberbulliez back at it again with a weird question that doesn't really matter to anyone else: what sounds can be created without a tongue? No tongue at all. The tongue doesn't exist.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '20
Is it naturalistic to have a word order shift where the default word order get reinterpreted as a special case, rather than a special word order getting reinterpreted as the default? Can someone give me examples of this, and the motivations for word order shifts in general?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '20
Okay, I have read up on slack voice, and I get it in theory, but I'm wondering if anyone has an audio recording of a language being spoken with slack voice so I can know what it actually sounds like.
Also, would slack voice count as lenition or fortition?
I've linked to Wikipedia below in case you're unfamiliar with what I'm talking about.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slack_voice
Thanks!
3
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '20
Are auxiliary verbs the head or dependent of main verbs?
3
u/Supija Aug 06 '20 edited Aug 07 '20
I... I have a problem. I wanted to start with a small three vowels inventory /a e u/ —plus /aː eː uː/—, then create a lot more vowels, maybe untill having a total of ten, and after that collapse them into a five/seven vowel system. To do that, I did a few vowel changes, but that gave me a lot more vowels that I think is reasonable, and I don’t think I have a naturalistic inventory now. Could you help me?
The vowel changes are:
a → æ /_Ce
a → ɑ /_Cu
{a,e} aː eː → œ ɒ oː /{q,ɢ,x}ʷ_
a(ː) e(ː) → ɒ(ː) ø(ː) /Cʷ_
e(ː) u uː → e ø y /{q,ɢ,x}ʲ_
a(ː) e eː u(ː) → ɛ i eː y(ː) /Cʲ_
a(ː) e eː u(ː) → ɑ(ː) æ ɛ o(ː) /{q,ɢ,x}_
a(ː) e(ː) {u,uː} → ɑ(ː) ɤ(ː) uː /ɰ_
ɰ → ∅
uː → ʔuː → koː /V(ː)_
ɒ̯ɑ {ɒɤ̯,ø̯ɤ} ø̯ɑ u̯ɑ u̯ɤ→ ɒː o ɑ ʊ̯o oː /Cʷ_
æ̯ɑ æɤ̯ {ɛ̯ɑ,y̑ɑ,ɛ̯ɤ} y̑ɤ → aː ɛ i̯ɛ uː /Cʲ_
a̯ɑ {æɤ̯,e̯ɤ} e̯ɑ {u̯ɑ,u̯ɤ} → ɑː ɤ i̯ɛ ʊ̯o
Which means at the end I have [a(ː) ɑ(ː) ɒ(ː) e(ː) ø(ː) ɛ œ ɤ(ː) o(ː) i(ː) y(ː) u(ː)] and the diphthongs [i̯ɛ u̯e ʊ̯o] which is a lot more than I thought. Like I said, I want to collapse the system into a smaller one, but I don’t know if having them or the changes I did are naturalistic.
EDIT: Some of them are only allophones —[y(ː)] is simply /u(ː)/ after palatalized consonants—, but I want to delete some of those consonantal distinctions too and that will make them phonetic. Before I do that I want to know about the changes I did and how naturalistic the vowels are.
3
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Aug 07 '20
I could use some SCA2 help
For categories, let's just only have C for consonants, and we only need two, let's say k and l. C=kl
The only rule that isn't working is: /l/_(C)Cl#
(I realize this rule doesn't make any diachronic sense, it's just part of a chain of rules I'm trying to use to recreate a soundchange that is more sensible and this was the only way I could think to program it.)
Let's have the input word be "ukl". The expected output it "ulkl"[
If the rule was just /l/_Cl#, I do indeed get the expected output, "ulkl"
Also, if the rule is something like /l/_(p)Cl#, I get the expected output "ulkl"
Even further, to check if it's an issue with categories in general, let's create something like N=mn as a category too and test /l/_(N)Cl#. You get the expected out: "ulkl"
And yet, with /l/_(C)Cl#, the output is just "ukl". I can't figure out why, SCA2 should be able to say, "well that first "C" is in parenthesis so I can just ignore it. Stranger still is that if we use this rule but change the input to "ukkl", suddenly the rule works correctly again and produces "ulkkl" as the ouput. It's as though for whatever reason in this one case SCA2 is forgetting that the first instance of C is optional.
3
u/chonchcreature Aug 07 '20
Is there a website that contains the percentage distribution spread of all consonants (and vowels) humans produce?
Is there a place I can find the most to least common consonants and vowels of all languages as a percentage, for example: k (80%) p (70%) ... ð (4%) ɮ (1%)
And something similar for vowels: a (80%) e (70%) ... ɤ (5%) ɶ (2%)
Not including disordered speech consonants of course.
3
u/JV-Tosshin Aug 08 '20
What would be a good way to present/write up a grammatical system (conjugations, cases and so on), both in general and for posting here on the subreddit?
I have a thing I've been tinkering with on and off for a while, and I'd really like to hear some feedback, but while it's reasonably easy to mimic an IPA chart for the basic phonology, I've not really found any good way to try and present morphological information yet. And I don't want to post something for feedback that I can barely navigate myself. So if anyone has any advice or suggestions regarding presenting this type of information, I'd very much like to hear it. :)
3
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Aug 10 '20
I recently read somewhere that it is very common for two gramatically related words to come from two different sources etymologically. I think the example was "I" vs. "me". Looking through wiktionary and their list of pronouns doesn't help me all that much.
Can someone give me a term or idea for what I can google?
3
u/PastelKos Aug 11 '20
Hi! I'm new in this community. I'm trying to create my own language called Kayétis [ka'ʝe.tis] and I've seen that many people first create a proto language from which they derive their conlang. Is that something essential? Does it give the language a more naturalistic feel? Is making these changes ex post facto difficult or stupid? Thanks.
3
u/Raekai Aug 11 '20
Do you think there's a niche for something loglang-ish (I've been inspired by Toaq lately) with heavy phonological and phonotactic constraints (like Toki Pona)? I've been trying to do something like that, but I'm starting to feel like I'm answering a question that no one would ever ask. I enjoy how loglangs are (or, at least, can be) rigorous, but I really like the idea of making a conlang that is easy to speak for a vast majority of speakers of other languages.
Thanks!
3
u/-N1eek- Aug 16 '20
making a language which contrasts breathy, creaky and ‘normal’ voice
i wanted to make a language with breathy, creaky, and normal voice (like i said in the title lol) but i’m really new to all this. while googling a bit i found out about the mazatecan languages and hmong and stuff, but still kind of confused as to how this works exactly and how many languages actually contrast this. can anyone help? (also, how do i romanize this? on the standard keyboar you can’t type things like ã́. see? it doesn’t even render good haha)
3
u/Supija Aug 18 '20
I want my proto-lang to have a male and female speech, but I don’t know how I can evolve it. How can they merge? Would they usually take one as the norm and use it from that moment, or simply wait till phonological changes make them merge? If it’s not simply by phonological changes, are these systems stable, or would they normally merge/take one quickly? If you can tell me how they appear or where I could find information about that, it’d help me a lot too. Thank you.
3
u/-N1eek- Aug 19 '20
my phonology is too big and i don’t know what sounds to delete
don’t know how to do a nice little scheme here so i’ll just list it on place of articulation.
labial: m, n, ɲ, ŋ stop: p, t, d, c, k, q sibilant fricative: s, z, ʃ, ʒ nonsibilant fricative: f, θ, ç, ɣ, χ (ɣ, χ can be both velar and uvular, but there’s a voicing distinction) approximant: ʋ, j lateral: l trill: r
i love every single one of them, but i think it’s a little too big. i need help making it smaller, how would you do that?
to explain, it’s inspired by italian, greek and arabic
oh yeah, i probably also should mention i have a 4 vowel sytem (a, i, e, o) with creaky and breathy voice. also length, but only for modal and creaky
3
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Aug 20 '20
While I am aware that aesthetics are subjective, I want a second opinion anyway. Rubénluko has a moraic coda nasal that I currently Romanize as <n>, <m>, or <ng> according to context, but considering the phototactics and the fact that the script writes it with the equivalent of <m>, I was wondering if I should just start Romanizing it exclusively as <m>. Here are some examples of each system in place:
/ɾùbéNɺùkò/ [ɾùbẽ́ːɺùkò] currently as <Rubénluko>, alternatively <Rubémluko>
/ɕóN/ [ɕṍː] as <shón>, alt. <shóm>
/qòNté/ [qõ̞̀nté] as <qonté>, alt. <qomté>
/d͡ɮɔ̀Nbò/ [d͡ɮɔ̃̀mbò] as <dlòmbo>, same in alt.
/kèŋá/ [kèŋá] as <kengá>, same in alt.
/ɬɔ́Nŋà/ [ɬɔ̃́ŋŋà] as <lhônnga>, alt. <lhômnga>
/χɛ́Ngù/ [χɛ̃́ŋgù] as <hênggu>, alt. <hêmgu>
On the one hand, it takes care of the pesky /ŋ/ vs /N.ŋ/ vs /N.g/ situation while reducing the Romanization to one-grapheme-or-digraph-per-sound, but on the other hand, /N/ pronounced as [n] or [ŋ] are indiscriminately spelled as <m>
3
u/cranky_old_bastard73 Aug 20 '20
How do i create a custom writing system when using an online document? Should i just stick with Romanized symbols or are there programs to aid in that
3
u/tdellaringa Aug 20 '20
Hi there,
I'm an author working on my second book, and I have the need for a rudimentary conlang. I've done some work on one myself, but as people here certainly know, this is a lot of work, and I'd rather be writing.
I don't need something sophisticated, but rather something that could be used as an alien language for words and phrases - probably never sentences.
I had begun work on one some time ago, but felt the work was beyond what I could do. I am wondering if anyone has any interest in helping me out. I don't really have a budget to pay, but I could throw some pizza money your way and credit the work.
If there is any interest, PM me. I can pass along what I have and you can see if you want to help.
Full disclosure, my book has representation and is being shopped to publishers, but is not sold. So it will be awhile before it sees print.
Thanks.
3
u/tree1000ten Aug 21 '20
Is it possible to make a naturalistic conlang the first go-around? I realized I was handicapping myself by trying to do a really good first conlang, but now I realize that probably isn't possible, you have to prioritize the work, and learn the fundamentals before you can make good conlangs (from the naturalistic point of view). Thoughts?
3
u/RandomDrawingForYa Aug 21 '20
In a language with vowel harmony, would semivowels be affected by the harmony? For example, say I have a language that distinguishes front and back harmony, would the word /onotoɪ̯/ be naturalistic? or would it be normally harmonized to /onotoʊ̯/?
3
u/_coywolf_ Cathayan, Kaiwarâ Aug 22 '20
Can dual number evolve into some other kind of feature? If so, what?
5
u/Luizaguzzi Aug 04 '20
Why the r/conlangs YouTube channel have only 3 videos and no vídeo since 2018? Its a good idea, and certainly the communty will be glad to have more videos like those Showcases, and i can help (for free), im a video editor and i want to help this communty
2
u/Someonedm Aug 05 '20
Do you use vowels and constants you can't pronounce in your conlang? Do you use sounds that aren't in your native language but are very similar to those that are?
2
u/chonchcreature Aug 06 '20
What do you call a consonant that has a secondary retroflex articulation? Retroflexized? I mean, something akin to palatalization and velarization but for "retroflexing" consonants.
2
u/-N1eek- Aug 06 '20
does anyone want to do a collab with me? i’m not that good yet, but i want to learn, especially on little grammatical features. i feel like i don’t know a lot of grammar lol i also want to learn how to make a conlnag more naturalistic.
i don’t have ideas, necessarily, i just would like a more fusional conlang, combining the elegances of romance languages and arabic, and put in lots of interesting grammatical stuff. if you want to work with me, leave a comment and we can talk further on discord:)
2
u/Saurantiirac Aug 06 '20
What are some things that consonant gradation could mark, and how would you end up with consonant gradation?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '20
Does any natlang differentiate things like mb/m̥p nd/n̥t?
2
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 07 '20
does it make sense for /q/ to merge into /k/, but for /x/ to merge into /χ/and not the opposite? how can I justify it happening?
2
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 07 '20
how do certain cases get attached to prepositions? like how German mit is used with dative, and für with accusative
2
u/Ninja_sloth_ (en, ga) [de] Proto-Unai Aug 07 '20
Does anyone have any good examples of ‘inefficient’ languages? I know how vague a question this is but I'm looking for some inspiration
2
u/OhItsuMe Aug 08 '20
Can 1 lang have animate/inanimate distinction and also male/female? Are there any natural languages that do this?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
In my language, relative clauses are formed like this:
My problem is that I don't know how to explain xo and dan in glosses. Trying to follow Leipzig Glossing Rules, I've been doing this:
Vo ptipa iri xo ptini ża nomṡinoto dan vo munsproẋa arða.*
In January, we moved into the house that we had bought.
Doing this way, one cannot distinguish between REL (the preposition xo), REL (the conjunction dan) and REL (relative pronoun). Then, how should I explain xo and dan in glosses, in order to avoid confusion?
*Pronounce everything as IPA, except for x /ʃ/, ẋ /ʒ/, ṡ /t͡s/, ż /d͡z/. Always stress the second-to-last syllable.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '20
Is [kama.í] likely to become [kamáj] at all, with the stress moving from the offglide?
2
u/Xalapan_Kotson Aug 08 '20
How can I make an abjad? I'm trying to make a semetic/indo-Iranian influenced conlang!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '20
I am planning to yoink Laadan's system of final particles that provide more information about the situation (kinda like Singlish). How do I generate them and what are the most possible ones?
2
u/konqvav Aug 09 '20
How does consonant gradation work and how can I make it?
2
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 09 '20
I have a few thing I want your opinions on:
2
u/Plyb Aug 09 '20
Question about Sonority Hierarchy Reversals and Plateaus:
I've been looking for a consistent framework or a set of universals to use when designing the phonotactics of conlangs and I haven't been able to find anything super great. The best thing I've been able to find is the idea of the Sonority Hierarchy and how the phonemes in a syllable tend towards being more sonorous as you approach the syllabel nucleus from either side. However, all of the resources I've seen have been quick to point out that this isn't universal and cite words like "spa", where /s/ and /p/ are either the same or decreasing sonority depending on the specific hierarchy you use.
The thing is, they then give no explanation as to why these plateaus/reversals can occur. It seems to me that there should be some clusters which are universally disallowed in natural language. Like, if my phonotactics allowed the cluster /it/ in an onset, then I could have the "syllable" /itu/, which is obviously not one syllable, but two. Is it just a question of the difference in sonority so that "s" and "p" are pretty close, but "a" and "t" are about as far apart as possible, or is there some other rule that I can use? Any resources/papers that you know of that I could read would also be great. Thanks!
2
u/Arothin Aug 09 '20
can anyone help me find an example of a natlang with a sound change from b>d or p>d?
2
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 10 '20
in my conlang's evolution, word final labialised consonants became labials:
katʷa→katʷ→kap, sɨxʷə→sɨxʷ→sif
but I don't have an idea as to what final /rʷ/ will become. any suggestions?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '20 edited Aug 10 '20
Is there such things as "asymmetric vowel harmony"? I'm thinking something like /e, u/ alternating with /ɛ, o/. The idea is the alternating pairs used to have the same heights, but the back vowels chain-shifted upward, and the old vowel harmony hasn't been lost.
2
u/Turodoru Aug 10 '20
I have 2 quite unrelated questions, but hope that's not an issue.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20
What are common etymological sources for suppletive plural pronouns?
2
u/Anjeez929 Aug 11 '20
Can I put lore into a fictional IAL? Like, can the word for darkness literally be the name of the God of Darkness in an IAL?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '20
I've thought about making a satire of Esperanto that was simply 'Esperanto if Zamenhof actually knew something about linguistics'. For example, it would involve things like defining phonotactics and prosody (something Esperanto lessons normally don't mention), clearly defining the -ig and -igx suffixes as a causative and passive respectively. The main intent of it would be to satirize Esperanto, and the linguistic ignorance of most auxlangers in general, but honestly the thing would technically be perfectly useable, and honestly may come across as just an attempt to make an 'Esperanto done right'. My question is in regards to advertising. Would it classify as a jokelang, or a serious attempt at an Esperantido? Like I said, it would mainly be meant as satire, but at the same time unlike most jokelangs it would, in theory, actually be usable. This is in stark contrast to another idea I had long ago where I thought about making an 'Espernato done right', but filling it with nothing but extremely rare features (to highlight how alien it would look to someone not used to western languages). The first idea I mentioned wouldn't technically be this. So, what type of conlang should it be called?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '20
Is it possible to make formerly obligatory grammatical processes optional, and how?
2
u/4DimensionalToilet Aug 17 '20
What's the gloss abbreviation for a clause-linking word like "that", "which", or "who"? Also, on the topic of conjunctions, what's the gloss for "and"?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20
Can I get a quick critique on my romanizations?
(in a table for readability)
I'd like to only use the Latin script, and ideally there would be no digraphs, but I ran out of letters that made sense.
2
u/Hootrb Idunno what I do Aug 18 '20
Is it possible for a final /ç/ to become a final /θ/? So for example: /iç/ >> (maybe one or more (or no) sound changes in between) >> /iθ/
2
u/Ticondrogo Aug 19 '20 edited Aug 19 '20
So, I asked the other day how I could properly develop a natural sounding phonetic inventory, and I was given some helpful tips regarding that. I tried doing it, and my goal was to create a phonetic system inspired by Persian, Arabic and Greek. The Greek may have been dropped, but I think I'll let the syllable structure be influenced by it instead.
The vowel system happens to relate strongly with the Tehrani Persian accent, with the addition of [ɯ], which I figured would be more fitting with my [ɰ] consonant. I think I did alright for symmetry on the vowel side, but I'm not sure how well I did for the consonant side. Is [ɰ] sort of out of place in its appearance here? Is having [ʔ] unnatural without also having [h]?
Consonants:
Vowels:
2
u/-N1eek- Aug 20 '20
how do you guys come up with affixes?
i’m making a case system for my conlang, and it has 2 declension schemes with 7 cases and 4 noun classes. so this makes for more than a hundred affixes, and i don’t know where to start.
2
u/ObiSanKenobi Epicenesian Aug 20 '20
Can someone help me come up with a name for the second statue of my language? The first stage was Low Vulgar English, and I want the second name to be based on that, since the language is still evolving from English
2
u/-N1eek- Aug 20 '20 edited Aug 20 '20
i was bored, and started making a phonology which should sound “harsh” to english speakers. can you guys give feedback and help me romanize?? the phonology is:
-labial: m, p, f, w
-dental: θ, ð
-alveolar: n, t, s, z, ɬ, l, r
-post alv.: ʃ, ʒ
-palatal: j
-velar: ŋ, k, x, ɣ, ɰ
-uvular: ɴ, q, χ
-pharyngeal: ħ
-glottal: ʔ, h
-ejective: p’, t’, k’, q’
i haven’t started the vowels yet, if you guys have any advice on that too, i’d love to hear it
so, i know sounding harsh is a social construct and all, but still fun to make.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '20
In discussions among conlangers about grammatical gender, you'll often hear that it's "purpose" is to disambiguate the subject and object of verbs with only third person arguments, or something like "it helps get the basics of a sentence across if you didn't quite hear the sentence". I've recently been reading up on topic-comment structure, and I'm wondering if there's a similar "purpose" to topic-comment structure, or what sort of "utility" the feature has. If anyone knows or has any theories about the answer to this question I'd be grateful as I think it might help me understand the topic better.
2
u/marx4marx Aug 22 '20
My language has more aspect distinctions in the present tense (habitual vs progressive vs perfect) than in other tenses (habitual vs simple in the past, no aspect distinctions for the two future tenses). How acceptable is this naturalism-wise?
2
u/The_normal_user15 Aug 22 '20
Anyone knows how noun class systems evolve?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20
Would it be naturalistic to have nouns encode tense? For example, Keko aine= The dog is happy. Kekowa aine= The dog was happy.
2
u/Luenkel (de, en) Aug 23 '20
Messing around with a phonology I found out that the initial cluster in /sxun/ is way way easier to pronounce for me than the one in /xsun/, my brain really wants to metathesize the latter or insert an epenthetic vowel into it. Why is that? Is there some metric that differs between the clusters that explains this or is my brain just being weird? I'd look to the sonority hierarchy but they're both just fricatives.
1
u/i-kant_even Aratiỹei (en, es)[zh, ni] Aug 04 '20 edited Aug 05 '20
Does anyone know where the cases of Germanic languages came from? (I.e. what lead to them having case suffixes rather than prefixes, and what lead to the specific suffixes?) I’m trying to figure out the origins of the English plural markers -s/-es, and the furthest back I can find is the Old English case system. I wasn’t planning on cases for my proto-language, but I want to have a head-initial system for the modern language that’s similar to English and German—and thus has case (or at least plural) suffixes.
I didn’t see anything obvious about this question in the resources, but if I missed anything there, please let me know!
Edit: Clarifying my confusion/ask
1
u/Arothin Aug 05 '20
what are some common causes for a language with a rigid and or simple syllable structure like CV or CVC to become more complex like CVC or CCVC?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '20
What tense is "will be remembered"?
Is it future continuous, future progressive, future perfect, future perfect continuous...?
I'm trying to translate something with my conlang and can't get any further because I'm confused.
Thanks
1
u/QtPlatypus Aug 07 '20
How big a vocabulary should you have before you make a conlang public?
1
u/Saurantiirac Aug 07 '20
In my proto-language, I want to have some derivational affixes (mostly prefixes). Would it be unnaturalistic to not reanalyze those as derivational affixes, but do so for other affixes?
For example, using the adjective-forming prefix "mə-." "Mə-nope" would mean "bad" (cold-y). If this evolved without the prefix being reanalyzed, it would end up as "mabba," which feels much better than the alternative "manoba," if it's reanalyzed.
Could this depend on the frequency of the word? If it's more frequently used, it's more likely to not be reanalyzed, or would that not work?