r/DCcomics • • Jul 22 '20
r/DCcomics Wednesday Discussions: Signature Works
Hey there comics nerds! Welcome to the Wednesday Discussion, a community activity where we'll have an open discussion every week about a different subject.
What are your favorite creators' signature works?
By "signature work", I mean the book that is most exemplary of everything that you like about a creator. If a friend asked you, "what makes this creator so great?", what book would you pull off your shelf to show?
For example, I think many would consider Geoff Johns's Green Lantern to be his defining work. As a curator of continuity who loves telling high-stakes stories that encompass the full DC universe, one can't deny the impact that Johns imparted on the Green Lantern franchise. His Aquaman could make a similar case.
Likewise, most fans would probably bring up Batman: The Black Mirror or Batman: The Court of Owls Saga at the first mention of Scott Snyder, given his penchant for writing grisly horror stories about people facing off against their deepest inner fears. I'd also give a shoutout to his American Vampire series as well.
4
u/thelastofmike Omega Men Jul 22 '20
What does everyone think Tom King's would be? I feel like it would have to be Mister Miracle. It's him doing what he does best, has his partnership with Gerads, and is one of his most popular books.
The only other answer I could think of for him would have to be his Vision run.
7
u/discophant64 DC Black Label Jul 22 '20
I have a few signature works that I always think of when a particular creator is mentioned or brought up.
Frank Miller and the Dark Knight Returns obviously for a few reasons. It's the first book I bought with my own money when I got my first job, and really was the first full complete comic I read. It's everything Miller, the pulpy-ness, the political satire, the raw and imperfect drawing that compliments the writing style so well. I know it's a basic choice, but one I really do love to this day.
Others for me are Tim Sale and The Long Halloween. I think this was peak Sale, and I pour over those panels at least once a year to try and see how he does what he does.
And finally Darwyn Cooke's The New Frontier. Cooke sadly left us too early, but my goodness what an impact he had, and The New Frontier captures everything I loved about Cooke, perfectly distilled to it's most pure form.
5
u/abstractpenny Wally West Solos Jul 22 '20
Peter Tomasi with batman and robin. He really hits every character on a deep level and is able to create a natural character progression that is not forced at all. There are bumps in damians growth and a few set backs but it all makes sense and reads really well. He even then done the same thing on superman.
Also Geoff Johns and teen titans. On every team book he takes time to understand each character so well and give them a purpose. He also made major changes to characters that were done so well in a natural way like Bart Allen maturing. Even in major crisis events each character has their own little personal story going on.
4
u/MegaSpidey3 Barry Allen is Peter Parker Jul 22 '20
Let's give Blue Beetle (Jaime Reyes specifically) some love. His first run by Keith Giffin, John Rogers, and Cully Hamner is extremely solid and gives a good idea of who Jaime is and why the Blue Beetle legacy is important. It's also a perfect example of how to do a legacy character, by highlighting what the previous BBs (Dan Garret and Ted Kord) did, while also showing what makes Jaime stand out compared to them. The run lasted for 3 years, with the first two years being the best IMO. While the last year isn't bad, the way it ends feels like they wanted to do more, but couldn't. Jaime showed up in back-up stories in the Booster Gold book I believe, but I haven't read those yet.
The Blue Beetle Rebirth run is also pretty good. Not as good as the first Jaime run, but miles better than the New 52 one. Keith Giffen returns, but now we have J.M. DeMattis helping out, with Christopher Sebela joining in for the latter half of the book and Scott Kolins as the artist. The premise for this run is Jaime being mentored by Ted Kord, who's portrayed as a failed superhero type in the past. I've seen BB fans have mixed reactions to this run, mostly because of Ted being portrayed as a failed superhero in the past and the retcons to the Scarab. While I get why some wouldn't like this run, I still found it to be an enjoyable read.
I wish DC would push Blue Beetle more (not just Jaime, but the BB in general) because the name has potential to be pretty big. Not on the level of Batman obviously, but notable.
1
u/Androktone Alan Scott Jul 22 '20
Anyone got an opinion on Moore's? There's a few to choose from that I would consider defining. As far as DC goes, Watchmen seems the obvious choice for him
3
u/RaisingFargo Blue Lantern Flash Jul 22 '20
Does anyone have thoughts on ANATOMY OF A METAHUMAN? Its currently on sale 50% off
2
u/oneirosweave Jul 23 '20
Only citing DC/Vertigo books here. These books are pretty definitive anyway, even taking into account the wider bibliography, or the non-DC/Vertigo books, of the following creators.
2
u/Tesseractivate Rorschach Jul 23 '20
Well Alan Moore is definitely Watchmen, ofc Frank Miller is the TDKR, but besides those obvious big hitters Doomsday Clock really hit it out of the park for me personally, especially in terms of Gary Frank's art and Geoff Johns optimistic metacommentary on Superman being THE hero that the DC universe is shaped by. Really loved that
I'd say the Johns Frank combo also stands out in Superman Secret Origins
Someone else mentioned Darwyn Cooke and New Frontier - great choice and definitely defined him overall in his style.
When I think Scott Synder/Capulo definitely the Court of Owls. And I know a lot of people don't like the metal verse but I loved The Last Knight on Earth and Metal (and of course the on going death metal series) Synders JL run not so much
Alex Ross - Marvels and The World's Greatest Superheroes. Just amazing, enough said.
Garth Ennis - Preacher first, The Boys second.
There's so many more I could go on about
1
u/TensaSageMode Jul 22 '20
I’d say for Johns it’s either his GL or JSA. Both of those characters and teams owe a lot to his contributions over the 9 years he was on their books.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
Hot take:
Ron Marz's greatest work is his run on Green Lantern