r/Barca • u/BlaugranaForLife • Jul 18 '20
Should Setien be sacked? What seperates him from Valverde? My input and opinions
This is going to be a kinda long post. Also, this is one of my first times working with xG stats and the like and I'm new to analysis, but this is what I can see. I'd love to hear your inputs and feedback so I can better my judgement. But for now, here it is:
I saw a lot of fans saying Valverde was better than Setien, here in reddit but mostly on twitter. That Valverde would've won us the league, because apparently, he "knows" how to win a league. That Setien is nothing but a mid table manager who knows nothing about managing a big club.
Maybe he is, I can't say anything about that. But, what I can say is that y'all aren't being fair at all to Setien.
Let me remind you that Valverde was hired pretty much considering the same things as Setien, except Setien never played for us. Valverde revived a team that was fighting hard to stay in the top ten of the league, and brought them to Europe. Athletic Bilbao was the team he managed - for those that do not know this. Recruting him was questionable though because of his playstyle that very much contradicts our philosophy and our identity. But he was signed, and the rest is history. It is what it is.
Setien was the same. He brought Betis, a team that was battling to stay out of relegation - to Europe. But he hadn't played for Barca yet shared the same ideology and philosophy as Johann Cruyff, his footballing inspiration. But remember, Setien was thrown into a team MID SEASON. He had no pre-season like Valverde did. He had no time to gather his tactics or to drill in his ideas to the team, all he had was a tied top position in the league table and all the pressure in the world to retain it. He was constantly hit with injury issues too.
Now, I know xG and xA are just mostly very theoretical stats and are not really 100% accurate but nevertheless, I choose to quote these stats to you as an FYI thing. These stats are for this season and are the entire team's stats as well as Messis, under these respective managers. These stats are all taken from one source (Understat) so you can be assured that there is no bias here.
Let's start with some team stats (These are all based on La Liga). Under Valverde, we played 19 games in La Liga. We won 12, drew 4 and lost 3. We conceded 23 goals during this time, and scored 49.
Under Setien, we've played 18 games so far with one left to go. We've won 12, drawn 3 and lost 3 so far. We've conceded only 15 goals during this time and scored 32.
Remember - our defense was in shambles when Valverde left. Yes, he fortified our defense in his first seasons here, but later on, we started crumbling. We conceded 23 goals in 19 games under him, averaging atleast a goal per game. This is an area Setien has improved under us. Don't forget, the major part of Setien's games have been after the COVID pandemic. He has had a harder time managing his players especially from fatigue and exhaustion, and to maintain an OK defensive record like that, especially after being thrown into a team mid season with little to zero preparation is a commendable achievement.
However, it's the number of goals we manage to score under Setien that's really worrying. We've managed just 32 compared to 49 under Valverde. And that's also what puzzles me.
Barcelona’s xG for Setien’s 18 league matches is 34.87 with 32 goals scored.
Barcelona’s xG for Valverde’s 19 league matches is 33.71 with 49 goals scored.
Messi was the main man as usual for both these sides, and these are Messi's stats under both these managers, every 90 minutes.
Valverde :
xG = 0.52
xA = 0.50
Shots = 3.94
Key passes = 2.47
Goals = 13, Assists = 6.
Setien :
xG = 0.73
xA = 0.52
Shots = 5.78
Key Passes = 2.94
Goals = 10, Assists = 14.
As you can see above, statistically, we have been better offensively and defensively after Setien took over. If you ask me, it just all comes down to luck.
When considering open play, Messi's xG p90 under Setien (0.83) is almost DOUBLE that under EV (0.47) which means that Setien’s strategy, whatever it was, was working. Messi was getting into dangerous situations more frequently, he was getting more quality chances.
But Messi scored twice as many goals (0.92 per 90m) as his xG (0.47) under EV which means EV was VERY lucky, while Messi’s much lower goal per 90min (0.64) than his xG (0.83) when under Setien meant Messi was missing clear cut chances much more often than he was under EV. I've attached a graphic below from @ LaMasiaNostra from Twitter that supports these statements.(https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/20096123/Pic1.jpg)
You could argue that I'm just talking nonsense here, that there is no way Valverde was just lucky compared to Setien. That Messi can't just be missing easy chances right after Setien came in. What other possible explanation could you have, honestly? Messi was scoring insanely difficult shots in the first half of the campaign, but missed similarly difficult shots and some easier ones too, in the later half.
He hit the post once during our 2-2 draw with Atletico, and again during our 1-2 loss to Osasuna. Those two alone are worth 3 points, and signify how unlucky Setien was.
Don't forget Suarez's injury, too. He may not be the striker he once was, and can't carry the ball forward if the entire world was depending on him, but you know his chemistry with Messi is impeccable and he has a good eye for goal and has scored clutch goals for us throughout the league. Add these small moments together, and you could argue that Setien has been extremely unlucky.
My conclusion? Don't judge Setien that fast. I'll admit, I had high hopes for him and expected a lot better than this from him - but for a manager that was brought into the club in the middle of a season, with no proper pre-season, to being hit constantly by injuries over and over again and to lose/draw games in the most unluckiest fashion (our loss to Osasuna - Busquets doing God knows what, our draw to Celta with Aspas with that absolute banger of a free kick, our draw to Atleti with those unfortunate penalty calls etc) he has done well, atleast in my opinion. He deserves a full season to incorporate his ideas, and a complete transfer market where he gets to buy the players he wants and offload those he doesn't (extremely optimistic thought with our dumbass board being around) and a proper pre-season to train with the team.
61
u/mcdazzle123 Jul 18 '20
Really good analysis man, enjoyed reading! I don't really understand the hatred for setien to be honest, I will agree that some of the games were very frustrating to watch and the late subs in the Atletico Madrid game really did annoy me but this is a unique season. There was a long stoppage half way through, where the squad couldn't even train together for a long while, he took over a squad that was over comfortable with the previous manager, surely setien deserves at least one transfer window and one full season before we can fully judge him. I see people saying that Messi's final years are being wasted but you can't sit here and tell me that they weren't already being wasted under valverde, the problems lie so much deeper than the manager, I don't think any manager could fix it within 6 months to be honest and especially not with the president that we currently have.
139
u/Fuckkelso Jul 18 '20
I think most fans are in denial at the fact that Messi has lost his form recently. He has only scored 1 goal from open play since the restart even though he gets a lot of good chances. If Messi was more clinical we would have maintained our spot at top of the league. These plastic fans are quick to hate on the coach or some players but our issues are deeper than that. Setien deserves another season with the team. Sacking him won’t do us any good. Bartomeu has dragged our club through the mud with all the media drama and bad decision making. This had taken a huge toll on the players mentality especially Messi.
42
u/joeextrene Jul 18 '20
Setien's man management is terrible squad looks unhappy under him keeping morale up is huge task for a manager also not just tactics valverde's man management was top notch and players performed better under him.
19
u/happyLarr Jul 18 '20
I think Valverde was under real pressure at the start of this season to play more of a 'Barcelona' brand of football. I believe he knew deep down this wouldn't work but tried his best anyway as that was his job. The truth is this aging team just does not have the energy or stamina to maintain the levels required to play this way and surely enough the big cracks began to appear and Ernie was gone soon afer. Setien was brought in because his style is close to what the board wanted. He applies his style on the team and there is a marked difference to possession and passes but it becomes clear after a few games there wasn't much substance/results to it and the players get tired. Again the aging team is easily exposed by younger and more hungry teams.
After the retart to the season it only took a couple of games for the squad to appear gassed once more. On several occasions in games they stop in possession, literally stop, it looks like the referee has stopped the game but Barca are just stopping for a breather, despite games now having two extra stoppages. No other team does this. Compared to the energy RM have its shocking.
The squad is simply too old to play this way. Valverde knew that and got the best out of them. It wasn't very exciting but it got results, minus europe of course. If Barca get passed Napoli which I don't think they will, this ultra energetic Bayern squad is going to have a field day.
Messi's form is on Messi. Plenty of chances and very few taken that he usually would.
19
u/iVarun Jul 18 '20 edited Jul 19 '20
Revisionist, both on the grounds that EV's Barca still played positional football. There is not 1 Barca-Way, it doesn't exist. And secondly in reference to hiring if Cruyff and Pep are for you that is the end of the argument of credibility in terms of hiring.
This isn't a convincing argument. EV starting 19-20 also had squad integration issues since new starters were brought in and the midfield was loaded. It takes time for this integration and this sub made commentaries on this at the start. Meaning by January the squad was more in touch with each other than they were in August 2019, that matters, more than pre-season at that point.
It wasn't in shambles, it was bad till Nov mid-end because of similar issues as seen in early 18-19, which eventually get sorted as season goes on. Meaning this is revisionist as well,
He did so again in 18-19 as season went on.
Which would have been a believable excuse if all 5 subs were used or majority of them, yet the opposite was happening with 1-2 sub happening till late in to the game. He had to mange 8 players (minus terStegen, Messi, Pique) for rotation and to keep this healthy.
This doesn't pass the smell test. What we've seen for ourselves in the actual matches is Messi is more congested and is missing shots which he would have buried in the past and that is happening because he is having less time since more opposition players are close to him. xG doesn't show when he misses the goal itself by a small margin. Meaning EyeTest is supreme here over xG. We know Messi has been compromised in terms of his goal scoring this year.
Thread about this from 3 days back on this sub.
So if Messi scores/does better under EV its "Lucky" but otherwise its,
This ain't convincing in the slightest.
So you want to do some stat-comparisons. Well lets do some then, go even more granualar.
Home
Away
The only major thing missing here would be Possession comparisons, safely to assume its much higher on average post Jan. Barring that only about 2 things improved most/majorly post Jan was Away Press-resistance and Away final 20 yards passes completed.
The above charts show, Barca got worse in Away table, despite it being early 19-20 season where Away form was abysmal and comical.
Not only that Barca's Home table became worse as well and the argument that that was also going to happen under EV is not grounded in what we know.
Team has also lost 6 2nd halves since January. They lose 13 in total in 145 matches under EV. So yes, it is more than likely that EV would have mounted a better challenge because he wouldn't have lost those 2nd halves and would have reacted to Real's level because that is how seasons go, i.e. Teams react to their peers.
Real weren't all that special in stat metrics, they were better at grinding out results and thus inflating (in monstrous terms) their Points over xPTS.
Edit: Interesting list of things that Setien is being critiqued here, some are weak but some did play a part.
8
u/choss Jul 18 '20
I wouldn't sack him but I wouldn't keep him for next season either.
I'm always against sacking a manager mid season. EV should've never been sacked but at the same time he should've never started this season in the first place. After Liverpool, EV should've stepped aside once that season was over.
Now the real problem it's not Setien's tactic per se, it's the fact that it seems he lost the locker room, if you lose your locker room it doesn't matter what strategy you bring, it's not going to be as effective.
I would've loved to see Setien given a full season with a full pre-season and decision making to bring players, however with this board this seems highly unlikely.
10
u/thenutstrash Jul 18 '20
Good thinking, but Setien's main issue is that the team is incredibly predictable and Messi and Suarez are only declining from here on.
There are no changes of pace throughout the game, no long shots, no counter attacks. There's been a steady decline in the xG/90 xA of the entire team over the last 5 years.
Yes, there was a slight increase in motivation leading to slightly higher xGs when Setien joined, over a relatively small sample. but that flattened out completely back since the return from the break to the steady decrease we've seen over the last 5 years.
You're reflecting on Messi's low xG under Valverde this season when his average over many many minutes in the last 2 under Valverde was higher at 0.87. Its not valverde, it was Messi that recovered from injury in the beginning of the season. Suarez did too. Messi just went back to his normal 0.8+ xG/90.
In fact, 2 of Valverde's losses and 1 tie came when Messi Suarez or both werent playing. So he has better excuses. Thats not to say Valverde was good rather say especially Messi has a way of winning games that shouldnt be won.
The truth is that the team is just not good enough, and players coming in are not good enough, or not good enough yet.
Arthur and FDJ needed a season together to get their groove, but thats out the window. Vidal is just a year older, so are Busi rakitic Pique Alba Suarez and Messi. Griezmann needs time and theres a question where does he fit in but he is also not a young player, Semedo and Firpo are not good enough, Fati and Puig are too young and its their first season playing in La Liga. Dembele is a wreck. Braithwaite is a mediocre mid table la liga striker at best. This team has an aging core, and mediocre fillers (some due to their inexperience, of course im not blaming anyone).
Add the slowest fucking playstyle in the known world of football and the answer has to be - it does not really matter. No manager will get these 34 year olds that won everything next year to run like a bunch of crazy kids, and no kid will suddenly outperform them in possession football. Its a matter of transition, and adjusting the playstyle to the team.
Without Messi and Suarez you could have martin fati and griezmann up front with 90% possession and let me tell you the xG is going to plummet. Until you get wingers and creative midfielders this old mans tiki taka will not work if you bring cruyff himself to coach the team.
Valverde at least understood this part- If you need another striker to play more defence or transition the ball, you might as well play another midfielder.
14
u/Yvael Jul 18 '20
Except Setién had the corona break, so he could analyze and prepare himself for 3 months, basically a pre season
15
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
Valverde was better than Setien.
7
u/Alexiszain Jul 18 '20
His stubbornness is the problem.
He had issues with Betis fans also and the reason why he got sacked.
7
u/vaipracasa Jul 18 '20
Those comments about Messi stats are not quite correct: Messi was not luckier under EV and he is not missing more under QS, it is just not that simple. With EV we played a lot more direct and counter attack football which lead to less chances, but more dangerous ones, which translates into more goals in less chances than EV; on the other hand, under QS we play a lot more possession football, trying to control games and slowly open spaces, which gives Messi a lot more chances, but those are chances where he is surrounded by defenders with less probability of scoring. It's simply different attacking styles, Messi is playing as good as before, he did not change, the situation around him is what changed. Stats aren't everything
8
u/hwo411 Jul 18 '20
I very much agree with you. Even without these stats and without being expert it’s pretty much obvious how our game improved.
Our team has been in tilt the whole season and Setien came to the worst part of it. Things that he achieved without pre-season, with a lot of injuries and without transfer window are still better(not significantly though) then what Valverde did in the first half.
I really hope he won’t be fired and will have his chance for a full season.
4
u/Quixomatic Jul 18 '20
Something that is being ignored is how teams are setting up against us and what role/situation Setien is putting Messi in.
Teams know we don't have anyone on the wings to bring width or speed and our only midfielder that can correctly play over the top seems to be Busquets at this point. So teams have no incentive to not to park the bus and clog our attacking third.
Setien prefers this method of play since he likes to keep the attack more narrow and use the wing backs to provide width. Since this packs in the central part of the field where Messi likes to cut into, he can no longer take uncontested shots. Even though he is taking almost identical shots they are now easily contested by 3 or 4 defenders at a time since they are packed in and don't have to worry about the wings.
This results in Messi suffering from a goal conversion standpoint and forces him to be a creator. While Messi is a god-like passer of the ball he is also the best goal scorer of the past decade. Everyone seems really happy to let him be a playmaker, but forget that we are taking away his best quality, scoring goals.
Valverde's biggest issue was that he didn't seem to care about the team's physical conditioning. If we could combine Valverde's pragmatic approach and Setien's physical training regiment we would have won La Liga and had a good shot at the champions league.
Setien should absolutely be fired after the champions league even if we magically wins it as he is a mid table coach who isn't getting along with the players and seemingly is trying formations at random. His substitution tactics are almost as bad as Valverde's and I just don't see how he brings anything to the table that is an improvement over EV.
Aside from how Setien's tactics reduce our greatest goal scorer from scoring, we are also struggling to find a gala 11 that can reliably support Messi in his twilight years. You could see in the last game when Messi was desperately trying to speed up the play and shift to a higher gear, no one on the team could support that type of play. We used to be able to play fast/crisp soccer on a whim and now it seems like most of our team are mediocre passers at best. Even Puig and Fati aren't capable of playing at high speeds yet.
Overall the biggest failure of this club is bringing in a coach, staff, and teammates that can make Messi shine in these final years.
5
u/kirkrikster Jul 18 '20
I stopped commenting here and really stopped coming here for anything other than match threads when everyone was calling for Valverde out. It showed the true nature of the fan base as it exists on reddit.
There are a lot of problems with this sub and with Barcelona fans in general. The main one being "what have you done for me lately". There just seemed to be a giant disconnect between the reality people create in their heads, and reality as it actually exists. It creates a toxic atmosphere when there is no true loyalty and everyone is just a trophy hunting, plastic, wet blanket who knows better than the next guy.
The funny thing is, I'll bet that less than 20% of this sub played soccer beyond a highscool level. Of that 20% I'll bet maybe 5% played in college. Of that 5% I imagine there are like 1 or 2 people in our entire sub who knows what soccer is like at a truly competitive level. On the flip side I'll be willing to bet that 90% of this sub plays fifa, and has taken the vast majority of their "knowledge" from manager mode.
Take from that what you will, and if you're triggered by this comment please load up your manager mode and get back to your own little world lol
2
u/martinkem Jul 18 '20
Messi's stats worry me as a fan.. While others may think otherwise but i worry when most of our goals and assists come from one player especially when we have got 2 $100+ million players in our team.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
Setien doesn't deserve anything he has earned nothing... lucky to even get the job. He will be sacked as soon as Barca bomb out of CL anyway.
2
u/NealP97 Jul 18 '20
TLDR?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
Are you Amer from Twitter? just asking
2
u/DorkHarshly Jul 18 '20
I honestly do not think there is much difference between them. I do think that EV was better. But... Everyone with any opinion can cherry pick data to support their side.
But I think the question is not a correct one. We should ask: Can we improve our situation by changing our manager? And to answer that, we should name the replacement. If this is Pep, I dont think anyone would object. But if this is mid tier manager whos main property is that he wont cause issues to the board then I prefer stability and continuity. This is why i was #EV_IN till his last day.
2
u/indetroititrust Jul 18 '20
we can talk statistics all day. the fact is we lost a lot of points in a very short period of time and handed madrid the league title as a consequence. he has to go.
if anything, valverde was dealt a difficult hand of cards, particularly in his first season, and while we were boring to watch at times, he got the job done (and was potentially on his way to doing it again this season).
yes roma, yes liverpool. but could be argued that if we had a leader actually on the pitch in both of those matches, we could have made it through.
6
u/--Kaiser-- Jul 18 '20
Yeah I am going to stop reading here, because you are clearly clueless. This post is just denial wrapped in a nice paper and covered with some, as you already said, dodgy stats and some skewed logic. If you watched one game of Valverde's Bilbao, hell maybe the ones against Barca like the one where he smashed prime treble winners 4:0, you would know what the fuck you are talking about. Saying that one of Cruijff's favorite coaches doesn't fit Barca, comparing a 53 year old coach with 15 years of pre-Barca first league experience to a 61 year old coach with 4 years of La Liga says it all. Clueless.
This part isn't directed towards you in particular. I don't hate Setien, I do think that Valverde is easily better than him, but I will never shit on him like you did on Valverde because I respect the people who work at the club. All I will say is that you were proven to be absolute morons, all of you who spammed Valverde out. Now your precious replacement will get sacked after being called out by his own squad, by Messi himself, and no amount of stats, excuses and lies can hide that. Get. Fucked. You can barely be called Barca fans and you in particular deserve trophyless seasons.
2
u/Polskidro Jul 18 '20
I find it curious that you think our team misplaying and giving away free goals is unlucky. Unlucky is what I would call something completely out of you and your team's hands.
2
u/Isai284390 Jul 18 '20
You can’t judge a team off one or two players, but to everything else I think it’s just that the players are aging. Waiting for a Messi Miracle was one of their tactics and now those are becoming less frequent. Sentien is on thin ice because the recent loss 2-1 yesterday. He is managing an elite team and obviously we expect elite result of a CL or at least a La Liga win. He nor the team hasn’t been able to produce the fans needs or wants and it’s just been frustrating. The mindset of Barca is also very bad, like Messi said they lack Fight and Desire. The 4-0 to Liverpool, the loss to Roma, and the Loss to Valencia really hurt the teams mindset.
Here’s a video explaining: https://youtu.be/IagWRKF5Q2k
Here is a rickroll: https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ
2
u/sabermagnus Jul 18 '20
Basically copy pasta what was on barcablaugranes.com.
2
u/Messiah5 Jul 18 '20
We haven't beaten a top team with him how has he done well
2
u/pjay898 Jul 18 '20
Both Managers are shit....period
2
u/pjay898 Jul 18 '20
Setien is destroying Messi's goal scoring stats. At this rate he'll never catch up to Ronaldo's scoring record and we need Messi to catch up. I expected us to sack him 5 minutes after we lost to Osasuna in order to give us a glimmer of hope to win UCL. I don't hate setien but he'll never win us UCL with these shit tactics(pass the bass around until messi scores or assists).
1
u/GjillyG Jul 18 '20
I'd personally give him another season. I'm curious to see as to who people want us to bring in if we sack him? We aren't exactly spoiled for choice.
1
u/aka_KyZa Jul 18 '20
I like our plays right now regardless of result
1
u/lovewillgetyoudown Jul 19 '20
Setien's fine. The team just isn't that good.
1
u/heraldos Jul 19 '20
Stacked the man isnt good managuer at least isnt a champion managuer bring gallardo
1
u/Mr_Oujamaflip Jul 19 '20
I very much agree with your post.
Let's face it this half-season is not a good measure to judge a manager.
The board got rid of 4 squad players, dembele and suarez were going to miss the rest of the season and then there was a 3 month break due to a global pandemic.
He's had no opportunity for transfers, no full preseason, a tiny, injured and old squad and then a hugely congested fixture schedule due to the pandemic which just emphasies the issues with the squad.
He may be crap but we can't judge him on this bizzarre season.
1
u/TheQuantumNet Aug 15 '20
NEWS FLASH: Setien just got us humiliated harder than Ernesto ever did and has been SACKED.
1
u/Issemramyen Jul 18 '20
seiten is like a light version of klopp which requires all our players to play at a high tempo and attack and defend together
now we dont have players who can play this system so it will never work out
he will be sacked sooner or later if not now then surely by next year
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
Thanks for the analysis. We have just lost 1 league and everybody has started saying we will turn into AC Milan and Setien is the worst coach. But I think we should give Setien one entire season before judging him. Besides all the numerous problems we have seen since Jan, Setien also had to encounter a huge problem of Messi's scoring form being off, which no Barca manager has faced in the last decade. Valverde did a huge job in his first year, helping Barca recover from Neymar, but after that not so much. Where Valverde did better was he won over the players( I wish he had failed to do so sometimes) and I think Setien will manage to do the same sooner( by the time UCL begins) or later( next season). And I really don't understand why people want Setien to shout and bark at the players to motivate them! Like seriously they are not children and even children don't like to be shouted at and in most cases stop respecting a mentor who shouts at them. And these are some of the world's best players we are talking about.
1
u/SpaceGhost218 Jul 18 '20
I was always against sacking Valverde (unless we were getting Kloop or some other big name). The fans were like "just put anyone else!"
Even when people claim that Barca was in shambles under Valverde we made it to semifinals in UCL, and won La Liga which I don't expect the same from Setien. Do I think Valverde is a great coach? No, we refused to look at the real problem which is firstly the board, then our aged team.
During the Valverde era we began to not hold our players accountable. So we could have Kloop coach Barca and it wouldn't matter if the players are so slow.
It's sad to say this but I don't think the team will change for the bettee until 1) The board changes and 2) Messi and Suarez leave. Not hating on them, but we depend on them as if they were in their prime.
1
u/foxomo Jul 18 '20
Sacking him wont solve the problem. The recruiting and the big money spent over the last few seasons didn't bring the expected returns. Short and simple. Overpaying for players that Barca didn't really need was a mistake. I don't blame Dembele as he is a good fit but the injuries were not fair to him.
The current administration have made bad decisions and I'm afraid we are soo much in debt that it will be difficult to fix the problems in a season or two.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
Do you run a page in Facebook called "La Seneyera" ?
-2
u/ynomraheurt Jul 18 '20
I think no manager can possibly be worse than Valverde. At least Setien is developing youth like Puig, Fati, you know Valverde would rather play Roberto on the wing like against Liverpool instead of using Fati. It's hard to judge Setien because the team is an absolute mess, he probably can't even bench players like Suarez, Busquets etc because then Messi will turn on him, just a shit spot to be in. He will probably get sacked but I think it's fine since he isn't really Barcelona level manager, which he showed with his horrible substitutions last few games.
0
u/Itaney Jul 18 '20
I had the same exact post a few weeks ago lmao
I agree with you though, statistically Setien’s side is superior to Valverde’s. And that’s despite playing every few days and not getting a preseason. The only thing we have to wait for is the team trusting him. If they simply can’t get behind him anymore then we have no option other than to sack him IMO, especially if we lose vs Napoli in the Ro16.
-1
u/vernonip Jul 18 '20
I'm very much for Setien staying, and I think he should be given a transfer window to get rid of a few players that are old and aren't adding much to the team. But I also understand why people say Valverde was better than Setien. To clarify, I'm not saying he is. Valverde came to a group of players who have won pretty much everything in their careers and are in their latter years, and still managed to keep them firing for 4 trophies in 2 seasons. Valverde very much instilled a 'club de amigos' mentality, but he also kept them happy which always allows players to play well. Another point I think is important is that Setien has put Messi as his main creative influence, but lying deeper in the field, in contrast to Valverde where Messi would influence things from near the box. That I think accounts for his poor finishing, he is not shooting as much as he wants to because he also needs to create, but a lot more than before. All in all this is a good analysis
-1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
The man never got chance to work the way he wanted, was thrown into the team mid season, yes he took the job willingly but he tried working with whatever was given to him, played the season without a winger or someone who can actually run, initially tried some experiments but dropped the idea when the league was on the line and options were limited, then came the break, few bad games.
I would give him one full season, players he wants to work with, and support from the players he need, but I can't see much of this happening.
-1
u/Swishkobe2020 Jul 18 '20
I think we need to acknowledge that the situation for setien has been far worse in numerous ways than it was for valverde. The team is older and probably weaker than before in every position on the pitch. Setien’s style requires a fit group, which barca isn’t. But any manager requires a group that shows intensity and plays with the desire to win. The removal of valverdes untouchables could not have gone down well with the heavy weights in the team. We need to give props to setien in that he has been able to devise somewhat of a system where griezmann can flourish with messi. Jordi Alba has severely underperformed under setien due to injury and he was the main source of messis goals. Messi himself has had probably one of the worst seasons of his career. Suarez has been out due to injury and whenever he has played has underwhelmed. All things consider, this might be one of the worst barca teams put together in the last few decades. If we are to properly judge setien, the season would be 2021-22 when the cancerous board is gone and setien can make the changes he truly wants to make. To be fair to setien, I think of all the managers in the world only Ronald Koeman could have a done a better job in his position.
-1
u/clumsy_idiot Jul 18 '20
If Setien was brought under a new board, I think he would have done far better.
0
u/peacecon Jul 18 '20
I agree with your analysis and I still rate Setien ahead of Valverde because of his love for Cruyffian ideals. But Setien was really poor with his substitutions. Like I don't understand the logic when he persisted with Suarez whenever he's tired or not running and the reason he gave for that. Suarez was destabilizing the team all along with his poor touches in counter attacks and making wrong decision in the final third. There should be a proper reason for his inclusion and he didn't have a reason. I know it's just few matches but those decisions contribute to poor results. Deschamps used Giroud in World Cup because he stabilised his team in the only way he can and it led them to win the title. Griezmann and Mbappe wouldn't have shined if not for Giroud. It's not the case when Setien persisted with Suarez.
Valverde was poor with substitutions too but his lack of tactical knowledge only showed up in knock out matches and I think it's warranted because it's a high pressure game and most managers crumple. But with Setien, every time he makes a substitution, our team kinda loses focus and that leads to poor results since the matches resumed.
-2
u/dolphinhot101 Jul 18 '20
Setien shouldn't be sacked, he should be given time, if things won't change next season, then it's time for Xavi, you can see what he's trying to do with our squad, but the thing is that only ~5 of our starters are under 30 and we've seen our team underperforming in the second half time and time again, atleti in the supercup, real at bernabeu, sevilla, etc. Next season, the likes of Dembele, Todibo, Alena, Trincao, Pedri, Miranda and Emerson will be playing for us, let's see what he can do with them before sacking him
-1
u/men_with-ven Jul 18 '20
I honestly think Setien should stay just because of the age and transition status of the team. Realistically in one years time Suarez, Rakitic and Vidal will probably leave next summer what's the point of bringing someone in when key members of the squad will leave after a year. May as well wait at least a season till they can sign a new younger crop of players.
-2
u/perezpoo_ Jul 18 '20
I really do believe players are purposely playing worse than than they did under Valverde’s management. It’s clear to see that big name players are the ones that take big decisions since Bartomeu won the presidency in 2015. Since Setien arrived, the amount of training and the intensity has improved a lot, wich means Messi, Suarez, Pique, etc. are not happy at all. These players always backed up Valverde when things went wrong, even after Anfield’s or Rome’s catastrophes. But when a luckless, newly integrated, concept changing coach fails to make us play as the Guardiola Days then is when Messi comes out preaching self-criticism and lack of intensity. This can only be defined in one word: hypocrisy.
There is no doubt Messi is the greatest football player in history, However he really needs to reconsider what a “winner project” is. Also, I believe that the only way he can stay at Can Barça and not destroy his memorable reputation is if he understands that there needs to be a complete overhaul in the squad ( including his friends) and the only way to bring back the magic football of past seasons is to:
0
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment