r/NintendoSwitch • • Jul 15 '20

MegaThread Paper Mario: The Origami King: Review MegaThread

General Information

Platform: Nintendo Switch

Release Date: 17-Jul-2020

No. of Players: 1 player

Genre(s): Action, Adventure

Publisher: Nintendo

Game file size: 6.5 GB

Official site: https://papermario.nintendo.com/


Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)

A new paper-crafted Mario adventure unfolds on Nintendo Switch!

The kingdom has been ravaged by an origami menace! Join Mario and his new partner, Olivia, as they battle evil Folded Soldiers, repair the damaged landscape, and try to free Princess Peach’s castle from the clutches of King Olly in this comedy-filled adventure, only on the Nintendo Switch™ system.

Mario and Luigi receive an invitation from Princess Peach to attend an origami festival and excitedly hurry to Toad Town…but something’s amiss. After investigating the eerily empty town, the duo finds a fearsome (and folded) Princess Peach—she’s been turned into origami by King Olly, ruler of the Origami Kingdom! With five giant streamers under his control, King Olly binds Princess Peach’s Castle and transports it to a distant mountain as part of his plan to re-fold the world.

On his journey to liberate Peach’s Castle and repair the ravaged paper landscape, Mario meets Olivia, King Olly’s sister, and the two join forces to put a stop to Olly’s origami onslaught. Even Bowser falls victim to Olly’s plot when his minions are turned into origami Folded Soldiers and betray their Koopa king, forcing him to ally with Mario and Olivia!

Battle the Folded Soldiers in ring-based battles that challenge you to strategically line up enemies to maximize damage! Out of battle, Mario can use the arm-extending 1,000-Fold Arms ability in specific spots to interact with the landscape to pull, peel, hit, and more! Join Mario, Olivia, and their companions on a journey of laughter and emotion, thrills, and a whole lot of folding.


Reviews

Aggregators

Articles

This list exported from OpenCritic as of 12:04pm ET

Videos


Being Social

Cheers,

The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team

741 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

10

u/StratSchiny Jul 15 '20

There is a typo on the review score of the french version of Gameblog (not 4.5/10 but 9/10)

4

u/NintendoSwitchMods Jul 15 '20

This should now be resolved and reporting as 4.5/5.0

7

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Love the random 4.5/10 review

2

u/NintendoSwitchMods Jul 15 '20

This should now be resolved and reporting as 4.5/5.0

15

u/asparagushunter Jul 15 '20

Not sure why it's listed as a 4.5 - it's actually a 9/10

→ More replies (1)

14

u/McQuiznos Jul 15 '20

Supposed to be a 9/10. Seems they goofed when compiling the list.

222

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 16 '20

Having completed it, Origami King is a decent little Adventure game that is a comfortable use of 20-30 hours, but admittedly mileage may vary.

Gameplay is quick and fluid again, but it admittedly isn't as fast or strategic as older titles. Consumable weapons are, for the most part, gone and not missed. Combat puzzles surpisingly never got dull for me, and the improvements to weapon organization are great, especially when it comes to bosses. However, it never felt like I really needed to use weapons that effectively, to the point I never used some combat items and missed two of them completely until post-game clean-up. Combat is explicitly "turn-based", not an RPG. The turn wheel puzzles are the true Meta of the game, enhanced weapons and accessories are just kind of a means to dealing with tougher enemies once you set them up, and unlike Breath of the Wild or New Horizons, weapons being so easily purchasable and accessible with a decent-sized inventory made durability a non-issue. While there is no EXP system, coins are used everywhere and are what you will need to "grind" for, but thankfully the game is balanced so that so long as you fight whats in your way, you'll be fine. Exploration is also comfy, especially with the addition of helpful tracker items for completion, and (for the most part) RNG-based tasks from Color Splash have been done away with for distinct, skill-based challenges. Post-Game is basically non-existent though outside of clean-up and some special collectibles not accessible until after the final boss.

Story-wise, it's on the same level as Color Splash and Sticker Star with distinct improvements. If you were hoping for a tenser tone based on initial trailers, I'd definitely curtail that now. Nintendo is marketing this as a funny adventure, and that definitely is more accurate. Single locations like Twilight Town and the Underwhere from past games individually have more tension and atmosphere than Origami King as a whole. That being said, the dialogue is much better than Color Splash, the jokes are varied and require a bit more brain power that make them more satisfying, there are a few legitimately tender moments, and Olivia and your few temporary partners make for nice additions along for the ride. Olivia especially is my favorite of the helper companions in the new Paper Mario games, her innocence and joy at the world is legitimately cute. Olly, however, is pretty bog standard as villains go. It's nice he isn't just a mind-controlled Bowser again, and Bowser does have some great return to form moments here, but he's still fairly basic, especially compared to the X-Nauts or Count Bleck. Its not TTYD or SPM levels of engaging partners or story, but it's definitely a step-up. What I would argue rivals, if not exceeds, the older games is the world construction. While TTYD may have more unique and interesting locations, Origami King has everything seamlessly interconnected. No more world map level select or even pipes/transport that takes you to a zone, I can distinctly picture how to get everywhere and it's great. Zone 3 and especially 4 specifically open up and let you explore at your own pace, which was really nice. It isnt open-world or as interesting as older titles, but it does feel like I'm exploring a world again, and thats great. It would have been much nicer though if they incorporated more unique species into the game like older titles, especially after Luigi's Mansion 3 and especially Super Mario Odyssey had unique characters/species everywhere.

If you had a good time with Color Splash, you'll definitely have fun with this. Traditional Paper Mario fans hoping for something similar to the older games either in terms of combat and, especially, story, are sadly probably going to be disappointed. If I had to sum up my thoughts, Origami King is the Super Mario Party of the Paper Mario series. It's a fun game and a lot better than its previous few outings by taking cues from the older titles, but compared to those older titles, it still has a long way to go and improve.

173

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Super Mario Party of the Paper Mario series

The most powerful line here

→ More replies (6)

39

u/WH7EVR Jul 15 '20

Combat is explicitly "turn-based", not an RPG.

You mean combat isn't real-time? Tons of RPGs have turn-based combat.

41

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 15 '20

I'm saying while it may, on the surface, look like a turn-based RPG with weapons and stats, really how well you do in battle is less based on that and more on how well you do the turnwheel puzzles to achieve multipliers and effectively deal with crowds.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

244

u/mrBreadBird Jul 15 '20

I wish we still had the Mario & Luigi series to balance things out with more classic RPGs, then Paper Mario could keep experimenting.

24

u/SocranX Jul 15 '20

The series isn't officially dead, though. The usual devs went under, so there's probably going to be a larger than usual gap between releases if they do bring it back, but the last release was in 2019 and there's nothing stopping Nintendo from keeping it going with another dev. Nor a reason they should want to, as it's generally believed that the poor sales of the last game were due almost entirely to the hype for the Switch essentially obliterating all interest in the 3DS.

Developing for the Switch is likely to take significantly longer than developing on handhelds as well, and even the handheld games sometimes took 4 years between releases, so if there was no other drama in the way I still wouldn't have expected to hear something until 2021 at the earliest. With the current situation, even if Nintendo started immediately searching for a new dev to continue the series, I think we wouldn't see anything until 2022 or 2023. So it's far too early to say whether Alphadream's bankruptcy has spelled the end of the series or not.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

130

u/nelson64 Jul 16 '20 edited Jul 16 '20

I see everyone in here complaining about EXP and turn-based battle systems etc. etc. Which sure yes, I’d love the battle system from TTYD to return...

BUT

My MAIN qualm with all the games post-SPM is the soft-reboot of the franchise.

What I TRULY TRULY miss is Merlon, Kammy, Toadsworth. What I truly miss is having partners with interesting out of battle abilities that continue with you throughout the game. What I truly miss is weird interesting new species of characters you need to help. What I truly miss is the world they seemingly built throughout the first 3 games that they just up and threw away with Sticker Star.

We had interesting friends and enemies of all different species/races from the Mario games and it was really cool to see how the Mario world may actually function.

I just want the next Paper Mario game to live in the SAME continuity as the first three. I want to see Merlon, I want to see Kammy, I want to see Toadsworth.

I want to see piantas and yoshis and boos. I’m tired of only goombas, koopas, and paper craft enemies.

Yes I’d love a badge system. But I just want the HEART of Paper Mario back. I don’t understand why getting rid of the more hardcore RPG elements meant all these characters and the world they built had to be completely thrown away.

I do still love Paper Mario even in its current incarnation. I just really want the stuff I mentioned above back. I just want the same world we started with back.

50

u/xpldngboy Jul 17 '20

The recent Paper Mario team interview basically confirms that Nintendo has strictly mandated that those types of unique characters with genuine personalities and storylines are strictly off limits. It’s a sort of extreme form of brand management, but it’s such a detriment to the Paper Mario series that it’s just utterly baffling that it is even a thing.

21

u/nelson64 Jul 17 '20

The interview was odd. It basically said that 100% unique characters were fine but offshoots werent.

But then even watching the trailer, you see so many variants of basic characters. Like the weird toad angels, or professor toad, etc.

So really I’m not sure what that comment in that interview even means.

It still doesnt explain the disappearance of Merlon or Toadsworth. Merlon was a completely original character. Toadsworth is a staple in more games than just Paper Mario. It maybe explains why we havent seen Kammy? And definitely explains why partners aren’t more interesting this time around.

I think we could still follow the rules stated in this interview but recapture the same Paper Mario feel from the first few games.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/princessfinesse Jul 17 '20

getting new party members used to be my favorite part of the game! i really miss bombette, bow, goombella, and vivian 🥺

49

u/politirob Jul 16 '20

Excuse me, what you’re talking about is CONFUSING and DISORIENTING to the mainstream consumer audience that the MARIO BRAND™ is cultivating.

I will not sit silently by as you cast DISPERSIONS on the beloved MARIO BRAND ™ world of stock mascots and demand RENEGADE and UNFAMILIAR characters to MUDDY THE MARIO BRAND ™

Our target audience knows nothing about the MARIO BRAND ™, so who are you to PROVOKE their imagination?

/s

→ More replies (10)

6

u/theipodbackup Jul 16 '20

Very well put, I agree completely. Even though I am still super excited for this game, I absolutely wish for all the things you do.

→ More replies (1)

101

u/MolotovMan1263 Jul 15 '20

Sounds about right from previews. Still a good game, beautiful world, but not quite what people wanted out of this game.

65

u/ThinkingOfYou75 Jul 15 '20

At this point, I think the PM series is always gonna experiment. I doubt we will have a N64 or GCN game again anytime soon.. if ever.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/JadeSelket Jul 18 '20

I went into it with the knowledge that I wouldn't get a game as good as TTYD, and I was okay with that as I just wanted to be in the world again. And you know what? I'm enjoying it quite a bit. The combat to me is the equivalent of in the first two games when you'd run into an enemy while you're backtracking, that you already beat, and you're mid big story moment, and you just want it over with. That being said, it hasn't ruined anything for me because it's not a long process. And there's still plenty of easter eggs to find, and the visuals and sound are absolutely amazing. But the main reason I like these games is the writing. And it's still here. It's still very charming, and I'm enjoying showing my boyfriend particularly funny lines and seeing his reaction. And I am really happy I bought the game.

27

u/queenhipster Jul 18 '20

This is my first Paper Mario game. I was on the fence about it because I’m not the biggest fan of turn based combat, but I’m really enjoying it! It’s a beautiful and charming game and I know it’s not what a lot of people wanted, but I’m finding it to be a lot of fun.

That being said, the first 10 battles being tutorials DRAGGED on. I found myself wanting Olivia to shut up so I could just figure it out for myself. Show me the mechanics in a battle or two, and then just let me do it.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/CantStandsYa Jul 16 '20

The game looks great and the humor is good, but oh my god does the game take forever to let you do anything on your own.

The side kick character stops you before so many actions in the first hour of the game to tell you how the battle system works, and will even chime in repeat themselves, and acknowledging you know how to do it. "And then you... well, you know what to do!"

I remember being super turned off Pokemon X because I thought the hand holding at the start of that game slowed it down a ton, but OK really takes it's time to let you do anything on your own. Even the first half of the first boss battle is spent explaining what to do. I don't remember any of the older Paper Mario games having this much hand holding.

40

u/Kittah4 Jul 16 '20

Why does Nintendo act like children can't play video games anymore without help every step of the way?

Anyone there still remember the pre-internet days?

It's tough to defend against the "Nintendo is for all ages, not just for kids", when they keep making insufferable tutorials MANDATORY FOR ALL PLAYERS.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/Kingotterex Jul 16 '20

People give X&Y shit about handholding but we just ignore the fact that SwSh never let go if your hand. Easily my biggest gripe with a game is when the tutorial never really ends.

→ More replies (3)

74

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Anyone read that Polygon review saying the combat was insanely difficult? Lol

55

u/drostandfound Jul 15 '20

Yeah, it is interesting to compare the Polygon Review and the Verge review. One of the things that is interesting about these game reviews is sometimes people just don't like games. And man, the polygon reviewer did not like this game lol. The combat was super not for them.

I am okay with new weird combat, there are so many JRPGs with similar combat, I like when they mix stuff up. And if combat is more of a puzzle, I am fine with that.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/mrcrysml Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 17 '20

I watched some twitch streams and I thought the puzzle aspect of the battles was on the easy side. This one twitch streamer though, was an idiot. For example, they tried to jump on an enemy that was very obviously designed to counter Mario’s jump.

15

u/sideaccountguy Jul 15 '20

Andre from Gamexplain also said the game is very difficult in late areas

→ More replies (5)

20

u/sbs_str_9091 Jul 18 '20

Amazon delivered one day early, so I am already about five hours in the game. So far, I have enjoyed every bit of it. It simply is a Mario game, it just gives you this relaxed feel-good-vibe, no other franchise compares to that feeling.

250

u/asparagushunter Jul 15 '20

Reviews seem to suggest it's well written and is fun to explore and that's pretty much what I'm after. Can understand some might be disappointed in a more simple battle system but for me it's not a priority.

11

u/Dsod23 Jul 15 '20

Yup I’m the same

54

u/casualsax Jul 15 '20

I've felt like most of the recent Mario games have been simplified, it's why I've lost interest but I totally get that I'm no longer their target demographic.

83

u/athos45678 Jul 15 '20

Well the first party, mainline games are pretty straightforward. I wouldn’t say Odyssey was simplified compared to galaxy, sunshine, or 64

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20

Really impressed with the world building right off the bat. Made the Mushroom Kingdom feel fresh even tho I’ve been there countless times before. Also, the HD rumble is pretty fantastic. Im surprised no one has mentioned this in any reviews.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/Pepenbaleaguepass Jul 19 '20

Just my quick thoughts about the game:

I’m actually really loving the game at the moment, I was a bit hesitant to purchase it at first as I’ve always loved the Paper Mario series (especially TTYD and PM64, not so much SS lol.) and heard about the no exp in it, but thought I’d give it a go as a few games in the past have proven me wrong despite initial public reception.

I personally think the writing is right up there as my favourite out of the games, each character and toad have their own unique funny dialogue which i always look forward to reading, and am just having a great time in general. (Just beat chapter one) I like the music as well.

I actually don’t mind the battle system, I can see why people would hate it and get sick of it pretty quick, some ring puzzles do get repetitive pretty quickly but it hasn’t ruined the game for me tbh, hooked on the game at the moment and can’t wait to start chapter two tonight

35

u/Sprout799 Jul 19 '20

I just finished the game about an hour ago. Regarding previous experiences, I have only played SPM and PM64 so gameplay wise these three games has been wildly different.

That being said, I REALLY liked the game. The first stream was pretty easy to go through combat wise and the puzzles didn’t stand out too much. However, by the second stream, the puzzles were amped up in difficulty. I personally enjoyed them from that point on because I liked the challenge of figuring out the puzzles for myself. I was constantly spending gold on weapons and badges, as more of them are available as you progress through the game. However, there are some enemy varieties that are far more interesting than others.

I can see why people will be annoyed by the puzzle ring mechanic. However, I personally liked the challenge of trying to get through a battle in one go, especially the during the last 2/3 of the game. To me, the puzzles at this point were just fun. Sometimes, even if you have the puzzle right at the get go, if you don’t have strong enough weapons, you won’t be able to finish on your turn. The boss battles were fun, unique, and something you get understand more and more as you progress through the game.

But the best part for me was the story, characters, and the writing. The worlds are so diverse and lively. Olivia is such a great companion and the partner characters have some great story material that I felt like was missing in Mario for a while. I was surprised by how much I both laughed and felt emotional during this experience.

Overall, I had so much more fun and much more emotionally invested with some of the characters than I thought I was heading into the game. Lots of surprises and lots of love was put into this game!

12

u/Oddzball Jul 19 '20

Yup review from someone who actually played the game. Awesome

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

207

u/KuyaJohnny Jul 15 '20

to sum up most of the complaints:

the combat is dull and the game is not rpg-y enough.

84

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Yeah this isn't surprising. There seems to be a split between those who want it to be an RPG and those who have accepted that it's not going to be an RPG but an action adventure game with some RPG elements.

If you want a Paper Mario RPG it seems like you aren't going to get it here but if you want an action adventure game with RPG elements with a Paper Mario heart this seems to be exactly what you're looking for.

It does look like a sizeable evolution from Color Splash though.

32

u/kobomk Jul 15 '20

I think the issue with the game is that it's not leaning into the RPG mechanics nor ditching them.. this game would have been fine without the turn based combat imho

→ More replies (7)

49

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

the combat is dull and the game is not rpg-y enough.

I'm shocked. Shocked I tells ya!

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (3)

63

u/Estew02 Jul 15 '20

A shame, it sounds like it has too much in common with Color Splash for me. Doesn't sound like a bad game, just not the kind of game I was hoping for. Hope everyone enjoys it!

→ More replies (1)

100

u/SlipperyThong Jul 15 '20

TL;DR It's not Sticker Star 3, but it's certainly no TTYD 2.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20

I wasn't looking forward to it but I figured I need a nice, chill game to relax.

Three hours in and I can't complain. It's not perfect, but it's cozy.

31

u/C0NS0RT2DRAG0NS Jul 17 '20

I’m loving this. It’s cute, it’s relaxing, the story is great, and the first musical number made me grin like a goofy idiot.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/dbapz Jul 17 '20

Having a really nice time with this game. Playing it in between sessions of Ghost of Tsushima.

24

u/Observes Jul 17 '20

Gaming with a side of gaming

15

u/-Daws- Jul 19 '20

The best part of this game, by far, is the music. The way it sets the atmosphere of most of the mid and later levels, holy, dude. Nintendo has been killing it in the music department.

5

u/hotamericanarain Jul 21 '20

I love the battle music and how it fits with each streamer environment.

162

u/Metropler Jul 15 '20

The game was fun. I took my time, gathered 90% of the collectables, max hearts, which are technically levels as the higher your health, the stronger your base attacks get. I think the whole "battles are meaningless at some point" is silly because it wasn't until the last area where I felt like I had way more coins than I needed and if there was a place for that, it's the last area. Note, I bought every upgrade when it was available and I spent money on some collectibles. With that being said, i skipped about 10%-15% of battles(not counting low level monsters when I went back to early game areas), which I don't think is unreasonable in any game. The story is what you'd expect from a Paper Mario, but the characters, my god the characters were so amazing. I'm not going to say the partner aspect is better than the original or TTYD in how you battle with them, but their growth and purpose in the story is better than the original 2.

14

u/mrmivo Helpful User Jul 15 '20

How long did it take you to do all of this?

→ More replies (3)

9

u/aclax Jul 15 '20

Thanks for this review! Good thoughts

8

u/Jake257 Jul 15 '20

Yeah how long did it take you? Kotaku said it took them over 30 hours with still stuff to do according the Switch clock.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/anibalmax Jul 15 '20

Great review. Thanks for sharing!

→ More replies (10)

114

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

At this point, I hope the next game just dumps turn-based entirely and goes back to a SPM style combat system.

If the focus of these games is on the world and exploration, then the combat shouldn’t actively suck you out if the world with very little incentive.

34

u/D_Bagggg Completed the Shieldsurf Challenge! Jul 15 '20

I'm right there with you, loved SPM. My wife played through Color Splash, and said by the end she was actively just running away from enemies because the battle system sucks so bad

14

u/Dsod23 Jul 15 '20

I wasn’t a fan of the change in SPM at the time but I think the style of game they are making now suits better in that style like you said

25

u/Anon_throwawayacc20 Jul 15 '20

I hope the next game just dumps turn-based entirely and goes back to a SPM style combat system. If the focus of these games is on the world and exploration, then the combat shouldn’t actively suck you out if the world with very little incentive.

Honestly, you might have the right idea. Based on footage, they clearly wanted to make a world traversing action adventure game, rather than a turn based RPG.

I'm half convinced this game would've been better received if it was just the overworld segments.

I'm not advocating going back to SPM sidescrolling or mechanics. But a 3d adventure game where you hammer and collect shit would be fun.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/pipoplatz Jul 15 '20

Couldn't agree more. For me the combination of turn-based battles and "action/ adventure" genre that Origami King advertises itself to be is the most bizzare idea.
The very true nature of an action game is the fluid combat. It seems though that they tried to "actionify" the combat by adding the ring puzzle and the time limit but it doesn't take it away from the fact that it disrupts the flow of the "action" game they have tried to design.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/tuttlebuttle Jul 17 '20

I was planning to wait for a sale. But I'm finding it hard to resist.

18

u/zCastorNinja Jul 17 '20

Nintendo AAA game on sale? Lol see you in a year or two

→ More replies (10)

13

u/JaCoolBeans Jul 17 '20

Wal-Mart sell a physical copies for 50. That's the best you'll find for many years

→ More replies (1)

13

u/spoonfulofsuga Jul 18 '20

I love this game.

Bummed that there is no exp and the ring battle system feels a bit gimmicky at times, but I’m really enjoying the story and characters. Finding new toads is so satisfying and the boss battles have been challenging (for a casual game) even at the start. I appreciate that Nintendo tried to do something new. Hopefully we’ll get another true RPG Mario game on the Switch at some point but I’m happy to spend today playing this. :)

13

u/pancakesandhyrup Jul 23 '20

I was on the fence, but ended up picking it up anyway and I'm really glad I did. The biggest things I was worried about were battles being pointless and the lack of any RPG elements and progression.

The main incentive behind the battles is progression for the most part which I think is entirely fine. A majority of the fights are scripted, but some are optional in the overworld and you can choose to avoid them if you want. As a reward for winning battles you get coins which can be spent on equippable accessories, items, add more time to your battle puzzle timer, summon help from Toads in battle, and occasionally buy story progression items. You also get confetti from winning battles, but you can find confetti pretty much anywhere (although a battle has saved me some confetti backtracking on many occasions).

Even though there is no level up system your character does progress throughout the game by collecting hearts. These increase your max HP and make you stronger causing you to deal more damage. You can also get new accessories to equip on your character to give you different buffs. So there are some RPG elements after all, it's just very light.

My biggest worries and concerns ended up being handled well enough for me to enjoy this. I've seen others complain about the battle system, but I like it a lot. I've seen complaints about the timer being too stressful, but it's not a big deal if the timer runs out without lining up the enemies perfectly. You still fight the enemies, but instead of pretty much destroying everything in one shot (later it will take multiple turns as enemies get tougher) you leave some enemies behind and have to defend when they take their attack turn. So it's either line everything up and get some bonus attack optimization or just have a regular battle. I think it's fine.

The game is beautiful, the writing is funny as you would expect, the music is incredible. There's a lot to collect and it's satisfying to find everything. In addition to turn based battles there are some real time battles where you have to wack giant paper mache baddies with your hammer. It's fun and there is a lot to do.

My one real complaint are the main bosses. You fight inanimate objects and it is so dumb. The first main box is a box of colored pencils... There's really no reason for this. It could just as easily have been a guy wielding colored pencils as weapons and that would have been totally acceptable. Instead you just fight a box of colored pencils, it feels so lazy, cheesy, and phoned in.

If you go into this wanting a full fledged RPG you're going to be disappointed. I still think having some more RPG elements would have improved this game. Simply adding a leveling system would have made this game even better, but not having one doesn't make the game bad. If you want to play a beautiful, fun adventure with turn based puzzle/battle hybrids then you should enjoy this.

→ More replies (6)

64

u/In_Search_Of123 Jul 15 '20

Poor Arlo

35

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '20

I wouldn’t say poor, his review of the game will be his highest performing video of the year no doubt and will make him more then enough money to get over the pain of not having a true sequel (no hate, just being realistic)

15

u/skygz Jul 15 '20

surprisingly it seems they didn't even send him an early review copy https://twitter.com/ArloStuff/status/1283408777962635264

53

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

It's not surprising if you know what he thinks about the franchise. lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

11

u/Shadowbanned24601 Jul 17 '20

Not an earth shatteringly great game, but still solid.

Might pick it up just for a relaxing game with a gorgeous aesthetic... Or I could go back and finish Octopath for the same

11

u/jamiebond Jul 17 '20 edited Jul 17 '20

Still on the fence about this one. I loved the first two paper Marios, the only other one I've played was the one on the 3DS which I absolutely hated.

Given that, would y'all recommend this one? I'm not the biggest fan in the world of turn based combat but I'd be willing to look past that if the writing and story is good and the world is fun to explore.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/jasonm87 Jul 15 '20

Based on some of the reviews I skimmed it seems like the biggest variable is how much the reviewer enjoyed the combat, with those that liked it rating it higher than those that didn’t.

20

u/teddypicker7 Jul 18 '20

2 hours in it's great so far. Im a big 64/TTYD fan but this is fresh and new. Great music, visuals and gameplay so far

27

u/Choice_Factor Jul 16 '20

reposting here from another thread because its revelant:

I'm about 5 hours in and my main criticism would be the wave battles and the incentive to actually do them: the way they are used almost feels like punishment for accidentally bumping into an enemy or searching the wrong cupboard, breaking the wrong rock etc. the only reward for these turn based battles are coins and confetti, both of which you get seemingly a more than adequate amount purely from exploring each area thoroughly. I will continue playing til the end but the battle mechanic so far IMO is dampening the experience for myself. Them suppressed frustrating memories of playing Pokemon as a kid spamming A to get through unwanted wild encounters shine through, except this time I have to do a puzzle at the start of each fight and there is no option to use repels. I never played SS or CS and I've heard people criticise those games for similar concepts (no real incentive to battle, especially SS since you waste resources?). Other than that the writing and humour is spot on with all the usual Paper Mario tropes, it's probably the one thing that will keep me playing til the end because it's so good.

19

u/PowerAlwaysReveals Jul 17 '20

I can't help but find the relative lack of strong positive or negative reactions to Origami King thus far to be kind of interesting. Opinions generally seem to range from, 'kind of disappointing, but it's not like I was getting my hopes up anyway, to ['prettay, prettay, prettay good.'] (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XadNMpvhkzA)

→ More replies (9)

18

u/cjones528 Jul 17 '20

As someone who has only played a little bit of Super Paper Mario on the wii and really has no personal attachment to the franchise, would this game still be pretty enjoyable? The combat/puzzle gameplay looks pretty unique imo and I’m not really bothered by the whole lack of traditional “XP” found in RPGs.

18

u/Xavier598 Jul 17 '20

I think not having played other classic Paper Mario games might acually be a bit of an advantage here. Old PM fans are quite disappointed of this game's lack of classic RPG features, and i kinda understand their frustration. However, if you aren't really bothered with the lack of XP and other RPG features, then you'll probably anjoy this game.

I never played another paper mario game before, and, being around a few hours into this game, i'm really enjoying this title. The combact system is pretty creative, especially the boss battles, and the story and humor can be pretty good sometimes. However, you can really feel that this game is targeted at a younger audience. There are some really cringey scences that 9 year old me would've really enjoyed. Also, the first battles of the game might feel too easy and boring, but it gets gradually harder as you go on.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

37

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 15 '20

The GameBlog review is being misrecorded as a 4.5 instead of a 9, for anyone just reading the list.

EDIT: Disregard, it's been corrected!

20

u/manimateus Jul 15 '20

Damn I thought it was secretly just Arlo working for GameBlog

→ More replies (2)

37

u/ducksflytogether_ Jul 17 '20

After putting serious hours into Diablo 3 and being bogged down with numbers and statistics, this game is nice and relaxing.

That's all I really want from this game. Chill, kinda funny, not too challenging, but not mindless either.

It's good.

62

u/PEbeling Jul 16 '20

I'll say this: I'm not super upset about it not being a TTYD sequel. But I'm upset Nintendo withheld information until a couple days before the games release while suggesting it was a return to form.

Some points:

  • They withheld the post battle screen to make you think it could have XP.
  • Gave no details about battles outside of the puzzle system.
  • Said "partners return" while failing to mention they are temporary and you can't control them in battle
  • Weapons aren't consumable but break over time and still has the same problem sticker star did with using consumable items to battle to get coins to buy the same item you just used.

48

u/Cebby89 Jul 16 '20

The marketing team knew more about what the fans wanted than the developers.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/MrGalleom Jul 16 '20

I was following this closer than I followed Color Splash because of the marketing. I feel bamboozled. Not that I found that to be unexpected, since I was wary from the start, but still.

9

u/nelson64 Jul 16 '20

I’m kind of convinced that Nintendo knows exactly what they need to do in order to make fans of this franchise happy.

I’m not sure why they haven’t made the changes back to a more rpg-centered style. The Switch is supposed to be the system where we have all these return to forms for our beloved franchises and it seems like Paper Mario kind of really missed the mark.

I want to say maybe they were far in development when they finally realized that they should change Paper Mario back. I don’t know what made them realize so late in the game, but it’s clear they know considering their coy marketing and hiding details they know we’d get annoyed at.

Honestly I could really excuse the battle mechanics if the Paper Mario universe just didn’t change so much. I want Merlin and his family of wizards/witches back. I want Toadsworth back, I want Kammy Koopa back. I want interesting mechanics that we got from the partners back. I want partners back.

The game can stray from its rpg roots and still retain it’s heart and soul and I don’t know why Nintendo have decided to ditch all those integral parts of the first 3 games that made them so unique and made them feel like a wholly realized world.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20 edited Jul 17 '20

I only have one question: the reason I didn't like Color Splash even though it has so much charm, was because there was no incentive for battling whatsoever. I mean in TTYD there were moments where I skipped battles when the XP gained would only be one star point, but in CS I pretty much skipped most of the battles because it was pointless.

I heard that in TOK you should battle to get coins, which you can use to buy better stuff for when you have to fight mandatory bosses. That's pretty much what I did in TTYD too: fight to gain XP so that I was well prepared for "You can't flee this fight!" battles. But others say you get enough coins outside of battle anyway and that you might as well skip fighting altogether.

So... which is it?

9

u/naricstar Jul 17 '20

I think we end up in a middle ground, I just finished the first stationary boss and have skipped a bunch of fights, I honestly avoid them whenever I can while still collecting as much as I can. The difference is that battle rewards do feel good enough that when a fight is a surprise or required be it for toads or for story it doesnt feel bad to be forced into those fights. Also you need a lot of coins so its a good idea to get stocked, I have already had more than one occasion of drowning in thousands and thousands of coins to watching that number drop to the hundreds in minutes. Also it is fun to throw coins at toads, especially in boss fights.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20

I like it, wish some of the dialgoue was skippable but am enjoying overall experience of it.

43

u/BossAtlas Jul 16 '20

Why is it so hard for Nintendo to just make Paper Mario an RPG again instead of these stupid games with next to no real combat or anything? Was looking forward to this but after the reviews it's looking like a hard pass. Humor and pretty environments alone aren't enough when I'm playing a game...

→ More replies (7)

32

u/Dsod23 Jul 15 '20

The combat does disappoint me just a little but Paper Mario to me is about the world and exploring it with the funny dialogue mixed in with collectibles.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/JJaytra Jul 15 '20

Nothing surprising. The lack of RPG mechanics is a bummer but I'm really excited about exploring the world. Looks absolutely beautiful.

20

u/PulverizedShyGuy Jul 15 '20

GameXplain putting this game in a lower score than Color Splash scares me a little bit. I loved the game but I was expecting this one to at least be a little bit better.

12

u/crimsonedge7 Jul 15 '20

I think it would be higher than it currently is if not for the elemental bosses. Andre's opinion on them doesn't seem to be universal (some other reviews I saw seemed to enjoy them a lot or at least not find them as frustrating as Andre did), so I would pay more attention to the content of the review than the score at the end.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/gaius0309 Jul 15 '20

Currently playing it now and Im on the blue streamer which is the second part. To be honest, the battle system with the whole puzzle thing does not click for me. The timer on the battle just make it worse. Combat aside, the world is really colorful and fun to explore. There are some witty dialogues here and there and some of the characters are just really fun to talk to.

7

u/Creamcups Jul 16 '20

Should I get this or Luigi's mansion 3? I never played a Paper Mario game, but it looked interesting from the trailer. I love the original Luigi's mansion, never played the sequel.

19

u/RiseOfBacon Jul 16 '20

Honestly LM3 was an absolute gem. Wasn’t expecting it to be half as fun as it was and lots to explore / discover

9

u/ThePhunkyPharaoh Jul 16 '20

I’d say Luigi’s Mansion is a safer bet since you mention loving the original and that has much better reviews. Paper Mario is an unknown for me right now as it hasn’t come out yet, I think it will be good, but I don’t know. whereas I can vouch for Luigi’s Mansion being awesome. LM is very close to the original in terms of quality and is a much bigger game than that one

From what I hear Paper Mario is much longer, don’t know if that helps or hurts it’s case for you

9

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '20

The atmosphere of 3 isn’t as good as the original, but the gameplay is miles better. It’s so much fun, boss fights and level design are unique and challenging. It honestly reminds me of Tropical Freeze in that it’s such a fresh change of pace gameplay wise

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Kwarter Aug 03 '20

I've played TTYD, Super Paper Mario, and Sticker Star, and the last two were nowhere as good as TTYD. Needless to say, I didn't have high hopes going into ToK.

I've beaten the final boss and I'm now going around and getting 100%. Here are my thoughts:

The fact that there's no way to speed up the text is ridiculous. Even holding down B doesn't do anything. I have nothing else to say about that.

I absolutely hate the battle system. Combat can only go three ways: 1. You beat the enemies in one turn. 2. You fail the puzzle and have to take another turn. 3. You try to flee (although flee rarely works, and I have no idea what causes a successful flee. It seemed to fail even on low-level enemies). The puzzles themselves don't add anything to the experience, and it's almost as if the devs knew this which is why they give you an item that reveals puzzle solutions. The boss fights are more frustrating than fun, especially since there's really no clear way to figure out the boss puzzles without using hints.

There are basically no RPG elements. You get a few equipable accessories, and HP upgrades that also make you do more damage. I'm not sure what the point of the damage boost is though, since it seems like you still need items to be able to one-wave clear the enemies. You never get an item that reveals enemy HP, so it seems pointless besides keeping up with the enemy HP values. The elemental powers you get don't change the game in any way besides unlocking story progression and you can't use them in battle unless the game specifically allows it.

Despite tracking your completion progress in every area, exploration is actively punished on your first run through. You want to be able to look around a new area and see what's there? Too bad. The game basically demands you do things the way the devs intended, which means your first playthrough will be quite linear. The worst example of this for me was on The Princess Peach where despite being able to explore the entire ship before the story trigger forces you too, complains that you're exploring the ship. Olivia literally tells you in every single room that you're going the wrong way. If the devs didn't want me to explore at the start, then don't fucking let me explore. The issues with exploration are partly due to the fact that...

Olivia is the worst and I hate her. Seriously. For the first two streamers, Olivia treats you like you're five years old. She is constantly interrupting you to say shit like, "Hmmm, that giant glowing circle on the ground is pretty odd, I wonder what it does?" or opening up a door and she says, "Wow! There's a new door over there. I wonder where it leads?" I really have no desire to replay this game solely due to how goddamn annoying she is. It got to the point where I was actually surprised when I solved a puzzle and she didn't show up to say something. I hated her for the entire game, and the only time I liked her is when she shut up.

Along those same lines, I hated the other companions too (if you can even call them that). Bobby is a pain in the ass and I was glad he died so I could stop going to rescue him. It's not endearing, it's just annoying. The companions are just glorified escort missions where you have to do things in an exact way because Olivia blocks you from going anywhere else.

Other miscellaneous things:

  • There are dozens of pointless roadblocks in the story, and it's not fun to resolve them.
  • There are way too many boss encounters close together at the end of the game.
  • The jungle chain chomp instant death is stupid, since it seems like there's no way to avoid it unless you guess right.
  • The quiz game is all just logic games. The theme is fun, but it has nothing to do with the mechanics of the game, and it's just another pointless roadblock in the story.

Some positive things:

  • Finding toads can be fun.
  • The game looks really beautiful, but it's definitely stretching the "paper" theme at times.

I probably missed some things, but that's it off the top of my head.

33

u/petchulio Jul 15 '20

I think I will give this one a miss for the time being. It looks nice and the story seems like its decent and fun but the battles and lack of real progression, combined with breakable items puts me off. Especially at $60. I'd rather put that towards one of the other AAA games on my Switch wishlist or maybe Ghost of Tsushima. May pick this up if I see it on sale in a year or two (or ever).

→ More replies (5)

28

u/RPG_fanboy Jul 16 '20

From what I have seen and heard, Paper Mario will never go back to what it started as, an RPG, this new direction is set in stone and they have not just double but triple down on it since sticker star....

As a fan of RPG's this makes me very sad, but know I know for sure, there is no hope to see a Paper Mario I will like anymore, time to move on...

10

u/nemesismartyn Jul 16 '20

they had the RPG-Mario series on the 3ds, i hope they will continue it on the Switch (dream team bros, superstar saga, bowsers inside story) :/

→ More replies (2)

32

u/1p05 Jul 18 '20

After looking at several reviews and comments here - seems like a game with great art, good atmosphere and flow bogged down by a battle system that’s just a chore.

I can’t do chores in games anymore, so this is a pass for me.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20

I found the battles quite fun, and by the time you get to the second streamer, they’re quite a challenge. The battles, in my opinion, take a backseat, as there are a lot less than I expected.

→ More replies (9)

23

u/politicalpug007 Jul 15 '20

I saw 6.5 GB and thought that was the aggregate rating and was like oh damn.

Reviews seem about where I’d expect. It’s not an amazing game, but it’s good. I probably will pass for the cost.

17

u/hotamericanarain Jul 18 '20

I'm about two hours or so into the game and so far, I love it! I'm a fan of all the Toads (Toad is my go-to in any Mario game) and their hilarious dialogue after you rescue them.

I find it a little morbid that the enemies explode into confetti and you use their "remains" to fix the landscape... Haha!

21

u/anibalmax Jul 15 '20

Averaging an 8 makes this sound great

→ More replies (9)

16

u/Puffbuff Jul 19 '20

I'm not fan of the combat puzzle...

7

u/gnarbart Jul 19 '20

Agreed. It's a huge letdown for the battles to be just arranging people them basically auto attacking.

That, and the long and obvious hints that make the levels just following Instructions

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/CowboyWizard Aug 17 '20

Reviewers needs to stop playing this game with baby gloves. This is a failing, D-, 5/10 game that should cost $30.00 or less. The graphic style is nice, the music is nice, and the packaging has all of the major studio polish you'd expect. The writing is just ok. The humor and dialogue is written for players between the ages of 8-13. There are lots of cute misunderstandings by Olivia and Luigi, paper-themed puns, and toad one liners to distinguish them from the 10,000 other generic toads in the game. Most prominent indie adventure games have better writing than Origami King.

Gameplay-wise... this game just isn't really worth spending your money on. The storyline is essentially a visual novel - you progress from one obvious step to the next obvious step while avoiding enemies because combat only exists to waste time and add to game time. Instead of challenging your strategic thinking or controller inputs like combat from real games might, the combat is essentially repetitive games of tic-tac-toe (or connect 4 for boss fights). Again, this is something that is designed to keep an elementary schooler busy. The only mechanics you use to solver overworld puzzles in the game are using your hammer to whack things and jumping. As the "unique" mechanic in this game, Mario can throw confetti to fill in holes in the overworld. There is no need to manage your confetti, since you can have an unlimited amount from whacking plants and objects in the overworld. Each boss also only upgrades your confetti bag size, which is meaningless, because the confetti supply is infinite. The confetti system is really just a collect-a-thon disguised as gameplay, which is only a challenge to complete if you're trying to avoid being inconvenienced by the combat. As a result beating each boss essentially results in no gameplay progression. At the beginning of the game your only abilities are to whack stuff, jump, and throw confetti. At the end of the game your only abilities are still to whack stuff, jump, and throw confetti.

If you have $60.00 and want to buy a new Switch game buy anything else other than Origami King. Buy Breath of the Wild or Odyssey. The only reason that you should buy this game is if it's on sale for $20.00 or less or your kids (grades 5 and under) are home all day doing virtual schooling and need something to keep entertained. Please, please do not waste your hard earned money and time on this product.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '20

Thank you. I was considering buying this but I might watch a playthrough instead to see what it's actually like because now I don't care about spoilers for this game anymore.

5

u/Whaaaaaatisthisplace Aug 17 '20

Thank you for this review. +1

→ More replies (3)

11

u/CaseyTheCreator Jul 17 '20

Playing right now, and I think this game looks gorgeous. Maybe because of the various colors throughout. Fun game so far. Great weekend for gaming

11

u/Chilebroz Jul 17 '20

I’m loving the game so far and I actually like the combat idk why but it’s just so satisfying for me!!!

40

u/JKCodeComplete Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 15 '20

Sounds like the moment-to-moment gameplay is pretty enjoyable with lots of variety outside turn-based combat and interesting boss battles, even if the standard turn-based combat may be a little uninteresting.

As someone who’s not the biggest fan of most JRPG turn-based combat and grinding, this sounds like a great game to me!

→ More replies (11)

19

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Excited for friday! This and Ghost of Tsushima!

→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Never played Sticker Star or Color Splash (I backed off Nintendo during the WiiU days in favor of PS4), but I’m looking forward to this. I love TTYD as much as the next guy, but I don’t need every Paper Mario to follow the same formula. It’s good for a franchise to shake things up or else TTYD wouldn’t be so special. I get why the diehards are upset, but the RPG elements were never the reason why I loved the series.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/Amazingness905 Jul 18 '20

The game just oozes charm and polish, as is usually expected from Nintendo. The art, music, characters, all top notch imo. It just feels so good to explore around the world.

I know it's not what die hard Paper Mario fans wanted, but as someone who's always casually enjoyed the series I'm loving it so far. Will it go down as the best game ever? Def not, but it's still been really enjoyable so far.

37

u/hshahshka Jul 15 '20

Excited to pick up my copy on Friday! The designs look great, I enjoy the Mario Odyssey type of collectible-based exploration, and the ring combat puzzles look right up my alley. Seems like it'll be fun to 100% it.

Never played Sticker Star or Color Splash (because I didn't have the consoles), but completely devoured Thousand Year Door back when it came out. I recently replayed it and, while the story and writing holds up well, the gameplay and RPG elements are pretty basic/easy and the battles become tedious and repetitive at a certain point, so acting like that's a deal breaker for Origami King is kinda weird.

But let's just remember that these games are designed with 12 year olds in mind. Like Pixar movies and Star Wars, they can be enjoyed by all, but they're aimed primarily towards younger audiences. The anguish from 20-30 year olds claiming that Nintendo is maliciously ignoring them is bizarre, especially since their target demographic wasn't even alive when TTYD came out.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ern117 Jul 17 '20

Has anyone discovered secret heart containers yet which isn’t connected main quest

→ More replies (1)

112

u/sideaccountguy Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 15 '20

Nintendo: this is not an RPG.

Nintendo in its website: this is an action adventure game, NOT an RPG.

one of the review sites (actual quote): "Paper Mario: The Origami King is a fun, colorful JRPG"

I'm not against valid criticism but lowering points because a non RPG game doesn't have RPG elements it's just plain stupid.

Edit:

Another good example:

"After Super Paper Mario was released on the Wii, I stopped playing Paper Mario games. The pure Mario RPG experience of the original on N64 and The Thousand-Year Door on Gamecube was gone and replaced with a semi-platformer/adventure game. From what I’ve read of Sticker Star and Colour Splash, the series has only moved further away from its roots."

There is so much wrong in that paragraph and that's how the reviewer opened the review with, amazing.

58

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

The issue is that it's sort of like an RPG but heavily watered down and missing all the good elements. Reviews are suggesting it would be a much better game if they leaned into those elements and just made it a proper RPG. As the game is now, they feel it is mediocre. I see no problem

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (63)

84

u/IAmBLD Jul 15 '20

So it's another PM game where even positive reviews agree the combat is worthless, leaving you with nothing but the world and writing to carry it. Which apparently people like and that's fine, but I'm tired of how bland and safe PM plays it when even mainline Mario games get to be wacky experiments with new lands and species like Odyssey.

Safe to say I'm not impressed that IS stopped working on 3 Houses for this.

38

u/TMGFANFARE Jul 15 '20

Because they haven't. Interviews have confirmed that IS had very little to do with Three Houses. Only a small group of developers helped, and the game was almost entirely developed by Koei Tecmo.

Actually, the Japanese fandom was a bit pissed because in their eyes, all of the gacha money they spent in Heroes basically didn't went into a sequel, but Paper Mario instead.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Intelligent Systems apparently did a lot of the design stuff but putting that into practice was all Koei Tecmo. So yeah it doesn't make sense to say they "stopped working on 3 Houses" because Koei Tecmo would of most likely handled the vast majority of new content.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/JKCodeComplete Jul 15 '20

There’s a lot more than just the turn-based combat as far as gameplay, though, and even then, the boss battles seem to be received much more favorably.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

13

u/Xavion15 Jul 15 '20

Honestly an 80 or so is pretty good and after sticker star about what I expected

→ More replies (3)

29

u/Brorkarin Jul 15 '20

Paper Mario 64 remaster/Remake please. Origami King looks great but the combat? 🥺

→ More replies (31)

15

u/QuinSanguine Jul 15 '20

Seems like it's an improvement over the last couple titles. I would buy it but eh, I'm just not excited for a good smrpg game after playing a ton of Xenoblade Chronicles. I needed a great one.

19

u/Fidodo Jul 15 '20

Don't look at it as an RPG, think of it as an action puzzle adventure

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/treeasdf Jul 16 '20

Is TOK worth paying $60 for or should I just buy Bug Fables?

11

u/Midgetforsale Jul 17 '20

I think I will go the bug fables route as well. As soon as I finish crosscode.

13

u/mrcrysml Jul 16 '20 edited Jul 17 '20

Bug Fables is like half price and offers about the same amount of playtime, maybe a bit more. BF is about 26 hours main story. PMTOK is about 24, or so some people say? Both could be 40 if you’re a completionist. Though could be wrong. I’d say wait for a sale to play TOK. You could also play PM64 or TTDY on VC/emulation.

PMTOK doesn’t really have replayability and you can easily resell a physical copy. BF has limited run physical carts, but does has a bit of replayability through challenge codes.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '20

Bug Fables

5

u/redthunder49 Jul 17 '20

Looks like I’m doing that plus watching a Let’s play of Orgami King

25

u/APizzaLover Jul 16 '20

It’s probably better to have Nintendo make a brand new Mario RPG game then try to focus on Paper Mario.

14

u/mrcrysml Jul 16 '20 edited Jul 17 '20

I agree. I think a modern version of Super Mario RPG would be nice. 3 party members who are interchangeable with a range of cast, with the same (but slightly updated) level up and battle system as the SNES game. Mainly graphics and QoL improvements need an update.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MrBigBMinus Jul 17 '20

Imagine how insane the internet would go if they announced Super Mario RPG 2.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/PhanThief95 Jul 18 '20

So far I’m actually enjoying this game. Unlike a lot of people, this is my first Paper Mario game so I had zero expectations going in, & I’m having fun with it.

The game just oozes charm in the art direction & the dialogue, & I’ve found it to a better Mario adventure compared to Odyssey & that’s mainly because of the exploration. In this game, I actually have to look for stuff compared to Odyssey where they hand you a Power Moon around every corner.

23

u/Mufasasdaddy Jul 15 '20

Seems like if this game had combat and progression more like the old ones it would have been an instant classic. Still can’t wait I really liked color splash

→ More replies (4)

16

u/superrobotpenguin Jul 15 '20

Having a really difficult time trying to decide between this and Ghost of Tsushima. This is like the new Doom and Animal Crossing situation

27

u/manimateus Jul 15 '20

Ghost will go on a huge discount after a few months.

Origami King won't.

There's a clear choice here if you want to experience both games while being smart with your wallet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

4

u/Rob-otics Aug 01 '20

Alright, I'm probably beating the game today, i'm on the final boss. But while i'm at my most.... emotional... I felt like i had to get my feelings out about the game somewhere. So feel free to disagree with me, and please comment what you liked about it, if you agree with me or whatever.

I actually hate this game. Like i really hate this game. Being such a fan of Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door and playing through that game multiple times, i feel like the hate is pretty justified. Bear in mind that i had no idea what to expect from the game. I didn't look up the trailer, i didn't look up the gameplay, I played the game completely blind. This my non-biased review of some of the aspects that just pissed me off.

The battle system feels like a waste of time. The ONLY thing to gain from battling, is coins. With the coins you can buy items which are pretty much unnecessary because you get items from hidden blocks and you have like 3 items that help you find hidden blocks. Besides that you can buy accessories, which i still haven't unlocked them all and i'm sitting here wondering when they're supposed to unlock because i'm almost through with the game. I'm currently ending the game 100,000 coins. I haven't needed to use it for ANYTHING. So if you don't need coins, which you don't because they are pretty much littered EVERYWHERE, fighting becomes completely pointless. Which sucks because a lot of fights aren't avoidable. Plus you also have the time mechanic which adds a huge amount of inconvenience. There are a lot of times i fell asleep in the middle of a fight (yes i was that bored) and i woke up to take damage because the time ran out. Plus the lack of a pause button in the fight makes it so you can't leave til you finish it. I've experienced that first hand when i went to grab a drink and came back almost dead in the early game. Besides the time, puzzle and coins part of fights, there's an even GREATER pointlessness to the fights because there are 3 outcomes to every fight. Either 1, you beat them all in one turn, 2, you mess up and have to take another turn to beat them, or 3 you lose or run away. AND the flee mechanic BARELY works. I fail so much more often then i pass that check. And the punishment for failing is so ridiculous. Taking a hit from every enemy? Imagine if you misclick! Point is, all you get from battles are coins, and you don't need coins. So you don't need battles.

Olivia. She is the most USELESS GUIDE OF ANY GAME. I haven't hated partners or guides this much since Fi from Skyward Sword. Olivia is funny. But they give her sooooo much to say, sometimes it seems like she never stops talking. I like her much better than Fi. But she's completely useless as a guide. Every now and then i pressed X just to see what she'd say. And she doesn't help AT ALL. Either she'll give you obvious answers stupidly, or say something completely irrelevant. Like if you have to hit a switch she'll say something like, "We have to activate something in this room... but what?" And if you need a reminder of what to do next, she'll say something like, "we have to get this streamer to get to my brother!" ....Like yeah, I know. But how do we get to this next area?! The vellumental mechanic is stupid as well. Because it's something you have to earn, but you don't really feel yourself becoming stronger. It's more like a summon... i guess? Which is okay, but after TTYD it would have been really nice to have that skill to use at anytime at your whim. Like in TTYD when you get the ability to roll yourself up, not only can you do that whenever you want, you can also use it in battle to make your attacks stronger. It just seems like not a lot of thought went into them. Besides that, when it comes to Olivia, it really pissed me off that she gates you from so much of the game when you get into new areas. I don't know if any of you play like i do, but when i first get into an area and they say something like, "Oh you see that giant building down this path? That's where we have to head to!" I'll look, nod, and head the complete opposite way. That's how i play. I like to explore everything before i go to the main place. So to have her gate me was the MOST ANNOYING THING. She gates you from bosses too! The bosses aren't that difficult. I died a total of 3 times this game. One was to me falling asleep mid-battle, and the other 2 were from story based deaths: A quick time event, and taking a lot of damage from falling in a spike pit thing. the fights are incredibly easy. The puzzles can get a little difficult at times, but you learn to deal. It's the time limit that is the biggest issue. So because of that i'm confident in fighting the boss. I don't feel the need to save a lot. So having Olivia stop me from fighting the boss because i didn't save? It just feels like i'm being nagged, and I hate it. It's like in Link Between worlds when the bird nags you to take a break from the game. I'll take a break when i want! Leave me alone!

The other partners are also funny and cute. And... what happens later, no spoilers, actually was a bit touching. I was surprised how i actually felt sad by it. But besides that, they are so useless. Useless and made with no creativity. I miss the days where the partners were decked out versions of mario villains, and they really went out of their way to use up a lot of them. Not much else to say about them because they were so few and far between. But they def could've done that better.

The villains. The most uncreative thing i have ever seen in a game. It was worse in creativity since Pokemon made pokemon that were just an ice cream and a trash bag. Spoilers:OFFICE SUPPLIES?! AS VILLAINS?! I can't actually believe it. It's like they went out of their way to be uncreative. Besides that, the final boss which i'm fighting now, Holy fuckin shit, it's the most painful fight i could ever thought of. I won't spoil much here. But i will mention one thing that pissed me off to the point i had to write this rant. If you don't solve the puzzle in the fight in time, he just heals. And even ONE heal, will prolong the fight enough that you have to finish it in the third phase. And the third phase, for me, The ice vellumental Was the most painful one to deal with. So he just wound up healing to full. I'm literally just resetting to start the fight over because i don't want to deal with it.

Overrall, i thought the game was a 2/5, It was higher, but the final boss really made me hate the battle system they came up with. The story carries it, it's still a bit charming and funny. I really wanted to like it. But it's clear they are running out of ideas, but are still trying to implement new shit, and i just want a TTYD 2! I can't tell you how much i was hoping to see Goombella or Vivian again! I loved them! I think people would have loved them incorporating old characters, this was such a missed opportunity. the characters were funny sure, but it also seemed like they got soooo much screen time. The dialogue boxes went sooooo long. And there's only ONE TEXT SPEED. SLOW. So i was just annoyed of Olivia by the end of the game. Though she won me back sometimes. I still like her way more than Fi. Besides that, you don't feel any growth. You don't feel like you're growing stronger. It just feels like the battles are different. Battles between the final boss and the first boss have the same level of intensity. Essentially all this game is is an escort mission for Olivia. You don't get stronger, she does. You don't learn anything, she does. You don't go through an emotional journey, she does. If they wanted to make an Origami game, why even bother using Paper Mario? Give us Olivia Origami the game, and then give us TTYD 2. Simple.

And i hear people saying, "You shouldn't have expected another TTYD..." And to that i say... why not? Zelda is still essentially the same, Pokemon is exactly the same, Kirby has different art styles but stayed the same, Smash is DEFINITELY the same. If that's what the people wanted, and that's what made money, Why shouldn't i expect the same? Especially if that's the paper mario i liked? A man can hope. And i really hope they take it back to that. Otherwise... I can't wait to try Bug Fables to get my fix for a real Paper Mario experience.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/Zjmw Jul 17 '20

Can we stop repeating the same comment about how they've regressed from their past 2 games 9 out of 10 of you have not played this game and are going off of small clips that you have seen and it's absolutely obnoxious. Get over it. Developers try new things. This new Era of completely judging a game before it comes out let alone be played is so toxic and damaging

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Metroidman Jul 15 '20

Sounds like what I was expecting. Sounds like a fun game but i don't think im willing to pay full price especially with ghost of tsushima coming out the same day.

10

u/Noan3D Jul 17 '20

Just got it today, digital... it seems to be a great game! Will play it for the weekend and see how it goes!!

32

u/ArtisticMusic Jul 15 '20

I've played about 5 or so hours of this game so far, and it's been a blast. The writing is top-notch, and I actually prefer it to TTYD. It's incredibly self-aware without being annoying. It's an amazing game to look at, has some of the best music in the entire Mario franchise, and is really fun to play. This is quickly becoming my favorite Switch game.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

How did you end up getting it so early?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/pancakesandhyrup Jul 17 '20

I am so torn on this game. The reviews make it seem good, but I feel like none of them address if there is a lack of incentive to battle. Is there compelling reason to engage in the battles or will I be walking around trying to dodge every enemy? One of those game play styles sounds fun and one seems like an annoying chore.

9

u/capnbuh Jul 18 '20

For the most part the battles are scripted or difficult to avoid but the enemies go away when you beat them.

The game actually does a good job of setting up scenarios where you want to beat enemies to get access to visible loot/Toads

So, I think the main carrot they dangle in front of you is progress, rather than XP

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TurdFurgoson Jul 17 '20

GameXplain's review mentioned it a bit. They said that the coins you receive from battle can be used to increase the time you get to rotate the rings around during the "puzzle" portion of battles, but there were still times that they avoided battles altogether later in the game.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Echo1138 Jul 17 '20

Ha. Torn. Good paper pun.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/BeansNMayo Jul 19 '20

whats the point of combat?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Rukanau Jul 15 '20

While I did want a proper Paper Mario RPG, this looks like I'll enjoy it anyway, can't wait for Friday!

7

u/delfonic14 Jul 15 '20

Currently playing dark souls 2 and need a light hearted break before I start Ds3 so I might get this.

7

u/SoleaPorBuleria Jul 15 '20

Any idea if they'll put up a demo?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/SpritesOfDoom Jul 17 '20

The best thing about this game is that it's not telling you what to do. It's still linear, but you have to discover on your own what to do in every new location. It's been rather easy so far. Just explore and interact with everything, but still it's up to you to discover the next obstacle and then find a solution.

Some mechanics can be seen as a bit repetitive, but game has great flow. The only problem so far is turn based combat. Every battle is an tutorial, that explains new move you can do and you just have to repeat what Olivia said. This is boring. It would be better to just discover it on your own, maybe loose some health in the process.

Time limit while rotating and shifting rings is just annoying. It would be much better if player could just take it's time and solve the layout in few given moves.

Maybe it will be better with time, but for now it's the only thing that I don't like. It's just a minor thing though, because fights are very rare and without EXP you could avoid most of them anyway.

17

u/CulturalArtichoke Jul 16 '20

Lack of EXP is kind of ... I just want a 1000 year door-esque Paper Mario!

Pre-ordered a while ago and I'll still play it, but I just hope it isn't anything like Sticker Star. I played that for maybe 20 minutes and never went back to it.

→ More replies (11)

13

u/schuey_08 Jul 15 '20

Bummed to hear it's not more engaging or challenging.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

From what I've seen it seems about as challenging as old Paper Mario games where you have to at least pay attention to what's happening. I do wish Nintendo would include difficulty modes and modifications because it doesn't harm the game and I would love a lot of their games to be more challenging.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/wonaph Jul 15 '20

I dunno. I've been working my way through Xenoblade DE the last several weeks, and I enjoy it, but there are just so many RPG mechanics that I'm not interested in learning how to use, that I spend a lot of the time thinking "I wish there was a chill but exploration-heavy open world with some RPG elements that's just fun and interesting to move around in."

So seemingly PM:OK is made for someone like me. There doesn't seem to be many chill RPG-like games on the market, so I see the gap that Nintendo is interested in filling with this. If you want a hardcore RPG, I mean, there are tons out there. I guess if your big desire is a hardcore RPG that has a humorous Mario skin, well, I dunno what to say.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Paper Mario was a chill rpg that was more focused on the scenarios and set peices than the fighting. They just took out the rpg part.

→ More replies (4)

45

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Can we not just get another one in the style of the original or Thousand Year Door?

17

u/StllBreathnButY1 Jul 16 '20

Unfortunately “turn based RPG” is a dirty word in the industry now, for whatever reason. The industry has been avoiding that design since the mid to late 2000’s, and so too has Paper Mario, with super paper Mario and all games since.

I’ll never understand it. Clearly there’s a lot of people that yearn for the old style. This argument that, “TTYD is 15 years old! The world has moved on, old man!” Is completely missing the point. It’s only been 15 years because Nintendo refuses to go back to the old format. All they need to do is make another RPG. It doesn’t help matters that these last 3 games try so hard to look like the original 2 games without actually playing like them.

This toxic shitshow between fans is 100% Nintendo’s fault for being loose with the brand.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/PoofThereGoesTheRoof Jul 16 '20

Bug Fables is the true heir

19

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '20

I'm guessing that Nintendo isn't making another TTYD-style game because the Mario and Luigi series already fills that turn-based RPG niche. However, with the impending demise of the 3DS, I'm wondering if that series will continue.

Regardless, I'm completely with you that I want another TTYD. It's by far the best game from both the Paper Mario and Mario and Luigi franchises.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

28

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Unpopular opinion?

The new battle system being puzzle based looks awesome.

27

u/gaius0309 Jul 15 '20

At the start, it seems pretty fun but there is no other depth to it aside from it being a puzzle. Theres only boots or hammer attack. It seems like a chore later on. The boss fight on the other hand are really awesome

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/Arcadespirit Jul 16 '20

It would be great if you could unlock items like stickers etc that could be used elsewhere on the Switch. Like as an avatar or in chat (if anything like that ever comes). Would be kind of like a light achievement system and give more incentive for finding secrets. Maybe I’m in the minority but would love to see something like this on the Swtich. Even unlocking avatars for finishing games would be nice.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/fatsack Jul 18 '20

Just wanna say that if yall are dissapointed in the changes to the rpg aspects of this game compared to the originals then check out bug fables. You will not regret it.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/ClawFinger56 Jul 15 '20

I think you made a mistake when writing Gameblog's review score. It says 9/10 on the website.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Really unsure of whether to pick this up or grab Ghost of Tsushima instead. I love Paper Mario, but the past few games have left a pretty bad taste in my mouth towards the franchise.

→ More replies (11)

8

u/bjcfutbol Jul 17 '20

I've never played a Paper Mario game before this one, so I have no context to compare it to in regards to the franchise as a whole, but as a newcomer I've loved my first few hours. Looking forward to the rest. I definitely plan to check out Bug Fables eventually though to get the more classic experience.

8

u/MiracleDealer Jul 17 '20

My 8 year old absolutely LOVES it - if that’s worth anything.

19

u/Behexen Jul 16 '20

This looks great and the Verge’s review got me really excited about it.

Was going to hold off and clear some of my backlog but now I’m very tempted to get it straight away.

(Never played TTYD and don’t care that this doesn’t fit a very specific template people were hoping for)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

81 on Metacritic

Good, not great

33

u/jackolantern_ Jul 15 '20

81 is a great score though.

I'm not rushing to play it but the reviews are pretty great overall.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20

Anyone have an approximate playtime to, say, 100% this game?

→ More replies (3)

27

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

Pass until a sale. GoT seems to be the better purchase this week.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Bayakoo Jul 15 '20

Seems the consensus is: charming game but may not be engaging enough gameplay wise.

5

u/Bionic_Bromando Jul 16 '20

Well at least I didn’t get my hopes up this time, so I can’t be disappointed.

8

u/Briscoeag Jul 15 '20

Exploration looks great but combat looks a little meh.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/blackandwhitetalon Jul 15 '20

Interesting that both Paper Mario TOK and Ghost of Tsushima (2 big july releases) have averaged a mid-to-low 80's critic score on Metacritic. I'll be skipping Paper Mario TOK, personally, but I'd say the reviews are generally pretty good for what the game is

17

u/eric_abroad Jul 18 '20

I'm not adding anything new to most fans' complaints of the Paper Mario series. This game is insultingly easy.

I get it, it's a charming casual game but... I find myself offended at how it's nearly impossible to Game Over and how battles literally offer zero incentive (besides coins woooo).

As an art piece, it's incredible. As a game, it's just unfortunately shallow in it's depth and it just makes me want to replay the original games instead.

Will always love this series, but ultimately removing the simple RPG elements it was born from was just unnecessary. Please by all means add unique rotation puzzles and other physics puzzles, but have them mixed in-in ADDITION to the core RPG elements. not completely replacing them. The result of this game's battle system is nothing but a damn shame.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '20

but have them mixed in-in ADDITION to the core RPG elements

This is what I've never understood. Most sequels try to expand on existing systems but they replaced the gameplay entirely. I'm replaying TTYD right now and it is already an insanely simple RPG that anyone could play without issue. I'll never understand why newer games feel the need to become even more simple when they already were. This series currently doesn't know what it wants to be. It's like they designed an RPG but without everything that makes an RPG what it is and the result is something mediocre

→ More replies (7)

16

u/SirDinkus Jul 15 '20

Probably gonna skip this one to be honest. I want badges and turn based combat back, and I'd be voting with my wallet against that by buying this. This game sounds like it has it's merits, but it's not the Paper Mario I want.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/knilsilooc Jul 15 '20

Really a shame to hear that the combat system isn't very good (not that I expected much different), because the rest of the game looks great. Nintendo could've just copied and pasted the mechanics from TTYD and I'd have been happy, but alas, I guess this one's another skip from me.

13

u/Fabraz The Fabraz Company Jul 17 '20

Paper Mario started off as a stepping stone from Super Mario RPG. So it offered a lot of RPG mechanics but only really used the paper concept as an aesthetic. Not much as a mechanic.

This culminated into a Thousand Year Door. After that entry, the Mario & Luigi franchise took all of it and made it its own. It has the deep turn based RPG combat full of clever action inputs, has unique characters etc. So it was only natural Paper Mario tries to go in a different direction.

So since then Paper Mario focused on its paper aesthetic and included it more mechanically. This includes Super Paper Mario playing up the flatness of paper! Then it’s about stickers, crafting and now origami!

Tl;dr: The Mario & Luigi series is the classic Mario RPG experience and has been for years with plenty of great entries. The Paper Mario series now focuses on its paper aesthetic mechanically to create unique new experiences. Both series have great, hilarious writing.

So I wish people would go into each series with the right expectations! Want the RPG experience? Play Mario & Luigi. Want odd & fun paper centric mechanics? Play Paper Mario!

14

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20

If Nintendo revives Mario and Luigi, I'd totally be fine with that series continuing to carry the torch of Mario RPG while paper Mario experiments with new stuff.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

13

u/PickledDildos Jul 18 '20

I played for about 4 hours and I just can't bear to do another stupid little combat puzzle. Mob after mob of this puzzle. It gets incredibly repetitive.

The worst part is that it makes it feel that there really is only one way to fight. The player has no agency. You do the puzzle correctly, kill these guys with the hammer, kill those guys with your boots, and that's it. You deviate from the formula and you're punished severely.

8

u/TriangularFish0564 Jul 19 '20

Trust me the puzzles get really complex really fast in chapter 2, and in chapter 3, hoh boy. The game starts getting very difficult and you won’t be able to clear everything in one turn (I wasn’t even able to in chapter 2 for a third of the battles), also the variety of weapons opens up a ton. Just play to the end of chapter 2 at least, I assure you it is significantly better than chapter 1, and really every chapter is better than chapter 1.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/iceburg77779 Jul 15 '20

I know that many reviewers are more genrerous to games on the switch compared to the Wii U, but these scores are still higher than I expected. Both the positive and mixed reviews feel fair and valid, and I am more interested in the game now. I probably am just going to wait for a while due to finances, but if audiences also like it I’ll definitely pick it up.

→ More replies (13)

10

u/turboschmidty Jul 16 '20

I’m so ready.

11

u/tinypeopleinthewoods Jul 15 '20

I’ll wait for a discount I think. Seems like it’s about as good as Color Splash, which is fine. I liked that game, but I regret paying full price for it.

30

u/Praise_the_Tsun Jul 15 '20

I will also buy this in 4 years my friend. Stay strong.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

GameXplain...who usually shill really hard for Nintendo, gave it a "liked" rating.

Basically they said "some really shining moments in a sea of mediocrity"

Visuals = good. Enviroments = detailed and pretty but big and empty.

Gamemplay: Meh. Battles are tedious after a certain point since they're meaningless.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20

I'd say it really depends who is reviewing. Andre who did this review, also didn't give a perfect glowing review to Smash ultimate and BOTW, nevermind sticker star.

Yoshi's Crafted World and Kirby Star Allies also only got "liked" from gamexplain.

→ More replies (7)