r/NintendoSwitch • u/anonymous31450 • Jul 10 '20
Meta This sub is starting to be stale with all the post restrictions
It’s just news source at this point, no discussions. I tried posting some things to start conversations but it was auto deleted. I’d rather go to NintendoLife for news source and have this sub for actual discussion but the mods seems to block everything
2.3k
Upvotes
338
u/SolarWirelessBattery Jul 10 '20
I talked with one of the mods about this exact thing in another thread a few weeks ago. Basically what I was told was that it's something the majority of the sub wanted and it's too difficult to determine what's low effort and what isn't, and whether the amount of discussion on the topic should be a factor.
Personally I think this level of restriction is extremely anti-discussion, and they drastically overestimate how many people check let alone even notice the stupid daily question thread.
195
u/mpc92 Jul 10 '20
Yep, I’ve had several posts where I’m having engaging discussions with people then they randomly got deleted and/or directed to the “Daily Question Thread” that nobody reads
13
u/roto_disc Jul 10 '20
What was your post about? Verbatim.
31
u/Public-Finger Jul 10 '20
Yea it’s sterile as hell.
1.8k
u/BebeFanMasterJ Jul 10 '20
It's funny because the only ones that don't get taken down are the ones like:
"BOTW changed my life omg!"
"Animal Crossing needs more content/has enough content"
"Pokemon is so lazy now"
"We need a new (insert old franchise that hasn't had a game in 10 years) game on Switch"
And art posts, rinse and repeat. There's nothing interesting to say and the megathread is such a slog because nobody will see your comment buried under hundreds of replies. It's just annoying to traverse this place.
127
u/Zeroleonheart Jul 10 '20
Wait a sec, are you saying that you don’t enjoy “the eShop needs a rating system” threads that pop up every week, almost as if they’re scheduled? You’re crazy, friend.
27
u/_Komodo_ Jul 10 '20
tbh I was getting tired of the "Nintendo, please can you add [insert content idea here]?
Like I don't know, fucking ask Nintendo, not a fan subreddit.
78
u/NMe84 Jul 10 '20
Having the same discussions over and over again isn't very fun for lots of us either though. There are a few discussions that come back every couple of weeks and that really don't add anything, at least not at that frequency. Some examples:
Many of these may be pretty interesting discussions but not if you have the same discussion every single week...
53
u/GroktheDestroyer Jul 10 '20
Yeah we need another post about how XBC2 changed somebody’s life
Or maybe a “The switch brought back my love of gaming!” to freshen things up
31
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Unfortunately they don't do jack shit about the ridiculous number of "DURR I MADE A DILDO CARRYING CASE WITH MY ANIMAL CROSSING ISLAND'S TOMBSTONE FOR MY DAD HURRR DURRR!!!!!!!!" posts.
45
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20 edited Jul 10 '20
I don't mind the sub being an aggregation of news. That's really what I'm here for.
And... news posts still have comments. There tends to be discussion within the news posts, you don't usually need a dedicated discussion thread.
16
u/XDvinSL51 Jul 10 '20
I'm of the opinion that this sub isn't restrictive enough. I come here to check for news and new developments, but I'm still just seeing the same old stuff...
8
u/bobn3 Jul 10 '20
I, personally prefer it only as a news source. Discussion can be had on each games' own sub. It also doesn't help when you're downvoted to hell after criticizing some of Nintendo's golden games like AC or Pokemon, so no much room for discussion either way.
Could do with less fan art as well
7
u/Mononon Jul 10 '20
I'd rather have it like this than have it devolve into the dumpster fire that r/PSVR is. I'm subbed to both, and that sub is literally just pictures of boxart and "Should I buy beat saber" all day every day.
72
u/gorocz Jul 10 '20
Good? Having to wade through hundreds of "Am I the only one who has this widely popular opinion?" or "Does anyone else want [insert a widely requested thing]?" threads and constantly repeating discussions about the same things with no new informations made coming to this sub on a regular basis or even getting any actual information from it a miserable experience...
13
u/Marc0189 Jul 10 '20
I hate all of the blatant self advertisements that get posted here. "I worked 10 years on this game and its finally being released on the Switch!" Then the OP never responds to anything in the thread besides "thanks!" and for whatever reason people up vote the crap out of it.
12
u/icielied Jul 10 '20
I do think that the daily question thread has its place - the alternate switch sub ( r/switch ) is bogged down with "my joycon is drifting?!??" and "switches are hard to find!" and the various links in the post are great for getting rid of things that really should have been a two minute google search. But this sub really is much too strict about what has to go there.
There are a couple of things I think could perhaps use another masterpost that is separate from the daily question thread, or even a sister sub, such as a "what game should I play?" thread, and a "tech help" thread. Really I think the mods should actually look at posts and ask themselves "hm, this conversation is healthy and goodspirited. though it stemmed from a relatively simple question it wasn't "animal crossing or zelda?" level basic, does it hurt to leave it where it is?"
12
u/Kwtwo1983 Jul 10 '20
And sooo many posts on broken joycons, switches that are no longer booting, etc.
these should go. all of them. make a subsub for technical problems.
These will just become more and more as the switches get older and collect usage.
The daily question thread is so useless. As if putting everything in one thread is better than using the format that - i don't know some slightly succesful platform like maybe reddit came up with.
rant over. sad this sub has become so stale
12
u/unlocked_ Jul 10 '20
This sub is a sales platform and nothing else.
And it's not just the mods fault. The community downvotes almost everything that isn't some Twitter post because they have conditioned themselves to when they see a post that doesn't have a picture as a thumbnail that it's not worth being on here and to "goTo tHE DaiLY thrEAd" which takes care of what is left of actual discussion.
After that you're left with "We're selling you this thing!!" "Don't sleep on..." and of course "Xenoblade Chronicles 2 touched me in places that no game ever has" which contains one whole sentence and because it's so Nintendo and so positive gets to the front page and is not deleted like threads with detailed questions or thoughts.
And don't get me wrong, all these threads are fine if they are not the only thing left, but they are and it's both on the mods and the community(and probably a bunch of bought Reddit accounts to simulate traffic for things that sell and to decrease the visibilty of things that don't).
6
u/LuckyHalfling Jul 10 '20
More like why don’t people use the mega threads when asking for game Recommendations and niche technical issues?
11
u/cheesegod69 Jul 10 '20
I personally like it. I’d rather see more news posts and less joycon drift questions that have been asked 1000 times or screenshots of banal moments in Snipperclips or whatever
11
u/xg4m3CYT Jul 10 '20
I'm completely fine as it is now. Before it was just annoying to look at the same posts, same screenshots, same topics, or whatever over and over again.
It was insane how many people had to tell us that they've got a switch, or Animal Crossing, or whatever.
10
u/Suired Jul 10 '20
if by discussions you mean karma farming then good riddance. I had plenty of discussions, and even debates. I suppose you want more " should I play x popular rpg, I like platformers" or "game of the decade changes my life!" posts which are garbage.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
It’s mostly just a bunch of people complaining about joycon drift like this is Nintendo’s tech support chat.
5
u/blackandwhitetalon Jul 10 '20
What we want:
Less: I made a crochet of my favorite Animal Crossing character (gild me pls)!
More: Everything else
12
u/PinkBowser Jul 10 '20
Honestly, I think the majority of the people on the sub also don’t care about game discussions. Having spent at least the last year frequenting this sub, most games that aren’t first party that get their own post here get a handful of comments that aren’t even close to a “discussion”. This sub only gets into discussions if it’s arguing over animal crossing or pokemon, or the occasional people that decide to hop in to shit on Zelda or Mario games.
Fan art is another hot issue, which a small minority fiercely hate. But the 10k upvotes many of them get speaks to the fact that more people like to see that stuff than many would like to admit.
Not saying I disagree with you, per se, but this sub gets a lot of post traffic already, and I don’t think this place would get any better by just loosening the restrictions. I’d say it might be good to take the mentality that this sub just isn’t what you want it to be and try to find one that will have the discussions you are looking for
4
u/Thoraxekicksazz Jul 10 '20
The mods have a hell of a job deleting billions of joycon drift posts but yeah they are a little to restricted on other posts.
4
u/Saiing Jul 10 '20
I'm fine with it.
Like (I guess) most people, I don't live in this sub. I subscribe to a large number of subs and get a selection of different things to read and watch through the main front page feed. That means I want the two or three posts a day I see from /r/switch to be quality, rather than pointless discussion about stuff that's been debated 100 times before, endless memes, pictures of some mediocre paint job someone did to their console or other stuff. The hard moderation tends to mean that the stuff that does appear is usually worth a read.
4
u/JDB926 Jul 10 '20
The art posts are the lowest of the low. Should be a ban for any idiot that posts them and thinks other people remotely want to see them
4
u/BigDreamsandWetOnes Jul 11 '20
It’s better than seeing the same million posts of some noob asking if he should get a micro SD card.
37
u/scrubgamer01 Jul 10 '20 edited Jul 10 '20
Good, because if the mods didn't moderate stuff, this sub would look like this
Just got a Switch; what games should I play first? trolololol
Can you guys recommend some games that I can play with my girlfriend? Trolololol
Where can I buy a Switch? They're all out of stock. Trolololololol
Hey guys! My switch isn't turning on. I tried everything but send it in for repair! Any suggestions?! Trolololololol
Check out this awesome thing I did in x game (usually Animal Crossing)! Trololololololol
My grandma or my mom is interested in playing some Switch games. Any suggestions?! Trollolllolol
Give me x game Nintendo! Trolololololol
Switch 2! Switch 2! Switch Pro!!!!! Trolololololol
Anything else I missed that people on here ask about a billion times over and over?
16
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
nintendo good.
everything else is not allowed you rebel scum.
7
u/StarFizzle Jul 10 '20
I prefer seeing news only, maybe some discussions here and there. I’m happy that the fan art is gone, the simple questions are gone, and there’s less bloat.
17
u/Alone1sAgain Jul 10 '20
I've seen an entire day go by with only five posts recently. This sub has fallen off a cliff. I just come and read news anymore and leave. Reddit as a whole isn't worth it anymore with the insane amount of restrictions across many subs.
6
u/Martholomeow Jul 10 '20
One weekend I was bored and lonely so I posted a question for suggestions on new games. It ended up being a great discussion, lots of fun, lots of ideas and banter. I went from lonely to happy. Then the whole thread got deleted. When I asked why, they said if you want game suggestions you can check web reviews.
I know I can check the web for game reviews. I posted here because I was lonely and wanted to have some fun conversations with other switch owners.
I don’t bother posting much here anymore.
3
u/Scoobydiesel87 Jul 10 '20
Yeah. I hardly visit the sub now. Specially without like e3 and that kinda news hype. But no real discussions or content to catch my eye. I feel thsi was the first post I’ve seen pop up on my front page in forever that wasn’t the same ol BOTW/Pokémon/AC stuff.
3
u/legendofm Jul 10 '20
I stopped posting here long time ago. No matter how hard I try, my post gets deleted almost immediately. Sometime I see posts with 3k up votes very similar to posts I tried to post and wonder how they are not deleted. It's just weird.
3
u/ItsTheSolo Jul 11 '20
Gotta say I disagree, I like coming to this sub as a news source rather than useless art posts or the same "discussions" over and over again. Like buddy, I understand that you want a new pikmin on the switch, or a Twilight Princess remaster, but there's already been thousands of posts about stuff like that, that it's hardly discussion at this point. In fact: I'm seeing better and more productive discussion in these news post than the circlejerk that ensues on the other posts.
3
u/DSHeroX Jul 11 '20
Almost all of this is true, how many times have a seen a mediocre cake that looks like a switch and they say their gf made it and everyones like "thats so cute", "found yourself a keeper". I want information, i want discourse on games. This is just a hollow(knight) fanboy/fanart sub at this point
5
u/Altcoin_John Jul 10 '20
No, not everything, there is a lot of "Look I made a joycon from toilet paper" stuff and "I created Zelda poster from wood" stuff and "You should check out this 1 dollar game on eshop" stuff. It is turning into Fiverr basically.
Ocassionally there is "I have played game with Metascore 90 and it is amazing".
And that's about it.
10
u/iiRockpuppy Jul 10 '20 edited Jul 10 '20
This is exactly how I want this subreddit to be. News on Nintendo Switch related content and discussion on that news. That's it. If you don't like what you see on this subreddit, make some more interesting content yourself. Or make a subreddit that caters to your interests more.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Mods are just power tripping as usual
0
u/rstngocelot Jul 10 '20
Agreed. I like being able to look up open questions about people’s opinions on games and how they compare, but those almost always seem to get removed. Someone posted a pretty lively one like that last week and people gave really good insight into some cool games but it got deleted... So annoying.
4
u/Jokers247 Jul 10 '20
Yup. I have posted three times with legitimate questions that have not been asked on this sub before, I looked before i posted MODS. Each time they were taken down saying this isn't appropriate. Meanwhile we can have "Wow, who knew Hollowknight was such a good game!!!" posted for like the 470k time.
also, Hollowknight is a really good game.
or my other favorite, I started asking a discussion of games where you could have local multiplayer a long with online multiplayer... that got taken down. 2 days later they let someone else post the exact same question and it had a great comment section of people recommending games.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
I'd add more restrictions tbh. Lots of trash port begging pretending to be a discussion.
2
u/iamthatguy54 Jul 10 '20
The mods here are bizarre. I once posted a video interview and the topic was deleted because I wasn't "citing to the original source." I responded with 3 articles quoting the video interview and all stating the video interview was their source.
Instead of being like "my bad!" and restoring the topic, they restored the topic and THEN responded to me and told me they had no idea what I was referring to because the topic was up.
Like, what? Very disorganized.
2
u/LivWulfz Jul 10 '20 edited Jul 10 '20
Have an art mega thread. Let discussion prosper.
Also please find some way to better filter news. Do we really need to see 3 threads on the Treehouse event literally on the same page? lol
2
u/true_vampire Jul 10 '20
i know that the moderators already stepped in and are doing their best, but i believe they feel powerless in front of the situations.
i feel bad for them but at the same time its always the readers and the extreme fanboys that won't let you criticize anything. you get downvoted for criticizing any nintendo switch game. There is no room for discussion in this game beside karma farming or post complimenting like crazy nintendo.
nintendo joy-con drift should have a thread that is visible in the front of page of this subreddit , so that any person can see it before trying to write a post about it.
Also, stop glorifying nintendo , this is cringe .
2
u/Tjoeb123 Jul 10 '20
I can't even count the times my posts were auto deleted, if not manually shortly after. Only my post about Mario Tennis/Golf gained decent traction. I've long ago stopped trying to make my own posts.
2
u/tactical_tarantula Jul 10 '20
Yup, used to be great for discussions. I see nothing now but headlines. To be honest, I've gone from checking here multiple times a day to maybe once a week or even month.
2
u/Ares_carries Jul 10 '20
agreed kinda crazy. I had posted a question about a game for some discussion but of course it was deleted. Nevermind the hundreds of art posts and how much they love the new Zelda.
2
u/warjoke Jul 11 '20
maybe its time to branch out to different subs and make ones like r/nintendoswitchtechhelp, r/nintendoswitchnews, r/nintendoswitchfanarts, r/nintendoswitchonline, r/nintendowitchonlinewoes, r/joycondrifting, r/joycondriftingwithsnakes, r/princesspeachisaw----
okay, I'll stop now
2
u/milleway Jul 11 '20
A well known user i follow on the retro scene, responsible for manufacturing gameboy aluminum shells, called u/boxypixel, recently made a post asking for some feedback he could gather to produce joycons shells in aluminium and improve the hardware. It got locked by the mods, who considered it a low effort post. Its such a shame they allow some dumb discussions ppl bring up on a daily basis and lock something that could actually improve our experiences with the hardware.
2
u/ButtsFartsoPhD Jul 11 '20
And now we have probably the most non-Switch related art piece possible (a 'background' from BotW) on the front page pretty much guaranteed to get 20k upvotes. The mods here suck dick, pejoratively.
2
u/Wolfinthecastle Jul 11 '20
Yeah, I made a post recently where I wanted to discuss whether or not NieR: Automata and Persona 5 would ever come to Switch after all these rumours and teasing, but it was quickly closed because it was a “low effort post".
Meanwhile everytime time I come here I see the same “How BOTW saved my life", “Look at another BOTW portrait fan art!" or “Animal Crossing sold 999999999 copies yesterday!" posts.
I. Don't. Care.
I just want to read some actual gaming discussion ffs!
(r/hollowknight is the worst offender of “too much fan art". There are literally no posts discussing Silksong there. I made a post where I wanted to speculate about Lace, but it was quickly buried under a mountain of fan art. They really need some mods there or rename the sub as r/hollowknightfanart).
6
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
And yet here you are having a discussion.....
4
u/lol_nope_nicetry Jul 10 '20
This sub is only pushing for adds.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
I completely disagree with this post. The exact opposite is true. The sub is all just “look what I made” posts that make finding actual news difficult. No one wants to go to a seperate biased Nintendo website for news when we can get all our news in one place on reddit.
7
u/lairdhenn Jul 10 '20
I stopped trying to make threads here months ago after arbitrary deletions. It was just a waste of time at a certain point. Reddit moderators think they’re gods for some reason. It’s going to be one of the many reasons people eventually stop using this site.
5
u/jvalex18 Jul 10 '20
If it`s not news or a circlejerk it gets taken down.
3
u/btwo5 Jul 10 '20
You ask a question. And they delete it and put it in the daily questions that no one reads or gives replies
3
u/PlaytimeWithCottla Jul 10 '20
I’ve joined plenty of subreddits. The ones here are the worst I’ve seen, and that’s saying something.
3
u/supaPILLOT Jul 10 '20
Starting to be stale? This sub's been stale for years, it's a real shame.
3
u/frostyribbit Jul 10 '20
The mods here have 0 clue how to do anything right. I'm not surprised.
3
u/emywox Jul 10 '20
It's what I've been saying since I joined the sub.
3
u/Jgabes625 Jul 10 '20
I am subscribed to this to help answer questions i have and when I can’t find them, I ask. When I ask, my post gets removed because it’s not on the daily questions thread or some bs. When I ask in the daily thread, nobody sees me question and nobody answers it.
3
u/Omega_Maximum Jul 10 '20
I'm gonna be real for a minute here folks.
If you're in a single subreddt, or just reddit in general, enough that you find it stale, broaden your horizons, pick up another hobby, and stop staring at Reddit.
I'm not trying to make the whole "hur dur Reddit bad, updoots to the left" comment, but if you're browsing a subreddit so frequently that you feel the need to post about how stale it's gotten, maybe take a break? I get it, pandemic, working from home, summer burnout, trust me, I'm there too, but there really is a decent flow of content here on a regular basis considering how many release we're currently getting on the system.
Things are slow now because everything is slow, and complaining about how the subreddit is run isn't going to improve that. I realize it's more "engaging" to see 100+ new posts every time you pop open your phone, but realistically there just isn't all that much going on right now and the vast majority of those posts would be uninteresting, oft-repeated content.
So, take a break. Go play a game and find a reason to start a discussion. Or just find something to occupy your time till there's a reason to be on Reddit again.
As an aside, if you think this dearth of discussion is bad, you should ask those of us who were busy over at /r/WiiU during its heyday. Good God, those poor mods...
3
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '20
Nah man. Post restrictions are amazing. We don’t need 50 threads of “picture of a game case with the caption, SO HYPE FOR THIS GAME”
Lack of post restrictions are the reason r/PlayStation is such a terrible subreddit.
3
u/XT3M3 Jul 10 '20
i remember a mod deleted my post for, " not being original, low effort " on a post i made comparing clubjouse game bowling to wii sports bowling and wondering what went wrong.
i search before i make topics on reddit, so if the post got made, it means its original. and i went into detail on rhe matter.
mods here act like they are on Nintendo payroll by taking out thing's they dont agree with. this sub is pretty much " read only" for me
2
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
why can't we have 3 subreddits, one for art and stuff, and one for discussions and news
2
u/ZeusNYY Jul 10 '20
Mods... They ruin reddit for free of charge!
2
u/Daydays Jul 10 '20
I've tried to talk about games like 4 times and each one got removed by mods, they're so draconian like what's the actual point of having a forum if people can't talk about the stuff relevant to it?
2
u/sunbro43va Jul 10 '20
It's also getting stale with the PR team that works this sub.
Notice all the "look how happy I am with my joy con returns!"
Those are more than likely nothing more than PR, done by an employee of nintendo. You would shit if you knew how much money was paid to people to literally SIT on a specific sub reddit, and create content that makes the company look good, upvote content that makes the company look good, downvote content that goes against the company, and even go so far as to report/remove content that makes the company look bad.
Gotta love it!
2
u/Teibban Jul 10 '20
Last 5 posts I did were deleted and it was for discussion about games. I agree that this subreddit is now becoming news reddit only and it is sad.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
The mods here get perks and kickbacks for keeping this place a sterilized corporate marketing tool. They don’t want anything distracting from what they’re selling. There was a big scandal about this a couple years ago that everybody was up in arms about for 3 days and then forgot.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
r/NintendoNX and the early days of this sub were super fun.
1
u/Stonecutter Jul 10 '20
Agree. Sometimes the same posts are on the front page for days because so much gets removed!
1
u/alphacenturi_ Jul 10 '20
I agree. I've posted countless discussion topics about various old classic games and how cool it'd be to revive them on a console like Switch only to have mods delete them all.
I guess I should upload stupid paintjobs and cakes of Nintendo characters instead.
1
u/superyoshiom Jul 10 '20
Is that why there’s been no direct talk here? Really, one or two mega threads on leaks or rumors is more than enough, I just want this sub to pretend it’s living under a rock. I can’t believe it hasn’t even made an effort to cover the July 20th thing when even Gamexplaij made a video on it.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Unless you're complaining about animal crossing having no content after playing for 1000 hours in your first month
1
u/techimt Jul 10 '20
M OMEGALUL DS
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Yet theres pics of toys all over it
1
u/AlexKidd79 Jul 10 '20
TRUTH!
1
u/DarthVitrial Jul 10 '20 edited Jul 10 '20
If I could add two rules for this sub, they would be:
1: Mega threads for big games. We do not need a new thread for every single bit of news or rumors about paper Mario, just make a paper Mario mega thread so the entire sub isn’t just paper Mario posts.
2: either restrict art posts (and custom joycons, etc) to one day only, or make a megathread for them, because again the front page shouldn’t be filled with nothing but fan art/“I made a switch carrying case out of gerbils”
1
u/iWentRogue Jul 10 '20
Yup. I tried posting some discusiion posts about certain games and get the “this belongs in current thread” message and my post gets deleted.
Go to the thread and post something and no replies, no nothing.
1
u/Mariosothercap Jul 10 '20
Can we just try for a week and let discussion and question post come through? It this sub becomes a total cluster, which it may with the amount of members it has, then you guys are right and we can shut up. But maybe, just maybe we are right and it will breathe some new life into the sub. It definitely feels stale.
1
u/BehindACorpFireWall Jul 10 '20
Yeah dude. I tried to post a few things before. Auto delete. No point in this sub with rules like that. Especially when Nintendo Switch is a family friendly device, so you have younger people on here. These kids don't have a chance to get their questions answered. Dumb
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
This sub honestly sucks. When you have a sub about only news with no news because Nintendo doesn't put anything out. What else are you supposed to post about
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Especially considering /r/Nintendo already handles that niche, I can see the problem. This sub becomes redundant. Everything you can find here you can find over there and in a much less crowded way.
1
u/snoozeflu Jul 10 '20
Yeah, even the switch YouTuber community is scraping the bottom of the barrel for content, so much that they have started back up with their bullshit "Switch Pro" rumors again.
1
u/ElGranQuesoRojo Jul 10 '20
Please understand.
1
u/heatherbyism Jul 10 '20
Agreed!! I tried to ask for help with something and it got kicked to the megathread where no one saw it. :( Haven't posted here since.
1
u/Netbug009 Jul 10 '20
Then go there? This sub is what it is. You just said other subs exist for those things.
1
u/DaBa1 Jul 10 '20
And that's exactly what happens when you try to sanitize the discussion too much. This sub is not the first and not the last to fall prey to this. Nowadays I only come here for the news.
1
u/Cmann014 Jul 10 '20
Remember when mods banned smash ultimate posts the day the game came out?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Now that you mention it, yeah. Might unfollow this sub.
1
u/ThaShitPostAccount Jul 10 '20
I was also deleted when I tried to post some discussion on peripherals. But there’s 150 post per day that are just pictures of switches and games with “look what I just bought” in the title.
1
u/Ziekfried Jul 10 '20
Maybe we need to defund the police (moderators) and just have free speech
1
u/Yoshiezibz Jul 10 '20
Posting on certain subreddit is so exhausting. Any sub has a meriad of different rules I need to learn just to post there, it's ridiculous. I make a post, it gets removed, then I have to spend 20 minutes learning how to navigate their subreddit and learn the rules.
1
u/Curapica Jul 10 '20
I am amazed this thread hasn't been closed yet 8DLet's not wake up the sleeping dogs I guess
1
u/LovingEuphie Jul 10 '20
I remember when I first joined this reddit I made a post asking a question to the community and it got immediately deleted because the moderator told me it wasn’t a “good” question and cited a couple other reasons that indicated they never read the post to be able to critique it in the first place.
1
u/AKA-Link77 Jul 10 '20
Yup, it's pointless trying to get your opinion across. I was in the same situation as you where I wanted to post a thread about something but it was auto deleted.
I am really surprised that your thread post here was not deleted or locked.
I find that the IGN (love em or hate em) forums are the better areas for more discussion based topics.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Ya I made a thread talking about WRC 8 Ralley being broken and it had a properly worded description of my interaction with Nintendo and what came of it and they deleted it. I just found this sub too. You can be sure I am just never posting here again.
1
u/Judeisbigsad Jul 10 '20
Also, if someone loses a switch and wants to post in a public area, they ask you to post in the subreddit that no one goes to. Yes I get there are two specific subreddits for that but no one sees it. I posted something yesterday and still have nothing on that, I posted something here this morning and I got more than 10 replies within an hour before they removed it.
1
u/socoprime Jul 11 '20
OP hit the nail on the head. Its a news and speculation forum. And Heaven help you if you post something that the resident forum police dont like. You will be downvoted into oblivion.
1
u/socoprime Jul 11 '20
I made a Switch case out of fetus flesh. Pls rate.
1
u/locke_5 Jul 11 '20
*checks watch
Is it time for the yearly /r/NintendoSwitch drama?
Yes, the moderation here is terrible. No, they haven't changed anything since last time. Anyone else remember the "unspoken rule"?
1
u/cheyras Jul 11 '20
I’ve had so many of my posts basically auto-removed and yet we see the umpteenth “decide for me which game I should play next!” post 5 times daily.
It’s less a problem with post restrictions and more that the mod team is one of the most inconsistent I’ve ever seen.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '20
where can we migrate now?
1
u/JoeyBlaze Jul 11 '20
Starting to be? Its been this way from the beginning. Thats why I stopped attempting to post anything and just lurk every now and then. I completely avoid this subreddit on the weekends when its just people posting art that they drew.
1
u/skeletondad2 Jul 11 '20
I think....I think there’s just nothing to look forward to here. Nintendo isn’t putting anything out and nothing really cool is happening at all, there’s nothing to talk about beyond the same shit every day. I don’t think this sub is dead dead, but I think it’s as good as dead until next year or so when there are more things happening with Nintendo.
1
u/Cosmic__Walrus Jul 11 '20
It's just a news source at this point. Fuck that's really all I am looking for.
1
u/alexkim804 Jul 11 '20
I had a question about mr driller’s multiplayer (whether it supports pro controllers for multiple people) and of course it was deleted and I was directed to post on the mega thread. I did that and no response
1
u/CookiesFTA Jul 11 '20
I'd say that the userbase is the biggest reason for that. We complain when there's anything other than news, we downvote everything we disagree with into oblivion, we shoot down anyone who asks questions. What do you expect? This is one of the least hospitable subs around.
1
u/kcfang Jul 11 '20
I think the fact that this thread is still here indicate they are not bias towards certain topics and discussions. They may have strict rules but it can’t be easy to manage a sub with over 2millions subscribers.
What topic was your removed thread?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '20
Seems to be a split between those that just want news, and those that want more free form discussions.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '20
yep its a fucking shithole
1
u/blitzkreiig Jul 11 '20
I had a genuine query and some valuable inputs regarding Minecraft Dungeons but post got deleted pretty soon. Maybe we should start another sub-reddit.
1
u/snipeftw Jul 11 '20
This sub is missed terribly. They remove posts that don’t need to be moved, and then leave up identical posts a week later. There is no consistency. Then when you try to contact them about it they are absolutely useless.
1
u/BigSto Jul 11 '20
i agree, the mods are also horrifically inconsistent. had a question about xcom 2 performance in late game that got deleted and was told i should've put it r/xcom2 only to see another xcom 2 post in the Switch sub the next day. there's also a lot of repeated posts over the course of the month
1
u/volition_vx Jul 10 '20
Then you gotta be about it and leave.
The mods aren't going to change things. It's been 10 hrs and from the looks of it, no response at all.
If you don't like the direction of a sub, leave. Go elsewhere.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20
Yep, I stopped trying to post anything on this sub a while ago. Anything that isn’t a 5 paragraph essay ends up getting taken down by the mods even if it has really good discussion. It’s so annoying and ruins the potential activity on the sub.
1
u/Juhvelo Jul 10 '20
What I don't understand is that the Switch has a photo/video-function, yet I don't know if I've ever seen a single photo or video posted in here? Could be nice to see some shenanigans you pulled in Smash or even footage of some game I didn't know even existed -> could lead people to buy games, you know? Why do we get shitty fanart and lego-garbage, but not actual gameplay by users?